Research Study Design
Dr Qurat-Ul-Ain
Assistant Professor / HoD
Community Dentistry Department
HBS Medical & Dental College, Islamabad
Learning Objectives
- What is research design
- Properties of a good research design
- Classification of epidemiological studies
- Descriptive study designs
1.Case Report,
2.cross-sectional
Longitudinal studies
What is a Research Design?
Research is "creative and systematic work
undertaken to increase the stock of
knowledge (human health state), and use to
devise new applications.“
It involves the collection, organization, and
analysis of information (data) to increase our
understanding of a topic or issue.
Research has three steps:
1.Pose a question.
2.Collect data to answer the question.
3.Present an answer to the question.
Properties of a Good Research Design;
 Objectivity
 Precision
 Reliability
 Validity
 Generalization
Epidemiological Methods
Descriptive Studies
Primary focus is on describing the distribution of
disease
Analytical Studies
Primary focus is on analyzing the determinants
of disease
Epidemiological Study Design Strategies
• Observational vs. Experimental
• Prospective vs. Retrospective
• Cross-sectional vs. Longitudinal
Classification of Epidemiological Study
Design
Descriptive
(who? what? where? when?)
Observational
1. Case Reports
2. Case Series
3. Cross Sectional Studies
Analytical (why?/how?)
Observational
1. Case-control Studies
2. Cohort Studies
Experimental
3. Clinical Trials
Case Reports
 Case reports are considered the lowest level of evidence, but they
are also the first line of evidence, because they are where new
issues and ideas emerge.
 A good case report will be clear about the importance of the
observation being reported.
 If multiple case reports show something similar, the next step
might be a case-control study to determine if there is a
relationship between the relevant variables.
Case Reports
 Real-life Examples;
 This case report was published by eight physicians in New York city
who had unexpectedly seen eight male patients with Kaposiâ sarcoma
(KS). Prior to this, KS was very rare in the U.S. and occurred primarily in
the lower extremities of older patients. These cases were decades
younger, had generalized KS, and a much lower rate of survival. This
was before the discovery of HIV or the use of the term AIDS and this
case report was one of the first published items about AIDS patients.
Case Reports
Case reports often describe:
 Unique cases that cannot be explained by known diseases or
syndromes
 Cases that show an important variation of a disease or condition
 Cases that show unexpected events that may produce new or
useful information
 Cases in which one patient has two or more unexpected diseases or
disorders
Case Reports
Advantages
 Can help in the identification of new trends or diseases
 Can help detect new drug side effects and potential
uses (adverse or beneficial)
 Educational “ a way of sharing lessons learned
 Identifies rare manifestations of a disease
Case Reports
Disadvantages
 Cases may not be generalizable
 Not based on systematic studies
 Causes or associations may have other
explanations
Cross- Sectional Study
 Carried out at a single point of time or over a
short period of time
 Also called prevalence studies, as they are
normally used to estimate the prevalence of the
outcome
Cross sectional study
 It does not involve manipulating variables
 It allows researchers to look at numerous characteristics at
once (age, income, gender, etc.)
 It's often used to look at the usual characteristics in a given
population
 It can provide information about what is happening in a
current population
Cross- Sectional Studies
• Advantages:
 Inexpensive
 Take little time
 Many outcomes & risk factors maybe studies
 No loss to follow up
 Can estimate prevalence of outcome
 Useful in public health planning & evaluation, understanding disease etiology and
generation of hypothesis
Cross- Sectional Studies
• Disadvantages:
 ▫ Difficult to make causal inference
 ▫ Only a snapshot-may change over time
 ▫ Neyman Bias (Prevalence-incidence bias)
 ▫ Not suitable for rare conditions
Longitudinal Studies
 Involve repeated observations on the same
population over a period of time
 Provide information on incidence, risk factors
and natural history of disease
Longitudinal Studies
 Advantages:
1. Several outcomes could be studied at the same time
2. Suitable for incidence estimation
 Limitations:
1. Expensive
2. Time -consuming
3. Inefficient for rare diseases
4. May not be feasible
Task - 1
Cross-sectional research is;
1. a study that uses an experiment to find out why there are differences
in the study groups
2. a study that takes place at one time and examines variable in different
research groups and that variable is not manipulated by researchers.
3. a study that takes place at different times and observes changes in
one group over time
Task-2
 A survey conducted to evaluated caries rate in pre-school
going children and followed the same group of children till
secondary level of school to find out dietary habits and dental
caries rate. This study is;
1. Case report study
2. Cross sectional study
3. Longitudinal study
4. Analytical study

Research study design._2020

  • 1.
