Great Plains Growers Conference
Tim Reinbott
University of Missouri
Columbia MO 65201
 Ca:Mg Ratio-68:12
• What Does Too Much Mg
Do?
 K-Balance: 2-5%
 P-Adequate Amounts
 Sulfur-Is it important?
 Micros-Cu, B, Zn
Does The Ca:Mg Ratio Really Make A
Difference?
Are Micros Really That Important
Sulfur?
Original
Soil
Analysis
-Very Balanced
-Required N,P, K, S
-Micros-Zn, Cu, B
-Pell Lime
Depth pHs OM P Ca Mg K CEC Mn
Inches % lb/acre lb/acre lb/acre lb/acre meq/100g ppm
0-3 5.6 4.2 16 3393 279 170 12.4 25.2
3-9 6.0 3.2 8 4211 318 85 14 25.0
9-12 6.0 2.5 7 3513 480 136 13.5 4.3
12-18 5.4 2.4 3 5459 1262 285 23.8 0.1
18-24 4.8 2.2 1 4598 1393 340 23.7 0.7
24-29 5.1 1.6 16 5101 1525 308 24 16.2
29-36 5.4 0.9 28 3728 906 267 16.4 35.4
36-48 5.7 0.9 32 4102 1244 244 17.8 26.0
From MU Bradford-2012
No P, K, S, Micros or anything else except
N
Kinsey Recommendations
NPKS only not micros
Kinsey Recommendations except KMg
used
Kinsey Recommendations except KMg
and no Pell lime
N plus micros only
Treatment kg/ha (bu/acre)
N only 10819 (161) c
Kinsey Recommendations 13642 (203) a
NPKS only 12298 (183) a
Recom:+Mg 11693 (174) bc
Recommendations: No Lime+Mg 12432 (185) ab
N and Micros only 11962 (178) bc
Letters indicate significance at the 0.10 probability level
No Pell Lime Recommendations
Treatment kg/ha (bu/acre)
N only 12365 (184) abc
Kinsey Recommendations 11558 (172) c
NPKS only 12970 (193) ab
Recom+Mg 13306 (198) a
Recom:No Lime+Mg 13306 (198) a
N and Micros only 12298 (183) abc
P and K only-MU 11626 (173) c
Letters indicate significance at the 0.10 probability level
Mg Level has gone
up.
Much more Ca is
Needed to keep
balance
Ca:Mg is now 57:14
Requires Lime and
Mg
Treatment Yield
Control 42
Recommendations 45
PKS only 43
Recom.+Mg 41
Recom. No lime +Mg 39
Micros only 40
P and K only 35
Following the Kinsey/Albrecht
Recommendations increased corn and
Soybean yield
• Additional Mg did not reduce corn in Year 1 and 2
but did reduce soybean yield in Year 3
Additive effects of PKS and Micronutrients
Importance of following soil test
recommendations each year
The soil microbes in the plow layer
has the mass equivalent of two
cows (2400 lbs) per acre that need
to be fed
Soil organisms are
much like cows, they
need inputs of plant
residues for food
and energy
Specifically, they
need the carbon that
is contained in plant
residue and soil
organic matter
28
With grain production that means cover crops
Small changes in SOC resulting from changes in
management practices can have large effects on
soil behavior and microbial processes.
LONG TERM PASTURE
TILLED IN A
CORN/SOYBEAN/WHEAT ROTATION
 Nutrient Cycling
• Nutrient Holding Capacity
• Pool of Nutrients
• Food for soil organisms
 Water Dynamics
• Improves water infiltration
• Improves water holding
capacity
 Structure
• Reduces crusting,
compaction, erosion
• Encourages root
development
Scientists describe 3 pools of soil organic matter
**really is a continuum of decomposition
38
Passive SOM
500 – 5000 yrs
C/N ratio 7 – 10
Active SOM
1 – 2 yrs
C/N ratio 15 – 30
Slow SOM
15 – 100 yrs
C/N ratio 10 – 25
• Recently deposited organic material
• Rapid decomposition
• 10 – 20% of SOM
• Intermediate age organic material
• Slow decomposition
• 10 – 20% of SOM
• Very stable organic
material
• Extremely slow
decomposition
• 60 – 80% of SOM
Results are read in a spectrometer in lab or
field or from a color card
Potassium
Permanganate Test
KMnO4 oxidizes active carbon. The
purple color of the chemical
changes to pink the more active
carbon there is in a soil sample.
