1
Mariano Marcos State University
COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION
Laoag City
LIT 106: Literary Criticism
MARXISM
Hi… I am CAPTAIN BARBELL. I usually help people in distress. I give
solutions to your problems. I am so happy that I am here today at the Sunshine City
of Laoag! Let’s meet my first client.
Hello…My name is Nicholas, “NICK” in short. Captain Barbell, I have a
problem about learning this literary approach called “MARXISM”. Can you help
me with this?
Sure! Did you hear it? Nick needs our help. So let us try to help him! Come on. Let’s do it.
So, let us begin helping Nick. But before delving deeper, let us first define the term? What is
Marxism? Let us consult my HEAVY-DUTY BARBELL!
We also need to meet the brains behind this literary approach. Here, I only included the top five
proponents.
If anything is certain, it is that I myself am not a Marxist.
Reported by Friedrich Engels
Letter to Eduard Bernstein
He was a 19th century German philosopher that became a part of the
Young Hegelians,and later, the Communist League. He was revered as one of
the most influential socialist thinkers of the 19th century.
General Description
Sources of the Trend
Karl Marx
Marxist literary criticism is the belief that literature reflects class
struggle and materialism. It looks at how literature functions in relation to
other aspects of the superstructure, particularly other articulations of
ideology.
Like feminist critics, it investigates how literature can work as a
force for social change, or as a reaffirmation of existing conditions.
Like New Historicism, it examines how history influences
literature; the difference is that Marxism focuses on the lower classes.
2
WORKS:
The German Ideology (1845): introduced the concept of dialectical materialism (argued that the
means of production controls a society’s institutions and beliefs, and contended that history is
progressing toward the eventual triumph of communism)
Communist Manifesto (1848): identified class struggle as the driving force behind history and
anticipated that it would lead to a revolution in which the workers would overturn the capitalists,
take control of economic production, and abolish private property by turning it over to the
government to distribute fairly
Das Kapital (1867): argued that history is determined by economic conditions and urged an end
to private ownership of public utilities, transportation, and the means of production
CORE MARXIST PRINCIPLES:
 Proletariat. Lower class
 Bourgeoisie. Upper class
 Capital. Means of gaining profit
 Hegemony. Upper class dominates the lower class
 False consciousness. Lower class doesn’t realize the effect that the upper class has on them.
He shared Marx’s socialist beliefs and provided support financially as well as
intellectually while Marx developed his theories.
WORKS:
The Condition of the Working Class in England (1844): argues
that the Industrial Revolution made workers worse off.
Co-authored The Communist Manifesto (1848)
He was a literary theorist and philosopherwho was widely viewed as one of the
founders of “Western Marxism”.
CONTRIBUTION:
Reflectionism or Vulgar Marxism
Believed that the text will reflect the society that has produced it
Stressed that historical approach is different to reflectionism
Reflectionists attribute the separation that they discover to the ills of
capitalism.
He was commonly referred to as a structural Marxist.
CONTRIBUTION:
Interpellation
Argued that literature and art affect the society
Believed that the working class is manipulated to accept the ideology
of the dominant one
FriedrichEngels
Georg Lukács
Louis Althusser
3
He was a leading Italian Marxist theoretician and politician.
CONTRIBUTION:
Developed the theory of cultural hegemony, to explain why the
"inevitable" revolution of the proletariat predicted by orthodox Marxism
had not occurred by the early 20th century.
Did you know that…?
The principles of Marxism were not designed to serve as a theory about how to interpret texts.
Instead, they were meant to be a set of social, economic, and political ideas that would, according
to their followers, change the world.
Base The methods of production in a given society
Bourgeoisie The name given by Marx to the owners of the means of production in a society
Capitalism An economic system that is based on private ownership of the means of
production and the creation of goods or services for profit
Hegemony Control or dominating influence by one person or group, especially by one
political group over society or one nation over others
Ideology A belief system
Proletariat The name given by Marx to the workers of the society
Socialism a political theory or system in which the means of production and distribution are
controlled by the people and operated according to equity and fairness rather than
market principles
Superstructure The social, political, and ideological systems and institutions – for example, the
values, art, and legal processes of a society – that are generated by the base
We already helped “Nick” on some of his problems. But I believe we should
teach him now the principles under Marxism. This will be a comprehensive view for him
to better understand the said literary approach.
That’s right Captain Barbell. So please help me read this table. Come
on! Let’s delve deeper in the world of Marxism.
General Precepts Underpinnings of the General Precept
Marxist literary criticism promotes the idea that
literature should be a tool in the revolutionary
struggle.
