Lessons learned
A step-wise implementation for application rationalization
Maik Schulz / November 16th, 2018 / EA Connect Days 2018
© NORMA GROUP SE. All rights reserved.
About me
23.11.2018 / Maik Schulz / EA Connect Days 2018 2
Maik Schulz
Director Application Management
NORMA Group Holding GmbH
4 years at NORMA Group
Both consulting and industry background in IT Management and EAM (15 years)
Development and architecture background (5 years)
© NORMA GROUP SE. All rights reserved. 23.11.2018 / Maik Schulz / EA Connect Days 2018 3
01
NORMA Group in brief
02
Architecture management challenges
03
Introducing LeanIX (2017)
04
Increasing the footprint (2018)
05
Critical mass generates interest
06
Outlook on 2019: governance
Agenda
01 NORMA Group in brief
© NORMA GROUP SE. All rights reserved.
NORMA Group in a nutshell
Company Presentation - 2018
NORMA Group is a global market leader in Engineered Joining
Technology that provides joining solutions for its customers by
meeting their individual needs. Driven by global and technological
megatrends, NORMA Group supports its customers in designing and
producing the right systems to gain competitive advantage.
NORMA Group Business Model
© NORMA GROUP SE. All rights reserved.
Delivers to more than
10,000 customers in 100
countries
NORMA Group key facts
Company Presentation - 2018
Offers more than 40,000
innovative joining solutions in
three product categories:
Clamp, Connect, Fluid
Employees > 9,000
worldwide
Operates a global network of
more than 29
manufacturing facilities
Numerous sales and
distribution sites across
Europe, the Americas and
Asia-Pacific
Global market and
technology leader in joining
technology
Headquarters in Maintal
near Frankfurt/Main,
Germany
Sales of about
EUR 1,017 million in
2017
Listed on the Frankfurt stock
exchange since 2011 and
included in the MDAX index
since 2013
© NORMA GROUP SE. All rights reserved.
A history of tradition and excellence
Company Presentation - 2018
Merger
ABA and
Rasmussen to
NORMA Group IPO
SDAX listing
MDAX listing
Founded by
Rasmussen
Production
starts
Opening
of head-
quarters
in Maintal
Acquisition
Breeze, USA
Foundation
NORMA Japan
Acquisition
Craig Assembly,
USA
Acquisition
Connectors
Verbindungs-
technik,
Switzerland
Acquisition
Davydick & Co,
Australia
Foundation
NORMA
China II
Foundation
NORMA China
Foundation
NORMA India
Foundation
NORMA Mexico
Acquisition
R.G. Ray, USA
Foundation
NORMA Korea
Foundation
NORMA Malaysia
Foundation
NORMA Turkey
Foundation
NORMA Russia
Acquisition
J-V shares, Spain
Acquisition
J-V shares, India
Opening Sales
& Competence
Center, Brazil
Foundation
NORMA Thailand
Foundation
NORMA Serbia
Acquisition
Chien Jin Plastic,
Malaysia
Acquisition
Nordic
Metalblok, Italy
Acquisition
Groen
Bevestigings-
materialen,
Netherlands
Acquisition
Variant, Poland
Acquisition
Guyco,
Australia
Foundation
NORMA Brazil
Acquisition
Five Star, USA
Acquisition
NDS, USA
1949 1955 1973 2006 2007 2008 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
Integration
NDS, USA
Acquisition
Autoline, France
2017
Acquisition
Lifial, Portugal
Acquisition
Fengfan, China
2018
Acquisition
Kimplas, India
Acquisition
Statek, Germany
© NORMA GROUP SE. All rights reserved.
Product categories for Fluid Handling solutions
Company Presentation - 2018
CONNECT CLAMP
FLUID
PLASTQUICK
FIX FLOW CONTROL
DRAIN
© NORMA GROUP SE. All rights reserved.
ICT at NORMA Group
23.11.2018 / Maik Schulz / EA Connect Days 2018
CIO
Infrastructure
& Operations
Application
Management
Solution
Architecture
Business
Solutions
Technical
Solutions
Information
Management
Global
Service Desk
EMEA Americas APAC
CIO Office
Risk &
Security
02 Architecture management challenges
© NORMA GROUP SE. All rights reserved.
