SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Available online at www.sciencedirect.com
2212-8271 © 2016 Published by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
Peer-review under responsibility of the organizing committee of the 26th CIRP Design Conference
doi:10.1016/j.procir.2016.05.016
Procedia CIRP 50 (2016) 408 – 413
ScienceDirect
26th CIRP Design Conference
Considering Part Orientation in Design for Additive Manufacturing
Bastian Leutenecker-Twelsieka,*
, Christoph Klahnb
, Mirko Meboldta
aETH Z¨urich, Leonhardstrasse 21, 8092 Z¨urich, Switzerland
bInspire AG, Leonhardstrasse 21, 8092 Z¨urich, Switzerland
∗ Corresponding author. Tel.: +41-44-633-83-87. E-mail address: bleutenecker@ethz.ch
Abstract
Additive Manufacturing (AM) is established not only in prototyping, but also in serial production of end-use products. To use the full potential
of the production technology the restrictions of current additive manufacturing processes (like support structures in Selective Laser Melting)
must be considered in the design process. Especially the compliance with design rules from early design stages on is important in AM serial
production, due to production quantities and the resulting scale effect. The part orientation in the build space has a strong influence on many
quality characteristics. In order to use the full potential and to consider the restrictions from the start, a design guideline is necessary to support
the whole design process.
For this purpose, this paper presents a framework for design guidelines. The framework distinguishes between process characteristics, design
principles and design rules; each supporting the designer during different stages of the design process. Furthermore, the paper examines the
influence of part orientation in existing design rules and elaborates its importance. Based on this result, the design principle ”early determination
of part orientation” is presented, which includes a process for determining the part orientation in early stage of the design process.
In addition, a design process for additive manufactured parts is demonstrated on an extensive showcase, following the guideline framework
and including the principle for early determination of part orientation. The presented framework proved to be helpful in the design process and
will be used in the future to collect more process characteristics, design principles and rules.
c 2016 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V.
Selection and peer-review under responsibility of Professor Lihui Wang.
Keywords: Part Orientation; Additive Manufacturing; Design Process; Design for Additive Manufacturing
1. Introduction
Additive Manufacturing (AM), or 3D printing - as it is re-
ferred to in the media, is a group of manufacturing technolo-
gies which produces three-dimensional objects by adding ma-
terial, usually in a layer by layer process. In the beginning of
the manufacturing technologies in the 1980th, the first applica-
tions were the production of prototypes. During the following
decades the manufacturing technology and materials evolved
and nowadays, new fields of application are possible.
Additive Manufacturing processes are technologically ma-
ture for industrial production and due to a sufficient process
stability and a rising competition between service providers [1]
Additive Manufacturing becomes economically feasible for a
growing number of industrial and end-user applications [2].
Today there are many different Additive Manufacturing pro-
cesses available, some of which are capable of serial direct part
production. Nowadays, processes like Selective Laser Melting
(SLM), Selective Laser Sintering (SLS) and, with some limita-
tions, Fused Deposition Modeling (FDM) are used to produce
end-user parts.
The possibility for serial direct part production brought new
challenges for industries. To implement new production tech-
nologies, companies have to identify suitable parts for AM [3].
Furthermore, the new production process created new possibil-
ities but also new restrictions to the design. Unlocking the de-
sign potential of AM is a big challenge, because of the tradition
and fixed mind-sets of experienced designers and of course due
to the lack of knowledge on the new technology [4,5].
Introducing a new way of thinking to designers can be
achieved through design guidelines and training. In particular,
it is difficult to obtain support for the designers in terms of de-
sign guidelines and design rules of AM. At the moment design
rules are mostly presented in academic publications for an aca-
demic target audience. There is a challenge to develop a design
guideline for AM which can be used in industry and is based on
industrial experience.
2. Design Guideline
The knowledge needed for a good design for a specific appli-
cation is complex and multi-facetted. The different publications
of design rules for AM are usually driven scientifically [5] and
follow a systematic scientific structure which doesn’t necessar-
ily match the workflow of practitioners.
To implement AM Design in the industry, a user-centered
structure of the design guideline is necessary to assist the de-
2212-8271 c 2016 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V.
Selection and peer-review under responsibility of Professor Lihui Wang.
© 2016 Published by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
Peer-review under responsibility of the organizing committee of the 26th CIRP Design Conference
409Bastian Leutenecker-Twelsiek et al. / Procedia CIRP 50 (2016) 408 – 413
signer in product development and to overcome reservations
against novel production methods. Therefore, the presented de-
sign guideline follows product development respectively design
process.
A design process can be roughly divided into the stages of
task clarification, conceptual design, embodiment design and
final design [6,7]. The tasks in each of these stages require a
different kind of guidelines to support designers. Based on the
needs along the process, the design guideline is divided into
three areas: process characteristics, design principles and de-
sign rules. These are not exclusively assigned to the individual
stages but are rather aligned with the developer’s needs.
The multitude of AM processes and materials makes the de-
velopment of a generic design guideline for all feasible com-
binations of processes and materials an impossible task, if it
is intended to have any practical use [5]. Therefore, the pre-
sented design guidelines primarily focus on AM processes for
the production of end-user parts, especially on SLS, SLM and
FDM. The presented process characteristics, design principles
and design rules can be applied to individual processes or even
to Additive Manufacturing in general. For reasons of simplicity,
this publication focuses primarily on SLM processes.
2.1. Process Characteristics
The process characteristics summarize the basic knowledge
on the working principle of a process for the design and should
be known to the designer if he wants to design AM compo-
nents. They describe the characteristics conditioned by the pro-
cess which have an impact on the design, and, therefore, must
be taken into account for the design of AM components. They
illustrate the specifics of the process. Thus, for example, the
stair-step effect is explained and the need for support structures.
The basics on process features of different AM technologies are
already available in the literature and can be derived respec-
tively prepared therefrom [2,8].
2.2. Design Principles
Design principles support the designer to transfer a principle
solution into a specific, manufacturable design. They enable
the developer to exploit AM’s freedom of design and to circum-
vent existing AM constraints creatively. The design principles
can range from simple notes to cut costs to recommendations
which largely impact the design of parts. They also give in-
structions to increase part quality or to reduce manufacturing
costs respectively post processing effort.
Like in design principles for conventional manufacturing a
trade-off between conflicting principles may be needed [9]. In
such a case, the designer has to rate the impact and decide
which principle is more important to the overall objective of
the design.
Design principles are rarely found in literature as they are
often based on experiences of developers. There are a few case
studies on good AM designs, but those usually don’t provide
enough background information to extract and refine the expe-
rience of the designer from the part design.
2.3. Design Rules
The design rules cover the necessary characteristic facts and
figures for designers to design manufacturable components for
the AM process. These design rules depend on the chosen man-
ufacturing process, material, machine and machine parameters.
Initial reference values for designing parts can be taken from the
literature. However for a specific design the characteristic val-
ues of the chosen production system are necessary and a com-
munication with the workshop is essential. The design rules
includes such values as minimum wall thickness or roughness
information which depend on the machine and process param-
eters.
3. Part Orientation
Part orientation describes the rotation of the part in the build
space around the axes of the machine’s coordinate system [10].
The term excludes a translation of the part along the coordinate
axes of the machine’s coordinate system during part positioning
[10].
3.1. Significance of Part Orientation for Design
Based on the layer by layer manufacturing process there is a
difference between the part geometry in building direction (typ-
ically the z-direction of the machine’s coordinate system) and
the geometry orthogonal to the building direction. The orthog-
onal shape is produced almost continuous while the part pro-
duction in build direction is discontinuous in discrete steps of
one layer thickness. Furthermore some AM processes require
support structures in build direction and the design has influ-
ence on the component warping. Therefore the impact of part
orientation on the design of the part is significant.
The importance of part orientation is reflected in an analysis
of already published design rules. Adam published a design
rule catalog to support suitable designs for AM with 55 design
rules [11]. The design rules are developed for SLS, FDM and
SLM based on a process independent method for developing
design rules for AM [12].
In preparation of this contribution we analyzed and classified
the design rules of Adam for direct, indirect or no dependence
of the part orientation. Design rules with direct request for ori-
entation are added to the direct dependence design rules. The
design rules which need a specific orientation to be applicable
are classified as indirect dependence design rules. For exam-
ple the rule on inner radius in simple curved elements provides
no instruction how to orientate the inner radius, but it states
the minimal radius to build up horizontal holes without sup-
port structure in SLM an FDM. Strictly speaking, this is no
direct instruction to orientate the element but a dependence on
the orientation is clearly stated. Therefore this rule is added to
the indirect dependent design rules.
The design rule analysis of Selective Laser Sintering (SLS)
shows that over 55% are direct or indirect dependent on the
orientation. For SLM and FDM 70% of the design rules depend
on part orientation, see Fig. 1.
410 Bastian Leutenecker-Twelsiek et al. / Procedia CIRP 50 (2016) 408 – 413
directly or indirectly depending on orientation
not depending on orientation
SLM SLS FDM
30% 30%
70%55%
45%
70%
Fig. 1. Analysis results of design rule dependencies on part orientation
3.2. Quality Features for Part Orientation
There is a variety of studies on the optimization of the part
orientation in Additive Manufacturing. The first ones were car-
ried out in the early stages of the technology in the 1990s years.
In particular, for Stereolithography (SLA) there are a variety
of publications [13,14]. Research [15–18] deals usually with
existing part designs to be oriented in build space. The compo-
nent orientation is set on the basis of different quality features.
These quality features are dimensional accuracy, surface qual-
ity, shape accuracy, building costs, building time, component
warping, stability, support volume, utilization of building space,
effort of post processing and accessibility of support structures
[15].
The quality features listed here are all directly dependent on
the geometry of the part. In common orientation strategies the
part (after the final design) is rotated along the part’s coordinate
axes to achieve an optimum of the quality features [19]. The
result of such a multi-objective optimization is a compromise
to balance the different quality features.
3.3. Design Principle: Early Determination of Part Orienta-
tion
This previous work demonstrates the importance of the ori-
entation in the build space for the quality of the produced part.
Nevertheless the work was limited on orienting a given final
part design. We propose a new principle to determine the orien-
tation at an early stage of the design process. The early deter-
mination the orientation before the final design allows changes
to the shape to improve the quality characteristics.
The design principle early determination of the part orienta-
tion states that the orientation should be determined before the
final design of the part begins. This allows the designer to base
his design on this decision and bypass or avoid certain process
restrictions by an appropriate design.
This principle has a high impact on the part design. This
is especially true for AM processes like SLM because of the
necessary support structure, component warping and orienta-
tion depending surface quality. The high number of orienta-
tion depending design rules highlights this. The impact of the
early orientation and application of common design rules is il-
lustrated by a simple part with same functions and two different
orientations in Fig. 2.
The challenge here is the determination of part orientation
despite an uncertainty due to the early stage of design process.
Fig. 2. Impact of part orientation on the final design
3.4. Process to Determine the Part Orientation
To assist the designer with the challenge of an early deter-
mination of the part orientation, the procedure depicted in Fig.
3 was developed. It is based on dividing the concept design of
the part into several design elements and analyzing these sep-
arately. In this analysis the orientation’s effects on the quality
features of the elements are evaluated. Subsequently the rele-
vance of each element to the part function is rated to quantify
the impact of part orientation. The orientation of the part is
determined based on this rating.
In the first step of the process depicted in Fig. 3 the concept
of the part is decomposed into design elements. Here a design
element is an individual or a meaningful combination of active
surfaces designated to fulfill a function in the component. An
example of a design element is a thread with a clamping surface
or the contact surfaces of an attachment.
The next step assesses whether a particular orientation of the
design element has a significant influence on the quality feature.
If not, the design element can be neglected in the orientation of
the part. If the element has an influence, then the designer must
determine the optimal positioning of the design element for the
quality feature. This can cause orientation conflicts between the
different quality characteristics, e.g. one orientation results in
