TEACHERS’ AND STUDENTS’ PERCEPTIONS
TOWARDS THE USE OF MOBILE PHONES AS
A TOOL FOR OPEN AND DISTANCE
LEARNING IN TANZANIA


                             Ayoub C Kafyulilo
                Dar es salaam University College of Education
                                     &
                                Petra Fisser
                            University of Twente

 Paper presented at the DEASA International conference for open and distance
 learning, from 30th September to 2nd October 2011, in Dar es salaam, Tanzania
INTRODUCTION
 Efforts to integrate technology in education in
  Tanzania started in 1997
 This is the period when the first computer
  syllabus was introduced in schools
 However these efforts encountered some
  challenges:
     Lack of technological tools in most of the schools
     Lack of a policy for technology in education
     Lack of skilled teachers
     Lack of reliable supply of electricity in most schools
     Limited access to internet
INTRODUCTION
 For a developing country like Tanzania where
  technology is not well embraced; a mobile
  phone becomes a vital ICT tool in schools
 Mobile phones are affordable to large
  community of Tanzanians in terms of both cost
  and usability.
 A mobile phone offers varieties of user options:
  internet, radio, video, audio, camera, mp3 etc.
 In addition, a mobile phone is handy; making it
  user friendly beyond the classroom walls.
PROBLEMS AND RESEARCH QUESTIONS
 Studies have shown that mobile phones use in
  education in Tanzania, is limited.
 Thus, our interest is to find out;
     What  is the level of accessibility of mobile phones
      to teachers and students?
     To what extent are mobile phones used in both
      teaching and learning processes?
     How do teachers and students perceive mobile
      phones as a tool for teaching and learning?
METHODOLOGY
 The present paper is an outcome of two
  independent studies carried out at DUCE in
  2010 and Kibasila secondary school in 2011
 At DUCE, the study adopted the action research
  design while at Kibasila a survey research
  design.
 29 pre-service teachers and 4 instructors from
  DUCE; also 12 teachers and 40 students from
  Kibasila participated in the study.
 Data were collected by using teachers’ and
  instructors’ interview as well as pre-service
  teachers’ and students’ questionnaire.
FINDINGS
Accessibility to various technological tools to
both pre-service teachers and school students

 Technological tool         DUCE         Kibasila
                            M (SD)       M (SD)
Computer (PC or laptop)   2.34 (0.55)   1.89 (0.83)
Radio                     2.21 (0.86)   2.02 (0.74)
Audio Equipment (Mp3)     1.34 (0.67)   1.04 (0.97)
iPods                     1.24 (0.58)   1.06 (0.98)
Mobile Phones             2.73 (0.94)   2.48 (0.88)
Digital Camera            1.40 (0.54)   1.25 (0.65)
Television                1.97 (0.82)   1.71 (0.87)
USE OF VARIOUS TECHNOLOGICAL
TOOLS IN LEARNING AT DUCE AND
KIBASILA
Technological Tool        DUCE         Kibasila
                          M (SD)        M (SD)
Personal Computers      3.34 (1.72)   2.46 (1.43)
Radio                   3.17 (1.79)   2.23 (1.29)
Audio equipment (Mp3)   2.16 (1.74)   1.64 (1.61)
iPod                    1.59 (1.38)   1.48 (1.08)
Mobile Phones           2.03 (2.18)   1.25 (1.23)
Digital photo camera    2.48 (1.72)   1.35 (1.42)
Television              3.00 (2.20)   2.40 (1.92)
PERCEPTIONS OF PRE-SERVICE TEACHERS ON
MOBILE PHONES USE
                                                          M    SD
The use of mobile phones in learning is interesting      4.62 0.50
Design of the lesson with a mobile phone was of interest 4.38 0.57
Mobile phones have enhanced my pedagogical competency 4.42 0.58
Mobile phones have enhanced my technology competency        4.54 0.71
The use of mobile phones enhance my thinking on how         4.69 0.55
technology can transform learning
If I learn how to use mobile phones I will use it in my     4.50 0.65
classroom
Mobile phones can replace computers                         3.88 1.31
Since I know about the use of mobile phone in teaching, I   4.46 0.65
will use technology in teaching
PERCEPTIONS OF SCHOOL STUDENTS ON THE
USE OF MOBILE PHONES IN LEARNING

