SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 12
Language Maintenance and Shift
Muhammad Azam
Research Scholar
COMSATS Institute of Information
Technology Lahore, Pakistan
Introduction
• What happens when people with different mother
tongues meet each others?
• 1. They simply maintained their mother tongue.
That’s called “Language Maintenance”
• 2. They shift to the new L2 as their main (or only)
language. It is “ Language Shift”
Introduction
• There are three main possible outcomes when
speakers are exposed to a second language:
Introduction
• How much time is required for language shift?
Introduction
• However, a ‘three generation shift‘ is not the only
possible pattern. Paulston (1994) cites the Greeks in
Pittsburgh as experiencing a four generation shift.
She attributes this slower shift to the use of a
standardized, prestigious written language; access to
an institution teaching Greek language and literacy
(i.e. Greek churches in Pittsburgh); and arranged
marriages with one partner being a monolingual
Greek speaker from Greece.
Introduction
• A five stage shift from minority language
monolingualism to majority language monolingualism
was found by Von Gleich and Wölck (1994) in Peru:
– (1) mono-lingualism in Quechua (Quichua),
– (2) bilingualism but Quechua stronger than Spanish,
– (3) bilingualism with Quechua and Spanish approximately
balanced,
– (4)bilingualism but Spanish dominant over Quechua,
– (5) mono-lingualism in Spanish.
Introduction
• Amongst Panjabi, Italian, Gaelic and Welsh
communities in Britain, there are occasional ‘fourth
generation’ individuals who sometimes wish to
revive the language of their ethnic origins.
• The pressure to become part of a larger whole seems
to result in a counter-balancing need to have secure
roots within a smaller and more domestic
community.
Political, Social and Demographic
Factors
Political, Social and Demographic
Factors
Cultural Factors
Cultural Factors
Linguistic Factors

More Related Content

What's hot

Language Changes, Shift, and Death
Language Changes, Shift, and DeathLanguage Changes, Shift, and Death
Language Changes, Shift, and DeathFlipped Channel
 
U fhp 2012-13-l3-sla-handout 1-2 - inconnu(e)
U fhp  2012-13-l3-sla-handout 1-2 - inconnu(e)U fhp  2012-13-l3-sla-handout 1-2 - inconnu(e)
U fhp 2012-13-l3-sla-handout 1-2 - inconnu(e)blessedkkr
 
Silence in second language acquisition. Granger, C. (2004)
Silence in second language acquisition. Granger, C. (2004)Silence in second language acquisition. Granger, C. (2004)
Silence in second language acquisition. Granger, C. (2004)M Gaye
 
Assigmen clea
Assigmen cleaAssigmen clea
Assigmen cleafarhasni
 
Linguistic Imperialism: Questionnaire
Linguistic Imperialism: Questionnaire Linguistic Imperialism: Questionnaire
Linguistic Imperialism: Questionnaire Rocio Villoria
 
Attitudes toward pidgin and creole language
Attitudes toward pidgin and creole languageAttitudes toward pidgin and creole language
Attitudes toward pidgin and creole languageNawan Rz
 
Pidgins and creoles as resources in the classroom
Pidgins and creoles as resources in the classroomPidgins and creoles as resources in the classroom
Pidgins and creoles as resources in the classroomNawan Rz
 
Code switching and mixing in internet Chatting
Code switching and mixing in internet Chatting Code switching and mixing in internet Chatting
Code switching and mixing in internet Chatting Hani Shakir
 
#language contact and language choice
#language contact and language choice #language contact and language choice
#language contact and language choice Ayman Batool
 
Language and communication (1)
Language and communication (1)Language and communication (1)
Language and communication (1)VivaAs
 
Code switching linguistic
Code switching linguistic  Code switching linguistic
Code switching linguistic Mahin Malik
 
Standards, codification and world englishes
Standards, codification and world englishesStandards, codification and world englishes
Standards, codification and world englishesLaiba Yaseen
 

What's hot (20)

Language Changes, Shift, and Death
Language Changes, Shift, and DeathLanguage Changes, Shift, and Death
Language Changes, Shift, and Death
 
U fhp 2012-13-l3-sla-handout 1-2 - inconnu(e)
U fhp  2012-13-l3-sla-handout 1-2 - inconnu(e)U fhp  2012-13-l3-sla-handout 1-2 - inconnu(e)
U fhp 2012-13-l3-sla-handout 1-2 - inconnu(e)
 
