e-Learning Alphabet
E-Learning Atheists




                                E-Learning Zealots
            My images: rights reserved
Barry Dahl dot com
A-Z                 A-Z




A-Z   N O P Q R S   A-Z
A-Z   Networked Learning   A-Z



                How many
               people are in
                this room?

A-Z   N O P Q R S          A-Z
Select each site where you
           have an account.
78%    1. Facebook
56%    2. Twitter
67%    3. Linked In
33%    4. Google Plus
50%    5. You Tube
11%    6. None of the above
A-Z                 A-Z




A-Z   N O P Q R S   A-Z
A-Z                 A-Z




      Open
A-Z   N O P Q R S   A-Z
A-Z                 A-Z




A-Z   N O P Q R S   A-Z
A-Z     Postman     A-Z



        Now
        this...

A-Z   N O P Q R S   A-Z
Neil Postman

• Public Discourse
  in the Age of
  Show Business
• Published 1985
Amusing Ourselves to Death
• Many of the
  remarks he made
  about television
  can be made
  today about
  computers and
  social networking
Which of these books have
             you read?

32%    1. 1984
11%    2. Brave New World
47%    3. Both of them
21%    4. Neither of them
Graphics by Stuart McMillen




Hey Barry! Read the beginning of the book!
Graphics by Stuart McMillen

• All words from “Amusing
  Ourselves to Death: Public
  Discourse in the Age of Show
  Business” by Neil Postman … a
  book about the possibility that
  Huxley, not Orwell, was right.
My Take on Postman

• Web 1.0 was just another one-way
  distraction device, very TV-like.
• However, Web 2.0 goes beyond
  amusement by bringing people
  together and encouraging creativity.
Related Questions
• How does the use of emerging
  technologies add value?

• If we aren’t adding value, are we
  simply trying to amuse ourselves?
A-Z                 A-Z




A-Z   N O P Q R S   A-Z
A-Z        Quality         A-Z

      E-Learning Quality
              =
       Quality Matters

           Right?
A-Z   N O P Q R S          A-Z
Quality Matters is Sufficient
                              Learning
• Um, no, it isn’t!!
• Quality Matters
  looks at the quality
  of course design.
                                Quality
• That’s good, but it’s        Concerns
  only one leg holding
  up the stool.         Teaching          Design
3 Major Components of e-Quality


               Learning Level
                  Is High
              Learning Assessment




     Teaching Level         Course Design
        Is High            Meets Standards
Is This a Problem?


          Learning Level
             Is High
         Learning Assessment




Teaching Level         Course Design
   Is High            Below Standard
Beautiful, Just Beautiful


          Learning Level
              Is Low
         Learning Assessment




Teaching Level         Course Design
    Is Low            Meets Standards
A-Z                 A-Z




A-Z   N O P Q R S   A-Z
A-Z                 A-Z




      Rubric
A-Z   N O P Q R S   A-Z
Table Exercise
• Revisit your list of factors
  affecting the amount of time
  flexibility in online courses.

• Construct a rubric that could be
  used to score the level of
  flexibility.
A-Z                 A-Z




A-Z   N O P Q R S   A-Z
A-Z       SMS       A-Z




A-Z   N O P Q R S   A-Z
McLuhanism
“We shape our
 tools and
 afterwards our
 tools shape us.”

                    CC-BY Photo of Marshall McLuhan
                    painting. Credit to Adobe of Chaos



                                                         41
McLuhanism
“We shape our       Mobile phones
 tools and
 afterwards our
 tools shape us.”


                      For Talking?
                    CC-BY Flickr Photo: snappybex
                                                    42
McLuhanism
“We shape our        Mobile phones
 tools and
 afterwards our
 tools shape us.”


                    No, for Texting!
                     CC-BY Flickr Photo: mattwi1s0n
                                                      43
Texting: most used data service in world



                4.2 Billion Texters
                   Worldwide




Source: http://www.mbaonline.com/planet-text/   44
Texting: 72% of cell phone users




                                                                 45
Source: http://cellphones.org/blog/facts-about-text-messaging/
Texting: higher minority use




                                                                 46
Source: http://cellphones.org/blog/facts-about-text-messaging/
Texting: 95% of 18-29 y-o




                                                                 47
Source: http://cellphones.org/blog/facts-about-text-messaging/
A-Z            SMS             A-Z


      Texting your Students?
41%    1. Good idea
59%
       2. Bad idea

A-Z      N O P Q R S           A-Z
Texting about what?
• Reminders
  about due
  dates
• Helpful hints
  about
  assignments

                            49
Texting about what?
• Breaking news
  relevant to class
• Links to useful
  information



                            50
Texting about what?
• Inspiration and
  encouragement
• Whenever you
  need their
  immediate
  attention


                             51
Hand Holding?
       • Overheard: “There’s a
         bit too much hand
         holding going on here.
         These students need to
         fend for themselves.”




