Health and Safety at Water Treatment Facilities
David P. Horowitz, P.E., CSP (@dphorowitz)
■ Health & Safety
– OSHA Top 10
■ Globally Harmonized System
– Changes
– Implementation Dates
■ General Water Treatment Plant Hazards
■ Safe Chemical Handling
– Typical treatment plant chemistries
– Initial response activities
– Tanks
Why do we care?
Why do we care?
Safety Takeaways
■ Watch for common
issues!
■ Watch your staff &
contractors
■ Management of change
– Safety Data Sheets
■ The most frequent injuries in water treatment
facilities are:
a. Cuts and bruises
b. Explosive and toxic gases
c. Slips and falls
d. Strains and Sprains
e. None of the above
I’m from OSHA.
I’m here to help.
I’m from OSHA.
I’m here to help.
#10 Electrical – Systems Design
■ Electrical design
■ Arc Flash (NFPA 70E)
System specific
evaluations
■ Proposed equipment
■ Existing equipment
■ PPE
#9 Machine Guarding
■ Engineered or
structural fixes
■ Job Hazard Analysis
(JHAs)
#8 Electrical - Wiring
■ Permanent
■ Temporary
#7 Ladders -
CONSTRUCTION
■ Design considerations
■ Milestone Observation
OSHA Video - Ladders
#6 Lockout /
Tagout
■ System specific
evaluation
■ Comprehensive
energy source
understanding
#5 Powered
Industrial Trucks
■ PIVs
■ Hoisting requirements
#4 Respiratory Protection
■ Engineer out, if possible
■ Written Plan
■ Baseline physical
■ Medical surveillance
■ Fit testing
#3 Scaffolding
-
CONSTRUCTIO
N
■ Design considerations
■ Milestone Observation
#2 Hazard
Communication
■ Globally Harmonized System
■ Risk Management Planning
– Chlorine Gas = >2,500 Lbs
#1 Fall Protection - CONSTRUCTION
■ Design considerations
■ Milestone Observation
■ The most frequent safety hazard from the use of
polymers is:
A. Attack on many types of stainless steel
B. Cause of severe burns and blindness
C. Evolution of a toxic gas
D. Extreme slipping hazard when spilled on surfaces
E. The boss scrutinizing chemical costs
Global Harmonized System
Major Changes
■ Training and implementation
■ Hazard classification
■ Labels and warnings
■ Standard Safety Data Sheets
OSHA Video - GHS
Hazard
Classifications
Physical
Hazards
Hazard
Classifications
Health
Hazards
■ The goal of GHS
■ Label elements and GHS pictograms
■ Labeling components
■ Possible sources of confusion
What’s wrong with
HAZCOM
Too many
systems
Too many
systems Too confusingToo confusing
Too time
consuming
Too time
consuming Too nationally
focused
Too nationally
focused
What’s wrong with HAZCOM?
Lots
Sometimes the Signs
Are Obvious
Sometimes They Can Be
Subject to Interpretation
Or need an interpreter
Or worse
Protect
yourself
Protect
others
Major Changes
The Basics
■ Hazard classification
■ Labels and warnings
■ Standard Safety Data Sheets
■ Training and implementation
Effective Completion
Date Requirement(s) Who
December 1, 2013 Training
•New Label Elements
•Safety Data Sheets
Employers
June 1, 2015 Manufacturer full compliance
HAZCOM plans updated
Chemical Manufacturers
Employers
December 1, 2015 Distribution Prohibitions for non
GHS labels
Chemical Manufacturers,
Importers and
Distributors
June 1, 2016 Updates to program and training
based on new hazard
classifications
Employers
Physical Hazard Health Hazard
HAZARD TYPES
■ Physical
– Unstable Chemicals (Water Reactive)
– Flammables or Combustibles
– Explosives
– Stored at High Pressures
– Thermal Effects
■ Health
– Acute
– Chronic
– Latency Period
PHYSICAL HAZARDS
■ May Cause Injury by Physical Action
■ Burns: Flammables, Combustibles
■ Pressure: Compressed Gasses
■ Explosions: Explosives, Reactives
Hazard
Classifications
Physical
Hazards
Hazard
Classifications
Physical
Hazards
EXAMPLES: PHYSICAL HAZARDS
■ Flammable
■ Explosive
■ Oxidizer
■ Pyrophoric
■ Unstable (Reactive)
■ Water Reactive
EXPLOSIVE
■ Sudden Release Of:
– Pressure
– Gas
– Heat
■ When Exposed To:
– Sudden Shock
– Pressure
– High Temperature
■ BLEVE: Boiling Liquid Expanding Vapor Explosion
OXIDIZER
■ Reacts With Organic Material
■ Releases Oxygen
■ Promotes Combustion
Sodium
Hypochlorite
Peracetic Acid
Oxygen
UNSTABLE (REACTIVE)
■ Unwanted Chemical Change During Normal
Handling
■ May Generate
– Heat
– Pressure
– Polymerization
■ Can Create
– Fires
– Explosions
WATER REACTIVE
■ Presence of Water
■ Forms a Gas That Is:
– Flammable or
– Toxic
Flammable Liquid Categories
Possibility for Confusion?
