The Science of Warm-up, Stretching and Strengthening: Injury Prevention in Athletics
                                       Lindsay Morgan, PT, DPT, ATC
                                       Anne Arundel Medical Center
                                Comprehensive Outpatient Rehabilitation Center
Athletic Injuries
    • Muscle injuries represent >30% of injuries seen in sports medicine.
    • Widely accepted ways for athletes to prevent muscular injuries:
               ▫ Warm up
               ▫ Stretching
               ▫ Strengthening

Are we stretching the truth?
    • Various research studies offer different viewpoints regarding the effectiveness of warm-up and stretching
        protocols in reducing injuries.

Warm-up
   • Prior to all athletic activity
   • Designed to improve muscle dynamics, and increase core temperature without fatiguing the individual.
   • Warm up can be active or passive
   • Physiological Effects of Warm-up
          • Increase in speed and force of muscle contractions.
          • Increase in temperature leads to the increase of oxygen uptake, providing more oxygen to
               working muscles.
          • Speed of nerve transmission increases contraction speed and reduction of reaction time.
          • Vasodilation
   • Should be tailored to needs of the athlete
   • Intensity
          • 40-60% of VO2 max should be utilized to increase muscle temperature, while also limiting high-
               energy phosphate depletion.
          • >60% VO2 max has shown to have an inverse relationship between warm up and short term
               performance

Stretching
    • Therapeutic intervention to increase mobility of soft tissue with the goal of increasing range of motion
         (ROM).
    • Stretching is SPORTS SPECIFIC!
    • High intensity sports
             • Football, soccer, basketball
             • High intensity stretch-shortening cycles (SSC) require a muscle-tendon unit which is compliant
                  enough to store and release the high amount of elastic energy.
             • Insufficient compliant muscle-tendon units = demands in energy absorption and release may
                  exceed the capacity of the muscle-tendon unit = injury.
             • Stretching is important for injury prevention.
    • Low intensity sports
             • Jogging, cycling, and swimming
             • No need for a very compliant muscle-tendon unit
             • Most of power generation is a consequence of active contractile muscle work that needs to be
                  directly transferred (by the tendon) to the articular system to generate motion.
             • Stretching exercises to improve the compliance of the tendon may have no beneficial effect on
                  injury prevention.
Types of Stretching
    • Static
•   Slow, passive and deliberate movement. Stretch maintained for 20 seconds will facilitate
                  elongation.
    •    Dynamic
             • Whole body movements and involves actively and rhythmically contracting a muscle through
                 part of its functional ROM.
    •    Proprioceptive Neuromuscular Facilitation (PNF)
             • Static stretch, an isometric contraction, and relaxation, followed by a static stretch

                        Effects of Warm-up, and Stretching on Injury Prevention
Stretch or Not to Stretch?
    • Evidence suggests pre-exercise muscle stretching protocols do not produce meaningful reduction in risk of
         exercise-related injuries.
    • HOWEVER, basic science supports the notion that an active warm up might protect against muscle strain
         injury.
              ▫ Theoretically, warm up activities that enhance neural activation will better prepare muscles to
                  absorb loads.
              ▫ Muscles under active contraction absorb significantly more energy than muscles at rest.

Effects of Warm-up on Injury
    • Study by Bixler and Jones
              ▫ Examined # of injuries occurring during the 3rd quarter of HS football games
              ▫ Intervention and control group (warm-up and stretching program conducted at half-time)
              ▫ No significant difference in total number of 3rd quarter injuries between groups
              ▫ HOWEVER, intervention group experience fewer 3rd quarter sprains/strains per game over
                    season.
Effects of Static Stretching on Injury
    • Study by Hartig and Henderson
              ▫ Examined effect of increased flexibility on decreasing lower extremity overuse injuries in military
                    basic trainees.
              ▫ Hamstring flexibility was measured before and after the 13-week basic training program
                         5 x 30 sec stretches, 3 times a day for 13 weeks
              ▫ Intervention group flexibility increased from 41.7-34.7 while control group increased slightly
                    (45.9 to 42.9)
              ▫ Intervention group experienced significantly fewer (25 vs. 43) LE overuse injuries
              ▫ Results demonstrate the ability of an increase in flexibility to reduce LE overuse injuries.
Effects of Dynamic Stretching on Injury
    • Study by Olsen et al.
              ▫ Dynamic warm-up vs. No warm-up
                         1,886 club soccer players (16 y/o)
              ▫ Dynamic warm-up and stretching
                         Running, agility, plyometric, balance activities
              ▫ Over course of season:
              ▫ 103 injuries in dynamic stretching group vs. 195 injuries in the no warm-up group.
              ▫ Acute knee or ankle injuries can be reduced by 50% with use of dynamic warm-up.