a better surface roughness while the other reduces the risk of
warping. Here, the designer has to specify which quality fea-
ture should be given higher priority and therefore determines
the orientation of the design element. In our experience a re-
view of all quality features for each design element is highly
time-consuming and often unnecessary. A reduction of scope
to quality features with a high impact in the early design phase
is quite useful to reduce the workload.
We analyzed the orientation processes of about twenty parts
to identify necessary quality features. Based on this analysis we
reduced the quality features to the following relevant ones: sur-
face quality, dimensional stability, component distortion, sup-
port structure and building height. This set of quality features
allows determining the part orientation in an early design phase
when no detailed part design is available.
Based on best individual orientations of each element the
overall part orientation is determined. The design elements are
weighted according to their importance for the function of the
component. It is likely that additional effort in post-processing
is needed when the design element is not positioned accord-
ing to its optimum orientation. Furthermore, the number of de-
sign elements lying in a similar orientation is important here,
since the effort of post-processing can increase significantly if
their orientation is not taken into account. The designer has to
411Bastian Leutenecker-Twelsiek et al. / Procedia CIRP 50 (2016) 408 – 413
part concept design
part final design
design elements
decompose
global orientation of part
69
z
7
z
z
analyze each
design element
and determin best
orientation
design elements
with orientation
design elements
with no impact on
part orientation
rate relevance of
design elements
for part orientation
adapt design to
quality features
Fig. 3. Process for defining part orientation in early design stage
consider in this step the entire part design also and whether an
adjustment of the orientation is possible by a redesign of indi-
vidual design elements.
4. Application to Design Process and Case Study
The design process of components for Additive Manufac-
turing is no different from the basic design process for con-
ventional components as documented in VDI 2221 [7]. The
designer rather has to pay attention to the process-specific de-
sign principles. In particular, the design principles of function-
oriented design and the early determination of the part orienta-
tion have great influence on the result of the design process.
4.1. Application in the Design Process
The developer must of course know the process character-
istics of Additive Manufacturing before he enters the design
process. In the first, task clarification phase of design process,
there is no difference to conventional design.
In the second, conceptual design phase, during the deter-
mination of functions and development of a principal solution
there is also no difference. However, it should be noted that it
has been shown in many cases that a very strict applied func-
tion abstraction away from the component geometry is useful.
This abstraction makes it easier for the designer to leave exist-
ing, conventional manufacturing constraints and enable him to
develop principle solutions, which use the design advantage of
Additive Manufacturing. In this phase of the design process, it
is necessary to know about the design principles of AM to en-
sure a good and adapted product design. After the second phase
there is a principal solution which fulfills all the specifications.
We refer to this principal solution or design concept as ideal-
design, because it is an ideal solution for all functions which
fulfills the specifications without any restrictions of a manufac-
turing process.
In the third, the conceptual design phase, the ideal-design is
transferred into a feasible-design, which is producible by AM
and following post-processing. In this phase the design princi-
ples become very important, because they support the designer
in the transfer and help to reduce cost and enhance quality. The
principle of early determination of the part orientation achieves
this by minimizing the limitations and restrictions of the pro-
duction process like support structure or component distortion.
Therefore, the ideal design can be divided into design elements
and the build orientation is determined on this basis using the
process presented here.
In the fourth, the final design phase, the feasible-design is
prepared. This step is supported by the design rules for AM
with characteristic variables for design elements.
4.2. Case Study
To illustrate the described design process and in particular
the procedure for part orientation a case study is presented be-
low. It involves a so-called laser cutting head of a laser cutter.
The laser cutter is used to cut or engrave panels of organic mate-
rials such as wood (medium-density fiberboard) or acrylic with
a CO2 Laser. The laser cutting head is guided on a movable
axis and has the function to hold the deflection mirror and the
focus lens. The bottom of the lens is purged by compressed air
to prevent contamination due to the resulting sublimation dust.
The goal of the redesign of the laser cutting head is to improve
the cleaning effect on the bottom of the lens by optimizing the
air outlet [20]. In addition a compressed air cleaning of the top
of the lens and the deflection mirror was implemented. The lens
holder is to be produced by SLM in AlSi12.
At the beginning of the design process, the environment and
the design space are set. For this all the interfaces of the system
laser cutting head and the predetermined functional areas are
specified in the CAD-model depicted in Fig. 4a.
a b v m/s[ ]
0
10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
Fig. 4. Fix arrangements (a) flow simulation for compressed air flush (b)
Subsequently, solutions have been developed for the opti-
mized cleaning of the mirror and of the lens using CFD. The
results of the optimization are shown in Fig. 4b. The results
from the simulation and function areas of the air duct for clean-
ing have been included in the CAD model. For a better view,
and thus improved division into shape elements all functional
surfaces were coated with a material thickness of 1 mm, result-
ing in the ideal-design of the laser cutting head in Fig. 5.
Here, the design principle of function-oriented design has
been taken into account. In the further procedure, the part is
412 Bastian Leutenecker-Twelsiek et al. / Procedia CIRP 50 (2016) 408 – 413
a b
Fig. 5. Ideal-design of internal (a) and external (b) geometry elements
oriented by applying the design principle early determination of
the part orientation. It begins with the dismantling into design
elements. Subsequently the design elements are analyzed and
the orientation is determined.
To illustrate the process presented here three design elements
of the laser cutting head are exemplarily discussed.
• The first group of elements is the mirror mounting sur-
face with the threads of screws, Fig. 5b No. 1. A suffi-
cient surface quality and dimensional accuracy is required
to position the mirror correctly. The SLM process is not
able to meet the requirements of both quality features de-
spite optimal positioning. Therefore, post-processing of
the mounting surface and threads is necessary. This will
also remove any support structure if it is not already omit-
ted by a suitable positioning. The building height is irrel-
evant due to the almost cubic body proportions relative to
the total component. In summary the necessary post pro-
cessing of the design elements makes the orientation of
this group no longer relevant for part orientation.
• The second group of elements are the guide rails for the
lens element, Fig. 5b No. 2. The achievable surface qual-
ity is sufficient for fulfilling the functions. The dimen-
sional stability is in all orientations also sufficient. The
possible component distortion of this design element is the
limit, therefore is an orientation parallel to the build direc-
tion is preferred. In this orientation support structures are
avoided at the rails. Since the removal of support struc-
tures from the guide rails is very tedious, this has a high
priority on the orientation. The building height is negligi-
ble in relation to the overall size of the part.
• The third and last design element discussed in this exam-
ple is the channel for the air, Fig. 5 No. 3. Both sur-
face quality and dimensional accuracy are sufficient for the
channel’s function. Due to its small diameter between 1-5
mm internal support structures are not required. Through
the integration of the channel in the component distortion
and component height are irrelevant. Therefore the layout
element is not relevant to the component orientation.
In summary the design elements of the guide rails of the
lens frame and the high demands on the design element of the
mounting surface and the positioning- and screw holes are de-
cisive for the orientation of the part in the build chamber. The
consideration of the overall component in respect of component
distortion and part height reinforce the decision to orientate the
laser cutting head in lying position with parallel to the build-
ing direction orientated guide rails for the lens holder. Since a
thread needs to be cut on the lens-side beam path, the removal
of the necessary support structure is negligible. The beam path
at the entrance on the other hand does not have to be reworked
and has a certain flexibility in the design. Therefore, the support
structures in the beam entrance can be avoided by an adjustment
of its shape.
Finally some minor adjustments are done to avoid support-
ing structures and to follow all the design rules for the process
and the material to meet specifications, creating the feasible-
design of the laser cutting head.
In Fig. 6a, the feasible design is shown on the produced laser
cutting head with all attachments during action in Fig. 6b.
a b
Fig. 6. Feasible-design (a) and additive manufactured part with assembled com-
ponents (b)
5. Conclusion
The continuous development of AM increases the applica-
tion fields for these technologies. In particular, advances in the
areas of materials, part quality, process stability and reduced
manufacturing costs extended the use of AM from prototyping
to the production of end-use parts in series production.
To a designer the very different characteristics of processes
and parts are a major challenge in unlocking the design po-
tential of AM. To address this current lack of experience and
implement design knowledge in industry, a user-centered de-
sign guideline for designers is developed. It consists of process
characteristics, design principles and design rules to support the
designer in the design phase of conceptual design, embodiment
design and final design.
One of these design principles is presented here. The princi-
ple of the early determination of the part orientation is of high
relevance particularly in the construction of SLM parts. There-
fore, an approach was presented to determine the part orienta-
tion in the early stage of the design based on the ideal-design. In
this approach, the part is decomposed in design elements which
are analyzed. This enables early determination of part orienta-
tion and thus sets the basis for the transfer of the ideal-designs
into a feasible design.
The presented design guideline will provide a proper guid-
ance for designers to use the design advantage of Additive Man-
ufacturing for serial products. The awareness for defining the
413Bastian Leutenecker-Twelsiek et al. / Procedia CIRP 50 (2016) 408 – 413
part orientation in an early design stage will help to avoid de-
sign iterations and post processing.
The presented framework of process characteristics, design
principles, design guidelines will be used in future works to
provide the necessary design knowledge in a structured way.
Further steps are a quantitative validation and the development
of additional principles. The framework is applicable to other
AM technologies and can be extended beyond the processes of
FDM, SLS and SLM.
References
[1] M. Baldinger, A. Duchi, Price benchmark of laser sintering service
providers, in: High Value Manufacturing: Advanced Research in Virtual
and Rapid Prototyping: Proceedings of the 6th International Conference
on Advanced Research in Virtual and Rapid Prototyping, Leiria, Portugal,
2013, pp. 37 – 42.
[2] A. Gebhardt, Understanding additive manufacturing : Rapid Prototyping -
Rapid Tooling - Rapid Manufacturing, 1st Edition, Hanser, Munich, 2012.
[3] C. Klahn, B. Leutenecker, M. Meboldt, Design for additive manufacturing
- supporting the substitution of components in series products, Procedia
CIRP 21 (2014) 138 – 143.
[4] N. Hopkinson, R. Hague, P. Dickens (Eds.), Rapid Manufacturing: An
Industrial Revolution for the Digital Age, 1st Edition, J. Wiley, Chichester,
2006.
[5] T. Wohlers, T. Caffrey (Eds.), Wohlers Report 2015 - Additive Manufac-
turing and 3D Printing State of the Industry - Annual Worldwide Progress
Report, Wohlers Associates, Fort Collins, CO, 2015.
[6] G. Pahl, K. Wallace, Engineering design: A systematic approach, 3rd Edi-
tion, Springer, London, 2007.
[7] VDI 2221, Methodik zum Entwickeln und Konstruieren technischer Sys-
teme und Produkte, Beuth, Berlin, 1993.
[8] VDI 3405, Additive manufacturing processes, rapid manufacturing - Ba-
sics, definitions, processes, Beuth, Berlin, 2014.
[9] P. Naefe, Einf¨uhrung in das Methodische Konstruieren: F¨ur Studium und
Praxis, 2nd Edition, Springer Vieweg, Wiesbaden, 2012.
[10] VDI 3405 Part 3, Additive manufacturing processes, rapid manufacturing -
Design rules for part production using laser sintering and laser beam melt-
ing, Beuth, Berlin, 2015.
[11] G. Adam, Systematische Erarbeitung von Konstruktionsregeln f¨ur die ad-
ditiven Fertigungsverfahren Lasersintern, Laserschmelzen und Fused De-
position Modeling, 1st Edition, Shaker, Aachen, 2015.
[12] G. Adam, D. Zimmer, Design for additive manufacturingelement transi-
tions and aggregated structures, CIRP Journal of Manufacturing Science
and Technology 1 (2014) 20 – 28.
[13] J. Hur, K. Lee, Determination of optimal build-up direction for stereolitho-
graphic rapid prototyping, Journal of the Korean Society for Precision En-
gineering 4 (1996) 163 – 173.
[14] N. Pududhai, D. Dutta, Determination of optimal orientation based on
variable slicing thickness in layered manufacturing, Technical report UM-
MEAM-94-14, Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of
Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, 1994.
[15] S. Danjou, Mehrzieloptimierung der Bauteilorientierung f¨ur Anwendungen
der Rapid-Technologie, 1st Edition, Cuvillier, G¨ottingen, 2010.
[16] G. Moroni, W. Syam, S. Petr, Functionality-based part orientation for ad-
ditive manufacturing, CIRP 25th Design Conference Innovative Product
Creation 36 (2015) 217 – 222.
[17] P. Pandey, N. Venkata Reddy, S. Dhande, Part deposition orientation stud-
ies in layered manufacturing, Journal of Materials Processing Technology
1 - 3 (2007) 125 – 131.
[18] S. Singhal, P. Jain, P. Pandey, A. Nagpal, Optimum part deposition ori-
entation for multiple objectives in SL and SLS prototyping, International
Journal of Production Research 22 (2009) 6375 – 6396.
[19] S. Danjou, P. K¨ohler, Determination of optimal build direction for differ-
ent rapid prototyping applications, in: Proceedings of the 14th European
Forum on Rapid Prototyping, Paris, 2009.
[20] M. Meboldt, C. Klahn, Produktentwicklung mit digitalisierten Technolo-
gien: Wertsch¨opfung durch 3D-gedruckte Serienbauteile im Maschinen-
bau, IM+io 1 (2015) 83 – 89.

