SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Toronto Solvent
Reduction ESR Review
© 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 2 Packaging
Toronto (Weston) Solvent Reduction ESR Review Topics
Project Goals
Current site Amended Certificate of Approval (C of A) / Previous
Air Toxics Dispersion Modeling
Potential Future Ministry of Environment (MOE) Control
Technology Standards
Current site process lines to APC equipment
Site solvent emissions (annual) and natural gas consumption
(annual) indexed to annual production rates
Options under consideration (Scenarios 1 – 3, 4B and 5B)
© 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 3 Packaging
Project Goals
 Minimize Weston’s solvent emission footprint per unit of production by
50%
 CY 2007: 0.1089 ton (US) emission / ton (US) production
 Goal: 0.0545 ton (US) emission / ton (US) production
 Satisfy current and future MOE standards
 Decrease airflow volumes exhausted to APC equipment
 Minimize additional APC equipment capacity needed
 Reduce APC equipment natural gas consumption per unit of production
 Improve workplace air quality conditions
 Satisfy PACK EHS 009 explosion prevention directive for solvent adhesive
laminators (Adh Lam 461 and Adh Lam 411)
© 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 4 Packaging
Current C of A / Previous Air Toxics Dispersion Modeling
Amended C of A Issued Oct. 30, 2005
Due for Expiration Oct. 30, 2010
Approved based on application and dispersion modeling submitted
in Sept. 2005 – Oct. 2005
Allowed for Adh Lam 461 and Flexo Press 306 emission to
atmosphere (uncontrolled)
Modeling (2005) was based on unrealistic (high) capture efficiency
rates and unrealistic (low) maximum short-term emission rates
Previous C of A approvals and dispersion modeling were based on
more representative capture efficiency rates
© 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 5 Packaging
Potential Future MOE Control Technology Standards
Under consideration by MOE for approximately last five years
2006 - 2007
Stakeholder Meetings
Comments prepared and filed by Alcan Packaging
Facility Profile for Weston prepared by MOE consultant (one of
22); corrections/revisions for Weston filed by Alcan Packaging
MOE investigation in to viability of PTEs and overall cost-
effectiveness of control technology-based standards
2008 – Beyond
Policy/Promulgation via MOE Standards Development Branch
© 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 6 Packaging
Current Site Process Lines to Oxidizer System
 Roto 207; approximately 20,000 scfm; est. 75% capture efficiency
 Roto 253; app. 60,000 scfm; est. 75% capture efficiency
 Roto 205; app. 36,000 scfm; est. 75% capture efficiency
 Roto 208; app. 40,000 scfm; est. 90% capture efficiency
 Adh. Lam. 461 (exhausted to atmosphere); app. 50,000 scfm; est. 70%
capture efficiency
 Flexo. 306 (exhausted to atmosphere); app. 3,000 scfm; est. 90% capture
efficiency
 Adh. Lam. 411; exhausted to atmosphere; app. 4,000 scfm; est. 80%
capture efficiency
 Ext. Lam. 421; exhausted to atmosphere; app. 9,000 scfm; est. 80%
capture efficiency
 Ext. Lam. 422; exhausted to atmosphere; app. 15,000 scfm; est. 80%
capture efficiency
© 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 7 Packaging
Site Solvent Emissions and Natural Gas Consumption in
Relation to Production (Reported PDM Data)
Site Solvent Emissions (tons, US) 2002 - 2007
Highest CY = 2002 (1,553 tons/year)
CY 2004 – CY 2007 in 700 tons/year – 900 tons/year range
Natural Gas Consumption (million ft3) 2002 - 2007
CY 2002 = 63.0 million ft3/year
Highest CY = 2006 (153.3 million ft3/year)
CY 2007 decreased to 126.8 million ft3/year
Solvent Emission to Production Ratio (tons US/tons US)
CY 2005 – CY 2007 in 0.10 – 0.13 range
NG Consumption to Production Ratio (MMft3/tons US)
CY 2005 – CY 2007 in 0.015 – 0.022 range
© 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 8 Packaging
Revised 2005 Baseline Dispersion Modeling
Summary
o Ethyl alcohol 164% of allowed
o Isopropyl acetate 581% of allowed
o Toluene 346% of allowed
o N-propyl acetate 1,010% of allowed (est. minimum
138% of allowed based on
AERMOD)
o Ethyl acetate 289% of allowed
o VM&P naphtha 486% of allowed
o Naphtha (aliphatic) 153% of allowed
-All exceed for odor, based on ½-hour allowed standard;
- N-propyl acetate AERMOD result is 24 hour based as allowed
© 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 9 Packaging
MOE
June 1 each year – Annual C of A Written Summary/Certification
(air toxic certification to permit)
MOE Meeting on June 26,2008
Letter to Agency July 7, 2008 - requesting extension to September
5, 2008 for submitting June 1 data and compliance plan
Meeting to be scheduled week of July 28 with MOE
© 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 10 Packaging
Project Options Under Consideration
Five Scenarios (1, 2, 3, 4B and 5B)
Solvent substitution has been reviewed with Weston technical
personnel but is not considered a viable option for MOE
compliance given several solvents with modeled baseline
exceedances, and quality and customer concerns
All five scenarios will help meet project goals other than MOE
compliance
© 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 11 Packaging
Scenario 1 Evaluation – Changes to Plant Configuration
Four roto presses, PTE, to RTO system; and
New or replacement adh lam (for 461 and 411), PTE, airflow
reduced to 25,000 scfm; or
Replace 461 dryer, 461 + 411 in PTE, total adh lam airflow
reduced to 25,000 scfm; and
Shutdown Flexo 306; and
Increase certain stack heights to 18.5 m (61 feet) above ground
level; and
Roto press dryer and room/plant airflow management
improvements; and
Add at least 50,000 scfm RTO capacity (quadraplex)
© 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 12 Packaging
Scenario 1 Evaluation – Changes to Plant Configuration
Scenario 1 Plant Emission Source Configuration
Process Line To Oxidizer or To Atmosphere Estimated Solvent Capture Efficiency
Roto 207 To Oxidizer 100%
Roto 253 To Oxidizer 100%
Roto 205 To Oxidizer 100%
Roto 208 To Oxidizer 100%
Adh Lam 461 To Oxidizer 100%
Adh Lam 411 To Oxidizer (or Shutdown) 100% (Unless Shutdown)
Ext Lam 421 1
To Atmosphere 80%
Ext Lam 422 1
To Atmosphere 80%
Table B Notes: 1. Scenario 1 presumes that Ext Lam 421 and Ext Lam 422 would not be operated
simultaneously due to machine-manning operating restrictions.
© 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 13 Packaging
Summary of Scenario 1
In compliance with MOE air toxics standards
Cost of project $9.0 million (US) capital - $400,000 Expense
© 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 14 Packaging
Scenario 2 Evaluation – Changes to Plant Configuration
Four roto presses, PTE, to RTO system; and
Adh Lam 411, Ext Lam 421 and Ext Lam 422 exhausted to a
relocated 30,000 scfm catalytic oxidizer; and
Shutdown Flexo 306; and
Increase certain stack heights to 18.5 m (61 feet) above ground
level; and
Roto press dryer and room/plant airflow management
improvements; and
Add at least 80,000 scfm RTO capacity (quadraplex)
© 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 15 Packaging
Scenario 2 Evaluation – Changes to Plant Configuration
Scenario 2 Plant Emission Source Configuration
Process Line To Oxidizer or To Atmosphere Estimated Solvent Capture Efficiency
Roto 207 To Oxidizer 100%
Roto 253 To Oxidizer 100%
Roto 205 To Oxidizer 100%
Roto 208 To Oxidizer 100%
Adh Lam 461 To Atmosphere 70%
Adh Lam 411 To Oxidizer 80%
Ext Lam 421 1
To Oxidizer 80%
Ext Lam 422 1
To Oxidizer 80%
Table C Notes: 1. Scenario 1 presumes that Ext Lam 421 and Ext Lam 422 would not be operated
simultaneously due to machine-manning operating restrictions.