Effects of Dynamic Stretching on Performance
    • Study by McMillian et al.
              ▫ Dynamic vs. Static vs. No warm-up
              ▫ Statistically significant increase in performance for all tests (agility and power via T drill, 5-step
                 jump, and medicine ball throw for distance) after completing dynamic stretching warm-up
              ▫ For tasks requiring power and agility, the results suggest that a dynamic warm-up might offer
                 performance benefits not found with static stretching or no warm up.
Which Stretching Protocol Is Best?
   • Static stretches held for 20-30 sec x 3-5 sets reported to increase muscle length that was maintained for
        24 hours
            ▫ GREATEST increase being maintained in first 15 minutes post stretching.
   • Dynamic warm-up of 5-10 minutes performed at 40-60% of VO2 max, followed by 5 minutes of recovery

Strengthening
    • To improve muscle strength, stress must be progressive and gradually challenged
              ▫ SAID principle (Specific Adaptation to Imposed Demands)
                        Body is placed under stress of varying intensities and durations, it attempts to overcome
                           the stress by adapting specifically to the imposed demands.
Principles of Strengthening
    • Working toward goals
              ▫ Strength, power, hypertrophy, or endurance
    • Varying program with periodization
              ▫ Changing the intensity, velocity, and volume as needed.
    • Type of muscle action focused in athletes sport
              ▫ Eccentric, concentric, and isometric

Strength Training
    • Strength
             ▫ Ability of the muscle to exert a maximum force at a specified velocity.
    • Power
             ▫ Force exerted x the velocity of movement
             ▫ Max power is achieved at 30-40% of 1RM
    • Endurance
             ▫ Ability to sustain an activity for extended periods of time
    • Isometric
             ▫ Force generated by muscle and the external force are equal and there is no lengthening of the
                  muscle.
             ▫ Most beneficial to increase endurance in spinal stabilizers.
    • Concentric
             ▫ Force produced by the muscle exceeds the external force or load.
    • Eccentric
             ▫ Whenever opposing force acting on a muscle exceeds the force produced by that muscle.
             ▫ Together with concentric contraction= stretch-shortening cycle (low-amplitude, mod-high
                  velocity contraction)
             ▫ Eccentric contractions ease mechanical forces and maximize performance.

Recommended Variables for Strength Training
    • Repetitions
           ▫ Strength: 8-12
           ▫ Power: 4-6
           ▫ Endurance: 12-15
    • Sets
           ▫ Multiple sets for all types of strengthening
    • Rest periods
           ▫ 1-2 minutes for smaller muscle groups
           ▫ 2-3 minutes for larger muscle groups
    • Intensity
           ▫ Strength: Start with 8 reps max
           ▫ Hypertrophy: Start with 10 reps max
▫ Power: Start with 6 reps max
              ▫ Endurance: Start with 15 reps max
     •    Velocity
              ▫ Slow, moderate, fast depending on specific goals.
     •    Muscle contraction
              ▫ Eccentric strengthening focused on with deceleration muscles
              ▫ Eccentric with concentric need to be focused on for acceleration muscles
     •    Length of time
              ▫ AT LEAST 2 days a week
              ▫ Any training over 4 weeks, the program needs periodization

Clinical Bottom Line
     • Stretching is sports specific
              ▫ Dynamic warm-up/stretching more beneficial prior to high intensity (football, basketball) sports
                  rather than lower intensity (bicycling, running).
     • Static stretching 15 minutes before athletic competition.
     • Dynamic stretching has been proven to be more effective in decreasing injuries and improving
          performance in sports requiring power and agility.
     • Strengthening is goal specific
              ▫ Strength training is dependent on what the athlete needs for athletic performance.

References
    •    Olsen et al. Exercise to prevent lower limb injuries in youth sports: cluster randomized controlled trial. BMJ.
         2005;330:449.
    •    McMillian DJ, Moore JH, Hatler BS, Taylor DC. Dynamic vs. static-stretching warm up: the effect of power and agility
         performance. Journal of Stretch and Conditioning Research. 2006; 20(3):492-499.
    •    Curry et al. Acute effects of dynamic stretching, static stretching, and light aerobic activity on muscular performance
         in women. Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research. 2009; 23(6):1811-1819.
    •    Mann DP, Jones MT. Guidelines to the implementation of a dynamic stretching program. Strength and Conditioning
         Journal. 1999;21(6):53-55.
    •    Young WB, Behm DG. Should static stretching be used during a warm-up for strength and power activities? National
         Strength and Conditioning Association. 2002; 24(6): 33-37.
    •    Donatelli R. Strength training concepts in Athletics. Sports –Specific Rehabilitation. St. Louis, Missouri :Elsevier; 2007.
    •    Woods K, Bishop P, Jones E. Warm-up and stretching in the prevention of muscular injury. Sports Medicine Journal.
         2007; 37(12):1089-1099.

