Fairness and Balance

   Not the Fox News kind
Fairness and Balance
• Fair: The report presents all important views
  on a subject
• Unbiased: The reporter separates her
  personal opinions
• Accurate: The news outlet each day makes
  a rigorous effort to ensure facts are accurate
  and presented in the correct context
• Get both sides and give sources a chance to
  answer their critics
• Avoid loaded language: reform, pro-family
The Echo Chamber
• Are you reporting what’s newsworthy and
  important to your audience, or do you
  consider it newsworthy because a news
  outlet you respect has given it attention?
• Incestuous amplification
• Are you writing to educate your audience
  or give them confirmation about their
  beliefs?
Verifying Assertions
• Don’t create an artificial balance: Legitimate
  scientists on one side, passionate nut jobs on
  the other
• It’s not enough to give the same amount of
  time if one side is saying things that are
  untrue
• The scientists who disagree with the
  concept of climate change are a very small
  number on the fringes (same with
  autism/vaccine link)
Verifying Assertions
• Question stats with the “common sense” test:
  – “as many as 2,000,000 children are abducted
    every year in the U.S.
  – 1 billion people watch the Academy Awards
• Avoid loaded language
  – Not always easy: illegal immigrants vs.
    undocumented workers
Fairness and Balance

   Not the Fox News kind

Fairness balance

  • 1.
    Fairness and Balance Not the Fox News kind
  • 2.
    Fairness and Balance •Fair: The report presents all important views on a subject • Unbiased: The reporter separates her personal opinions • Accurate: The news outlet each day makes a rigorous effort to ensure facts are accurate and presented in the correct context • Get both sides and give sources a chance to answer their critics • Avoid loaded language: reform, pro-family
  • 3.
    The Echo Chamber •Are you reporting what’s newsworthy and important to your audience, or do you consider it newsworthy because a news outlet you respect has given it attention? • Incestuous amplification • Are you writing to educate your audience or give them confirmation about their beliefs?
  • 4.
    Verifying Assertions • Don’tcreate an artificial balance: Legitimate scientists on one side, passionate nut jobs on the other • It’s not enough to give the same amount of time if one side is saying things that are untrue • The scientists who disagree with the concept of climate change are a very small number on the fringes (same with autism/vaccine link)
  • 5.
    Verifying Assertions • Questionstats with the “common sense” test: – “as many as 2,000,000 children are abducted every year in the U.S. – 1 billion people watch the Academy Awards • Avoid loaded language – Not always easy: illegal immigrants vs. undocumented workers
  • 6.
    Fairness and Balance Not the Fox News kind