FEA Based Pipe Stress Analysis -
Introduction To Pipe Calculation
System (PCS)
Presented by RMC and VIAS
Carlos Eduardo Alvares
Arindam Chakraborty, PhD, PE
© 2017 Virtual Integrated Analytics Solutions Inc.
Agenda
1 VIAS and RMC Overview
2 Standard Flexibility Methods And Other Available Techniques
3 Overview of PCS
4 Demo
5 Contact Information
6 Q&A
2
VIAS AND RMC OVERVIEW
© 2017 Virtual Integrated Analytics Solutions Inc.
About VIAS
Engineering
Consultancy
Training
Hardware
Software
• Multiple Industry Experience – Oil & Gas, Machinery &
Equipment, Petrochemical & Process, Nuclear,
Aerospace, Medical Devices
• Presence in Houston, Cincinnati, San Francisco, Detroit
• Team consists of Ph.D. and Masters in Solid Mechanics,
Fluid Mechanics, Materials and Corrosion, Numerical
Analysis, Statistics; Optimization and Reliability
• Solution partner of Dassault Systèmes SIMULIA products
– Abaqus, Isight, fe-safe, Tosca
• Provide Virtual Design Experience through Collaboration
and Data Analytics – Provides Automation and
Customization
• Provide 3D Printing and AM Simulation Services
4
© 2017 Virtual Integrated Analytics Solutions Inc.
VIAS Technical Capabilities
Design Analysis and
Validation using
Simulation
FEA based Fracture /
Damage Mechanics /
ECA
Optimization and
Reliability
Multi-physics
Simulations (CFD,
Thermal Analysis)
Composites and
Elastomer modelling
Structural Analysis /
Plant Engineering
Integrity Management –
FFS, RBI
Simulation Automation /
Workflow Development
Corrosion Testing and
Material Test Program
Support
Data Analytics
5
© 2017 Virtual Integrated Analytics Solutions Inc.
Training at VIAS – In-Class / Online
http://www.viascorp.com/course-schedule/
6
© 2017 Virtual Integrated Analytics Solutions Inc.
VIAS – Abaqus Support Day
7
© 2017 Virtual Integrated Analytics Solutions Inc.
About RMC
• Established since 1984;
• Engineering services and software for O&G and Energy
industries.
8
© 2017 Virtual Integrated Analytics Solutions Inc.
RMC Mission
To provide customers with best in class engineering services
and engineering software products, ensuring them fast, safe,
reliable and profitable operations.
9
© 2017 Virtual Integrated Analytics Solutions Inc.
RMC Software Products
10
STANDARD FLEXIBILITY METHODS AND
OTHER AVAILABLE TECHNIQUES
© 2017 Virtual Integrated Analytics Solutions Inc.
• 172 tagged lines
• Large diameters (between 16” and
24”)
• 87snubbers + 165 spring hangers
• Non-standard components
• Temperature range: 0 to 690°C
• Larson-Miller, Time-History e Slug-
Flow
• 54 independent load cases
Coke Drum Analysis by Standard
Flexibility Methods
12
© 2017 Virtual Integrated Analytics Solutions Inc.
Flexibility & Stress Intensification
Factors
SIFs (i):
• Experimentally developed on the late 40’s.
• Incorporated in ASME B31.3 on 1955.
• Compares fatigue strength of a component against a
standard butt-welded straight pipe.
• In-fact, “i” factors are penalty factors.
• Developed considering displacement controlled loads
only (secondary loads).
• Available for simple components only.
Warnings:
• D/t ratio
• Non-standard components
• Flexibility Factors strongly influences SIFs
• Different weld procedures from the 50’s
• Fatigue from primary loads
• HCF or LCF (penalty factor f)
• Nonlinearities
Flexibility Factors (k):
• Analytically developed on the early 1900’s.
• Extremely dependent on pipe ovalization.
• Valid for small values of h.
• Available for simple components only.
Ref.: ASME-B31.3,"Chemical Plant and Petroleum Refinery Piping", New York, N.Y., (2012).
13
© 2017 Virtual Integrated Analytics Solutions Inc.
Acknowledging Limitations - The need
for more applicable data
Ref.: ASME-B31.3,"Chemical Plant and Petroleum Refinery Piping", New York, N.Y., (2012).
14
© 2017 Virtual Integrated Analytics Solutions Inc.
PCS vs. Markl`s Lab Tests
15
© 2017 Virtual Integrated Analytics Solutions Inc.
Details of a typical pipe specimen
Ref: Vishnuvardhan, S., Raghava, G., Gandhi, P., Goyal, S., Gupta, S. K., and Bhasin, V., 2013,
“Ratcheting Strain Assessment in Pressurised Stainless Steel Elbows Subjected to In-
plane Bending,” Procedia Eng., 55, pp. 666–670.
