TataKelola dan KamSiber Kecerdasan Buatan v022.pdf
28.02.22 How to structure your research
1. How to structure your
research (and reference!)
DISSERTATION AND PRACTICE AS RESEARCH
Week
5
Dissertation
and
Practice
as
Research
2. Sections/Chapters
Research Projects – PaR/science-based/primary case-study research
• Tend to require research reports to be divided into sections, with the use of
plentiful clear heading and sub-headings
Arts/humanities theses – discursive/lit. based research/comparative/case-
study
• The core chapters develop your argument, each chapter investigating an
aspect of the overall topic.
Week 5
Dissertation and Practice as Research
4. Overall Project
To advance understanding of a
specific issue, building on what has
gone before, and laying groundwork
for future enquiry
Understand how knowledge is
constructed in your subject
Draw on what you have learnt already
on your course and integrate a broad
range of skills
Manage complexity, making sensible
decisions in an independent way, with
a good feel for when to ask for advice
Week 5
Dissertation and Practice as Research
5. Abstract
To summarise the key points of the
research project so that others can
decide quickly whether its worth
reading in full
To help others to search and browse
for relevant research
Can think clearly and precisely – and
can present that thought in writing
Can construct an abstract in the style
typical for our academic discipline
Week 5
Dissertation and Practice as Research
6. Title page/slide
To provide the title, author details,
date, submission details
Can set out your research in a
professional way, following instructions
Week 5
Dissertation and Practice as Research
7. Contents
To help the reader find each chapter,
section, appendix or table quickly and
easily
Can organise information clearly and
accurately, taking your reader into
account
Week 5
Dissertation and Practice as Research
8. Introduction
To provide contextual background such as
why the research was undertaken, what it
aims to achieve, and a rationale for the focus
or angle taken
For arts/humanities theses – the Introduction is
a larger section that provides the research
background, literature and methods (see next
slides)
Provide evidence of a broad background
understanding to your topic and write about
this in a way that avoids waffle or irrelevant
details
Make sensible judgements about what other
relatively academic readers, who are not
expert in your topic, would need to know as a
starting place for making sense of your
research
Present a reasoned case for undertaking the
research: that is has some purpose or
significance or addresses a relevant issue
Set the scene for the reader about what you
did, and why, without going into too much
detail that would be covered in the rest of the
report
Week 5
Dissertation and Practice as Research
9. Literature Review
For the researcher to be as informed as
possible about their specialism or area of
expertise
To ensure that the research is well
grounded in theory, methodology and
knowledge base of the subject
To ensure that their work is original and
hasn’t been covered by someone else
To make clear to the readers how their
research has made use of existing
sources of information – how these have
been interpreted for the purposes of this
research
Have researched widely into the
background of the subject
Select the right material and convey to
others its relevance to your research
Present previous research in a structured
way that shows the development of
understanding this issue
Week 5
Dissertation and Practice as Research
10. Methodology
Ensure ethical codes are adhered to
To inform the reader of the methodological
principles that inform the research
To help the reader to grasp the thinking
behind the research, so that they can form
their own conclusions about whether the
design was fit for purpose or contained some
flaws
Understand the methodological assumptions
and philosophies relevant to your subject
discipline
Understand the ethical considerations and
take these on board
Have thought through each aspect of your
research carefully to see that it is fir for
purpose
Have designed your project to be internally
consistent; the purpose, philosophy, methods
and conclusions are mutually supporting
Explain your methods fully, but briefly, with a
clear rationale for why you chose them. Don’t
account for why you haven’t chosen methods
that clearly would not be suitable for your
discipline/topic
Week 5
Dissertation and Practice as Research
11. Results
To inform the reader of the outcome of the
research (mainly for research presenting
quantitative or PaR data)
Data:
Present data and findings clearly and accurately,
using the best graphics
Identify the key findings rather than presenting
everything
Demonstrate integrity in presenting true results rather
than correcting the figures to improve a particular
point
Performance
Present performance work that clearly and
accurately relates to your research questions, using
appropriate creative and technical skills
Identify an extract of the performance or key
segments from performance practice
documentation
Demonstrate integrity in presenting appropriate
creative approaches to your enquiry in terms of form
and style
Week 5
Dissertation and Practice as Research
12. Discussion / Chapters
To draw out the significance of the findings
and what this means for understanding the
issue in the context of the field and/or brief
To evaluate the extent to which the results
can be used as the basis for generalisations
To evaluate the methodology
To draw out lessons about the potential
relevance of the research and where future
research might take the issue further
Describe your findings briefly, precisely and
with integrity
Interpret your own findings correctly
Evaluate appropriately the significance or
relevance of your findings and make that
clear to your reader
Evaluate your methods with a critical eye,
demonstrating that you understand what
worked or didn’t work as expected, why this
occurred, and what is likely to work better
Identify how future research could build on
your methods or findings, or take them in new
directions
Week 5
Dissertation and Practice as Research
13. Discussion / Chapters
For arts and humanities subjects, most of your chapters will consist of
discussion. Each will focus on a distinct part of your analysis of the
materials and your argument.
