SlideShare a Scribd company logo
On the Way to Dialogic teaching:
Action Research as a Means to
change Classroom Discourse
Muhammad Azam
Research Scholar
COMSATS Institute of Information
Technology Lahore, Pakistan
Introduction
• This Study focuses on implementing dialogic teaching
principles in lower secondary school teaching.
• Two kinds of teaching
• Authoritative: controlled by the teacher
• Dialogic: collaboration between students and teacher
Introduction
• Vygotsky’s idea of zone of proximal development
– Difference between the current level of a child’s
performance and the potential development level with a
teacher’s assistance.
• Scaffolding
– A temporary support provided to the student by the
teacher.
– To focus on the particular skill at the particular time
Features of Dialogic teaching
• The focus on particular aspects of classroom discourse
assessed according to the dialogic quality it introduces.
• We can assess this by focusing the dialogues between teacher
and students.
– Question level
– Question length
– Question ecology
– Communication pattern
– Classroom interaction
(Smart and Marshall, 2013)
Features of Dialogic teaching
• Model proposed by Nystrand et al. (1997):
– Authentic questions
– Uptake
– Higher-order evaluation
– Open discussion
• Model of kuo, Clark, Anderson and others;
– Authority
– Question
– Feedback
– Connecting student ideas
– Explanation
– Collaboration
Methodology
• Seminar for teachers (Teacher Development Programme)
– Four teachers participated
• Discussion of the presented topics
• Video recording of the classrooms
• Discussion of the recording between teachers and
the researcher
Data Collection
• 1. interview between a teacher and a reseacher
• 2. Sound recording of group discussion at seminars
• 3. video recordings form lesson
• 4. sound recording of reflective interviews
• 5. Questionnaire for the students at the beginning and at
the end of the programme
Data Analysis
• The use of ATLAS.ti and Statistica
• A set of codes for analysis of data;
– The character of teacher initiations
• (openness, cognitive, demand)
– The character of student replies
• Length, cognitive correspondence
– The presence of student initiations and their nature
• Cognitive demand and openness
– The occurrence of triadic interaction
Data Analysis
• The use of t-test;
– For analysis of control and experimental group of teachers
• Conclusion
• Teachers made their questions more open and more
cognitively and students replies became longer and
their initiations also grew.
• Teachers changed the way they communicate.

More Related Content

What's hot

Project Based Learning Ppt
Project Based Learning PptProject Based Learning Ppt
Project Based Learning Ppt
ragogli
 
Project Based Learning
Project Based LearningProject Based Learning
Project Based Learning
mlegan31
 
Teaching large classes
Teaching large classes Teaching large classes
Teaching large classes
Ahmed Mayouf
 
Professional learning communities
Professional learning communitiesProfessional learning communities
Professional learning communities
Miami-Dade County Public Schools
 
Collaborative learning
Collaborative learningCollaborative learning
Collaborative learning
yeni fitria
 
Stakeholder of Assessment
Stakeholder of AssessmentStakeholder of Assessment
Stakeholder of Assessment
Cate Boty
 
Differentiation vs scaffolding
Differentiation vs scaffoldingDifferentiation vs scaffolding
Differentiation vs scaffolding
S MD
 
Teaching Concepts
Teaching ConceptsTeaching Concepts
Teaching Concepts
wartschowk
 
Effective teaching strategies
Effective teaching strategiesEffective teaching strategies
Effective teaching strategies
manish shrivastava
 
Teacher Tested Strategies for Differentiated Instruction
Teacher Tested Strategies for Differentiated InstructionTeacher Tested Strategies for Differentiated Instruction
Teacher Tested Strategies for Differentiated Instruction
Edutopia
 
USING CAT4 DATA
USING CAT4 DATAUSING CAT4 DATA
USING CAT4 DATA
JOHN DSOUZA
 
Project Based Learning Webinar
Project Based Learning WebinarProject Based Learning Webinar
Project Based Learning Webinar
Karen Brooks
 
The Educator as a Researcher: A Practical Guide to Writing an Action Research
The Educator as a Researcher: A Practical Guide to Writing an Action ResearchThe Educator as a Researcher: A Practical Guide to Writing an Action Research
The Educator as a Researcher: A Practical Guide to Writing an Action Research
Rachel Luna Peralta
 
