SlideShare a Scribd company logo
LIMITATIONS  OF PERFORMANCE  APPRAISAL  By, Suraj.T.S Deepa  Mohan
What  is  Performance  Appraisal? Performance Appraisal is the formal conclusion to a performance management process at the end of a prescribed term.  Prescribed terms may be any length but are usually a 12 month period.
The Performance Appraisal process involves an interview between a staff member and their manager where the objectives and deliverables for the staff member are reviewed, and an overall assessment of the staff member's performance is agreed. It must be understood that a Performance Appraisal is only a component part of a Performance Management System. Many people confuse the two and interchange the terminology.
      LIMITATIONS  OF  PERFORMANCE APPRAISAL The results  of  merit  rating  will not  be  accurate  unless  the  factors  in  the  assessment  are  relevant. Sometimes , supervisors  do not  possess  the  critical  ability  in  assessing  the  staff.   The  methods  of  performance  appraisal  are  unreliable.
The  actual  rating  of  subjective  factors  like  initiative  and  personality  of  the  employees  may  not  be  on  scientific  lines Sometimes , proper  weights  may  not  be      given  to  the  different  qualities  to  be  rated.  The  review  is  done  in  retrospect  and  is  an  average  of  six  months  old  so  recollection  of  events  is  poor.
The  opinions  of  staff  and  manager  are  often  in  opposition , causing  demotivation. The  process  is  usually  manager  driven  and  the  staff  member  is  expected  to  be  complaint  in  the  interview. There  is  no  room  for  remedial  action  during  the  year.
The  process  is  usually  done  in  a  rushed  manner  to  meet  a  budget  development  process  and  therefore  loses  its  relevance  to  performance. The  process  usually  involves  the  manager  giving  their  opinion  and  the  staff  member  having  to  defend  the  position , rather  than  a  positive  discussion.

More Related Content

What's hot

Supervisory Skills
Supervisory SkillsSupervisory Skills
Supervisory Skills
Laurence Yap M.A. (UM) CHRM
 
Supervision 2
Supervision 2Supervision 2
Supervision 2
RedwanAlHammodAlAhme
 
Human resource management
Human resource managementHuman resource management
Human resource management
Rashi Bisaria
 
Performance appraisal
Performance appraisalPerformance appraisal
Performance appraisal
Jobin Jacob
 
PSAB Performance Webinar
PSAB Performance WebinarPSAB Performance Webinar
PSAB Performance Webinar
Nancy J Hess
 
Organizational Development
Organizational DevelopmentOrganizational Development
Organizational DevelopmentJunhel Dalanon
 
PROFESSIONAL SUPERVISION
PROFESSIONAL SUPERVISIONPROFESSIONAL SUPERVISION
PROFESSIONAL SUPERVISION
Curtin University, Perth, Australia
 
Legal & Ethical Perspectives In Pa
Legal & Ethical Perspectives In PaLegal & Ethical Perspectives In Pa
Legal & Ethical Perspectives In Pa
Jayashree Prabhu
 
Performance appraisal
Performance appraisalPerformance appraisal
Performance appraisal
AakshiD
 
Professor assistant performance appraisal
Professor assistant performance appraisalProfessor assistant performance appraisal
Professor assistant performance appraisal
sammywood963
 
Production controller perfomance appraisal 2
Production controller perfomance appraisal 2Production controller perfomance appraisal 2
Production controller perfomance appraisal 2tonychoper0704
 
Unisource HR Procedure v1
Unisource HR Procedure v1Unisource HR Procedure v1
Unisource HR Procedure v1Wei Dai
 
Performace appraisal
Performace appraisalPerformace appraisal
Performace appraisal
RajThakuri
 
The Performance Appraisal System.
The Performance Appraisal System.The Performance Appraisal System.
The Performance Appraisal System.
Binit Das
 
Performance review training for managers
Performance review training for managersPerformance review training for managers
Performance review training for managers
Helen Joseph
 
Uses of performance appraisal
Uses of performance appraisalUses of performance appraisal
Uses of performance appraisal
tommylong551
 
Supervision
SupervisionSupervision
Supervision
RajeshGupta543
 
Designing of performance appraisal form
Designing of performance appraisal formDesigning of performance appraisal form
Designing of performance appraisal form
Deependra Singh
 

What's hot (20)

Supervisory Skills
Supervisory SkillsSupervisory Skills
Supervisory Skills
 
Supervision 2
Supervision 2Supervision 2
Supervision 2
 
Human resource management
Human resource managementHuman resource management
Human resource management
 
Performance appraisal
Performance appraisalPerformance appraisal
Performance appraisal
 