Active Carbon
Treatment mg C/kg
N only 548 bc
Kinsey Recommendations 603 a
NPKS only 616 a
Recommendations+Mg 595 ab
No Lime+Mg 627 a
N and Micros only 533 c
P and K only-MU 526 c
Letters indicate significance at the 0.10 probability level
Soil C and Soil N
Percent Percent
Treatment Soil C Soil N
N only 1.65 b 0.182 b
Kinsey Recommendations 1.70 b 0.191 bc
NPKS only 1.80 ab 0.199 a
Recommendations+Mg 1.73 b 0.194 b
Recom. No Lime+Mg 1.85 a 0.206 a
N and Micros only 1.68 b 0.190 b
P and K only-MU 1.70 b 0.190 b
Letters indicate significance at the 0.10 probability level
No-Till With Cover Crops
No-Till In A Corn/Soybean Rotation
Tilled Each Year in a Corn/Soybean Rotation
Fencerow
Native Warm Season Grass
Cool Season Grass Mix
Restored Native Prairie
Soil Structure
• arrangement of soil solids and voids
• influences water infiltration and retention, erosion,
crusting, nutrient recycling, root infiltration and crop
yield
• expressed as degree of aggregate stability
• aggregation is controlled by SOC, microorganisms,
ionic bridging, clay
http://vro.dpi.vic.gov.au/dpi/vro/vrosite.nsf/pages/soilhealth_soil_structurehttp://ecomerge.blogspot.com/2010/05/what-soil-aggregates-are-
and-how-its.html
Soil Structure
 The grouping or arrangement
of individual soil properties into
a larger grouping.
(Also called aggregate, ped)
Formation of Soil
Structure
 Flocculation: Bringing the
particles close together,
enhanced by polyvalent
cations (Al+++, Ca++,
etc.). Mg is not as good
as Ca in flocculation.
 Stabilization: Providing
durability to maintain the
arrangement. Some clay;
organic matter; oxides of
Fe and Al.
53
From Muneer and Oades, 1989
From Muneer and Oades, 1989
Water Aggregate Stability After Two Years
Rotation Water Aggregate Stability (g/g)
Corn/Soybean 38 b
Corn/rye/Soybean/rye 41 a
Corn/rye/Soybean/hairy vetch 43 a
Corn/rye/Soybean/HV+rye 44 a
Letters indicate significant difference at the 0.10 probability level
From Villamil, et al., 2006
Granular Prismatic Blocky Platey
Flocculated by Ca Restricted
Enhanced by OM Movement
Aggregate
Stability
Fungal-produced glomalin helps
bind aggregates
Measured with wet sieving
http://ed.fnal.gov/trc_new/pandp/soil_research/soil_aggregates.html
Wright, et al., 1999
My son doing his favorite thing After a two inch rain
Water Infiltration
Good infiltration
allows for less
runoff and erosion
Soils with poor
aggregate stability will
crust, damaging
emerging seedlings and
increasing runoff
Aggregate Stability-Better Water
Infiltration
Fungal-produced
glomalin helps
bind aggregates
http://ed.fnal.gov/trc_new/pandp/soil_research/soil
_aggregates.html
Wright, et al., 1999
Tillage reduces aggregate stability and
sizes
Chen et al., 2000
Soil Microbial biomass is important
Interaction of soil microbe excretions and
Ca on soil aggregate stability
Balanced soils produce more biomass;
above and below ground and in return feed
microbial system
Tim Reinbott
University of MO
ReinbottT@missouri.edu

Was Dr. Albrecht Correct?

  • 1.
