University Centers in
Europe, Middle East and Asia

                                    Anders Norberg
           Skellefteå/Sioux Falls   Education Strategist
           2013-03-21               Campus Skellefteå

                                    +PhD student, Applied
                                    Educational Science
                                    Umeå University
My presentation
•   Me, Campus Skellefteå
•   My search for campus identity / Europe
•   Definition attempts + Middle East, Asia
•   Theory, Implications: ”University”/”Place”
•   Q&A

• YouTube film about a planned campus in
  Pleven, Bulgaria, 8 min
15000 students, 4
             campuses




   1,1
   million

                        2500 students




8,2
million


                36 000 students, 4
                campuses
Campus Skellefteå
    2500 students, some R&D
    About 120 univ-employed
    15 programs + 3 polytechnics
    Businesses, EU-projects


                                           Learning
                                           Centre




                             Trätek
                                      www.campus.skelleftea.se
About Campus Varberg:
        (outside
  Gothenburg, Sweden)
9 university programs
4 polytechnical programs
1100 students
Was formed 2003                                 Universities at
                  Applied research              Campus Varberg

                                                                      Study
   Adult education                                                    counseling


 Project
 ideas, management, ad
 ministration




                                                                      Polytechnical
                                                 Business startup     educations
                                                 project
       Library                                                      Student union
                                     Learning
                                     centre
But who are we?
What is this?

A local random
construction?
Something that just
happened?
What should we
call it?
Identity search for a regional
       learning environment?

THE CENTRALIZED UNIVERSITY VOICE:
• Isn it enough that we call it ”Umeå
  university in Skellefteå”, or ”Umeå
  university educations in Skellefteå”?(before ~2008)

• We call it our ”Skellefteå Campus” (Luleå
  University of Technology)
Older identity trials
• ….started as SKERIA, in the 80ies,
  ”Skellefteå Education and Research on
  Industrial Applications”
• ”A study center”? ”A learning center”?
• A ”college”, undefined in Sweden?
• …was this a ”university hotel”, like an
  ”office hotel” or ”web hotel”?
• …or a multi-university campus?
”Multi-university campus”
…hmm…worth a web search…
• Chricton Campus, Dumfries, Scotland –
  ”the first multi-university campus in the
  United Kingdom”

• …and after many contacts attempts:

• …Prof Rex Taylor, University of
  Glasgow, Director Chricton Campus :
     Come! We must talk about this!
http://www.crichton.ac.uk/
”Multi-institutional campus”
"A campus where two or more distant
  educational institutions cooperate with
  each other and local development
  agencies to create new educational and
  training opportunities in a locality deprived
  of such opportunities“

(Prof Rex Taylor, Director of University of Glasgow’s operations on Crichton
    Campus, presentation on Campus Skellefteå October 26th, 2005)
What is a ”multi-institutional
            campus” (MIC)?
• …or a multi-university campus?

Well, it is not…

•   The same main campus for two universities
•   A multi-campus university
•   A university system
•   A university in the making
•   A multiversity
A MODERN
  HYBRID
  LEARNING ENVIRONMENT?




                                An Education hub?

A multi-institutional campus?
A university center?
http://www.medway.ac.uk/
Tremough Campus,
  Combined Universities Cornwall,




http://www.cuc.ac.uk/
Seinäjoki Campus, Finland
                        Kajaani
                        Pori
                        Lahti
                        Mikkeli
                        Kokkola
                        …other
                        MIC / Univ
                        consortia
European Union -
Interreg IVC: UNICREDS
         project
Exchange of experiences
    between regions
   …about Triple Helix
 functions / dysfunctions
and alternative models for
 education and research
 access & growth in the
   knowledge society
15 partners in 7 European
   regions, 2010-2012
    www.unicreds.eu
3 MULTI-INSTITUTIONAL
 CAMPUSES: Skellefteå,
   Seinäjoki, Cornwall
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WzcVE6i7H1I
Searching wider…

googleing more,

networking
Qatar Education City




http://www.myeducationcity.com/
http://www.hbku.edu.qa/
Dubai International Academic City