More Related Content

What's hot

Hydraulic ciruits
Hydraulic ciruitsHydraulic ciruits
Hydraulic ciruits
Abhishek Patange
 
Unit 2.1 cim
Unit 2.1 cimUnit 2.1 cim
Unit 2.1 cim
Vetri Vezhan
 
INTRODUCTION AUTOMOBILE ENGINEERING
INTRODUCTION AUTOMOBILE ENGINEERINGINTRODUCTION AUTOMOBILE ENGINEERING
INTRODUCTION AUTOMOBILE ENGINEERING
O.P.S •
 
Automobile exhaust System
Automobile exhaust SystemAutomobile exhaust System
Automobile exhaust SystemMayank Jaggi
 
Sla recoating issues & fdm
Sla recoating issues & fdmSla recoating issues & fdm
Sla recoating issues & fdmAbdul Kalam
 
Electrical system in automobile shabaz
Electrical system in automobile  shabazElectrical system in automobile  shabaz
Electrical system in automobile shabazShahbaz Bhati
 
Transmission system
Transmission systemTransmission system
Transmission system
Shubham gupta
 
Lubrication System - IC Engine - Unit-III
Lubrication System - IC Engine - Unit-IIILubrication System - IC Engine - Unit-III
Lubrication System - IC Engine - Unit-III
S.Vijaya Bhaskar
 
SURFACE MODELLING .pptx
SURFACE MODELLING .pptxSURFACE MODELLING .pptx
SURFACE MODELLING .pptx
jntuhcej
 
LUBRICATING AND COOLING SYSTEM
LUBRICATING AND COOLING SYSTEMLUBRICATING AND COOLING SYSTEM
LUBRICATING AND COOLING SYSTEM
Ronak Parmar
 
Vehicle dynamics ppt shiva
Vehicle dynamics ppt shivaVehicle dynamics ppt shiva
Vehicle dynamics ppt shiva
Shiva Nand
 
Aircraft oil systems
Aircraft oil systemsAircraft oil systems
Aircraft oil systems
MalcolmHarnden
 
Vehicle aerodynamics – effects of side winds
Vehicle aerodynamics – effects of side windsVehicle aerodynamics – effects of side winds
Vehicle aerodynamics – effects of side winds
Ram Pranav
 
Vibration measuring instruments
Vibration measuring instrumentsVibration measuring instruments
Automobile chassis and body
Automobile chassis and bodyAutomobile chassis and body
Automobile chassis and body
Ràhúl Pâtêl
 
Carburettor ppt
Carburettor pptCarburettor ppt
Carburettor ppt
Sudhakar Uppalapati
 
Vehicle body
Vehicle bodyVehicle body
Vehicle body
sundara mahalingam v
 
Climate control system in Automotives
Climate control system in AutomotivesClimate control system in Automotives
Climate control system in Automotives
Yuga Aravind Kumar
 
Balancing of Rotating masses
Balancing of Rotating massesBalancing of Rotating masses
Balancing of Rotating masses
Rohit Singla
 
Module 1 Additive Manufacturing
Module 1 Additive ManufacturingModule 1 Additive Manufacturing
Module 1 Additive Manufacturing
taruian
 

What's hot (20)

Hydraulic ciruits
Hydraulic ciruitsHydraulic ciruits
Hydraulic ciruits
 
Unit 2.1 cim
Unit 2.1 cimUnit 2.1 cim
Unit 2.1 cim
 
INTRODUCTION AUTOMOBILE ENGINEERING
INTRODUCTION AUTOMOBILE ENGINEERINGINTRODUCTION AUTOMOBILE ENGINEERING
INTRODUCTION AUTOMOBILE ENGINEERING
 
Automobile exhaust System
Automobile exhaust SystemAutomobile exhaust System
Automobile exhaust System
 
Sla recoating issues & fdm
Sla recoating issues & fdmSla recoating issues & fdm
Sla recoating issues & fdm
 
Electrical system in automobile shabaz
Electrical system in automobile  shabazElectrical system in automobile  shabaz
Electrical system in automobile shabaz
 
Transmission system
Transmission systemTransmission system
Transmission system
 
Lubrication System - IC Engine - Unit-III
Lubrication System - IC Engine - Unit-IIILubrication System - IC Engine - Unit-III
Lubrication System - IC Engine - Unit-III
 
SURFACE MODELLING .pptx
SURFACE MODELLING .pptxSURFACE MODELLING .pptx
SURFACE MODELLING .pptx
 
LUBRICATING AND COOLING SYSTEM
LUBRICATING AND COOLING SYSTEMLUBRICATING AND COOLING SYSTEM
LUBRICATING AND COOLING SYSTEM
 
Vehicle dynamics ppt shiva
Vehicle dynamics ppt shivaVehicle dynamics ppt shiva
Vehicle dynamics ppt shiva
 
Aircraft oil systems
Aircraft oil systemsAircraft oil systems
Aircraft oil systems
 
Vehicle aerodynamics – effects of side winds
Vehicle aerodynamics – effects of side windsVehicle aerodynamics – effects of side winds
Vehicle aerodynamics – effects of side winds
 
Vibration measuring instruments
Vibration measuring instrumentsVibration measuring instruments
Vibration measuring instruments
 
Automobile chassis and body
Automobile chassis and bodyAutomobile chassis and body
Automobile chassis and body
 
