Conservatism Dr. Christopher S. Rice
What  IS  a conservative?
 
 
 
 
All conservatives want to conserve/preserve  something (hence the name) (duh)
Two ways of considering conservatism as an ideology
Conservatism as  resisting change
 
Conservatism as a distinctive political position
Classical Conservatives vs. Individualist Conservatives
Divisions run deep…
How Conservatism differs  from other ideologies Rather than being defined in terms of abstract principles of justice, conservatism is commonly defined in relation to changing historical contexts. Conservatism can be considered more of a disposition or temperament, rather than a strict belief system. Conservatism as a belief system (if it is a belief system at all) is marked by many internal tensions. Conservatives, because of their lack of agreement over philosophical principles, tend to unite around specific  issues . Conservatives, according to Charles Kessler, often find it easier to say what they are against than what they are for. Specifically, they often tend to oppose aspects of liberal capitalism.
How Conservatism differs  from other ideologies Rather than being defined in terms of abstract principles of justice, conservatism is commonly defined in relation to changing historical contexts. Conservatism can be considered more of a disposition or temperament, rather than a strict belief system. Conservatism as a belief system (if it is a belief system at all) is marked by many internal tensions. Conservatives, because of their lack of agreement over philosophical principles, tend to unite around specific  issues . Conservatives, according to Charles Kessler, often find it easier to say what they are against than what they are for. Specifically, they often tend to oppose aspects of liberal capitalism.
“ To be conservative…is to prefer the familiar to the unknown, to prefer the tried to the untried, fact to mystery, the actual to the possible, the limited to the unbounded, the near to the distant, the sufficient to the superabundant, the convenient to the perfect, present laughter to utopian bliss.” Michael Oakeshott, “On Being Conservative
It is easier to say  who  is a conservative rather than what conservatism  is .
How Conservatism differs  from other ideologies Rather than being defined in terms of abstract principles of justice, conservatism is commonly defined in relation to changing historical contexts. Conservatism can be considered more of a disposition or temperament, rather than a strict belief system. Conservatism as a belief system (if it is a belief system at all) is marked by many internal tensions. Conservatives, because of their lack of agreement over philosophical principles, tend to unite around specific  issues . Conservatives, according to Charles Kessler, often find it easier to say what they are against than what they are for. Specifically, they often tend to oppose aspects of liberal capitalism.
How Conservatism differs  from other ideologies Rather than being defined in terms of abstract principles of justice, conservatism is commonly defined in relation to changing historical contexts. Conservatism can be considered more of a disposition or temperament, rather than a strict belief system. Conservatism as a belief system (if it is a belief system at all) is marked by many internal tensions. Conservatives, because of their lack of agreement over philosophical principles, tend to unite around specific  issues . Conservatives, according to Charles Kessler, often find it easier to say what they are against than what they are for. Specifically, they often tend to oppose aspects of liberal capitalism.
How Conservatism differs  from other ideologies Rather than being defined in terms of abstract principles of justice, conservatism is commonly defined in relation to changing historical contexts. Conservatism can be considered more of a disposition or temperament, rather than a strict belief system. Conservatism as a belief system (if it is a belief system at all) is marked by many internal tensions. Conservatives, because of their lack of agreement over philosophical principles, tend to unite around specific  issues . Conservatives, according to Charles Kessler, often find it easier to say what they are against than what they are for. Specifically, they often tend to oppose aspects of liberal capitalism.
Is conservatism an ideology?
 
The public interest “is what men would choose if they saw clearly, thought rationally, acted disinterestedly and benevolently.” William F. Buckley
Are Buckley and other conservatives making  Marx’s mistake?
Classical (Burkean) Conservatism
 