Divide the material into logical chapters. If relevant piece together the
findings emerging from the research and your interpretations of the
material.
Chapters tend to build your argument consider what your reader needs
to know first in order to understand the next key argument.
Chapters may be thematic rather than methods based
i.e. you might use interview data throughout the various chapters but each
chapter addresses a different key theme that emerged from the research
Week 5
Dissertation and Practice as Research
14. Discussion / Chapters
Before you commit to a linear structure, carry out a visual mapping of the
ideas and case studies that will form part of your dissertation research
Create a spider diagram or use coloured sticky notes to group ideas
together into clusters.
Then, move the ideas into a linear form, thinking about an order for the
material that creates through-lines of connection in the inquiry
Use that as a basis for discussion with your peers and tutor.
Week 5
Dissertation and Practice as Research
15. Conclusion
To draw together and summarise
thoughts about the research findings
and methods, and their significance
Understand which aspects are the
most significant to include, and
summarise these succinctly
Present these logically and coherently,
drawing on material you have
previously presented
Week 5
Dissertation and Practice as Research
16. Bibliography
To provide details of the material used as
background for the project, whether cited in
the text or not
Have read broadly around the subject, and
that your reading indicates a good
background knowledge of the field
Demonstrate through the rest of your report
that your breadth of knowledge and
understanding is consistent with the
bibliography
Based your research on previous work in your
field
Are able to draw appropriately on the work of
others
Can cite and reference sources correctly
Attribute work to others appropriately
Apply the correct conventions for referencing
sources
Week 5
Dissertation and Practice as Research
17. Appendices
To provide supporting details and
materials which, if included in the
main body of the report, would
interrupt its flow for the reader
Conducted the research yourself, as
the appendices are likely to reveal
copied data and material more easily
Collated and interpreted data
correctly
Produced materials that met ethical
and other guidelines and were fit for
purpose
Week 5
Dissertation and Practice as Research
18. Quotations
Quotations will be of two kinds:
Short (i.e. less than 40 words). These will appear in
single quotation marks within the main body of the
double spaced text, and correctly referenced using
the Harvard referencing system.
Long (quotation exceeding 40 words). These will be
indented, typed in single spacing, not in quotation
marks, and correctly referenced.
Week 5
Dissertation and Practice as Research
19. In-text citations
Cite them right - https://brum.beds.ac.uk/record=b1960744~S20
According to Bell (2014), the most important part of the research process is ...
Goddard and Barrett (2016, p. 17) noted that 'teenagers are vulnerable’.
This was proved by Young et al. (2015, pp. 21–23)…
In their review of the literature (Norrie et al., 2012)…
The most important part of the research process is “...” (Bell, 2014).
Name – Date – Page (where relevant)
Sentences should make sense when the bracketed material is removed.
Week 5
Dissertation and Practice as Research
20. Bibliographic References
Different format depending on type of resource and
Number of authors
Edition
Missing information like dates, etc.
Organisation/specific author(s)
Electronic/print
Cite them right - https://brum.beds.ac.uk/record=b1960744~S20
Week 5
Dissertation and Practice as Research