http://www.diacedu.ae/
DIAC
                   (Dubai International Academic City)
•   American University in the Emirates (AUE)    •    Saint-Petersburg State University of
•   Amity University Dubai Campus                     Engineering & Economics
•   BITS, Pilani - Dubai                         •    Shaheed Zulfikar Ali Bhutto Institute of
                                                      Science and Technology, Dubai (SZABIST)
•   Cambridge College International
                                                 •    The British University in Dubai (BUiD)
•   Canada International College
                                                 •    Université Saint Joseph Law School – Dubai
•   French Fashion University ESMOD Dubai
                                                 •    University of Bradford
•   Heriot-Watt University Dubai Campus
                                                 •    University of Exeter
•   Hult International Business School
                                                 •    University of Wollongong in Dubai
•   Imam Malik College
•   Institute of Management Technology, Dubai
•   Islamic Azad University (IAU)
•   JSS Education                               “Dubai International Academic City (DIAC)
•   Manchester Business School                  is the world’s only Free Zone dedicated to
•   Manipal University, Dubai                   Higher Education. Established in 2007 as
•   Michigan State University Dubai
                                                part of TECOM Investments, DIAC aims to
•   Middlesex University Dubai
                                                develop the region’s talent pool and
•   Murdoch University Dubai
                                                establish the UAE as a knowledge-based
•   S P Jain Center of Management
•   SAE Institute Dubai
                                                economy.” http://www.tecom.ae/dubai-international-
                                                academic-city/
Guangzhou Mega Education City




Start 2005: 10 000 students, 2011:150 000,
Finally 350 000 – 400 000 students
Sun Yat-sen University,
South China University of Technology,
South China Normal University,
Guangdong University of Foreign Studies,
Guangdong University of Technology,
Guangzhou University,
Guangzhou University of Chinese Medicine,
Guangdong Pharmaceutical University,
Xinghai Conservatory of Music
Guangzhou Academy of Fine Arts
  http://www.guangzhou.gov.cn/special/2006/node_969/
Guangzhou HE Mega Center:
             Idea?
• Focus on IT industry: implementing the
  integration of “studies, research, production”
  through interactivities with the existing IT
  industry, and thus enhancing the
  comprehensive competitiveness of
  Guangzhou City.
• Promoting academic culture and tourism : the
  university town is situated near by dozens of
  touristic attractions in Guangzhou. The
  rich campus culture can eventually add lustre
  to the existing tourism industry.

 http://www.upo.gov.cn/plan2007/zdxmgh/949.shtml
Guangzhou HE Mega Center:
        Common management
• The establishment and operation of the university
  town is the integration of the cooperation between the government,
  universities and community.
• Guangzhou University town’s management model
   – Social security and traffic communications - responsibility of the
      government.
   – Public facilities management - responsibility of municipal
   – logistics of service – the responsibility of the community and
      society.
• Police station, the traffic police brigade, fire brigade are established in
  the university to ensure the security management is in place;
• The management in the university are taken care by the
  municipality and the government, hence the schools could focus
  on their academic activities.
  http://www.lwlm.com/KaoChaBaoGao/201201/627882.htm
“University Town”
  大学城                          “Campus City”
• Definition by China National Committee for
  Terms in Sciences and Technology

“An urban (suburban) area which develops
around one or several well-known
universities. Such new town is constituted by
one or more campuses, and is equipped with
living/residential area, sport stadium, research
& development zone and large green open
space.”
  http://baike.baidu.com/view/46244.htm
Songjiang University town




   Started planning year 2000, completed year 2005
University town of Shenzhen




http://www.utsz.edu.cn/02pic/showPicInfo.aspx?infoid=104&cateid=
7
http://www.thebestcolleges.org/10-cities-becoming-education-   SEE Kinser, K & Lane, J.E. (2010). Educational Hubs:
destinations/                                                  Archipelagos & Acropolises. International Higher Education, 59,
Theory, implications…
Range of MIC:s
• From nearly local service for distance
  educations…
• ….to small campuses, comparable with
  smaller HE institutions
• …to supermarkets of universities
• …to massive upscaling projects aiming at
  400 000 students at the same campus
  – …but some characteristics in common!
Mechanisms?
•   Higher education access needed
•   Life-Long Learning increases
•   The symbolic importance of places
•   Regions take their fate in own hands
•   Fast education up-scaling by outsourcing
•   Differentiation of regional education
    provision in a world of institutional
    specialization
“University” vs “place”


     …changes
     over time
First medieval universities
were communities and corporations
     of masters and students
Identification between ”University” & ”Campus”
”University” & ”campus” sliding
              apart
• A ”University” becomes more of a
  specialized international brand of research
  ….and education?

