Good practices of SAIs to control and audit fraud, Kjell Larsson, Algiers 8-9 April 2015
•
1 like•394 views
Presentation by Kjell Larsson from Sweden during the workshop on The role of the Court of Accounts in preventing and fighting fraud and corruption. This workshop was jointly organised by SIGMA and the Algerian Court of Accounts in Algiers 8-9 April 2015. Further information, please contact bianca.breteche@oecd.org.
More Related Content
Viewers also liked
Viewers also liked (15)
Similar to Good practices of SAIs to control and audit fraud, Kjell Larsson, Algiers 8-9 April 2015
Similar to Good practices of SAIs to control and audit fraud, Kjell Larsson, Algiers 8-9 April 2015 (20)
More from Support for Improvement in Governance and Management SIGMA
More from Support for Improvement in Governance and Management SIGMA (20)
Recently uploaded
Recently uploaded (20)
Good practices of SAIs to control and audit fraud, Kjell Larsson, Algiers 8-9 April 2015
- 1. © OECD AjointinitiativeoftheOECDandtheEuropeanUnion, principallyfinancedbytheEU The role of the Court of Accounts in preventing and fighting fraud and corruption Good practices of SAIs to control and audit fraud Kjell Larsson, Sweden Algiers, 8-9 April 2015
- 2. AjointinitiativeoftheOECDandtheEuropeanUnion, principallyfinancedbytheEU Why didn’t we notice? A failure of auditors that become a turning point (INTOSAI Journal July 2010) • The case ≥5000 research projects and ≥1billion € / year Thousands of audits, hundreds of auditors (Internal auditors, external SAI auditors, private and public) Auditors “EVERYTHING OK” every year Then OLAF, the Anti Fraud Office, got information from a whistle-blower. A check raised many ??? Auditors and OLAF realised. We have to work close together! 1
- 3. AjointinitiativeoftheOECDandtheEuropeanUnion, principallyfinancedbytheEU Why didn’t we notice? Work together! • Work together? How? Synergies! Every day co-operation! New rules and practices Auditors to fully meet ISA 240 /ISSAI 1240, tailored to the situation Amount of data (terabytes) data mining tools Auditors and OLAF, can use each other’s strengths! After some months: Several major scams for years. 5 million € lost in a few years. 2
- 4. AjointinitiativeoftheOECDandtheEuropeanUnion, principallyfinancedbytheEU Why didn’t we notice? Conclusions • Auditors had for long audited a few trees. But they had never ever tried to see the forest! • The new audit standards must be used fully • Close cooperation auditors – fraud investigators a must. New cooperation mechanisms needed. Respecting our diverse roles and mandates • Audit tools and competence must be upgraded / renewed. 3
- 5. AjointinitiativeoftheOECDandtheEuropeanUnion, principallyfinancedbytheEU Why didn´t we notice? Modus operandi • Fake documents identical to correct ones • Shell companies in remote places. Fake annual reports, full history and not only positive news, audit opinions, professional websites etc. • Fictitious staff with fabricated CVs. Elaborated exchanges of emails between “staff” including private stories about children and illnesses. • Names of real companies and real people used • Contracts, invoices, accounting transactions (including corrections) massively falsified • Cross payments and back-payments to circumvent control ISN’T ALL THIS EASY TO DETECT WHEN AUDITING? 4
- 6. AjointinitiativeoftheOECDandtheEuropeanUnion, principallyfinancedbytheEU Interesting SAI practices. 1. Where to start? • Important points that often come up A “strategy” before? Or, learning by doing? Why and how, how ambitious ? • Covering prevention, detection, sanctions? Culture? • SAI to do the work? • Or getting others to do their part? Cooperation with others? No! Yes! Public support? Whistle-blower systems? Perhaps a risk map of the SAI? Is the SAI managing the risks of “not being relevant” ? 5