A reaction to the French Revolution
A few basic points… Accepted some increase in democratization, but retained a belief in the importance of strong authorities. Accepted some aspects of capitalism, but feared that the economic liberties of individuals posed moral dangers to the good of society. Wanted to protect the world from the onslaught of rapid social, economic and technological changes.
A few basic points… Accepted some increase in democratization, but retained a belief in the importance of strong authorities. Accepted some aspects of capitalism, but feared that the economic liberties of individuals posed moral dangers to the good of society. Wanted to protect the world from the onslaught of rapid social, economic and technological changes.
A few basic points… Accepted some increase in democratization, but retained a belief in the importance of strong authorities. Accepted some aspects of capitalism, but feared that the economic liberties of individuals posed moral dangers to the good of society. Wanted to protect the world from the onslaught of rapid social, economic and technological changes.
IMPOSSIBLE!
slow the modernization of society  as much as possible
The Problem of Abstract Rights
the historical development of rights
PROBLEM: Abstract demands for rights can lead to redistribution of land and money .
Conservatives Say: Politics based on abstract rights promotes individualism at the expense of historical understanding, mitigating institutions and the bonds that hold society together
protection of private property provides social stability
Noblesse Oblige
Undesirable Results of Capitalism
What to do?
Human Nature
human beings are, and always will be,  flawed
Original Sin
Rationality?
Law of Unintended Consequences
Weak Rationality
Atomistic Individualism Vs. Organic/ Interconnected Individualism
Social Fabric
Liberty worthwhile ONLY when  properly ordered
Government not perceived as an obstacle
Classical Conservative Model of Freedom (Ball and Dagger,  Political Ideologies and the Democratic Ideal ) OBSTACLE: Radical ideas, innovation; passions, desires, lack of restraint AGENT: Inter-connected, “organic” individuals GOAL: Order, stability, harmony, continuity
Conservatives & Change
Reckless & Rapid Change
Ideological Change Change based on preconceived ideological notions which give no concession to the inherent limits of the human condition.
The Problem of Innovation
An “Anti-Ideology”?
Reform change that is slow, thoughtfully considered and based on the past
Conservatism and Democracy
The Natural Aristocracy
Concentration of Power
“ Little Platoons”
Conservatism as an Ideology
Explanation
Evaluation
Orientation
Political Program
21 st  Century  Conservatism: 4 Strands
Traditional Conservatism
Individualist Conservatism
 
The New Christian Right
 
 
Neoconservatism
 
Irving Kristol on Neoconservatism Support for welfare state, opposition to bureaucratic paternalism & intrusion Respect for the free market Support for traditional values and religion (vs. “counterculture”) Opposition to “egalitarianism” Strong anti-communist foreign policy
Irving Kristol on Neoconservatism Support for welfare state, opposition to bureaucratic paternalism & intrusion Respect for the free market Support for traditional values and religion (vs. “counterculture”) Opposition to “egalitarianism” Strong anti-communist foreign policy
Irving Kristol on Neoconservatism Support for welfare state, opposition to bureaucratic paternalism & intrusion Respect for the free market Support for traditional values and religion (vs. “counterculture”) Opposition to “egalitarianism” Strong anti-communist foreign policy
Irving Kristol on Neoconservatism Support for welfare state, opposition to bureaucratic paternalism & intrusion Respect for the free market Support for traditional values and religion (vs. “counterculture”) Opposition to “egalitarianism” Strong anti-communist foreign policy
Irving Kristol on Neoconservatism Support for welfare state, opposition to bureaucratic paternalism & intrusion Respect for the free market Support for traditional values and religion (vs. “counterculture”) Opposition to “egalitarianism” Strong anti-communist foreign policy
Contemporary Conservatism
4 Main Problems: Failure of Western foreign policy to promote the interests of the “free world.” Promotion of socialist domestic problems by increasingly strong central governments. Prominence/power of radicals, social engineers, socialist utopians in educational institutions. Culture of permissiveness, relativism
4 Main Problems: Failure of Western foreign policy to promote the interests of the “free world.” Promotion of socialist domestic problems by increasingly strong central governments. Prominence/power of radicals, social engineers, socialist utopians in educational institutions. Culture of permissiveness, relativism
4 Main Problems: Failure of Western foreign policy to promote the interests of the “free world.” Promotion of socialist domestic problems by increasingly strong central governments. Prominence/power of radicals, social engineers, socialist utopians in educational institutions. Culture of permissiveness, relativism
4 Main Problems: Failure of Western foreign policy to promote the interests of the “free world.” Promotion of socialist domestic problems by increasingly strong central governments. Prominence/power of radicals, social engineers, socialist utopians in educational institutions. Culture of permissiveness, relativism
 
 
Strong  Anti-Communism
Moral Hazards of Great Society
Problem of Big Government
Deregulation  +  financial incentives
Strengthen the Traditional Family
Boy, those universities sure are bad, huh?

