Comparative Study of
Religion
 philosophy of religion
 comparative philosophy—how to compare concepts from
different cultures, how to compare models of personhood or
subjectivity in different cultures
 psychology of religion
 and cultural studies (critical theory and religion)—how the
overlapping layers of cognition and biology, selfhood and
kinship, language and the arts speak through us while we
speak through them
How power works in
religious traditions
 Spectrum – from individual experience to social realms of
power
 How do people describe their experiences of power
 How do traditions establish hierarchies of power
 Who belongs, who doesn’t, from the outside (social) to the
inside (sense of self) of exclusion/inclusion dynamics
 One of the most complex and ambiguous relationships is
found in women’s descriptions of their roles. As 50% or
higher of religious community, essential to understand.
How do people achieve
selfhood or status?
 Axes of power by which people organize their traditions
 gender,
 racialized identities,
 and social status (including class, caste, and marginalized
people)
 Examples: Can women attain the highest levels of religious
authority? How does caste continue to work even though it
was officially forbidden in the Indian constitution?
How do people describe
their access to power?
 The enduring power of belonging in or to a religious
tradition. Religious identities are:
 Resilient—conservative (retain tradition) and progressive
(motivated to make contemporary meaning of life)
 Flexible—people negotiate all the time with doctrine
 Embodied, muscular memory of ritual practices including
prayer, birth, marriage, death rituals, belonging. Of interest
to medicine, sociology, psychology, cognitive
sciences, politics.
My interest: Social Justice
and Structural Peace
 Attracted to points of conflict, points of peace-making to
understand what’s going on.
 Why is the contact between religious traditions so often
fraught with violence?
 Why have major non-violence movements been driven by
religiously inspired people?
 One of the most complex and ambiguous relationships is
found in women’s descriptions of their roles. This makes for
powerful understanding.

Keller intro 2013

  • 2.
    Comparative Study of Religion philosophy of religion  comparative philosophy—how to compare concepts from different cultures, how to compare models of personhood or subjectivity in different cultures  psychology of religion  and cultural studies (critical theory and religion)—how the overlapping layers of cognition and biology, selfhood and kinship, language and the arts speak through us while we speak through them
  • 3.
    How power worksin religious traditions  Spectrum – from individual experience to social realms of power  How do people describe their experiences of power  How do traditions establish hierarchies of power  Who belongs, who doesn’t, from the outside (social) to the inside (sense of self) of exclusion/inclusion dynamics  One of the most complex and ambiguous relationships is found in women’s descriptions of their roles. As 50% or higher of religious community, essential to understand.
  • 4.
    How do peopleachieve selfhood or status?  Axes of power by which people organize their traditions  gender,  racialized identities,  and social status (including class, caste, and marginalized people)  Examples: Can women attain the highest levels of religious authority? How does caste continue to work even though it was officially forbidden in the Indian constitution?
  • 5.
    How do peopledescribe their access to power?  The enduring power of belonging in or to a religious tradition. Religious identities are:  Resilient—conservative (retain tradition) and progressive (motivated to make contemporary meaning of life)  Flexible—people negotiate all the time with doctrine  Embodied, muscular memory of ritual practices including prayer, birth, marriage, death rituals, belonging. Of interest to medicine, sociology, psychology, cognitive sciences, politics.
  • 6.
    My interest: SocialJustice and Structural Peace  Attracted to points of conflict, points of peace-making to understand what’s going on.  Why is the contact between religious traditions so often fraught with violence?  Why have major non-violence movements been driven by religiously inspired people?  One of the most complex and ambiguous relationships is found in women’s descriptions of their roles. This makes for powerful understanding.