© 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 16 Packaging
Summary of Scenario 2
Not in compliance with MOE air toxics standards (n-propyl acetate
at 264%)
Cost of project $5.2 million (US) capital and $400,000 expense.
© 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 17 Packaging
Scenario 3 Evaluation – Changes to Plant Configuration
 No PTEs
 Replace 461 dryer, reduce airflow to 25,000 scfm; and
 Adh Lam 411, Ext Lam 421, Ext Lam 422 exhausted to a relocated 30,000
scfm catalytic oxidizer; and
 Shutdown Flexo 306; and
 Increase certain stack heights to 18.5 m (61 feet) above ground level; and
Roto press dryer and room/plant airflow management improvements:
 MUA units as needed
 Roto Press 253 thermal fluid system
 Added LEL monitoring for Roto Press 208
 Recirculation ductwork modifications for Roto Press 205
© 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 18 Packaging
Scenario 3 Evaluation – Changes to Plant Configuration
Scenario 3 Plant Emission Source Configuration
Process Line To APC Equipment or To
Atmosphere
Estimated Solvent Capture Efficiency
Roto 207 To RTO System 75%
Roto 253 To RTO System 75%
Roto 205 To RTO System 75%
Roto 208 To RTO System 90%
Adh Lam 461 To RTO System 70%
Adh Lam 411 To Catalytic Oxidizer 80%
Ext Lam 421 To Catalytic Oxidizer 80%
Ext Lam 422 To Catalytic Oxidizer 80%
© 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 19 Packaging
Summary of Scenario 3
Not in compliance with MOE air toxics standards (isopropyl acetate
at 184%)
Cost of project $6.9 million (US) capital and $200,000 expense
Cost includes air make-up at a cost of $1.05 million (US)
© 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 20 Packaging
Scenario 4A
Same as Scenario 4B except relocate Alcoa adhesive laminator
(Instead of replacing dryer system for Adh Lam 461)
Engineering review has concluded the Alcoa laminator will not
feasibly fit in the available footprint at Weston
© 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 21 Packaging
Scenario 4B Evaluation – Changes to Plant Configuration
 No PTEs
 Replace 461 dryer, reduce airflow to 25,000 scfm and improve capture
efficiency to 90%; and
 Install relocated 30,000 scfm catalytic oxidizer and connect with RTOs
(quadraplex); connect Adh Lam 411, Ext Lam 421 and Ext Lam 422; and
 Shutdown Flexo 306; and
 Increase certain stack heights to 18.5 m (61 feet) above ground level; and
 Roto press dryer and room/plant airflow management improvements:
 MUA units as needed
 Roto Press 253 - tie-in to Roto Press 208 thermal fluid system
 Added LEL monitoring for Roto Press 208
© 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 22 Packaging
Scenario 4B Evaluation – Changes to Plant Configuration
Scenario 4B Plant Emission Source Configuration
Process Line To APC Equipment or To
Atmosphere
Estimated Solvent Capture Efficiency
Roto 207 To RTO/Catalytic Oxidizer
System
75%
Roto 253 To RTO/Catalytic Oxidizer
System
75%
Roto 205 To RTO/Catalytic Oxidizer
System
75%
Roto 208 To RTO/Catalytic Oxidizer
System
90%
Adh Lam 461 To RTO/Catalytic Oxidizer
System
90%
Adh Lam 411 To RTO/Catalytic Oxidizer
System
80%
Ext Lam 421 To RTO/Catalytic Oxidizer
System
80%
Ext Lam 422 To RTO/Catalytic Oxidizer
System
80%
© 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 23 Packaging
Summary of Scenario 4B
In compliance with MOE air toxics standards
Cost of project $4.5 million (US) capital and $200,000 expense
Cost includes air make-up at a cost of $1.05 million (US)
There is a question if 461 can meet 90% capture.
© 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 24 Packaging
Summary of Scenario 4C
In compliance with MOE air toxics standards
This scenario will include a new laminator for 461instead of new
oven or Alcoa laminator
Cost of project $5.6 million (US) capital and $750,000 Expense
Cost includes air make-up at a cost of $1.05 million (US)
© 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 25 Packaging
Scenario 5A
Same as Scenario 5B except relocate Alcoa adhesive laminator
(Instead of replacing dryer system for Adh Lam 461)
Engineering review has concluded the Alcoa laminator will not
feasibly fit in the available footprint at Weston
© 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 26 Packaging
Scenario 5B Evaluation – Changes to Plant Configuration
 No PTEs
 Replace 461 dryer, reduce airflow to 25,000 scfm and improve capture
efficiency to 90%; and
 Install rotary concentrator (Roto 207, Roto 253 & roto floor sweeps)
 Connect Adh Lam 411, Ext Lam 421 and Ext Lam 422 to RTOs; and
 Shutdown Flexo 306; and
 Increase certain stack heights to 18.5 m (61 feet) above ground level; and
 Roto press dryer and room/plant airflow management improvements:
 MUA units as needed
 Added LEL monitoring for Roto Press 208
© 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 27 Packaging
Scenario 5B Evaluation – Changes to Plant Configuration
Scenario 5B Plant Emission Source Configuration
Process Line To APC Equipment or To
Atmosphere
Estimated Solvent Capture Efficiency
Roto 207 To Rotary Concentrator/RTO
System
75%
Roto 253 To Rotary Concentrator/RTO
System
75%
Roto Press
Room Floor
Sweeps
To Rotary Concentrator/RTO
System
Included
Roto 205 To RTO System 75%
Roto 208 To RTO System 90%
Adh Lam 461 To RTO System 90%
Adh Lam 411 To RTO System 80%
Ext Lam 421 To RTO System 80%
Ext Lam 422 To RTO System 80%
© 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 28 Packaging
Summary of Scenario 5B
 Projected in compliance with MOE air toxics standards for n-propyl acetate and
isopropyl acetate; modeling needs to be further completed for remaining solvents
 Cost of project $4.3 million (US) capital and $200,000 expense
 To address the make-up air issue in the plant duct the air from concentrator to the make-
up air for ovens (cost $500,000 US) included above
 There is a question if 461 can meet 90% capture.
Pros
- New oven (decrease in waste and improved efficiency)
- Lower capital cost
- No write-off
- Energy reduction of $450,000 versus today $150,000 versus scenario 4)
Cons
- Time to shutdown and upgrade the process (3 months)
- Risk of achieving the goal of production (quality, drying and start-up time)
© 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 29 Packaging
Summary of Scenario 5C
 In compliance with MOE air toxics standards
 This scenario will include a new laminator for 461instead of new oven or Alcoa laminator
 Cost of project $5.2 million (US) capital and $750,000 expense
 To address the make-up air issue in the plant duct the air from concentrator to the make-
up air for ovens (cost $500,000 US) included above
Pros
- Shutdown 411
- Increase speed and efficiency (400 m/min)
- Easy execution (not shutdown 461)
- No risk of not improving the quality
- Lower operating cost - energy of $450,000 versus today $150,000 versus scenario 4)
- 100% capture
Cons
- Cost of project
- Write-off of laminator 461
© 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 30 Packaging
Summary of Scenarios
Scenario Capital cost Expense cost Total cost
Operating cost
for utilities Comments
1 $8,952,000 $431,000 $9,383,000 Increase
2 $5,216,000 $356,000 $5,572,000 Increase Not meet air toxic
3 $6,896,500 $200,000 $7,096,500 Increase Not meet air toxic
4A $4,550,100 $1,200,000 $5,750,100 Increase Alcoa laminator not fit
4B $4,548,500 $200,000 $4,748,500 Increase Scheduling downtime major issues
4C $5,653,500 $750,000 $6,403,500 Increase
5A $4,269,700 $1,200,000 $5,469,700 Dec $450,000 Alcoa laminator not fit
5B $4,312,100 $200,000 $4,512,100 Dec $450,000 Scheduling downtime major issues
5C $5,213,100 $750,000 $5,963,100 Dec $450,000 Preferred option
Toronto solvent reduction esr presentation 7 15-2008