TRAINING FOR TEACHERS
TRAINING FOR TEACHERSTRAINING FOR TEACHERS
TRAINING FOR TEACHERS
SMITA RASTOGI
 
LESSON OBSERVATION Wayne Stagg 2014
LESSON OBSERVATION Wayne Stagg 2014LESSON OBSERVATION Wayne Stagg 2014
LESSON OBSERVATION Wayne Stagg 2014
wayne140858
 
What is Research
What is ResearchWhat is Research
What is Research
Janice Orcutt
 
Project Based Learning
Project Based LearningProject Based Learning
Project Based Learning
avalenzuela2000
 
Gagne's Nine Events of Instruction
Gagne's Nine Events of InstructionGagne's Nine Events of Instruction
Gagne's Nine Events of Instruction
Mr. Ronald Quileste, PhD
 
Classroom Management workshop
Classroom Management workshopClassroom Management workshop
Classroom Management workshop
Suman Tiwari
 
Testing a Test: Evaluating Our Assessment Tools
Testing a Test: Evaluating Our Assessment ToolsTesting a Test: Evaluating Our Assessment Tools
Testing a Test: Evaluating Our Assessment Tools
Eddy White, Ph.D.
 

What's hot (20)

Project Based Learning Ppt
Project Based Learning PptProject Based Learning Ppt
Project Based Learning Ppt
 
Project Based Learning
Project Based LearningProject Based Learning
Project Based Learning
 
Teaching large classes
Teaching large classes Teaching large classes
Teaching large classes
 
Professional learning communities
Professional learning communitiesProfessional learning communities
Professional learning communities
 
Collaborative learning
Collaborative learningCollaborative learning
Collaborative learning
 
Stakeholder of Assessment
Stakeholder of AssessmentStakeholder of Assessment
Stakeholder of Assessment
 
Differentiation vs scaffolding
Differentiation vs scaffoldingDifferentiation vs scaffolding
Differentiation vs scaffolding
 
Teaching Concepts
Teaching ConceptsTeaching Concepts
Teaching Concepts
 
Effective teaching strategies
Effective teaching strategiesEffective teaching strategies
Effective teaching strategies
 
Teacher Tested Strategies for Differentiated Instruction
Teacher Tested Strategies for Differentiated InstructionTeacher Tested Strategies for Differentiated Instruction
Teacher Tested Strategies for Differentiated Instruction
 
USING CAT4 DATA
USING CAT4 DATAUSING CAT4 DATA
USING CAT4 DATA
 
Project Based Learning Webinar
Project Based Learning WebinarProject Based Learning Webinar
Project Based Learning Webinar
 
The Educator as a Researcher: A Practical Guide to Writing an Action Research
The Educator as a Researcher: A Practical Guide to Writing an Action ResearchThe Educator as a Researcher: A Practical Guide to Writing an Action Research
The Educator as a Researcher: A Practical Guide to Writing an Action Research
 
TRAINING FOR TEACHERS
TRAINING FOR TEACHERSTRAINING FOR TEACHERS
TRAINING FOR TEACHERS
 
LESSON OBSERVATION Wayne Stagg 2014
LESSON OBSERVATION Wayne Stagg 2014LESSON OBSERVATION Wayne Stagg 2014
LESSON OBSERVATION Wayne Stagg 2014
 
What is Research
What is ResearchWhat is Research
What is Research
 
Project Based Learning
Project Based LearningProject Based Learning
Project Based Learning
 
Gagne's Nine Events of Instruction
Gagne's Nine Events of InstructionGagne's Nine Events of Instruction
Gagne's Nine Events of Instruction
 
Classroom Management workshop
Classroom Management workshopClassroom Management workshop
Classroom Management workshop
 
Testing a Test: Evaluating Our Assessment Tools
Testing a Test: Evaluating Our Assessment ToolsTesting a Test: Evaluating Our Assessment Tools
Testing a Test: Evaluating Our Assessment Tools
 