16
© 2017 Virtual Integrated Analytics Solutions Inc.
Flexibility Analysis – Available Techniques
TEMPERATURE
PRESSURE
LOW MEDIUM HIGH
LOADING HISTORY
GEOMETRY
17
© 2017 Virtual Integrated Analytics Solutions Inc.
TEMPERATURE
PRESSURE
LOW MEDIUM HIGH
LOADING HISTORY
GEOMETRY
STANDARD FLEXIBILITY
METHOD
18
Flexibility Analysis – Available Techniques
© 2017 Virtual Integrated Analytics Solutions Inc.
TEMPERATURE
PRESSURE
LOW MEDIUM HIGH
LOADING HISTORY
GEOMETRY
STANDARD FLEXIBILITY METHOD
+
NON-STANDARD FEA TOOLS
19
Flexibility Analysis – Available Techniques
© 2017 Virtual Integrated Analytics Solutions Inc.
TEMPERATURE
PRESSURE
LOW MEDIUM HIGH
LOADING HISTORY
GEOMETRY
HIGH PERFORMANCE
FINITE ELEMENTS
(ABAQUS)
20
Flexibility Analysis – Available Techniques
© 2017 Virtual Integrated Analytics Solutions Inc.
TEMPERATURE
PRESSURE
LOW MEDIUM HIGH
LOADING HISTORY
GEOMETRY
PCS – PIPE CALCULATION SYSTEM
21
Flexibility Analysis – Available Techniques
© 2017 Virtual Integrated Analytics Solutions Inc.
Simulia Abaqus
• Linear and nonlinear analysis
• Complex material models
• Complex assemblies
• Contact, fracture & failure capabilities
• Scalability (High-Performance
Computing)
• Open development API
22
OVERVIEW OF PCS
© 2017 Virtual Integrated Analytics Solutions Inc.
Overview of PCS
24
© 2017 Virtual Integrated Analytics Solutions Inc.
• Internal Databases
• Pipe Routing
• Bends
• Supports
• Hangers
• Rigid
• Pre-processing
• Running
• Input and Output tabular reports:
➢ Human readable.
➢ Evidence of all calculation
assumptions and results.
➢ Easy storage.
• Standard Abaqus .inp files.
• Standard Abaqus .odb files.
Overview of PCS
25
© 2017 Virtual Integrated Analytics Solutions Inc.
Case Study #1 – Benchmark 24
Benchmark 24:
8”- sch. 40 – API-5L B (~80 m)
Corrosion Allowance: 1.6 mm
Temperature: 70 °C
S.G: 1.0
26
© 2017 Virtual Integrated Analytics Solutions Inc.
Short Demo
Demo!
27
© 2017 Virtual Integrated Analytics Solutions Inc.
Case Study #2 – Benchmark 07
Benchmark 07:
14”/16”/18”- STD – API-5L B
(~250 m)
Corrosion Allowance: 1.6 mm
Temperature: 70 °C
S.G: 0.82
Fx [N] Fy [N] Fz [N]
PCS 58,097.0 -33,800.0 144,763.0
Caesar II (No Flg) -28,803.0 27,410.0 -80,066.0
Caesar II (2 Flg) -37,732.0 30,729.0 -101,969.0
28
© 2017 Virtual Integrated Analytics Solutions Inc.
Case Study #3 – Pipeline Jog
Pipeline Jog:
16”- STD – P22
Temperature: 594 °C
29
© 2017 Virtual Integrated Analytics Solutions Inc.
Case Study #3 – Pipeline Jog
T=21°C
T=594°C
T=21°C
T=21°C
T=594°C
T=594°C
30
CONTACT INFORMATION
© 2017 Virtual Integrated Analytics Solutions Inc.
Eng. Carlos Eduardo A. de C. e Sousa
PCS Development Manager / FEA Specialist
eduardo@rmcrs.com.br
Contact Information
RMC Consultoria
www.rmcrs.com.br
www.explorepcs.com
+55 (51) 3335-15-05
Rua 24 de Outubro,
1681/209
90510-003
Porto Alegre – RS – Brazil
RMC Contact Information
32
© 2017 Virtual Integrated Analytics Solutions Inc.
VIAS Contact Information
Certified Simulia Support and Training
Engineering Consulting, Automation
Email : support@viascorp.com
Phone : +1 (832) 301-0881
33
THANK YOU!
Q&A

FEA Based Pipe Stress Analysis - Introduction To Pipe Calculation System (PCS)

  • 1.