PSAB Performance Webinar
PSAB Performance WebinarPSAB Performance Webinar
PSAB Performance Webinar
 
Organizational Development
Organizational DevelopmentOrganizational Development
Organizational Development
 
PROFESSIONAL SUPERVISION
PROFESSIONAL SUPERVISIONPROFESSIONAL SUPERVISION
PROFESSIONAL SUPERVISION
 
Legal & Ethical Perspectives In Pa
Legal & Ethical Perspectives In PaLegal & Ethical Perspectives In Pa
Legal & Ethical Perspectives In Pa
 
Performance appraisal
Performance appraisalPerformance appraisal
Performance appraisal
 
Professor assistant performance appraisal
Professor assistant performance appraisalProfessor assistant performance appraisal
Professor assistant performance appraisal
 
Production controller perfomance appraisal 2
Production controller perfomance appraisal 2Production controller perfomance appraisal 2
Production controller perfomance appraisal 2
 
Unisource HR Procedure v1
Unisource HR Procedure v1Unisource HR Procedure v1
Unisource HR Procedure v1
 
Performace appraisal
Performace appraisalPerformace appraisal
Performace appraisal
 
The Performance Appraisal System.
The Performance Appraisal System.The Performance Appraisal System.
The Performance Appraisal System.
 
Performance review training for managers
Performance review training for managersPerformance review training for managers
Performance review training for managers
 
Pc
PcPc
Pc
 
Supervisor ppt
Supervisor pptSupervisor ppt
Supervisor ppt
 
Uses of performance appraisal
Uses of performance appraisalUses of performance appraisal
Uses of performance appraisal
 
Supervision
SupervisionSupervision
Supervision
 
Designing of performance appraisal form
Designing of performance appraisal formDesigning of performance appraisal form
Designing of performance appraisal form
 

Viewers also liked

Ie Rei
Ie ReiIe Rei
Ie Rei
ajithsrc
 
Trade Mark
Trade MarkTrade Mark
Trade Mark
ajithsrc
 
Conference Sept32008
Conference Sept32008Conference Sept32008
Conference Sept32008
ajithsrc
 
Capital & New Issue
Capital & New IssueCapital & New Issue
Capital & New Issue
ajithsrc
 
Chapter7 New
Chapter7 NewChapter7 New
Chapter7 Newajithsrc
 
Ch14 Inventory Management
Ch14  Inventory ManagementCh14  Inventory Management
Ch14 Inventory Managementajithsrc
 
International Bank For Reconstruction And Development
International Bank For Reconstruction And DevelopmentInternational Bank For Reconstruction And Development
International Bank For Reconstruction And Development
ajithsrc
 

Viewers also liked (8)

Ie Rei
Ie ReiIe Rei
Ie Rei
 
Trade Mark
Trade MarkTrade Mark
Trade Mark
 
Conference Sept32008
Conference Sept32008Conference Sept32008
Conference Sept32008
 
Capital & New Issue
Capital & New IssueCapital & New Issue
Capital & New Issue
 
Chapter7 New
Chapter7 NewChapter7 New
Chapter7 New
 
Ch14 Inventory Management
Ch14  Inventory ManagementCh14  Inventory Management
Ch14 Inventory Management
 
International Bank For Reconstruction And Development
International Bank For Reconstruction And DevelopmentInternational Bank For Reconstruction And Development
International Bank For Reconstruction And Development
 
Ch04
Ch04Ch04
Ch04
 

Similar to Performance Appraisal

PERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT SYSTEM (2).pdf
PERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT SYSTEM (2).pdfPERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT SYSTEM (2).pdf
PERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT SYSTEM (2).pdf
ssuser72b81e
 
Performance appraisal.pptx
Performance appraisal.pptxPerformance appraisal.pptx
Performance appraisal.pptx
DrAsifMohammad
 
Objectives performance appraisal
Objectives performance appraisalObjectives performance appraisal
Objectives performance appraisal
dbell3034
 
Performance management system
Performance management systemPerformance management system
Performance management systemvimalesh kumar
 
Positive performance appraisal
Positive performance appraisalPositive performance appraisal
Positive performance appraisal
barnesali609
 
Chapter 2: Performance Management Process
Chapter 2: Performance Management ProcessChapter 2: Performance Management Process
Chapter 2: Performance Management ProcessHRM751
 
Performance appraisal articles
Performance appraisal articlesPerformance appraisal articles
Performance appraisal articles
aidencarter91
 
Sample performance review phrases
Sample performance review phrasesSample performance review phrases
Sample performance review phrases
jameswhite1498
 
Performance reviews 101
Performance reviews 101Performance reviews 101
Performance reviews 101
Heather Flaherty
 