Conservatism

  • 1.
  • 2.
    What IS a conservative?
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 7.
    All conservatives wantto conserve/preserve something (hence the name) (duh)
  • 8.
    Two ways ofconsidering conservatism as an ideology
  • 9.
    Conservatism as resisting change
  • 10.
  • 11.
    Conservatism as adistinctive political position
  • 12.
    Classical Conservatives vs.Individualist Conservatives
  • 13.
  • 14.
    How Conservatism differs from other ideologies Rather than being defined in terms of abstract principles of justice, conservatism is commonly defined in relation to changing historical contexts. Conservatism can be considered more of a disposition or temperament, rather than a strict belief system. Conservatism as a belief system (if it is a belief system at all) is marked by many internal tensions. Conservatives, because of their lack of agreement over philosophical principles, tend to unite around specific issues . Conservatives, according to Charles Kessler, often find it easier to say what they are against than what they are for. Specifically, they often tend to oppose aspects of liberal capitalism.
  • 15.
    How Conservatism differs from other ideologies Rather than being defined in terms of abstract principles of justice, conservatism is commonly defined in relation to changing historical contexts. Conservatism can be considered more of a disposition or temperament, rather than a strict belief system. Conservatism as a belief system (if it is a belief system at all) is marked by many internal tensions. Conservatives, because of their lack of agreement over philosophical principles, tend to unite around specific issues . Conservatives, according to Charles Kessler, often find it easier to say what they are against than what they are for. Specifically, they often tend to oppose aspects of liberal capitalism.
  • 16.
    “ To beconservative…is to prefer the familiar to the unknown, to prefer the tried to the untried, fact to mystery, the actual to the possible, the limited to the unbounded, the near to the distant, the sufficient to the superabundant, the convenient to the perfect, present laughter to utopian bliss.” Michael Oakeshott, “On Being Conservative
  • 17.
    It is easierto say who is a conservative rather than what conservatism is .
  • 18.
    How Conservatism differs from other ideologies Rather than being defined in terms of abstract principles of justice, conservatism is commonly defined in relation to changing historical contexts. Conservatism can be considered more of a disposition or temperament, rather than a strict belief system. Conservatism as a belief system (if it is a belief system at all) is marked by many internal tensions. Conservatives, because of their lack of agreement over philosophical principles, tend to unite around specific issues . Conservatives, according to Charles Kessler, often find it easier to say what they are against than what they are for. Specifically, they often tend to oppose aspects of liberal capitalism.
  • 19.
    How Conservatism differs from other ideologies Rather than being defined in terms of abstract principles of justice, conservatism is commonly defined in relation to changing historical contexts. Conservatism can be considered more of a disposition or temperament, rather than a strict belief system. Conservatism as a belief system (if it is a belief system at all) is marked by many internal tensions. Conservatives, because of their lack of agreement over philosophical principles, tend to unite around specific issues . Conservatives, according to Charles Kessler, often find it easier to say what they are against than what they are for. Specifically, they often tend to oppose aspects of liberal capitalism.
  • 20.
    How Conservatism differs from other ideologies Rather than being defined in terms of abstract principles of justice, conservatism is commonly defined in relation to changing historical contexts. Conservatism can be considered more of a disposition or temperament, rather than a strict belief system. Conservatism as a belief system (if it is a belief system at all) is marked by many internal tensions. Conservatives, because of their lack of agreement over philosophical principles, tend to unite around specific issues . Conservatives, according to Charles Kessler, often find it easier to say what they are against than what they are for. Specifically, they often tend to oppose aspects of liberal capitalism.
  • 21.
  • 22.
  • 23.
    The public interest“is what men would choose if they saw clearly, thought rationally, acted disinterestedly and benevolently.” William F. Buckley
  • 24.
    Are Buckley andother conservatives making Marx’s mistake?
  • 25.
  • 26.
  • 27.
    A reaction tothe French Revolution
  • 28.
    A few basicpoints… Accepted some increase in democratization, but retained a belief in the importance of strong authorities. Accepted some aspects of capitalism, but feared that the economic liberties of individuals posed moral dangers to the good of society. Wanted to protect the world from the onslaught of rapid social, economic and technological changes.
  • 29.