Flashpoint
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 110 120 130 140 150 160 170 180 190 200
NFPA / OSHA Flammable Combustible
NFPA 704 Diamond 4 3 2
EPA / DOT Flammable Combustible
GHS 1 or 2 3 4
Signal Word Danger Danger Warning
Hazard Statement
Extremely flammable liquid and
vapor
Highly flammable liquid and
vapor
Flammable liquid and vapor Combustible liquid
Pictogram Nothing
Possibility for Confusion?
NFPA Video - Confusion
Compressed Gasses
■ Injurious due to
pressure
Ethylene
Oxide
Oxygen
HEALTH HAZARDS
■ Acute
– Immediate Effects
■ Chronic
– Effects May Build Over Time
– May Be Latency Before Recognized Effects
■ Latency Period
– Period Between Exposure and Exposure Effects
OSHA Video - PELs
Hazard
Classifications
Health
Hazards
Hazard
Classifications
Health
Hazards
ACUTE EXPOSURE / EFFECTS
■ Example: Acids
■ Body Recognizes on Immediate Exposure
■ Can Get Prompt Medical Attention
CORROSIVE
■ A Hazardous Material That
Causes Visible
Destruction Of, or
Irreversible Alteration in
Living Tissue at the Site
of Contact
Sodium
Hypochlorite
Sodium
Hypochlorite
Peracetic AcidPeracetic Acid
Acutely Toxic – Low Hazard
■ Acutely
– Effects are “immediate”
■ Toxic
– Chemical that causes
harmful effects
– To target organ(s)
– Effects are different
depending on target
organ
■ May be Systemic
– Affects almost all target
organs
Acutely Toxic – Low Hazard
Isopropyl
alcohol
Isopropyl
alcohol
DacarbazineDacarbazine
GlutaraldehydeGlutaraldehyde
AcetoneAcetone
Acutely Toxic - Irritant
■ A Hazardous Material That Causes a Reversible
Inflammatory Effect on Living Tissue by Chemical
Action at the Site of Contact
Isopropyl alcohol
Acutely Toxic – Sensitizer
■ A Hazardous Material That Causes a Percentage of
the Exposed Group to Develop an Allergic
Reaction After Repeated Exposure
Methyl methacrylate
Acutely Toxic – High Hazard
■ Acutely
– Effects are “immediate”
■ Toxic
– Chemical that causes
harmful effects
– To target organ(s)
– Effects are different
depending on target
organ
■ High Hazards
– Effects are significant
– May be immediately life
threatening
Ammonia
Chronic Toxic Effects
■ Examples
– Carcinogens
– Teratogens
– Reproductive toxins
■ Health effects
– Vary with chemical
– Affect target organ
– May not show up for
years after
overexposure
Dacarbazine Glutaraldehyde
Label Elements
■ Sodium hypochlorite
Label
Elements
Label Elements
Safety Data Sheets
■ Prescriptive requirements
■ Sections must be consistent
■ Information dictated by GHS guidance
SDS Hazards
Description
SDS Sections
■ Section 1, Identification
■ Section 2, Hazard(s)
■ Section 3, Composition/information
■ Section 4, First-aid measures
■ Section 5, Fire-fighting measures
■ Section 6, Accidental release measures
■ Section 7, Handling and storage
■ Section 8, Exposure controls/personal protection
■ Section 9, Physical and chemical properties
■ Section 10, Stability and reactivity
■ Section 11, Toxicological information
■ Section 12, Ecological information
■ Section 13, Disposal considerations
■ Section 14, Transport information
■ Section 15, Regulatory information
■ Section 16, Other information, includes the date of preparation or last revision.