Employee performance review phrases
Employee performance review phrasesEmployee performance review phrases
Employee performance review phrases
origincooper
 
Writing a performance appraisal
Writing a performance appraisalWriting a performance appraisal
Writing a performance appraisal
bushmiller440
 
Cipd performance appraisal
Cipd performance appraisalCipd performance appraisal
Cipd performance appraisal
bushmiller440
 
Effective Design of appraisal system
Effective Design of appraisal systemEffective Design of appraisal system
Effective Design of appraisal system
TayyabaMahmood1
 
PERFORMANCE_APPRAISAL_IN_TATA_MOTORS.pdf
PERFORMANCE_APPRAISAL_IN_TATA_MOTORS.pdfPERFORMANCE_APPRAISAL_IN_TATA_MOTORS.pdf
PERFORMANCE_APPRAISAL_IN_TATA_MOTORS.pdf
marwaelsadat
 
modern methods of performance appraisal.pdf
modern methods of performance appraisal.pdfmodern methods of performance appraisal.pdf
modern methods of performance appraisal.pdf
Kiran Dubb
 
15 questions for effective employee evaluation
15 questions for effective employee evaluation15 questions for effective employee evaluation
15 questions for effective employee evaluation
GroSum
 
Introduction to Employee performance management(EPM) -Performance Management ...
Introduction to Employee performance management(EPM) -Performance Management ...Introduction to Employee performance management(EPM) -Performance Management ...
Introduction to Employee performance management(EPM) -Performance Management ...
Mouneswari
 
Performance appraisal
Performance appraisalPerformance appraisal
Performance appraisal
Mahmoud Alkhatib
 
Human resource management performance appraisal
Human resource management performance appraisalHuman resource management performance appraisal
Human resource management performance appraisal
zonaharper2
 
Performance appraisal mistakes
Performance appraisal mistakesPerformance appraisal mistakes
Performance appraisal mistakes
elenavogel8
 

Similar to Performance Appraisal (20)

PERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT SYSTEM (2).pdf
PERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT SYSTEM (2).pdfPERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT SYSTEM (2).pdf
PERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT SYSTEM (2).pdf
 
Performance appraisal.pptx
Performance appraisal.pptxPerformance appraisal.pptx
Performance appraisal.pptx
 
Objectives performance appraisal
Objectives performance appraisalObjectives performance appraisal
Objectives performance appraisal
 
Performance management system
Performance management systemPerformance management system
Performance management system
 
Positive performance appraisal
Positive performance appraisalPositive performance appraisal
Positive performance appraisal
 
Chapter 2: Performance Management Process
Chapter 2: Performance Management ProcessChapter 2: Performance Management Process
Chapter 2: Performance Management Process
 
Performance appraisal articles
Performance appraisal articlesPerformance appraisal articles
Performance appraisal articles
 
Sample performance review phrases
Sample performance review phrasesSample performance review phrases
Sample performance review phrases
 
Performance reviews 101
Performance reviews 101Performance reviews 101
Performance reviews 101
 
Employee performance review phrases
Employee performance review phrasesEmployee performance review phrases
Employee performance review phrases
 
Writing a performance appraisal
Writing a performance appraisalWriting a performance appraisal
Writing a performance appraisal
 
Cipd performance appraisal
Cipd performance appraisalCipd performance appraisal
Cipd performance appraisal
 
Effective Design of appraisal system
Effective Design of appraisal systemEffective Design of appraisal system
Effective Design of appraisal system
 
PERFORMANCE_APPRAISAL_IN_TATA_MOTORS.pdf
PERFORMANCE_APPRAISAL_IN_TATA_MOTORS.pdfPERFORMANCE_APPRAISAL_IN_TATA_MOTORS.pdf
PERFORMANCE_APPRAISAL_IN_TATA_MOTORS.pdf
 
modern methods of performance appraisal.pdf
modern methods of performance appraisal.pdfmodern methods of performance appraisal.pdf
modern methods of performance appraisal.pdf
 
15 questions for effective employee evaluation
15 questions for effective employee evaluation15 questions for effective employee evaluation
15 questions for effective employee evaluation
 
Introduction to Employee performance management(EPM) -Performance Management ...
Introduction to Employee performance management(EPM) -Performance Management ...Introduction to Employee performance management(EPM) -Performance Management ...
Introduction to Employee performance management(EPM) -Performance Management ...
 