             CC-BY Flickr Photo: mikebaird
                                             52
Lots of naysayers out there - 1
  • “Really? Should we stay up all night and
    ‘cram’ with them also? Come on, let the
    STUDENT be accountable, load the due
    dates in their own phones, etc.
    Good grief Higher Education is not
    Kindergarten.”

http://chronicle.com/blogs/wiredcampus/professor-textblaster/21451
                                                                     53
Lots of naysayers out there - 2
  • “Students can ignore this text like they
    do all other written communications,
    like the syllabus and class schedules.
    The good students get a break and the
    weaker students will still live in denial.”



http://chronicle.com/blogs/wiredcampus/professor-textblaster/21451
                                                                     54
Hand Holding?
       • Overheard: “There’s a
         bit too much hand
         holding going on here.
         These students need to
         fend for themselves.”

       • Also overheard: “We
         have huge retention
         issues. Going the extra
         mile can save a student
         from failing.”
             CC-BY Flickr Photo: mikebaird
                                             55
Group Messaging Options




                          56
A-Z                   A-Z




A-Z   T U V W X Y Z   A-Z
A-Z       Twitter     A-Z



       Speaking of
       Twitter …….

A-Z   T U V W X Y Z   A-Z
A-Z                          A-Z
      Twitter is Stupid!!!
31%   1. Twue
69%
      2. False


A-Z   T U V W X Y Z          A-Z
My Twitter Network
• Social Learning
• I learn more every
  day from my
  Twitter network
  than I ever did in
  school.            (Blasphemy, I know)
A-Z                   A-Z




A-Z   T U V W X Y Z   A-Z
A-Z        Un           A-Z

 Unfriend
      Unfollow
             Uncircle
A-Z   T U V W X Y Z     A-Z
Twitter makes me like people I’ve never met and Facebook
makes me hate people I know in real life. @shaylamaddox
A-Z                   A-Z




A-Z   T U V W X Y Z   A-Z
A-Z       VILOS       A-Z




A-Z   T U V W X Y Z   A-Z
A-Z                   A-Z




A-Z   T U V W X Y Z   A-Z
A-Z                Wi-Fi          A-Z

       Campus Wi-Fi is an Important
      Component to Student Success

88%     1. True
12%     2. False

A-Z      T U V W X Y Z            A-Z
Educause: ECAR Undergrads Study




   ECAR National Study of
   Undergraduate Students
 and Information Technology


Source: http://net.educause.edu/ir/library/pdf/ERS1103/ERS1103W.pdf
70-75% of students                 78% of students who
          Educause:
     say they use Wi-Fi   ECAR   Undergrads Studyit is
                                         use Wi-Fi say
    networks and want                 “extremely important”
    anytime, anywhere                   to their academic
           access.                           success.




                     79% say that college
                    “would be a lot harder”
                     without Wi-Fi access.



Source: http://net.educause.edu/ir/library/pdf/ERS1103/ERS1103W.pdf
Beer or Wi-Fi?
 • 48% would give up              • Before giving up Wi-Fi




Source: http://www.wi-fi.org --- short URL = http://goo.gl/Eg5kp
Better Wi-Fi = Better Grades?
 • 75% of students polled        • agree that Wi-Fi helps
                                   them get better grades.




Source: computerworld.com --- short URL = http://goo.gl/Fh2F2
Importance in College Choice?




Source: http://www.wi-fi.org --- short URL = http://goo.gl/Eg5kp
60% say they wouldn’t attend a college
      that doesn’t offer free Wi-Fi




Source: http://www.wi-fi.org --- short URL = http://goo.gl/Eg5kp
Choose each true statement
89%   1.   You are a texter
89%   2.   You have Wi-Fi in your house
53%   3.   You have 5+ cloud documents
42%   4.   You can define the term “Web 2.0”
5%    5.   None of the above are true
What is Web 2.0?
A-Z                   A-Z