    Great Plains GrowersConference Tim Reinbott University of Missouri Columbia MO 65201
  • 8.
     Ca:Mg Ratio-68:12 •What Does Too Much Mg Do?  K-Balance: 2-5%  P-Adequate Amounts  Sulfur-Is it important?  Micros-Cu, B, Zn
  • 9.
    Does The Ca:MgRatio Really Make A Difference? Are Micros Really That Important Sulfur?
  • 10.
  • 12.
    Depth pHs OMP Ca Mg K CEC Mn Inches % lb/acre lb/acre lb/acre lb/acre meq/100g ppm 0-3 5.6 4.2 16 3393 279 170 12.4 25.2 3-9 6.0 3.2 8 4211 318 85 14 25.0 9-12 6.0 2.5 7 3513 480 136 13.5 4.3 12-18 5.4 2.4 3 5459 1262 285 23.8 0.1 18-24 4.8 2.2 1 4598 1393 340 23.7 0.7 24-29 5.1 1.6 16 5101 1525 308 24 16.2 29-36 5.4 0.9 28 3728 906 267 16.4 35.4 36-48 5.7 0.9 32 4102 1244 244 17.8 26.0 From MU Bradford-2012
  • 13.
    No P, K,S, Micros or anything else except N Kinsey Recommendations NPKS only not micros Kinsey Recommendations except KMg used Kinsey Recommendations except KMg and no Pell lime N plus micros only
  • 16.
    Treatment kg/ha (bu/acre) Nonly 10819 (161) c Kinsey Recommendations 13642 (203) a NPKS only 12298 (183) a Recom:+Mg 11693 (174) bc Recommendations: No Lime+Mg 12432 (185) ab N and Micros only 11962 (178) bc Letters indicate significance at the 0.10 probability level
  • 17.
    No Pell LimeRecommendations
  • 18.
    Treatment kg/ha (bu/acre) Nonly 12365 (184) abc Kinsey Recommendations 11558 (172) c NPKS only 12970 (193) ab Recom+Mg 13306 (198) a Recom:No Lime+Mg 13306 (198) a N and Micros only 12298 (183) abc P and K only-MU 11626 (173) c Letters indicate significance at the 0.10 probability level
  • 19.
    Mg Level hasgone up. Much more Ca is Needed to keep balance
  • 20.
    Ca:Mg is now57:14 Requires Lime and Mg
  • 22.
    Treatment Yield Control 42 Recommendations45 PKS only 43 Recom.+Mg 41 Recom. No lime +Mg 39 Micros only 40 P and K only 35
  • 23.
    Following the Kinsey/Albrecht Recommendationsincreased corn and Soybean yield • Additional Mg did not reduce corn in Year 1 and 2 but did reduce soybean yield in Year 3 Additive effects of PKS and Micronutrients Importance of following soil test recommendations each year
  • 26.
    The soil microbesin the plow layer has the mass equivalent of two cows (2400 lbs) per acre that need to be fed Soil organisms are much like cows, they need inputs of plant residues for food and energy Specifically, they need the carbon that is contained in plant residue and soil organic matter
  • 28.
  • 30.
    With grain productionthat means cover crops
  • 33.
    Small changes inSOC resulting from changes in management practices can have large effects on soil behavior and microbial processes.
  • 34.
    LONG TERM PASTURE TILLEDIN A CORN/SOYBEAN/WHEAT ROTATION
  • 35.
     Nutrient Cycling •Nutrient Holding Capacity • Pool of Nutrients • Food for soil organisms  Water Dynamics • Improves water infiltration • Improves water holding capacity  Structure • Reduces crusting, compaction, erosion • Encourages root development
  • 38.
    Scientists describe 3pools of soil organic matter **really is a continuum of decomposition 38 Passive SOM 500 – 5000 yrs C/N ratio 7 – 10 Active SOM 1 – 2 yrs C/N ratio 15 – 30 Slow SOM 15 – 100 yrs C/N ratio 10 – 25 • Recently deposited organic material • Rapid decomposition • 10 – 20% of SOM • Intermediate age organic material • Slow decomposition • 10 – 20% of SOM • Very stable organic material • Extremely slow decomposition • 60 – 80% of SOM
  • 39.
