Starting the Conversation about
Feedback
Jennifer Smithers Marten
#vlconf2014
#vlconf2014
Why do I take the time to write comments on their papers?
The students who need it, don’t read it.
Even the good kids just flip through to find the grade.
3-point conventions score measures
•Punctuation
•Grammar
•Capitalization
•Spelling
6-point composition score measures
•Purpose
•Organization
•Content development
•Sentence fluency
•Word choice
ABOUT EFFECTIVE FEEDBACK
WHAT WE KNOW
#vlconf2014
"The effects of feedback depend on the
nature of the feedback. Feedback can be the
information that drives the process or the
stumbling block that derails the process."
~ Susan Brookhart
Evaluative Feedback
• Tells learners how they
compare to others
• Provides a
judgment summarizing the
quality of the learning
• Is a direct result of
summative assessment
Descriptive Feedback
• Provides specific
information in the form of
written comments or
conversations
• Helps the learner
understand what he or she
needs to do to improve
• Is a crucial part of formative
assessment
Achievement Feedback
• Tells the student what was
done well
• Praises the work or process,
not the student
Intervention Feedback
• Tells the student what
needs improving
• Gives enough information
so the student knows what
to do next
Feedback Levels
Three Questions
Where am I going?
How am I going?
Where to next?
• Just as a thermostat adjusts a room temperature,
effective feedback helps maintain a supportive
environment for learning.
•
~ Dylan Wiliam
How Feedback Varies
Attributes of Effective Feedback
Clear
Builds Trust
User-friendly
Specific
Focused
Differentiated
Timely
Invites Follow-Up
Tomlinson & Moon, 2013
Effective Strategies
Student-to-Student Feedback
Student to Student Strategies
Peer-to-Peer Feedback
Peer-to-Peer Strategies
Getting Feedback from Students
Student-to-Teacher Strategies
"The most powerful single moderator
that enhances achievement is
feedback." ~ John Hattie
Let’s continue the conversation
Contact Info
• Twitter: @jenmarten
• Blog: teach from the heart
• Skype: jenmarten
• Websites: Feedback
Tech in the Classroom
• Linkedin: jenmarten
• Email: jmarten@tds.net
#vlconf2014
Learn more about Visible Learningplus
at www.corwin.com/visiblelearning

Starting the Conversation on Feedback

  • 1.
    Starting the Conversationabout Feedback Jennifer Smithers Marten #vlconf2014
  • 2.
    #vlconf2014 Why do Itake the time to write comments on their papers?
  • 3.
    The students whoneed it, don’t read it.
  • 4.
    Even the goodkids just flip through to find the grade.
  • 9.
    3-point conventions scoremeasures •Punctuation •Grammar •Capitalization •Spelling 6-point composition score measures •Purpose •Organization •Content development •Sentence fluency •Word choice
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12.
    "The effects offeedback depend on the nature of the feedback. Feedback can be the information that drives the process or the stumbling block that derails the process." ~ Susan Brookhart
  • 13.
    Evaluative Feedback • Tellslearners how they compare to others • Provides a judgment summarizing the quality of the learning • Is a direct result of summative assessment Descriptive Feedback • Provides specific information in the form of written comments or conversations • Helps the learner understand what he or she needs to do to improve • Is a crucial part of formative assessment
  • 14.
    Achievement Feedback • Tellsthe student what was done well • Praises the work or process, not the student Intervention Feedback • Tells the student what needs improving • Gives enough information so the student knows what to do next
  • 15.
    Feedback Levels Three Questions Wheream I going? How am I going? Where to next?
  • 16.
    • Just asa thermostat adjusts a room temperature, effective feedback helps maintain a supportive environment for learning. • ~ Dylan Wiliam
  • 17.
  • 18.
    Attributes of EffectiveFeedback Clear Builds Trust User-friendly Specific Focused Differentiated Timely Invites Follow-Up Tomlinson & Moon, 2013 Effective Strategies
  • 19.
    Student-to-Student Feedback Student toStudent Strategies Peer-to-Peer Feedback Peer-to-Peer Strategies Getting Feedback from Students Student-to-Teacher Strategies
  • 20.
    "The most powerfulsingle moderator that enhances achievement is feedback." ~ John Hattie
  • 21.
  • 22.
    Contact Info • Twitter:@jenmarten • Blog: teach from the heart • Skype: jenmarten • Websites: Feedback Tech in the Classroom • Linkedin: jenmarten • Email: jmarten@tds.net #vlconf2014
  • 23.
    Learn more aboutVisible Learningplus at www.corwin.com/visiblelearning