This PPT discusses the qualities of the places we like. Most of the cherished and highly valued places in Australia, as well as other parts of the world, share key characteristics or 'Place Qualities'. More information available at http://www.placefocus.com/Place-Qualities/place-qualities.html
You can buy a copy of our manual or enrol in an on-line course at http://placefocus.com/Shop/placefocus-shop.html
Place qualities - section 3 intro to urban design and placemaking
1. PROGRAM – SESSION 3
Paddington Reservoir Gardens –
1 Urban Design +
Placemaking 101
2 Civic Principles
3 Place Qualities
8 Outcomes
4 Place Typology
5 Place process
6 Place roles
7 Toolkit - placemaking ideas
9/10 Links+ conclusions
Aussie tour of our bonza places
2. Anster St – Adelaide, SA, AUS
3. QUALITIES OF GOOD PLACES
1. Character
2. Diversity
3. Accessibility
4. Fit + function
5. Animators
6. Continuity + enclosure
7. Consistency + variety
8. Legibility
9. Structure
10. Features
11. Social Fabric
12. Sustainability
PlaceDrivers 13. Quality of the public realm
14. Safety
15. Creativity
16. Sensory pleasure
PlacePreference
NZ Urban Design Protocol
VIC Urban Design Charter
Councillor’s Guide to Urban Design
(Urban Initiatives, 2003).
3. 3.1 DRIVERS OF GOOD PLACES
▸ Character: sense of
place and history
▸ All sites have intrinsic
environmental qualities,
community use and site
characteristics.
▸ We create authenticity
by enriching these
unique qualities.
▸ This is a key ingredient
for successful places.
▸ “Do designers destroy
the story” D Engwicht
The Front Walk – Rottnest Island, WA
4. 3.1 DRIVERS OF GOOD PLACES
▸ But cities change... and
so do people
▸ We have also inherited
aspirations for a better
future, and a tradition of
cultural vitality
▸ Good urban design:
▸ is attentive to the past
▸ adopts a critical stance
toward the status quo
▸ explores possible destinies
▸ and imagines and fulfils
visions
Shields St, Cairns, QLD, AUS
5. 3.1 DRIVERS OF GOOD PLACES
▸ An example of character guidance
▸ Recognise sub-regions
▸ Respect topography
▸ Diversify the built environment
▸ Consider local character and design
▸ Integrate with nature
▸ Acknowledge informality
▸ Use vegetation
▸ Ensure open space diversity
▸ Incorporate access to open space
▸ Design for water
▸ Develop outdoor centres
▸ Develop outdoor meeting places
6. 3.2 DRIVERS OF GOOD PLACES
▸ Diversity: ease of choice and
adaptability
▸ Everyone benefits from centres
which feature a range of uses for a
diverse community.
▸ It is a key criteria for a walkable
urban environment - triple bottom
line benefits.
▸ Drivers of diversity
▸ public buildings particularly hospitals and
universities
▸ density
▸ small street blocks
▸ Small allotments
▸ day and night time activity
▸ old buildings
▸ affordable housing
Affordable Housing, Hartopp Lane, KGUV – Brisbane
8. 3.3 DRIVERS OF GOOD PLACES
▸ Accessibility: connectivity and
permeability
▸ Places need to be easy to get to and be
integrated with their surroundings...
▸ by foot, bicycle, wheelchair, scooter,
public transport and the car - and in that
order
▸ density being highest where access to
public transport is best
▸ a choice of connected, safe, high quality
routes
▸ Flexible and responsive to demands of
constant change
▸ D Engwicht Secret 4 – focus on
exchanges not mobility
▸ planned v spontaneous
Ormeau Town Centre Concept Plan
(Deicke Richards)
▸ Walk Score
13. 3.5 DRIVERS OF GOOD PLACES
▸ Animators: active, safe, well-
used public spaces
▸ Active building edges
▸ Activities in and overlooking public
spaces
▸ Comfortable and interesting places
▸ Activation also extends to people
on the move
▸ Animation through management
and use of places
▸ Anchoring presence
▸ Lingering nodes – numbers vs
length of stay
William St - Northbridge, Perth, WA, AUS
14. 3.4 DRIVERS OF GOOD PLACES
▸ Fit & function: support the intended use of spaces
while also allowing for their adaptability
▸ ‘Fit’ the extent to which something serves its purpose,
works for people and makes them comfortable.