Carburettor ppt
Carburettor pptCarburettor ppt
Carburettor ppt
 
Vehicle body
Vehicle bodyVehicle body
Vehicle body
 
Climate control system in Automotives
Climate control system in AutomotivesClimate control system in Automotives
Climate control system in Automotives
 
Balancing of Rotating masses
Balancing of Rotating massesBalancing of Rotating masses
Balancing of Rotating masses
 
Module 1 Additive Manufacturing
Module 1 Additive ManufacturingModule 1 Additive Manufacturing
Module 1 Additive Manufacturing
 

Similar to Considering part orientation in design for additive manufacturing

Ce seminar
Ce seminarCe seminar
Ce seminar
Ashutosh Satpathy
 
PLA and the SC 2002-04-15
PLA and the SC 2002-04-15PLA and the SC 2002-04-15
PLA and the SC 2002-04-15Jay van Zyl
 
Design For Manufacturing, (DFM)
Design For Manufacturing, (DFM)Design For Manufacturing, (DFM)
Design For Manufacturing, (DFM)
Ali Karandish
 
Introduction to rp
Introduction to rpIntroduction to rp
Introduction to rpGK Naidu
 
An Enterprise Architecture Design Build Approach - Innovate Vancouver.pdf
An Enterprise Architecture Design  Build Approach - Innovate Vancouver.pdfAn Enterprise Architecture Design  Build Approach - Innovate Vancouver.pdf
An Enterprise Architecture Design Build Approach - Innovate Vancouver.pdf
Innovate Vancouver
 
a-beginners-guide-to-systems-engineering.pdf
a-beginners-guide-to-systems-engineering.pdfa-beginners-guide-to-systems-engineering.pdf
a-beginners-guide-to-systems-engineering.pdf
ssuser1f55c6
 
U-1.pptx
U-1.pptxU-1.pptx
U-1.pptx
DrBorigorlaVenu
 
Experimental Plans and Intensive Numerical Aided Design
Experimental Plans and Intensive Numerical Aided DesignExperimental Plans and Intensive Numerical Aided Design
Experimental Plans and Intensive Numerical Aided Design
IJERA Editor
 
Process design synthesis, intensification, and integration of chemical processes
Process design synthesis, intensification, and integration of chemical processesProcess design synthesis, intensification, and integration of chemical processes
Process design synthesis, intensification, and integration of chemical processes
Up Seven
 
Tp96 pub102
Tp96 pub102Tp96 pub102
Tp96 pub102
Dave Davidson
 
Chapter 1 intr m dfina
Chapter 1 intr m dfinaChapter 1 intr m dfina
Chapter 1 intr m dfina
Khalil Alhatab
 
design_fundamental_new_.ppt
design_fundamental_new_.pptdesign_fundamental_new_.ppt
design_fundamental_new_.ppt
MohsenGhorbani9
 
Chemical Engineering Apparatus Design, ChEg4191-1.pptx
Chemical Engineering Apparatus Design, ChEg4191-1.pptxChemical Engineering Apparatus Design, ChEg4191-1.pptx
Chemical Engineering Apparatus Design, ChEg4191-1.pptx
WendeDegefu
 
Understanding and Applying The Open Group Architecture Framework (TOGAF)
Understanding and Applying The Open Group Architecture Framework (TOGAF)Understanding and Applying The Open Group Architecture Framework (TOGAF)
Understanding and Applying The Open Group Architecture Framework (TOGAF)Nathaniel Palmer
 
Understanding and Applying The Open Group Architecture Framework (TOGAF)
Understanding and Applying The Open Group Architecture Framework (TOGAF)Understanding and Applying The Open Group Architecture Framework (TOGAF)
Understanding and Applying The Open Group Architecture Framework (TOGAF)Nathaniel Palmer
 
Chapter 1 intr m dfina
Chapter 1 intr m dfinaChapter 1 intr m dfina
Chapter 1 intr m dfina
Khalil Alhatab
 
Concurrent Engineering- for Environment & Sustainability
Concurrent Engineering- for Environment & SustainabilityConcurrent Engineering- for Environment & Sustainability
Concurrent Engineering- for Environment & Sustainability
IRJET Journal
 
Chapter2 framework-for-design
Chapter2 framework-for-designChapter2 framework-for-design
Chapter2 framework-for-designVin Voro
 
Tp02 pub31
Tp02 pub31Tp02 pub31
Tp02 pub31
Dave Davidson
 

Similar to Considering part orientation in design for additive manufacturing (20)

Ce seminar
Ce seminarCe seminar
Ce seminar
 
PLA and the SC 2002-04-15
PLA and the SC 2002-04-15PLA and the SC 2002-04-15
PLA and the SC 2002-04-15
 
Design For Manufacturing, (DFM)
Design For Manufacturing, (DFM)Design For Manufacturing, (DFM)
Design For Manufacturing, (DFM)
 
Introduction to rp
Introduction to rpIntroduction to rp
Introduction to rp
 
An Enterprise Architecture Design Build Approach - Innovate Vancouver.pdf
An Enterprise Architecture Design  Build Approach - Innovate Vancouver.pdfAn Enterprise Architecture Design  Build Approach - Innovate Vancouver.pdf
An Enterprise Architecture Design Build Approach - Innovate Vancouver.pdf
 
a-beginners-guide-to-systems-engineering.pdf
a-beginners-guide-to-systems-engineering.pdfa-beginners-guide-to-systems-engineering.pdf
a-beginners-guide-to-systems-engineering.pdf
 
U-1.pptx
U-1.pptxU-1.pptx
U-1.pptx
 
Experimental Plans and Intensive Numerical Aided Design
Experimental Plans and Intensive Numerical Aided DesignExperimental Plans and Intensive Numerical Aided Design
Experimental Plans and Intensive Numerical Aided Design
 
Process design synthesis, intensification, and integration of chemical processes
Process design synthesis, intensification, and integration of chemical processesProcess design synthesis, intensification, and integration of chemical processes
Process design synthesis, intensification, and integration of chemical processes
 
concurrent engineering.pdf
concurrent engineering.pdfconcurrent engineering.pdf
concurrent engineering.pdf
 
Tp96 pub102
Tp96 pub102Tp96 pub102
Tp96 pub102
 
Chapter 1 intr m dfina
Chapter 1 intr m dfinaChapter 1 intr m dfina
Chapter 1 intr m dfina
 
design_fundamental_new_.ppt
design_fundamental_new_.pptdesign_fundamental_new_.ppt
design_fundamental_new_.ppt
 
Chemical Engineering Apparatus Design, ChEg4191-1.pptx
Chemical Engineering Apparatus Design, ChEg4191-1.pptxChemical Engineering Apparatus Design, ChEg4191-1.pptx
Chemical Engineering Apparatus Design, ChEg4191-1.pptx
 
Understanding and Applying The Open Group Architecture Framework (TOGAF)
Understanding and Applying The Open Group Architecture Framework (TOGAF)Understanding and Applying The Open Group Architecture Framework (TOGAF)
Understanding and Applying The Open Group Architecture Framework (TOGAF)
 
Understanding and Applying The Open Group Architecture Framework (TOGAF)
Understanding and Applying The Open Group Architecture Framework (TOGAF)Understanding and Applying The Open Group Architecture Framework (TOGAF)
Understanding and Applying The Open Group Architecture Framework (TOGAF)
 
Chapter 1 intr m dfina
Chapter 1 intr m dfinaChapter 1 intr m dfina
Chapter 1 intr m dfina
 
Concurrent Engineering- for Environment & Sustainability
Concurrent Engineering- for Environment & SustainabilityConcurrent Engineering- for Environment & Sustainability
Concurrent Engineering- for Environment & Sustainability
 
Chapter2 framework-for-design
Chapter2 framework-for-designChapter2 framework-for-design
Chapter2 framework-for-design
 
Tp02 pub31
Tp02 pub31Tp02 pub31
Tp02 pub31
 

More from Phuong Dx

Small scale vertical axis wind turbine design
Small scale vertical axis wind turbine designSmall scale vertical axis wind turbine design
Small scale vertical axis wind turbine design
Phuong Dx
 
Qblade an open source tool for design and simulation
Qblade an open source tool for design and simulation Qblade an open source tool for design and simulation
Qblade an open source tool for design and simulation
Phuong Dx
 
Development and application of a simulation tool for vertical and horizontal ...
Development and application of a simulation tool for vertical and horizontal ...Development and application of a simulation tool for vertical and horizontal ...
Development and application of a simulation tool for vertical and horizontal ...
Phuong Dx
 
Design of a vertical axis wind turbine- how the aspect ratio affects
Design of a vertical axis wind turbine- how the aspect ratio affectsDesign of a vertical axis wind turbine- how the aspect ratio affects
Design of a vertical axis wind turbine- how the aspect ratio affects
Phuong Dx
 
Design of a vertical axis wind turbine how the aspect ratio affects
Design of a vertical axis wind turbine how the aspect ratio affectsDesign of a vertical axis wind turbine how the aspect ratio affects
Design of a vertical axis wind turbine how the aspect ratio affects
Phuong Dx
 
aerodynamic models for darrieus type
aerodynamic models for darrieus typeaerodynamic models for darrieus type
aerodynamic models for darrieus type
Phuong Dx
 
aeolos v 300w and 600w brochure
 aeolos v 300w and 600w brochure aeolos v 300w and 600w brochure
aeolos v 300w and 600w brochure
Phuong Dx
 
Chuong 1 gt cong nghe phun ep
Chuong 1 gt cong nghe phun epChuong 1 gt cong nghe phun ep
Chuong 1 gt cong nghe phun ep
Phuong Dx
 
Fixed pitchpropellers 2011_04
Fixed pitchpropellers 2011_04Fixed pitchpropellers 2011_04
Fixed pitchpropellers 2011_04
Phuong Dx
 
Ok the balanced scorecard a review of five research areas
Ok the balanced scorecard a review of five research areasOk the balanced scorecard a review of five research areas
Ok the balanced scorecard a review of five research areas
Phuong Dx
 
Ok (review ) celebrating 20 years of the balanced scorecard
Ok (review ) celebrating 20 years of the balanced scorecardOk (review ) celebrating 20 years of the balanced scorecard
Ok (review ) celebrating 20 years of the balanced scorecard
Phuong Dx
 
