1
CUSTOMER ENGAGEMENT
AN OMNICHANNEL
PERSPECTIVE
Deborah Weinswig
Executive Director – Head Global Retail & Technology
Fung Business Intelligence Center Global
2
DEBORAH
WEINSWIG
•  Executive Director and Head of Global Retail & Technology for
the Fung Business Intelligence Centre
•  Award-winning global retail analyst and a specialist in retail
innovation and technology
•  12 Years at Citi Research where she served as Head of the
Global Staples & Consumer Discretionary Team
•  #1 ranking analyst by Institutional Investor for nine years
•  Mentor to Silicon Valley accelerators including Alchemist
Accelerator and Plug & Play
•  Certified Public Accountant, with a Masters of Business
Administration degree from the University of Chicago
3
FUNG
BUSINESS
INTELLIGENCE
CENTRE (FBIC)
•  Established in 2000 and headquartered in
Hong Kong
•  FBIC (formerly known as the Li & Fung
Research Centre) has served as the
knowledge bank and think tank for the Fung
Group
•  New York–based Global Retail & Technology
research team follows broader retail and
technology trends
4
AGENDA •  Omnichannel Trends
•  Current Trends
•  Future Trends
5
OMNICHANNEL TRENDS
6
THE STATE OF
SHOPPING
•  Internet shopping is about functionality,
not fun
•  As more shoppers move online, in-store
shopping will increasingly focus on leisure
shopping and the quality of experience
•  Online/offline division is becoming artificial
as consumers browse, compare and buy
across channels
•  More complex than simply “showrooming”
•  Click & collect provides the functional
transaction coupled with in-store experience
•  Stores must be set up to deliver a quality
experience
7
OPPORTUNITY
COST OF
NON-OMNICHANNEL
10%
Lost revenue
=
$110+ mn
in lost revenue lost for 1 billion retailer
Source:	
  RIS-­‐EKN	
  Customer	
  Engagement	
  Study,	
  2014,	
  EKN-­‐Toshiba	
  Omni-­‐Channel	
  ExecuDon	
  Study	
  
8
EVOLUTION OF CORE
OMNICHANNEL
EXECUTION
Source:	
  RIS-­‐EKN	
  Customer	
  Engagement	
  Survey,	
  2014	
  (100+	
  retail	
  execuDves	
  surveyed	
  in	
  the	
  US)	
  
Figures	
  are	
  %	
  of	
  total	
  respondents	
  
9
OMNICHANNEL
CUSTOMERS:
MORE PROFITABLE
BUT UNKNOWN
76%
Don’t know how who their
Omni channel customers are
Source:	
  RIS-­‐EKN	
  Customer	
  Engagement	
  Study,	
  2014,	
  
10
RETAILERS STILL
USING OLD KEY
PERFORMANCE
INDICATORS
Top KPI’s that retailers
measure
Sales/
channel 82%
Customer
satisfaction
Average
margin
57%
45%
Customer
Lifetime
Value
22%
Share of
wallet
Customer engagement
across channels
8%
Source: RIS-EKN Customer Engagement Study, 2014
KPI’s that they need to
pay more attention to
11
B&M STORE:
THE OMNICHANNEL
H U B
1 in 2
have deployed digital coupon
reading in-store
66%
of retailers have currently
deployed store specific social
media initiatives
46%
have store specific websites
75%
will use their store as a delivery
hub for online orders by 2015
Sources:	
  RIS-­‐EKN	
  Customer	
  Engagement	
  Study,	
  2014;	
  EKN	
  Future	
  of	
  Store	
  Study,	
  2013	
  