- 7. Interesting SAI practices - 2. Cleaning our own house first Impact Probability Grade Design Implemen- tation Timeline Operational: 1 Performingpoor qualityaudits ( financial&VFM audits) Developandkeep corporateandaudit quality -Performing qualitativeauditsand deliveringqualitative auditreports Incorrectopinionfor RegularityAuditand conclusionnotevidenced forPerformanceaudits FailuretoapplyOAG methodology PoorQuality ManagementReview PoorSkill Mix ReputationalRisk-reduced ImpactofSAIactivity- ObjectivesnotMet Major Moderate Extreme Manualsand Guidelines,inbuilt controlinthe processes,QMF,Peer Reviews Yes-partial Improvedmanagementprocesses Robustarrangementsforupdating manualsandguidelinesasworking practicechange.Strongerquality controlwithinprocess.Develop relationshipswithSAIcommunity. Developskillsforauditof computerizedsystems tobedecided tbd tbd 2 InadequateQualityof auditreports Developandkeep corporateandaudit quality-Performing qualitativeauditsand deliveringqualitative auditreports Auditreportsarenotclear, relevant and understandablefor stakeholdersanddonot haverequiredfocusin promotingchangeor offering constructive recommendationsto achievethis PoorReportWritingSkills Poor SkillMixPoorQuality ManagementReviewFailureto fullyunderstandclientand maintainongoingcontacts throughouttheyear ReputationalRisk-reduced ImpactofSAIactivity objectivesnotmet. Negativemediaregrading SAI.LackoftrustinSAI asa reliablesourceof information Major Moderate Extreme Template(s)and Guidelines,inbuilt controlinthe processes,QMF,Peer Reviews.Expert Group,Widerliaision withexternal stakeholders Yespartial - EffectiveexpertgroupsAdditional trainingsonreportwriting/using template.Gettingfeedbackfrom auditeesandstakeholdersmaybe usedasaninputforimprovingquality ofauditreportsandfortraining topics. tobedecided 3 Timelinessofaudit reports Developandkeep corporateandaudit quality Internaldeadlinesnot achievedtoallowsufficient qualityreviewof reports. Notreportingontimeas specifiedInlegal frameworkforspecific reports. WeakProjectManagementand staffutilisationOutsourced companiesmaynotcomplywith contract deadlines ReputationalRisk-reduced impactofSAIactivity.Not beingabletomeetthe deadlinesforlegalreporting mayimpactthereputation. Budgetalllocationprocess maybeimpactedifreports arelate. Mod-major Rare(unlikely?) Medium Auditplanning, time recordingsoftware Yes-partial Functionalisetheuseoftime recordingsystemforbetter audit/resource planningandtracking ofauditwork tobedecided 4 Bilateralagreements notmet Developandkeep corporateandaudit quality Benefitsofbi-lateral projectsandarrangements lost-sustainabilitynot achieved Ineffectivemechanismsfor sharingoutputsofproject initiativesacrossthe organisation.Redundancyof recommendationstracker. Inabilitytointernallydevelop auditfocus-eggood governance. Effectiveauditand corporate practicesnot applied.Quality managementprocesswill highlightincreasednon applicationofaudit methodology.Reporting qualitywillreduce Moderate- Major Rare(unlikely?) Medium Effective managementof recommendations tracker.Implement mechanismsto ensurelessons learnedfromexternal inputsareeffectively shared.More effectivestrategic plans Yes-partial Clearaccountabilityrramgementsto beimplementedacrossorganisation TypeofriskNo ResponsibilityObjective Riskdescription PossibleCauses Desciptionoflikelyimpact RiskAssessment Controlsrequired Controlsinplace Additionalcontrolneeds
- 8. 5 Externalexpectations ofSAInotmet Developandkeep corporateandaudit quality ExpectationsofParliamemt notclearandconsequently notaddressed.Poor relationshipwith stakeholders. LackofskillsinSAImiddle mangerstofacilitatepositive relationshipswhichclearlyset outexpectationsand responsibilitiesonbothsides. Poorcommunicationwithnew membersofParliament IneffectivereviewofSAI outputs.Lackofchange resultingfromSAIwork Moderate- Major Rare(unlikely?) Medium Trainingwith membersof Parliamentand internally.Specific developmentof writtenbriefingsand pressreleases. Communication Strategy. Yes-partly Widerinvolvementofmiddle management 6 IneffectiveChange Management Developandkeep corporateandaudit quality Delaysinadoptionofnew law/appointmentofnew AGhaveanegativeimpact ofoperationsofSAI. Inabilitytorecruitandkeep