More Related Content

What's hot

Europe User Conference: GRACE catalyst trial evaluation
Europe User Conference: GRACE catalyst trial evaluationEurope User Conference: GRACE catalyst trial evaluation
Europe User Conference: GRACE catalyst trial evaluation
KBC (A Yokogawa Company)
 
Europe User Conference: ADNOC optimization of hydrocracking process as a func...
Europe User Conference: ADNOC optimization of hydrocracking process as a func...Europe User Conference: ADNOC optimization of hydrocracking process as a func...
Europe User Conference: ADNOC optimization of hydrocracking process as a func...
KBC (A Yokogawa Company)
 
Resume talley 1.5.2016.formatted
Resume talley 1.5.2016.formattedResume talley 1.5.2016.formatted
Resume talley 1.5.2016.formatted
Dennis Talley
 
Compare cryogenic process
Compare cryogenic processCompare cryogenic process
Compare cryogenic process
simachem
 
CO2 capture, transport and geological storage programmes
CO2 capture, transport and geological storage programmesCO2 capture, transport and geological storage programmes
CO2 capture, transport and geological storage programmes
Global CCS Institute
 
New Simulated Distillation Software & Applications
New Simulated Distillation Software & ApplicationsNew Simulated Distillation Software & Applications
New Simulated Distillation Software & Applications
Shimadzu Scientific Instruments
 
Simdis (simulated distillation)
Simdis (simulated distillation)Simdis (simulated distillation)
Simdis (simulated distillation)
Mohammad Amir Akhtar
 
Polymer APC
Polymer APCPolymer APC
Polymer APC
Alexis Piron
 
H05414750
H05414750H05414750
H05414750
IOSR-JEN
 
Experience from TCM, Olav Falk Pedersen (Gassnova) UK/Norway/Canada Meeting 1...
Experience from TCM, Olav Falk Pedersen (Gassnova) UK/Norway/Canada Meeting 1...Experience from TCM, Olav Falk Pedersen (Gassnova) UK/Norway/Canada Meeting 1...
Experience from TCM, Olav Falk Pedersen (Gassnova) UK/Norway/Canada Meeting 1...
UK Carbon Capture and Storage Research Centre
 
Europe User Conference: thermodynamic behaviour of HPHT reservoir fluids and ...
Europe User Conference: thermodynamic behaviour of HPHT reservoir fluids and ...Europe User Conference: thermodynamic behaviour of HPHT reservoir fluids and ...
Europe User Conference: thermodynamic behaviour of HPHT reservoir fluids and ...
KBC (A Yokogawa Company)
 
Brownfield Briefing Ra 2008 Presentation Mfc
Brownfield Briefing Ra 2008 Presentation MfcBrownfield Briefing Ra 2008 Presentation Mfc
Brownfield Briefing Ra 2008 Presentation Mfc
mfchen2002
 
Gas-FACTS - Future Advanced Capture Technology Systems - Jon Gibbins at the U...
Gas-FACTS - Future Advanced Capture Technology Systems - Jon Gibbins at the U...Gas-FACTS - Future Advanced Capture Technology Systems - Jon Gibbins at the U...
Gas-FACTS - Future Advanced Capture Technology Systems - Jon Gibbins at the U...
UK Carbon Capture and Storage Research Centre
 
Chemical process debottlenecking
Chemical process debottleneckingChemical process debottlenecking
Chemical process debottlenecking
Stephen (Steve) Galante
 
Piotr Blaut Student Placement
Piotr Blaut Student PlacementPiotr Blaut Student Placement
Piotr Blaut Student PlacementPiotr Blaut
 
Velocys ppt140730_Velocys_GTL Technology Forum
Velocys ppt140730_Velocys_GTL Technology ForumVelocys ppt140730_Velocys_GTL Technology Forum
Velocys ppt140730_Velocys_GTL Technology ForumJohn Glenning
 
Operating a compost facility to maximize carbon credits
Operating a compost facility to maximize carbon creditsOperating a compost facility to maximize carbon credits
Operating a compost facility to maximize carbon credits
SWANA Northern Lights Chapter
 
AISI Direct Steelmaking Final Report
AISI Direct Steelmaking Final ReportAISI Direct Steelmaking Final Report
AISI Direct Steelmaking Final ReportRobert Meegan
 

What's hot (20)

Europe User Conference: GRACE catalyst trial evaluation
Europe User Conference: GRACE catalyst trial evaluationEurope User Conference: GRACE catalyst trial evaluation
Europe User Conference: GRACE catalyst trial evaluation
 
Europe User Conference: ADNOC optimization of hydrocracking process as a func...
Europe User Conference: ADNOC optimization of hydrocracking process as a func...Europe User Conference: ADNOC optimization of hydrocracking process as a func...
Europe User Conference: ADNOC optimization of hydrocracking process as a func...
 
Resume talley 1.5.2016.formatted
Resume talley 1.5.2016.formattedResume talley 1.5.2016.formatted
Resume talley 1.5.2016.formatted
 
SHREYAS__SABNIS CV
SHREYAS__SABNIS CVSHREYAS__SABNIS CV
SHREYAS__SABNIS CV
 
Compare cryogenic process
Compare cryogenic processCompare cryogenic process
Compare cryogenic process
 
CO2 capture, transport and geological storage programmes
CO2 capture, transport and geological storage programmesCO2 capture, transport and geological storage programmes
CO2 capture, transport and geological storage programmes
 
New Simulated Distillation Software & Applications
New Simulated Distillation Software & ApplicationsNew Simulated Distillation Software & Applications
New Simulated Distillation Software & Applications
 
Simdis (simulated distillation)
Simdis (simulated distillation)Simdis (simulated distillation)
Simdis (simulated distillation)
 
Polymer APC
Polymer APCPolymer APC
Polymer APC
 
H05414750
H05414750H05414750
H05414750
 
Experience from TCM, Olav Falk Pedersen (Gassnova) UK/Norway/Canada Meeting 1...
Experience from TCM, Olav Falk Pedersen (Gassnova) UK/Norway/Canada Meeting 1...Experience from TCM, Olav Falk Pedersen (Gassnova) UK/Norway/Canada Meeting 1...
Experience from TCM, Olav Falk Pedersen (Gassnova) UK/Norway/Canada Meeting 1...
 
Europe User Conference: thermodynamic behaviour of HPHT reservoir fluids and ...
Europe User Conference: thermodynamic behaviour of HPHT reservoir fluids and ...Europe User Conference: thermodynamic behaviour of HPHT reservoir fluids and ...
Europe User Conference: thermodynamic behaviour of HPHT reservoir fluids and ...
 
Brownfield Briefing Ra 2008 Presentation Mfc
Brownfield Briefing Ra 2008 Presentation MfcBrownfield Briefing Ra 2008 Presentation Mfc
Brownfield Briefing Ra 2008 Presentation Mfc
 
Gas-FACTS - Future Advanced Capture Technology Systems - Jon Gibbins at the U...
Gas-FACTS - Future Advanced Capture Technology Systems - Jon Gibbins at the U...Gas-FACTS - Future Advanced Capture Technology Systems - Jon Gibbins at the U...
Gas-FACTS - Future Advanced Capture Technology Systems - Jon Gibbins at the U...
 
