Thermal Power Stations
Efficiency & Heat Rate
1
Manohar Tatwawadi
3/2/2021
Thermal Power Cycle Schemetic
S
T
A
C
K
DRUM
FURNACE
SH
RH
ECON
A
P
H
A
P
H
PA FANS FD FANS
ID FANS
HOT PA
HEADER
COLD PA
HEADER
BUNKER,
RCF & CM
ESP
ESP
HP
HEATERS
LP
HEATERS,
EJECTOR,
GS
COOLER
CON
HP IP
LP
GEN
DEAIRATOR
FEED TANK
Boiler Feed Pumps
CEP
210 MW
P-130, T- 540
P-28, T- 320
P-24, T- 535
P-1.32, T- 180
P-0.0889, T- 43
P-0.0889, T- 43
P-22, T- 43
CW in,
T- 30
CW out,
T- 41
T- 156
T- 167
P-150 T- 173
T- 255
T- 340
P-145
T- 340
2
Manohar Tatwawadi
3/2/2021
B
o
i
l
e
r
s 3
Manohar Tatwawadi
3/2/2021
Turbines
4
Manohar Tatwawadi
3/2/2021
Efficiency
Efficiency = Output / Input
Output = Input - Losses
(Input - Losses)
Input
Efficiency =
Efficiency =
(100 - Losses)
100
5
Manohar Tatwawadi
3/2/2021
Losses in Boiler & Efficiency
(As per Designer)
Heat Supplied to
Turbine (Output)
Heat Lost
in hot flue
gasses = 6%
Other Losses
1 Moisture in Fuel 1.2%.
2 Moisture in Air 0.1%
3 Hydrogen in Fuel 5.00%
4 Radiation Loss 0.2%.
Heat Lost in Unburnt in Fly
and Bottom Ash = 0.4%
Total Heat
Input = 100%
C
H
I
M
N
E
Y
E.S.P.
F
U
R
N
A
C
E
AirHeater
IDFan
Boiler Efficiency = 86.5%
Excess Air
Loss = 0.75%
6
Manohar Tatwawadi
3/2/2021
HP Turbine Efficiency
Inlet Steam
130kg/sq.cm.
5350C
Outlet Steam
30kg/sq.cm.
2800C
HP Turbine Efficiency
= 81.11%
7
Manohar Tatwawadi
3/2/2021
IP Turbine Efficiency
Inlet Steam
27kg/sq.cm.
5350C
Outlet Steam
1.2kg/sq.cm.
2000C
IP Turbine Efficiency
= 89.83%
8
Manohar Tatwawadi
3/2/2021
LP Turbine Efficiency
Inlet Steam from IPT
0.09 kg/sq.cm. abs 470C
Outlet Steam to condenser
1.2kg/sq.cm.
2000C
LP Turbine Efficiency
= 85%
9
Manohar Tatwawadi
3/2/2021
HP Turbine Efficiency = 81.11%
IP Turbine Efficiency = 89.83 %
LP Turbine Efficiency =85.00 %
Turbine Efficiencies
(Design Efficiencies)
10
Manohar Tatwawadi
3/2/2021
Turbine Losses
Internal Losses
1. Nozzle Friction
2. Blade Friction
3. Disc Friction
4. Diaphragm gland and Blade tip leakage
5. Partial Admission
6. Wetness at Exhaust
11
Manohar Tatwawadi
3/2/2021
Turbine Losses contd…
External Losses
1. Shaft Gland leakages
12
Manohar Tatwawadi
3/2/2021
Cylinder Efficiency
Causes of deterioration
1. Damage to blades caused by debris getting
past the strainers
2. Damage to tip seals and inter-stage glands.
3. Deposition on blades (Last few IP Stages &
first few LP Stages.
