Compare and Contrast both Models

1. Compare and Contrast
ADDIE Model
to
Dick and Carey Model
Athena Russell
HRD-647-OL-2004: DIGITAL DESIGN FOR E-LEARNING

2. The ADDIE model is the generic process traditionally used by instructional
designers and training developers. The five phases—Analysis, Design,
Development, Implementation, and Evaluation—represent a dynamic,
flexible guideline for building effective training and performance support
tools.

3. The Dick and Carey Model is an instructional systems design (ISD) model
taking a systems approach and based on the research based of Walter Dick
of Florida State University and Lou and James Carey of the University of
South Florida.

4. Both use a systems approach (input, output and process
of designing the curriculum)
Step-by-step occurs linearly with easy distinction in
progression
Unique characteristics and elements that make up each
phase
Analysis Phase
Evaluation Phase
ADDIE MODEL - DICK & CAREY MODEL
COMPARISON

5. Number of steps in each model
ADDIE – 5 phases
Dick & Carey - 10 phases
Evaluation process of each method of design
ADDIE – last phase
Dick & Carey at every phase
ADDIE – More Linear
Dick & Carey – More Agile
ADDIE – Used in business and organizations
Dick & Carey – Used in curriculum development in school
ADDIE MODEL - DICK & CAREY MODEL
CONTRAST

6. ADVANTAGE
ADDIE
 Most widely used model and
is the foundation for other ID
models.
 Evaluation is a key
component built into ADDIE.
DICK & CAREY
 Designer requires clear and
measurable learning
objectives.
 Evaluation is a key
component built throughout
the model.

7. DISADVANTAGE
ADDIE
 Because the process is so
detailed, it sometimes deters
the creative process
 You cant get to the next
phase without addressing the
one before it.
DICK & CAREY
 To many phases which takes
up a lot of time.
 It is base on the premise that
every one of its components
are essential, and therefore
none can be skipped

8. CONCLUSION
In conclusion of the similar view between both models is the
system approach which focus on the input, output and process of
designing the curriculum. In comparison between both models
there are two main differences between them. The first is the
steps where ADDIE has five phases and the Dick and Carey has
ten phases that are more detailed. The second is the evaluation in
each model. The ADDIE has it in the last phases and the Dick and
Carey has evaluation throughout the model.

9. REFERENCE
https://www.instructionaldesign.org/models/addie/#:~:text=The%20ADDIE%20model%2
0is%20the,training%20and%20performance%20support%20tools.
https://trainingindustry.com/wiki/content-development/the-dick-and-carey-model/
https://educationaltechnology.net/dick-and-carey-instructional-model/
https://educationaltechnology.net/the-addie-model-instructional-design/