• A ”Campus” develops into a
  customizeable local / regional platform for
  universities and other organizations, filling
  a local function
Two perspectives in MIC
           backgrounds
1) University outreach perspective
2) Regional development perspective
1. University outreach perspective


Learning centres

                                                     Branch campuses




                             Main campus

    International
    campus
                                                       SL campus



                    …and there are 17000+ universities… (source:Webometrics)
..so universities international campuses
sometimes happens to co-exist in the same
infrastructures elsewhere…

…which often is the idea itself from the
regional perspective

But MIC:s are not easily visible from the
centralized university / hierarchical horizon?
2. Regional development
              perspective
• Regions, subregions, cities, villages are trying
  to become competitive in the global
  knowledge economy

• Belief in “Triple Helix” cooperation and
  innovation, “the Knowledge triangle”, “The
  Entrepreneurial university”, etc

…but what if there is no university present?
…regional development
            perspective
• …a university presence, or a local
  campus, is very valuable for development
  purposes…at almost any cost?
• …but a university can demand 50+ years
  to form
• …and we have a tension between old
  national provision and current regional
  demand
• …university presence /representation is
  becoming a necessity in all communities?
Zayed University, Abu Dhabi, UAE                 True?




        And it comes now in all sizes:
        ..there are no future-confident regions that lack higher
        education, research and innovation?
Lets sum up: MIC – “recipe” / European

•   >1 regional university with decentralised F2F (face-to-face) classes
•   Learning centre with support to flexible learning students
•   Local R&D, development projects, mm
•   Vocational and polytechnical education
•   Science Park, Business labs & business startup
•   Local coordination organisation often needed
•   Local construction and ownership of buildings and infrastructure? Or
    is there an older useful infrastructure?

= concentration of development factors in one
  place, a MIC – representing the direction
  towards the future?
MIC PROBLEM AREAS
•   Very dependent on the universities
•   Must attract students
•   Expensive for the local region/city
•   Hard to understand at first glance
•   Education-heavy, research-poor
MIC POSSIBILITIES
• Very flexible
• Very scalable
• Can offer university presence without a new
  university
• Can support local business development
• If one university leaves, another can replace it
• Synergy effects between universities possible
• The MIC recruits mostly students that won t
  move to a big campus – and these students will
  often stay in the area after exam –if, but only
  if, there are jobs…
Alternatives for local representation of a
              university on a MUC
•    Research and teaching department?
•    Regional office?
•    Only educations?
•    Franchise construction?
•    Subcontractor?

• …and often is a regional development
  organisation important as a coordinator and
  catalyst
University-University-relations on a MUC

•   Parallelism?               Policy agreement?
•   Coordination?              Consortium document?
                               Deal?
•   Cooperation?               “Agreement”?
                               “Tolerance”?
•   Competition?
•   Coopetition?

• Vertical relation – to mother university
• Horisontal relation – to other universities and
  stakeholders on the MIC
University internal motivations
• Possibility to specialize more on academic
  matters (as someone else helps manage
  campus infrastructure)
• Specialization in global research makes a
  university handicapped in broadness of local
  education offerings in the long run, will
  increasingly need cooperation in education
• Local / regional interests pay some
  infrastructure costs
Multi-institutional campus as HETEROTOPIA”/
      ”Of Other Spaces”? (Foucault 1967)
• “We are in the epoch of simultaneity: we are in
  the epoch of juxtaposition, the epoch of the near
  and far, of the side-by-side, of the dispersed.”
• “We may still not have reached the point of a
  practical de-sanctification of space…”
• ”…something like counter-sites, a kind of
  effectively enacted utopia in which the real
  sites…are simultaneously represented,
  contested, and inverted.”
• “The heterotopia is capable of juxtaposing in a
  single real place several spaces…in themselves
  incompatible.” http://foucault.info/documents/heteroTopia/foucault.heteroTopia.en.html
Wrapping up MIC…with speculations:



• Will most campuses in the future be of a multi-
  institutional character?