▸ An urban space can help us to do what we want safely
and efficiently.
▸ However, the relationship between people and their
environments is never exact, and a ‘loose fit’ is often most
desirable.
▸ Most urban spaces need to accommodate varied events
rather than one specialised activity.
▸ Good public places tolerate and promote this variety,
responding to a range of viewpoints and contexts...
▸ Create the potential
▸ “infinite possibilities not future destination” D Engwicht
Chinatown Mall – Adelaide, SA, AUS
15. 3.4 DRIVERS OF GOOD PLACES
The Strand - Townsville, QLD, AUS
16. Main Street, Rouse Hill Town Centre, Sydney, NSW, AUS
3.6 PLACE DRIVER
▸ Continuity and enclosure
▸ Cities benefit from a
consistency in urban
form which encloses the
street…and clarity about
their use.
▸ streets and open spaces
overlooked by buildings
▸ relationship between public
and private space
▸ avoiding gaps
▸ enclosing with buildings and
trees
▸ no leftover spaces unused and
uncared for
17. 3.7 DRIVERS OF GOOD PLACES
▸ Consistency & variety: balance order
and diversity in the interests of
appreciating both
▸ Variety for intellectual and aesthetic
stimulation while avoiding confusion
▸ Cities need a balance of:
▸ individuality and community,
▸ logic and feeling,
▸ order and random incident.
▸ A city’s public realm provides coherence
and order while
▸ private ventures introduce variety and
interest
▸ One condition benefits from the other
▸ “Great places celebrate inherent
contradictions” D Engwicht
Melbourne, Vic, AUS
18. 3.8 PLACE DRIVER
▸ Legibility: ease of understanding
▸ A strong human requirement and helps us to
understand and appreciate our cities and towns
▸ landmarks and focal points
▸ views
▸ clear and easily
navigable routes gateways
to particular areas
▸ lighting
▸ works of art and craft and
▸ signage and waymarkers
▸ Need to balance with the element of
surprise
Moorabool St, Geelong, VIC, AUS
21. New Farm, Brisbane, QLD, AUS
3.9 DRIVERS OF GOOD PLACES
▸ Structure: organise places so
their parts relate well to each
other
▸ ‘Structure’ refers to the way an
urban area is physically put
together its:
▸ layout,
▸ shapes of land parcels
▸ routes of movement
▸ street patterns and
▸ networks of public spaces.
▸ A city is more than the sum of
these parts; connections
between the parts make a
coherent, functioning whole.
▸ A good structure allows for
change while the structure itself
remains stable.
22. 3.10 DRIVERS OF GOOD PLACES
▸ Features: a reason to go there
▸ Hard infrastructure which attracts
people to places
▸ Or environment
▸ Or culture
▸ Engwicht Secret 11 - encourage
play
▸ “Embrace the abstract”
▸ 8-80
The Esplanade, Cairns, QLD, AUS
23. 3.11 DRIVERS OF GOOD PLACES
▸ Social fabric: events,
activities and cultural infrastructure
▸ The quality of the public realm is a
means to an end not the end itself
▸ The places we like are not only
created, designed and delivered
- they also need to be maintained
St Patricks Day – George St, Brisbane, QLD, AUS
24. 3.12 DRIVERS OF GOOD PLACES
▸ Sustainability: environmentally,
socially and economically
▸ We exist because of our
environment – we are a part of it
▸ Places need to strike a balance
between the natural and manmade
environment
▸ the climate
▸ landform
▸ landscape and ecology
▸ We need to find opportunities to
celebrate the environment in cities
– easiest at our river and harbour
edges and creek crossings?