A-Z   T U V W X Y Z   A-Z
A-Z         X         A-Z




A-Z   T U V W X Y Z   A-Z
A-Z   Xena, Warrior Princess   A-Z




A-Z    T U V W X Y Z           A-Z
A-Z                   A-Z




A-Z   T U V W X Y Z   A-Z
A-Z      You Tube     A-Z




A-Z   T U V W X Y Z   A-Z
The State of YouTube
A-Z                   A-Z




A-Z   T U V W X Y Z   A-Z
The e-Learning Battle
• The Zealots are those
  that tout the benefits
  of online learning
  without having any
  evidence to back it up.
• Zealots begin many of
  their sentences with
  “one time there was
  this one student …”
                            E-Learning Zealots
                                                 83
Sample Zealot Comment
• And here we are, in 2011, fer cryin‘aloud,
  with dodgy naysayers STILL kicking and
  screaming and throwing fits in regards (sic) to
  online teaching and learning. Get over it,
  already – the days of having students seated
  around your flowing toga in utter awe of your
  knowledge and acumen are LONG GONE.
  Welcome to the present.
  Source: http://chronicle.com/article/How-Big-Can-E-Learning-Get-At/128809/
                                                                               84
Last Words

  Wrap-up from
Postman and Godin
Quoting Postman
• “Our politics, religion, news, athletics,
  education and commerce have been
  transformed into congenial adjuncts of
  show business, largely without protest
  or even much popular notice.
• The result is that we are a people on the
  verge of amusing ourselves to death.”
                                  Pg. 3
Linchpins
Don’t Need
(no stinkin’)
 Résumés
What is a linchpin?
An artist

What is an artist?
Anyone who does
“emotional work”

Work that matters
Everyone’s an
  artist now
  It’s not
what you do
It’s how
  you do it

Make the leap
Be an artist

Do emotional work
It’s a choice

 Choose it

e-Learning A to Z - Part 2 (N-Z)