12
AMAZON:
GOLD STANDARD
OF EXECUTION
Mobile Commerce
and Engagement
1 Amazon (56%)
2 Starbucks (9%)
3 Apple (7%)
Unified Commerce
1 Amazon (28%)
2 Macy’s (9%)
3
Nordstrom/Wal-
Mart/Best Buy (7%)
Customer
Engagement
1 Amazon (33%)
2 Nordstrom (8%)
3
Best Buy/
Starbucks (5%)
Source:	
  RIS-­‐EKN	
  Customer	
  Engagement	
  Study,	
  2014	
  
13
CURRENT TRENDS
14
UBIQUITY OF
MOBILE DEVICES
•  Constant connectivity enables shoppers to
find product details, compare prices and buy
anything anywhere
•  Digital devices are essential part of any
shopping journey
•  94% of global internet users go online to
research purchases in at least one category
15
UBIQUITY OF
MOBILE DEVICES
16
WEBROOMING
BEATS
SHOWROOMING
•  Webrooming, or researching online and then buying
in a store, has become the norm and more common
than showrooming
•  69% to 46% respectively according to Harris Poll
•  Amazon remains top destination for both showrooming
and webrooming
Millennials
Prefer
Webrooming
17
WEBROOMING
BEATS
SHOWROOMING
Why Shoppers webroom?
•  Don’t want to pay for shipping
•  Don’t want to wait for delivery
•  Like to touch and feel a product before they buy
•  Like to ask store to match better prices found online
•  Like the option to return to store if needed
18
BRICK-AND-MORTAR
INVESTING IN
TECHNOLOGY
•  B&M retailers using tech for
–  Delivery & pickup
–  Personalization
–  Inventory tracking
–  Beacons
–  Wearable tech
•  More than 40% used a smartphone or tablet
for Black Friday activities (NRF)
19
RETAILER TECH
SPENDING
•  Capex of selected retailers was approximately
3.3% of sales in 2014, flat with 2013
•  Technology capex:
–  CVSHealth: 37% of 2014 capex on technology and
other corporate initiatives
–  Nordstrom: 35% of 2014 capex; plans to spend $4.3B
(5% of sales) over next five years
–  Walmart: 29% of 2014 US capex; spending “$1.2-1.5
billion in e-commerce Web sites and mobile commerce
applications”
–  Home Depot: “Tilting investments towards
interconnected retail and technology”
0%	
  
1%	
  
2%	
  
3%	
  
4%	
  
5%	
  
6%	
  
7%	
  
Nordstrom	
  
Macy's	
  
Kohl's	
  
TJX	
  
Walmart	
  
Target	
  
JCPenney	
  
Home	
  Depot	
  
CVS	
  
Sears	
  
Capex/Sales	
   Average	
  
2014 Capex/Sales for Selected Retailers
Average = 3.3%
20
GAMIFICATION
STIMULATES
NEW CUSTOMER
BEHAVIORS
•  Gamification is the use of elements from
computer and video games in real-world or
other activities
•  These elements stimulate our psychological
needs for desire, incentive, challenge,
achievement and rewards, feedback, and mastery
21
SOCIAL MEDIA AS
NEW MARKETING
PLATFORM
•  Internet now ruled by pictures and videos
•  Consistent but slowing growth in social media usage
expected worldwide over the next 5 years
•  Most of the growth in Asia
•  Growth in the number of users is decelerating
•  Many social media experiences now on a mobile phone
22
MOBILE APPS BURY
THE BROWSER IN
SHOPPING
The browser is dead …
BROWSER	
  
	
  
	
  
	
  
1999-­‐2014	
  
… long live app nation!
Source:	
  Flurry	
  AnalyDcs	
  
88% 82%
12% 18%
Smartphone Tablet
Mobile App vs. Browser Split
App Browser
23
FUTURE TRENDS
24
DIGITAL
ADVERTISING
TO DOMINATE
•  Digital receiving new money because
marketers can prove that digital works
(Forrester)
Sources:	
  	