Starting point and direction
• Until 5 years ago, ICT at NORMA Group was decentralized, with regional (EMEA, Americas, APAC) and local responsibilities
and organizational structures, and low drive towards harmonization in the application landscape
• Blooming shadow IT, not all IT-related budgets were under ICT control, not even for the large group applications
• Documentation was better in some countries, worse in others
• Frequent acquisitions led to a very diverse application landscape (our application zoo)
Direction: standardization, harmonization, centralization
• ICT is centralized since 5 years, including responsibility for all IT-related activities
• All applications are managed by ICT, all infrastructure is managed by ICT, all IT-related budgets are covered by ICT
• And thus the journey began…
Decentralised history, low architecture management maturity level
23.11.2018 / Maik Schulz / EA Connect Days 2018 11
© NORMA GROUP SE. All rights reserved. 23.11.2018 / Maik Schulz / EA Connect Days 2018 12
Excel- & PowerPoint-based “EAM” until end of 2016
V1
V2
03 Introducing LeanIX (2017)
© NORMA GROUP SE. All rights reserved.
The beginning: populating the applications
• The first target in 2017 was to get rid of Excel for keeping track of applications, and get a critical mass of data to make it useful
• We used two workspaces, one “Release Production” workspace for the “real” data, and a “Demo” workspace to try things out
• We started with our Excel list of applications, used the export feature from the LeanIX Application Inventory to see what the structure for
importing an Excel needs to look like, modified our Excel, and imported to start with ca. 300 applications (it took many iterations to get the
data in shape). This gave us application names, and in a few cases, descriptions.
23.11.2018 / Maik Schulz / EA Connect Days 2018 14
Step 1
Our best friends
when we started
© NORMA GROUP SE. All rights reserved.
The beginning: populating the applications
• Next up we (our solution architect and I) triaged the applications to fill in User Group (*) data from the original Excel. We had this
information already, and did not want to lose it when we stopped using the Excel. Also, in the second version of the application
Excel, we had information about which processes are supported by an application, so we used this as a basis for Business
Capabilities. This enabled the Application Landscape and Application Matrix reports in LeanIX.
23.11.2018 / Maik Schulz / EA Connect Days 2018 15
Step 2
© NORMA GROUP SE. All rights reserved.
The beginning: populating the applications
• On top, we created application-level tags to signify if we wanted to get rid of an application (eliminate) as part of our
harmonization, if we tolerated it (because there was no defined standard application), if it was only the wrong version (update), if
it was indeed our target application (nowadays renamed to “invest”), or if it needed more clarification. This allows us to show a
target Application Landscape, and for each User Group how far away they are.
• A second tag shows which group in ICT is responsible for the application: Regional ICT, Application Management, Infrastructure
& Operations, CIO Office, or if we keep it outside ICT (shop floor IT mostly). This gives a graphic view to the Regional ICT
Directors on how much better their live could be if they got rid of the applications that they are responsible for.
23.11.2018 / Maik Schulz / EA Connect Days 2018 16
Step 3
© NORMA GROUP SE. All rights reserved.
The result: an application roadmap
• After we updated application life-cycles, and defined successors,
we could use the Application Roadmap report, which shows us
where we are on our application rationalization path. The
Application Matrix helps us define projects to replace non-
standard applications by showing us where to look.
Step 4
23.11.2018 / Maik Schulz / EA Connect Days 2018 17
© NORMA GROUP SE. All rights reserved.
The beginning: what we left out
• I really like the idea of the Business Capability Cost report. It would make for some nice discussion
(“why are we spending as much on HR applications, as on Business Development, or on
Logistics?”). So, we captured some of this data, but stopped after a few entries. We already have
good transparency on what we are spending in ICT on different services. But getting this data out
of the current systems and into LeanIX, or worse, keeping LeanIX updated manually with that
same information, seemed like a bad idea.
• Business Processes are normally modeled in a BPMN tool, which gives you a graphical
representation. We still have them in MS Office, and not all of them. I don’t see the value of
connecting applications to Business Processes in LeanIX, at least not at our current maturity level
wrt BPM.