Similar to On the way to dialogic teaching

Multi-Media Laboratory, PSI, LCI
Multi-Media Laboratory, PSI, LCIMulti-Media Laboratory, PSI, LCI
Multi-Media Laboratory, PSI, LCI
Vijayalakshmi Murugesan
 
Lesson studyintro for HE
Lesson studyintro for HELesson studyintro for HE
Lesson studyintro for HE
Philwood
 
Final presentation ppt(final)
Final presentation ppt(final)Final presentation ppt(final)
Final presentation ppt(final)
Farwa Khalid
 
Final presentation ppt(final)
Final presentation ppt(final)Final presentation ppt(final)
Final presentation ppt(final)
Farwa Khalid
 
Danielson framework overview syracuse new york pptx copy 2.2003 version
Danielson framework overview   syracuse new york pptx copy 2.2003 versionDanielson framework overview   syracuse new york pptx copy 2.2003 version
Danielson framework overview syracuse new york pptx copy 2.2003 version
mtkendrick
 
Marsh b
Marsh bMarsh b
Marsh b
shaun_allison
 
Classroom interactions
Classroom interactionsClassroom interactions
Classroom interactions
Mayra Arcos
 
Sensemaking LS and DL
Sensemaking LS and DLSensemaking LS and DL
Sensemaking LS and DL
Philwood
 
Using SMS-Based Classroom Response System To Enhance Student’s Active Learning
Using SMS-Based Classroom Response System To Enhance Student’s Active Learning Using SMS-Based Classroom Response System To Enhance Student’s Active Learning
Using SMS-Based Classroom Response System To Enhance Student’s Active Learning
Austin Mpando
 
Evaluation
EvaluationEvaluation
Evaluation
farshad azimi
 
Aaaagroup3 130725095934-phpapp01
Aaaagroup3 130725095934-phpapp01Aaaagroup3 130725095934-phpapp01
Aaaagroup3 130725095934-phpapp01
Evangeline Deocareza
 
Second language teacher education
Second language teacher educationSecond language teacher education
Second language teacher education
Sarat Kumar Doley
 
Rationalise, Response, Results - Keynote Presentation by Dr. Daniel Tan
Rationalise, Response, Results - Keynote Presentation by Dr. Daniel Tan Rationalise, Response, Results - Keynote Presentation by Dr. Daniel Tan
Rationalise, Response, Results - Keynote Presentation by Dr. Daniel Tan
REC:all project
 
Scitt paper atee 2014
Scitt paper atee 2014Scitt paper atee 2014
Scitt paper atee 2014
Philwood
 
[Hmlt5203] assignment1 m rinaldi
[Hmlt5203] assignment1 m rinaldi[Hmlt5203] assignment1 m rinaldi
[Hmlt5203] assignment1 m rinaldi
m_rinaldi
 
IMPLEMENTING THE CURRICULUM (curriculum development)
IMPLEMENTING THE CURRICULUM (curriculum development)IMPLEMENTING THE CURRICULUM (curriculum development)
IMPLEMENTING THE CURRICULUM (curriculum development)
Mayla Gimpao-Bertez
 
Interactive Learning: AECT Presentation
Interactive Learning: AECT PresentationInteractive Learning: AECT Presentation
Interactive Learning: AECT Presentation
National University
 
modelsofteaching-120122073945-phpapp01-140222111541-phpapp02.pdf
modelsofteaching-120122073945-phpapp01-140222111541-phpapp02.pdfmodelsofteaching-120122073945-phpapp01-140222111541-phpapp02.pdf
modelsofteaching-120122073945-phpapp01-140222111541-phpapp02.pdf
FrancisHasselPedido2
 
What is instructional frame work
What is instructional frame workWhat is instructional frame work
What is instructional frame work
Qazi GHAFOOR
 
Catering for gifted students in unit planning
Catering for gifted students in unit planningCatering for gifted students in unit planning
Catering for gifted students in unit planning
Charles Otoo
 

Similar to On the way to dialogic teaching (20)

Multi-Media Laboratory, PSI, LCI
Multi-Media Laboratory, PSI, LCIMulti-Media Laboratory, PSI, LCI
Multi-Media Laboratory, PSI, LCI
 
