APPLIED CRITICAL RACE THEORY




KEY TENETS TO                         RESEARCH                    APPLYING CRT IN
     CRT                               REVIEW                     THE CLASSROOM

                                  Primary Lenses:                Authentic Caring- Holding
Centrality of                                                    high expectations as well as
                                                                 providing a high level of
Whiteness White                   Teacher Bias Hidden            care, concern & support to
ideology, values, and             stereotypes compel             all students in need.
interests are at the center       adults to have different
of all aspects of                                                Reframing
                                  expectations and hold
                                                                 Responsibility- Relentless
dominant culture &                Black students to a            focus on adults not children
policy                            different standard.            as the target for change with
                                                                 the indicators in the student
The Challenge to                  Institutional Bias-            outcomes
dominant ideology                 Inequality is reproduced       Institutional Nurturing-
Countering the claims             regardless of individuals      Individuals caring is not
that the legal system of          in the institution or          enough. The institution
justice and all post-             assumed institutional          must function in a race
modern American                   intolerance of racism          responsive way toward
institutions, namely                                             equity.
public education is               Cultural Mismatch-             Culturally Responsive-
colorblind, race-neutral          Black students culture is      Adjusting teaching to
and provides equal                pathologized and viewed        responding to the cultural
opportunity (Brown v              as incompatible with the       needs & learning styles of
Board)                            educational setting Payne
                                   Copyright © May 2011 Macheo   each student.
                                         All Rights Reserved
APPLIED CRITICAL
                                              RACE THEORY




          KEY TENET OF CRT                                                                 KEY TENET OF CRT
Centrality of Whiteness Unconscious                                            The Challenge to dominant ideology
hegemonic ideology that places white                                           Countering claims that the legal system of
values and interests at the center of all                                      justice and public institutions, namely
aspects of dominant culture & policy,                                          public education is colorblind, race-
perpetuating white supremacy (Ladson-                                          neutral and provides equal opportunity
Billings, 1998; Picower, 2009).                                                (Solorzano, 1997; Yosso, 2005).




PRIMARY EXPLANATIONS IN THE                      PRIMARY EXPLANATIONS IN THE                             PRIMARY EXPLANATIONS IN THE
         RESEARCH                                         RESEARCH                                                RESEARCH
Cultural Mismatch- Black students’              Teacher Bias- Hidden stereotypes lead                    Institutional Bias- Inequality is
culture is pathologized and viewed as           teachers to view Black students negatively
                                                holding them to a different set of standards,            reproduced through racially biased
incompatible with the educational               overusing disruption, defiance and disrespect as         policies such as zero tolerance
setting (Monroe, 2005).                         a reason for out of class referrals (Skiba, 2002).       (Skiba, 2000).




