1. Module Title CPI 2020
Student Name Sebastian Gonzalez
Student Number b9010377
Mark Awarded 58
(Summary of literature search) Limited summary of literature search with substantial limitations
(Search strategy) Adequate search strategy but some elements were not fuly encompassed
(Results of search) Good list of results but there were a surprisingly low number of original research articles
(Best evidence - selection of sources)Adequate selection of source evidence
(Best evidence - justification of sources)The explanation of why evidence was selected was superficial and lacked defined
reasoning(Introduction - basic background) Adequate introduction but various elements that would be expected to be
included in a report like this were absent
(Intro - Pathogens and disease outcomes) Adequate description of the pathogens that cause this disease but limited
discussions on the effect on the host
(Intro - Risk factors and epidemiology) Adequate description of the epidemiology of infection but limited content on risk
factors associated with the disease
(Intro - Use of stats) Adequate use of validated statistics in your introduction
(Intro - Use of figures) No use of figures but this had no impact on the quality of the introduction
(VF - Range of mechanisms) Only a portion of the content related to virulence
(VF - Depth of content) Good details for some mechanisms but too few mechanisms were included
(VF - Clarity of figure) Good figure, easy to follow but may be too simplistic in some elements
(VF - Use of evidence) Very good integration of citations and source material
(HDM - Range of mechanisms) Good range of mechanisms included in your figure
(HDM - Depth of content) Good detail for multiple mechanisms included in your figure
(HDM - Clarity of figure) Good figure, easy to follow but may be too simplistic in some elements
(HDM - Use of evidence) Very good integration of citations and source material
(Treatment - standard therapy) Good description of the first line treatement protocols but limited description of other
standard therapies
(Treatment - resistance, treatment failure, new agents) Superficial content on novel drug discovery in this area and no
content at all on the treatment failure issues associated with the need for new chemotherapeutic agents
(Prevention - standard prevention techniques) Good description of the primary and predominant prevention method but
limited description of other approaches
(Prevention - novel strategies) No content on novel prevention techniques, either immunological, non-immunological or
both,
(Structure and presentation of the report) The report was generally well structured and presented but there were minor
issues in both areas
(Referencing and citation) Adequate reference list but the range of resources used was limited and various key texts were
not identified