In Communist Manifesto (1848), Karl Marx
and Friedrich Engels identified class struggle
as the driving force behind history and
anticipated that it would lead to a revolution in
which the workers would overturn the
capitalists, take control of economic
production, and abolish property by turning it
over to the government to distribute fairly.
Antonio Gramsci
Table of General Precepts and Underpinnings about Marxism
Trivia Corner
Definitionof Terms
4
It attempts to clarify the relationship of literary
work to social reality.
It judges literature by how it represents the main
struggles for power going on that time, how it may
Louis Althusser pointed out that there remains
a possibility that the working class will develop
its own culture, which can lead to revolution
and the establishment of a new hegemony, or
power base. This idea is referred to as
production theory.
The concept of dialectical materialism argued
that the means of production controls a
society’s institutions and beliefs, and
contended that history is progressing toward
the eventual triumph of communism.
Georg Lucáks viewed the text as a reflection to
the society that has produced it. This is also
known as reflectionism.
Marxist reflection theory advocates that readers
who recognize the influence of capitalistic
classes on human behavior and the
perpetuation of injustice and inequality should
propose workable solutions.
Lucáks’s Vulgar Marxism seeks to determine
the nature of a given society, to find “a truer,
more concrete insight into reality” and look for
the “full process of life.”
Althusser’s Interpellation stated that the
working class is manipulated to accept the
ideology of the dominant one.
Frederick Jameson stressed on the political
unconscious, the exploitation and oppression
buried in a work. The critic, according to
Jameson, seeks to uncover those buried forces
and bring them to light.
To write well is more than a matter of ‘style’; it
also means having at one’s disposal an
ideological perspective which can penetrate to
the realities of men’s experience in a certain
situation.
In Joseph Conrad’s Nostromo, the pessimistic
view is rather a unique transformation into art
of an ideological pessimism rife in his period—
a sense of history as futile and cyclical, of
individuals as impenetrable and solitary, of
human values as relativistic and irrational,
which marks a drastic crisis in the ideology of
the Western bourgeois class to which Conrad
allied himself.
To explain any social or political context, any
event or product, it is necessary to first
understand the material and historical
circumstance in which they occur.
Marxism is the basis of a system of thought
that sees inequitable relationships as the source
5
influence those struggles.
It should follow rules laid down by literary
tradition.
of class conflict.
Literary works are forms of perception,
particular ways of seeing the world which is
the ‘social mentality’ or ideology of an age.
For Antonio Gramsci, literature is a tool of the
privileged class.
Joseph Stalin stressed that literature should
promote Socialism.
Writers and critics alike began to use Marxist
interpretations and evaluations of society in
their work. Through this, it became
interestingly important to ask how a given text
contributed to the solution of social problems
based on Marxist principles
Marx described his own works in a letter to
Engels as forming an ‘artistic whole’, and was
scrupulously sensitive to questions of literary
style.
Marxist criticism is not merely a ‘sociology of
literature’ concerned with how novels get
published and whether they mention the
working class. It should be sensitive to forms,
styles and meanings.
1. Who are the powerful people in the society depicted in the text? Who are the powerless people?
Are they depicted with equal attention?
2. Why do the powerful have that power? Why is it denied to others?
3. Do you find evidence of class conflict and struggle?
4. Do you find repression and manipulation of workers by owners?
5. Is there evidence of alienation and fragmentation?
CONTENT
Should be portrayed as being
oppressive to most people
ELEMENT
Follows the rules laid down by
literary tradition
WRITER
On the side of the oppressed
READER
Enlightened about the
relationship of the powerful
few to the powerless many
WORK
Anatomy of Marxist Literary Criticism
Guide Questions for Marxist Literary Criticism
6
6. Does the bourgeoisie in the text, either consciously or unconsciously, routinely repress and
manipulate less powerful groups? If so, what are the tools they use? News? Media? Religion?
Literature?
7. What does the setting tell you about the distribution of power and wealth?
8. Is there evidence of conspicuous consumption?
9. Does the society that is depicted value things for their usefulness, for their potential for resale or
trade, or for their power to convey social status?
10. Do you find in the text itself evidence that it is a product of the culture in which it originated?
11. What ideology is revealed by the answers to the preceding questions? Does it support the values
of capitalism or any other "ism" that institutionalizes the domination of one group of people over
another--for example, racism, sexism or imperialism? Or does it condemn such systems?
12. Is the work consistent in its ideology? Or does it have inner conflicts?
13. Do you find concepts from other schools of literary criticism--for example, cultural studies,
feminism, postmodernism--overlapping with this one?
