ERO Technology Group
                                   Presented by


Ethics of AI
                                   Andreas Heil

                                   Date
                                   11. December 2006
About Potential, Limitations and
Concerns in Robotics
Intelligent Robotics
There are many misconceptions in the public mind about the
capabilities of artificial intelligence in general and intelligent
robots in particular. As intelligent behaviours become
embedded in everyday equipment, there is an increasing need
to understand the huge potential of these new technologies,
as well as their limitations. This workshop will review not only
the latest developments in intelligent robotics and promote
discussion of the challenges they present, but also question
the desirability of research into different application areas and
review public concerns regarding the quest to create
'conscious' robots.
Definition: Robot
 A robot is an electro-mechanical device that can perform autonomous or pre-
 programmed tasks. A robot may act under the direct control of a human (e.g. the
 Canadarm on the space shuttle) or autonomously under the control of a
 programmed computer.
                                                                             Wikipedia
     1. Mechanical device programmed to perform tasks
          Any machine that can be programmed to carry out instructions and
          perform particular duties, especially one that can take over tasks
          normally done by people
     2. Imaginary machine like human
          A machine that resembles a human in appearance and can function like
          a human, especially in science fiction
     3. Person like a machine
          Somebody who works or behaves mechanically, showing little or no
          emotion and often responding to orders without question
     4. Traffic light
          South Africa - a set of automatic traffic lights
                                                                   Encarta Dictionary
Definition: Robot

               A robot is a device, hard- or
               software with the capability
               of sensing and (re)acting.
Robotics Market Potential

Service and consumer markets just emerging
•   Remote assistance/presence
•   Assistive
•   Facilities maintenance
•   Security
•   Education
•   Entertainment

Why Robotics Research at All?
•High market expectation
•Demographic push in health & elderly care
•Longer working times – people spend less
time at home
•Service in the public
Military
•300 units x 800k                            * Source Japan Robotics Association
3
                                              2
                                                                              1
                                                                                                     20
                                                                                                     05
                                                                                                          Real vacuum cleaner




      Filtering unnecessary Information
      Household devices (Microwave, Fridge)
                                                                                                     20
                                                                                                           Robot with integrated communication capabilities1




                                                                                                     07
                                                                                                           Robot loading dishwasher2




                                                                                                     20
                                                                                                     10
                                                                                                           Tourguide3
                                                                                                                                                                                                Development Trend




                                                                                                           Robot adapting to individual needs




                                                                                                           Gaming robot




      Learning about new environments by taking a tour of it, after that it can re-give that tour.
                                                                                                     20
                                                                                                           Robot helping handicapped people

                                                                                                     15
                                                                                                                                                               Increasing Software Challenges




                                                                                                          Ironing robot
                                                                                                           Proactive robot
                                                                                                           Robot understanding human activities
                                                                                                     20
                                                                                                     20




                                                                                                          24h assistant
                                                                                                           Companion for elderly people
* Source EURON Workshop 2005
Microsoft & Robotics

        Experience                               Groups
  Systems                             Microsoft Research
  • PC Ecosystem (desktop, web,       •   Enabling Technologies
    mobile, home)                     •   Human Robot Interaction
  • XP, XP Embedded, CE (real-time)   •   Personal Robotics
                                      •   Educational Robotics
  Development Environment and Tools   •   Programming Environments
  • Programming IDE                   Microsoft Robotics Groups
  • Debugging and Optimization
                                      • Microsoft Robotics Group
  Existing Applicable Technologies      Redmond
                                      • Center for Innovative Robotics
  • Speech                              Carnegie Mellon University
  • Real-time Communications          • External Research Office
  • Infrastructure                      Cambridge
New Requirements
New Requirements

•   Ultra Heterogeneity
•   Distributed Environments
•   Dynamic Configuration
•   Context-Awareness
•   Personalization
•   Extensibility
•   Reliability
•   Security
•   Privacy Protection
•   Usability
•   Autonomy
•   …

Ubiquitous computing environments should be deployed incrementally

• Living space is not a demonstration room
• We like to replace existing objects

How can software infrastructures help to decrease the complexities?
Challenges to Address
Future Applications
• Support & care, education, entertainment
• Timesaving, repetitive work
• Have a servant, companion

Personal Robotics
• Human-robotics Interaction
• Mediator between Digital/Real world            From nature to
• Natural and Affective Interaction (speech,     software models

  gestures, emotions)
• Adaptive to individual needs

What is needed so that robots could be
 successfully integrated in our everyday life?
 What are the key technical issues?
Come more Challenges
•    Costs
     When a human is in danger, robots can do this work on behalf, then
     maybe, the costs are a minor issue