Gosford, NSW, AUS
25. Given Tce, Paddington, Bne, QLD, AUS
3. QUALITIES OF GOOD PLACES
1. Character
2. Diversity
3. Accessibility
4. Fit + function
5. Animators
6. Continuity + enclosure
7. Consistency + variety
8. Legibility
9. Structure
10. Features
11. Social Fabric
12. Sustainability
PlaceDrivers 13. Quality of the public realm
14. Safety
15. Creativity
16. Sensory pleasure
PlacePreferenceNZ Urban Design Protocol
VIC Urban Design Charter
Councillor’s Guide to Urban Design
(Urban Initiatives, 2003).
26. 3.13 PLACE PREFERENCE
▸ Quality of the public realm: sense of wellbeing & amenity
▸ For places to be well-used and well-loved, they generally are safe, comfortable, varied and
attractive , distinctive, and offer variety, choice and fun
▸ We must design places which meet the existing and expected needs and aspirations of all users
▸ Engwicht Secret 1 – Make people feel at home
▸ “You can create a house with money but not a home”
Hill St, Emu Park – QLD
http://www.peet.com.au/Uploads/Images/emu-park-2-003218.jpg
27. Mawson Lakes – Adelaide, SA, AUS
3.14 PLACE PREFERENCE
▸ Safety: design spaces that help us
understand risk to support safe
behaviour
▸ Risk is not the problem, need to be
able to read the risk
▸ Create places where people can use
their own natural aptitudes to keep
themselves and others safe from
harm.
▸ This requires support for human
abilities of perception e.g. street
lamps that emit white light help
▸ Safety is supported when people can
see potential threats, judge risks,
escape if a threat is perceived, seek
assistance and give aid if needed.
28. 3.15 PLACE PREFERENCE
▸ Creativity: richness and diversity
▸ Placemaking requires creative and
innovative approaches
▸ It turns a functional place into a
memorable place
▸ Creativity facilitates new ways of
thinking and a willingness to think
through problems afresh to:
▸ experiment and rewrite rules
▸ to harness new technology, and
▸ to visualise new futures.
Creative Industries Precinct - Kelvin Grove Urban Village, Brisbane, QLD, AUS
29. Adelaide Central Markets – Adelaide, SA, AUS
3.16 PLACE PREFERENCE
▸ Sensory pleasure: create spaces that
engage the senses and delight the mind
▸ Appearance, hearing, taste, smell and
touch, and awareness of our body’s position
and movement through space and across
the topography
▸ Good urban design addresses visible and
invisible dimensions of human experience
▸ Engwicht Secret 10 – feed the senses
30. Darling St, Balmain, Sydney, NSW, AUS
3. QUALITIES OF GOOD PLACES
1. Character
2. Diversity
3. Accessibility
4. Fit + function
5. Animators
6. Continuity + enclosure
7. Consistency + variety
8. Legibility
9. Structure
10. Features
11. Social Fabric
12. Sustainability
PlaceDrivers
13. Quality of the public realm
14. Safety
15. Creativity
16. Sensory pleasure
PlacePreference NZ Urban Design Protocol
VIC Urban Design Charter
Councillor’s Guide to Urban Design
(Urban Initiatives, 2003).
31. Little Stanley St, Southbank – Brisbane QLD, AUS
3. QUALITIES – IMPLEMENTATION?
▸ Performance vs
▸ Prescription vs
▸ Expectations (Hamilton NZ)
32. Rundle St Mall – Adelaide, SA, AUS
3 QUALITIES OF GOOD PLACES
▸ Engwicht Secret 3 – break the
rules
▸ Understand the rules but don’t
be bound by them
▸ Seek the inherent
contradictions
▸ Everything we design should
have multiple or conflicting
implications
35. 3. REFLECTION
▸ Individual – group: short answer test p156
3.6 Are any qualities more important than others?
▸ Place driver
01 Character
02 Diversity
03 Accessibility
02 Fit + Function
05 Animators
06 Continuity + Enclosure
07 Consistency +Variety
08 Legibility
09 Structure
10 Features
11. Social Fabric
12. Sustainability
3.7 (different) Consider your local centre? What qualities does it have?
3.8 Are any qualities missing from this place?
▸ Aussie tour of our bonza places
▸ Postcard from the future!
George St, The Rocks, Sydney, NSW, AUS
▸ Place preference
13 Quality of the Public Realm
12 Safety
15 Creativity
16 Sensory Pleasure
Editor's Notes
Has anyone visited the Reservoir Gardens in Paddington? The conversion of an old filled in reservoir into an urban park – reminiscent of Greece?