What hasn’t changed
■ Exclusions and exemptions
■ Elements of the HAZCOM program
■ Training requirements
■ Secondary container labeling
■ Temporary container exclusion
■ Special labeling systems
– NFPA 704
– HMIS
Effective Completion
Date Requirement(s) Who
December 1, 2013 Training
•New Label Elements
•Safety Data Sheets
Employers
June 1, 2015 Manufacturer full compliance
HAZCOM plans updated
Chemical Manufacturers
Employers
December 1, 2015 Distribution Prohibitions for non
GHS labels
Chemical Manufacturers,
Importers and
Distributors
June 1, 2016 Updates to program and training
based on new hazard
classifications
Employers
Conclusion
■ HAZCOM is adopting GHS
■ Broad applicability – everybody is “in”
■ Lots to do
– Training on GHS elements
– Plans and programs need to be revised
– SDS need to be developed
– New labels need to be designed and implemented
Safety Issues for Water Operators
■ Confined Space
– Monitoring
– Definition
– PRCS
– Procedures
■ Lockout/Tagout
– Energy Control procedures
– Locks & tags
– Electrical exposure
■ Fire Safety/Extinguishers
– A-comb; B-electrical; C-chemical
– Safe storage of flammables
■ Safe Lifting
– Sizing up the lift
– Back braces
– Two person lifts
– Lifting aids (hoists)
■ Hazard Communication
– Hazard types: physical/health
– Health hazards: acute/chronic
– NFPA 704/HMIS
– MSDS
■ Chemical Safety Information
– Caustics: corrosivity
– Always add acid to water
– Good ventilation
Safety Issues for Water Operators
■ Machine Guarding
– Power transmission
– Guards & blocks
■ Walking/Working Surfaces
– Housekeeping
– Oils
– Caustics
– Ice
– Ladders
– Fall safety
■ Chemical Monitoring
– Instruments
– O2 deficiency
– Combustible gas indicator
– H2S
■ PPE
– Safety glasses: a must!
– Gloves: compatible material
– Respirators
– Hearing protection
– Eyewashes/Showers
Safety Issues for Water Operators
■ Emergency Preparedness
– Emergency action plan
– Take care of yourself first
– Call postings
– Evacuation procedures
– Buddy system
■ Accident Prevention
– Signs: caution, warning, danger
– Labeling containers & tanks
– Pipe colors
Storage Tank Update
West Virginia News
■ Tank Trouble
– Elk River, WV
» 400,000 w/o water
» January 10, 2014
– Laurens, SC
» Mystery oil spill
– Belgrade, Montana
» Tank fire
– Bryan, OH
» Massive bird kill
Storage Tank Update
Storage Tank Update
■ Typical Tank Uses
– Fleet fueling
– Facility heating
– Generator fueling
■ Underground Tanks
– USTs
– Fuel tanks need operators
■ Aboveground Tanks
– ASTs
– Receiving scrutiny
Remote Spill Box/Fill
Fuel Dispenser
Fuel Pump
Interstitial
Leak Detection
Spill Kit
Normal Vent
Labels
Dispenser Hose Bollards
Secondary Tank
Emergency Vent
Primary Tank
Emergency
Vent
Mechanical Gauge
Preventive Limiting Barrier
Concrete Pad
1.5-inches
Nut
Integral Containment
Rain Shield
Ideal Installation – Generator Tank
Questions
David P. Horowitz, P.E., CSP
Tighe & Bond
53 Southampton Rd.
Westfield, MA 01085
413.572.3211
dphorowitz@tighebond.com
Tighe & Bond
177 Corporate Drive
Portsmouth, NH 03801
603-433-8818
l
446 Main Street
Worcester, MA 01605
508-754-2201
l
4 Barlows Landing Road, Unit #18
Pocasset, MA 02559
508-564-7285
l
213 Court Street, Suite 900
Middletown, CT 06457
860-704-4760
l
1000 Bridgeport Avenue
Shelton, CT 06484
203-712-1100

Health & Safety For Water Treatment Plant Operators

  • 1.
    Health and Safetyat Water Treatment Facilities David P. Horowitz, P.E., CSP (@dphorowitz)
  • 3.
    ■ Health &Safety – OSHA Top 10 ■ Globally Harmonized System – Changes – Implementation Dates ■ General Water Treatment Plant Hazards ■ Safe Chemical Handling – Typical treatment plant chemistries – Initial response activities – Tanks
  • 4.