 APPLYING CRT IN THE CLASSROOM                   APPLYING CRT IN THE CLASSROOM                            APPLYING CRT IN THE INSTITUTION
Culturally Responsive Classroom                 Authentic Caring- Holding high                           Race-based interventions- Individuals
                                                expectations as well as providing a                      caring is not enough. The institution must
Management- Centering                           Copyright © May 2011 Macheo Payne                        function in a race responsive way toward
instruction around the cultural                 high level Rights Reserved & support
                                                         All of care, concern                            equity with strategies similar to affirmative
needs & learning styles of each                 to all students who need it                              action & Oakland’s African American male
student (Gay, 2000).                            (Valenzuela, 1999).                                      achievement office.
APPLIED CRITICAL RACE THEORY MODEL FOR EDUCATION
Ideological Basis                 Institutional Basis                  Narrative                       Applying CRT                     Importance of CRT
According to CRT the              Major institutions in this           CRT uses narrative in           Effective interventions should   CRT is interdisciplinary and
ideological foundation of this    country implicitly function to       research to substantiate the    address equity problems using    compliments many other
country is implicitly biased      keep white privilege in place.       problem as well a in            CRT tenets for the purpose of    frameworks but serves a
against all non-whites                                                 interventions that address      eliminating inequitable          critically unique function in
                                                                       inequity in education           outcomes                         equity analysis in education
Whiteness as Property-            Institutional Racism-                Counter Narrative-              Race-based                       Naming the Oppressor-
Possession of rights that         Inequitable outcomes for             countering institutional        Intervention- Addressing         Proper diagnosis,
are respected by laws             nonwhite groups                      bias of empirical process       the root cause, not the          Recasting the “blaming of
default to whiteness              consistently, for decades,           of inquiry & research           effect, being race specific,     the victim” not “blaming
                                  all over the country                                                 not race neutral                 the oppressor”
Centrality of Whiteness-          Implicit Bias- Inequality            Traditional Narrative-          Parallel process- The            Demystifying Racism-
White ideology, values,           is reproduced regardless             Affirming validity of           necessity of both site-          Ceasing to view the
and interests are at the          of individuals in the                humanity through story          based interventions as           effects of racism from the
center of all aspects of          institution or assumed               and narrative from the          well as broader                  restrictive view. (no hood,
dominant culture & policy         institutional intolerance of         Subject, not interpretation     institutional change on a        no foul)
                                  racism                               from the observer               fundamental level and
                                                                                                       over the long term
White Supremacy- All              Restrictive vs.                      Decentralizing                  It’s the Adults stupid!-         Addressing the cause
nonwhites are naturally           Expansive view- The                  Whiteness- Reframing            Relentless focus on adults       not the effect- Refocusing
inferior, (post-modern            legal burden of the victim           and recasting the               not children as the target       attention on white
form- nonwhites are               to prove racist intent of            perspective from the            for change with the              supremacy, not those it
permanently                       policy instead of proving            experience of the Subject       indicators in the student        impacts (going upstream)
disadvantaged)                    race-based impact                    through narrative.              outcomes
                                  (explicit vs. implicitly
                                  racist)
                                  Interest Convergence-                                                Institutional Nurturing-         Picks the right target-
                                  Power is shared when                                                 Individuals caring is not        Not confusing race-based
                                  there is a mutual benefit.                                           enough. The institution          impact with other
                                  If there is a conflict in                                            must function in a race          overlapping forms of
                                  interest, all change, no                                             responsive way toward            oppression like poverty,
                                  matter how noble, will be                                            equity. (ex. transformative      class, geography, etc.
                                  resisted by the power                                                leadership)
                                  group (Brown v. Board)
                                                                   Copyright © May 2011 Macheo Payne
                                                                           All Rights Reserved
APPLIED CRITICAL RACE THEORY




Ideological Basis          Institutional                             The use of       Applying CRT in
    to CRT                 Basis to CRT                              Narrative in       the field of
                                                                        CRT             Education
Whiteness as             Institutional Racism-
property Possession      Inequitable outcomes                                         Race-based
of rights that are       for nonwhite groups                     Counter              Intervention-
respected by laws        consistently, for decades,              Narrative-           Addressing the root
defaults to whiteness    all over the country                    countering           cause, not the effect,
first                    Implicit Bias-                          institutional bias   being race specific, not
                                                                                      race-neutral
                         Inequality is reproduced                of inquiry &
Centrality of            regardless of individuals
Whiteness White          in the institution or
                                                                 research             Parallel process- The
ideology, values, and    assumed institutional                                        necessity of both site-
                         intolerance of racism                   Traditional          based interventions as
interests are at the
                                                                                      well as broader
center of all aspects
                         Restrictive vs.
                                                                 Narrative-           institutional change on
of dominant culture      Expansive view- The                     Affirming validity   a fundamental level and
& policy                 legal burden of the                     of humanity          over the long term
                         victim to prove racist
White supremacy          intent of policy instead
                                                                 through story and    It’s the Adults
Scientific & religious   of proving race-based                   narrative            stupid!- Relentless
frameworks of white      impact (explicit vs.                                         focus on adults not
                         implicitly racist)                                           children as the target
moral, physical,                                                 Decentralizing
intellectual                                                                          for change with the
                         Interest Convergence-                   Whiteness-           indicators in the
superiority: natural     Power is shared when                    Reframing and        student outcomes
selection & manifest     there is a mutual benefit.
destiny. (post-          If there is a conflict in
                                                                 recasting from the
                                                                 experience of the    Institutional
modern form:             interest, all change, no                                     Nurturing- Individuals
nonwhites are            matter how noble, will                  oppressed through    caring is not enough.
                         be resisted by the power
permanently
                         group (Brown v. Board)
                                                                 narrative            The institution must
disadvantaged)                                                                        function in a race
                                          Copyright © May 2011 Macheo Payne           responsive way toward
                                                  All Rights Reserved                 equity