                                                         M      SD
I am interested to learn by using a mobile phone        4.05   0.97
Mobile phones can make me more involved in learning 4.43       0.84
Use of mobile phones can simplify learning              4.58   0.68
Mobile phones can help me to learn beyond a classroom 4.10     1.01
Through a mobile phone I can learn after classroom      4.32   1.07
hours
Mobile phones can help me to answer difficult questions 4.25   0.95
A mobile phone can replace computer and other learning 3.63    1.50
technologies
The use of a mobile phone saves time                    4.50   0.64
I feel comfortable to learn by using a mobile phone     4.73   0.51
LECTURERS’ AND INSERVICE TEACHERS’
PERCEPTIONS TOWARDS MOBILE PHONES IN
TEACHING
  Both lecturers and inservice teachers admit
   to have not learned to use mobile phones in
   teaching
  Lecturers were willing to use mobile phones if
   they learn on how to use them
  School teachers on the other hand had
   serveral reservations over mobile phones use
   in teaching.
  Some of these reservation were:
   I don’t know how I can use a mobile phone in
    teaching
   Teachers are not allowed to communicated with
    students through a mobile phone
   Our school laws prohibit mobile phones among
    students
   The government banned mobile phones in schools
   Mobile phones are the source of students’
    misbehaviours
   Mobile phones draw away students attention to
    learning
CONCLUSIONS
 From the findings of this study, a mobile phone
  is the most accessible technological tool in
  Tanzania
 There is a limited use of mobile phones in
  teaching and learning in both university and in
  schools
 At university level, lecturers and preservice
  teachers are willing to use mobile phone as a
  learning tool
 At school level, students are willing to use a
  mobile phone for learning while teachers are
  still reserved.
CONCLUSIONS
 Despite its handy, accessibility and affordability,
  mobile phones are not accepted in schools for
  use in learning.
 Teachers are not allowed to communicate with
  students, this can hinder the opportunity for
  learning beyond the classroom walls
 The current teachers’ attitude towards mobile
  phone technology acts as a set-back towards
  the development of open and distance learning
  in the lower level of education
RECOMMENDATIONS
  To bring the concept of open and distance
   learning in the lower level of education, a
   change should start at a government level
  Teachers should also be exposed to the
   multitude of learning opportunities provided
   through the learning flexibility offered by a
   mobile phone.
  For a country with poorly resourced schools
   like Tanzania, a mobile phone can be a
   solution at hand for technology development
   in education.
THANK YOU FOR YOUR ATTENTION


KARIBU SANA TANZANIA

Teachers' and students' perceptions towards the use of mobile phones as a tool for teaching and learning in Tanzania