    Why do wecare?
  • 5.
    Why do wecare?
  • 6.
    Safety Takeaways ■ Watchfor common issues! ■ Watch your staff & contractors ■ Management of change – Safety Data Sheets
  • 7.
    ■ The mostfrequent injuries in water treatment facilities are: a. Cuts and bruises b. Explosive and toxic gases c. Slips and falls d. Strains and Sprains e. None of the above
  • 8.
    I’m from OSHA. I’mhere to help. I’m from OSHA. I’m here to help.
  • 10.
    #10 Electrical –Systems Design ■ Electrical design ■ Arc Flash (NFPA 70E) System specific evaluations ■ Proposed equipment ■ Existing equipment ■ PPE
  • 11.
    #9 Machine Guarding ■Engineered or structural fixes ■ Job Hazard Analysis (JHAs)
  • 12.
    #8 Electrical -Wiring ■ Permanent ■ Temporary
  • 13.
    #7 Ladders - CONSTRUCTION ■Design considerations ■ Milestone Observation
  • 14.
    OSHA Video -Ladders
  • 15.
    #6 Lockout / Tagout ■System specific evaluation ■ Comprehensive energy source understanding
  • 16.
    #5 Powered Industrial Trucks ■PIVs ■ Hoisting requirements
  • 17.
    #4 Respiratory Protection ■Engineer out, if possible ■ Written Plan ■ Baseline physical ■ Medical surveillance ■ Fit testing
  • 18.
    #3 Scaffolding - CONSTRUCTIO N ■ Designconsiderations ■ Milestone Observation
  • 19.
    #2 Hazard Communication ■ GloballyHarmonized System ■ Risk Management Planning – Chlorine Gas = >2,500 Lbs
  • 20.
    #1 Fall Protection- CONSTRUCTION ■ Design considerations ■ Milestone Observation
  • 22.
    ■ The mostfrequent safety hazard from the use of polymers is: A. Attack on many types of stainless steel B. Cause of severe burns and blindness C. Evolution of a toxic gas D. Extreme slipping hazard when spilled on surfaces E. The boss scrutinizing chemical costs
  • 23.
    Global Harmonized System MajorChanges ■ Training and implementation ■ Hazard classification ■ Labels and warnings ■ Standard Safety Data Sheets
  • 24.
  • 25.
  • 26.
  • 27.
    ■ The goalof GHS ■ Label elements and GHS pictograms ■ Labeling components ■ Possible sources of confusion
  • 28.
    What’s wrong with HAZCOM Toomany systems Too many systems Too confusingToo confusing Too time consuming Too time consuming Too nationally focused Too nationally focused
  • 29.
    What’s wrong withHAZCOM? Lots
  • 35.
  • 36.
    Sometimes They CanBe Subject to Interpretation
  • 37.
    Or need aninterpreter
  • 38.
  • 39.
  • 40.
  • 41.
    Major Changes The Basics ■Hazard classification ■ Labels and warnings ■ Standard Safety Data Sheets ■ Training and implementation
  • 42.
    Effective Completion Date Requirement(s)Who December 1, 2013 Training •New Label Elements •Safety Data Sheets Employers June 1, 2015 Manufacturer full compliance HAZCOM plans updated Chemical Manufacturers Employers December 1, 2015 Distribution Prohibitions for non GHS labels Chemical Manufacturers, Importers and Distributors June 1, 2016 Updates to program and training based on new hazard classifications Employers
  • 43.
  • 44.
    HAZARD TYPES ■ Physical –Unstable Chemicals (Water Reactive) – Flammables or Combustibles – Explosives – Stored at High Pressures – Thermal Effects ■ Health – Acute – Chronic – Latency Period
  • 45.
    PHYSICAL HAZARDS ■ MayCause Injury by Physical Action ■ Burns: Flammables, Combustibles ■ Pressure: Compressed Gasses ■ Explosions: Explosives, Reactives
  • 46.
  • 47.
  • 48.
    EXAMPLES: PHYSICAL HAZARDS ■Flammable ■ Explosive ■ Oxidizer ■ Pyrophoric ■ Unstable (Reactive) ■ Water Reactive
  • 49.
    EXPLOSIVE ■ Sudden ReleaseOf: – Pressure – Gas – Heat ■ When Exposed To: – Sudden Shock – Pressure – High Temperature ■ BLEVE: Boiling Liquid Expanding Vapor Explosion
  • 50.