• We played around with Technology Stacks. So far, I haven’t seen compelling value from designing
a good stack separation and maintaining this data in LeanIX. At least not for NORMA Group,
YMMV.
• We never even started using Project fact sheets. Projects are maintained elsewhere, and it works
well enough. There is no compelling case for us to maintain project information in LeanIX.
We are not using every type of fact sheet
23.11.2018 / Maik Schulz / EA Connect Days 2018 18
04 Increasing the footprint (2018)
© NORMA GROUP SE. All rights reserved.
Using more fact sheet types
• We still had our interfaces Excel, with lots of fields that do not
exist in LeanIX (and that we don’t want to be visible to
everyone, like network paths of batch file directories etc).
• We started to add interfaces (and changing naming
conventions for the Interface fact sheet several times) still in
2017, at first without using Data Object fact sheets.
• In 2018, we started to investigate how we can find a good
structure on our SharePoint intranet that we can “outsource”
detailed information to, but have LeanIX as the central point of
entry for information. Now we have the first iteration, and link to
it from the Documents tab on the Interface fact sheet
Final Excel to get rid of
23.11.2018 / Maik Schulz / EA Connect Days 2018 20
© NORMA GROUP SE. All rights reserved.
The surprising appearance of GDPR
• A lot of people probably remember May 25th of this year, thanks to GDPR going
into full effect. So do we.
• We already the vast majority of our applications document, and a fair amount of
our interfaces. To be able to answer requests based on GDPR (e.g. “Which data
about me is in which applications, and where in the world?”), we had to introduce
Data Object fact sheets (we had been playing around with them, but not
seriously, they need a good structural design), as well as Provider fact sheets
(which, unfortunately, are linked to IT Component fact sheets). On top we added
tags to indicate handling of personal data, and special categories of personal
data to the Data Object fact sheets. Interfaces can have a tag “GDPR-relevant”.
Building on what we had
23.11.2018 / Maik Schulz / EA Connect Days 2018 21
© NORMA GROUP SE. All rights reserved.
Gathering lots of data quickly
• In order to gather information on which application processes which
data, we had to scale out.
• Based on Business Capabilities, we added global process owners as
subscribers to the Application fact sheets. For them we extracted an
Excel of applications that fall into their area of responsibility, and asked
them to name functional application owners.
• We added the functional application owners as responsible subscribers,
and used surveys to inquire about Data Objects and Interfaces.
Using surveys
23.11.2018 / Maik Schulz / EA Connect Days 2018 22
05 Critical mass generates interest
© NORMA GROUP SE. All rights reserved.
Requests to use LeanIX from other ICT areas
• LeanIX is the best source of information for the 1st level of our global services desk. Before LeanIX, in many cases they had no
information on a local application and cases took much longer to resolve.
• We are adding a technical application owner subscription to Application fact sheets to aid the service desk in finding the right
person to talk to.
• The next wish list item is to link to documents with our SLOs for applications, documentation, etc. All this will be provided via
SharePoint, using LeanIX as the entry, and linking from the Documents tab.
Infrastructure & Operations
• Would like to connect their database of servers and other infrastructure components to LeanIX. Will be investigated next year.
Risk & Compliance
• Just started adding information about ISO certifications of our XaaS providers, their audit findings etc. to the Documents tab of
IT Component fact sheets.
• We defined the business criticality of Applications based on input of the managing directors of the companies that use them
The list will grow…
Service Desk
23.11.2018 / Maik Schulz / EA Connect Days 2018 24
06 Outlook on 2019: governance
© NORMA GROUP SE. All rights reserved.
Relevant governance processes
• Projects change or add applications to the landscape. When a project is in a stage where it is reasonably certain it will execute
and change the application landscape, we add the application to LeanIX. The process is not well defined enough yet that we get
timely input for the lifecycle definition from the project (2019…)
• Non-standard application requests add applications to the landscape. As soon as we get a request, we add the application to
LeanIX. The process is not well enough defined yet that we can be certain we hear about it if someone rejects the request
(2019…)
• Service Management is in implementation right now, we will have to look at how to integrate with LeanIX in 2019
23.11.2018 / Maik Schulz / EA Connect Days 2018 26
Thank you very much for
your attention

Lessons learned: A step-wise implementation for Application Rationalization

  • 1.