• Robot’s image is cultural depended
    > We will never accept a Japanese robot because of its cultural differences
    > Its important to build a robot corresponding to your culture


• Japan vs. Hollywood
    > Japan, friendly TV-series
    > Hollywood, dangerous, instable
                                                        Bring me a cup of tea…
• Acceptance
    > Emotional component
    > Robot as a luxury

• Learning vs. Imitation
    > “Do I really want it to play as bad chess as I do?”
VRDK – A Research Prototype
• Building a compelling & engaging
  Programmable Environment
• Innovative, very easy, flexible
  Programming Environment for Robot
  control applications
• Accessible to non technical audiences
  (children, nurses, elderly, machine
  operators)
• Enables a ‘Path’ from very simple
  (beginner, child) to professional (using
 Visual Studio)

                   Abstracting complexity on different levels

                  Source Code                         Visual
Domain Specific Language

    Visual N#
                                      Users can switch between
• Domain-specific                     both notations
  graphical language
• Extension of VRDK
• Easy to design
                                                            Code Translator
                                 N#
                       • Domain-specific
                         textual language
                       • Easy to read and write
                                                      C# / VB.NET

                                                   • General purpose
                                                     programming language
                                                   • Don’t write code
                                                     anymore
N# - A Textual Notation for Visual N#

ambient MyAmbient @ Person
       where filter ($1.Company == „Microsoft Research“),
             filter($1.Location == „Cambridge"),
             filter($1.SecurityLevel > 2) {
       discover Lights @ Light
                  where distance(a),
                        filter($1.Color == „green");
       process OnLampAdd @ l = Lights.Added {
              l.On();
       }
       process OnLampRemove @ l = Lights.Removed {
              l.Off();
       }
       a = 100;
}
AI
• A lot of the AI will stay in its virtual world

• Only limited connections to the real world

• Responsibility
The Microsoft Robotics Studio – Tools No Rules*

A lightweight concurrency and services oriented runtime
• Handling of sensory input and controlling actuators
• Based on synchronous message passing
• Decentralised System Services (DSS) facilitating tasks and
  basic services such as debugging, logging, monitoring,
  security, discovery and data persistence

Authoring/development tools
• Visual programming editor
• Simulation
• Message debugging

Technology libraries and basic algorithms
• Code samples and documentation




                                                               * AI2005
Runtime Environment
An application is a composition of loosely-coupled services concurrently executing across
scopes

• Interactions described using service contacts
• Components are networked
• Provides isolation between components
   > Reliability – ability to restart independently, replaceable/updatable
   > Parallelism
                                                                                            y
                                                                                        dar
                                                                                     oun
   UI

                                                                                    B
                                                                                ion
                               Main Port

                                                                        ic    at
                                                                   A ppl                                       Main Port

                                Service
                                                                                                Private Port
                                Code
                                State      Main Port                                                             Service
                                                                                         Main Port
                                                                                                                  Code
                   Main Port
Private Port                                                                                                      State
                                                                       Private Port
                                             Service
               Service                        Code                                    Service
               Code                           State                                   Code
               State                                                                  State


                                                                                                      H/W                  H/W
* Example: Model car + sensors
Simulation Capabilities
Supported KUKA robot
Community: Robot Swarm Heading Target Area




                       * R.D. Rango, http://channel9.msdn.com/ShowPost.aspx?PostID=244706
Community: Robot Swarm Simulation




                       * R.D. Rango, http://channel9.msdn.com/ShowPost.aspx?PostID=244706
Community: Maze Simulator




* B. Axelrod, T. Taylor, http://channel9.msdn.com/ShowPost.aspx?PostID=226071
Outlook
• VRDK
 > Research Prototype
 > Proof of Concept

• Microsoft Robotics Studio
 >   Available as CTP (November CTP)
 >   Improved Visualization
 >   Package based Deployment
 >   Wrap up for final version end of Dec 2006
 >   CCR / DSS maybe available as separate DL
 >   http://msdn.microsoft.com/robotics/

• N#
 >   Ongoing research
 >   Publications etc.
 >   Visual Studio integration
 >   http://research.microsoft.com/ero/
Thank you or your attention.