    OXIDIZER ■ Reacts WithOrganic Material ■ Releases Oxygen ■ Promotes Combustion Sodium Hypochlorite Peracetic Acid Oxygen
  • 51.
    UNSTABLE (REACTIVE) ■ UnwantedChemical Change During Normal Handling ■ May Generate – Heat – Pressure – Polymerization ■ Can Create – Fires – Explosions
  • 52.
    WATER REACTIVE ■ Presenceof Water ■ Forms a Gas That Is: – Flammable or – Toxic
  • 53.
  • 54.
    Possibility for Confusion? Flashpoint 010 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 110 120 130 140 150 160 170 180 190 200 NFPA / OSHA Flammable Combustible NFPA 704 Diamond 4 3 2 EPA / DOT Flammable Combustible GHS 1 or 2 3 4 Signal Word Danger Danger Warning Hazard Statement Extremely flammable liquid and vapor Highly flammable liquid and vapor Flammable liquid and vapor Combustible liquid Pictogram Nothing
  • 55.
  • 56.
    Compressed Gasses ■ Injuriousdue to pressure Ethylene Oxide Oxygen
  • 57.
    HEALTH HAZARDS ■ Acute –Immediate Effects ■ Chronic – Effects May Build Over Time – May Be Latency Before Recognized Effects ■ Latency Period – Period Between Exposure and Exposure Effects
  • 58.
  • 59.
  • 60.
  • 61.
    ACUTE EXPOSURE /EFFECTS ■ Example: Acids ■ Body Recognizes on Immediate Exposure ■ Can Get Prompt Medical Attention
  • 62.
    CORROSIVE ■ A HazardousMaterial That Causes Visible Destruction Of, or Irreversible Alteration in Living Tissue at the Site of Contact Sodium Hypochlorite Sodium Hypochlorite Peracetic AcidPeracetic Acid
  • 63.
    Acutely Toxic –Low Hazard ■ Acutely – Effects are “immediate” ■ Toxic – Chemical that causes harmful effects – To target organ(s) – Effects are different depending on target organ ■ May be Systemic – Affects almost all target organs
  • 64.
    Acutely Toxic –Low Hazard Isopropyl alcohol Isopropyl alcohol DacarbazineDacarbazine GlutaraldehydeGlutaraldehyde AcetoneAcetone
  • 65.
    Acutely Toxic -Irritant ■ A Hazardous Material That Causes a Reversible Inflammatory Effect on Living Tissue by Chemical Action at the Site of Contact Isopropyl alcohol
  • 66.
    Acutely Toxic –Sensitizer ■ A Hazardous Material That Causes a Percentage of the Exposed Group to Develop an Allergic Reaction After Repeated Exposure Methyl methacrylate
  • 67.
    Acutely Toxic –High Hazard ■ Acutely – Effects are “immediate” ■ Toxic – Chemical that causes harmful effects – To target organ(s) – Effects are different depending on target organ ■ High Hazards – Effects are significant – May be immediately life threatening Ammonia
  • 68.
    Chronic Toxic Effects ■Examples – Carcinogens – Teratogens – Reproductive toxins ■ Health effects – Vary with chemical – Affect target organ – May not show up for years after overexposure Dacarbazine Glutaraldehyde
  • 70.
  • 71.
  • 72.
  • 74.
    Safety Data Sheets ■Prescriptive requirements ■ Sections must be consistent ■ Information dictated by GHS guidance
  • 75.
  • 76.
    SDS Sections ■ Section1, Identification ■ Section 2, Hazard(s) ■ Section 3, Composition/information ■ Section 4, First-aid measures ■ Section 5, Fire-fighting measures ■ Section 6, Accidental release measures ■ Section 7, Handling and storage ■ Section 8, Exposure controls/personal protection ■ Section 9, Physical and chemical properties ■ Section 10, Stability and reactivity ■ Section 11, Toxicological information ■ Section 12, Ecological information ■ Section 13, Disposal considerations ■ Section 14, Transport information ■ Section 15, Regulatory information ■ Section 16, Other information, includes the date of preparation or last revision.
  • 77.
    What hasn’t changed ■Exclusions and exemptions ■ Elements of the HAZCOM program ■ Training requirements ■ Secondary container labeling ■ Temporary container exclusion ■ Special labeling systems – NFPA 704 – HMIS
  • 78.