  • 1.
    e-Learning Alphabet E-Learning Atheists E-Learning Zealots My images: rights reserved
  • 2.
  • 3.
    A-Z A-Z A-Z N O P Q R S A-Z
  • 4.
    A-Z Networked Learning A-Z How many people are in this room? A-Z N O P Q R S A-Z
  • 5.
    Select each sitewhere you have an account. 78% 1. Facebook 56% 2. Twitter 67% 3. Linked In 33% 4. Google Plus 50% 5. You Tube 11% 6. None of the above
  • 7.
    A-Z A-Z A-Z N O P Q R S A-Z
  • 8.
    A-Z A-Z Open A-Z N O P Q R S A-Z
  • 9.
    A-Z A-Z A-Z N O P Q R S A-Z
  • 10.
    A-Z Postman A-Z Now this... A-Z N O P Q R S A-Z
  • 11.
    Neil Postman • PublicDiscourse in the Age of Show Business • Published 1985
  • 12.
    Amusing Ourselves toDeath • Many of the remarks he made about television can be made today about computers and social networking
  • 13.
    Which of thesebooks have you read? 32% 1. 1984 11% 2. Brave New World 47% 3. Both of them 21% 4. Neither of them
  • 14.
    Graphics by StuartMcMillen Hey Barry! Read the beginning of the book!
  • 27.
    Graphics by StuartMcMillen • All words from “Amusing Ourselves to Death: Public Discourse in the Age of Show Business” by Neil Postman … a book about the possibility that Huxley, not Orwell, was right.
  • 28.
    My Take onPostman • Web 1.0 was just another one-way distraction device, very TV-like. • However, Web 2.0 goes beyond amusement by bringing people together and encouraging creativity.
  • 29.
    Related Questions • Howdoes the use of emerging technologies add value? • If we aren’t adding value, are we simply trying to amuse ourselves?
  • 30.
    A-Z A-Z A-Z N O P Q R S A-Z
  • 31.
    A-Z Quality A-Z E-Learning Quality = Quality Matters Right? A-Z N O P Q R S A-Z
  • 32.
    Quality Matters isSufficient Learning • Um, no, it isn’t!! • Quality Matters looks at the quality of course design. Quality • That’s good, but it’s Concerns only one leg holding up the stool. Teaching Design
  • 33.
    3 Major Componentsof e-Quality Learning Level Is High Learning Assessment Teaching Level Course Design Is High Meets Standards
  • 34.
    Is This aProblem? Learning Level Is High Learning Assessment Teaching Level Course Design Is High Below Standard
  • 35.
    Beautiful, Just Beautiful Learning Level Is Low Learning Assessment Teaching Level Course Design Is Low Meets Standards
  • 36.
    A-Z A-Z A-Z N O P Q R S A-Z
  • 37.
    A-Z A-Z Rubric A-Z N O P Q R S A-Z
  • 38.
    Table Exercise • Revisityour list of factors affecting the amount of time flexibility in online courses. • Construct a rubric that could be used to score the level of flexibility.
  • 39.
    A-Z A-Z A-Z N O P Q R S A-Z
  • 40.
    A-Z SMS A-Z A-Z N O P Q R S A-Z
  • 41.
    McLuhanism “We shape our tools and afterwards our tools shape us.” CC-BY Photo of Marshall McLuhan painting. Credit to Adobe of Chaos 41
  • 42.
    McLuhanism “We shape our Mobile phones tools and afterwards our tools shape us.” For Talking? CC-BY Flickr Photo: snappybex 42
  • 43.
    McLuhanism “We shape our Mobile phones tools and afterwards our tools shape us.” No, for Texting! CC-BY Flickr Photo: mattwi1s0n 43
  • 44.
    Texting: most useddata service in world 4.2 Billion Texters Worldwide Source: http://www.mbaonline.com/planet-text/ 44
  • 45.
    Texting: 72% ofcell phone users 45 Source: http://cellphones.org/blog/facts-about-text-messaging/
  • 46.
    Texting: higher minorityuse 46 Source: http://cellphones.org/blog/facts-about-text-messaging/
  • 47.
    Texting: 95% of18-29 y-o 47 Source: http://cellphones.org/blog/facts-about-text-messaging/
  • 48.
    A-Z SMS A-Z Texting your Students? 41% 1. Good idea 59% 2. Bad idea A-Z N O P Q R S A-Z
  • 49.
    Texting about what? •Reminders about due dates • Helpful hints about assignments 49
  • 50.
    Texting about what? •Breaking news relevant to class • Links to useful information 50
  • 51.
    Texting about what? •Inspiration and encouragement • Whenever you need their immediate attention 51
  • 52.
    Hand Holding? • Overheard: “There’s a bit too much hand holding going on here. These students need to fend for themselves.” CC-BY Flickr Photo: mikebaird 52
  • 53.
    Lots of naysayersout there - 1 • “Really? Should we stay up all night and ‘cram’ with them also? Come on, let the STUDENT be accountable, load the due dates in their own phones, etc. Good grief Higher Education is not Kindergarten.” http://chronicle.com/blogs/wiredcampus/professor-textblaster/21451 53
  • 54.
    Lots of naysayersout there - 2 • “Students can ignore this text like they do all other written communications, like the syllabus and class schedules. The good students get a break and the weaker students will still live in denial.” http://chronicle.com/blogs/wiredcampus/professor-textblaster/21451 54
  • 55.
    Hand Holding? • Overheard: “There’s a bit too much hand holding going on here. These students need to fend for themselves.” • Also overheard: “We have huge retention issues. Going the extra mile can save a student from failing.” CC-BY Flickr Photo: mikebaird 55
  • 56.
  • 57.
    A-Z A-Z A-Z T U V W X Y Z A-Z
  • 58.
    A-Z Twitter A-Z Speaking of Twitter ……. A-Z T U V W X Y Z A-Z
  • 59.
    A-Z A-Z Twitter is Stupid!!! 31% 1. Twue 69% 2. False A-Z T U V W X Y Z A-Z
  • 60.
    My Twitter Network •Social Learning • I learn more every day from my Twitter network than I ever did in school. (Blasphemy, I know)
  • 61.
    A-Z A-Z A-Z T U V W X Y Z A-Z
  • 62.
    A-Z Un A-Z Unfriend Unfollow Uncircle A-Z T U V W X Y Z A-Z
  • 63.
    Twitter makes melike people I’ve never met and Facebook makes me hate people I know in real life. @shaylamaddox
  • 64.
    A-Z A-Z A-Z T U V W X Y Z A-Z
  • 65.
    A-Z VILOS A-Z A-Z T U V W X Y Z A-Z
  • 66.
    A-Z A-Z A-Z T U V W X Y Z A-Z
  • 67.
    A-Z Wi-Fi A-Z Campus Wi-Fi is an Important Component to Student Success 88% 1. True 12% 2. False A-Z T U V W X Y Z A-Z
  • 68.
    Educause: ECAR UndergradsStudy ECAR National Study of Undergraduate Students and Information Technology Source: http://net.educause.edu/ir/library/pdf/ERS1103/ERS1103W.pdf
  • 69.
    70-75% of students 78% of students who Educause: say they use Wi-Fi ECAR Undergrads Studyit is use Wi-Fi say networks and want “extremely important” anytime, anywhere to their academic access. success. 79% say that college “would be a lot harder” without Wi-Fi access. Source: http://net.educause.edu/ir/library/pdf/ERS1103/ERS1103W.pdf
  • 70.
    Beer or Wi-Fi? • 48% would give up • Before giving up Wi-Fi Source: http://www.wi-fi.org --- short URL = http://goo.gl/Eg5kp
  • 71.
    Better Wi-Fi =Better Grades? • 75% of students polled • agree that Wi-Fi helps them get better grades. Source: computerworld.com --- short URL = http://goo.gl/Fh2F2
  • 72.
    Importance in CollegeChoice? Source: http://www.wi-fi.org --- short URL = http://goo.gl/Eg5kp
  • 73.
    60% say theywouldn’t attend a college that doesn’t offer free Wi-Fi Source: http://www.wi-fi.org --- short URL = http://goo.gl/Eg5kp
  • 74.
    Choose each truestatement 89% 1. You are a texter 89% 2. You have Wi-Fi in your house 53% 3. You have 5+ cloud documents 42% 4. You can define the term “Web 2.0” 5% 5. None of the above are true
  • 75.
  • 76.
    A-Z A-Z A-Z T U V W X Y Z A-Z
  • 77.
    A-Z X A-Z A-Z T U V W X Y Z A-Z
  • 78.
    A-Z Xena, Warrior Princess A-Z A-Z T U V W X Y Z A-Z
  • 79.
    A-Z A-Z A-Z T U V W X Y Z A-Z
  • 80.
    A-Z You Tube A-Z A-Z T U V W X Y Z A-Z
  • 81.
    The State ofYouTube
  • 82.
    A-Z A-Z A-Z T U V W X Y Z A-Z
  • 83.
    The e-Learning Battle •The Zealots are those that tout the benefits of online learning without having any evidence to back it up. • Zealots begin many of their sentences with “one time there was this one student …” E-Learning Zealots 83
  • 84.
    Sample Zealot Comment •And here we are, in 2011, fer cryin‘aloud, with dodgy naysayers STILL kicking and screaming and throwing fits in regards (sic) to online teaching and learning. Get over it, already – the days of having students seated around your flowing toga in utter awe of your knowledge and acumen are LONG GONE. Welcome to the present. Source: http://chronicle.com/article/How-Big-Can-E-Learning-Get-At/128809/ 84
  • 85.
    Last Words Wrap-up from Postman and Godin
  • 86.
    Quoting Postman • “Ourpolitics, religion, news, athletics, education and commerce have been transformed into congenial adjuncts of show business, largely without protest or even much popular notice. • The result is that we are a people on the verge of amusing ourselves to death.” Pg. 3
  • 87.
  • 88.
    What is alinchpin?
  • 89.
  • 90.
    Anyone who does “emotionalwork” Work that matters
  • 91.
    Everyone’s an artist now It’s not what you do
  • 92.
    It’s how you do it Make the leap
  • 93.
    Be an artist Doemotional work
  • 94.