    Research Study Design DrQurat-Ul-Ain Assistant Professor / HoD Community Dentistry Department HBS Medical & Dental College, Islamabad
  • 2.
    Learning Objectives - Whatis research design - Properties of a good research design - Classification of epidemiological studies - Descriptive study designs 1.Case Report, 2.cross-sectional Longitudinal studies
  • 3.
    What is aResearch Design? Research is "creative and systematic work undertaken to increase the stock of knowledge (human health state), and use to devise new applications.“ It involves the collection, organization, and analysis of information (data) to increase our understanding of a topic or issue.
  • 4.
    Research has threesteps: 1.Pose a question. 2.Collect data to answer the question. 3.Present an answer to the question.
  • 5.
    Properties of aGood Research Design;  Objectivity  Precision  Reliability  Validity  Generalization
  • 6.
    Epidemiological Methods Descriptive Studies Primaryfocus is on describing the distribution of disease Analytical Studies Primary focus is on analyzing the determinants of disease
  • 7.
    Epidemiological Study DesignStrategies • Observational vs. Experimental • Prospective vs. Retrospective • Cross-sectional vs. Longitudinal
  • 8.
    Classification of EpidemiologicalStudy Design Descriptive (who? what? where? when?) Observational 1. Case Reports 2. Case Series 3. Cross Sectional Studies Analytical (why?/how?) Observational 1. Case-control Studies 2. Cohort Studies Experimental 3. Clinical Trials
  • 9.
    Case Reports  Casereports are considered the lowest level of evidence, but they are also the first line of evidence, because they are where new issues and ideas emerge.  A good case report will be clear about the importance of the observation being reported.  If multiple case reports show something similar, the next step might be a case-control study to determine if there is a relationship between the relevant variables.
  • 10.
    Case Reports  Real-lifeExamples;  This case report was published by eight physicians in New York city who had unexpectedly seen eight male patients with Kaposiâ sarcoma (KS). Prior to this, KS was very rare in the U.S. and occurred primarily in the lower extremities of older patients. These cases were decades younger, had generalized KS, and a much lower rate of survival. This was before the discovery of HIV or the use of the term AIDS and this case report was one of the first published items about AIDS patients.
  • 11.
    Case Reports Case reportsoften describe:  Unique cases that cannot be explained by known diseases or syndromes  Cases that show an important variation of a disease or condition  Cases that show unexpected events that may produce new or useful information  Cases in which one patient has two or more unexpected diseases or disorders
  • 12.
    Case Reports Advantages  Canhelp in the identification of new trends or diseases  Can help detect new drug side effects and potential uses (adverse or beneficial)  Educational “ a way of sharing lessons learned  Identifies rare manifestations of a disease
  • 13.
    Case Reports Disadvantages  Casesmay not be generalizable  Not based on systematic studies  Causes or associations may have other explanations
  • 14.
    Cross- Sectional Study Carried out at a single point of time or over a short period of time  Also called prevalence studies, as they are normally used to estimate the prevalence of the outcome
  • 16.
    Cross sectional study It does not involve manipulating variables  It allows researchers to look at numerous characteristics at once (age, income, gender, etc.)  It's often used to look at the usual characteristics in a given population  It can provide information about what is happening in a current population
  • 18.
    Cross- Sectional Studies •Advantages:  Inexpensive  Take little time  Many outcomes & risk factors maybe studies  No loss to follow up  Can estimate prevalence of outcome  Useful in public health planning & evaluation, understanding disease etiology and generation of hypothesis
  • 19.
    Cross- Sectional Studies •Disadvantages:  ▫ Difficult to make causal inference  ▫ Only a snapshot-may change over time  ▫ Neyman Bias (Prevalence-incidence bias)  ▫ Not suitable for rare conditions
  • 20.
    Longitudinal Studies  Involverepeated observations on the same population over a period of time  Provide information on incidence, risk factors and natural history of disease
  • 21.
    Longitudinal Studies  Advantages: 1.Several outcomes could be studied at the same time 2. Suitable for incidence estimation  Limitations: 1. Expensive 2. Time -consuming 3. Inefficient for rare diseases 4. May not be feasible
  • 23.
    Task - 1 Cross-sectionalresearch is; 1. a study that uses an experiment to find out why there are differences in the study groups 2. a study that takes place at one time and examines variable in different research groups and that variable is not manipulated by researchers. 3. a study that takes place at different times and observes changes in one group over time
  • 24.
    Task-2  A surveyconducted to evaluated caries rate in pre-school going children and followed the same group of children till secondary level of school to find out dietary habits and dental caries rate. This study is; 1. Case report study 2. Cross sectional study 3. Longitudinal study 4. Analytical study