    Effective Completion Date Requirement(s)Who December 1, 2013 Training •New Label Elements •Safety Data Sheets Employers June 1, 2015 Manufacturer full compliance HAZCOM plans updated Chemical Manufacturers Employers December 1, 2015 Distribution Prohibitions for non GHS labels Chemical Manufacturers, Importers and Distributors June 1, 2016 Updates to program and training based on new hazard classifications Employers
  • 79.
    Conclusion ■ HAZCOM isadopting GHS ■ Broad applicability – everybody is “in” ■ Lots to do – Training on GHS elements – Plans and programs need to be revised – SDS need to be developed – New labels need to be designed and implemented
  • 80.
    Safety Issues forWater Operators ■ Confined Space – Monitoring – Definition – PRCS – Procedures ■ Lockout/Tagout – Energy Control procedures – Locks & tags – Electrical exposure ■ Fire Safety/Extinguishers – A-comb; B-electrical; C-chemical – Safe storage of flammables ■ Safe Lifting – Sizing up the lift – Back braces – Two person lifts – Lifting aids (hoists) ■ Hazard Communication – Hazard types: physical/health – Health hazards: acute/chronic – NFPA 704/HMIS – MSDS ■ Chemical Safety Information – Caustics: corrosivity – Always add acid to water – Good ventilation
  • 81.
    Safety Issues forWater Operators ■ Machine Guarding – Power transmission – Guards & blocks ■ Walking/Working Surfaces – Housekeeping – Oils – Caustics – Ice – Ladders – Fall safety ■ Chemical Monitoring – Instruments – O2 deficiency – Combustible gas indicator – H2S ■ PPE – Safety glasses: a must! – Gloves: compatible material – Respirators – Hearing protection – Eyewashes/Showers
  • 82.
    Safety Issues forWater Operators ■ Emergency Preparedness – Emergency action plan – Take care of yourself first – Call postings – Evacuation procedures – Buddy system ■ Accident Prevention – Signs: caution, warning, danger – Labeling containers & tanks – Pipe colors
  • 83.
  • 84.
  • 85.
    ■ Tank Trouble –Elk River, WV » 400,000 w/o water » January 10, 2014 – Laurens, SC » Mystery oil spill – Belgrade, Montana » Tank fire – Bryan, OH » Massive bird kill Storage Tank Update
  • 86.
    Storage Tank Update ■Typical Tank Uses – Fleet fueling – Facility heating – Generator fueling ■ Underground Tanks – USTs – Fuel tanks need operators ■ Aboveground Tanks – ASTs – Receiving scrutiny
  • 87.
    Remote Spill Box/Fill FuelDispenser Fuel Pump Interstitial Leak Detection Spill Kit Normal Vent Labels
  • 88.
    Dispenser Hose Bollards SecondaryTank Emergency Vent Primary Tank Emergency Vent Mechanical Gauge Preventive Limiting Barrier Concrete Pad 1.5-inches Nut
  • 89.
  • 90.
    Ideal Installation –Generator Tank
  • 91.
    Questions David P. Horowitz,P.E., CSP Tighe & Bond 53 Southampton Rd. Westfield, MA 01085 413.572.3211 dphorowitz@tighebond.com Tighe & Bond 177 Corporate Drive Portsmouth, NH 03801 603-433-8818 l 446 Main Street Worcester, MA 01605 508-754-2201 l 4 Barlows Landing Road, Unit #18 Pocasset, MA 02559 508-564-7285 l 213 Court Street, Suite 900 Middletown, CT 06457 860-704-4760 l 1000 Bridgeport Avenue Shelton, CT 06484 203-712-1100

Editor's Notes

  • #54 Example for physical Hazard Classification scheme
  • #84 Different than the Kyoto protocol in that the allowances aren’t free. Approximately generators 230 in 10-state region; 30 in MA, 15 in CT RGGI is started in the absence of an acceptable national climate policy
  • #85 Different than the Kyoto protocol in that the allowances aren’t free. Approximately generators 230 in 10-state region; 30 in MA, 15 in CT RGGI is started in the absence of an acceptable national climate policy
  • #86 Different than the Kyoto protocol in that the allowances aren’t free. Approximately generators 230 in 10-state region; 30 in MA, 15 in CT RGGI is started in the absence of an acceptable national climate policy
  • #87 Different than the Kyoto protocol in that the allowances aren’t free. Approximately generators 230 in 10-state region; 30 in MA, 15 in CT RGGI is started in the absence of an acceptable national climate policy