The document discusses action research. It states that action research involves:
1) Identifying an issue or problem in one's practice that needs to be addressed.
2) Involving coworkers or others as coresearchers to work through a cyclical process of planning action, taking action, observing the results, and reflecting on the process.
3) Using reflection on one cycle to plan further cycles of research, with the goal of bringing about positive changes in practice.
2. Action Research is useful for…
• Developing changes in classroom practice
• Managing effects of programme restructuring
• Developing new understandings of students or self as teacher
• Developing new professional relationships with colleagues and students
• Teaching a new process to the students
• Seeking a quantifiable answer (to what extent are portfolios an
appropriate assessment tool for nursery children?)
Week 9
Dissertation and Practice as Research
3. Questionnaires
Disadvantages
It is more difficult if you are not already skilled
to some extent in working collaboratively with
others
It is challenging, as you are seeking to effect
change as well as study it
It is demanding in terms of your own integrity
when describing results
Findings will be specific to that group and are
therefore unlikely to lead to generalisations
Workplace conditions tend to change for a
variety of reasons outside the researchers’
control.
Week 9
Dissertation and Practice as Research
Advantages
There are several different models to choose
from (see Hart and Bond, 1995)
It is useful for researching into the impact of
teaching delivery
It is useful for providing a chance to research
in a way that makes a difference to your own
workplace
It can give a sense of ‘shared ownership’ of
the research
It can develop reflective and team-working
skills
4. Action research is:
Practical as it involves making chance to practice
Theoretical as it is informed by theory and can generate new
insights
Collaborative as it encourages engagement with others in the
process
Reflexive as it requires practitioner researchers to keeps their own
knowledge, values, and professional activities under review
Contextual as it acknowledges institutional, national, historical and
societal influences
Week 9
Dissertation and Practice as Research
5. Steps involved in
action research
Identify issues or
challenges in
practice
Review possible
interventions and
select a course
of action
Implement
action
Collect data to
evaluate the
action
Reflect on
learning
Week 9
Dissertation and Practice as Research
6. Steps involved in action researcher
The researcher:
Identifies an issue or problem that needs to be resolved
Involves co-workers or other relevant people as co-researchers
Works as part of this group in a 5-stage cyclical process of (1)
identifying issue (2) planning for action (3) undertaking action (4)
observation (5) reflection
Uses the reflection on the first cycle to review how far the solution is
working, still pertinent or applicable to other contexts, and develop
the odea for further action through a second cycle of active research;
this might continue for many cycles
Week 9
Dissertation and Practice as Research
7. Steps involved in action researcher
The researcher:
Is part of the change process rather than an outside investigator
Devises ways of measuring the change that occurs as a result of the
action taken, evaluating its impact
Can utilise diverse research methods, as relevant to the project
Week 9
Dissertation and Practice as Research
8. Reflexivity
Reflexive practice
Looking at our own thinking and decision making and asking questions
Thinking about how we perceive and understand issues and situations
Keep our approaches, beliefs and ways of seeing the practice landscape
under review
Take our subjectivity into account as an important part of making meaning
from our findings
Week 9
Dissertation and Practice as Research
9. Data collection and interpretation
Methods
Semi-structured interviews
Observations
Reflections on your own practice
Focus groups
Informal interviews
Questionnaires
Artefacts (student assessment work or discussion posts)
Week 9
Dissertation and Practice as Research
10. Data collection and interpretation
Data collection
To enable practitioner researchers to assess the effectiveness of an intervention
“How do I…?” rather than hypothesis questions (“This will do that”)
Data analysis and interpretation
Should be aligned with the research methods and the research question
Open coding of interview transcripts to inform findings
Summarising key themes from interviews without transcription
Creating individual stories from each of the interviews by condensing the interviewees
words into a short summary narrative
Week 9
Dissertation and Practice as Research
11. Reliability
Action research is unlikely to produce consistent results through repeated
studies
Must still demonstrate quality and rigour
Trustworthiness (validity)
Transparency in design and reporting
Contribution to knowledge
Paradigmatic considerations (theoretical and practical – praxis-based
paradign)
Week 9
Dissertation and Practice as Research
12. Generalisations
Action research in about developing our practice in our context, rather
than creating generalisable rules for other practitioners
Relatability
Being explicit what has worked for us in our context will resonate with other
practitioners in theirs
Open up discussion and debate with others
Week 9
Dissertation and Practice as Research
13. Research questions
What issues are influencing my students’ success or experience? What
issues arise from student feedback? What areas of student performance
are of most concern?
After reflection or systematic self-review, what are my personal
development needs? What development areas fit with my career
aspirations?
What are the challenges that the face the institution or department? How
could my research contribute to these? What are the strategic priorities of
my institution?
What areas of practice do I find inherently interesting? What inspires me?
Week 9
Dissertation and Practice as Research