    FEA Based PipeStress Analysis - Introduction To Pipe Calculation System (PCS) Presented by RMC and VIAS Carlos Eduardo Alvares Arindam Chakraborty, PhD, PE
  • 2.
    © 2017 VirtualIntegrated Analytics Solutions Inc. Agenda 1 VIAS and RMC Overview 2 Standard Flexibility Methods And Other Available Techniques 3 Overview of PCS 4 Demo 5 Contact Information 6 Q&A 2
  • 3.
    VIAS AND RMCOVERVIEW
  • 4.
    © 2017 VirtualIntegrated Analytics Solutions Inc. About VIAS Engineering Consultancy Training Hardware Software • Multiple Industry Experience – Oil & Gas, Machinery & Equipment, Petrochemical & Process, Nuclear, Aerospace, Medical Devices • Presence in Houston, Cincinnati, San Francisco, Detroit • Team consists of Ph.D. and Masters in Solid Mechanics, Fluid Mechanics, Materials and Corrosion, Numerical Analysis, Statistics; Optimization and Reliability • Solution partner of Dassault Systèmes SIMULIA products – Abaqus, Isight, fe-safe, Tosca • Provide Virtual Design Experience through Collaboration and Data Analytics – Provides Automation and Customization • Provide 3D Printing and AM Simulation Services 4
  • 5.
    © 2017 VirtualIntegrated Analytics Solutions Inc. VIAS Technical Capabilities Design Analysis and Validation using Simulation FEA based Fracture / Damage Mechanics / ECA Optimization and Reliability Multi-physics Simulations (CFD, Thermal Analysis) Composites and Elastomer modelling Structural Analysis / Plant Engineering Integrity Management – FFS, RBI Simulation Automation / Workflow Development Corrosion Testing and Material Test Program Support Data Analytics 5
  • 6.
    © 2017 VirtualIntegrated Analytics Solutions Inc. Training at VIAS – In-Class / Online http://www.viascorp.com/course-schedule/ 6
  • 7.
    © 2017 VirtualIntegrated Analytics Solutions Inc. VIAS – Abaqus Support Day 7
  • 8.
    © 2017 VirtualIntegrated Analytics Solutions Inc. About RMC • Established since 1984; • Engineering services and software for O&G and Energy industries. 8
  • 9.
    © 2017 VirtualIntegrated Analytics Solutions Inc. RMC Mission To provide customers with best in class engineering services and engineering software products, ensuring them fast, safe, reliable and profitable operations. 9
  • 10.
    © 2017 VirtualIntegrated Analytics Solutions Inc. RMC Software Products 10
  • 11.
    STANDARD FLEXIBILITY METHODSAND OTHER AVAILABLE TECHNIQUES
  • 12.
    © 2017 VirtualIntegrated Analytics Solutions Inc. • 172 tagged lines • Large diameters (between 16” and 24”) • 87snubbers + 165 spring hangers • Non-standard components • Temperature range: 0 to 690°C • Larson-Miller, Time-History e Slug- Flow • 54 independent load cases Coke Drum Analysis by Standard Flexibility Methods 12
  • 13.
    © 2017 VirtualIntegrated Analytics Solutions Inc. Flexibility & Stress Intensification Factors SIFs (i): • Experimentally developed on the late 40’s. • Incorporated in ASME B31.3 on 1955. • Compares fatigue strength of a component against a standard butt-welded straight pipe. • In-fact, “i” factors are penalty factors. • Developed considering displacement controlled loads only (secondary loads). • Available for simple components only. Warnings: • D/t ratio • Non-standard components • Flexibility Factors strongly influences SIFs • Different weld procedures from the 50’s • Fatigue from primary loads • HCF or LCF (penalty factor f) • Nonlinearities Flexibility Factors (k): • Analytically developed on the early 1900’s. • Extremely dependent on pipe ovalization. • Valid for small values of h. • Available for simple components only. Ref.: ASME-B31.3,"Chemical Plant and Petroleum Refinery Piping", New York, N.Y., (2012). 13
  • 14.
    © 2017 VirtualIntegrated Analytics Solutions Inc. Acknowledging Limitations - The need for more applicable data Ref.: ASME-B31.3,"Chemical Plant and Petroleum Refinery Piping", New York, N.Y., (2012). 14
  • 15.
    © 2017 VirtualIntegrated Analytics Solutions Inc. PCS vs. Markl`s Lab Tests 15
  • 16.