    Lessons learned A step-wiseimplementation for application rationalization Maik Schulz / November 16th, 2018 / EA Connect Days 2018
  • 2.
    © NORMA GROUPSE. All rights reserved. About me 23.11.2018 / Maik Schulz / EA Connect Days 2018 2 Maik Schulz Director Application Management NORMA Group Holding GmbH 4 years at NORMA Group Both consulting and industry background in IT Management and EAM (15 years) Development and architecture background (5 years)
  • 3.
    © NORMA GROUPSE. All rights reserved. 23.11.2018 / Maik Schulz / EA Connect Days 2018 3 01 NORMA Group in brief 02 Architecture management challenges 03 Introducing LeanIX (2017) 04 Increasing the footprint (2018) 05 Critical mass generates interest 06 Outlook on 2019: governance Agenda
  • 4.
  • 5.
    © NORMA GROUPSE. All rights reserved. NORMA Group in a nutshell Company Presentation - 2018 NORMA Group is a global market leader in Engineered Joining Technology that provides joining solutions for its customers by meeting their individual needs. Driven by global and technological megatrends, NORMA Group supports its customers in designing and producing the right systems to gain competitive advantage. NORMA Group Business Model
  • 6.
    © NORMA GROUPSE. All rights reserved. Delivers to more than 10,000 customers in 100 countries NORMA Group key facts Company Presentation - 2018 Offers more than 40,000 innovative joining solutions in three product categories: Clamp, Connect, Fluid Employees > 9,000 worldwide Operates a global network of more than 29 manufacturing facilities Numerous sales and distribution sites across Europe, the Americas and Asia-Pacific Global market and technology leader in joining technology Headquarters in Maintal near Frankfurt/Main, Germany Sales of about EUR 1,017 million in 2017 Listed on the Frankfurt stock exchange since 2011 and included in the MDAX index since 2013
  • 7.
    © NORMA GROUPSE. All rights reserved. A history of tradition and excellence Company Presentation - 2018 Merger ABA and Rasmussen to NORMA Group IPO SDAX listing MDAX listing Founded by Rasmussen Production starts Opening of head- quarters in Maintal Acquisition Breeze, USA Foundation NORMA Japan Acquisition Craig Assembly, USA Acquisition Connectors Verbindungs- technik, Switzerland Acquisition Davydick & Co, Australia Foundation NORMA China II Foundation NORMA China Foundation NORMA India Foundation NORMA Mexico Acquisition R.G. Ray, USA Foundation NORMA Korea Foundation NORMA Malaysia Foundation NORMA Turkey Foundation NORMA Russia Acquisition J-V shares, Spain Acquisition J-V shares, India Opening Sales & Competence Center, Brazil Foundation NORMA Thailand Foundation NORMA Serbia Acquisition Chien Jin Plastic, Malaysia Acquisition Nordic Metalblok, Italy Acquisition Groen Bevestigings- materialen, Netherlands Acquisition Variant, Poland Acquisition Guyco, Australia Foundation NORMA Brazil Acquisition Five Star, USA Acquisition NDS, USA 1949 1955 1973 2006 2007 2008 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Integration NDS, USA Acquisition Autoline, France 2017 Acquisition Lifial, Portugal Acquisition Fengfan, China 2018 Acquisition Kimplas, India Acquisition Statek, Germany
  • 8.
    © NORMA GROUPSE. All rights reserved. Product categories for Fluid Handling solutions Company Presentation - 2018 CONNECT CLAMP FLUID PLASTQUICK FIX FLOW CONTROL DRAIN
  • 9.
    © NORMA GROUPSE. All rights reserved. ICT at NORMA Group 23.11.2018 / Maik Schulz / EA Connect Days 2018 CIO Infrastructure & Operations Application Management Solution Architecture Business Solutions Technical Solutions Information Management Global Service Desk EMEA Americas APAC CIO Office Risk & Security
  • 10.
  • 11.
