This document summarizes the case of a 38-year-old man who suffered traumatic amputation of his right index finger distal phalanx. He presented to the emergency department 6 hours after the injury with the amputated part preserved on ice. The patient was stabilized and treated with antibiotics and tetanus prophylaxis. Given the viability of the amputated part and timing within acceptable warm ischemia limits, the plan was to perform replantation surgery along with postoperative monitoring and rehabilitation. Key factors regarding indications, contraindications and management of traumatic amputations are discussed.