Youth Sports Injury Day: The Science of Warm-Ups

  • 1.
    The Science ofWarm-up, Stretching and Strengthening: Injury Prevention in Athletics Lindsay Morgan, PT, DPT, ATC Anne Arundel Medical Center Comprehensive Outpatient Rehabilitation Center Athletic Injuries • Muscle injuries represent >30% of injuries seen in sports medicine. • Widely accepted ways for athletes to prevent muscular injuries: ▫ Warm up ▫ Stretching ▫ Strengthening Are we stretching the truth? • Various research studies offer different viewpoints regarding the effectiveness of warm-up and stretching protocols in reducing injuries. Warm-up • Prior to all athletic activity • Designed to improve muscle dynamics, and increase core temperature without fatiguing the individual. • Warm up can be active or passive • Physiological Effects of Warm-up • Increase in speed and force of muscle contractions. • Increase in temperature leads to the increase of oxygen uptake, providing more oxygen to working muscles. • Speed of nerve transmission increases contraction speed and reduction of reaction time. • Vasodilation • Should be tailored to needs of the athlete • Intensity • 40-60% of VO2 max should be utilized to increase muscle temperature, while also limiting high- energy phosphate depletion. • >60% VO2 max has shown to have an inverse relationship between warm up and short term performance Stretching • Therapeutic intervention to increase mobility of soft tissue with the goal of increasing range of motion (ROM). • Stretching is SPORTS SPECIFIC! • High intensity sports • Football, soccer, basketball • High intensity stretch-shortening cycles (SSC) require a muscle-tendon unit which is compliant enough to store and release the high amount of elastic energy. • Insufficient compliant muscle-tendon units = demands in energy absorption and release may exceed the capacity of the muscle-tendon unit = injury. • Stretching is important for injury prevention. • Low intensity sports • Jogging, cycling, and swimming • No need for a very compliant muscle-tendon unit • Most of power generation is a consequence of active contractile muscle work that needs to be directly transferred (by the tendon) to the articular system to generate motion. • Stretching exercises to improve the compliance of the tendon may have no beneficial effect on injury prevention. Types of Stretching • Static
  • 2.
    Slow, passive and deliberate movement. Stretch maintained for 20 seconds will facilitate elongation. • Dynamic • Whole body movements and involves actively and rhythmically contracting a muscle through part of its functional ROM. • Proprioceptive Neuromuscular Facilitation (PNF) • Static stretch, an isometric contraction, and relaxation, followed by a static stretch Effects of Warm-up, and Stretching on Injury Prevention Stretch or Not to Stretch? • Evidence suggests pre-exercise muscle stretching protocols do not produce meaningful reduction in risk of exercise-related injuries. • HOWEVER, basic science supports the notion that an active warm up might protect against muscle strain injury. ▫ Theoretically, warm up activities that enhance neural activation will better prepare muscles to absorb loads. ▫ Muscles under active contraction absorb significantly more energy than muscles at rest. Effects of Warm-up on Injury • Study by Bixler and Jones ▫ Examined # of injuries occurring during the 3rd quarter of HS football games ▫ Intervention and control group (warm-up and stretching program conducted at half-time) ▫ No significant difference in total number of 3rd quarter injuries between groups ▫ HOWEVER, intervention group experience fewer 3rd quarter sprains/strains per game over season. Effects of Static Stretching on Injury • Study by Hartig and Henderson ▫ Examined effect of increased flexibility on decreasing lower extremity overuse injuries in military basic trainees. ▫ Hamstring flexibility was measured before and after the 13-week basic training program  5 x 30 sec stretches, 3 times a day for 13 weeks ▫ Intervention group flexibility increased from 41.7-34.7 while control group increased slightly (45.9 to 42.9) ▫ Intervention group experienced significantly fewer (25 vs. 43) LE overuse injuries ▫ Results demonstrate the ability of an increase in flexibility to reduce LE overuse injuries. Effects of Dynamic Stretching on Injury • Study by Olsen et al. ▫ Dynamic warm-up vs. No warm-up  1,886 club soccer players (16 y/o) ▫ Dynamic warm-up and stretching  Running, agility, plyometric, balance activities ▫ Over course of season: ▫ 103 injuries in dynamic stretching group vs. 195 injuries in the no warm-up group. ▫ Acute knee or ankle injuries can be reduced by 50% with use of dynamic warm-up. Effects of Dynamic Stretching on Performance • Study by McMillian et al. ▫ Dynamic vs. Static vs. No warm-up ▫ Statistically significant increase in performance for all tests (agility and power via T drill, 5-step jump, and medicine ball throw for distance) after completing dynamic stretching warm-up ▫ For tasks requiring power and agility, the results suggest that a dynamic warm-up might offer performance benefits not found with static stretching or no warm up.