• And will perhaps regional organizations run
  practical management?
Thanks for your attention!

   Anders.norberg@edusci.umu.se



…now researching ”Blended Learning and
Educational Logistics”; the landscape
beyond the campus/distance dichotomy.

Time, space and education, combinations
Q (& A?)

"University Centers in Europe..." at University Centers conference, Sioux Falls March 2013

  • 1.
    University Centers in Europe,Middle East and Asia Anders Norberg Skellefteå/Sioux Falls Education Strategist 2013-03-21 Campus Skellefteå +PhD student, Applied Educational Science Umeå University
  • 2.
    My presentation • Me, Campus Skellefteå • My search for campus identity / Europe • Definition attempts + Middle East, Asia • Theory, Implications: ”University”/”Place” • Q&A • YouTube film about a planned campus in Pleven, Bulgaria, 8 min
  • 3.
    15000 students, 4 campuses 1,1 million 2500 students 8,2 million 36 000 students, 4 campuses
  • 5.
    Campus Skellefteå 2500 students, some R&D About 120 univ-employed 15 programs + 3 polytechnics Businesses, EU-projects Learning Centre Trätek www.campus.skelleftea.se
  • 6.
    About Campus Varberg: (outside Gothenburg, Sweden) 9 university programs 4 polytechnical programs 1100 students Was formed 2003 Universities at Applied research Campus Varberg Study Adult education counseling Project ideas, management, ad ministration Polytechnical Business startup educations project Library Student union Learning centre
  • 7.
    But who arewe? What is this? A local random construction? Something that just happened? What should we call it?
  • 8.
    Identity search fora regional learning environment? THE CENTRALIZED UNIVERSITY VOICE: • Isn it enough that we call it ”Umeå university in Skellefteå”, or ”Umeå university educations in Skellefteå”?(before ~2008) • We call it our ”Skellefteå Campus” (Luleå University of Technology)
  • 9.
    Older identity trials •….started as SKERIA, in the 80ies, ”Skellefteå Education and Research on Industrial Applications” • ”A study center”? ”A learning center”? • A ”college”, undefined in Sweden? • …was this a ”university hotel”, like an ”office hotel” or ”web hotel”? • …or a multi-university campus?
  • 10.
    ”Multi-university campus” …hmm…worth aweb search… • Chricton Campus, Dumfries, Scotland – ”the first multi-university campus in the United Kingdom” • …and after many contacts attempts: • …Prof Rex Taylor, University of Glasgow, Director Chricton Campus : Come! We must talk about this!
  • 11.
  • 13.
    ”Multi-institutional campus” "A campuswhere two or more distant educational institutions cooperate with each other and local development agencies to create new educational and training opportunities in a locality deprived of such opportunities“ (Prof Rex Taylor, Director of University of Glasgow’s operations on Crichton Campus, presentation on Campus Skellefteå October 26th, 2005)
  • 14.
    What is a”multi-institutional campus” (MIC)? • …or a multi-university campus? Well, it is not… • The same main campus for two universities • A multi-campus university • A university system • A university in the making • A multiversity
  • 15.
    A MODERN HYBRID LEARNING ENVIRONMENT? An Education hub? A multi-institutional campus? A university center?
  • 16.
  • 17.
    Tremough Campus, Combined Universities Cornwall, http://www.cuc.ac.uk/
  • 19.
    Seinäjoki Campus, Finland Kajaani Pori Lahti Mikkeli Kokkola …other MIC / Univ consortia
  • 20.
    European Union - InterregIVC: UNICREDS project Exchange of experiences between regions …about Triple Helix functions / dysfunctions and alternative models for education and research access & growth in the knowledge society 15 partners in 7 European regions, 2010-2012 www.unicreds.eu 3 MULTI-INSTITUTIONAL CAMPUSES: Skellefteå, Seinäjoki, Cornwall
  • 21.
  • 22.
  • 23.
  • 26.
  • 27.
    Dubai International AcademicCity http://www.diacedu.ae/
  • 28.