Silence in second language acquisition. Granger, C. (2004)
Silence in second language acquisition. Granger, C. (2004)Silence in second language acquisition. Granger, C. (2004)
Silence in second language acquisition. Granger, C. (2004)
 
Assigmen clea
Assigmen cleaAssigmen clea
Assigmen clea
 
what is Linguistics
what is Linguisticswhat is Linguistics
what is Linguistics
 
Linguistic Imperialism
Linguistic ImperialismLinguistic Imperialism
Linguistic Imperialism
 
Linguistic Imperialism: Questionnaire
Linguistic Imperialism: Questionnaire Linguistic Imperialism: Questionnaire
Linguistic Imperialism: Questionnaire
 
Language change
Language changeLanguage change
Language change
 
Attitudes toward pidgin and creole language
Attitudes toward pidgin and creole languageAttitudes toward pidgin and creole language
Attitudes toward pidgin and creole language
 
Pidgins and creoles as resources in the classroom
Pidgins and creoles as resources in the classroomPidgins and creoles as resources in the classroom
Pidgins and creoles as resources in the classroom
 
Phonological universal
Phonological universalPhonological universal
Phonological universal
 
Paper nilep vip
Paper nilep vipPaper nilep vip
Paper nilep vip
 
Code switching and mixing in internet Chatting
Code switching and mixing in internet Chatting Code switching and mixing in internet Chatting
Code switching and mixing in internet Chatting
 
#language contact and language choice
#language contact and language choice #language contact and language choice
#language contact and language choice
 
Language and communication (1)
Language and communication (1)Language and communication (1)
Language and communication (1)
 
Week 9 language change
Week 9 language changeWeek 9 language change
Week 9 language change
 
Code Switching
Code SwitchingCode Switching
Code Switching
 
Code switching linguistic
Code switching linguistic  Code switching linguistic
Code switching linguistic
 
Presentation coglab
Presentation coglabPresentation coglab
Presentation coglab
 
Standards, codification and world englishes
Standards, codification and world englishesStandards, codification and world englishes
Standards, codification and world englishes
 

Similar to Language Maintenance Shift and Factors

Language Contact Delil and Workineh.pptx
Language Contact  Delil and Workineh.pptxLanguage Contact  Delil and Workineh.pptx
Language Contact Delil and Workineh.pptxDELILKASIM1
 
Language Contact:aspects and Its Results
Language Contact:aspects and Its ResultsLanguage Contact:aspects and Its Results
Language Contact:aspects and Its ResultsDESTAWWAGNEW
 
Acquisition of multilingualism
Acquisition of multilingualismAcquisition of multilingualism
Acquisition of multilingualismNur Khalidah
 
A Study of Positive Transfer on Junior High Students in English Vocabulary L...
 A Study of Positive Transfer on Junior High Students in English Vocabulary L... A Study of Positive Transfer on Junior High Students in English Vocabulary L...
A Study of Positive Transfer on Junior High Students in English Vocabulary L...English Literature and Language Review ELLR
 
TQ_vol47-3_Cenoz et al.pdf
TQ_vol47-3_Cenoz et al.pdfTQ_vol47-3_Cenoz et al.pdf
TQ_vol47-3_Cenoz et al.pdfSTELLAMALUENDA
 
Prof. barbara seidlhofer
Prof. barbara seidlhoferProf. barbara seidlhofer
Prof. barbara seidlhoferRichard Pinner
 
Week 2 unit 3 & 4 - language maintenance and shift - linguistic varieties an...
Week 2  unit 3 & 4 - language maintenance and shift - linguistic varieties an...Week 2  unit 3 & 4 - language maintenance and shift - linguistic varieties an...
Week 2 unit 3 & 4 - language maintenance and shift - linguistic varieties an...Mar Iam
 
Sociolinguistics - 8. language existence online version
Sociolinguistics - 8. language existence online versionSociolinguistics - 8. language existence online version
Sociolinguistics - 8. language existence online versionMashrurShahidHossain
 
Translanguaging theory. questionnaire.
Translanguaging theory. questionnaire. Translanguaging theory. questionnaire.
Translanguaging theory. questionnaire. SolCortese1
 
Bilingualism in Children: Learning a Second Language in the Home vs. Acquirin...
Bilingualism in Children: Learning a Second Language in the Home vs. Acquirin...Bilingualism in Children: Learning a Second Language in the Home vs. Acquirin...
Bilingualism in Children: Learning a Second Language in the Home vs. Acquirin...Jessie Mason
 
