HAWTHORNE EXPERIMENT
GROUP MEMBERS
O VIKAS AGRAHARI 03
O VENKATESH
O KEVAL PATEL 38
O TEJAL RANE 43
O AKASH SALVE 48
O MOHAMMED PARVEZ SHAH 53
O SHIJI THOMAS 56
O VISHAL WAVHAL 66
INTRODUCTION
O DISCOVERED BY “GEORGE ELTON MAYO”
(1880-1949)
O KNOWN AS MANAGEMENT GURU
O FOUNDER OF HUMAN RELATIONS
MOVEMENT
O AUTHOR OF BOOK “HUMAN
PROBLEMS OF AN
INDUSTRIAL CIVILIZATION”
PHASES OF HAWTHRONE EXPERIMENT
O IILUMINATION EXPERIMENTS (1924-27)
• DESIGN TO TEST THE EFFECT OF LIGHTNING ON
WORKERS PRODUCTIVITY
• INFLUENCE OF HUMAN RELATIONS ON WORK
BEHAVIOUR
O CONCLUSION
• LIGHT INTENSITY HAS NO CONCLUSIVE EFFECT
ON OUTPUT
• PRODUCTIVITY HAS A PSYCHOLOGICAL COMPONENT
• CONCEPT OF “HAWTHORNE EFFECT” WAS CREATED
O RELAY ASSEMBLY TEST ROOM EXPERIMENTS (1927-
28)
• DETERMINE THE EFFECT OF CHANGES IN
VARIOUS JOB CONDITIONS ON GROUP
ACTIVITY
O CONCLUSION
• WORKERS OUTPUT INCREASED AS A RESPONSE TO ATTENTION,
NON-DIRECTIVE SUPERVISION etc..
• STRONG SOCIAL BONDS WERE CREATED WITHIN THE TEST
GROUP.
O MASS INTERVIEWING PROGRAMME
(1928-30)
• CONDUCTED 2100 INTERVIEWS
• TO EXPLORE INFORMATION , USED TO IMPROVE SUPERVISORY
TRAINING
• METHOD OF DIRECT QUESTIONING CHANGED TO NON DIRECTIVE
O CONCLUSION
• INCREASE THE MORALE
• DEEP ROOTED DISTURBANCES
BANK WIRING ROOM
EXPERIMENTS
O AFFECT OF PAYMENT INCENTIVE ON PRODUCTIVITY
O EMPLOYEES
• TOTAL = 14 WORKERS
• 9 WIREMEN
• 3 SOLDERMEN
• 2 INSPECTOR
O FEW SPECIAL CONDITIONS
• SEGREGATED WORK AREA
• NO MANAGEMENT VISITS
• SUPERVISION REMAINS THE SAME
• OBSERVER WOULD RECORD DATA – NO INTERACTION
WITH WORKERS
RESULTS
O OUTPUT WAS LOWER THAN WHAT COMPANY HAS DETERMINED
REASONS:
• FEAR OF UNEMPLOYMENT
• FEAR OF RAISING THE STANDARDS
• PROTECTION OF SLOWER WORKERS
• SATISFACTION ON THE PART OF MANAGEMENT
• CONCLUSION:
O WELL ESTABLISHED PERFOMANCE NORMS EXISTED IN THE GROUP
O INFORMAL SOCIAL ORGANISATION DICTATED LITTLE DEVIATION
FROM THE ESTABLISHED PRODUCTION STANDARDS
O INFORMAL SOCIAL PROTECT WORKERS FROM MANAGERS WHO
• RAISE PRODUCTIN STANDARDS
• CUT PAY RATES
• CHALLENGE WORKPLACE NORMS
CRITICISM
O IT LACKS VALIDITY
O MORE IMPORTANCE TO HUMAN ASPECTS
O MORE EMPHASIS ON GROUP DECISION MAKING
O THE EXPERIMENT LACKED SCIENTIFIC BASIS
O HAWTHRONE PLANT WAS A THOROUGHLY UNPLEASANT
PLACE TO WORK
CONCLUSION
O SOCIAL UNIT
O GROUP INFLUENCE
O GROUP BEHAVIOUR
O MOTIVATION
O SUPERVISION
O WORKING CONDITIONS
O EMPLOYEE MORALE
O COMMUNICATION
O BALANCED APPROACH
Bank wiring observation room experiment

Bank wiring observation room experiment

  • 1.
