Liberalism
Dr. Christopher S. Rice
The American Political
Spectrum is small…
4
The Western
Transformation
1500-1700
(cc) 2005 Flickr user jurvetson
5
Organic vs. Mechanistic
(cc) 2008 Flickr user Peter from Wellington
6
Organic Worldview
(cc) 2008 Flickr user h.koppdelaney
7
First Nature
(cc) 2006 Flickr user Bruno Monginoux
8
Second Nature
(cc) 2007 Flickr user autan
The world is a living
world…
Ruach
Gaia
13
Unrestrained growth is
an aberration, undesired
(cc) 2006 Flickr user Euthman
14
Mechanistic
Worldview
(cc) 2008 Flickr user Ralph Bijker
15
The world is a
“dead” world…
(cc) 2006 Flickr user Caro Wallis
16
Lack of continuous
growth = death
(cc) 2006 Flickr user Wolfgang Kopp
Logical Positivism
Leads to the
Mechanistic Worldview
Cogito Ergo Sum
Mechanistic
Philosophy
Logical Positivism
Is science objective?
Economics?
The Liberal concept of agency is
based on the theory of
possessive individualism
Possessive Individualism
1. What makes one human is freedom from dependence on the wills of
others.
2. Freedom from dependence on others means freedom from any
relations with others except those relations which the individual
enters voluntarily with a view to his own interest.
3. The individual is essentially the proprietor of his or her own person
and capacities, for which he or she owes nothing to society.
4. Although an individual cannot alienate the whole of his property in
his own person, he may alienate his capacity to labor.
5. Human society consists of a series of market relations – Since the
individual is human only in so far as free, and free only in so far as
proprietor of him- or herself, human society can only be a series of
relations between sole proprietors, i.e., a series of market relations.
6. Since freedom from the wills of others is what makes one human,
each individual’s freedom can rightfully be limited only by such
obligations and rules as are necessary to secure the same freedom
for others.
7. Political society is a human contrivance for the protection of the
individual’s property in his person and goods, and (therefore) for the
maintenance of orderly relations of exchange between individuals
regarded as proprietors of themselves.
(C. B. Macpherson, The Political Theory of Possessive Individualism)
Liberal Philosophy
Four Elements of Liberal Philosophy
Equality Liberty
Individuality Rationality
Four Elements of Liberal Philosophy
Equality Liberty
Individuality Rationality
Equality of Opportunity
vs.
Equality of Outcome
Four Elements of Liberal Philosophy
Equality Liberty
Individuality Rationality
Four Elements of Liberal Philosophy
Equality Liberty
Individuality Rationality
Four Elements of Liberal Philosophy
Equality Liberty
Individuality Rationality
Four Elements of Liberal Philosophy
Equality Liberty
Individuality Rationality
Liberal Society
Feudalism Capitalism
Why a free-market
economy is important…
The Pursuit of The Good
Liberal Politics
strict distinction between the
state and civil society
ambivalence about the
benefits of democracy
Government is BAD!
Government is GREAT!
Utilitarianism
Jeremy Bentham
The Principle of
Utility Maximization
Utility
=
Total Happiness
–
Total Pain
49
50
Government should
ameliorate the effects
of utility maximization
(cc) 2008 Flickr user gruntzooki
general conclusions
about government
52
Government should
leave people
alone.
(cc) 2007 Flickr user afroboof
53
Increase democratic
participation
(cc) 2008 Flickr user Edward DC
John Stuart Mill
Defend and Extend
individual liberty
56
(cc) 2008 Flickr user jukebox 909
Harm Principle
Every sane adult should be
free to do whatever he or she
wants as long as his or her
actions do not harm, or
threaten to harm, others.
Natural Rights
Pragmatic Utility
Society, as a whole, will
benefit if people are
allowed to think and act
freely.
Representative democracy
only for the educated,
wealthy?
Neoclassical liberalism
VS.
Welfare Liberalism
Neoclassical liberalism
Social Darwinism
Charles Darwin
Herbert Spencer
William Graham Sumner
Welfare Liberalism
Government as a
POSITIVE
force
T.H. Green
Negative VS. Positive
Freedom
Socialism
VS.
Welfare Liberalism
Option #1:
Money can be divided up such that
20% of us will get 82.7% of the
income and property, 20% will get
11.7% of income and property, 20%
will get 2.3% of income, 20% will get
1.9%, and the last 20% will get
1.4%.
Option #2:
Divide it up such that everyone
gets an equal share of the
wealth and property, regardless
of job or status. (Each group will
get 20% of income, divided
equally).
John Rawls
77
The Veil of
Ignorance
(cc) 2008 Flickr user left-hand
78
The Original Position
(cc) 2008 Flickr user Tostie14
The Original Position
Non-presocial liberal ideas that, if
consensually held, would lead
everyone to accept the equal
liberty and difference principles as
the basis for mutually beneficial
social cooperation.
4 Ideas of
The Original Position
Equal Respect
Non-Risky
Rationality
Mutual
Disinterested-
ness
The Veil of
Ignorance
81
Equal Respect
Non-Risky
Rationality
Mutual
Disinterested-
ness
The Veil of
Ignorance
82
Equal Respect
Non-Risky
Rationality
Mutual
Disinterested-
ness
The Veil of
Ignorance
83
Equal Respect
Non-Risky
Rationality
Mutual
Disinterested-
ness
The Veil of
Ignorance
84
Equal Respect
Non-Risky
Rationality
Mutual
Disinterested-
ness
The Veil of
Ignorance
85
Equal Respect
Non-Risky
Rationality
Mutual
Disinterested-
ness
The Veil of
Ignorance
86
Principles of Justice
Equal Liberty Principle
The state must provide the most
extensive system of equal
liberties that is feasible and
desirable. All individuals must
enjoy the greatest degree of
liberty consistent with the
enjoyment of like liberty by
everyone else.
Difference Principle
Primary social goods are to be
distributed equally unless an
unequal distribution would
improve the welfare of the least
well-off in society.
Liberal Economics
Laissez-faire Capitalism
and Freedom
Adam Smith
David Ricardo
Milton Friedman
The problem of
market failures and
inefficiencies
John Maynard Keynes
The many benefits of capitalism
are offset by certain problems:
• Complete market freedom results in
various types of market failures.
• Monopolies which undermine
competition & lead to concentrated
power.
• Business cycles which create
economic inefficiency and insecurity.
The many benefits of capitalism
are offset by certain problems:
• Capitalism creates externalities
which harm the broader public.
• Pure Market Systems unable to
provide many public goods.
• Wealth isn’t distributed to everyone.
Methods of Stimulating the
Economy
Reduce taxes
Increase
government
expenditures
“Priming the Pump”
+
The “Multiplier Effect”
Three ways to deal with deficits:
• Grow your way out of it – as
incomes rise, taxes rise as people
move up through the tax brackets.
• Increase income taxes on the
wealthy, create luxury taxes, etc.
• Reduce government spending in
specific areas where it is no longer
needed.
PROBLEMS
History
106
HumanCondition
Time
Human Nature
108
The Social Contract
110
Thomas Hobbes
111
John Locke
Jean-Jacques Rousseau

PS 240 Liberalism Spring 2015