    DIAC (Dubai International Academic City) • American University in the Emirates (AUE) • Saint-Petersburg State University of • Amity University Dubai Campus Engineering & Economics • BITS, Pilani - Dubai • Shaheed Zulfikar Ali Bhutto Institute of Science and Technology, Dubai (SZABIST) • Cambridge College International • The British University in Dubai (BUiD) • Canada International College • Université Saint Joseph Law School – Dubai • French Fashion University ESMOD Dubai • University of Bradford • Heriot-Watt University Dubai Campus • University of Exeter • Hult International Business School • University of Wollongong in Dubai • Imam Malik College • Institute of Management Technology, Dubai • Islamic Azad University (IAU) • JSS Education “Dubai International Academic City (DIAC) • Manchester Business School is the world’s only Free Zone dedicated to • Manipal University, Dubai Higher Education. Established in 2007 as • Michigan State University Dubai part of TECOM Investments, DIAC aims to • Middlesex University Dubai develop the region’s talent pool and • Murdoch University Dubai establish the UAE as a knowledge-based • S P Jain Center of Management • SAE Institute Dubai economy.” http://www.tecom.ae/dubai-international- academic-city/
  • 29.
    Guangzhou Mega EducationCity Start 2005: 10 000 students, 2011:150 000, Finally 350 000 – 400 000 students Sun Yat-sen University, South China University of Technology, South China Normal University, Guangdong University of Foreign Studies, Guangdong University of Technology, Guangzhou University, Guangzhou University of Chinese Medicine, Guangdong Pharmaceutical University, Xinghai Conservatory of Music Guangzhou Academy of Fine Arts http://www.guangzhou.gov.cn/special/2006/node_969/
  • 30.
    Guangzhou HE MegaCenter: Idea? • Focus on IT industry: implementing the integration of “studies, research, production” through interactivities with the existing IT industry, and thus enhancing the comprehensive competitiveness of Guangzhou City. • Promoting academic culture and tourism : the university town is situated near by dozens of touristic attractions in Guangzhou. The rich campus culture can eventually add lustre to the existing tourism industry. http://www.upo.gov.cn/plan2007/zdxmgh/949.shtml
  • 31.
    Guangzhou HE MegaCenter: Common management • The establishment and operation of the university town is the integration of the cooperation between the government, universities and community. • Guangzhou University town’s management model – Social security and traffic communications - responsibility of the government. – Public facilities management - responsibility of municipal – logistics of service – the responsibility of the community and society. • Police station, the traffic police brigade, fire brigade are established in the university to ensure the security management is in place; • The management in the university are taken care by the municipality and the government, hence the schools could focus on their academic activities. http://www.lwlm.com/KaoChaBaoGao/201201/627882.htm
  • 32.
    “University Town” 大学城 “Campus City” • Definition by China National Committee for Terms in Sciences and Technology “An urban (suburban) area which develops around one or several well-known universities. Such new town is constituted by one or more campuses, and is equipped with living/residential area, sport stadium, research & development zone and large green open space.” http://baike.baidu.com/view/46244.htm
  • 33.
    Songjiang University town Started planning year 2000, completed year 2005
  • 34.
    University town ofShenzhen http://www.utsz.edu.cn/02pic/showPicInfo.aspx?infoid=104&cateid= 7
  • 36.
    http://www.thebestcolleges.org/10-cities-becoming-education- SEE Kinser, K & Lane, J.E. (2010). Educational Hubs: destinations/ Archipelagos & Acropolises. International Higher Education, 59,
  • 37.
  • 38.
    Range of MIC:s •From nearly local service for distance educations… • ….to small campuses, comparable with smaller HE institutions • …to supermarkets of universities • …to massive upscaling projects aiming at 400 000 students at the same campus – …but some characteristics in common!
  • 39.
    Mechanisms? • Higher education access needed • Life-Long Learning increases • The symbolic importance of places • Regions take their fate in own hands • Fast education up-scaling by outsourcing • Differentiation of regional education provision in a world of institutional specialization
  • 40.
  • 41.
    First medieval universities werecommunities and corporations of masters and students
  • 42.
  • 43.
    ”University” & ”campus”sliding apart • A ”University” becomes more of a specialized international brand of research ….and education? • A ”Campus” develops into a customizeable local / regional platform for universities and other organizations, filling a local function
  • 44.
    Two perspectives inMIC backgrounds 1) University outreach perspective 2) Regional development perspective
  • 45.