A re balanced scorecard- a strategic approach to enhance manageri
A re balanced scorecard- a strategic approach to enhance manageriA re balanced scorecard- a strategic approach to enhance manageri
A re balanced scorecard- a strategic approach to enhance manageri
Phuong Dx
 
Implementing a sustainability balanced scorecard to contribute to
Implementing a sustainability balanced scorecard to contribute toImplementing a sustainability balanced scorecard to contribute to
Implementing a sustainability balanced scorecard to contribute to
Phuong Dx
 
A review of balanced scorecard use in small to medium enterprises
A review of balanced scorecard use in small to medium enterprisesA review of balanced scorecard use in small to medium enterprises
A review of balanced scorecard use in small to medium enterprises
Phuong Dx
 
Fluid and structural modeling of cavitating propeller flows
Fluid and structural modeling of cavitating propeller flowsFluid and structural modeling of cavitating propeller flows
Fluid and structural modeling of cavitating propeller flows
Phuong Dx
 
Fatigue testing of a composite propeller blade using fiber optic strain sensors
Fatigue testing of a composite propeller blade using fiber optic strain sensorsFatigue testing of a composite propeller blade using fiber optic strain sensors
Fatigue testing of a composite propeller blade using fiber optic strain sensors
Phuong Dx
 
Composite propeller performance monitoring with embedded fb gs
Composite propeller performance monitoring with embedded fb gsComposite propeller performance monitoring with embedded fb gs
Composite propeller performance monitoring with embedded fb gs
Phuong Dx
 
Applications of composites in marine industry
Applications of composites in marine industryApplications of composites in marine industry
Applications of composites in marine industry
Phuong Dx
 
A potential panel method for prediction of midchord face and back cavitation ...
A potential panel method for prediction of midchord face and back cavitation ...A potential panel method for prediction of midchord face and back cavitation ...
A potential panel method for prediction of midchord face and back cavitation ...
Phuong Dx
 
Finite element modeling of the broaching process of inconel718
Finite element modeling of the broaching process of inconel718Finite element modeling of the broaching process of inconel718
Finite element modeling of the broaching process of inconel718
Phuong Dx
 

More from Phuong Dx (20)

Small scale vertical axis wind turbine design
Small scale vertical axis wind turbine designSmall scale vertical axis wind turbine design
Small scale vertical axis wind turbine design
 
Qblade an open source tool for design and simulation
Qblade an open source tool for design and simulation Qblade an open source tool for design and simulation
Qblade an open source tool for design and simulation
 
Development and application of a simulation tool for vertical and horizontal ...
Development and application of a simulation tool for vertical and horizontal ...Development and application of a simulation tool for vertical and horizontal ...
Development and application of a simulation tool for vertical and horizontal ...
 
Design of a vertical axis wind turbine- how the aspect ratio affects
Design of a vertical axis wind turbine- how the aspect ratio affectsDesign of a vertical axis wind turbine- how the aspect ratio affects
Design of a vertical axis wind turbine- how the aspect ratio affects
 
Design of a vertical axis wind turbine how the aspect ratio affects
Design of a vertical axis wind turbine how the aspect ratio affectsDesign of a vertical axis wind turbine how the aspect ratio affects
Design of a vertical axis wind turbine how the aspect ratio affects
 
aerodynamic models for darrieus type
aerodynamic models for darrieus typeaerodynamic models for darrieus type
aerodynamic models for darrieus type
 
aeolos v 300w and 600w brochure
 aeolos v 300w and 600w brochure aeolos v 300w and 600w brochure
aeolos v 300w and 600w brochure
 
Chuong 1 gt cong nghe phun ep
Chuong 1 gt cong nghe phun epChuong 1 gt cong nghe phun ep
Chuong 1 gt cong nghe phun ep
 
Fixed pitchpropellers 2011_04
Fixed pitchpropellers 2011_04Fixed pitchpropellers 2011_04
Fixed pitchpropellers 2011_04
 
Ok the balanced scorecard a review of five research areas
Ok the balanced scorecard a review of five research areasOk the balanced scorecard a review of five research areas
Ok the balanced scorecard a review of five research areas
 
Ok (review ) celebrating 20 years of the balanced scorecard
Ok (review ) celebrating 20 years of the balanced scorecardOk (review ) celebrating 20 years of the balanced scorecard
Ok (review ) celebrating 20 years of the balanced scorecard
 
A re balanced scorecard- a strategic approach to enhance manageri
A re balanced scorecard- a strategic approach to enhance manageriA re balanced scorecard- a strategic approach to enhance manageri
A re balanced scorecard- a strategic approach to enhance manageri
 
Implementing a sustainability balanced scorecard to contribute to
Implementing a sustainability balanced scorecard to contribute toImplementing a sustainability balanced scorecard to contribute to
Implementing a sustainability balanced scorecard to contribute to
 
A review of balanced scorecard use in small to medium enterprises
A review of balanced scorecard use in small to medium enterprisesA review of balanced scorecard use in small to medium enterprises
A review of balanced scorecard use in small to medium enterprises
 
Fluid and structural modeling of cavitating propeller flows
Fluid and structural modeling of cavitating propeller flowsFluid and structural modeling of cavitating propeller flows
Fluid and structural modeling of cavitating propeller flows
 
Fatigue testing of a composite propeller blade using fiber optic strain sensors
Fatigue testing of a composite propeller blade using fiber optic strain sensorsFatigue testing of a composite propeller blade using fiber optic strain sensors
Fatigue testing of a composite propeller blade using fiber optic strain sensors
 
Composite propeller performance monitoring with embedded fb gs
Composite propeller performance monitoring with embedded fb gsComposite propeller performance monitoring with embedded fb gs
Composite propeller performance monitoring with embedded fb gs
 
Applications of composites in marine industry
Applications of composites in marine industryApplications of composites in marine industry
Applications of composites in marine industry
 
A potential panel method for prediction of midchord face and back cavitation ...
A potential panel method for prediction of midchord face and back cavitation ...A potential panel method for prediction of midchord face and back cavitation ...
A potential panel method for prediction of midchord face and back cavitation ...
 
Finite element modeling of the broaching process of inconel718
Finite element modeling of the broaching process of inconel718Finite element modeling of the broaching process of inconel718
Finite element modeling of the broaching process of inconel718
 

Recently uploaded

NO1 Uk best vashikaran specialist in delhi vashikaran baba near me online vas...
NO1 Uk best vashikaran specialist in delhi vashikaran baba near me online vas...NO1 Uk best vashikaran specialist in delhi vashikaran baba near me online vas...
NO1 Uk best vashikaran specialist in delhi vashikaran baba near me online vas...
Amil Baba Dawood bangali
 
Industrial Training at Shahjalal Fertilizer Company Limited (SFCL)
Industrial Training at Shahjalal Fertilizer Company Limited (SFCL)Industrial Training at Shahjalal Fertilizer Company Limited (SFCL)
Industrial Training at Shahjalal Fertilizer Company Limited (SFCL)
MdTanvirMahtab2
 
space technology lecture notes on satellite
space technology lecture notes on satellitespace technology lecture notes on satellite
space technology lecture notes on satellite
ongomchris
 
English lab ppt no titlespecENG PPTt.pdf
English lab ppt no titlespecENG PPTt.pdfEnglish lab ppt no titlespecENG PPTt.pdf
English lab ppt no titlespecENG PPTt.pdf
BrazilAccount1
 
Unbalanced Three Phase Systems and circuits.pptx
Unbalanced Three Phase Systems and circuits.pptxUnbalanced Three Phase Systems and circuits.pptx
Unbalanced Three Phase Systems and circuits.pptx
ChristineTorrepenida1
 
Immunizing Image Classifiers Against Localized Adversary Attacks
Immunizing Image Classifiers Against Localized Adversary AttacksImmunizing Image Classifiers Against Localized Adversary Attacks
Immunizing Image Classifiers Against Localized Adversary Attacks
gerogepatton
 
14 Template Contractual Notice - EOT Application
14 Template Contractual Notice - EOT Application14 Template Contractual Notice - EOT Application
14 Template Contractual Notice - EOT Application
SyedAbiiAzazi1
 
Student information management system project report ii.pdf
Student information management system project report ii.pdfStudent information management system project report ii.pdf
Student information management system project report ii.pdf
Kamal Acharya
 
AKS UNIVERSITY Satna Final Year Project By OM Hardaha.pdf
AKS UNIVERSITY Satna Final Year Project By OM Hardaha.pdfAKS UNIVERSITY Satna Final Year Project By OM Hardaha.pdf
AKS UNIVERSITY Satna Final Year Project By OM Hardaha.pdf
SamSarthak3
 
Water Industry Process Automation and Control Monthly - May 2024.pdf
Water Industry Process Automation and Control Monthly - May 2024.pdfWater Industry Process Automation and Control Monthly - May 2024.pdf
Water Industry Process Automation and Control Monthly - May 2024.pdf
Water Industry Process Automation & Control
 
在线办理(ANU毕业证书)澳洲国立大学毕业证录取通知书一模一样
在线办理(ANU毕业证书)澳洲国立大学毕业证录取通知书一模一样在线办理(ANU毕业证书)澳洲国立大学毕业证录取通知书一模一样
在线办理(ANU毕业证书)澳洲国立大学毕业证录取通知书一模一样
obonagu
 
HYDROPOWER - Hydroelectric power generation
HYDROPOWER - Hydroelectric power generationHYDROPOWER - Hydroelectric power generation
HYDROPOWER - Hydroelectric power generation
Robbie Edward Sayers
 
Cosmetic shop management system project report.pdf
Cosmetic shop management system project report.pdfCosmetic shop management system project report.pdf
Cosmetic shop management system project report.pdf
Kamal Acharya
 
NUMERICAL SIMULATIONS OF HEAT AND MASS TRANSFER IN CONDENSING HEAT EXCHANGERS...
NUMERICAL SIMULATIONS OF HEAT AND MASS TRANSFER IN CONDENSING HEAT EXCHANGERS...NUMERICAL SIMULATIONS OF HEAT AND MASS TRANSFER IN CONDENSING HEAT EXCHANGERS...
NUMERICAL SIMULATIONS OF HEAT AND MASS TRANSFER IN CONDENSING HEAT EXCHANGERS...
ssuser7dcef0
 