Chemical process debottlenecking
Chemical process debottleneckingChemical process debottlenecking
Chemical process debottlenecking
 
Piotr Blaut Student Placement
Piotr Blaut Student PlacementPiotr Blaut Student Placement
Piotr Blaut Student Placement
 
Velocys ppt140730_Velocys_GTL Technology Forum
Velocys ppt140730_Velocys_GTL Technology ForumVelocys ppt140730_Velocys_GTL Technology Forum
Velocys ppt140730_Velocys_GTL Technology Forum
 
SENTHIL PANDIAN CV
SENTHIL PANDIAN CVSENTHIL PANDIAN CV
SENTHIL PANDIAN CV
 
Operating a compost facility to maximize carbon credits
Operating a compost facility to maximize carbon creditsOperating a compost facility to maximize carbon credits
Operating a compost facility to maximize carbon credits
 
AISI Direct Steelmaking Final Report
AISI Direct Steelmaking Final ReportAISI Direct Steelmaking Final Report
AISI Direct Steelmaking Final Report
 

Similar to Toronto solvent reduction esr presentation 7 15-2008

03 Gtz Proklima Hc Residential Ac Systems In India & China Markus Wypior
03 Gtz Proklima Hc Residential Ac Systems In India & China Markus Wypior03 Gtz Proklima Hc Residential Ac Systems In India & China Markus Wypior
03 Gtz Proklima Hc Residential Ac Systems In India & China Markus WypiorKoeppen Halvart
 
State of the art in the pu sub sector-technology options and trends
State of the art in the pu sub sector-technology options and trendsState of the art in the pu sub sector-technology options and trends
State of the art in the pu sub sector-technology options and trends
UNEP OzonAction
 
POX O2 Spargers- Report Summary2 Next STEP
POX O2 Spargers- Report Summary2 Next STEPPOX O2 Spargers- Report Summary2 Next STEP
POX O2 Spargers- Report Summary2 Next STEPChris Galeotti
 
Technologies for Carbon Capture in Oil Refineries
Technologies for Carbon Capture in Oil RefineriesTechnologies for Carbon Capture in Oil Refineries
Technologies for Carbon Capture in Oil Refineriescanaleenergia
 
Field Experience from a Biotechnology Approach to Water Flood Improvement
Field Experience from a Biotechnology Approach to Water Flood ImprovementField Experience from a Biotechnology Approach to Water Flood Improvement
Field Experience from a Biotechnology Approach to Water Flood Improvement
Bill-NewAERO
 
Utilities and oil movement-Final.pdf
Utilities and oil movement-Final.pdfUtilities and oil movement-Final.pdf
Utilities and oil movement-Final.pdf
hariskhalil8
 
P.P.S technical presentation
P.P.S technical presentationP.P.S technical presentation
P.P.S technical presentation
Ornella Ramsarran
 
HGSC Technique Presentation2.pptx
HGSC Technique Presentation2.pptxHGSC Technique Presentation2.pptx
HGSC Technique Presentation2.pptx
hansinagengprakoso1
 
Upgrading co2 removal systems
Upgrading co2 removal systemsUpgrading co2 removal systems
Upgrading co2 removal systems
VK Arora
 
96924703 performance-monitoring-for-gas-turbine
96924703 performance-monitoring-for-gas-turbine96924703 performance-monitoring-for-gas-turbine
96924703 performance-monitoring-for-gas-turbine
manojg1990
 
Dr Wang Rui - Status of Sinopec CCUS technology
Dr Wang Rui - Status of Sinopec CCUS technologyDr Wang Rui - Status of Sinopec CCUS technology
Dr Wang Rui - Status of Sinopec CCUS technology
Global CCS Institute
 
Development of Next Generation Low NOx Combustion Promoters Technical Article...
Development of Next Generation Low NOx Combustion Promoters Technical Article...Development of Next Generation Low NOx Combustion Promoters Technical Article...
Development of Next Generation Low NOx Combustion Promoters Technical Article...Eric F. Griesinger, P.E., CQE
 
Sector Summary - Subsea
Sector Summary - SubseaSector Summary - Subsea
Sector Summary - SubseaThomas Burke
 
Spe Wellhead Compression
Spe Wellhead CompressionSpe Wellhead Compression
Spe Wellhead Compression
jurlaub
 
IRJET- Diesel Particulate Filter by using Copper Oxide as a Filter Medium
IRJET- Diesel Particulate Filter by using Copper Oxide as a Filter MediumIRJET- Diesel Particulate Filter by using Copper Oxide as a Filter Medium
IRJET- Diesel Particulate Filter by using Copper Oxide as a Filter Medium
IRJET Journal
 
Status of US CCS projects and data available
Status of US CCS projects and data availableStatus of US CCS projects and data available
Status of US CCS projects and data available
IEA-ETSAP
 
Control and Reduction of Emissions using Catalytic Converter
Control and Reduction of Emissions using Catalytic ConverterControl and Reduction of Emissions using Catalytic Converter
Control and Reduction of Emissions using Catalytic Converter
IRJET Journal
 
October 2015 EHS Regulatory Update
October 2015 EHS Regulatory UpdateOctober 2015 EHS Regulatory Update
October 2015 EHS Regulatory Update
dhuxl
 
PC200-8 Improvement.ppt excavator kelas 20ton
PC200-8 Improvement.ppt excavator kelas 20tonPC200-8 Improvement.ppt excavator kelas 20ton
PC200-8 Improvement.ppt excavator kelas 20ton
mulyadiwork
 

Similar to Toronto solvent reduction esr presentation 7 15-2008 (20)

03 Gtz Proklima Hc Residential Ac Systems In India & China Markus Wypior
03 Gtz Proklima Hc Residential Ac Systems In India & China Markus Wypior03 Gtz Proklima Hc Residential Ac Systems In India & China Markus Wypior
03 Gtz Proklima Hc Residential Ac Systems In India & China Markus Wypior
 
State of the art in the pu sub sector-technology options and trends
State of the art in the pu sub sector-technology options and trendsState of the art in the pu sub sector-technology options and trends
State of the art in the pu sub sector-technology options and trends
 
POX O2 Spargers- Report Summary2 Next STEP
POX O2 Spargers- Report Summary2 Next STEPPOX O2 Spargers- Report Summary2 Next STEP
POX O2 Spargers- Report Summary2 Next STEP
 
Technologies for Carbon Capture in Oil Refineries
Technologies for Carbon Capture in Oil RefineriesTechnologies for Carbon Capture in Oil Refineries
Technologies for Carbon Capture in Oil Refineries
 
Field Experience from a Biotechnology Approach to Water Flood Improvement
Field Experience from a Biotechnology Approach to Water Flood ImprovementField Experience from a Biotechnology Approach to Water Flood Improvement
Field Experience from a Biotechnology Approach to Water Flood Improvement
 
Utilities and oil movement-Final.pdf
Utilities and oil movement-Final.pdfUtilities and oil movement-Final.pdf
Utilities and oil movement-Final.pdf
 
P.P.S technical presentation
P.P.S technical presentationP.P.S technical presentation
P.P.S technical presentation
 
HGSC Technique Presentation2.pptx
HGSC Technique Presentation2.pptxHGSC Technique Presentation2.pptx
HGSC Technique Presentation2.pptx
 
Upgrading co2 removal systems
Upgrading co2 removal systemsUpgrading co2 removal systems
Upgrading co2 removal systems
 
96924703 performance-monitoring-for-gas-turbine
96924703 performance-monitoring-for-gas-turbine96924703 performance-monitoring-for-gas-turbine
96924703 performance-monitoring-for-gas-turbine
 
Dr Wang Rui - Status of Sinopec CCUS technology
Dr Wang Rui - Status of Sinopec CCUS technologyDr Wang Rui - Status of Sinopec CCUS technology
Dr Wang Rui - Status of Sinopec CCUS technology
 
Development of Next Generation Low NOx Combustion Promoters Technical Article...
Development of Next Generation Low NOx Combustion Promoters Technical Article...Development of Next Generation Low NOx Combustion Promoters Technical Article...
Development of Next Generation Low NOx Combustion Promoters Technical Article...
 