14. Does this text make you aware of your own acceptance of any social, economic, or political
practices that involve control or oppression of others?
Preview the short story titled The Necklace by Guy de Maupassant and be ready to answer the
questions which will be given to you by the reporter.
You are going to watch a video titled The Fox and the Sick Lion by Aesop. Concentrate watching
it so that you can find some of the Marxist principles present in the video.
Are you done? Do you like the video? Were you able to find there the principles of Marxism?
Now, fill up the table below.
QUESTIONS ANSWER PROOF/REASON
Who is the bourgeoisie?
Who are the proletariats?
What is the capital that is being
depicted in the video?
Is hegemony present in the
video?
Take a Glimpse
Task 1. If Your Eyes Can See
7
Does the video present false
consciousness?
Form groups of four. Invent a very brief story based on one of the pictures below. (Note: The
picture that will be given to you will depend on your groupings.) Be guided on the following Marxists
principles to come up with the work.
1 The characters should consist of both bourgeoisie and proletariats.
2 Gaining a capital should be depicted in the story.
3 False consciousness, as well as hegemony, is evident in the work.
Are you done? Now, be ready to share it in class.
Based on the discussion and your experience you had in analyzing literary works in a Marxist
approach, I believe you are now ready for our last task.
Formulate your own definition of Marxism. Write your answer below. Be ready to share it in
class.
My Own Definition of Marxism
__________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________
Task 3. Define Me
Task 2. Be a Marxist!
8
Wow! We just helped ‘Nick’ on his problem. Well, I enjoyed my stay
here at Laoag City. I enjoyed being with you ‘Nick’ and our friends. Until next
time!
Thank you for coming to our city Captain Barbell. I hope you will
come back. Thank you for helping me in my problems.
I am ‘Nick’. I am a Marxist.
Because of ‘Nick’ and with the help of Captain
Barbell, I was able to become a better critic of a literary
work. I am not already blind with what is happening around
me. I am proud to be a Marxist critic! Thank you, guys. 
REFERENCES
Eagleton, Terry A. (1976). Marxism and Literary Criticism (pp. 551-573). University of
California Press
Shor, Ira. Literary Criticism: Marxism. Helena High
Dobie, Ann. Theory into Practice: Marxist Criticism (pp. 79-96).
JESPER C. SILVA
BSEd III-A, English
DR. JAHNESE D. ASUNCION
Professor
LIT 106: Literary Criticism
October 14, 2015
S.Y. 2015-2016
Your name here:
_______________________________
BSEd III-A, English

Marxist Literary Criticism

  • 1.
    1 Mariano Marcos StateUniversity COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION Laoag City LIT 106: Literary Criticism MARXISM Hi… I am CAPTAIN BARBELL. I usually help people in distress. I give solutions to your problems. I am so happy that I am here today at the Sunshine City of Laoag! Let’s meet my first client. Hello…My name is Nicholas, “NICK” in short. Captain Barbell, I have a problem about learning this literary approach called “MARXISM”. Can you help me with this? Sure! Did you hear it? Nick needs our help. So let us try to help him! Come on. Let’s do it. So, let us begin helping Nick. But before delving deeper, let us first define the term? What is Marxism? Let us consult my HEAVY-DUTY BARBELL! We also need to meet the brains behind this literary approach. Here, I only included the top five proponents. If anything is certain, it is that I myself am not a Marxist. Reported by Friedrich Engels Letter to Eduard Bernstein He was a 19th century German philosopher that became a part of the Young Hegelians,and later, the Communist League. He was revered as one of the most influential socialist thinkers of the 19th century. General Description Sources of the Trend Karl Marx Marxist literary criticism is the belief that literature reflects class struggle and materialism. It looks at how literature functions in relation to other aspects of the superstructure, particularly other articulations of ideology. Like feminist critics, it investigates how literature can work as a force for social change, or as a reaffirmation of existing conditions. Like New Historicism, it examines how history influences literature; the difference is that Marxism focuses on the lower classes.
  • 2.