EMI and CLIL and ELF: how do they relate?
EMI and CLIL and ELF: how do they relate?EMI and CLIL and ELF: how do they relate?
EMI and CLIL and ELF: how do they relate?Richard Pinner
 
Bilingualism by Agnes Lam
Bilingualism by Agnes LamBilingualism by Agnes Lam
Bilingualism by Agnes LamParth Bhatt
 
Decline and fall of the native speaker
Decline and fall of the native speakerDecline and fall of the native speaker
Decline and fall of the native speakerYunita Wulansari
 
Acquisition, creativity, standards and testing
Acquisition, creativity, standards and testingAcquisition, creativity, standards and testing
Acquisition, creativity, standards and testingLaiba Yaseen
 
Tesol2011 pc
Tesol2011 pcTesol2011 pc
Tesol2011 pcvacurves
 
(Applied linguistics) shmitt's book ch 1
(Applied linguistics) shmitt's book ch 1(Applied linguistics) shmitt's book ch 1
(Applied linguistics) shmitt's book ch 1VivaAs
 

Similar to Language Maintenance Shift and Factors (20)

Language Contact Delil and Workineh.pptx
Language Contact  Delil and Workineh.pptxLanguage Contact  Delil and Workineh.pptx
Language Contact Delil and Workineh.pptx
 
Language Contact:aspects and Its Results
Language Contact:aspects and Its ResultsLanguage Contact:aspects and Its Results
Language Contact:aspects and Its Results
 
Acquisition of multilingualism
Acquisition of multilingualismAcquisition of multilingualism
Acquisition of multilingualism
 
A Study of Positive Transfer on Junior High Students in English Vocabulary L...
 A Study of Positive Transfer on Junior High Students in English Vocabulary L... A Study of Positive Transfer on Junior High Students in English Vocabulary L...
A Study of Positive Transfer on Junior High Students in English Vocabulary L...
 
TQ_vol47-3_Cenoz et al.pdf
TQ_vol47-3_Cenoz et al.pdfTQ_vol47-3_Cenoz et al.pdf
TQ_vol47-3_Cenoz et al.pdf
 
Mc kay bolouri
Mc kay bolouriMc kay bolouri
Mc kay bolouri
 
Prof. barbara seidlhofer
Prof. barbara seidlhoferProf. barbara seidlhofer
Prof. barbara seidlhofer
 
Week 2 unit 3 & 4 - language maintenance and shift - linguistic varieties an...
Week 2  unit 3 & 4 - language maintenance and shift - linguistic varieties an...Week 2  unit 3 & 4 - language maintenance and shift - linguistic varieties an...
Week 2 unit 3 & 4 - language maintenance and shift - linguistic varieties an...
 
Sociolinguistics - 8. language existence online version
Sociolinguistics - 8. language existence online versionSociolinguistics - 8. language existence online version
Sociolinguistics - 8. language existence online version
 
Translanguaging theory. questionnaire.
Translanguaging theory. questionnaire. Translanguaging theory. questionnaire.
Translanguaging theory. questionnaire.
 
Bilingualism in Children: Learning a Second Language in the Home vs. Acquirin...
Bilingualism in Children: Learning a Second Language in the Home vs. Acquirin...Bilingualism in Children: Learning a Second Language in the Home vs. Acquirin...
Bilingualism in Children: Learning a Second Language in the Home vs. Acquirin...
 
EMI and CLIL and ELF: how do they relate?
EMI and CLIL and ELF: how do they relate?EMI and CLIL and ELF: how do they relate?
EMI and CLIL and ELF: how do they relate?
 