    © 2017 VirtualIntegrated Analytics Solutions Inc. Details of a typical pipe specimen Ref: Vishnuvardhan, S., Raghava, G., Gandhi, P., Goyal, S., Gupta, S. K., and Bhasin, V., 2013, “Ratcheting Strain Assessment in Pressurised Stainless Steel Elbows Subjected to In- plane Bending,” Procedia Eng., 55, pp. 666–670. 16
  • 17.
    © 2017 VirtualIntegrated Analytics Solutions Inc. Flexibility Analysis – Available Techniques TEMPERATURE PRESSURE LOW MEDIUM HIGH LOADING HISTORY GEOMETRY 17
  • 18.
    © 2017 VirtualIntegrated Analytics Solutions Inc. TEMPERATURE PRESSURE LOW MEDIUM HIGH LOADING HISTORY GEOMETRY STANDARD FLEXIBILITY METHOD 18 Flexibility Analysis – Available Techniques
  • 19.
    © 2017 VirtualIntegrated Analytics Solutions Inc. TEMPERATURE PRESSURE LOW MEDIUM HIGH LOADING HISTORY GEOMETRY STANDARD FLEXIBILITY METHOD + NON-STANDARD FEA TOOLS 19 Flexibility Analysis – Available Techniques
  • 20.
    © 2017 VirtualIntegrated Analytics Solutions Inc. TEMPERATURE PRESSURE LOW MEDIUM HIGH LOADING HISTORY GEOMETRY HIGH PERFORMANCE FINITE ELEMENTS (ABAQUS) 20 Flexibility Analysis – Available Techniques
  • 21.
    © 2017 VirtualIntegrated Analytics Solutions Inc. TEMPERATURE PRESSURE LOW MEDIUM HIGH LOADING HISTORY GEOMETRY PCS – PIPE CALCULATION SYSTEM 21 Flexibility Analysis – Available Techniques
  • 22.
    © 2017 VirtualIntegrated Analytics Solutions Inc. Simulia Abaqus • Linear and nonlinear analysis • Complex material models • Complex assemblies • Contact, fracture & failure capabilities • Scalability (High-Performance Computing) • Open development API 22
  • 23.
  • 24.
    © 2017 VirtualIntegrated Analytics Solutions Inc. Overview of PCS 24
  • 25.
    © 2017 VirtualIntegrated Analytics Solutions Inc. • Internal Databases • Pipe Routing • Bends • Supports • Hangers • Rigid • Pre-processing • Running • Input and Output tabular reports: ➢ Human readable. ➢ Evidence of all calculation assumptions and results. ➢ Easy storage. • Standard Abaqus .inp files. • Standard Abaqus .odb files. Overview of PCS 25
  • 26.
    © 2017 VirtualIntegrated Analytics Solutions Inc. Case Study #1 – Benchmark 24 Benchmark 24: 8”- sch. 40 – API-5L B (~80 m) Corrosion Allowance: 1.6 mm Temperature: 70 °C S.G: 1.0 26
  • 27.
    © 2017 VirtualIntegrated Analytics Solutions Inc. Short Demo Demo! 27
  • 28.
    © 2017 VirtualIntegrated Analytics Solutions Inc. Case Study #2 – Benchmark 07 Benchmark 07: 14”/16”/18”- STD – API-5L B (~250 m) Corrosion Allowance: 1.6 mm Temperature: 70 °C S.G: 0.82 Fx [N] Fy [N] Fz [N] PCS 58,097.0 -33,800.0 144,763.0 Caesar II (No Flg) -28,803.0 27,410.0 -80,066.0 Caesar II (2 Flg) -37,732.0 30,729.0 -101,969.0 28
  • 29.
    © 2017 VirtualIntegrated Analytics Solutions Inc. Case Study #3 – Pipeline Jog Pipeline Jog: 16”- STD – P22 Temperature: 594 °C 29
  • 30.
    © 2017 VirtualIntegrated Analytics Solutions Inc. Case Study #3 – Pipeline Jog T=21°C T=594°C T=21°C T=21°C T=594°C T=594°C 30
  • 31.
  • 32.
    © 2017 VirtualIntegrated Analytics Solutions Inc. Eng. Carlos Eduardo A. de C. e Sousa PCS Development Manager / FEA Specialist eduardo@rmcrs.com.br Contact Information RMC Consultoria www.rmcrs.com.br www.explorepcs.com +55 (51) 3335-15-05 Rua 24 de Outubro, 1681/209 90510-003 Porto Alegre – RS – Brazil RMC Contact Information 32
  • 33.
    © 2017 VirtualIntegrated Analytics Solutions Inc. VIAS Contact Information Certified Simulia Support and Training Engineering Consulting, Automation Email : support@viascorp.com Phone : +1 (832) 301-0881 33
  • 34.
  • 35.