  • 3.
    Which Stretching ProtocolIs Best? • Static stretches held for 20-30 sec x 3-5 sets reported to increase muscle length that was maintained for 24 hours ▫ GREATEST increase being maintained in first 15 minutes post stretching. • Dynamic warm-up of 5-10 minutes performed at 40-60% of VO2 max, followed by 5 minutes of recovery Strengthening • To improve muscle strength, stress must be progressive and gradually challenged ▫ SAID principle (Specific Adaptation to Imposed Demands)  Body is placed under stress of varying intensities and durations, it attempts to overcome the stress by adapting specifically to the imposed demands. Principles of Strengthening • Working toward goals ▫ Strength, power, hypertrophy, or endurance • Varying program with periodization ▫ Changing the intensity, velocity, and volume as needed. • Type of muscle action focused in athletes sport ▫ Eccentric, concentric, and isometric Strength Training • Strength ▫ Ability of the muscle to exert a maximum force at a specified velocity. • Power ▫ Force exerted x the velocity of movement ▫ Max power is achieved at 30-40% of 1RM • Endurance ▫ Ability to sustain an activity for extended periods of time • Isometric ▫ Force generated by muscle and the external force are equal and there is no lengthening of the muscle. ▫ Most beneficial to increase endurance in spinal stabilizers. • Concentric ▫ Force produced by the muscle exceeds the external force or load. • Eccentric ▫ Whenever opposing force acting on a muscle exceeds the force produced by that muscle. ▫ Together with concentric contraction= stretch-shortening cycle (low-amplitude, mod-high velocity contraction) ▫ Eccentric contractions ease mechanical forces and maximize performance. Recommended Variables for Strength Training • Repetitions ▫ Strength: 8-12 ▫ Power: 4-6 ▫ Endurance: 12-15 • Sets ▫ Multiple sets for all types of strengthening • Rest periods ▫ 1-2 minutes for smaller muscle groups ▫ 2-3 minutes for larger muscle groups • Intensity ▫ Strength: Start with 8 reps max ▫ Hypertrophy: Start with 10 reps max
  • 4.
    ▫ Power: Startwith 6 reps max ▫ Endurance: Start with 15 reps max • Velocity ▫ Slow, moderate, fast depending on specific goals. • Muscle contraction ▫ Eccentric strengthening focused on with deceleration muscles ▫ Eccentric with concentric need to be focused on for acceleration muscles • Length of time ▫ AT LEAST 2 days a week ▫ Any training over 4 weeks, the program needs periodization Clinical Bottom Line • Stretching is sports specific ▫ Dynamic warm-up/stretching more beneficial prior to high intensity (football, basketball) sports rather than lower intensity (bicycling, running). • Static stretching 15 minutes before athletic competition. • Dynamic stretching has been proven to be more effective in decreasing injuries and improving performance in sports requiring power and agility. • Strengthening is goal specific ▫ Strength training is dependent on what the athlete needs for athletic performance. References • Olsen et al. Exercise to prevent lower limb injuries in youth sports: cluster randomized controlled trial. BMJ. 2005;330:449. • McMillian DJ, Moore JH, Hatler BS, Taylor DC. Dynamic vs. static-stretching warm up: the effect of power and agility performance. Journal of Stretch and Conditioning Research. 2006; 20(3):492-499. • Curry et al. Acute effects of dynamic stretching, static stretching, and light aerobic activity on muscular performance in women. Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research. 2009; 23(6):1811-1819. • Mann DP, Jones MT. Guidelines to the implementation of a dynamic stretching program. Strength and Conditioning Journal. 1999;21(6):53-55. • Young WB, Behm DG. Should static stretching be used during a warm-up for strength and power activities? National Strength and Conditioning Association. 2002; 24(6): 33-37. • Donatelli R. Strength training concepts in Athletics. Sports –Specific Rehabilitation. St. Louis, Missouri :Elsevier; 2007. • Woods K, Bishop P, Jones E. Warm-up and stretching in the prevention of muscular injury. Sports Medicine Journal. 2007; 37(12):1089-1099.