Bilingualism by Agnes Lam
Bilingualism by Agnes LamBilingualism by Agnes Lam
Bilingualism by Agnes Lam
 
Decline and fall of the native speaker
Decline and fall of the native speakerDecline and fall of the native speaker
Decline and fall of the native speaker
 
Acquisition, creativity, standards and testing
Acquisition, creativity, standards and testingAcquisition, creativity, standards and testing
Acquisition, creativity, standards and testing
 
Assignment 2
Assignment 2Assignment 2
Assignment 2
 
Indrani ptn
Indrani ptnIndrani ptn
Indrani ptn
 
Module 1
Module 1Module 1
Module 1
 
Tesol2011 pc
Tesol2011 pcTesol2011 pc
Tesol2011 pc
 
(Applied linguistics) shmitt's book ch 1
(Applied linguistics) shmitt's book ch 1(Applied linguistics) shmitt's book ch 1
(Applied linguistics) shmitt's book ch 1
 

More from Azam Almubarki

The power behind images advertisement discourse
The power behind images advertisement discourseThe power behind images advertisement discourse
The power behind images advertisement discourseAzam Almubarki
 
The most mutual intelligible languages
The most mutual intelligible languagesThe most mutual intelligible languages
The most mutual intelligible languagesAzam Almubarki
 
The discourse of computer assisted language learning
The discourse of computer assisted language learningThe discourse of computer assisted language learning
The discourse of computer assisted language learningAzam Almubarki
 
Predicates and its types
Predicates and its typesPredicates and its types
Predicates and its typesAzam Almubarki
 
On the way to dialogic teaching
On the way to dialogic teachingOn the way to dialogic teaching
On the way to dialogic teachingAzam Almubarki
 
Language varieties as boundaries and as national identity
Language varieties as boundaries and as national identityLanguage varieties as boundaries and as national identity
Language varieties as boundaries and as national identityAzam Almubarki
 
Language maintenance and shift
Language maintenance and shiftLanguage maintenance and shift
Language maintenance and shiftAzam Almubarki
 
Integrating receptive and productive skills in a reading
Integrating receptive and productive skills in a readingIntegrating receptive and productive skills in a reading
Integrating receptive and productive skills in a readingAzam Almubarki
 
Error analysis of the writings of undergraduate students of comsats lahore
Error analysis of the writings of undergraduate students of comsats lahoreError analysis of the writings of undergraduate students of comsats lahore
Error analysis of the writings of undergraduate students of comsats lahoreAzam Almubarki
 
Discourse analysis and vocabulary
Discourse analysis and vocabularyDiscourse analysis and vocabulary
Discourse analysis and vocabularyAzam Almubarki
 
Cultural approaches to discourse
Cultural approaches to discourseCultural approaches to discourse
Cultural approaches to discourseAzam Almubarki
 
Crafting astrological advertisements in pakistan; a systemic functional analysis
Crafting astrological advertisements in pakistan; a systemic functional analysisCrafting astrological advertisements in pakistan; a systemic functional analysis
Crafting astrological advertisements in pakistan; a systemic functional analysisAzam Almubarki
 
Classroom procedure for explicit instruction in conversational implicature
Classroom procedure for explicit instruction in conversational implicatureClassroom procedure for explicit instruction in conversational implicature
Classroom procedure for explicit instruction in conversational implicatureAzam Almubarki
 
Bilingualism why so many languages
Bilingualism why so many languagesBilingualism why so many languages
Bilingualism why so many languagesAzam Almubarki
 
A study of conversational implicatures in titanic film
A study of conversational implicatures in titanic filmA study of conversational implicatures in titanic film
A study of conversational implicatures in titanic filmAzam Almubarki
 
A Systemic Functional approach to an analysis of amulet advertisements
A Systemic Functional approach to an analysis of amulet advertisementsA Systemic Functional approach to an analysis of amulet advertisements
A Systemic Functional approach to an analysis of amulet advertisementsAzam Almubarki
 
A case study on college english classroom discourse
A case study on college english classroom discourseA case study on college english classroom discourse
A case study on college english classroom discourseAzam Almubarki
 
Crafting astrological advertisements in pakistan; a systemic functional analysis
Crafting astrological advertisements in pakistan; a systemic functional analysisCrafting astrological advertisements in pakistan; a systemic functional analysis
Crafting astrological advertisements in pakistan; a systemic functional analysisAzam Almubarki
 

More from Azam Almubarki (20)

The power behind images advertisement discourse
The power behind images advertisement discourseThe power behind images advertisement discourse
The power behind images advertisement discourse
 
The most mutual intelligible languages
The most mutual intelligible languagesThe most mutual intelligible languages
The most mutual intelligible languages
 
The discourse of computer assisted language learning
The discourse of computer assisted language learningThe discourse of computer assisted language learning
The discourse of computer assisted language learning
 
Predicates and its types
Predicates and its typesPredicates and its types
Predicates and its types
 