  • 2.
    GROUP MEMBERS O VIKASAGRAHARI 03 O VENKATESH O KEVAL PATEL 38 O TEJAL RANE 43 O AKASH SALVE 48 O MOHAMMED PARVEZ SHAH 53 O SHIJI THOMAS 56 O VISHAL WAVHAL 66
  • 3.
    INTRODUCTION O DISCOVERED BY“GEORGE ELTON MAYO” (1880-1949) O KNOWN AS MANAGEMENT GURU O FOUNDER OF HUMAN RELATIONS MOVEMENT O AUTHOR OF BOOK “HUMAN PROBLEMS OF AN INDUSTRIAL CIVILIZATION”
  • 4.
    PHASES OF HAWTHRONEEXPERIMENT O IILUMINATION EXPERIMENTS (1924-27) • DESIGN TO TEST THE EFFECT OF LIGHTNING ON WORKERS PRODUCTIVITY • INFLUENCE OF HUMAN RELATIONS ON WORK BEHAVIOUR O CONCLUSION • LIGHT INTENSITY HAS NO CONCLUSIVE EFFECT ON OUTPUT • PRODUCTIVITY HAS A PSYCHOLOGICAL COMPONENT • CONCEPT OF “HAWTHORNE EFFECT” WAS CREATED
  • 5.
    O RELAY ASSEMBLYTEST ROOM EXPERIMENTS (1927- 28) • DETERMINE THE EFFECT OF CHANGES IN VARIOUS JOB CONDITIONS ON GROUP ACTIVITY O CONCLUSION • WORKERS OUTPUT INCREASED AS A RESPONSE TO ATTENTION, NON-DIRECTIVE SUPERVISION etc.. • STRONG SOCIAL BONDS WERE CREATED WITHIN THE TEST GROUP.
  • 6.
    O MASS INTERVIEWINGPROGRAMME (1928-30) • CONDUCTED 2100 INTERVIEWS • TO EXPLORE INFORMATION , USED TO IMPROVE SUPERVISORY TRAINING • METHOD OF DIRECT QUESTIONING CHANGED TO NON DIRECTIVE O CONCLUSION • INCREASE THE MORALE • DEEP ROOTED DISTURBANCES
  • 7.
    BANK WIRING ROOM EXPERIMENTS OAFFECT OF PAYMENT INCENTIVE ON PRODUCTIVITY O EMPLOYEES • TOTAL = 14 WORKERS • 9 WIREMEN • 3 SOLDERMEN • 2 INSPECTOR O FEW SPECIAL CONDITIONS • SEGREGATED WORK AREA • NO MANAGEMENT VISITS • SUPERVISION REMAINS THE SAME • OBSERVER WOULD RECORD DATA – NO INTERACTION WITH WORKERS
  • 8.
    RESULTS O OUTPUT WASLOWER THAN WHAT COMPANY HAS DETERMINED REASONS: • FEAR OF UNEMPLOYMENT • FEAR OF RAISING THE STANDARDS • PROTECTION OF SLOWER WORKERS • SATISFACTION ON THE PART OF MANAGEMENT • CONCLUSION: O WELL ESTABLISHED PERFOMANCE NORMS EXISTED IN THE GROUP O INFORMAL SOCIAL ORGANISATION DICTATED LITTLE DEVIATION FROM THE ESTABLISHED PRODUCTION STANDARDS O INFORMAL SOCIAL PROTECT WORKERS FROM MANAGERS WHO • RAISE PRODUCTIN STANDARDS • CUT PAY RATES • CHALLENGE WORKPLACE NORMS
  • 9.
    CRITICISM O IT LACKSVALIDITY O MORE IMPORTANCE TO HUMAN ASPECTS O MORE EMPHASIS ON GROUP DECISION MAKING O THE EXPERIMENT LACKED SCIENTIFIC BASIS O HAWTHRONE PLANT WAS A THOROUGHLY UNPLEASANT PLACE TO WORK
  • 10.
    CONCLUSION O SOCIAL UNIT OGROUP INFLUENCE O GROUP BEHAVIOUR O MOTIVATION O SUPERVISION O WORKING CONDITIONS O EMPLOYEE MORALE O COMMUNICATION O BALANCED APPROACH