Ethics of AI

  • 1.
    ERO Technology Group Presented by Ethics of AI Andreas Heil Date 11. December 2006 About Potential, Limitations and Concerns in Robotics
  • 3.
    Intelligent Robotics There aremany misconceptions in the public mind about the capabilities of artificial intelligence in general and intelligent robots in particular. As intelligent behaviours become embedded in everyday equipment, there is an increasing need to understand the huge potential of these new technologies, as well as their limitations. This workshop will review not only the latest developments in intelligent robotics and promote discussion of the challenges they present, but also question the desirability of research into different application areas and review public concerns regarding the quest to create 'conscious' robots.
  • 4.
    Definition: Robot Arobot is an electro-mechanical device that can perform autonomous or pre- programmed tasks. A robot may act under the direct control of a human (e.g. the Canadarm on the space shuttle) or autonomously under the control of a programmed computer. Wikipedia 1. Mechanical device programmed to perform tasks Any machine that can be programmed to carry out instructions and perform particular duties, especially one that can take over tasks normally done by people 2. Imaginary machine like human A machine that resembles a human in appearance and can function like a human, especially in science fiction 3. Person like a machine Somebody who works or behaves mechanically, showing little or no emotion and often responding to orders without question 4. Traffic light South Africa - a set of automatic traffic lights Encarta Dictionary
  • 5.
    Definition: Robot A robot is a device, hard- or software with the capability of sensing and (re)acting.
  • 6.
    Robotics Market Potential Serviceand consumer markets just emerging • Remote assistance/presence • Assistive • Facilities maintenance • Security • Education • Entertainment Why Robotics Research at All? •High market expectation •Demographic push in health & elderly care •Longer working times – people spend less time at home •Service in the public Military •300 units x 800k * Source Japan Robotics Association
  • 7.
    3 2 1 20 05 Real vacuum cleaner Filtering unnecessary Information Household devices (Microwave, Fridge) 20 Robot with integrated communication capabilities1 07 Robot loading dishwasher2 20 10 Tourguide3 Development Trend Robot adapting to individual needs Gaming robot Learning about new environments by taking a tour of it, after that it can re-give that tour. 20 Robot helping handicapped people 15 Increasing Software Challenges Ironing robot Proactive robot Robot understanding human activities 20 20 24h assistant Companion for elderly people * Source EURON Workshop 2005
  • 8.
    Microsoft & Robotics Experience Groups Systems Microsoft Research • PC Ecosystem (desktop, web, • Enabling Technologies mobile, home) • Human Robot Interaction • XP, XP Embedded, CE (real-time) • Personal Robotics • Educational Robotics Development Environment and Tools • Programming Environments • Programming IDE Microsoft Robotics Groups • Debugging and Optimization • Microsoft Robotics Group Existing Applicable Technologies Redmond • Center for Innovative Robotics • Speech Carnegie Mellon University • Real-time Communications • External Research Office • Infrastructure Cambridge
  • 9.
    New Requirements New Requirements • Ultra Heterogeneity • Distributed Environments • Dynamic Configuration • Context-Awareness • Personalization • Extensibility • Reliability • Security • Privacy Protection • Usability • Autonomy • … Ubiquitous computing environments should be deployed incrementally • Living space is not a demonstration room • We like to replace existing objects How can software infrastructures help to decrease the complexities?
  • 10.
    Challenges to Address FutureApplications • Support & care, education, entertainment • Timesaving, repetitive work • Have a servant, companion Personal Robotics • Human-robotics Interaction • Mediator between Digital/Real world From nature to • Natural and Affective Interaction (speech, software models gestures, emotions) • Adaptive to individual needs What is needed so that robots could be successfully integrated in our everyday life? What are the key technical issues?
  • 11.
    Come more Challenges • Costs When a human is in danger, robots can do this work on behalf, then maybe, the costs are a minor issue • Robot’s image is cultural depended > We will never accept a Japanese robot because of its cultural differences > Its important to build a robot corresponding to your culture • Japan vs. Hollywood > Japan, friendly TV-series > Hollywood, dangerous, instable Bring me a cup of tea… • Acceptance > Emotional component > Robot as a luxury • Learning vs. Imitation > “Do I really want it to play as bad chess as I do?”
  • 12.
    VRDK – AResearch Prototype • Building a compelling & engaging Programmable Environment • Innovative, very easy, flexible Programming Environment for Robot control applications • Accessible to non technical audiences (children, nurses, elderly, machine operators) • Enables a ‘Path’ from very simple (beginner, child) to professional (using Visual Studio) Abstracting complexity on different levels Source Code Visual
  • 13.
    Domain Specific Language Visual N# Users can switch between • Domain-specific both notations graphical language • Extension of VRDK • Easy to design Code Translator N# • Domain-specific textual language • Easy to read and write C# / VB.NET • General purpose programming language • Don’t write code anymore
  • 14.
    N# - ATextual Notation for Visual N# ambient MyAmbient @ Person where filter ($1.Company == „Microsoft Research“), filter($1.Location == „Cambridge"), filter($1.SecurityLevel > 2) { discover Lights @ Light where distance(a), filter($1.Color == „green"); process OnLampAdd @ l = Lights.Added { l.On(); } process OnLampRemove @ l = Lights.Removed { l.Off(); } a = 100; }
  • 15.
    AI • A lotof the AI will stay in its virtual world • Only limited connections to the real world • Responsibility
  • 16.
    The Microsoft RoboticsStudio – Tools No Rules* A lightweight concurrency and services oriented runtime • Handling of sensory input and controlling actuators • Based on synchronous message passing • Decentralised System Services (DSS) facilitating tasks and basic services such as debugging, logging, monitoring, security, discovery and data persistence Authoring/development tools • Visual programming editor • Simulation • Message debugging Technology libraries and basic algorithms • Code samples and documentation * AI2005
  • 17.
    Runtime Environment An applicationis a composition of loosely-coupled services concurrently executing across scopes • Interactions described using service contacts • Components are networked • Provides isolation between components > Reliability – ability to restart independently, replaceable/updatable > Parallelism y dar oun UI B ion Main Port ic at A ppl Main Port Service Private Port Code State Main Port Service Main Port Code Main Port Private Port State Private Port Service Service Code Service Code State Code State State H/W H/W * Example: Model car + sensors
  • 18.
  • 19.
  • 20.
    Community: Robot SwarmHeading Target Area * R.D. Rango, http://channel9.msdn.com/ShowPost.aspx?PostID=244706
  • 21.
    Community: Robot SwarmSimulation * R.D. Rango, http://channel9.msdn.com/ShowPost.aspx?PostID=244706
  • 22.
    Community: Maze Simulator *B. Axelrod, T. Taylor, http://channel9.msdn.com/ShowPost.aspx?PostID=226071
  • 23.
    Outlook • VRDK >Research Prototype > Proof of Concept • Microsoft Robotics Studio > Available as CTP (November CTP) > Improved Visualization > Package based Deployment > Wrap up for final version end of Dec 2006 > CCR / DSS maybe available as separate DL > http://msdn.microsoft.com/robotics/ • N# > Ongoing research > Publications etc. > Visual Studio integration > http://research.microsoft.com/ero/
  • 24.
    Thank you oryour attention.

