Common poisons include
Sulfur
Chlorides and other halides
Metals including arsenic, vanadium, mercury, alkali metals (including potassium)
Phosphates
Organo-metalics
"Federated learning: out of reach no matter how close",Oleksandr Lapshyn
Steam Reforming - Poisons
1. Steam Reforming - Poisons
Gerard B. Hawkins
Managing Director
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
2. The aim of this presentation is to
• Introduce the various poisons
• Indicate actions that need to be taken if
catalyst is poisoned
• Effect of ultra purification
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
3. Common poisons include
• Sulfur
• Chlorides and other halides
• Metals including arsenic, vanadium, mercury,
alkali metals (including potassium)
• Phosphates
• Organo-metalics
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
4. Reduced catalyst activity
In primary reformer this means
• Reduced reaction
• Reduced reaction heat load
• High tube/process gas temperatures
• More susceptible to carbon formation
• Hot bands
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
6. Steam reforming catalyst requirements
Poison Limit Effect
Sulfur <0.1 ppmv Poison
Chlorides <0.1 ppmv Poison
As/V/Pb/Hg <5ppbv Poison
Olefins <1-2 vol% Carbon
• Process gas feed to reformer (dry basis)
• Excludes Pre Reforming catalysts
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
7. For Pre Reformers must be lower than for
primary reformers
Sulfur specified at 25 ppb or less
But needs to be checked using a space
velocity calculation
Chlorides and Sodium are also poisons
Silica is also an issue
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
10. • Vast majority of poisoned
reformers are affected by Sulfur
• Many problems with sulfur
analysis
• At more than 5 ppm will cause
severe and rapid deactivation
• At 20-30 ppb will lead to slow
deactivation
• Nickel is excellent sulfur
absorbent
• At high enough levels will
completely de-active catalyst
Pellet
S
SS
S
S
S
S
S
S S
Nickel
CH
H O
4
2
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
11. Sulfur less ‘sticky’ at high temperatures
Only affects upper parts of tube
Little affect lower down - usually hot bands are
so bad that catalyst is changed out prior to
affecting bottom part of tube
Poisoning is generally reversible - can steam
May lose some activity
Particularly if low inlet temperature
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
12. Sulfur can be passed to reformer if
• ZnO saturated - difficult to test
• COS in feed gas and not hydrolyzed over
ZnO
• Organics in feed with no CoMo/NiMo
• Plants with NG bypass to secondary
• Bypass around HDS/ZnO
◦ DP Tappings
◦ Bypass lines
◦ Incorrect valves open
• Leaks on HDS interchangers
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
13. COS not as common as H2S, mercaptans
COS + H2O H2S + CO2
Reacts over CoMo/NiMo at typical conditions
or
Over ZnO that contains some alumina
NOTE: COS is not removed by amine systems
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
14. Zinc Oxide will remove some COS provided
that there is alumina in support
As with VSG-S201- series
Competitors have no alumina
Organic sulfur compounds (mercaptans)
pass through zinc oxide
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
15. • Difficult to set up analysis
• Tests are difficult
• Tests not accurate
• Looking at low levels
• Generally looking for sulfur at detection limit
of the laboratory equipment
• Limit is 10 ppb
• ZnO will slip about 10 ppb
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
16. • Problems of sampling
• Pipe work must be of stainless
• Sulfur absorbs into Carbon Steel
• Will absorb into stainless but at lower rate
• Short pipe runs
• Prevent absorption
• Sample keeps for four hours
• In a stainless steel sample bomb
• Use plastic sample bags if sample to be
transported
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
17. • Some sulfur is removed during shut down
• All shut downs include a steam out
• Bulk and surface different readings
• use surface
• Better to conduct full steam out
• Test condensate for sulfur compounds
• Or smell condensate (beware)
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
18. Of benefit to most plants
Effect most pronounced in tough conditions
◦ Low S/C operation where Carbon formation is likely
◦ Prereformers which are very sensitive
◦ GHRs where deactivation impacts heat transfer
◦ Heavy feed reforming where poisoning and carbon
formation determine life
◦ Heavily stressed reformers
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
19. Together with ZnO at regular
operating conditions
◦ ZnO to remove bulk of sulfur (H2S)
◦ Followed by a layer of
Ultrapurification for polishing
Cannot replace ZnO completely since
it has a lower saturation capacity
Catalyst requires reduction prior to
use
Can be pyrophoric on discharge -
similar to LTS
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
20. Unfortunately, measuring low ppbv levels of
sulfur is difficult
So proof has to come from lab/field work
We wanted to test the concept
So we chose a plant where we can measure
the effect of deactivation, a reformer we
know suffers from deactivation, and where
LTS catalysts are known to pick up sulfur
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
21. • Smaller, slower
decrease of GHR UA
expected in theory with
Cu/Zn
• Historical evidence
from plant that UA
settles to lower than
SOR value
UA v Days online
0.8
0.85
0.9
0.95
1
1.05
0 200 400 600
Without With
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
22. Arsenic is a very virulent poison
If a reformer has been poisoned by arsenic
then must clean tubes thoroughly
If this is not done then arsenic will poison
then next batch of catalyst
And continue to do so
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
23. • Most common as HCI or highly mobile ion
• Remove less than 5ppb
• Accelerates sintering in catalyst metal
crystallites
• Found in:
• Feed storage locations
• Crude and distillate oils
• Certain refinery processes
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
24. Effect of Chloride on ZnO Sulfur Removal Catalyst
1. Fresh ZnO 2. Poisoned ZnO
HCl
ZnO
Crystallites
Catalyst
Pores
ZnCl2 blocks
catalyst surface
and pores to
prevent sulfur
absorption
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM
26. Most steam reforming catalysts can handle
olefins
Typically between 1-2%
Can lead to rapid formation of hot bands
If more than this then need to be treated in
HDS
WWW.GBHENTERPRISES.COM