  Forrester,	
  PWC,	
  and	
  eMarketer.com	
  
40	
  
60	
  
80	
  
100	
  
120	
  
2012	
   2013	
   2014	
   2015	
   2016	
   2017	
   2018	
   2019	
  
Radio	
   Digital	
   TV	
  
25
CLICK & COLLECT
IS COMING
•  Digital receiving new money because
marketers can prove that digital works
(Forrester)
5	
  
13	
  
35	
  
0	
   5	
   10	
   15	
   20	
   25	
   30	
   35	
  
Germany	
  
US	
  
UK	
  
%	
  of	
  shoppers	
  saying	
  they	
  "currently	
  use	
  click	
  &	
  collect"	
  
Source:	
  Planet	
  Retail,	
  2014	
  
Survey	
  Base:	
  15,000	
  respondents	
  across	
  10	
  countries	
  
26
THE LINE WITH
CLICK & COLLECT
IS BLURRING
•  More than two-thirds of UK shoppers used click &
collect services in 2014
•  76% of UK shoppers will click & collect by 2017
•  Amazon launched its lockers in Sept. 2011
•  Only 17% of US consumers used click & collect
in 2013
•  Walmart started testing a drive-through grocery
pick-up service in Oct. 2014
Walmart	
  	
  
Drive-­‐Through	
  
27
Brick-and-Mortar vs. Click & Collect
A shopping facility where consumers can
buy or order goods from the store’s website
and then collect them from a store location
convenient to them
Brick-and-mortar refers to
businesses that have physical
stores that offer face-o-face
customer experiences.
Consumer can visit and enter
physically to see touch and
purchase merchandise
28
E-COMMERCE
OPENING
BRICK-AND-
MORTAR STORES
•  Excluding Amazon, most online pure-plays hit a $1
billion revenue ceiling
•  Establishing a brick-and-mortar presence aids in
brand building and growing consumer awareness
•  Easier to get VC funding with technology connection
in the apparel/retail business model
•  eBay UK offers collection through Argos general
merchandise stores
•  ASOS offers collection through Collect+, a network
of 5,800 local shops such as newsagents and
convenience stores serving as collection points
•  Amazon signed up to Doddle, a new network of
collection-only stores concentrated on railway
stations
•  More in 2015
29
SUBSCRIPTIONS
NIBBLING AWAY AT
BRICK-AND-MORTAR
•  Consumers love the convenience and
dependability of the services
•  Retailers love subscription models as a source of
recurring revenue
•  Consumers find value in avoiding the drudgery of
shopping for everyday commodity items
•  They appreciate the benefits of curation
•  Many consumers use subscriptions to treat
themselves to a monthly gift
30
SUBSCRIPTIONS
NIBBLING AWAY AT
BRICK-AND-MORTAR
31
ONLINE GROCERY IS A
NEW GROWTH AREA
•  Global Grocery Market: $4 Trillion
•  U.S. Grocery Market: $600B
•  Percent Online: 1.2%
•  Approx. 12% of Internet users have bought
grocery items online
32
TAP & PAY
POISED FOR
HUGE GROWTH
$3,737
$6,815
$10,451
$16,240
$23,472
$34,160
2014	
   2015	
   2016	
   2017	
   2018	
   2019	
  
CAGR	
  =	
  50%	
  
US	
  Contactless	
  Mobile	
  Payment	
  Market	
  
($	
  Millions)	
  
%	
  	
  of	
  
All	
  Mobile	
  
Payments	
  
7%	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  10%	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  13%	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  16%	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  20%	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  24%	
  
