This case report describes a 50-year-old Hispanic female admitted to the hospital for agitation and passive suicidal ideation. She has a history of brain meningioma in 2001, Capgras syndrome diagnosis in 2009, and multiple psychiatric hospitalizations. Her symptoms have worsened with non-compliance to treatment. Her examination shows intact cognition but poor insight. She is diagnosed with medical/surgical induced psychotic disorder and has significant psychosocial stressors. The treatment plan is to restart olanzapine and engage in various therapies with a guarded prognosis due to her history of non-compliance.