Politeness
PolitenessPoliteness
Politeness
 
On the way to dialogic teaching
On the way to dialogic teachingOn the way to dialogic teaching
On the way to dialogic teaching
 
Language varieties as boundaries and as national identity
Language varieties as boundaries and as national identityLanguage varieties as boundaries and as national identity
Language varieties as boundaries and as national identity
 
Language maintenance and shift
Language maintenance and shiftLanguage maintenance and shift
Language maintenance and shift
 
Integrating receptive and productive skills in a reading
Integrating receptive and productive skills in a readingIntegrating receptive and productive skills in a reading
Integrating receptive and productive skills in a reading
 
Error analysis of the writings of undergraduate students of comsats lahore
Error analysis of the writings of undergraduate students of comsats lahoreError analysis of the writings of undergraduate students of comsats lahore
Error analysis of the writings of undergraduate students of comsats lahore
 
Discourse analysis and vocabulary
Discourse analysis and vocabularyDiscourse analysis and vocabulary
Discourse analysis and vocabulary
 
Cultural approaches to discourse
Cultural approaches to discourseCultural approaches to discourse
Cultural approaches to discourse
 
Crafting astrological advertisements in pakistan; a systemic functional analysis
Crafting astrological advertisements in pakistan; a systemic functional analysisCrafting astrological advertisements in pakistan; a systemic functional analysis
Crafting astrological advertisements in pakistan; a systemic functional analysis
 
Conversation analysis
Conversation analysisConversation analysis
Conversation analysis
 
Classroom procedure for explicit instruction in conversational implicature
Classroom procedure for explicit instruction in conversational implicatureClassroom procedure for explicit instruction in conversational implicature
Classroom procedure for explicit instruction in conversational implicature
 
Bilingualism why so many languages
Bilingualism why so many languagesBilingualism why so many languages
Bilingualism why so many languages
 
A study of conversational implicatures in titanic film
A study of conversational implicatures in titanic filmA study of conversational implicatures in titanic film
A study of conversational implicatures in titanic film
 
A Systemic Functional approach to an analysis of amulet advertisements
A Systemic Functional approach to an analysis of amulet advertisementsA Systemic Functional approach to an analysis of amulet advertisements
A Systemic Functional approach to an analysis of amulet advertisements
 
A case study on college english classroom discourse
A case study on college english classroom discourseA case study on college english classroom discourse
A case study on college english classroom discourse
 
Crafting astrological advertisements in pakistan; a systemic functional analysis
Crafting astrological advertisements in pakistan; a systemic functional analysisCrafting astrological advertisements in pakistan; a systemic functional analysis
Crafting astrological advertisements in pakistan; a systemic functional analysis
 

Language Maintenance Shift and Factors

  • 1. Language Maintenance and Shift Muhammad Azam Research Scholar COMSATS Institute of Information Technology Lahore, Pakistan
  • 2. Introduction • What happens when people with different mother tongues meet each others? • 1. They simply maintained their mother tongue. That’s called “Language Maintenance” • 2. They shift to the new L2 as their main (or only) language. It is “ Language Shift”
  • 3. Introduction • There are three main possible outcomes when speakers are exposed to a second language:
  • 4. Introduction • How much time is required for language shift?
  • 5. Introduction • However, a ‘three generation shift‘ is not the only possible pattern. Paulston (1994) cites the Greeks in Pittsburgh as experiencing a four generation shift. She attributes this slower shift to the use of a standardized, prestigious written language; access to an institution teaching Greek language and literacy (i.e. Greek churches in Pittsburgh); and arranged marriages with one partner being a monolingual Greek speaker from Greece.
  • 6. Introduction • A five stage shift from minority language monolingualism to majority language monolingualism was found by Von Gleich and Wölck (1994) in Peru: – (1) mono-lingualism in Quechua (Quichua), – (2) bilingualism but Quechua stronger than Spanish, – (3) bilingualism with Quechua and Spanish approximately balanced, – (4)bilingualism but Spanish dominant over Quechua, – (5) mono-lingualism in Spanish.
  • 7. Introduction • Amongst Panjabi, Italian, Gaelic and Welsh communities in Britain, there are occasional ‘fourth generation’ individuals who sometimes wish to revive the language of their ethnic origins. • The pressure to become part of a larger whole seems to result in a counter-balancing need to have secure roots within a smaller and more domestic community.
  • 8. Political, Social and Demographic Factors
  • 9. Political, Social and Demographic Factors