1. Prof. Makarem discusses a student paper and provides feedback over multiple pages. 2. The feedback addresses the structure, analysis, and arguments within the paper. Suggestions are made to strengthen sections and support claims. 3. In the final paragraph, Prof. Makarem encourages the student to revise the paper based on the feedback and to schedule a meeting to further discuss the improvements.

1. Prof. Makarem 1

2. ! !" %& '() * +!
#$
"* " + ,'
! " # #
-
$ % " & '
. /" ( !
(
) " . /" ( ,'
" & &
! 0
! " # " #
S
. +
. !
. / +
. + ,'
. /" ( !
1 & ,'
. /" ( ! & !
. /" ( ,' " #
( & 2 . /" ( ,'
" / 0 Prof. Makarem 2

3. 6 "* " + ,'
. / +
. /" ( !
0 ",
. /" ( ,'
& ! " #
0
! " # # $3 /
$ 4 5) " & !
" # 3
6 / 2 +4 5
7 /" ( !4 % 5
7 /" ( ,' 4 Prof. Makarem
53

4. . / 80 9 8 " : ,( ; !'(&, * &, - 46
" " 5
/ $ "* " " ( " " # ,/ < "
# !$. / 01 * 01 ! 2& 3#& 4 &$(" 5 $6 '$5 7
'" ! 58
6
( ( " : ,( ( 9
# " = " (
( = ", > # " !
Prof. Makarem 4

5. " +
! " #
. / +
& . / + (
! " #
. /" ( ,' . /" ( !
0
0 +4. 53
7 " ? ( "* " '# ' = $ / * # /
2 +%
@ " & ( = ", > # " !
0 + ( " !' # + ( " +
A ; = ( =
; @ " B < ; : / " ( " & +
C " D
Prof. Makarem 5

6. . / 2 +
0 +
. / +
. / + (
. /" ( !
. /" ( ,'
7
. / 2 +
8 + -
. /" ( !
. /" ( ,'
" &2 +
& ! " #
Prof. Makarem 6

7. . / 2
+ 0 ! '(
'#
+ < "@ /
-
" ( " = "* "
8 + ,/ / ( / +
. /" (
!
. / + ( 9 (
. / +
A ! '( + C
& + / (
" +
. / 2 " ( (
+ . / + " !' # ?
( + ( ( "
. / +
8 +
+
. /" (
!
. /" ( ,'
Prof. Makarem 7

8. . / +
(
8 +
-
. / + " &2
+
. /" (
!
. /" (
,'
( ! ( =
" # # ! ! @ =
E@ F.@GHE.I @9 J 8 L.I '#
K
( $ ( &
Prof. Makarem 8

9. . / 2 + . 5 ;,'/
4M / " ( " ,( 7
" ( " " = 3
62 " = 3 / " ( "
72 " = +
3 / " ( "
# & ! " #
7 /" ( ! / " ( "
# & ! " #
7 /" ( ,' / " ( "
# & ! " #
Prof. Makarem 9

10. ,/ " : # $ % # " #
,+ = ",
Prof. Makarem 10

11. I ,+ =
", N ( O # " !7
@ / +
"'/ " ( "'/ ' /" ( !@
/ + (
,/ "'/ # / + ( /" (
! / ,/ ! / # " ( ! ( !
!@ < "" +' & !
" #
. / 2 +
. / + (
. / +
8 +
. /" ( !
. /" ( ,'
Prof. Makarem 11

12. 8 ( ,' ( !
,' ( & " & "* "
" ( "; = ! #
$
" "* " " ( "
,/ "'/ #
; = # /
" ( ,' '# $
" D ,+
" "'# ! ,' (
P " / "
M
Prof. Makarem 12

13. ? / + (
;,'/ < "
' /" ( !
'# 6 " 4 5
/ ( " !
"
Prof. Makarem 13

14. QR &2 + " : ,( & " ?
( "* " & 4 5 #
'# ( " &2 +
" ? ( ( / " ( " & !
: ! $
; " " # / *
(; ( !
,/ " " ( @ ! :
! ( ;,'/ " ! ( / " ( "
&2 +
Prof. Makarem 14

15. S = ! # ( "* " / " ( " &
4 !" #
0 ; / & # " @ &2 + :
;
( " ,' '# " ( " ( #
" +
$% & ' ( ( ) *
S ! "@ & " = " ! ;,'/ " " !
?; * " / + "
Prof. Makarem 15

16. Prof. Makarem 16

17. ! !" %& '() ! # &,1 0#
#$
T ( = ", U # " ! @ ! " # #
- ; = " :
, ( - ! ! * #"* " " ( " ) " " 6
V ( '# ? ! " 6
" ( " !' # ( (
A ; = C '# :
,/ " : # " ( ,' B :
; ! -
. / +
. / + (
0 ( 9
(
Prof. Makarem 17

18. ! !" & '() 9 * *#$:&,
#$% 10
" / + "'/ " @ " / " ( "6
; / " ( !4 % 5
;1 & ,# & 0* !" & ! 1 ! 0& 3
$<
62 ." ! 4# 5
72 " = ,' # " ( ! ( ,' ,' ,
V2 T ( & ! "
G80 ' >1 ,#
." !
W ? 1
T ! ,#
"
T ",
S,'( " 4
"'/ T ; +
" "'/ " 5
Prof. Makarem 18