    1. University outreachperspective Learning centres Branch campuses Main campus International campus SL campus …and there are 17000+ universities… (source:Webometrics)
  • 46.
    ..so universities internationalcampuses sometimes happens to co-exist in the same infrastructures elsewhere… …which often is the idea itself from the regional perspective But MIC:s are not easily visible from the centralized university / hierarchical horizon?
  • 47.
    2. Regional development perspective • Regions, subregions, cities, villages are trying to become competitive in the global knowledge economy • Belief in “Triple Helix” cooperation and innovation, “the Knowledge triangle”, “The Entrepreneurial university”, etc …but what if there is no university present?
  • 48.
    …regional development perspective • …a university presence, or a local campus, is very valuable for development purposes…at almost any cost? • …but a university can demand 50+ years to form • …and we have a tension between old national provision and current regional demand • …university presence /representation is becoming a necessity in all communities?
  • 49.
    Zayed University, AbuDhabi, UAE True? And it comes now in all sizes: ..there are no future-confident regions that lack higher education, research and innovation?
  • 53.
    Lets sum up:MIC – “recipe” / European • >1 regional university with decentralised F2F (face-to-face) classes • Learning centre with support to flexible learning students • Local R&D, development projects, mm • Vocational and polytechnical education • Science Park, Business labs & business startup • Local coordination organisation often needed • Local construction and ownership of buildings and infrastructure? Or is there an older useful infrastructure? = concentration of development factors in one place, a MIC – representing the direction towards the future?
  • 54.
    MIC PROBLEM AREAS • Very dependent on the universities • Must attract students • Expensive for the local region/city • Hard to understand at first glance • Education-heavy, research-poor
  • 55.
    MIC POSSIBILITIES • Veryflexible • Very scalable • Can offer university presence without a new university • Can support local business development • If one university leaves, another can replace it • Synergy effects between universities possible • The MIC recruits mostly students that won t move to a big campus – and these students will often stay in the area after exam –if, but only if, there are jobs…
  • 56.
    Alternatives for localrepresentation of a university on a MUC • Research and teaching department? • Regional office? • Only educations? • Franchise construction? • Subcontractor? • …and often is a regional development organisation important as a coordinator and catalyst
  • 57.
    University-University-relations on aMUC • Parallelism? Policy agreement? • Coordination? Consortium document? Deal? • Cooperation? “Agreement”? “Tolerance”? • Competition? • Coopetition? • Vertical relation – to mother university • Horisontal relation – to other universities and stakeholders on the MIC
  • 58.
    University internal motivations •Possibility to specialize more on academic matters (as someone else helps manage campus infrastructure) • Specialization in global research makes a university handicapped in broadness of local education offerings in the long run, will increasingly need cooperation in education • Local / regional interests pay some infrastructure costs
  • 59.
    Multi-institutional campus asHETEROTOPIA”/ ”Of Other Spaces”? (Foucault 1967) • “We are in the epoch of simultaneity: we are in the epoch of juxtaposition, the epoch of the near and far, of the side-by-side, of the dispersed.” • “We may still not have reached the point of a practical de-sanctification of space…” • ”…something like counter-sites, a kind of effectively enacted utopia in which the real sites…are simultaneously represented, contested, and inverted.” • “The heterotopia is capable of juxtaposing in a single real place several spaces…in themselves incompatible.” http://foucault.info/documents/heteroTopia/foucault.heteroTopia.en.html
  • 60.
    Wrapping up MIC…withspeculations: • Will most campuses in the future be of a multi- institutional character? • And will perhaps regional organizations run practical management?
  • 61.
    Thanks for yourattention! Anders.norberg@edusci.umu.se …now researching ”Blended Learning and Educational Logistics”; the landscape beyond the campus/distance dichotomy. Time, space and education, combinations
  • 62.