    2 WORKS: The German Ideology(1845): introduced the concept of dialectical materialism (argued that the means of production controls a society’s institutions and beliefs, and contended that history is progressing toward the eventual triumph of communism) Communist Manifesto (1848): identified class struggle as the driving force behind history and anticipated that it would lead to a revolution in which the workers would overturn the capitalists, take control of economic production, and abolish private property by turning it over to the government to distribute fairly Das Kapital (1867): argued that history is determined by economic conditions and urged an end to private ownership of public utilities, transportation, and the means of production CORE MARXIST PRINCIPLES:  Proletariat. Lower class  Bourgeoisie. Upper class  Capital. Means of gaining profit  Hegemony. Upper class dominates the lower class  False consciousness. Lower class doesn’t realize the effect that the upper class has on them. He shared Marx’s socialist beliefs and provided support financially as well as intellectually while Marx developed his theories. WORKS: The Condition of the Working Class in England (1844): argues that the Industrial Revolution made workers worse off. Co-authored The Communist Manifesto (1848) He was a literary theorist and philosopherwho was widely viewed as one of the founders of “Western Marxism”. CONTRIBUTION: Reflectionism or Vulgar Marxism Believed that the text will reflect the society that has produced it Stressed that historical approach is different to reflectionism Reflectionists attribute the separation that they discover to the ills of capitalism. He was commonly referred to as a structural Marxist. CONTRIBUTION: Interpellation Argued that literature and art affect the society Believed that the working class is manipulated to accept the ideology of the dominant one FriedrichEngels Georg Lukács Louis Althusser
  • 3.
    3 He was aleading Italian Marxist theoretician and politician. CONTRIBUTION: Developed the theory of cultural hegemony, to explain why the "inevitable" revolution of the proletariat predicted by orthodox Marxism had not occurred by the early 20th century. Did you know that…? The principles of Marxism were not designed to serve as a theory about how to interpret texts. Instead, they were meant to be a set of social, economic, and political ideas that would, according to their followers, change the world. Base The methods of production in a given society Bourgeoisie The name given by Marx to the owners of the means of production in a society Capitalism An economic system that is based on private ownership of the means of production and the creation of goods or services for profit Hegemony Control or dominating influence by one person or group, especially by one political group over society or one nation over others Ideology A belief system Proletariat The name given by Marx to the workers of the society Socialism a political theory or system in which the means of production and distribution are controlled by the people and operated according to equity and fairness rather than market principles Superstructure The social, political, and ideological systems and institutions – for example, the values, art, and legal processes of a society – that are generated by the base We already helped “Nick” on some of his problems. But I believe we should teach him now the principles under Marxism. This will be a comprehensive view for him to better understand the said literary approach. That’s right Captain Barbell. So please help me read this table. Come on! Let’s delve deeper in the world of Marxism. General Precepts Underpinnings of the General Precept Marxist literary criticism promotes the idea that literature should be a tool in the revolutionary struggle. In Communist Manifesto (1848), Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels identified class struggle as the driving force behind history and anticipated that it would lead to a revolution in which the workers would overturn the capitalists, take control of economic production, and abolish property by turning it over to the government to distribute fairly. Antonio Gramsci Table of General Precepts and Underpinnings about Marxism Trivia Corner Definitionof Terms
  • 4.
    4 It attempts toclarify the relationship of literary work to social reality. It judges literature by how it represents the main struggles for power going on that time, how it may Louis Althusser pointed out that there remains a possibility that the working class will develop its own culture, which can lead to revolution and the establishment of a new hegemony, or power base. This idea is referred to as production theory. The concept of dialectical materialism argued that the means of production controls a society’s institutions and beliefs, and contended that history is progressing toward the eventual triumph of communism. Georg Lucáks viewed the text as a reflection to the society that has produced it. This is also known as reflectionism. Marxist reflection theory advocates that readers who recognize the influence of capitalistic classes on human behavior and the perpetuation of injustice and inequality should propose workable solutions. Lucáks’s Vulgar Marxism seeks to determine the nature of a given society, to find “a truer, more concrete insight into reality” and look for the “full process of life.” Althusser’s Interpellation stated that the working class is manipulated to accept the ideology of the dominant one. Frederick Jameson stressed on the political unconscious, the exploitation and oppression buried in a work. The critic, according to Jameson, seeks to uncover those buried forces and bring them to light. To write well is more than a matter of ‘style’; it also means having at one’s disposal an ideological perspective which can penetrate to the realities of men’s experience in a certain situation. In Joseph Conrad’s Nostromo, the pessimistic view is rather a unique transformation into art of an ideological pessimism rife in his period— a sense of history as futile and cyclical, of individuals as impenetrable and solitary, of human values as relativistic and irrational, which marks a drastic crisis in the ideology of the Western bourgeois class to which Conrad allied himself. To explain any social or political context, any event or product, it is necessary to first understand the material and historical circumstance in which they occur. Marxism is the basis of a system of thought that sees inequitable relationships as the source
  • 5.