13
Manohar Tatwawadi
3/2/2021
Generator Losses &
Efficiency
1. Copper Losses (I2R)
2. Iron Losses
3. Other Losses
All the above losses account to 2%
Hence the Generator Efficiency = 98%
14
Manohar Tatwawadi
3/2/2021
Steam Cycle Efficiency
Water
Steam
Turbine
Heat Energy
Energy Converted to
Electrical Energy = 40%
100%
Cycle Efficiency = 40%
Heat Taken
away in
Condenser
= 60%
15
Manohar Tatwawadi
3/2/2021
HEAT RATE
One Unit 1 KWH = 860 Kcal heat
Heat required to generate 1 KWH
is the heat rate
Unit of Heat Rate is KCAL / KWH
16
Manohar Tatwawadi
3/2/2021
Energy generated by the generator and
losses
Energy
generated
1KWH
(860KCAL)
Energy going out of generator
in the form of heat 20 KCAL
Generator
Energy
given to
the
generator
880 KCAL
17
Manohar Tatwawadi
3/2/2021
TURBINE HEAT RATE & LOSSES
Energy given to
the generator
880 KCAL
Heat going
out from
condenser
CW System
962 KCAL
Energy
supplied by
the boiler =
Turbine Heat
Rate (2065
KCAL)
Other Losses in Turbine
& Heaters 223 KCAL
Condenser
L.P.T
To CEP
18
Manohar Tatwawadi
3/2/2021
Heat Lossesin the Boiler & Unit Heat Rate
(As per Manufacturer)
Heat Supplied
to Turbine
2065 Kcal
Heat
Lost to
Flue gas
122 Kcal
Other Losses
1 Moisture in Coal 30 Kcal
2 Hydrogen in Coal 150 Kcal
3 Radiation Losses 5 Kcal.
Heat in BA & FA
Unburnt Coal 24 Kcal
Total Heat
Supplied
to Unit
2396 Kcal
C
H
I
M
N
E
Y
E.S.P.
F
U
R
N
A
C
E
AirHeater
IDFan
19
Manohar Tatwawadi
3/2/2021
GROSS UNIT HEAT RATE
1. Gross Turbine Heat Rate = 2065 Kcal/KWh
2. Heat Losses in Boiler = 331 Kcal
3. Gross Unit Heat Rate = 2396 Kcal/Kwh (GUHR)
4. Heat Value of Coal (GCV)= 3500 Kcal/Kg
5. Coal required for Generation of 1 KWh =2396/3500
= 0.68 Kg.
Reducing the HEAT RATE will reduce
the consumption of Coal and SAVE
COAL. 20
Manohar Tatwawadi
3/2/2021
HEAT RATE of 210 MW UNIT
S
T
A
C
K
DRUM
FURNACE
SH
RH
ECON
A
P
H
A
P
H
PA FANS FD FANS
ID FANS
HOT PA
HEADER
COLD PA
HEADER
BUNKER,
RCF & CM
ESP
ESP
HP
HEATERS
LP
HEATERS,
EJECTOR,
GS
COOLER
CONDE
NSER
HP IP
LP
GEN
DEAIRATOR
FEED TANK
Boiler Feed Pumps
CEP
HOT PRIMARY AIR
HOT SECONDARY AIR
860 ¹ˆ Å
. ˆ Á
Å
. /1
¹ˆ Å̈
¸Á
‚ (¡¸º
¹›¸’ )
Stn. Aux-
51 Kcal

¸›¸ú
°¸¸÷
¸ú
¥¸­¸›¸ú- 20 ˆ Å
ú
. ˆ Á
Å
880¹ˆÅ
. ˆÁ
Å
.
Heat Rejected
962 Kcal
Total Turbine
Losses includes
Heat Rejected - 1185
Kcal
Energy Input
to Turbine
2065 Kcal
Stack Loss
122 Kcal
Unburnt-24 Kcal
H2 fuel-150 Kcal
H2O fuel-30Kcal
Radiation- 5Kcal
Total -210 Kcal
Total Boiler Losses -
331 Kcal
Total Boiler Input -
2396 Kcal
Design Turbine Heat Rate - GTHR - 2065 Kcal/Kwh
and Gross Unit Heat Rate- GUHR - 2396 Kcal/Kwh
* Any amount of energy or heat/Coal/Water going out of cycle is increasing the heat rate.
21
Manohar Tatwawadi
3/2/2021
BOILER OPTIMISATION
Boiler Efficiency Optimisation
A. Optimising of Total Air supplies
Too Little air will cause Unburnt Losses and too
much air will increase the dry flue gas losses.