Source: Forrester Research, October 2014
33
Beacons and
Location-Based
Marketing
•  What is a beacon?
•  The best solution for
improving the in-store
retail experience
•  2016 is expected to be the year of the Beacon
•  US installed base expands rapidly, but consumer
response is key to further penetration
$41.0
$444.0
2015 2016
Beacon-Influenced In-Store Retail Sales ($ Billion)
Source: Bi Intelligence, Feb. 9, 2015
34
MICRO-LOCATIONS
IMPROVE IN-STORE
EXPERIENCE
They know where you are!
35
UBERFICATION
ENBODYS THE
SHARING
ECONOMY
MODEL
•  Uber is the most visible player (and driver) of
the “sharing economy”
•  Changing consumer mindsets will challenge
retailers
•  Opportunities for retailers: How much is
convenience worth?
36
CYBERSECURITY
DEMANDS
SMARTER
INVESTMENT
•  Important decisions will have to be made
regarding how to address privacy and
security
•  Retailers need to spend smarter, not
necessarily more on cybersecurity
•  Holistic, enterprise-wide cyber-risk detection
and prevention are critical first steps
37
THANK YOU

Chicago Retail Analytics Summit, May 1st, 2015

  • 1.
    1 CUSTOMER ENGAGEMENT AN OMNICHANNEL PERSPECTIVE DeborahWeinswig Executive Director – Head Global Retail & Technology Fung Business Intelligence Center Global
  • 2.
    2 DEBORAH WEINSWIG •  Executive Directorand Head of Global Retail & Technology for the Fung Business Intelligence Centre •  Award-winning global retail analyst and a specialist in retail innovation and technology •  12 Years at Citi Research where she served as Head of the Global Staples & Consumer Discretionary Team •  #1 ranking analyst by Institutional Investor for nine years •  Mentor to Silicon Valley accelerators including Alchemist Accelerator and Plug & Play •  Certified Public Accountant, with a Masters of Business Administration degree from the University of Chicago
  • 3.
    3 FUNG BUSINESS INTELLIGENCE CENTRE (FBIC) •  Establishedin 2000 and headquartered in Hong Kong •  FBIC (formerly known as the Li & Fung Research Centre) has served as the knowledge bank and think tank for the Fung Group •  New York–based Global Retail & Technology research team follows broader retail and technology trends
  • 4.
    4 AGENDA •  OmnichannelTrends •  Current Trends •  Future Trends
  • 5.
  • 6.
    6 THE STATE OF SHOPPING • Internet shopping is about functionality, not fun •  As more shoppers move online, in-store shopping will increasingly focus on leisure shopping and the quality of experience •  Online/offline division is becoming artificial as consumers browse, compare and buy across channels •  More complex than simply “showrooming” •  Click & collect provides the functional transaction coupled with in-store experience •  Stores must be set up to deliver a quality experience
  • 7.
    7 OPPORTUNITY COST OF NON-OMNICHANNEL 10% Lost revenue = $110+mn in lost revenue lost for 1 billion retailer Source:  RIS-­‐EKN  Customer  Engagement  Study,  2014,  EKN-­‐Toshiba  Omni-­‐Channel  ExecuDon  Study  
  • 8.
    8 EVOLUTION OF CORE OMNICHANNEL EXECUTION Source:  RIS-­‐EKN  Customer  Engagement  Survey,  2014  (100+  retail  execuDves  surveyed  in  the  US)   Figures  are  %  of  total  respondents  
  • 9.
    9 OMNICHANNEL CUSTOMERS: MORE PROFITABLE BUT UNKNOWN 76% Don’tknow how who their Omni channel customers are Source:  RIS-­‐EKN  Customer  Engagement  Study,  2014,  
  • 10.
    10 RETAILERS STILL USING OLDKEY PERFORMANCE INDICATORS Top KPI’s that retailers measure Sales/ channel 82% Customer satisfaction Average margin 57% 45% Customer Lifetime Value 22% Share of wallet Customer engagement across channels 8% Source: RIS-EKN Customer Engagement Study, 2014 KPI’s that they need to pay more attention to
  • 11.