    A few basicpoints… Accepted some increase in democratization, but retained a belief in the importance of strong authorities. Accepted some aspects of capitalism, but feared that the economic liberties of individuals posed moral dangers to the good of society. Wanted to protect the world from the onslaught of rapid social, economic and technological changes.
  • 30.
    A few basicpoints… Accepted some increase in democratization, but retained a belief in the importance of strong authorities. Accepted some aspects of capitalism, but feared that the economic liberties of individuals posed moral dangers to the good of society. Wanted to protect the world from the onslaught of rapid social, economic and technological changes.
  • 31.
  • 32.
    slow the modernizationof society as much as possible
  • 33.
    The Problem ofAbstract Rights
  • 34.
  • 35.
    PROBLEM: Abstract demandsfor rights can lead to redistribution of land and money .
  • 36.
    Conservatives Say: Politicsbased on abstract rights promotes individualism at the expense of historical understanding, mitigating institutions and the bonds that hold society together
  • 37.
    protection of privateproperty provides social stability
  • 38.
  • 39.
  • 40.
  • 41.
  • 42.
    human beings are,and always will be, flawed
  • 43.
  • 44.
  • 45.
    Law of UnintendedConsequences
  • 46.
  • 47.
    Atomistic Individualism Vs.Organic/ Interconnected Individualism
  • 48.
  • 49.
    Liberty worthwhile ONLYwhen properly ordered
  • 50.
  • 51.
    Classical Conservative Modelof Freedom (Ball and Dagger, Political Ideologies and the Democratic Ideal ) OBSTACLE: Radical ideas, innovation; passions, desires, lack of restraint AGENT: Inter-connected, “organic” individuals GOAL: Order, stability, harmony, continuity
  • 52.
  • 53.
  • 54.
    Ideological Change Changebased on preconceived ideological notions which give no concession to the inherent limits of the human condition.
  • 55.
    The Problem ofInnovation
  • 56.
  • 57.
    Reform change thatis slow, thoughtfully considered and based on the past
  • 58.
  • 59.
  • 60.
  • 61.
  • 62.
  • 63.
  • 64.
  • 65.
  • 66.
  • 67.
    21 st Century Conservatism: 4 Strands
  • 68.
  • 69.
  • 70.
  • 71.
  • 72.
  • 73.
  • 74.
  • 75.
  • 76.
    Irving Kristol onNeoconservatism Support for welfare state, opposition to bureaucratic paternalism & intrusion Respect for the free market Support for traditional values and religion (vs. “counterculture”) Opposition to “egalitarianism” Strong anti-communist foreign policy
  • 77.
    Irving Kristol onNeoconservatism Support for welfare state, opposition to bureaucratic paternalism & intrusion Respect for the free market Support for traditional values and religion (vs. “counterculture”) Opposition to “egalitarianism” Strong anti-communist foreign policy
  • 78.
    Irving Kristol onNeoconservatism Support for welfare state, opposition to bureaucratic paternalism & intrusion Respect for the free market Support for traditional values and religion (vs. “counterculture”) Opposition to “egalitarianism” Strong anti-communist foreign policy
  • 79.
    Irving Kristol onNeoconservatism Support for welfare state, opposition to bureaucratic paternalism & intrusion Respect for the free market Support for traditional values and religion (vs. “counterculture”) Opposition to “egalitarianism” Strong anti-communist foreign policy
  • 80.
    Irving Kristol onNeoconservatism Support for welfare state, opposition to bureaucratic paternalism & intrusion Respect for the free market Support for traditional values and religion (vs. “counterculture”) Opposition to “egalitarianism” Strong anti-communist foreign policy
  • 81.
  • 82.
    4 Main Problems:Failure of Western foreign policy to promote the interests of the “free world.” Promotion of socialist domestic problems by increasingly strong central governments. Prominence/power of radicals, social engineers, socialist utopians in educational institutions. Culture of permissiveness, relativism
  • 83.
    4 Main Problems:Failure of Western foreign policy to promote the interests of the “free world.” Promotion of socialist domestic problems by increasingly strong central governments. Prominence/power of radicals, social engineers, socialist utopians in educational institutions. Culture of permissiveness, relativism
  • 84.
    4 Main Problems:Failure of Western foreign policy to promote the interests of the “free world.” Promotion of socialist domestic problems by increasingly strong central governments. Prominence/power of radicals, social engineers, socialist utopians in educational institutions. Culture of permissiveness, relativism
  • 85.
    4 Main Problems:Failure of Western foreign policy to promote the interests of the “free world.” Promotion of socialist domestic problems by increasingly strong central governments. Prominence/power of radicals, social engineers, socialist utopians in educational institutions. Culture of permissiveness, relativism
  • 86.
  • 87.
  • 88.
  • 89.
    Moral Hazards ofGreat Society
  • 90.
    Problem of BigGovernment
  • 91.
    Deregulation + financial incentives
  • 92.
  • 93.
    Boy, those universitiessure are bad, huh?