    © NORMA GROUPSE. All rights reserved. Starting point and direction • Until 5 years ago, ICT at NORMA Group was decentralized, with regional (EMEA, Americas, APAC) and local responsibilities and organizational structures, and low drive towards harmonization in the application landscape • Blooming shadow IT, not all IT-related budgets were under ICT control, not even for the large group applications • Documentation was better in some countries, worse in others • Frequent acquisitions led to a very diverse application landscape (our application zoo) Direction: standardization, harmonization, centralization • ICT is centralized since 5 years, including responsibility for all IT-related activities • All applications are managed by ICT, all infrastructure is managed by ICT, all IT-related budgets are covered by ICT • And thus the journey began… Decentralised history, low architecture management maturity level 23.11.2018 / Maik Schulz / EA Connect Days 2018 11
  • 12.
    © NORMA GROUPSE. All rights reserved. 23.11.2018 / Maik Schulz / EA Connect Days 2018 12 Excel- & PowerPoint-based “EAM” until end of 2016 V1 V2
  • 13.
  • 14.
    © NORMA GROUPSE. All rights reserved. The beginning: populating the applications • The first target in 2017 was to get rid of Excel for keeping track of applications, and get a critical mass of data to make it useful • We used two workspaces, one “Release Production” workspace for the “real” data, and a “Demo” workspace to try things out • We started with our Excel list of applications, used the export feature from the LeanIX Application Inventory to see what the structure for importing an Excel needs to look like, modified our Excel, and imported to start with ca. 300 applications (it took many iterations to get the data in shape). This gave us application names, and in a few cases, descriptions. 23.11.2018 / Maik Schulz / EA Connect Days 2018 14 Step 1 Our best friends when we started
  • 15.
    © NORMA GROUPSE. All rights reserved. The beginning: populating the applications • Next up we (our solution architect and I) triaged the applications to fill in User Group (*) data from the original Excel. We had this information already, and did not want to lose it when we stopped using the Excel. Also, in the second version of the application Excel, we had information about which processes are supported by an application, so we used this as a basis for Business Capabilities. This enabled the Application Landscape and Application Matrix reports in LeanIX. 23.11.2018 / Maik Schulz / EA Connect Days 2018 15 Step 2
  • 16.
    © NORMA GROUPSE. All rights reserved. The beginning: populating the applications • On top, we created application-level tags to signify if we wanted to get rid of an application (eliminate) as part of our harmonization, if we tolerated it (because there was no defined standard application), if it was only the wrong version (update), if it was indeed our target application (nowadays renamed to “invest”), or if it needed more clarification. This allows us to show a target Application Landscape, and for each User Group how far away they are. • A second tag shows which group in ICT is responsible for the application: Regional ICT, Application Management, Infrastructure & Operations, CIO Office, or if we keep it outside ICT (shop floor IT mostly). This gives a graphic view to the Regional ICT Directors on how much better their live could be if they got rid of the applications that they are responsible for. 23.11.2018 / Maik Schulz / EA Connect Days 2018 16 Step 3
  • 17.
    © NORMA GROUPSE. All rights reserved. The result: an application roadmap • After we updated application life-cycles, and defined successors, we could use the Application Roadmap report, which shows us where we are on our application rationalization path. The Application Matrix helps us define projects to replace non- standard applications by showing us where to look. Step 4 23.11.2018 / Maik Schulz / EA Connect Days 2018 17
  • 18.
    © NORMA GROUPSE. All rights reserved. The beginning: what we left out • I really like the idea of the Business Capability Cost report. It would make for some nice discussion (“why are we spending as much on HR applications, as on Business Development, or on Logistics?”). So, we captured some of this data, but stopped after a few entries. We already have good transparency on what we are spending in ICT on different services. But getting this data out of the current systems and into LeanIX, or worse, keeping LeanIX updated manually with that same information, seemed like a bad idea. • Business Processes are normally modeled in a BPMN tool, which gives you a graphical representation. We still have them in MS Office, and not all of them. I don’t see the value of connecting applications to Business Processes in LeanIX, at least not at our current maturity level wrt BPM. • We played around with Technology Stacks. So far, I haven’t seen compelling value from designing a good stack separation and maintaining this data in LeanIX. At least not for NORMA Group, YMMV. • We never even started using Project fact sheets. Projects are maintained elsewhere, and it works well enough. There is no compelling case for us to maintain project information in LeanIX. We are not using every type of fact sheet 23.11.2018 / Maik Schulz / EA Connect Days 2018 18
  • 19.