    11 B&M STORE: THE OMNICHANNEL HU B 1 in 2 have deployed digital coupon reading in-store 66% of retailers have currently deployed store specific social media initiatives 46% have store specific websites 75% will use their store as a delivery hub for online orders by 2015 Sources:  RIS-­‐EKN  Customer  Engagement  Study,  2014;  EKN  Future  of  Store  Study,  2013  
  • 12.
    12 AMAZON: GOLD STANDARD OF EXECUTION MobileCommerce and Engagement 1 Amazon (56%) 2 Starbucks (9%) 3 Apple (7%) Unified Commerce 1 Amazon (28%) 2 Macy’s (9%) 3 Nordstrom/Wal- Mart/Best Buy (7%) Customer Engagement 1 Amazon (33%) 2 Nordstrom (8%) 3 Best Buy/ Starbucks (5%) Source:  RIS-­‐EKN  Customer  Engagement  Study,  2014  
  • 13.
  • 14.
    14 UBIQUITY OF MOBILE DEVICES • Constant connectivity enables shoppers to find product details, compare prices and buy anything anywhere •  Digital devices are essential part of any shopping journey •  94% of global internet users go online to research purchases in at least one category
  • 15.
  • 16.
    16 WEBROOMING BEATS SHOWROOMING •  Webrooming, orresearching online and then buying in a store, has become the norm and more common than showrooming •  69% to 46% respectively according to Harris Poll •  Amazon remains top destination for both showrooming and webrooming Millennials Prefer Webrooming
  • 17.
    17 WEBROOMING BEATS SHOWROOMING Why Shoppers webroom? • Don’t want to pay for shipping •  Don’t want to wait for delivery •  Like to touch and feel a product before they buy •  Like to ask store to match better prices found online •  Like the option to return to store if needed
  • 18.
    18 BRICK-AND-MORTAR INVESTING IN TECHNOLOGY •  B&Mretailers using tech for –  Delivery & pickup –  Personalization –  Inventory tracking –  Beacons –  Wearable tech •  More than 40% used a smartphone or tablet for Black Friday activities (NRF)
  • 19.
    19 RETAILER TECH SPENDING •  Capexof selected retailers was approximately 3.3% of sales in 2014, flat with 2013 •  Technology capex: –  CVSHealth: 37% of 2014 capex on technology and other corporate initiatives –  Nordstrom: 35% of 2014 capex; plans to spend $4.3B (5% of sales) over next five years –  Walmart: 29% of 2014 US capex; spending “$1.2-1.5 billion in e-commerce Web sites and mobile commerce applications” –  Home Depot: “Tilting investments towards interconnected retail and technology” 0%   1%   2%   3%   4%   5%   6%   7%   Nordstrom   Macy's   Kohl's   TJX   Walmart   Target   JCPenney   Home  Depot   CVS   Sears   Capex/Sales   Average   2014 Capex/Sales for Selected Retailers Average = 3.3%
  • 20.
    20 GAMIFICATION STIMULATES NEW CUSTOMER BEHAVIORS •  Gamificationis the use of elements from computer and video games in real-world or other activities •  These elements stimulate our psychological needs for desire, incentive, challenge, achievement and rewards, feedback, and mastery
  • 21.
    21 SOCIAL MEDIA AS NEWMARKETING PLATFORM •  Internet now ruled by pictures and videos •  Consistent but slowing growth in social media usage expected worldwide over the next 5 years •  Most of the growth in Asia •  Growth in the number of users is decelerating •  Many social media experiences now on a mobile phone
  • 22.
    22 MOBILE APPS BURY THEBROWSER IN SHOPPING The browser is dead … BROWSER         1999-­‐2014   … long live app nation! Source:  Flurry  AnalyDcs   88% 82% 12% 18% Smartphone Tablet Mobile App vs. Browser Split App Browser
  • 23.
  • 24.
    24 DIGITAL ADVERTISING TO DOMINATE •  Digitalreceiving new money because marketers can prove that digital works (Forrester) Sources:    Forrester,  PWC,  and  eMarketer.com   40   60   80   100   120   2012   2013   2014   2015   2016   2017   2018   2019   Radio   Digital   TV  
  • 25.