Carbon monoxide monitor can be effectively
used for enabling supply of correct quantity of
air for combustion (Residual CO Typical 100
PPM)
22
Manohar Tatwawadi
3/2/2021
BOILER OPTIMISATION
Boiler Efficiency Optimisation
B. Unburnt in BA & FA
Normally 4.8% in BA and 0.8% in FA
•Measure of effectiveness of Combustion
Process and Milling plant
•Proper Adjustment of Supply of Secondary air
•Furnace leakages
23
Manohar Tatwawadi
3/2/2021
BOILER OPTIMISATION
C. Air Heater gas outlet temperature
Causes for high APH gas outlet Temp
1. Ineffective APH Soot blowers
2. Holed & Torn elements generally at the
cold end.
3. Deposits on Water tubes, Superheater 7
reheater
Boiler Efficiency Optimisation
24
Manohar Tatwawadi
3/2/2021
BOILER OPTIMISATION
Other Causes for high APH gas outlet Temp
High Excess air--- if very high will decrease the FG Temp
Low FW Temp at Eco Inlet
Defective Baffles in FG Path
Poor milling & Poor combustion resulting in long burnoff
time resulting in fouling as well.
Use of High row of burners at low loads
Air leakages before combustion chamber
25
Manohar Tatwawadi
3/2/2021
UNIT OPTIMISATION
Monitor following parameters for taking
necessary steps for Unit Optimisation
1. Condenser Vacuum
2. Main Steam Press and Temp at Turbine Inlet
3. Reheat Temp at Turbine Inlet
4. Feed water temp at Eco Inlet
5. Boiler Excess air
6. Unburnt in Ash
7. APH gas outlet temp
8. Make up water consumption
26
Manohar Tatwawadi
3/2/2021
SAVING OF HEAT IS SAVING OF
COAL AND SAVING OF MONEY
Cost of Coal = Rs 1800/- Ton
= Rs 1.80 /Kg
Heat in 1 Kg of coal = 3500 Kcal (Minimum)
If the Heat Rate is
reduced by 50 Kcal
the value of 50 Kcal
= 2.5 Paise/Unit (KWh
Units generated by a 210 MW Unit in one day = 5040000 KWh
Hence saving per day = 5040000X2.5 Paise
= Rs 1,26,000/- Per day per unit
27
Manohar Tatwawadi
3/2/2021
28
Manohar Tatwawadi
3/2/2021

Thermal power plant efficiency

  • 1.
    Thermal Power Stations Efficiency& Heat Rate 1 Manohar Tatwawadi 3/2/2021
  • 2.
    Thermal Power CycleSchemetic S T A C K DRUM FURNACE SH RH ECON A P H A P H PA FANS FD FANS ID FANS HOT PA HEADER COLD PA HEADER BUNKER, RCF & CM ESP ESP HP HEATERS LP HEATERS, EJECTOR, GS COOLER CON HP IP LP GEN DEAIRATOR FEED TANK Boiler Feed Pumps CEP 210 MW P-130, T- 540 P-28, T- 320 P-24, T- 535 P-1.32, T- 180 P-0.0889, T- 43 P-0.0889, T- 43 P-22, T- 43 CW in, T- 30 CW out, T- 41 T- 156 T- 167 P-150 T- 173 T- 255 T- 340 P-145 T- 340 2 Manohar Tatwawadi 3/2/2021
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 5.
    Efficiency Efficiency = Output/ Input Output = Input - Losses (Input - Losses) Input Efficiency = Efficiency = (100 - Losses) 100 5 Manohar Tatwawadi 3/2/2021
  • 6.
    Losses in Boiler& Efficiency (As per Designer) Heat Supplied to Turbine (Output) Heat Lost in hot flue gasses = 6% Other Losses 1 Moisture in Fuel 1.2%. 2 Moisture in Air 0.1% 3 Hydrogen in Fuel 5.00% 4 Radiation Loss 0.2%. Heat Lost in Unburnt in Fly and Bottom Ash = 0.4% Total Heat Input = 100% C H I M N E Y E.S.P. F U R N A C E AirHeater IDFan Boiler Efficiency = 86.5% Excess Air Loss = 0.75% 6 Manohar Tatwawadi 3/2/2021
  • 7.