Editor's Notes

  • #3 Discuss: What do you see? My Answer: The opportunity for 50,000 robots within the next few years/decades Announcement of Korean Government -> at least on robot per home within the next years (maybe 10 years) Already test area with 10,000 households to be populated with robots -> Question: Is it already I,Robot like? Japanese/Asian are more willing to adapt
  • #4 Embedded in everyday equipment: PDA, Speech Recognition, addressed in research, see N# Potential: we will see “the” standard slide later on Limitations : I will talk about this later Latest development: Here we go – that’s the reason I am here Public concerns: somethin about MS Research and the ERO Mission
  • #5 Two definitions from Wikipedia and Encarta, I liked especially the one of the traffic light in south Africa However address they address the mechanical aspects Robot from the polish language, introduced in 1930s by Issac assimov in one of his early novels – and stands for workers – there is some responsibility
  • #6 Our one, clear definition. As you can see it is simple – but there is not a lot of intelligence. Actually also a piece of software can
  • #7 Less work at home – service in the public – sound to me like ROBOT by its origin definition - worker
  • #8 Increasing software challenges, but also increasing responsibilities, 24h assistant, companion, pro-active robots
  • #9 Where and why does Microsoft as a company fit in there?
  • #11 Yellow: re-invent the slavery
  • #13 The Visual Robotik Development Kit is a first approach in building an unique visual programming environment. By abstracting from underlying source code, the VRDK enables non technical audience or groups of persons nor familiar with this certain domain of technology to access and program its functionality. Thereby the VRDK allows abstracting on different levels. Abstract models can be used as well as a in-depth look into source code is provided corresponding to the audience, from beginners up to experts.
  • #14 TBD
  • #15 TBD
  • #16 TBD
  • #17 Tools – no rules This Microsoft thing is just sitting there, without the manufactuere doing anything, nothing happens --- Improved CCR and DSS Runtime We’ve made some significant improvements that has doubled message throughput within node (between services) and between nodes. XML footprint has been reduced by half. Peak message throughput on multiprocessor machines is now close to 90,000 SOAP messages per second, between services on the same node, and 2,500 messages between nodes (using TCP or HTTP, full serialization). A scalable, extensible runtime architecture that can span a wide variety of hardware and devices. The programming interface can be used to address robots using 8-bit or 16-bit processors as well as 32-bit systems with multi-core processors and devices from simple touch sensors to laser distance finding devices. A set of useful tools that make programming and debugging robot applications scenarios easier. These include a high quality visual simulation environment that uses for software physics supplied by the Ageia Technologies PhysX engine. A set of useful technology libraries services samples to help developers get started with writing robot applications.