Performance appraisal
Performance appraisalPerformance appraisal
Performance appraisal
 
Human resource management performance appraisal
Human resource management performance appraisalHuman resource management performance appraisal
Human resource management performance appraisal
 
Performance appraisal mistakes
Performance appraisal mistakesPerformance appraisal mistakes
Performance appraisal mistakes
 

More from ajithsrc

Business Plan On Retail Mall
Business Plan On Retail MallBusiness Plan On Retail Mall
Business Plan On Retail Mall
ajithsrc
 
New Ethics 5
New Ethics 5New Ethics 5
New Ethics 5ajithsrc
 
New Ethics 4
New Ethics 4New Ethics 4
New Ethics 4ajithsrc
 
Valuation Of S Ecurities
Valuation Of S EcuritiesValuation Of S Ecurities
Valuation Of S Ecuritiesajithsrc
 
Ajith Resume
Ajith ResumeAjith Resume
Ajith Resumeajithsrc
 
Operations Research
Operations ResearchOperations Research
Operations Researchajithsrc
 
Evolution Of Operations Management
Evolution Of Operations ManagementEvolution Of Operations Management
Evolution Of Operations Managementajithsrc
 
Textile Industry
Textile IndustryTextile Industry
Textile Industryajithsrc
 
Syndicate 1 Tqm
Syndicate 1 TqmSyndicate 1 Tqm
Syndicate 1 Tqmajithsrc
 
Supply Chain Mgmt Jit
Supply Chain Mgmt JitSupply Chain Mgmt Jit
Supply Chain Mgmt Jitajithsrc
 
Stevenson9e Ch04
Stevenson9e Ch04Stevenson9e Ch04
Stevenson9e Ch04ajithsrc
 

More from ajithsrc (20)

Business Plan On Retail Mall
Business Plan On Retail MallBusiness Plan On Retail Mall
Business Plan On Retail Mall
 
Ethics
EthicsEthics
Ethics
 
Ethics
EthicsEthics
Ethics
 
Ethics
EthicsEthics
Ethics
 
New Ethics 5
New Ethics 5New Ethics 5
New Ethics 5
 
New Ethics 4
New Ethics 4New Ethics 4
New Ethics 4
 
Valuation Of S Ecurities
Valuation Of S EcuritiesValuation Of S Ecurities
Valuation Of S Ecurities
 
Transport
TransportTransport
Transport
 
Inflation
InflationInflation
Inflation
 
Auto
AutoAuto
Auto
 
Ajith Resume
Ajith ResumeAjith Resume
Ajith Resume
 
Ksrtc
KsrtcKsrtc
Ksrtc
 
Operations Research
Operations ResearchOperations Research
Operations Research
 
Evolution Of Operations Management
Evolution Of Operations ManagementEvolution Of Operations Management
Evolution Of Operations Management
 
Tqm Tool2
Tqm Tool2Tqm Tool2
Tqm Tool2
 
Tqm Tool1
Tqm Tool1Tqm Tool1
Tqm Tool1
 
Textile Industry
Textile IndustryTextile Industry
Textile Industry
 
Syndicate 1 Tqm
Syndicate 1 TqmSyndicate 1 Tqm
Syndicate 1 Tqm
 
Supply Chain Mgmt Jit
Supply Chain Mgmt JitSupply Chain Mgmt Jit
Supply Chain Mgmt Jit
 
Stevenson9e Ch04
Stevenson9e Ch04Stevenson9e Ch04
Stevenson9e Ch04
 

Performance Appraisal

  • 1. LIMITATIONS OF PERFORMANCE APPRAISAL By, Suraj.T.S Deepa Mohan
  • 2. What is Performance Appraisal? Performance Appraisal is the formal conclusion to a performance management process at the end of a prescribed term. Prescribed terms may be any length but are usually a 12 month period.
  • 3. The Performance Appraisal process involves an interview between a staff member and their manager where the objectives and deliverables for the staff member are reviewed, and an overall assessment of the staff member's performance is agreed. It must be understood that a Performance Appraisal is only a component part of a Performance Management System. Many people confuse the two and interchange the terminology.
  • 4. LIMITATIONS OF PERFORMANCE APPRAISAL The results of merit rating will not be accurate unless the factors in the assessment are relevant. Sometimes , supervisors do not possess the critical ability in assessing the staff. The methods of performance appraisal are unreliable.
  • 5. The actual rating of subjective factors like initiative and personality of the employees may not be on scientific lines Sometimes , proper weights may not be given to the different qualities to be rated. The review is done in retrospect and is an average of six months old so recollection of events is poor.
  • 6. The opinions of staff and manager are often in opposition , causing demotivation. The process is usually manager driven and the staff member is expected to be complaint in the interview. There is no room for remedial action during the year.
  • 7. The process is usually done in a rushed manner to meet a budget development process and therefore loses its relevance to performance. The process usually involves the manager giving their opinion and the staff member having to defend the position , rather than a positive discussion.