    04 Increasing thefootprint (2018)
  • 20.
    © NORMA GROUPSE. All rights reserved. Using more fact sheet types • We still had our interfaces Excel, with lots of fields that do not exist in LeanIX (and that we don’t want to be visible to everyone, like network paths of batch file directories etc). • We started to add interfaces (and changing naming conventions for the Interface fact sheet several times) still in 2017, at first without using Data Object fact sheets. • In 2018, we started to investigate how we can find a good structure on our SharePoint intranet that we can “outsource” detailed information to, but have LeanIX as the central point of entry for information. Now we have the first iteration, and link to it from the Documents tab on the Interface fact sheet Final Excel to get rid of 23.11.2018 / Maik Schulz / EA Connect Days 2018 20
  • 21.
    © NORMA GROUPSE. All rights reserved. The surprising appearance of GDPR • A lot of people probably remember May 25th of this year, thanks to GDPR going into full effect. So do we. • We already the vast majority of our applications document, and a fair amount of our interfaces. To be able to answer requests based on GDPR (e.g. “Which data about me is in which applications, and where in the world?”), we had to introduce Data Object fact sheets (we had been playing around with them, but not seriously, they need a good structural design), as well as Provider fact sheets (which, unfortunately, are linked to IT Component fact sheets). On top we added tags to indicate handling of personal data, and special categories of personal data to the Data Object fact sheets. Interfaces can have a tag “GDPR-relevant”. Building on what we had 23.11.2018 / Maik Schulz / EA Connect Days 2018 21
  • 22.
    © NORMA GROUPSE. All rights reserved. Gathering lots of data quickly • In order to gather information on which application processes which data, we had to scale out. • Based on Business Capabilities, we added global process owners as subscribers to the Application fact sheets. For them we extracted an Excel of applications that fall into their area of responsibility, and asked them to name functional application owners. • We added the functional application owners as responsible subscribers, and used surveys to inquire about Data Objects and Interfaces. Using surveys 23.11.2018 / Maik Schulz / EA Connect Days 2018 22
  • 23.
    05 Critical massgenerates interest
  • 24.
    © NORMA GROUPSE. All rights reserved. Requests to use LeanIX from other ICT areas • LeanIX is the best source of information for the 1st level of our global services desk. Before LeanIX, in many cases they had no information on a local application and cases took much longer to resolve. • We are adding a technical application owner subscription to Application fact sheets to aid the service desk in finding the right person to talk to. • The next wish list item is to link to documents with our SLOs for applications, documentation, etc. All this will be provided via SharePoint, using LeanIX as the entry, and linking from the Documents tab. Infrastructure & Operations • Would like to connect their database of servers and other infrastructure components to LeanIX. Will be investigated next year. Risk & Compliance • Just started adding information about ISO certifications of our XaaS providers, their audit findings etc. to the Documents tab of IT Component fact sheets. • We defined the business criticality of Applications based on input of the managing directors of the companies that use them The list will grow… Service Desk 23.11.2018 / Maik Schulz / EA Connect Days 2018 24
  • 25.
    06 Outlook on2019: governance
  • 26.
    © NORMA GROUPSE. All rights reserved. Relevant governance processes • Projects change or add applications to the landscape. When a project is in a stage where it is reasonably certain it will execute and change the application landscape, we add the application to LeanIX. The process is not well defined enough yet that we get timely input for the lifecycle definition from the project (2019…) • Non-standard application requests add applications to the landscape. As soon as we get a request, we add the application to LeanIX. The process is not well enough defined yet that we can be certain we hear about it if someone rejects the request (2019…) • Service Management is in implementation right now, we will have to look at how to integrate with LeanIX in 2019 23.11.2018 / Maik Schulz / EA Connect Days 2018 26
  • 27.
    Thank you verymuch for your attention