Good urban design or good park design?
Based on the discussions during the last six months I have modified the qualities.
The first 12 are drivers of good urban design/placemaking. The “optimisers” (not sure if this is the best word yet?) are variable based on personal preference. For example you and a teenager might have a different tolerance for safety (‘grittiness’)?
This is still a work in progress so tell me what you think?
The first quality and possibly the hardest to reproduce?
A unique Australian Street - the front walk on Rottnest Island. Largely unchanged over the last 150 years of continuous use. Building from local material make a significant contribution to character.
Can you spot the quokka?
A lovely dichotomy...
There are guidelines which inform the design of our places and buildings in relation to climate and context.
Diversity is a key driver for successful places – part of the reason we enjoy being in the inner city.
This resident of affordable housing at the end of Hartop Lane in KGUV maintains the street plants. She is coordinating the construction of a community vege garden in the adjacent park.
Because this Brisbane Housing Company site is on the main street it delivers retail and commercial at the front... with an awning!
If you haven’t read this book for a while it is well worth picking up again – an easy read.
Jane is an urban legend (in more ways than one).
Check out her thoughts on the generators of diversity.
Most people like Portland – which has a tight 80m by 80m grid. Brisbane and Sydney’s is 200 by 100m. Melbourne is whopping 200 by 200 with the ‘little’ streets making it 200 by 100m and than the lanes and places in between. This block division is a big part of Melbourne’s urban experience
Placing a known city grid over a site is a good tool for giving people an idea of the scale.
This drawing (produced in a design workshop) should deliver good permeability and connectivity. The density is high around the new train station, with a good street network and mix of uses.
Walkability – safe and comfortable routes, not too far too walk and something to do when you get there!
This development, in the northern suburbs of Brisbane, was highlighted to me by a participant in the first course.
Let’s say my mate stinky (and yes I do have a mate called stinky) lives one house away. Mad Mr Steptoe won’t let us cut through his property, then this is how far we would have to walk or ride our bikes... PTO
A long way!
This is partly because the old boundary between Brisbane City and Pine Rivers Shire runs down the centre of the image.
Lack of cross boundary planning is compounded by cul-de-sac and worm street patterns. These tend to provide quiet streets for some, at the expense of others. Not so good for public transport or cyclists.
My kids and their friends play in our street which is not a cul-de-sac (we actually have buses in it!).
This development, in the northern suburbs of Brisbane, was highlighted to me by a participant in the first course.
Let’s say my mate stinky (and yes I do have a mate called stinky) lives one house away. Mad Mr Steptoe won’t let us cut through his property, then this is how far we would have to walk or ride our bikes... PTO
During my time at HASSELL we were asked to develop an alternative layout plan to the one approved on the Gold Coast (guess which one).
Our plan created a park entry overlooked by houses. It also distributed the golf course view down the street. This has been proven to add more value to the development. We also created more street and Park frontage for the medium density sites.
Unfortunately, they stuck with the existing.
Good urban design introduces, maintains and intensifies human activity within the public realm.
An example of an active building:
retail use
transparent facade
interaction with the street
a little whimsical?
This quality replaces robustness in the manual because it refers to fit – including the concept of ‘loose fit’
Where new developments aspire to street level retail uses they provide higher floor to ceiling heights for ground floor apartments in the short term.
This is a seminal urban design guide – because of the diversity of the authors. A great ‘how to’ on your shelf.
A resident personalising the Strand in Townsville - BYO as well! Places need to be available for people who don’t want to buy a coffee or a meal.
The new regional centre at Rouse Hill, Sydney was facilitated by Landcom and built by GPT. It incorporates this Main St, a town square, medium density housing and commercial development. Leading edge for Australian shopping centres!
The street features wide footpaths (they need to be up to 7m wide for main streets), narrow carriage way, low kerbs, parallel parking, pedestrian crossing... All designed to keep traffic speed low and favour the pedestrian.
Unfortunately, I was asked to stop taking photographs. While the spaces sound (Main Street) and feel like public spaces - they are privatised. I have sent them an email to ask why?