    HP Turbine Efficiency InletSteam 130kg/sq.cm. 5350C Outlet Steam 30kg/sq.cm. 2800C HP Turbine Efficiency = 81.11% 7 Manohar Tatwawadi 3/2/2021
  • 8.
    IP Turbine Efficiency InletSteam 27kg/sq.cm. 5350C Outlet Steam 1.2kg/sq.cm. 2000C IP Turbine Efficiency = 89.83% 8 Manohar Tatwawadi 3/2/2021
  • 9.
    LP Turbine Efficiency InletSteam from IPT 0.09 kg/sq.cm. abs 470C Outlet Steam to condenser 1.2kg/sq.cm. 2000C LP Turbine Efficiency = 85% 9 Manohar Tatwawadi 3/2/2021
  • 10.
    HP Turbine Efficiency= 81.11% IP Turbine Efficiency = 89.83 % LP Turbine Efficiency =85.00 % Turbine Efficiencies (Design Efficiencies) 10 Manohar Tatwawadi 3/2/2021
  • 11.
    Turbine Losses Internal Losses 1.Nozzle Friction 2. Blade Friction 3. Disc Friction 4. Diaphragm gland and Blade tip leakage 5. Partial Admission 6. Wetness at Exhaust 11 Manohar Tatwawadi 3/2/2021
  • 12.
    Turbine Losses contd… ExternalLosses 1. Shaft Gland leakages 12 Manohar Tatwawadi 3/2/2021
  • 13.
    Cylinder Efficiency Causes ofdeterioration 1. Damage to blades caused by debris getting past the strainers 2. Damage to tip seals and inter-stage glands. 3. Deposition on blades (Last few IP Stages & first few LP Stages. 13 Manohar Tatwawadi 3/2/2021
  • 14.
    Generator Losses & Efficiency 1.Copper Losses (I2R) 2. Iron Losses 3. Other Losses All the above losses account to 2% Hence the Generator Efficiency = 98% 14 Manohar Tatwawadi 3/2/2021
  • 15.
    Steam Cycle Efficiency Water Steam Turbine HeatEnergy Energy Converted to Electrical Energy = 40% 100% Cycle Efficiency = 40% Heat Taken away in Condenser = 60% 15 Manohar Tatwawadi 3/2/2021
  • 16.
    HEAT RATE One Unit1 KWH = 860 Kcal heat Heat required to generate 1 KWH is the heat rate Unit of Heat Rate is KCAL / KWH 16 Manohar Tatwawadi 3/2/2021
  • 17.
    Energy generated bythe generator and losses Energy generated 1KWH (860KCAL) Energy going out of generator in the form of heat 20 KCAL Generator Energy given to the generator 880 KCAL 17 Manohar Tatwawadi 3/2/2021
  • 18.
    TURBINE HEAT RATE& LOSSES Energy given to the generator 880 KCAL Heat going out from condenser CW System 962 KCAL Energy supplied by the boiler = Turbine Heat Rate (2065 KCAL) Other Losses in Turbine & Heaters 223 KCAL Condenser L.P.T To CEP 18 Manohar Tatwawadi 3/2/2021
  • 19.
    Heat Lossesin theBoiler & Unit Heat Rate (As per Manufacturer) Heat Supplied to Turbine 2065 Kcal Heat Lost to Flue gas 122 Kcal Other Losses 1 Moisture in Coal 30 Kcal 2 Hydrogen in Coal 150 Kcal 3 Radiation Losses 5 Kcal. Heat in BA & FA Unburnt Coal 24 Kcal Total Heat Supplied to Unit 2396 Kcal C H I M N E Y E.S.P. F U R N A C E AirHeater IDFan 19 Manohar Tatwawadi 3/2/2021
  • 20.
    GROSS UNIT HEATRATE 1. Gross Turbine Heat Rate = 2065 Kcal/KWh 2. Heat Losses in Boiler = 331 Kcal 3. Gross Unit Heat Rate = 2396 Kcal/Kwh (GUHR) 4. Heat Value of Coal (GCV)= 3500 Kcal/Kg 5. Coal required for Generation of 1 KWh =2396/3500 = 0.68 Kg. Reducing the HEAT RATE will reduce the consumption of Coal and SAVE COAL. 20 Manohar Tatwawadi 3/2/2021
  • 21.