19. ! !" %& '() 9 0* *#$:&,
#$ 1 &,
7 ; / 3
. (" " / -! !
0" / #
. (" " -
1 2 !
/ #
X * " "* " " ( " - ; = (
= ", U # " ! (" ( ( =
", 67 4U222222 67 5
I ; / ) / ( ,( = ", Y
" ; ; = = ", Z 4Y 222222 Z5
Prof. Makarem 19

20. 10* *#$:&, &,(=$<
&, & !
S = = ", Y # " ! (
@ &
! " " / " : ,+
4 5 - ; = "
: ,( >1 & ,# & 0* !" & '() ? 8
$<
W ; = @; / ( ;,'/ / " ( "
,/ "'/ # / +
T ( & ! " / " ( " " =
,' # %,' " ( !
. "[ ,' , ' & " = " # #
" : '# ,'( ,'# " ( "
47 / + @@@@ ; / " (
! @@@@@@@@@ ( & !
" 5
Prof. Makarem 20

21. 8 + . / + ( 9
T " + ,'
0 !
" &2 + . / + (
8 + 0 +
. / 2 +. / +
G & G &
. /" (
! . /" (
!
. / + "'/ . / +
" ' " ; + "'/ "
T ( & ! "
G80 ;
" :
" = ,' 80
S / " ( ! 21

22. 10* *#$:&, !
&, !
W ( ! " #
. "
# " : , 9 +
= T "
A - ; = " : +
!( 2& ! A '() 1< ,( 7
# G
& 0
" ! '# & ,( " :
$ # /" (
W,'+
!
. / +
." ,( $ # / 80
4 / " : # / 805
W,'+
22

23. . " +
T " +
0
W,'+
" :
W ; = @ / " : ( "
" : 4 $ % $ " !
"P ,' '# ? ! ,'+
Prof. Makarem 23

24. $ - #
. +
"* " @ 9 I . / ,+
.,'
! !
. / " + TB P
,+ G & W !
2 "'/ ,'
W,'+ ,'
T " +
. / (
0 ", 1 +" !
2 . /
- ,' ,+
T " + . /
(
. /" ( !
T " +
W,'+ . / " ( . / (
,'
24

25. + 0 ",
." !
T " + .,' T ( &
G,' ; " "
: / 80 T ( &
. / ( " "
. /
(
/
G
8 ( ,'
&
0" - ! I " :
T " + " : , ! !
G,' ; " .,'
: / 80
S,'(
. / ( ,+
; + "'/ " =
W,'+ W,'+ ( 25

26. T " +
. / " : #
/" ( !
W,'+
,/ " : # %,' " ( @ ,'+ '# !
,' ; " # "' ( " : % ,' "
0 = ", N 9 O # " ! /
@ ( (
( C "P ! ,'+
0,( ,( / ( & " ( "'/ /
$ " D ,+
Prof. Makarem 26

27. " +
T " +
" :
W,'+
G &
/ " : + "'/ ' " + (
" = # ( & ! "
T " + " : " ",' % ,' ,(
" = # & & ! ! "
,/ "'/ ,+ " + ( / " : -
; = '# "P ,' = ", Z (" (
" ( " '# "P ( = ", 67
Prof. Makarem 27

28. T " + . " +
T " +
W,'+ 0 W,'+ 0
T ( &
! "
T " + T " +
0 0
T " . " +
+
0
G
W,'+ & 0
W,'+
-
T ( &
! " 0
T "
0
+
28

29. I " :
. " +
T " +
+
; +
"'/ "
W,'+ G &
W,'+ (
" : " : (
( "'/ " ' " +
Prof. Makarem 29

30. . / ,+
G,' " : ,( ,(
( & ! ! !
" @ / " ( " " = . /" (
,' # %,' " ( !
!2 ' ", < ,#
. / #
S = "'( @%,' ( / 80
,( %,' " ( ! (
%,' " : (
/ ( ; : / " ( "
" : ,
" = # /
( " ! " %,'
Prof. Makarem 30

31. ! ! " = ,' 80
QR +
2 . /" ( !
" :
. / # /
80 ; +
"'/ "
W,'+ (
" '# & ) " # " + (
"'/ " ; : / " ( " =
." "* " # ;,'/ / ( ,'+ (
S,'( ,+ " : " :" & " ;,'( "'/
" # / " : (
Prof. Makarem 31

32. 1 < ,#
" = ,' 80
8 1 ,#
S,'( "' ,+
" = ,' " (
! ( /
. / # " (
!
G,' " :
32

33. B $ C) *1<D
# 0* $.'
3 4 " 5 6
" "'# ! ! ( " = ,' #
%,' " ( !
" "'# '# " : , ( " :
=
Prof. Makarem 33

34. !
I " :
,
=
W,'+ ( " "'# ,'+ (
" +
T " +
T ( &
! "
W ? ,#
1
T ( &
", "
T " +
34

35. & " # & & 6 ! & &
" "'# ! ,+ " "'# " $ " "'# !7 !
Prof. Makarem 35

36. " "'# !7
" "'# !6 !9
" "'# ,'+ ( !9 " ( "
" ( "6 " =
( &
" "'# ! " (
9 " "'# !6 !9
"6 " = 7 ! " ( " ( &
Prof. Makarem 36

37. Prof. Makarem 37

38. 38

39. E
.I HE]^ _ 83 WJ `^ a
8 01^