Lesson studyintro for HE
Lesson studyintro for HELesson studyintro for HE
Lesson studyintro for HE
 
Final presentation ppt(final)
Final presentation ppt(final)Final presentation ppt(final)
Final presentation ppt(final)
 
Final presentation ppt(final)
Final presentation ppt(final)Final presentation ppt(final)
Final presentation ppt(final)
 
Danielson framework overview syracuse new york pptx copy 2.2003 version
Danielson framework overview   syracuse new york pptx copy 2.2003 versionDanielson framework overview   syracuse new york pptx copy 2.2003 version
Danielson framework overview syracuse new york pptx copy 2.2003 version
 
Marsh b
Marsh bMarsh b
Marsh b
 
Classroom interactions
Classroom interactionsClassroom interactions
Classroom interactions
 
Sensemaking LS and DL
Sensemaking LS and DLSensemaking LS and DL
Sensemaking LS and DL
 
Using SMS-Based Classroom Response System To Enhance Student’s Active Learning
Using SMS-Based Classroom Response System To Enhance Student’s Active Learning Using SMS-Based Classroom Response System To Enhance Student’s Active Learning
Using SMS-Based Classroom Response System To Enhance Student’s Active Learning
 
Evaluation
EvaluationEvaluation
Evaluation
 
Aaaagroup3 130725095934-phpapp01
Aaaagroup3 130725095934-phpapp01Aaaagroup3 130725095934-phpapp01
Aaaagroup3 130725095934-phpapp01
 
Second language teacher education
Second language teacher educationSecond language teacher education
Second language teacher education
 
Rationalise, Response, Results - Keynote Presentation by Dr. Daniel Tan
Rationalise, Response, Results - Keynote Presentation by Dr. Daniel Tan Rationalise, Response, Results - Keynote Presentation by Dr. Daniel Tan
Rationalise, Response, Results - Keynote Presentation by Dr. Daniel Tan
 
Scitt paper atee 2014
Scitt paper atee 2014Scitt paper atee 2014
Scitt paper atee 2014
 
[Hmlt5203] assignment1 m rinaldi
[Hmlt5203] assignment1 m rinaldi[Hmlt5203] assignment1 m rinaldi
[Hmlt5203] assignment1 m rinaldi
 
IMPLEMENTING THE CURRICULUM (curriculum development)
IMPLEMENTING THE CURRICULUM (curriculum development)IMPLEMENTING THE CURRICULUM (curriculum development)
IMPLEMENTING THE CURRICULUM (curriculum development)
 
Interactive Learning: AECT Presentation
Interactive Learning: AECT PresentationInteractive Learning: AECT Presentation
Interactive Learning: AECT Presentation
 
modelsofteaching-120122073945-phpapp01-140222111541-phpapp02.pdf
modelsofteaching-120122073945-phpapp01-140222111541-phpapp02.pdfmodelsofteaching-120122073945-phpapp01-140222111541-phpapp02.pdf
modelsofteaching-120122073945-phpapp01-140222111541-phpapp02.pdf
 
What is instructional frame work
What is instructional frame workWhat is instructional frame work
What is instructional frame work
 
Catering for gifted students in unit planning
Catering for gifted students in unit planningCatering for gifted students in unit planning
Catering for gifted students in unit planning
 

More from Azam Almubarki

The power behind images advertisement discourse
The power behind images advertisement discourseThe power behind images advertisement discourse
The power behind images advertisement discourse
Azam Almubarki
 
The most mutual intelligible languages
The most mutual intelligible languagesThe most mutual intelligible languages
The most mutual intelligible languages
Azam Almubarki
 
The discourse of computer assisted language learning
The discourse of computer assisted language learningThe discourse of computer assisted language learning
The discourse of computer assisted language learning
Azam Almubarki
 
Predicates and its types
Predicates and its typesPredicates and its types
Predicates and its types
Azam Almubarki
 
Politeness
PolitenessPoliteness
Politeness
Azam Almubarki
 
Models for bilingualism
Models for bilingualismModels for bilingualism
Models for bilingualism
Azam Almubarki
 