    5 influence those struggles. Itshould follow rules laid down by literary tradition. of class conflict. Literary works are forms of perception, particular ways of seeing the world which is the ‘social mentality’ or ideology of an age. For Antonio Gramsci, literature is a tool of the privileged class. Joseph Stalin stressed that literature should promote Socialism. Writers and critics alike began to use Marxist interpretations and evaluations of society in their work. Through this, it became interestingly important to ask how a given text contributed to the solution of social problems based on Marxist principles Marx described his own works in a letter to Engels as forming an ‘artistic whole’, and was scrupulously sensitive to questions of literary style. Marxist criticism is not merely a ‘sociology of literature’ concerned with how novels get published and whether they mention the working class. It should be sensitive to forms, styles and meanings. 1. Who are the powerful people in the society depicted in the text? Who are the powerless people? Are they depicted with equal attention? 2. Why do the powerful have that power? Why is it denied to others? 3. Do you find evidence of class conflict and struggle? 4. Do you find repression and manipulation of workers by owners? 5. Is there evidence of alienation and fragmentation? CONTENT Should be portrayed as being oppressive to most people ELEMENT Follows the rules laid down by literary tradition WRITER On the side of the oppressed READER Enlightened about the relationship of the powerful few to the powerless many WORK Anatomy of Marxist Literary Criticism Guide Questions for Marxist Literary Criticism
  • 6.
    6 6. Does thebourgeoisie in the text, either consciously or unconsciously, routinely repress and manipulate less powerful groups? If so, what are the tools they use? News? Media? Religion? Literature? 7. What does the setting tell you about the distribution of power and wealth? 8. Is there evidence of conspicuous consumption? 9. Does the society that is depicted value things for their usefulness, for their potential for resale or trade, or for their power to convey social status? 10. Do you find in the text itself evidence that it is a product of the culture in which it originated? 11. What ideology is revealed by the answers to the preceding questions? Does it support the values of capitalism or any other "ism" that institutionalizes the domination of one group of people over another--for example, racism, sexism or imperialism? Or does it condemn such systems? 12. Is the work consistent in its ideology? Or does it have inner conflicts? 13. Do you find concepts from other schools of literary criticism--for example, cultural studies, feminism, postmodernism--overlapping with this one? 14. Does this text make you aware of your own acceptance of any social, economic, or political practices that involve control or oppression of others? Preview the short story titled The Necklace by Guy de Maupassant and be ready to answer the questions which will be given to you by the reporter. You are going to watch a video titled The Fox and the Sick Lion by Aesop. Concentrate watching it so that you can find some of the Marxist principles present in the video. Are you done? Do you like the video? Were you able to find there the principles of Marxism? Now, fill up the table below. QUESTIONS ANSWER PROOF/REASON Who is the bourgeoisie? Who are the proletariats? What is the capital that is being depicted in the video? Is hegemony present in the video? Take a Glimpse Task 1. If Your Eyes Can See
  • 7.
    7 Does the videopresent false consciousness? Form groups of four. Invent a very brief story based on one of the pictures below. (Note: The picture that will be given to you will depend on your groupings.) Be guided on the following Marxists principles to come up with the work. 1 The characters should consist of both bourgeoisie and proletariats. 2 Gaining a capital should be depicted in the story. 3 False consciousness, as well as hegemony, is evident in the work. Are you done? Now, be ready to share it in class. Based on the discussion and your experience you had in analyzing literary works in a Marxist approach, I believe you are now ready for our last task. Formulate your own definition of Marxism. Write your answer below. Be ready to share it in class. My Own Definition of Marxism __________________________________________________________________ __________________________________________________________________ __________________________________________________________________ Task 3. Define Me Task 2. Be a Marxist!
  • 8.
    8 Wow! We justhelped ‘Nick’ on his problem. Well, I enjoyed my stay here at Laoag City. I enjoyed being with you ‘Nick’ and our friends. Until next time! Thank you for coming to our city Captain Barbell. I hope you will come back. Thank you for helping me in my problems. I am ‘Nick’. I am a Marxist. Because of ‘Nick’ and with the help of Captain Barbell, I was able to become a better critic of a literary work. I am not already blind with what is happening around me. I am proud to be a Marxist critic! Thank you, guys.  REFERENCES Eagleton, Terry A. (1976). Marxism and Literary Criticism (pp. 551-573). University of California Press Shor, Ira. Literary Criticism: Marxism. Helena High Dobie, Ann. Theory into Practice: Marxist Criticism (pp. 79-96). JESPER C. SILVA BSEd III-A, English DR. JAHNESE D. ASUNCION Professor LIT 106: Literary Criticism October 14, 2015 S.Y. 2015-2016 Your name here: _______________________________ BSEd III-A, English