Critical Race Theory Model

  • 1.
    APPLIED CRITICAL RACETHEORY KEY TENETS TO RESEARCH APPLYING CRT IN CRT REVIEW THE CLASSROOM Primary Lenses: Authentic Caring- Holding Centrality of high expectations as well as providing a high level of Whiteness White Teacher Bias Hidden care, concern & support to ideology, values, and stereotypes compel all students in need. interests are at the center adults to have different of all aspects of Reframing expectations and hold Responsibility- Relentless dominant culture & Black students to a focus on adults not children policy different standard. as the target for change with the indicators in the student The Challenge to Institutional Bias- outcomes dominant ideology Inequality is reproduced Institutional Nurturing- Countering the claims regardless of individuals Individuals caring is not that the legal system of in the institution or enough. The institution justice and all post- assumed institutional must function in a race modern American intolerance of racism responsive way toward institutions, namely equity. public education is Cultural Mismatch- Culturally Responsive- colorblind, race-neutral Black students culture is Adjusting teaching to and provides equal pathologized and viewed responding to the cultural opportunity (Brown v as incompatible with the needs & learning styles of Board) educational setting Payne Copyright © May 2011 Macheo each student. All Rights Reserved
  • 2.
    APPLIED CRITICAL RACE THEORY KEY TENET OF CRT KEY TENET OF CRT Centrality of Whiteness Unconscious The Challenge to dominant ideology hegemonic ideology that places white Countering claims that the legal system of values and interests at the center of all justice and public institutions, namely aspects of dominant culture & policy, public education is colorblind, race- perpetuating white supremacy (Ladson- neutral and provides equal opportunity Billings, 1998; Picower, 2009). (Solorzano, 1997; Yosso, 2005). PRIMARY EXPLANATIONS IN THE PRIMARY EXPLANATIONS IN THE PRIMARY EXPLANATIONS IN THE RESEARCH RESEARCH RESEARCH Cultural Mismatch- Black students’ Teacher Bias- Hidden stereotypes lead Institutional Bias- Inequality is culture is pathologized and viewed as teachers to view Black students negatively holding them to a different set of standards, reproduced through racially biased incompatible with the educational overusing disruption, defiance and disrespect as policies such as zero tolerance setting (Monroe, 2005). a reason for out of class referrals (Skiba, 2002). (Skiba, 2000). APPLYING CRT IN THE CLASSROOM APPLYING CRT IN THE CLASSROOM APPLYING CRT IN THE INSTITUTION Culturally Responsive Classroom Authentic Caring- Holding high Race-based interventions- Individuals expectations as well as providing a caring is not enough. The institution must Management- Centering Copyright © May 2011 Macheo Payne function in a race responsive way toward instruction around the cultural high level Rights Reserved & support All of care, concern equity with strategies similar to affirmative needs & learning styles of each to all students who need it action & Oakland’s African American male student (Gay, 2000). (Valenzuela, 1999). achievement office.
  • 3.
    APPLIED CRITICAL RACETHEORY MODEL FOR EDUCATION Ideological Basis Institutional Basis Narrative Applying CRT Importance of CRT According to CRT the Major institutions in this CRT uses narrative in Effective interventions should CRT is interdisciplinary and ideological foundation of this country implicitly function to research to substantiate the address equity problems using compliments many other country is implicitly biased keep white privilege in place. problem as well a in CRT tenets for the purpose of frameworks but serves a against all non-whites interventions that address eliminating inequitable critically unique function in inequity in education outcomes equity analysis in education Whiteness as Property- Institutional Racism- Counter Narrative- Race-based Naming the Oppressor- Possession of rights that Inequitable outcomes for countering institutional Intervention- Addressing Proper diagnosis, are