The centre is built over a huge structured carpark which may restrict redevelopment in the future?
Melbourne – a great example of the cities public realm providing the order (and a little of the interest) and the private ventures providing the interest.
Signage is placed last on the list for a reason.
I don’t know about you but I don’t feel comfortable in a new place unless I have a rough idea of orientation.
Not necessarily a key quality for visitors though? Participants have talked about having the time to get lost in cities like Venice – and then marvel at finding Piazza San Marco around the last corner!
This is the Rouse Hill Town Square – in which you can’t take any photos.
Remember Lynch’s seminal book on legibility from our university studies?
Developed through his mind map research – which you will do later.
Castle Hill provides a strong landmark in Townsville. If you look closely you can see the saint graffiti on the side.
Some street trees along this footpath would help, and maybe some public art on the wall? The bollards might be overkill?
Signage is placed last on the list for a reason.
I don’t know about you but I don’t feel comfortable in a new place unless I have a rough idea of orientation.
Not necessarily a key quality for visitors though? Participants have talked about having the time to get lost in cities like Venice – and then marvel at finding Piazza San Marco around the last corner!
This is the Rouse Hill Town Square – in which you can’t take any photos.
The structure of a place can play a large role in its success.
Inner city New Farm in Brisbane benefits from central centres, alternative routes of movement, density, and a well located park.
Really good urban places benefit from features like the Southbank pool, Sydney Opera House, Guggenheim Museum, Eifel Tower or London Eye.
While these features do not necessarily represent ‘good’ urban design they make a significant contribution to attracting people.
The quality of the place might bring them back?
We talked about sense of place in the introduction.
No doubt Birdsville delivers good built form outcomes. However, people probably travel long distances for the event and the associated festival (and the thrill of getting there!).
The new Council building in Melbourne not only has high environmental credentials (e.g. the facade responds to the sun) it also reinforces a small, but quality, urban place.
Apparently the additional costs in the ‘healthy’ building were justified by the reduction costs due to sick leave.
Based on the discussions during the last six months I have modified the qualities.
The first 12 are drivers of good urban design/placemaking. The “optimisers” (not sure if this is the best word yet?) are variable based on personal preference. For example you and a teenager might have a different tolerance for safety (‘grittiness’)?
This is still a work in progress so tell me what you think?
I facilitated the stakeholder workshop for this street improvement on the Capricorn Coast. We ended up with the majority of the town there with plenty of great ideas and comments!
They would remind me about their issue/idea every time I went back!
We ere able to underground the powerlines, widen footpaths and provide pedestrian amenities. Unfortunately, they really wanted palms (which don’t provide a lot of shade).
The new residential development at Mawson Lakes is impressive given it’s distance from the city.
These footpaths are well overlooked by the buildings.
Some people like gritty and grungy places which some of us may describe as being unsafe?
Creativity in the design of the place and in it’s delivery.
The Creative Industries Precinct is Australia's first site dedicated to creative experimentation and commercial development in the creative industries. It provides a unique opportunity for designers, artists, researchers, educators and entrepreneurs to easily connect and collaborate with others to create new work, develop new ideas and grow the creative industries sector in Queensland.
Working closely with partners from government and industry, QUT is a national leader in the development of creative industries in Queensland and Australia and is fast becoming an internationally-networked hub of creative enterprise.
The $60 million Creative Industries Precinct boasts some of the most advanced digital facilities to support the creative work undertaken and some of the most exciting partners in identifying the next generation of ideas.
Most of my sensory organs are overwhelmed at city markets!
Private open space?
Based on the discussions during the last six months I have modified the qualities.
The first 12 are drivers of good urban design/placemaking. The “optimisers” (not sure if this is the best word yet?) are variable based on personal preference. For example you and a teenager might have a different tolerance for safety (‘grittiness’)?
This is still a work in progress so tell me what you think?
We acknowledge the need to engage with stakeholders- although we could be more effective?
Participatory design (design workshop, EbD, etc) is one example.
Another movie you will eventually be able to see on www.placefocus.com
Another movie you will eventually be able to see on www.placefocus.com