  • 1.
    TEACHERS’ AND STUDENTS’PERCEPTIONS TOWARDS THE USE OF MOBILE PHONES AS A TOOL FOR OPEN AND DISTANCE LEARNING IN TANZANIA Ayoub C Kafyulilo Dar es salaam University College of Education & Petra Fisser University of Twente Paper presented at the DEASA International conference for open and distance learning, from 30th September to 2nd October 2011, in Dar es salaam, Tanzania
  • 2.
    INTRODUCTION  Efforts tointegrate technology in education in Tanzania started in 1997  This is the period when the first computer syllabus was introduced in schools  However these efforts encountered some challenges:  Lack of technological tools in most of the schools  Lack of a policy for technology in education  Lack of skilled teachers  Lack of reliable supply of electricity in most schools  Limited access to internet
  • 3.
    INTRODUCTION  For adeveloping country like Tanzania where technology is not well embraced; a mobile phone becomes a vital ICT tool in schools  Mobile phones are affordable to large community of Tanzanians in terms of both cost and usability.  A mobile phone offers varieties of user options: internet, radio, video, audio, camera, mp3 etc.  In addition, a mobile phone is handy; making it user friendly beyond the classroom walls.
  • 4.
    PROBLEMS AND RESEARCHQUESTIONS  Studies have shown that mobile phones use in education in Tanzania, is limited.  Thus, our interest is to find out;  What is the level of accessibility of mobile phones to teachers and students?  To what extent are mobile phones used in both teaching and learning processes?  How do teachers and students perceive mobile phones as a tool for teaching and learning?
  • 5.
    METHODOLOGY  The presentpaper is an outcome of two independent studies carried out at DUCE in 2010 and Kibasila secondary school in 2011  At DUCE, the study adopted the action research design while at Kibasila a survey research design.  29 pre-service teachers and 4 instructors from DUCE; also 12 teachers and 40 students from Kibasila participated in the study.  Data were collected by using teachers’ and instructors’ interview as well as pre-service teachers’ and students’ questionnaire.
  • 6.
    FINDINGS Accessibility to varioustechnological tools to both pre-service teachers and school students Technological tool DUCE Kibasila M (SD) M (SD) Computer (PC or laptop) 2.34 (0.55) 1.89 (0.83) Radio 2.21 (0.86) 2.02 (0.74) Audio Equipment (Mp3) 1.34 (0.67) 1.04 (0.97) iPods 1.24 (0.58) 1.06 (0.98) Mobile Phones 2.73 (0.94) 2.48 (0.88) Digital Camera 1.40 (0.54) 1.25 (0.65) Television 1.97 (0.82) 1.71 (0.87)
  • 7.
    USE OF VARIOUSTECHNOLOGICAL TOOLS IN LEARNING AT DUCE AND KIBASILA Technological Tool DUCE Kibasila M (SD) M (SD) Personal Computers 3.34 (1.72) 2.46 (1.43) Radio 3.17 (1.79) 2.23 (1.29) Audio equipment (Mp3) 2.16 (1.74) 1.64 (1.61) iPod 1.59 (1.38) 1.48 (1.08) Mobile Phones 2.03 (2.18) 1.25 (1.23) Digital photo camera 2.48 (1.72) 1.35 (1.42) Television 3.00 (2.20) 2.40 (1.92)
  • 8.
    PERCEPTIONS OF PRE-SERVICETEACHERS ON MOBILE PHONES USE M SD The use of mobile phones in learning is interesting 4.62 0.50 Design of the lesson with a mobile phone was of interest 4.38 0.57 Mobile phones have enhanced my pedagogical competency 4.42 0.58 Mobile phones have enhanced my technology competency 4.54 0.71 The use of mobile phones enhance my thinking on how 4.69 0.55 technology can transform learning If I learn how to use mobile phones I will use it in my 4.50 0.65 classroom Mobile phones can replace computers 3.88 1.31 Since I know about the use of mobile phone in teaching, I 4.46 0.65 will use technology in teaching
  • 9.
    PERCEPTIONS OF SCHOOLSTUDENTS ON THE USE OF MOBILE PHONES IN LEARNING M SD I am interested to learn by using a mobile phone 4.05 0.97 Mobile phones can make me more involved in learning 4.43 0.84 Use of mobile phones can simplify learning 4.58 0.68 Mobile phones can help me to learn beyond a classroom 4.10 1.01 Through a mobile phone I can learn after classroom 4.32 1.07 hours Mobile phones can help me to answer difficult questions 4.25 0.95 A mobile phone can replace computer and other learning 3.63 1.50 technologies The use of a mobile phone saves time 4.50 0.64 I feel comfortable to learn by using a mobile phone 4.73 0.51
  • 10.
    LECTURERS’ AND INSERVICETEACHERS’ PERCEPTIONS TOWARDS MOBILE PHONES IN TEACHING  Both lecturers and inservice teachers admit to have not learned to use mobile phones in teaching  Lecturers were willing to use mobile phones if they learn on how to use them  School teachers on the other hand had serveral reservations over mobile phones use in teaching.  Some of these reservation were:
  • 11.
    I don’t know how I can use a mobile phone in teaching  Teachers are not allowed to communicated with students through a mobile phone  Our school laws prohibit mobile phones among students  The government banned mobile phones in schools  Mobile phones are the source of students’ misbehaviours  Mobile phones draw away students attention to learning
  • 12.
    CONCLUSIONS  From thefindings of this study, a mobile phone is the most accessible technological tool in Tanzania  There is a limited use of mobile phones in teaching and learning in both university and in schools  At university level, lecturers and preservice teachers are willing to use mobile phone as a learning tool  At school level, students are willing to use a mobile phone for learning while teachers are still reserved.
  • 13.
    CONCLUSIONS  Despite itshandy, accessibility and affordability, mobile phones are not accepted in schools for use in learning.  Teachers are not allowed to communicate with students, this can hinder the opportunity for learning beyond the classroom walls  The current teachers’ attitude towards mobile phone technology acts as a set-back towards the development of open and distance learning in the lower level of education
  • 14.
    RECOMMENDATIONS  Tobring the concept of open and distance learning in the lower level of education, a change should start at a government level  Teachers should also be exposed to the multitude of learning opportunities provided through the learning flexibility offered by a mobile phone.  For a country with poorly resourced schools like Tanzania, a mobile phone can be a solution at hand for technology development in education.
  • 15.
    THANK YOU FORYOUR ATTENTION KARIBU SANA TANZANIA