Language varieties as boundaries and as national identity
Language varieties as boundaries and as national identityLanguage varieties as boundaries and as national identity
Language varieties as boundaries and as national identity
Azam Almubarki
 
Language maintenance and shift
Language maintenance and shiftLanguage maintenance and shift
Language maintenance and shift
Azam Almubarki
 
Integrating receptive and productive skills in a reading
Integrating receptive and productive skills in a readingIntegrating receptive and productive skills in a reading
Integrating receptive and productive skills in a reading
Azam Almubarki
 
Error analysis of the writings of undergraduate students of comsats lahore
Error analysis of the writings of undergraduate students of comsats lahoreError analysis of the writings of undergraduate students of comsats lahore
Error analysis of the writings of undergraduate students of comsats lahore
Azam Almubarki
 
Discourse analysis and vocabulary
Discourse analysis and vocabularyDiscourse analysis and vocabulary
Discourse analysis and vocabulary
Azam Almubarki
 
Cultural approaches to discourse
Cultural approaches to discourseCultural approaches to discourse
Cultural approaches to discourse
Azam Almubarki
 
Crafting astrological advertisements in pakistan; a systemic functional analysis
Crafting astrological advertisements in pakistan; a systemic functional analysisCrafting astrological advertisements in pakistan; a systemic functional analysis
Crafting astrological advertisements in pakistan; a systemic functional analysis
Azam Almubarki
 
Conversation analysis
Conversation analysisConversation analysis
Conversation analysis
Azam Almubarki
 
Classroom procedure for explicit instruction in conversational implicature
Classroom procedure for explicit instruction in conversational implicatureClassroom procedure for explicit instruction in conversational implicature
Classroom procedure for explicit instruction in conversational implicature
Azam Almubarki
 
Bilingualism why so many languages
Bilingualism why so many languagesBilingualism why so many languages
Bilingualism why so many languages
Azam Almubarki
 
A study of conversational implicatures in titanic film
A study of conversational implicatures in titanic filmA study of conversational implicatures in titanic film
A study of conversational implicatures in titanic film
Azam Almubarki
 
A Systemic Functional approach to an analysis of amulet advertisements
A Systemic Functional approach to an analysis of amulet advertisementsA Systemic Functional approach to an analysis of amulet advertisements
A Systemic Functional approach to an analysis of amulet advertisements
Azam Almubarki
 
A case study on college english classroom discourse
A case study on college english classroom discourseA case study on college english classroom discourse
A case study on college english classroom discourse
Azam Almubarki
 
Crafting astrological advertisements in pakistan; a systemic functional analysis
Crafting astrological advertisements in pakistan; a systemic functional analysisCrafting astrological advertisements in pakistan; a systemic functional analysis
Crafting astrological advertisements in pakistan; a systemic functional analysis
Azam Almubarki
 

More from Azam Almubarki (20)

The power behind images advertisement discourse
The power behind images advertisement discourseThe power behind images advertisement discourse
The power behind images advertisement discourse
 
The most mutual intelligible languages
The most mutual intelligible languagesThe most mutual intelligible languages
The most mutual intelligible languages
 
The discourse of computer assisted language learning
The discourse of computer assisted language learningThe discourse of computer assisted language learning
The discourse of computer assisted language learning
 
Predicates and its types
Predicates and its typesPredicates and its types
Predicates and its types
 
Politeness
PolitenessPoliteness
Politeness
 
Models for bilingualism
Models for bilingualismModels for bilingualism
Models for bilingualism
 
Language varieties as boundaries and as national identity
Language varieties as boundaries and as national identityLanguage varieties as boundaries and as national identity
Language varieties as boundaries and as national identity
 
Language maintenance and shift
Language maintenance and shiftLanguage maintenance and shift
Language maintenance and shift
 
Integrating receptive and productive skills in a reading
Integrating receptive and productive skills in a readingIntegrating receptive and productive skills in a reading
Integrating receptive and productive skills in a reading
 
Error analysis of the writings of undergraduate students of comsats lahore
Error analysis of the writings of undergraduate students of comsats lahoreError analysis of the writings of undergraduate students of comsats lahore
Error analysis of the writings of undergraduate students of comsats lahore
 