specialiststaff. Inabilitytomakerequired operationalchangesto effectivelyaddressexpanding portfolio.Lackofstrategic directionduetocapacity shortfallsatseniormangement level. TheSAIstagnates.No effectivehandovertonew topmanagement.No opportunitytoincentivise staff Moderate- Major Rare(unlikely?) Medium workwithministries andgovernemnton thelaw.Develop inductionpackagefor newincoming managers.Restate accountabilitiesof seniormanagement team. Yes-partial Moreformalisedmanagement reportingprocesses 7 Weakcorporate serviceprograms Secureownership andinstitutional sustainability Noteffectivemangement ofcorporateoperations. Performancereviewsnot appliedconsistently. Essentaildatatosupport effectivemanagementis lacking. Lackofcapacitytoimplement effectivestrategicplansandrisk amangement.Lackofbudgetto implementcorporate developments. Onlybyimplementingnew auditapproachesand methodologiescantheSAI offerthequalityaudits expectedbyParliamentand INTOSAI Moderate- Major Rare(unlikely?) Medium FinalisationofCDS andassoci-ated businessplansfor Divisions.Replanning offinancialplans relatedtorequired developmentseg auditpackage Yes-partial 8 IneffectiveHR support Secureownership andinstitutional sustainability Poorstaffdevelopment relatedtoorganisational needsparticularly leadershipskills. InefficientHRsystems. HRcapacityshortfalls.Training requirementsnotcaptured adequatelyduetoineffective appraisalprocess SkillsmixofSAIdoesnot developatrequiredpace. HRteamfocusedon operationalnotstrategic issues Moderate- Major Rare(unlikely?) Medium HRstrategyand operationalplan. Effectiveappraisal process. Partly
- 9. AjointinitiativeoftheOECDandtheEuropeanUnion, principallyfinancedbytheEU Interesting SAI practices. 2. cleaning our own house first. Continued • Training auditors to know what to look for. And how to find answers. • Building up specialist teams. • Create data mining capacities (and access to data) • Result? 8
- 10. AjointinitiativeoftheOECDandtheEuropeanUnion, principallyfinancedbytheEU Interesting SAI practices. 3. Do it differently! Procurement. • Instead of auditing some procurement projects in one / a few entities every year The SAI will now • audit big (similar) procurement projects in several entities covering 5-6 years. Follow up on indications of prize-fixing, use of identical /fake sub- contractors, ownership relations, fake persons, “payment carousels”, eventual corruption. SAI use external experts + new technologies to control quality and delivered amounts of procured materials. Result? 9
- 11. AjointinitiativeoftheOECDandtheEuropeanUnion, principallyfinancedbytheEU Interesting SAI practices. 3. Do it differently! . Use Representation Letters SAI changed from • Rarely / never using Representation Letter (RL) • To always using RL Result? As RL “make top management take fraud and corruption much more seriously and now facilitate every aspect of audit work”. 10
- 12. AjointinitiativeoftheOECDandtheEuropeanUnion, principallyfinancedbytheEU Interesting SAI practices. 3. Do it differently! SAI fieldwork • Preparation More accurate risk assessment. Including overall financial situation and “market” situation Limit the likelihood audit evidence is altered • During Get access to essential information Drill deeper / re-check important evidence • After Triple check if complete picture Document and have other auditors to re-check Result? 11
- 13. AjointinitiativeoftheOECDandtheEuropeanUnion, principallyfinancedbytheEU Interesting SAI practices. 3. Do it differently! SAI and good practices • SAI has a unique overview • Decided to sum up and disseminate national good practices found in audits on fraud prevention, detection and sanctions • Stimulated (and assisted) entities to spread the practices internally • Results? 12
- 14. AjointinitiativeoftheOECDandtheEuropeanUnion, principallyfinancedbytheEU Concluding remarks • No one “right solution” for all SAIs (or other public entities!) exists. • However, the stakes and risks for society are high Money / resources Confidence SAIs well placed and must contribute! 13