    25 CLICK & COLLECT ISCOMING •  Digital receiving new money because marketers can prove that digital works (Forrester) 5   13   35   0   5   10   15   20   25   30   35   Germany   US   UK   %  of  shoppers  saying  they  "currently  use  click  &  collect"   Source:  Planet  Retail,  2014   Survey  Base:  15,000  respondents  across  10  countries  
  • 26.
    26 THE LINE WITH CLICK& COLLECT IS BLURRING •  More than two-thirds of UK shoppers used click & collect services in 2014 •  76% of UK shoppers will click & collect by 2017 •  Amazon launched its lockers in Sept. 2011 •  Only 17% of US consumers used click & collect in 2013 •  Walmart started testing a drive-through grocery pick-up service in Oct. 2014 Walmart     Drive-­‐Through  
  • 27.
    27 Brick-and-Mortar vs. Click& Collect A shopping facility where consumers can buy or order goods from the store’s website and then collect them from a store location convenient to them Brick-and-mortar refers to businesses that have physical stores that offer face-o-face customer experiences. Consumer can visit and enter physically to see touch and purchase merchandise
  • 28.
    28 E-COMMERCE OPENING BRICK-AND- MORTAR STORES •  ExcludingAmazon, most online pure-plays hit a $1 billion revenue ceiling •  Establishing a brick-and-mortar presence aids in brand building and growing consumer awareness •  Easier to get VC funding with technology connection in the apparel/retail business model •  eBay UK offers collection through Argos general merchandise stores •  ASOS offers collection through Collect+, a network of 5,800 local shops such as newsagents and convenience stores serving as collection points •  Amazon signed up to Doddle, a new network of collection-only stores concentrated on railway stations •  More in 2015
  • 29.
    29 SUBSCRIPTIONS NIBBLING AWAY AT BRICK-AND-MORTAR • Consumers love the convenience and dependability of the services •  Retailers love subscription models as a source of recurring revenue •  Consumers find value in avoiding the drudgery of shopping for everyday commodity items •  They appreciate the benefits of curation •  Many consumers use subscriptions to treat themselves to a monthly gift
  • 30.
  • 31.
    31 ONLINE GROCERY ISA NEW GROWTH AREA •  Global Grocery Market: $4 Trillion •  U.S. Grocery Market: $600B •  Percent Online: 1.2% •  Approx. 12% of Internet users have bought grocery items online
  • 32.
    32 TAP & PAY POISEDFOR HUGE GROWTH $3,737 $6,815 $10,451 $16,240 $23,472 $34,160 2014   2015   2016   2017   2018   2019   CAGR  =  50%   US  Contactless  Mobile  Payment  Market   ($  Millions)   %    of   All  Mobile   Payments   7%                      10%                      13%                      16%                  20%                    24%   Source: Forrester Research, October 2014
  • 33.
    33 Beacons and Location-Based Marketing •  Whatis a beacon? •  The best solution for improving the in-store retail experience •  2016 is expected to be the year of the Beacon •  US installed base expands rapidly, but consumer response is key to further penetration $41.0 $444.0 2015 2016 Beacon-Influenced In-Store Retail Sales ($ Billion) Source: Bi Intelligence, Feb. 9, 2015
  • 34.
  • 35.
    35 UBERFICATION ENBODYS THE SHARING ECONOMY MODEL •  Uberis the most visible player (and driver) of the “sharing economy” •  Changing consumer mindsets will challenge retailers •  Opportunities for retailers: How much is convenience worth?
  • 36.
    36 CYBERSECURITY DEMANDS SMARTER INVESTMENT •  Important decisionswill have to be made regarding how to address privacy and security •  Retailers need to spend smarter, not necessarily more on cybersecurity •  Holistic, enterprise-wide cyber-risk detection and prevention are critical first steps
  • 37.