    HEAT RATE of210 MW UNIT S T A C K DRUM FURNACE SH RH ECON A P H A P H PA FANS FD FANS ID FANS HOT PA HEADER COLD PA HEADER BUNKER, RCF & CM ESP ESP HP HEATERS LP HEATERS, EJECTOR, GS COOLER CONDE NSER HP IP LP GEN DEAIRATOR FEED TANK Boiler Feed Pumps CEP HOT PRIMARY AIR HOT SECONDARY AIR 860 ¹ˆ Å . ˆ Á Å . /1 ¹ˆ Å̈ ¸Á ‚ (¡¸º ¹›¸’ ) Stn. Aux- 51 Kcal  ¸›¸ú °¸¸÷ ¸ú ¥¸­¸›¸ú- 20 ˆ Å ú . ˆ Á Å 880¹ˆÅ . ˆÁ Å . Heat Rejected 962 Kcal Total Turbine Losses includes Heat Rejected - 1185 Kcal Energy Input to Turbine 2065 Kcal Stack Loss 122 Kcal Unburnt-24 Kcal H2 fuel-150 Kcal H2O fuel-30Kcal Radiation- 5Kcal Total -210 Kcal Total Boiler Losses - 331 Kcal Total Boiler Input - 2396 Kcal Design Turbine Heat Rate - GTHR - 2065 Kcal/Kwh and Gross Unit Heat Rate- GUHR - 2396 Kcal/Kwh * Any amount of energy or heat/Coal/Water going out of cycle is increasing the heat rate. 21 Manohar Tatwawadi 3/2/2021
  • 22.
    BOILER OPTIMISATION Boiler EfficiencyOptimisation A. Optimising of Total Air supplies Too Little air will cause Unburnt Losses and too much air will increase the dry flue gas losses. Carbon monoxide monitor can be effectively used for enabling supply of correct quantity of air for combustion (Residual CO Typical 100 PPM) 22 Manohar Tatwawadi 3/2/2021
  • 23.
    BOILER OPTIMISATION Boiler EfficiencyOptimisation B. Unburnt in BA & FA Normally 4.8% in BA and 0.8% in FA •Measure of effectiveness of Combustion Process and Milling plant •Proper Adjustment of Supply of Secondary air •Furnace leakages 23 Manohar Tatwawadi 3/2/2021
  • 24.
    BOILER OPTIMISATION C. AirHeater gas outlet temperature Causes for high APH gas outlet Temp 1. Ineffective APH Soot blowers 2. Holed & Torn elements generally at the cold end. 3. Deposits on Water tubes, Superheater 7 reheater Boiler Efficiency Optimisation 24 Manohar Tatwawadi 3/2/2021
  • 25.
    BOILER OPTIMISATION Other Causesfor high APH gas outlet Temp High Excess air--- if very high will decrease the FG Temp Low FW Temp at Eco Inlet Defective Baffles in FG Path Poor milling & Poor combustion resulting in long burnoff time resulting in fouling as well. Use of High row of burners at low loads Air leakages before combustion chamber 25 Manohar Tatwawadi 3/2/2021
  • 26.
    UNIT OPTIMISATION Monitor followingparameters for taking necessary steps for Unit Optimisation 1. Condenser Vacuum 2. Main Steam Press and Temp at Turbine Inlet 3. Reheat Temp at Turbine Inlet 4. Feed water temp at Eco Inlet 5. Boiler Excess air 6. Unburnt in Ash 7. APH gas outlet temp 8. Make up water consumption 26 Manohar Tatwawadi 3/2/2021
  • 27.
    SAVING OF HEATIS SAVING OF COAL AND SAVING OF MONEY Cost of Coal = Rs 1800/- Ton = Rs 1.80 /Kg Heat in 1 Kg of coal = 3500 Kcal (Minimum) If the Heat Rate is reduced by 50 Kcal the value of 50 Kcal = 2.5 Paise/Unit (KWh Units generated by a 210 MW Unit in one day = 5040000 KWh Hence saving per day = 5040000X2.5 Paise = Rs 1,26,000/- Per day per unit 27 Manohar Tatwawadi 3/2/2021
  • 28.