Sector Summary - Subsea
Sector Summary - SubseaSector Summary - Subsea
Sector Summary - Subsea
 
Spe Wellhead Compression
Spe Wellhead CompressionSpe Wellhead Compression
Spe Wellhead Compression
 
IRJET- Diesel Particulate Filter by using Copper Oxide as a Filter Medium
IRJET- Diesel Particulate Filter by using Copper Oxide as a Filter MediumIRJET- Diesel Particulate Filter by using Copper Oxide as a Filter Medium
IRJET- Diesel Particulate Filter by using Copper Oxide as a Filter Medium
 
Status of US CCS projects and data available
Status of US CCS projects and data availableStatus of US CCS projects and data available
Status of US CCS projects and data available
 
Control and Reduction of Emissions using Catalytic Converter
Control and Reduction of Emissions using Catalytic ConverterControl and Reduction of Emissions using Catalytic Converter
Control and Reduction of Emissions using Catalytic Converter
 
October 2015 EHS Regulatory Update
October 2015 EHS Regulatory UpdateOctober 2015 EHS Regulatory Update
October 2015 EHS Regulatory Update
 
PC200-8 Improvement.ppt excavator kelas 20ton
PC200-8 Improvement.ppt excavator kelas 20tonPC200-8 Improvement.ppt excavator kelas 20ton
PC200-8 Improvement.ppt excavator kelas 20ton
 
11-IAGT-202_paper
11-IAGT-202_paper11-IAGT-202_paper
11-IAGT-202_paper
 

More from tasander

Searching For Sustainability
Searching  For SustainabilitySearching  For Sustainability
Searching For Sustainability
tasander
 
Fotos curiosas
Fotos curiosasFotos curiosas
Fotos curiosas
tasander
 
Car recovery
Car recoveryCar recovery
Car recovery
tasander
 
Electrical safety control panel
Electrical safety control panel Electrical safety control panel
Electrical safety control panel
tasander
 
FM 1 44 damage limiting construction presentation May 2008
FM 1 44 damage limiting construction presentation May 2008FM 1 44 damage limiting construction presentation May 2008
FM 1 44 damage limiting construction presentation May 2008
tasander
 
Alcan aluminum recycling
Alcan aluminum recyclingAlcan aluminum recycling
Alcan aluminum recycling
tasander
 
Carbon dioxide fire suppression
Carbon dioxide fire suppressionCarbon dioxide fire suppression
Carbon dioxide fire suppression
tasander
 
Pack ehs tra009 explosion prevention in drying processes training module
Pack ehs tra009  explosion prevention in drying processes training modulePack ehs tra009  explosion prevention in drying processes training module
Pack ehs tra009 explosion prevention in drying processes training module
tasander
 
Crocodiles
CrocodilesCrocodiles
Crocodiles
tasander
 
2003 7 up presentation Halloween
2003 7 up presentation Halloween2003 7 up presentation Halloween
2003 7 up presentation Halloween
tasander
 
2003 7 up presentation
2003 7 up presentation2003 7 up presentation
2003 7 up presentation
tasander
 
Football fast start pres
Football fast start presFootball fast start pres
Football fast start pres
tasander
 
Basketball presentation
Basketball presentationBasketball presentation
Basketball presentation
tasander
 

More from tasander (13)

Searching For Sustainability
Searching  For SustainabilitySearching  For Sustainability
Searching For Sustainability
 
Fotos curiosas
Fotos curiosasFotos curiosas
Fotos curiosas
 
Car recovery
Car recoveryCar recovery
Car recovery
 
Electrical safety control panel
Electrical safety control panel Electrical safety control panel
Electrical safety control panel
 
FM 1 44 damage limiting construction presentation May 2008
FM 1 44 damage limiting construction presentation May 2008FM 1 44 damage limiting construction presentation May 2008
FM 1 44 damage limiting construction presentation May 2008
 
Alcan aluminum recycling
Alcan aluminum recyclingAlcan aluminum recycling
Alcan aluminum recycling
 
Carbon dioxide fire suppression
Carbon dioxide fire suppressionCarbon dioxide fire suppression
Carbon dioxide fire suppression
 
Pack ehs tra009 explosion prevention in drying processes training module
Pack ehs tra009  explosion prevention in drying processes training modulePack ehs tra009  explosion prevention in drying processes training module
Pack ehs tra009 explosion prevention in drying processes training module
 
Crocodiles
CrocodilesCrocodiles
Crocodiles
 
2003 7 up presentation Halloween
2003 7 up presentation Halloween2003 7 up presentation Halloween
2003 7 up presentation Halloween
 
2003 7 up presentation
2003 7 up presentation2003 7 up presentation
2003 7 up presentation
 
Football fast start pres
Football fast start presFootball fast start pres
Football fast start pres
 
Basketball presentation
Basketball presentationBasketball presentation
Basketball presentation
 

Recently uploaded

RAT: Retrieval Augmented Thoughts Elicit Context-Aware Reasoning in Long-Hori...
RAT: Retrieval Augmented Thoughts Elicit Context-Aware Reasoning in Long-Hori...RAT: Retrieval Augmented Thoughts Elicit Context-Aware Reasoning in Long-Hori...
RAT: Retrieval Augmented Thoughts Elicit Context-Aware Reasoning in Long-Hori...
thanhdowork
 
Building Electrical System Design & Installation
Building Electrical System Design & InstallationBuilding Electrical System Design & Installation
Building Electrical System Design & Installation
symbo111
 
一比一原版(SFU毕业证)西蒙菲莎大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版(SFU毕业证)西蒙菲莎大学毕业证成绩单如何办理一比一原版(SFU毕业证)西蒙菲莎大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版(SFU毕业证)西蒙菲莎大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
bakpo1
 
Student information management system project report ii.pdf
Student information management system project report ii.pdfStudent information management system project report ii.pdf
Student information management system project report ii.pdf
Kamal Acharya
 
Industrial Training at Shahjalal Fertilizer Company Limited (SFCL)
Industrial Training at Shahjalal Fertilizer Company Limited (SFCL)Industrial Training at Shahjalal Fertilizer Company Limited (SFCL)
Industrial Training at Shahjalal Fertilizer Company Limited (SFCL)
MdTanvirMahtab2
 
road safety engineering r s e unit 3.pdf
road safety engineering  r s e unit 3.pdfroad safety engineering  r s e unit 3.pdf
road safety engineering r s e unit 3.pdf
VENKATESHvenky89705
 
Tutorial for 16S rRNA Gene Analysis with QIIME2.pdf
Tutorial for 16S rRNA Gene Analysis with QIIME2.pdfTutorial for 16S rRNA Gene Analysis with QIIME2.pdf
Tutorial for 16S rRNA Gene Analysis with QIIME2.pdf
aqil azizi
 
Nuclear Power Economics and Structuring 2024
Nuclear Power Economics and Structuring 2024Nuclear Power Economics and Structuring 2024
Nuclear Power Economics and Structuring 2024
Massimo Talia
 
一比一原版(UofT毕业证)多伦多大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版(UofT毕业证)多伦多大学毕业证成绩单如何办理一比一原版(UofT毕业证)多伦多大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版(UofT毕业证)多伦多大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
ydteq
 
在线办理(ANU毕业证书)澳洲国立大学毕业证录取通知书一模一样
在线办理(ANU毕业证书)澳洲国立大学毕业证录取通知书一模一样在线办理(ANU毕业证书)澳洲国立大学毕业证录取通知书一模一样
在线办理(ANU毕业证书)澳洲国立大学毕业证录取通知书一模一样
obonagu
 