DfMAy 2024 - key insights and contributions
DfMAy 2024 - key insights and contributionsDfMAy 2024 - key insights and contributions
DfMAy 2024 - key insights and contributions
gestioneergodomus
 
Final project report on grocery store management system..pdf
Final project report on grocery store management system..pdfFinal project report on grocery store management system..pdf
Final project report on grocery store management system..pdf
Kamal Acharya
 
Hybrid optimization of pumped hydro system and solar- Engr. Abdul-Azeez.pdf
Hybrid optimization of pumped hydro system and solar- Engr. Abdul-Azeez.pdfHybrid optimization of pumped hydro system and solar- Engr. Abdul-Azeez.pdf
Hybrid optimization of pumped hydro system and solar- Engr. Abdul-Azeez.pdf
fxintegritypublishin
 
block diagram and signal flow graph representation
block diagram and signal flow graph representationblock diagram and signal flow graph representation
block diagram and signal flow graph representation
Divya Somashekar
 
Fundamentals of Electric Drives and its applications.pptx
Fundamentals of Electric Drives and its applications.pptxFundamentals of Electric Drives and its applications.pptx
Fundamentals of Electric Drives and its applications.pptx
manasideore6
 
6th International Conference on Machine Learning & Applications (CMLA 2024)
6th International Conference on Machine Learning & Applications (CMLA 2024)6th International Conference on Machine Learning & Applications (CMLA 2024)
6th International Conference on Machine Learning & Applications (CMLA 2024)
ClaraZara1
 

Recently uploaded (20)

NO1 Uk best vashikaran specialist in delhi vashikaran baba near me online vas...
NO1 Uk best vashikaran specialist in delhi vashikaran baba near me online vas...NO1 Uk best vashikaran specialist in delhi vashikaran baba near me online vas...
NO1 Uk best vashikaran specialist in delhi vashikaran baba near me online vas...
 
Industrial Training at Shahjalal Fertilizer Company Limited (SFCL)
Industrial Training at Shahjalal Fertilizer Company Limited (SFCL)Industrial Training at Shahjalal Fertilizer Company Limited (SFCL)
Industrial Training at Shahjalal Fertilizer Company Limited (SFCL)
 
space technology lecture notes on satellite
space technology lecture notes on satellitespace technology lecture notes on satellite
space technology lecture notes on satellite
 
English lab ppt no titlespecENG PPTt.pdf
English lab ppt no titlespecENG PPTt.pdfEnglish lab ppt no titlespecENG PPTt.pdf
English lab ppt no titlespecENG PPTt.pdf
 
Unbalanced Three Phase Systems and circuits.pptx
Unbalanced Three Phase Systems and circuits.pptxUnbalanced Three Phase Systems and circuits.pptx
Unbalanced Three Phase Systems and circuits.pptx
 
Immunizing Image Classifiers Against Localized Adversary Attacks
Immunizing Image Classifiers Against Localized Adversary AttacksImmunizing Image Classifiers Against Localized Adversary Attacks
Immunizing Image Classifiers Against Localized Adversary Attacks
 
14 Template Contractual Notice - EOT Application
14 Template Contractual Notice - EOT Application14 Template Contractual Notice - EOT Application
14 Template Contractual Notice - EOT Application
 
Student information management system project report ii.pdf
Student information management system project report ii.pdfStudent information management system project report ii.pdf
Student information management system project report ii.pdf
 
AKS UNIVERSITY Satna Final Year Project By OM Hardaha.pdf
AKS UNIVERSITY Satna Final Year Project By OM Hardaha.pdfAKS UNIVERSITY Satna Final Year Project By OM Hardaha.pdf
AKS UNIVERSITY Satna Final Year Project By OM Hardaha.pdf
 
Water Industry Process Automation and Control Monthly - May 2024.pdf
Water Industry Process Automation and Control Monthly - May 2024.pdfWater Industry Process Automation and Control Monthly - May 2024.pdf
Water Industry Process Automation and Control Monthly - May 2024.pdf
 
在线办理(ANU毕业证书)澳洲国立大学毕业证录取通知书一模一样
在线办理(ANU毕业证书)澳洲国立大学毕业证录取通知书一模一样在线办理(ANU毕业证书)澳洲国立大学毕业证录取通知书一模一样
在线办理(ANU毕业证书)澳洲国立大学毕业证录取通知书一模一样
 
HYDROPOWER - Hydroelectric power generation
HYDROPOWER - Hydroelectric power generationHYDROPOWER - Hydroelectric power generation
HYDROPOWER - Hydroelectric power generation
 
Cosmetic shop management system project report.pdf
Cosmetic shop management system project report.pdfCosmetic shop management system project report.pdf
Cosmetic shop management system project report.pdf
 
NUMERICAL SIMULATIONS OF HEAT AND MASS TRANSFER IN CONDENSING HEAT EXCHANGERS...
NUMERICAL SIMULATIONS OF HEAT AND MASS TRANSFER IN CONDENSING HEAT EXCHANGERS...NUMERICAL SIMULATIONS OF HEAT AND MASS TRANSFER IN CONDENSING HEAT EXCHANGERS...
NUMERICAL SIMULATIONS OF HEAT AND MASS TRANSFER IN CONDENSING HEAT EXCHANGERS...
 
DfMAy 2024 - key insights and contributions
DfMAy 2024 - key insights and contributionsDfMAy 2024 - key insights and contributions
DfMAy 2024 - key insights and contributions
 
Final project report on grocery store management system..pdf
Final project report on grocery store management system..pdfFinal project report on grocery store management system..pdf
Final project report on grocery store management system..pdf
 
Hybrid optimization of pumped hydro system and solar- Engr. Abdul-Azeez.pdf
Hybrid optimization of pumped hydro system and solar- Engr. Abdul-Azeez.pdfHybrid optimization of pumped hydro system and solar- Engr. Abdul-Azeez.pdf
Hybrid optimization of pumped hydro system and solar- Engr. Abdul-Azeez.pdf
 
block diagram and signal flow graph representation
block diagram and signal flow graph representationblock diagram and signal flow graph representation
block diagram and signal flow graph representation
 
Fundamentals of Electric Drives and its applications.pptx
Fundamentals of Electric Drives and its applications.pptxFundamentals of Electric Drives and its applications.pptx
Fundamentals of Electric Drives and its applications.pptx
 
6th International Conference on Machine Learning & Applications (CMLA 2024)
6th International Conference on Machine Learning & Applications (CMLA 2024)6th International Conference on Machine Learning & Applications (CMLA 2024)
6th International Conference on Machine Learning & Applications (CMLA 2024)
 

