2. Selecting a proper explosive is an important part of blast design to
assure a successful blasting operation.
A product be selected and used in such a manner that optimum
fragmentation and displacement is obtained while giving lowest overall
cast with adequate safety
The factors for selecting suitable explosive can be divided as;
1) Economic factors
2) Explosives
3) Rock and blasting conditions
4) Blasting results
2
3. 1) ECONOMIC FACTORS
(a) Cost of explosive
Generally ANFO has the lowest cost per unit of energy
Slurry explosives range from slightly more than to about 4 times the
cost of ANFO
Cheaper slurries or emulsions are designed for use in large diameter
blast holes and contain no high cost, high energy ingredients
They are low in energy per unit weight basis
The more expensive slurries are designed to be used in small
diameter blast holes and are high energy products containing large
amounts of aluminium or other high energy ingredients
Cost of NG-based explosives range from 3 to 5 times that of ANFO
depending largely on depending largely on the proportion of NG or
other ingredients.
3
4. Despite its excellent economics, ANFO is not always the best product for the
job because of its several shortcoming
ANFO has no water resistance, it has low specific gravity, and under diverse
conditions it tends to detonate inefficiently
However site conditions may make the use of high explosives more attractive
(b) Cost of drilling
Under normal drilling conditions, the lowest cost explosives should be
selected that will give adequate, dependable fragmentation
However, cost of drilling increases typically in hard dense rock, the cost of
explosives and drilling should be optimized through controlled
experimentation.
4
5. when drilling is expensive, the blaster will want to increase energy
density of explosive, even though the explosive with high energy tend
to be more expensive.
The energy density of explosive depends upon density and proportion
of high energy ingredients such as aluminum, used in formulation.
In small diameter blast hole, the density of ANFO may be increased up
to 20% by high velocity pneumatic loading.
The explosion energy of ANFO can be increased by the use of fine
aluminum
The economics of higher energy density explosives slurry or emulsion
improve where the rock is more difficult to drill and blast
5
6. (a) Explosive energy
It is the most commonly considered property when explosives are
compared
It is generally agreed that most explosive energy is released in the
form of shock energy (S.E), bubble energy (B.E) and heat energy
(H.E), of which S.E and B.E being the useful energy components
for the blast process
(b) Storage considerations
Magazine construction is less stringent for blasting agents than
for high explosives
Magazine must be well ventilated, resistant to bullets, fire,
weather and theft, where as blasting agents are protected from
theft only. Shelf life is also important consideration. Slurries
compared to NG based explosives have less shelf life
6
7. (c) Sensitivity considerations
Sensitivity reflects on safety and dependability of an explosive
More sensitive explosives like dynamite are more vulnerable to
accidental initiation by impact or spark than blasting agents
Slurries are generally less sensitive than NG based explosives
Some explosives are affected by detonating cord used in the
blast hole, therefore sensitivity to cord needs to be considered.
Low energy detonating cord can be used while initiating these
explosives
7
8. (a) Charge diameter
The dependability and efficiency of ANFO are sometimes reduced at
smaller diameters, specially in damp conditions or with adequate
confinement.
Diameter within 50mm ANFO functions best when pneumatically loaded
into a dry blast hole
When using charge diameter less than 50mm, many blasters prefer slurry
or NG based cartridge despite the higher cost because such economy on
cost by ANFO can be lost
In blast hole diameter more than 100mm, a bulk loaded ANFO, slurry or
emulsion should be used unless there is some compelling reason to use a
cartridges explosive
ANFO efficiency and dependability increases as the charge diameter
increases 8
9. (b) Rock conditions
Both drilling and fragmentation difficulties are experienced in
hard, dense rock and jointed rock
Explosives with high detonation velocity does help in
fragmenting hard, massive rock
With cartridge dynamites, the detonation velocity increases as
the NG content increases
It has been experienced that explosive having VOD of about 6000
m/s doesn't yield acceptable results in average conditions
In general for granite, quartzite and similar rocks, explosives
equivalent to 90% gelatins better results, whereas for medium
soft rock ANFO type explosives are more suitable
9
10. (c) Water conditions
ANFO has no water resistance. It may however be used in blast
holes containing water if some technique is followed to
overcome this drawback
Emulsions are more water proof and do not depend on a
package of water resistance, this is due to the protective nature
of oil and wax membrane surrounding each particle.
Slurries are gelled and cross linked to provide a barrier against
water intrusion, and as a result exhibit good water resistance.
Water resistance of any explosive can be provided by either the
inherent physical and chemical properties of the explosive or it
packaging.
10
11. (d) Temperature
Until the development of slurries, atmospheric temperature were not an
important factor for selecting an explosive
Many NG based explosives use low freezing oils which permit their use in
low temperatures. ANFO and slurries are not affected by low temp if
priming is adequate.
The effect of low temperature is alleviated if explosives are heated in the
magazine or if they are in the borehole long enough to achieve the
ambient borehole temperature
Under hot storage conditions above 32C, many compounds will
decompose slowly or change properties and shelf life will be decreased.
11
12. (e) Medical aspects
Although, most explosives are oxygen balanced to maximize energy and
minimize toxic detonation, some are bad from stand point of fumes.
Even with oxygen balanced products, unfavorable field conditions may
increase generation of toxic gases particularly when explosive without water
resistance get wet.
Storage and use of NG based explosives have headache producing effect
(f) Explosive atmosphere
Blasting in gassy atmosphere can be catastrophic if the atmosphere is ignited
by the flame from the explosive.
All underground coal mines are classified as gassy. In such situations
permissible explosives offer protection against gas explosions
Depending upon the gassiness of mines, corresponding class of explosives is
to be used.
12
13. Production costs are directly related to the degree of fragmentation achieved.
There is the evidence the matching VOD and sonic velocity of rock increase
the fragmentation in hard, massive rock
With NG based explosives VOD increases as the NG content increases. Thus
90% gelatin has high VOD than 60% gelatin
VOD of ANFO depends on charge diameter and it particle size. In dia of
225mm, VOD of ANFO will exceed 4000m/s and it would be 5000m/s in
375mm dia.
In smaller diameter below 50mm the VOD is less than 2500m/s and it may be
increased to 3000m/s by high velocity pneumatic loading
In many operations with expensive drilling and difficult fragmentation, it may
be advantageous for blaster to compromise and use a dense, high velocity
explosive in the bottom of the borehole and lower energy product as a
column charge 13