Gen AI Study Jams _ For the GDSC Leads in India.pdf
Gen AI Study Jams _ For the GDSC Leads in India.pdfGen AI Study Jams _ For the GDSC Leads in India.pdf
Gen AI Study Jams _ For the GDSC Leads in India.pdf
gdsczhcet
 
Forklift Classes Overview by Intella Parts
Forklift Classes Overview by Intella PartsForklift Classes Overview by Intella Parts
Forklift Classes Overview by Intella Parts
Intella Parts
 
Immunizing Image Classifiers Against Localized Adversary Attacks
Immunizing Image Classifiers Against Localized Adversary AttacksImmunizing Image Classifiers Against Localized Adversary Attacks
Immunizing Image Classifiers Against Localized Adversary Attacks
gerogepatton
 
一比一原版(IIT毕业证)伊利诺伊理工大学毕业证成绩单专业办理
一比一原版(IIT毕业证)伊利诺伊理工大学毕业证成绩单专业办理一比一原版(IIT毕业证)伊利诺伊理工大学毕业证成绩单专业办理
一比一原版(IIT毕业证)伊利诺伊理工大学毕业证成绩单专业办理
zwunae
 
Investor-Presentation-Q1FY2024 investor presentation document.pptx
Investor-Presentation-Q1FY2024 investor presentation document.pptxInvestor-Presentation-Q1FY2024 investor presentation document.pptx
Investor-Presentation-Q1FY2024 investor presentation document.pptx
AmarGB2
 
English lab ppt no titlespecENG PPTt.pdf
English lab ppt no titlespecENG PPTt.pdfEnglish lab ppt no titlespecENG PPTt.pdf
English lab ppt no titlespecENG PPTt.pdf
BrazilAccount1
 
14 Template Contractual Notice - EOT Application
14 Template Contractual Notice - EOT Application14 Template Contractual Notice - EOT Application
14 Template Contractual Notice - EOT Application
SyedAbiiAzazi1
 
Basic Industrial Engineering terms for apparel
Basic Industrial Engineering terms for apparelBasic Industrial Engineering terms for apparel
Basic Industrial Engineering terms for apparel
top1002
 
Recycled Concrete Aggregate in Construction Part III
Recycled Concrete Aggregate in Construction Part IIIRecycled Concrete Aggregate in Construction Part III
Recycled Concrete Aggregate in Construction Part III
Aditya Rajan Patra
 
Design and Analysis of Algorithms-DP,Backtracking,Graphs,B&B
Design and Analysis of Algorithms-DP,Backtracking,Graphs,B&BDesign and Analysis of Algorithms-DP,Backtracking,Graphs,B&B
Design and Analysis of Algorithms-DP,Backtracking,Graphs,B&B
Sreedhar Chowdam
 

Recently uploaded (20)

RAT: Retrieval Augmented Thoughts Elicit Context-Aware Reasoning in Long-Hori...
RAT: Retrieval Augmented Thoughts Elicit Context-Aware Reasoning in Long-Hori...RAT: Retrieval Augmented Thoughts Elicit Context-Aware Reasoning in Long-Hori...
RAT: Retrieval Augmented Thoughts Elicit Context-Aware Reasoning in Long-Hori...
 
Building Electrical System Design & Installation
Building Electrical System Design & InstallationBuilding Electrical System Design & Installation
Building Electrical System Design & Installation
 
一比一原版(SFU毕业证)西蒙菲莎大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版(SFU毕业证)西蒙菲莎大学毕业证成绩单如何办理一比一原版(SFU毕业证)西蒙菲莎大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版(SFU毕业证)西蒙菲莎大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
 
Student information management system project report ii.pdf
Student information management system project report ii.pdfStudent information management system project report ii.pdf
Student information management system project report ii.pdf
 
Industrial Training at Shahjalal Fertilizer Company Limited (SFCL)
Industrial Training at Shahjalal Fertilizer Company Limited (SFCL)Industrial Training at Shahjalal Fertilizer Company Limited (SFCL)
Industrial Training at Shahjalal Fertilizer Company Limited (SFCL)
 
road safety engineering r s e unit 3.pdf
road safety engineering  r s e unit 3.pdfroad safety engineering  r s e unit 3.pdf
road safety engineering r s e unit 3.pdf
 
Tutorial for 16S rRNA Gene Analysis with QIIME2.pdf
Tutorial for 16S rRNA Gene Analysis with QIIME2.pdfTutorial for 16S rRNA Gene Analysis with QIIME2.pdf
Tutorial for 16S rRNA Gene Analysis with QIIME2.pdf
 
Nuclear Power Economics and Structuring 2024
Nuclear Power Economics and Structuring 2024Nuclear Power Economics and Structuring 2024
Nuclear Power Economics and Structuring 2024
 
一比一原版(UofT毕业证)多伦多大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版(UofT毕业证)多伦多大学毕业证成绩单如何办理一比一原版(UofT毕业证)多伦多大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版(UofT毕业证)多伦多大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
 
在线办理(ANU毕业证书)澳洲国立大学毕业证录取通知书一模一样
在线办理(ANU毕业证书)澳洲国立大学毕业证录取通知书一模一样在线办理(ANU毕业证书)澳洲国立大学毕业证录取通知书一模一样
在线办理(ANU毕业证书)澳洲国立大学毕业证录取通知书一模一样
 
Gen AI Study Jams _ For the GDSC Leads in India.pdf
Gen AI Study Jams _ For the GDSC Leads in India.pdfGen AI Study Jams _ For the GDSC Leads in India.pdf
Gen AI Study Jams _ For the GDSC Leads in India.pdf
 
Forklift Classes Overview by Intella Parts
Forklift Classes Overview by Intella PartsForklift Classes Overview by Intella Parts
Forklift Classes Overview by Intella Parts
 
Immunizing Image Classifiers Against Localized Adversary Attacks
Immunizing Image Classifiers Against Localized Adversary AttacksImmunizing Image Classifiers Against Localized Adversary Attacks
Immunizing Image Classifiers Against Localized Adversary Attacks
 
一比一原版(IIT毕业证)伊利诺伊理工大学毕业证成绩单专业办理
一比一原版(IIT毕业证)伊利诺伊理工大学毕业证成绩单专业办理一比一原版(IIT毕业证)伊利诺伊理工大学毕业证成绩单专业办理
一比一原版(IIT毕业证)伊利诺伊理工大学毕业证成绩单专业办理
 
Investor-Presentation-Q1FY2024 investor presentation document.pptx
Investor-Presentation-Q1FY2024 investor presentation document.pptxInvestor-Presentation-Q1FY2024 investor presentation document.pptx
Investor-Presentation-Q1FY2024 investor presentation document.pptx
 
English lab ppt no titlespecENG PPTt.pdf
English lab ppt no titlespecENG PPTt.pdfEnglish lab ppt no titlespecENG PPTt.pdf
English lab ppt no titlespecENG PPTt.pdf
 
14 Template Contractual Notice - EOT Application
14 Template Contractual Notice - EOT Application14 Template Contractual Notice - EOT Application
14 Template Contractual Notice - EOT Application
 
Basic Industrial Engineering terms for apparel
Basic Industrial Engineering terms for apparelBasic Industrial Engineering terms for apparel
Basic Industrial Engineering terms for apparel
 
Recycled Concrete Aggregate in Construction Part III
Recycled Concrete Aggregate in Construction Part IIIRecycled Concrete Aggregate in Construction Part III
Recycled Concrete Aggregate in Construction Part III
 
Design and Analysis of Algorithms-DP,Backtracking,Graphs,B&B
Design and Analysis of Algorithms-DP,Backtracking,Graphs,B&BDesign and Analysis of Algorithms-DP,Backtracking,Graphs,B&B
Design and Analysis of Algorithms-DP,Backtracking,Graphs,B&B
 