Considering part orientation in design for additive manufacturing

  • 1. Available online at www.sciencedirect.com 2212-8271 © 2016 Published by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/). Peer-review under responsibility of the organizing committee of the 26th CIRP Design Conference doi:10.1016/j.procir.2016.05.016 Procedia CIRP 50 (2016) 408 – 413 ScienceDirect 26th CIRP Design Conference Considering Part Orientation in Design for Additive Manufacturing Bastian Leutenecker-Twelsieka,* , Christoph Klahnb , Mirko Meboldta aETH Z¨urich, Leonhardstrasse 21, 8092 Z¨urich, Switzerland bInspire AG, Leonhardstrasse 21, 8092 Z¨urich, Switzerland ∗ Corresponding author. Tel.: +41-44-633-83-87. E-mail address: bleutenecker@ethz.ch Abstract Additive Manufacturing (AM) is established not only in prototyping, but also in serial production of end-use products. To use the full potential of the production technology the restrictions of current additive manufacturing processes (like support structures in Selective Laser Melting) must be considered in the design process. Especially the compliance with design rules from early design stages on is important in AM serial production, due to production quantities and the resulting scale effect. The part orientation in the build space has a strong influence on many quality characteristics. In order to use the full potential and to consider the restrictions from the start, a design guideline is necessary to support the whole design process. For this purpose, this paper presents a framework for design guidelines. The framework distinguishes between process characteristics, design principles and design rules; each supporting the designer during different stages of the design process. Furthermore, the paper examines the influence of part orientation in existing design rules and elaborates its importance. Based on this result, the design principle ”early determination of part orientation” is presented, which includes a process for determining the part orientation in early stage of the design process. In addition, a design process for additive manufactured parts is demonstrated on an extensive showcase, following the guideline framework and including the principle for early determination of part orientation. The presented framework proved to be helpful in the design process and will be used in the future to collect more process characteristics, design principles and rules. c 2016 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V. Selection and peer-review under responsibility of Professor Lihui Wang. Keywords: Part Orientation; Additive Manufacturing; Design Process; Design for Additive Manufacturing 1. Introduction Additive Manufacturing (AM), or 3D printing - as it is re- ferred to in the media, is a group of manufacturing technolo- gies which produces three-dimensional objects by adding ma- terial, usually in a layer by layer process. In the beginning of the manufacturing technologies in the 1980th, the first applica- tions were the production of prototypes. During the following decades the manufacturing technology and materials evolved and nowadays, new fields of application are possible. Additive Manufacturing processes are technologically ma- ture for industrial production and due to a sufficient process stability and a rising competition between service providers [1] Additive Manufacturing becomes economically feasible for a growing number of industrial and end-user applications [2]. Today there are many different Additive Manufacturing pro- cesses available, some of which are capable of serial direct part production. Nowadays, processes like Selective Laser Melting (SLM), Selective Laser Sintering (SLS) and, with some limita- tions, Fused Deposition Modeling (FDM) are used to produce end-user parts. The possibility for serial direct part production brought new challenges for industries. To implement new production tech- nologies, companies have to identify suitable parts for AM [3]. Furthermore, the new production process created new possibil- ities but also new restrictions to the design. Unlocking the de- sign potential of AM is a big challenge, because of the tradition and fixed mind-sets of experienced designers and of course due to the lack of knowledge on the new technology [4,5]. Introducing a new way of thinking to designers can be achieved through design guidelines and training. In particular, it is difficult to obtain support for the designers in terms of de- sign guidelines and design rules of AM. At the moment design rules are mostly presented in academic publications for an aca- demic target audience. There is a challenge to develop a design guideline for AM which can be used in industry and is based on industrial experience. 2. Design Guideline The knowledge needed for a good design for a specific appli- cation is complex and multi-facetted. The different publications of design rules for AM are usually driven scientifically [5] and follow a systematic scientific structure which doesn’t necessar- ily match the workflow of practitioners. To implement AM Design in the industry, a user-centered structure of the design guideline is necessary to assist the de- 2212-8271 c 2016 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V. Selection and peer-review under responsibility of Professor Lihui Wang. © 2016 Published by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/). Peer-review under responsibility of the organizing committee of the 26th CIRP Design Conference
  • 2. 409Bastian Leutenecker-Twelsiek et al. / Procedia CIRP 50 (2016) 408 – 413 signer in product development and to overcome reservations against novel production methods. Therefore, the presented de- sign guideline follows product development respectively design process. A design process can be roughly divided into the stages of task clarification, conceptual design, embodiment design and final design [6,7]. The tasks in each of these stages require a different kind of guidelines to support designers. Based on the needs along the process, the design guideline is divided into three areas: process characteristics, design principles and de- sign rules. These are not exclusively assigned to the individual stages but are rather aligned with the developer’s needs. The multitude of AM processes and materials makes the de- velopment of a generic design guideline for all feasible com- binations of processes and materials an impossible task, if it is intended to have any practical use [5]. Therefore, the pre- sented design guidelines primarily focus on AM processes for the production of end-user parts, especially on SLS, SLM and FDM. The presented process characteristics, design principles and design rules can be applied to individual processes or even to Additive Manufacturing in general. For reasons of simplicity, this publication focuses primarily on SLM processes. 2.1. Process Characteristics The process characteristics summarize the basic knowledge on the working principle of a process for the design and should be known to the designer if he wants to design AM compo- nents. They describe the characteristics conditioned by the pro- cess which have an impact on the design, and, therefore, must be taken into account for the design of AM components. They illustrate the specifics of the process. Thus, for example, the stair-step effect is explained and the need for support structures. The basics on process features of different AM technologies are already available in the literature and can be derived respec- tively prepared therefrom [2,8]. 2.2. Design Principles Design principles support the designer to transfer a principle solution into a specific, manufacturable design. They enable the developer to exploit AM’s freedom of design and to circum- vent existing AM constraints creatively. The design principles can range from simple notes to cut costs to recommendations which largely impact the design of parts. They also give in- structions to increase part quality or to reduce manufacturing costs respectively post processing effort. Like in design principles for conventional manufacturing a trade-off between conflicting principles may be needed [9]. In such a case, the designer has to rate the impact and decide which principle is more important to the overall objective of the design. Design principles are rarely found in literature as they are often based on experiences of developers. There are a few case studies on good AM designs, but those usually don’t provide enough background information to extract and refine the expe- rience of the designer from the part design. 2.3. Design Rules The design rules cover the necessary characteristic facts and figures for designers to design manufacturable components for the AM process. These design rules depend on the chosen man- ufacturing process, material, machine and machine parameters. Initial reference values for designing parts can be taken from the literature. However for a specific design the characteristic val- ues of the chosen production system are necessary and a com- munication with the workshop is essential. The design rules includes such values as minimum wall thickness or roughness information which depend on the machine and process param- eters. 3. Part Orientation Part orientation describes the rotation of the part in the build space around the axes of the machine’s coordinate system [10]. The term excludes a translation of the part along the coordinate axes of the machine’s coordinate system during part positioning [10]. 3.1. Significance of Part Orientation for Design Based on the layer by layer manufacturing process there is a difference between the part geometry in building direction (typ- ically the z-direction of the machine’s coordinate system) and the geometry orthogonal to the building direction. The orthog- onal shape is produced almost continuous while the part pro- duction in build direction is discontinuous in discrete steps of one layer thickness. Furthermore some AM processes require support structures in build direction and the design has influ- ence on the component warping. Therefore the impact of part orientation on the design of the part is significant. The importance of part orientation is reflected in an analysis of already published design rules. Adam published a design rule catalog to support suitable designs for AM with 55 design rules [11]. The design rules are developed for SLS, FDM and SLM based on a process independent method for developing design rules for AM [12]. In preparation of this contribution we analyzed and classified the design rules of Adam for direct, indirect or no dependence of the part orientation. Design rules with direct request for ori- entation are added to the direct dependence design rules. The design rules which need a specific orientation to be applicable are classified as indirect dependence design rules. For exam- ple the rule on inner radius in simple curved elements provides no instruction how to orientate the inner radius, but it states the minimal radius to build up horizontal holes without sup- port structure in SLM an FDM. Strictly speaking, this is no direct instruction to orientate the element but a dependence on the orientation is clearly stated. Therefore this rule is added to the indirect dependent design rules. The design rule analysis of Selective Laser Sintering (SLS) shows that over 55% are direct or indirect dependent on the orientation. For SLM and FDM 70% of the design rules depend on part orientation, see Fig. 1.
  • 3. 410 Bastian Leutenecker-Twelsiek et al. / Procedia CIRP 50 (2016) 408 – 413 directly or indirectly depending on orientation not depending on orientation SLM SLS FDM 30% 30% 70%55% 45% 70% Fig. 1. Analysis results of design rule dependencies on part orientation 3.2. Quality Features for Part Orientation There is a variety of studies on the optimization of the part orientation in Additive Manufacturing. The first ones were car- ried out in the early stages of the technology in the 1990s years. In particular, for Stereolithography (SLA) there are a variety of publications [13,14]. Research [15–18] deals usually with existing part designs to be oriented in build space. The compo- nent orientation is set on the basis of different quality features. These quality features are dimensional accuracy, surface qual- ity, shape accuracy, building costs, building time, component warping, stability, support volume, utilization of building space, effort of post processing and accessibility of support structures [15]. The quality features listed here are all directly dependent on the geometry of the part. In common orientation strategies the part (after the final design) is rotated along the part’s coordinate axes to achieve an optimum of the quality features [19]. The result of such a multi-objective optimization is a compromise to balance the different quality features. 3.3. Design Principle: Early Determination of Part Orienta- tion This previous work demonstrates the importance of the ori- entation in the build space for the quality of the produced part. Nevertheless the work was limited on orienting a given final part design. We propose a new principle to determine the orien- tation at an early stage of the design process. The early deter- mination the orientation before the final design allows changes to the shape to improve the quality characteristics. The design principle early determination of the part orienta- tion states that the orientation should be determined before the final design of the part begins. This allows the designer to base his design on this decision and bypass or avoid certain process restrictions by an appropriate design. This principle has a high impact on the part design. This is especially true for AM processes like SLM because of the necessary support structure, component warping and orienta- tion depending surface quality. The high number of orienta- tion depending design rules highlights this. The impact of the early orientation and application of common design rules is il- lustrated by a simple part with same functions and two different orientations in Fig. 2. The challenge here is the determination of part orientation despite an uncertainty due to the early stage of design process. Fig. 2. Impact of part orientation on the final design 3.4. Process to Determine the Part Orientation To assist the designer with the challenge of an early deter- mination of the part orientation, the procedure depicted in Fig. 3 was developed. It is based on dividing the concept design of the part into several design elements and analyzing these sep- arately. In this analysis the orientation’s effects on the quality features of the elements are evaluated. Subsequently the rele- vance of each element to the part function is rated to quantify the impact of part orientation. The orientation of the part is determined based on this rating. In the first step of the process depicted in Fig. 3 the concept of the part is decomposed into design elements. Here a design element is an individual or a meaningful combination of active surfaces designated to fulfill a function in the component. An example of a design element is a thread with a clamping surface or the contact surfaces of an attachment. The next step assesses whether a particular orientation of the design element has a significant influence on the quality feature. If not, the design element can be neglected in the orientation of the part. If the element has an influence, then the designer must determine the optimal positioning of the design element for the quality feature. This can cause orientation conflicts between the different quality characteristics, e.g. one orientation results in a better surface roughness while the other reduces the risk of warping. Here, the designer has to specify which quality fea- ture should be given higher priority and therefore determines the orientation of the design element. In our experience a re- view of all quality features for each design element is highly time-consuming and often unnecessary. A reduction of scope to quality features with a high impact in the early design phase is quite useful to reduce the workload. We analyzed the orientation processes of about twenty parts to identify necessary quality features. Based on this analysis we reduced the quality features to the following relevant ones: sur- face quality, dimensional stability, component distortion, sup- port structure and building height. This set of quality features allows determining the part orientation in an early design phase when no detailed part design is available. Based on best individual orientations of each element the overall part orientation is determined. The design elements are weighted according to their importance for the function of the component. It is likely that additional effort in post-processing is needed when the design element is not positioned accord- ing to its optimum orientation. Furthermore, the number of de- sign elements lying in a similar orientation is important here, since the effort of post-processing can increase significantly if their orientation is not taken into account. The designer has to