    Results are readin a spectrometer in lab or field or from a color card Potassium Permanganate Test KMnO4 oxidizes active carbon. The purple color of the chemical changes to pink the more active carbon there is in a soil sample.
  • 42.
    Active Carbon Treatment mgC/kg N only 548 bc Kinsey Recommendations 603 a NPKS only 616 a Recommendations+Mg 595 ab No Lime+Mg 627 a N and Micros only 533 c P and K only-MU 526 c Letters indicate significance at the 0.10 probability level
  • 43.
    Soil C andSoil N Percent Percent Treatment Soil C Soil N N only 1.65 b 0.182 b Kinsey Recommendations 1.70 b 0.191 bc NPKS only 1.80 ab 0.199 a Recommendations+Mg 1.73 b 0.194 b Recom. No Lime+Mg 1.85 a 0.206 a N and Micros only 1.68 b 0.190 b P and K only-MU 1.70 b 0.190 b Letters indicate significance at the 0.10 probability level
  • 46.
    No-Till With CoverCrops No-Till In A Corn/Soybean Rotation Tilled Each Year in a Corn/Soybean Rotation
  • 47.
    Fencerow Native Warm SeasonGrass Cool Season Grass Mix Restored Native Prairie
  • 51.
    Soil Structure • arrangementof soil solids and voids • influences water infiltration and retention, erosion, crusting, nutrient recycling, root infiltration and crop yield • expressed as degree of aggregate stability • aggregation is controlled by SOC, microorganisms, ionic bridging, clay http://vro.dpi.vic.gov.au/dpi/vro/vrosite.nsf/pages/soilhealth_soil_structurehttp://ecomerge.blogspot.com/2010/05/what-soil-aggregates-are- and-how-its.html
  • 52.
    Soil Structure  Thegrouping or arrangement of individual soil properties into a larger grouping. (Also called aggregate, ped) Formation of Soil Structure  Flocculation: Bringing the particles close together, enhanced by polyvalent cations (Al+++, Ca++, etc.). Mg is not as good as Ca in flocculation.  Stabilization: Providing durability to maintain the arrangement. Some clay; organic matter; oxides of Fe and Al.
  • 53.
  • 54.
    From Muneer andOades, 1989
  • 55.
    From Muneer andOades, 1989
  • 56.
    Water Aggregate StabilityAfter Two Years Rotation Water Aggregate Stability (g/g) Corn/Soybean 38 b Corn/rye/Soybean/rye 41 a Corn/rye/Soybean/hairy vetch 43 a Corn/rye/Soybean/HV+rye 44 a Letters indicate significant difference at the 0.10 probability level From Villamil, et al., 2006
  • 57.
    Granular Prismatic BlockyPlatey Flocculated by Ca Restricted Enhanced by OM Movement
  • 58.
    Aggregate Stability Fungal-produced glomalin helps bindaggregates Measured with wet sieving http://ed.fnal.gov/trc_new/pandp/soil_research/soil_aggregates.html Wright, et al., 1999
  • 59.
    My son doinghis favorite thing After a two inch rain
  • 60.
    Water Infiltration Good infiltration allowsfor less runoff and erosion Soils with poor aggregate stability will crust, damaging emerging seedlings and increasing runoff
  • 61.
    Aggregate Stability-Better Water Infiltration Fungal-produced glomalinhelps bind aggregates http://ed.fnal.gov/trc_new/pandp/soil_research/soil _aggregates.html Wright, et al., 1999
  • 62.
    Tillage reduces aggregatestability and sizes Chen et al., 2000
  • 64.
    Soil Microbial biomassis important Interaction of soil microbe excretions and Ca on soil aggregate stability Balanced soils produce more biomass; above and below ground and in return feed microbial system
  • 65.
    Tim Reinbott University ofMO ReinbottT@missouri.edu