Discourse analysis and vocabulary
Discourse analysis and vocabularyDiscourse analysis and vocabulary
Discourse analysis and vocabulary
 
Cultural approaches to discourse
Cultural approaches to discourseCultural approaches to discourse
Cultural approaches to discourse
 
Crafting astrological advertisements in pakistan; a systemic functional analysis
Crafting astrological advertisements in pakistan; a systemic functional analysisCrafting astrological advertisements in pakistan; a systemic functional analysis
Crafting astrological advertisements in pakistan; a systemic functional analysis
 
Conversation analysis
Conversation analysisConversation analysis
Conversation analysis
 
Classroom procedure for explicit instruction in conversational implicature
Classroom procedure for explicit instruction in conversational implicatureClassroom procedure for explicit instruction in conversational implicature
Classroom procedure for explicit instruction in conversational implicature
 
Bilingualism why so many languages
Bilingualism why so many languagesBilingualism why so many languages
Bilingualism why so many languages
 
A study of conversational implicatures in titanic film
A study of conversational implicatures in titanic filmA study of conversational implicatures in titanic film
A study of conversational implicatures in titanic film
 
A Systemic Functional approach to an analysis of amulet advertisements
A Systemic Functional approach to an analysis of amulet advertisementsA Systemic Functional approach to an analysis of amulet advertisements
A Systemic Functional approach to an analysis of amulet advertisements
 
A case study on college english classroom discourse
A case study on college english classroom discourseA case study on college english classroom discourse
A case study on college english classroom discourse
 
Crafting astrological advertisements in pakistan; a systemic functional analysis
Crafting astrological advertisements in pakistan; a systemic functional analysisCrafting astrological advertisements in pakistan; a systemic functional analysis
Crafting astrological advertisements in pakistan; a systemic functional analysis
 

On the way to dialogic teaching

  • 1. On the Way to Dialogic teaching: Action Research as a Means to change Classroom Discourse Muhammad Azam Research Scholar COMSATS Institute of Information Technology Lahore, Pakistan
  • 2. Introduction • This Study focuses on implementing dialogic teaching principles in lower secondary school teaching. • Two kinds of teaching • Authoritative: controlled by the teacher • Dialogic: collaboration between students and teacher
  • 3. Introduction • Vygotsky’s idea of zone of proximal development – Difference between the current level of a child’s performance and the potential development level with a teacher’s assistance. • Scaffolding – A temporary support provided to the student by the teacher. – To focus on the particular skill at the particular time
  • 4. Features of Dialogic teaching • The focus on particular aspects of classroom discourse assessed according to the dialogic quality it introduces. • We can assess this by focusing the dialogues between teacher and students. – Question level – Question length – Question ecology – Communication pattern – Classroom interaction (Smart and Marshall, 2013)
  • 5. Features of Dialogic teaching • Model proposed by Nystrand et al. (1997): – Authentic questions – Uptake – Higher-order evaluation – Open discussion • Model of kuo, Clark, Anderson and others; – Authority – Question – Feedback – Connecting student ideas – Explanation – Collaboration
  • 6. Methodology • Seminar for teachers (Teacher Development Programme) – Four teachers participated • Discussion of the presented topics • Video recording of the classrooms • Discussion of the recording between teachers and the researcher
  • 7. Data Collection • 1. interview between a teacher and a reseacher • 2. Sound recording of group discussion at seminars • 3. video recordings form lesson • 4. sound recording of reflective interviews • 5. Questionnaire for the students at the beginning and at the end of the programme
  • 8. Data Analysis • The use of ATLAS.ti and Statistica • A set of codes for analysis of data; – The character of teacher initiations • (openness, cognitive, demand) – The character of student replies • Length, cognitive correspondence – The presence of student initiations and their nature • Cognitive demand and openness – The occurrence of triadic interaction
  • 9. Data Analysis • The use of t-test; – For analysis of control and experimental group of teachers • Conclusion • Teachers made their questions more open and more cognitively and students replies became longer and their initiations also grew. • Teachers changed the way they communicate.