What makes humans
different?
Michael Tomasello
Mike
Origins of Human Communication
The cultural origins of human cognition
Why are we different from animals?
• Animals mostly in the jungle
• We have technology
• Communication systems
• Organizations
• We are different!
•How did it happen?
Noam: Grammar suddenly appeared in our
brains
About 50,000 years ago
For no reason
Absolutely no reason
ランダム(突然)変異
RANDOM MUTATION
Sudden and for no reason
By the way, it also allowed us to THINK
But it was RANDOM, and for no reason
Homo sapiens: well over 50,000 years ago
Homo sapiens: at least 200,000 years ago
50,000 years is a short time for evolution
Very SUDDEN
Physically IDENTICAL to US
Anatomically IDENTICAL
Big brains
Small guts
Stand up straight
Good long-distance runners
Not like this
Big differences
Able to make ALL the speech sounds we
can
Able to make ALL the speech sounds we
can
From 200,000 years ago
ALL the speech sounds!
Homo sapiens: Any sound you can make
…
I can make it
Same teeth
Same lips
Same tongue
Same hard palate (硬口蓋)
Same soft palate (軟口蓋
Same voice box (発声器)
Same everything
Anatomically identical
They are US!
Anatomically identical
•解剖学的同一
Exactly the same!
200,000 years ago
Exactly the same!
Why?!
Remember Homo Erectus?
From two million years ago
NOT exactly the same as us
Closer to us than chimpanzees and gorillas
But NOT the same
CANNOT make all the sounds yet
NOT the same lips, tongue etc.
Homo erectus is ON THE WAY to us
Then Homo Sapiens …
From 200,000 years ago …
Has the same speech ability as us!
… and THEN gets grammar!
… 50,000 years ago!
For no reason!
… by random mutation!
ランダム(突然)変異
… and starts speaking AFTER that!
Mike: No, that’s complete nonsense
Mike: CULTURE
Mike: humans got culture
Human culture started millions of years
ago
Mike: humans COOPERATED to develop
culture etc.
What do human individuals have that
allows this?
Why are human individuals able to do this?
How does culture CHANGE individuals?
Compare ape learning and human learning
They can see things like us and remember
They understand why things happen
They recognize things and connections
They understand the emotions and goals
of others
VERY very intelligent
What CAN’T they do?
9 month old baby
Shared intentionality
Intentionality =意図的に行われたこと
Shared Intentionality =work together for a
goal
Collaboration: 協力、
Work together and watch other people
One year old: Start “showing” things to
others
“Look at this!” at around 12 months
Look at this! It’s cool!!
Joint attention
共同注意
Show things and check out the other
person
Chimpanzees are really intelligent
They are interested in things
They play with things
But they don’t look at others
They don’t point
They don’t show
They are kind of selfish!
Look at chimpanzee eyes
We can see eye DIRECTION
Chimpanzee follow HEAD movement
We also follow EYE movement
Chimpanzee:
•You close your eyes and look up
•The chimpanzee looks up
•You look up with your eyes
•The chimpanzee doesn’t look
Human child
• You close your eyes and look up
• The child just looks at your face
• You open your eyes and look with just your eyes
• The child follows your eyes
•Chimps follow the head
•Children follow the eyes
We evolved to do things together
We show where we are looking
Because we want to cooperate
Chimpanzees HIDE where they’re looking
They are competing
Humans are much better at this
共同の目的
役割X 役割Y
共同の目的
役割X 役割Y
共同注意
共同の目的
役割X 役割Y
共同注意
視点X 視点Y
共同の目的
• Joint goal
• Joint attention
• Part of our perspective:
• Fairness
• Equality
• etc
What makes us HUMAN?
•We see from OTHERS’ point
of view!
•Animals, not so much
•We share attention
•We each have our own point
of view
That’s the big difference
Children want to play together
Chimpanzees are less interested
For example: Pointing
1 year old babies understand pointing
Animals don’t get it
Chimpanzees don’t understand that we are
trying to help
There’s something useful for YOU
Chimpanzees don’t get it
Pragmatics
Language use in real situations
Cooperation is the GOAL
Cooperation: I’m telling you something
useful for you
So CULTURE -- cooperation
So CULTURE – started a long time ago
Homo?
Australopithecus afarensis
Lucy: 2 ~ 4 million years ago
Brains: smaller than ours
Bodies: smaller than ours
More like apes – long arms for tree-life
Bigger guts than humans
But walking on two legs
Eating meat
Homo habilis?
2 ~ 1.5 million years ago
Used tools
Used tools
Mouths getting smaller
Homo ergaster
Getting more like us
But not quite
Can’t make as many sounds as us
But culture and cooperation was
developing
They were communicating
They were evolving
They were evolving to become like us!
They didn’t need chimpanzee mouths
They had communities
They had fire
Tools
They could cook
Their food was softer
They had culture
Less time chewing and eating
More time for hunting
They were communicating
They were speaking
And they got better and better at it
They evolved
Mike: It was a slow process
Mike: Evolution
Remember Dan Everett?
Dan: It was a slow process
Dan: Evolution
NO! ランダム(突然)変異
You don’t know they were cooperating!
ランダム(突然)変異
They had fire
Tools
They could cook
Their food was softer
Their mouths evolved because they were
eating cooked food
Catching fire
Richard Wrangham: Catching fire
Dick: Cooking helped us evolve
Dick: Cooking gave us Homo Erectus
Dick: humans have been cooking for 2
million years!
Wonderwerk cave in South Africa
Cooking at least 1 million years ago
Dick: Cooking gives more calories
Dick: Less chewing, more free time
Dick: Our brains got bigger
Dick: Our jaws got smaller
Dick: Our guts got smaller
Dick: We could walk and run better
Dick: Our mouths changed so WE COULD
SPEAK
We started cooking a long time ago
Two million years!!
We got more nutrition
Our brains grew
Our guts got smaller
We could stand up straighter
We could run better
We could hunt better
Better nutrition
from cooking
We got bigger
Smaller guts
Bigger brains
Stand upright
Good long-distance
runners
Less chewing
That’s why our mouths changed
Forget evolution!
ランダム(突然)変異
Our speech organs DID evolve
But NOT because we were speaking!
Because we were making better tools!
Because we could control fire!
We could cook!
We could eat nice SOFT food!
To get better nutrition!
So our brains could grow etc!
OK
But do
you
really
believe
But do
you really
believe
We could
cooperate
in hunting
But do you
really believe
We could
cooperate in
controlling fire
But do you
really
believe
We could
cooperate in
toolmaking
But do you
really
believe
We could
cooperate in
COOKING
But do you
really believe
We NEVER
tried to
speak!
YES! ランダム(突然)変異
Speech had to wait until 50,000 years ago
When our speech organs were ALREADY
fully developed
And our brains were ALREADY fully
developed
Language ability suddenly appeared
•Only 50,000 ~ 100,000
years ago!
•By accident!
•AFTER we developed
modern mouths and
tongues!!
Language ability suddenly appeared
•Only 50,000 ~ 100,000
years ago!
•By accident!
•AFTER we developed
modern brains!!
You believe that?
You can believe whatever you want
… but I CAN’T believe that

Sem8