Toronto solvent reduction esr presentation 7 15-2008

  • 2. © 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 2 Packaging Toronto (Weston) Solvent Reduction ESR Review Topics Project Goals Current site Amended Certificate of Approval (C of A) / Previous Air Toxics Dispersion Modeling Potential Future Ministry of Environment (MOE) Control Technology Standards Current site process lines to APC equipment Site solvent emissions (annual) and natural gas consumption (annual) indexed to annual production rates Options under consideration (Scenarios 1 – 3, 4B and 5B)
  • 3. © 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 3 Packaging Project Goals  Minimize Weston’s solvent emission footprint per unit of production by 50%  CY 2007: 0.1089 ton (US) emission / ton (US) production  Goal: 0.0545 ton (US) emission / ton (US) production  Satisfy current and future MOE standards  Decrease airflow volumes exhausted to APC equipment  Minimize additional APC equipment capacity needed  Reduce APC equipment natural gas consumption per unit of production  Improve workplace air quality conditions  Satisfy PACK EHS 009 explosion prevention directive for solvent adhesive laminators (Adh Lam 461 and Adh Lam 411)
  • 4. © 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 4 Packaging Current C of A / Previous Air Toxics Dispersion Modeling Amended C of A Issued Oct. 30, 2005 Due for Expiration Oct. 30, 2010 Approved based on application and dispersion modeling submitted in Sept. 2005 – Oct. 2005 Allowed for Adh Lam 461 and Flexo Press 306 emission to atmosphere (uncontrolled) Modeling (2005) was based on unrealistic (high) capture efficiency rates and unrealistic (low) maximum short-term emission rates Previous C of A approvals and dispersion modeling were based on more representative capture efficiency rates
  • 5. © 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 5 Packaging Potential Future MOE Control Technology Standards Under consideration by MOE for approximately last five years 2006 - 2007 Stakeholder Meetings Comments prepared and filed by Alcan Packaging Facility Profile for Weston prepared by MOE consultant (one of 22); corrections/revisions for Weston filed by Alcan Packaging MOE investigation in to viability of PTEs and overall cost- effectiveness of control technology-based standards 2008 – Beyond Policy/Promulgation via MOE Standards Development Branch
  • 6. © 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 6 Packaging Current Site Process Lines to Oxidizer System  Roto 207; approximately 20,000 scfm; est. 75% capture efficiency  Roto 253; app. 60,000 scfm; est. 75% capture efficiency  Roto 205; app. 36,000 scfm; est. 75% capture efficiency  Roto 208; app. 40,000 scfm; est. 90% capture efficiency  Adh. Lam. 461 (exhausted to atmosphere); app. 50,000 scfm; est. 70% capture efficiency  Flexo. 306 (exhausted to atmosphere); app. 3,000 scfm; est. 90% capture efficiency  Adh. Lam. 411; exhausted to atmosphere; app. 4,000 scfm; est. 80% capture efficiency  Ext. Lam. 421; exhausted to atmosphere; app. 9,000 scfm; est. 80% capture efficiency  Ext. Lam. 422; exhausted to atmosphere; app. 15,000 scfm; est. 80% capture efficiency
  • 7. © 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 7 Packaging Site Solvent Emissions and Natural Gas Consumption in Relation to Production (Reported PDM Data) Site Solvent Emissions (tons, US) 2002 - 2007 Highest CY = 2002 (1,553 tons/year) CY 2004 – CY 2007 in 700 tons/year – 900 tons/year range Natural Gas Consumption (million ft3) 2002 - 2007 CY 2002 = 63.0 million ft3/year Highest CY = 2006 (153.3 million ft3/year) CY 2007 decreased to 126.8 million ft3/year Solvent Emission to Production Ratio (tons US/tons US) CY 2005 – CY 2007 in 0.10 – 0.13 range NG Consumption to Production Ratio (MMft3/tons US) CY 2005 – CY 2007 in 0.015 – 0.022 range
  • 8. © 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 8 Packaging Revised 2005 Baseline Dispersion Modeling Summary o Ethyl alcohol 164% of allowed o Isopropyl acetate 581% of allowed o Toluene 346% of allowed o N-propyl acetate 1,010% of allowed (est. minimum 138% of allowed based on AERMOD) o Ethyl acetate 289% of allowed o VM&P naphtha 486% of allowed o Naphtha (aliphatic) 153% of allowed -All exceed for odor, based on ½-hour allowed standard; - N-propyl acetate AERMOD result is 24 hour based as allowed
  • 9. © 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 9 Packaging MOE June 1 each year – Annual C of A Written Summary/Certification (air toxic certification to permit) MOE Meeting on June 26,2008 Letter to Agency July 7, 2008 - requesting extension to September 5, 2008 for submitting June 1 data and compliance plan Meeting to be scheduled week of July 28 with MOE
  • 10. © 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 10 Packaging Project Options Under Consideration Five Scenarios (1, 2, 3, 4B and 5B) Solvent substitution has been reviewed with Weston technical personnel but is not considered a viable option for MOE compliance given several solvents with modeled baseline exceedances, and quality and customer concerns All five scenarios will help meet project goals other than MOE compliance
  • 11. © 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 11 Packaging Scenario 1 Evaluation – Changes to Plant Configuration Four roto presses, PTE, to RTO system; and New or replacement adh lam (for 461 and 411), PTE, airflow reduced to 25,000 scfm; or Replace 461 dryer, 461 + 411 in PTE, total adh lam airflow reduced to 25,000 scfm; and Shutdown Flexo 306; and Increase certain stack heights to 18.5 m (61 feet) above ground level; and Roto press dryer and room/plant airflow management improvements; and Add at least 50,000 scfm RTO capacity (quadraplex)
  • 12. © 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 12 Packaging Scenario 1 Evaluation – Changes to Plant Configuration Scenario 1 Plant Emission Source Configuration Process Line To Oxidizer or To Atmosphere Estimated Solvent Capture Efficiency Roto 207 To Oxidizer 100% Roto 253 To Oxidizer 100% Roto 205 To Oxidizer 100% Roto 208 To Oxidizer 100% Adh Lam 461 To Oxidizer 100% Adh Lam 411 To Oxidizer (or Shutdown) 100% (Unless Shutdown) Ext Lam 421 1 To Atmosphere 80% Ext Lam 422 1 To Atmosphere 80% Table B Notes: 1. Scenario 1 presumes that Ext Lam 421 and Ext Lam 422 would not be operated simultaneously due to machine-manning operating restrictions.
  • 13. © 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 13 Packaging Summary of Scenario 1 In compliance with MOE air toxics standards Cost of project $9.0 million (US) capital - $400,000 Expense
  • 14. © 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 14 Packaging Scenario 2 Evaluation – Changes to Plant Configuration Four roto presses, PTE, to RTO system; and Adh Lam 411, Ext Lam 421 and Ext Lam 422 exhausted to a relocated 30,000 scfm catalytic oxidizer; and Shutdown Flexo 306; and Increase certain stack heights to 18.5 m (61 feet) above ground level; and Roto press dryer and room/plant airflow management improvements; and Add at least 80,000 scfm RTO capacity (quadraplex)
  • 15. © 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 15 Packaging Scenario 2 Evaluation – Changes to Plant Configuration Scenario 2 Plant Emission Source Configuration Process Line To Oxidizer or To Atmosphere Estimated Solvent Capture Efficiency Roto 207 To Oxidizer 100% Roto 253 To Oxidizer 100% Roto 205 To Oxidizer 100% Roto 208 To Oxidizer 100% Adh Lam 461 To Atmosphere 70% Adh Lam 411 To Oxidizer 80% Ext Lam 421 1 To Oxidizer 80% Ext Lam 422 1 To Oxidizer 80% Table C Notes: 1. Scenario 1 presumes that Ext Lam 421 and Ext Lam 422 would not be operated simultaneously due to machine-manning operating restrictions.