  • 4. 411Bastian Leutenecker-Twelsiek et al. / Procedia CIRP 50 (2016) 408 – 413 part concept design part final design design elements decompose global orientation of part 69 z 7 z z analyze each design element and determin best orientation design elements with orientation design elements with no impact on part orientation rate relevance of design elements for part orientation adapt design to quality features Fig. 3. Process for defining part orientation in early design stage consider in this step the entire part design also and whether an adjustment of the orientation is possible by a redesign of indi- vidual design elements. 4. Application to Design Process and Case Study The design process of components for Additive Manufac- turing is no different from the basic design process for con- ventional components as documented in VDI 2221 [7]. The designer rather has to pay attention to the process-specific de- sign principles. In particular, the design principles of function- oriented design and the early determination of the part orienta- tion have great influence on the result of the design process. 4.1. Application in the Design Process The developer must of course know the process character- istics of Additive Manufacturing before he enters the design process. In the first, task clarification phase of design process, there is no difference to conventional design. In the second, conceptual design phase, during the deter- mination of functions and development of a principal solution there is also no difference. However, it should be noted that it has been shown in many cases that a very strict applied func- tion abstraction away from the component geometry is useful. This abstraction makes it easier for the designer to leave exist- ing, conventional manufacturing constraints and enable him to develop principle solutions, which use the design advantage of Additive Manufacturing. In this phase of the design process, it is necessary to know about the design principles of AM to en- sure a good and adapted product design. After the second phase there is a principal solution which fulfills all the specifications. We refer to this principal solution or design concept as ideal- design, because it is an ideal solution for all functions which fulfills the specifications without any restrictions of a manufac- turing process. In the third, the conceptual design phase, the ideal-design is transferred into a feasible-design, which is producible by AM and following post-processing. In this phase the design princi- ples become very important, because they support the designer in the transfer and help to reduce cost and enhance quality. The principle of early determination of the part orientation achieves this by minimizing the limitations and restrictions of the pro- duction process like support structure or component distortion. Therefore, the ideal design can be divided into design elements and the build orientation is determined on this basis using the process presented here. In the fourth, the final design phase, the feasible-design is prepared. This step is supported by the design rules for AM with characteristic variables for design elements. 4.2. Case Study To illustrate the described design process and in particular the procedure for part orientation a case study is presented be- low. It involves a so-called laser cutting head of a laser cutter. The laser cutter is used to cut or engrave panels of organic mate- rials such as wood (medium-density fiberboard) or acrylic with a CO2 Laser. The laser cutting head is guided on a movable axis and has the function to hold the deflection mirror and the focus lens. The bottom of the lens is purged by compressed air to prevent contamination due to the resulting sublimation dust. The goal of the redesign of the laser cutting head is to improve the cleaning effect on the bottom of the lens by optimizing the air outlet [20]. In addition a compressed air cleaning of the top of the lens and the deflection mirror was implemented. The lens holder is to be produced by SLM in AlSi12. At the beginning of the design process, the environment and the design space are set. For this all the interfaces of the system laser cutting head and the predetermined functional areas are specified in the CAD-model depicted in Fig. 4a. a b v m/s[ ] 0 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 Fig. 4. Fix arrangements (a) flow simulation for compressed air flush (b) Subsequently, solutions have been developed for the opti- mized cleaning of the mirror and of the lens using CFD. The results of the optimization are shown in Fig. 4b. The results from the simulation and function areas of the air duct for clean- ing have been included in the CAD model. For a better view, and thus improved division into shape elements all functional surfaces were coated with a material thickness of 1 mm, result- ing in the ideal-design of the laser cutting head in Fig. 5. Here, the design principle of function-oriented design has been taken into account. In the further procedure, the part is
  • 5. 412 Bastian Leutenecker-Twelsiek et al. / Procedia CIRP 50 (2016) 408 – 413 a b Fig. 5. Ideal-design of internal (a) and external (b) geometry elements oriented by applying the design principle early determination of the part orientation. It begins with the dismantling into design elements. Subsequently the design elements are analyzed and the orientation is determined. To illustrate the process presented here three design elements of the laser cutting head are exemplarily discussed. • The first group of elements is the mirror mounting sur- face with the threads of screws, Fig. 5b No. 1. A suffi- cient surface quality and dimensional accuracy is required to position the mirror correctly. The SLM process is not able to meet the requirements of both quality features de- spite optimal positioning. Therefore, post-processing of the mounting surface and threads is necessary. This will also remove any support structure if it is not already omit- ted by a suitable positioning. The building height is irrel- evant due to the almost cubic body proportions relative to the total component. In summary the necessary post pro- cessing of the design elements makes the orientation of this group no longer relevant for part orientation. • The second group of elements are the guide rails for the lens element, Fig. 5b No. 2. The achievable surface qual- ity is sufficient for fulfilling the functions. The dimen- sional stability is in all orientations also sufficient. The possible component distortion of this design element is the limit, therefore is an orientation parallel to the build direc- tion is preferred. In this orientation support structures are avoided at the rails. Since the removal of support struc- tures from the guide rails is very tedious, this has a high priority on the orientation. The building height is negligi- ble in relation to the overall size of the part. • The third and last design element discussed in this exam- ple is the channel for the air, Fig. 5 No. 3. Both sur- face quality and dimensional accuracy are sufficient for the channel’s function. Due to its small diameter between 1-5 mm internal support structures are not required. Through the integration of the channel in the component distortion and component height are irrelevant. Therefore the layout element is not relevant to the component orientation. In summary the design elements of the guide rails of the lens frame and the high demands on the design element of the mounting surface and the positioning- and screw holes are de- cisive for the orientation of the part in the build chamber. The consideration of the overall component in respect of component distortion and part height reinforce the decision to orientate the laser cutting head in lying position with parallel to the build- ing direction orientated guide rails for the lens holder. Since a thread needs to be cut on the lens-side beam path, the removal of the necessary support structure is negligible. The beam path at the entrance on the other hand does not have to be reworked and has a certain flexibility in the design. Therefore, the support structures in the beam entrance can be avoided by an adjustment of its shape. Finally some minor adjustments are done to avoid support- ing structures and to follow all the design rules for the process and the material to meet specifications, creating the feasible- design of the laser cutting head. In Fig. 6a, the feasible design is shown on the produced laser cutting head with all attachments during action in Fig. 6b. a b Fig. 6. Feasible-design (a) and additive manufactured part with assembled com- ponents (b) 5. Conclusion The continuous development of AM increases the applica- tion fields for these technologies. In particular, advances in the areas of materials, part quality, process stability and reduced manufacturing costs extended the use of AM from prototyping to the production of end-use parts in series production. To a designer the very different characteristics of processes and parts are a major challenge in unlocking the design po- tential of AM. To address this current lack of experience and implement design knowledge in industry, a user-centered de- sign guideline for designers is developed. It consists of process characteristics, design principles and design rules to support the designer in the design phase of conceptual design, embodiment design and final design. One of these design principles is presented here. The princi- ple of the early determination of the part orientation is of high relevance particularly in the construction of SLM parts. There- fore, an approach was presented to determine the part orienta- tion in the early stage of the design based on the ideal-design. In this approach, the part is decomposed in design elements which are analyzed. This enables early determination of part orienta- tion and thus sets the basis for the transfer of the ideal-designs into a feasible design. The presented design guideline will provide a proper guid- ance for designers to use the design advantage of Additive Man- ufacturing for serial products. The awareness for defining the
  • 6. 413Bastian Leutenecker-Twelsiek et al. / Procedia CIRP 50 (2016) 408 – 413 part orientation in an early design stage will help to avoid de- sign iterations and post processing. The presented framework of process characteristics, design principles, design guidelines will be used in future works to provide the necessary design knowledge in a structured way. Further steps are a quantitative validation and the development of additional principles. The framework is applicable to other AM technologies and can be extended beyond the processes of FDM, SLS and SLM. References [1] M. Baldinger, A. Duchi, Price benchmark of laser sintering service providers, in: High Value Manufacturing: Advanced Research in Virtual and Rapid Prototyping: Proceedings of the 6th International Conference on Advanced Research in Virtual and Rapid Prototyping, Leiria, Portugal, 2013, pp. 37 – 42. [2] A. Gebhardt, Understanding additive manufacturing : Rapid Prototyping - Rapid Tooling - Rapid Manufacturing, 1st Edition, Hanser, Munich, 2012. [3] C. Klahn, B. Leutenecker, M. Meboldt, Design for additive manufacturing - supporting the substitution of components in series products, Procedia CIRP 21 (2014) 138 – 143. [4] N. Hopkinson, R. Hague, P. Dickens (Eds.), Rapid Manufacturing: An Industrial Revolution for the Digital Age, 1st Edition, J. Wiley, Chichester, 2006. [5] T. Wohlers, T. Caffrey (Eds.), Wohlers Report 2015 - Additive Manufac- turing and 3D Printing State of the Industry - Annual Worldwide Progress Report, Wohlers Associates, Fort Collins, CO, 2015. [6] G. Pahl, K. Wallace, Engineering design: A systematic approach, 3rd Edi- tion, Springer, London, 2007. [7] VDI 2221, Methodik zum Entwickeln und Konstruieren technischer Sys- teme und Produkte, Beuth, Berlin, 1993. [8] VDI 3405, Additive manufacturing processes, rapid manufacturing - Ba- sics, definitions, processes, Beuth, Berlin, 2014. [9] P. Naefe, Einf¨uhrung in das Methodische Konstruieren: F¨ur Studium und Praxis, 2nd Edition, Springer Vieweg, Wiesbaden, 2012. [10] VDI 3405 Part 3, Additive manufacturing processes, rapid manufacturing - Design rules for part production using laser sintering and laser beam melt- ing, Beuth, Berlin, 2015. [11] G. Adam, Systematische Erarbeitung von Konstruktionsregeln f¨ur die ad- ditiven Fertigungsverfahren Lasersintern, Laserschmelzen und Fused De- position Modeling, 1st Edition, Shaker, Aachen, 2015. [12] G. Adam, D. Zimmer, Design for additive manufacturingelement transi- tions and aggregated structures, CIRP Journal of Manufacturing Science and Technology 1 (2014) 20 – 28. [13] J. Hur, K. Lee, Determination of optimal build-up direction for stereolitho- graphic rapid prototyping, Journal of the Korean Society for Precision En- gineering 4 (1996) 163 – 173. [14] N. Pududhai, D. Dutta, Determination of optimal orientation based on variable slicing thickness in layered manufacturing, Technical report UM- MEAM-94-14, Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, 1994. [15] S. Danjou, Mehrzieloptimierung der Bauteilorientierung f¨ur Anwendungen der Rapid-Technologie, 1st Edition, Cuvillier, G¨ottingen, 2010. [16] G. Moroni, W. Syam, S. Petr, Functionality-based part orientation for ad- ditive manufacturing, CIRP 25th Design Conference Innovative Product Creation 36 (2015) 217 – 222. [17] P. Pandey, N. Venkata Reddy, S. Dhande, Part deposition orientation stud- ies in layered manufacturing, Journal of Materials Processing Technology 1 - 3 (2007) 125 – 131. [18] S. Singhal, P. Jain, P. Pandey, A. Nagpal, Optimum part deposition ori- entation for multiple objectives in SL and SLS prototyping, International Journal of Production Research 22 (2009) 6375 – 6396. [19] S. Danjou, P. K¨ohler, Determination of optimal build direction for differ- ent rapid prototyping applications, in: Proceedings of the 14th European Forum on Rapid Prototyping, Paris, 2009. [20] M. Meboldt, C. Klahn, Produktentwicklung mit digitalisierten Technolo- gien: Wertsch¨opfung durch 3D-gedruckte Serienbauteile im Maschinen- bau, IM+io 1 (2015) 83 – 89.