Editor's Notes

  • #17 [twitter]Orwell feared the book banners. Huxley feared that there would be no reason to ban books, no one would want to read them.[/twitter]
  • #19 [twitter]Orwell feared we would be deprived of information. Huxley feared we would have too much information, becoming passive & egoistic[/twitter]
  • #21 [twitter]Orwell feared the truth would be concealed from us. Huxley feared the truth would be drowned in a sea of irrelevance.[/twitter]
  • #23 [twitter]Orwell feared we would become a captive culture. Huxley feared we would become a trivial culture.[/twitter]
  • #24 [twitter]Huxley quote: Those opposed to tyranny “failed to take into account man’s almost infinite appetite for distractions.”[/twitter]
  • #27 [twitter]In short, Orwell feared that what we hate will ruin us. Huxley feared that what we love will ruin us.[/twitter]
  • #28 [twitter] Graphics by Stuart McMillen, with permission. http://bit.ly/cz8kFd[/twitter]
  • #29 [twitter] “Amusing Ourselves to Death” by Neil Postman … a book about the possibility that Huxley, not Orwell, was right.[/twitter]
  • #30 [twitter] “Amusing Ourselves to Death” highly recommended – here’s a link to purchase for under $10 http://amzn.to/9AzH1N [/twitter]
  • #61 [twitter]How many millions of people are in this room right now? How many people can we reach through our networks?[/twitter]
  • #93 [twitter]Work that you put your heart and soul into. Everybody’s an artist now (or could be). It’s not what you do, it’s how you do it.[/twitter]