respected by laws nonwhite groups bias of empirical process the root cause, not the Recasting the “blaming of default to whiteness consistently, for decades, of inquiry & research effect, being race specific, the victim” not “blaming all over the country not race neutral the oppressor” Centrality of Whiteness- Implicit Bias- Inequality Traditional Narrative- Parallel process- The Demystifying Racism- White ideology, values, is reproduced regardless Affirming validity of necessity of both site- Ceasing to view the and interests are at the of individuals in the humanity through story based interventions as effects of racism from the center of all aspects of institution or assumed and narrative from the well as broader restrictive view. (no hood, dominant culture & policy institutional intolerance of Subject, not interpretation institutional change on a no foul) racism from the observer fundamental level and over the long term White Supremacy- All Restrictive vs. Decentralizing It’s the Adults stupid!- Addressing the cause nonwhites are naturally Expansive view- The Whiteness- Reframing Relentless focus on adults not the effect- Refocusing inferior, (post-modern legal burden of the victim and recasting the not children as the target attention on white form- nonwhites are to prove racist intent of perspective from the for change with the supremacy, not those it permanently policy instead of proving experience of the Subject indicators in the student impacts (going upstream) disadvantaged) race-based impact through narrative. outcomes (explicit vs. implicitly racist) Interest Convergence- Institutional Nurturing- Picks the right target- Power is shared when Individuals caring is not Not confusing race-based there is a mutual benefit. enough. The institution impact with other If there is a conflict in must function in a race overlapping forms of interest, all change, no responsive way toward oppression like poverty, matter how noble, will be equity. (ex. transformative class, geography, etc. resisted by the power leadership) group (Brown v. Board) Copyright © May 2011 Macheo Payne All Rights Reserved
  • 4.
    APPLIED CRITICAL RACETHEORY Ideological Basis Institutional The use of Applying CRT in to CRT Basis to CRT Narrative in the field of CRT Education Whiteness as Institutional Racism- property Possession Inequitable outcomes Race-based of rights that are for nonwhite groups Counter Intervention- respected by laws consistently, for decades, Narrative- Addressing the root defaults to whiteness all over the country countering cause, not the effect, first Implicit Bias- institutional bias being race specific, not race-neutral Inequality is reproduced of inquiry & Centrality of regardless of individuals Whiteness White in the institution or research Parallel process- The ideology, values, and assumed institutional necessity of both site- intolerance of racism Traditional based interventions as interests are at the well as broader center of all aspects Restrictive vs. Narrative- institutional change on of dominant culture Expansive view- The Affirming validity a fundamental level and & policy legal burden of the of humanity over the long term victim to prove racist White supremacy intent of policy instead through story and It’s the Adults Scientific & religious of proving race-based narrative stupid!- Relentless frameworks of white impact (explicit vs. focus on adults not implicitly racist) children as the target moral, physical, Decentralizing intellectual for change with the Interest Convergence- Whiteness- indicators in the superiority: natural Power is shared when Reframing and student outcomes selection & manifest there is a mutual benefit. destiny. (post- If there is a conflict in recasting from the experience of the Institutional modern form: interest, all change, no Nurturing- Individuals nonwhites are matter how noble, will oppressed through caring is not enough. be resisted by the power permanently group (Brown v. Board) narrative The institution must disadvantaged) function in a race Copyright © May 2011 Macheo Payne responsive way toward All Rights Reserved equity