  • 16. © 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 16 Packaging Summary of Scenario 2 Not in compliance with MOE air toxics standards (n-propyl acetate at 264%) Cost of project $5.2 million (US) capital and $400,000 expense.
  • 17. © 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 17 Packaging Scenario 3 Evaluation – Changes to Plant Configuration  No PTEs  Replace 461 dryer, reduce airflow to 25,000 scfm; and  Adh Lam 411, Ext Lam 421, Ext Lam 422 exhausted to a relocated 30,000 scfm catalytic oxidizer; and  Shutdown Flexo 306; and  Increase certain stack heights to 18.5 m (61 feet) above ground level; and Roto press dryer and room/plant airflow management improvements:  MUA units as needed  Roto Press 253 thermal fluid system  Added LEL monitoring for Roto Press 208  Recirculation ductwork modifications for Roto Press 205
  • 18. © 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 18 Packaging Scenario 3 Evaluation – Changes to Plant Configuration Scenario 3 Plant Emission Source Configuration Process Line To APC Equipment or To Atmosphere Estimated Solvent Capture Efficiency Roto 207 To RTO System 75% Roto 253 To RTO System 75% Roto 205 To RTO System 75% Roto 208 To RTO System 90% Adh Lam 461 To RTO System 70% Adh Lam 411 To Catalytic Oxidizer 80% Ext Lam 421 To Catalytic Oxidizer 80% Ext Lam 422 To Catalytic Oxidizer 80%
  • 19. © 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 19 Packaging Summary of Scenario 3 Not in compliance with MOE air toxics standards (isopropyl acetate at 184%) Cost of project $6.9 million (US) capital and $200,000 expense Cost includes air make-up at a cost of $1.05 million (US)
  • 20. © 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 20 Packaging Scenario 4A Same as Scenario 4B except relocate Alcoa adhesive laminator (Instead of replacing dryer system for Adh Lam 461) Engineering review has concluded the Alcoa laminator will not feasibly fit in the available footprint at Weston
  • 21. © 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 21 Packaging Scenario 4B Evaluation – Changes to Plant Configuration  No PTEs  Replace 461 dryer, reduce airflow to 25,000 scfm and improve capture efficiency to 90%; and  Install relocated 30,000 scfm catalytic oxidizer and connect with RTOs (quadraplex); connect Adh Lam 411, Ext Lam 421 and Ext Lam 422; and  Shutdown Flexo 306; and  Increase certain stack heights to 18.5 m (61 feet) above ground level; and  Roto press dryer and room/plant airflow management improvements:  MUA units as needed  Roto Press 253 - tie-in to Roto Press 208 thermal fluid system  Added LEL monitoring for Roto Press 208
  • 22. © 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 22 Packaging Scenario 4B Evaluation – Changes to Plant Configuration Scenario 4B Plant Emission Source Configuration Process Line To APC Equipment or To Atmosphere Estimated Solvent Capture Efficiency Roto 207 To RTO/Catalytic Oxidizer System 75% Roto 253 To RTO/Catalytic Oxidizer System 75% Roto 205 To RTO/Catalytic Oxidizer System 75% Roto 208 To RTO/Catalytic Oxidizer System 90% Adh Lam 461 To RTO/Catalytic Oxidizer System 90% Adh Lam 411 To RTO/Catalytic Oxidizer System 80% Ext Lam 421 To RTO/Catalytic Oxidizer System 80% Ext Lam 422 To RTO/Catalytic Oxidizer System 80%
  • 23. © 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 23 Packaging Summary of Scenario 4B In compliance with MOE air toxics standards Cost of project $4.5 million (US) capital and $200,000 expense Cost includes air make-up at a cost of $1.05 million (US) There is a question if 461 can meet 90% capture.
  • 24. © 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 24 Packaging Summary of Scenario 4C In compliance with MOE air toxics standards This scenario will include a new laminator for 461instead of new oven or Alcoa laminator Cost of project $5.6 million (US) capital and $750,000 Expense Cost includes air make-up at a cost of $1.05 million (US)
  • 25. © 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 25 Packaging Scenario 5A Same as Scenario 5B except relocate Alcoa adhesive laminator (Instead of replacing dryer system for Adh Lam 461) Engineering review has concluded the Alcoa laminator will not feasibly fit in the available footprint at Weston
  • 26. © 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 26 Packaging Scenario 5B Evaluation – Changes to Plant Configuration  No PTEs  Replace 461 dryer, reduce airflow to 25,000 scfm and improve capture efficiency to 90%; and  Install rotary concentrator (Roto 207, Roto 253 & roto floor sweeps)  Connect Adh Lam 411, Ext Lam 421 and Ext Lam 422 to RTOs; and  Shutdown Flexo 306; and  Increase certain stack heights to 18.5 m (61 feet) above ground level; and  Roto press dryer and room/plant airflow management improvements:  MUA units as needed  Added LEL monitoring for Roto Press 208
  • 27. © 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 27 Packaging Scenario 5B Evaluation – Changes to Plant Configuration Scenario 5B Plant Emission Source Configuration Process Line To APC Equipment or To Atmosphere Estimated Solvent Capture Efficiency Roto 207 To Rotary Concentrator/RTO System 75% Roto 253 To Rotary Concentrator/RTO System 75% Roto Press Room Floor Sweeps To Rotary Concentrator/RTO System Included Roto 205 To RTO System 75% Roto 208 To RTO System 90% Adh Lam 461 To RTO System 90% Adh Lam 411 To RTO System 80% Ext Lam 421 To RTO System 80% Ext Lam 422 To RTO System 80%
  • 28. © 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 28 Packaging Summary of Scenario 5B  Projected in compliance with MOE air toxics standards for n-propyl acetate and isopropyl acetate; modeling needs to be further completed for remaining solvents  Cost of project $4.3 million (US) capital and $200,000 expense  To address the make-up air issue in the plant duct the air from concentrator to the make- up air for ovens (cost $500,000 US) included above  There is a question if 461 can meet 90% capture. Pros - New oven (decrease in waste and improved efficiency) - Lower capital cost - No write-off - Energy reduction of $450,000 versus today $150,000 versus scenario 4) Cons - Time to shutdown and upgrade the process (3 months) - Risk of achieving the goal of production (quality, drying and start-up time)
  • 29. © 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 29 Packaging Summary of Scenario 5C  In compliance with MOE air toxics standards  This scenario will include a new laminator for 461instead of new oven or Alcoa laminator  Cost of project $5.2 million (US) capital and $750,000 expense  To address the make-up air issue in the plant duct the air from concentrator to the make- up air for ovens (cost $500,000 US) included above Pros - Shutdown 411 - Increase speed and efficiency (400 m/min) - Easy execution (not shutdown 461) - No risk of not improving the quality - Lower operating cost - energy of $450,000 versus today $150,000 versus scenario 4) - 100% capture Cons - Cost of project - Write-off of laminator 461
  • 30. © 2 0 08 A L C A N I N C.Slide 30 Packaging Summary of Scenarios Scenario Capital cost Expense cost Total cost Operating cost for utilities Comments 1 $8,952,000 $431,000 $9,383,000 Increase 2 $5,216,000 $356,000 $5,572,000 Increase Not meet air toxic 3 $6,896,500 $200,000 $7,096,500 Increase Not meet air toxic 4A $4,550,100 $1,200,000 $5,750,100 Increase Alcoa laminator not fit 4B $4,548,500 $200,000 $4,748,500 Increase Scheduling downtime major issues 4C $5,653,500 $750,000 $6,403,500 Increase 5A $4,269,700 $1,200,000 $5,469,700 Dec $450,000 Alcoa laminator not fit 5B $4,312,100 $200,000 $4,512,100 Dec $450,000 Scheduling downtime major issues 5C $5,213,100 $750,000 $5,963,100 Dec $450,000 Preferred option