STRESS MANAGEMENT


                                                                       Capital   Mitigating
                             P & L Impact                 RWA Impact
                                                                       Impact    Measures
Positive Impact




                                                                                 Provisions,
                  Interest                     Trade                             Divestment,
                    Rate                      Income,                              Capital,
                                                Fees,                                etc
                                            Commission

                             Impairment                     Rating
Negative Impact




                                            Operating &
                              Increased     Adm. Costs
                                                          Increased     Net
                                Cost of                     RWA         P&L
                               Funding                                 Impact

                               Trading
                                 Loss
STRESS ASSESSMENT

                          Capital Impact
                                              Liabilities &
                    Assets
                                                 Equity

                  Bank Book
                                                              Default Assets

                                                              Restructuring


                  Loans, Debt,                Wholesale
Macro Scenario
                  Receivables,                   Retail
                 Securitisation               Inter Bank
 Interest Rate
   Scenario
                  Trade Book
  Sovereign
   Haircut
                  Real Estate                   Equity

                                Market Risk
                                 Scenario
RISK MANAGEMENT


                      Risk Assessment

                            Capital
   Risk Appetite           ICAAP           Economic Capital


Counterparty       Operating Environment
 Customer /




                                                      Market / Credit / Operations /
                                                      Regulatory / Insurance Risks
                      External Factors

                          Exposure

                      Internal Factors
Portfolio
Product




                   Scenarios / Sensitivity

                      Policies / Models
                    Valuation, Impairment, etc
STRESS TESTING MODEL


                                                             Operational Model
                                                         Integrated Risk Processes & Appetite

                                       Stress Policy               Risk Sensitivity & Scenario Definition




                                                                                                                     Business Impact - Environment & Operations
                                                                   Financial Measures
Strategic & Operational Parameters




                                     Macro Economic                                                 Reporting -
                                       Impact of                                                 Profit & Loss A/C
                                       Operating                                                   Balance Sheet
                                      Conditions                     Stress Test                      Capital
                                                                       Engine                        Liquidity
                                       Business &                                                Including Explain
                                     Portfolio Factors                                            & Assumptions
                                          Impact                  Business Scenarios

                                                                                                   Mitigating /
                                         Risk              Stress Models -                          Remedial
                                     Impact Factors                          Model Selection
                                                           Business, Risk,                           Actions
                                                                              & Calculation
                                                               Finance,
                                        Valuation                                Criteria
                                                              Treasury
                                                                                                   Validation &
                                                 Reconciled Risk & Finance Data                     Approval

                                                                Finance Infrastructure
STRESS TESTING CRITICAL SUCCESS FACTORS
Robust and comprehensive models, with appropriate scenarios, vetted and supported by senior stakeholders.
Senior Management uses insights derived from stress testing to address problematic business areas.
Stress testing must be embedded into the decision-making process in a consistent manner across business units and
into valuation models.
Reconciled risk, finance and treasury data must be used for stress testing accordingly.
Shortfalls in stress testing have led to a lack of credibility and limited buy-in from senior management in critical
decision making and/or taking preventative actions based on stress testing results.
Risk appetite should be embedded in business units and monitored with stress test results measured against it.
Stress results should be applied to test how the firm responds to adverse market conditions in terms of risk sensitivity
and risk management effectiveness.
Stress testing capabilities should comprise of all risk types applicable, be consistent, aggregate exposures across
product lines, businesses and legal entities, and address the secondary effects of risk in capital structure and strategy.
A challenge is to define scenarios which are useful both to the business and to the risk management function.
Behavioural assumptions must be consistently applied to gauge effects of risk events on market and credit activities.
Valuation data and associated risk measures should be consistently applied across all positions, products, operating
units, and legal entities.
Data elements must be available across all required dimensions, including risk factor hierarchies, trade data, static
data, daily valuations, sensitivity data, business entity exposures, VaR, and EaR, etc.
Prior methodologies and procedures such as Value at Risk and Economic Capital provide an overall net view of risk
making it incomplete, as they disguised the size of individual positions. Exposures were netted and reduced by hedges
and further reduced by correlations, hiding the true size of gross exposures.

  Sensitivity        Scenario                                                          Business &         Mitigation &
                                    Plausibility     Risk Types      Aggregation        Financial
   Factors          Generation                                                                            Contingency
                                       Test                                              Impact               Plan
Integrated Stress Testing
                  • Aggregate Level
                  • For Decision Making
  Top Down        • Available On Demand
                  • Quick View of Position and Impact
                  • 80 % Accuracy

                  • Transaction Level
                  • For Reporting
  Bottom Up
                  • Annual Exercise or Expected Event Based
                  • 100 % Accuracy

                  • All Business and Operating Units
Enterprise Wide
                  • All Portfolios


  Risk Types      • Across All Material Risk Types of the Enterprise



 Embedded In      • Core of the Decision Making Level of the Business
  Business        • Into Risk Appetite at Capital and Limit Setting Level
Stress Testing Framework
                          Directives
Policy Initiative         Economic Variables
                          Sectoral Decomposition                    Credit
      And
                          Materiality
  Scenarios               Severity
                                                                    Counterparty
                          Cross Risk Effects
                                                                    Concentration
                          Decomposition
 Management               Calculation                               Market
      Of                  Integration




                                                   Material Risks
                          Analysis                                  Operational
Test execution
                          Reporting
                                                                    Liquidity
                          Capital
  Approach                Liquidity                                 Funding
                          Operational
      and
                          Insurance                                 Regulatory
  Resources               Ratings
                          Margins                                   Compliance
                          Capital Planning
                                                                    Insurance
                          Business Planning
    Stress                Contingency Planning                      Reputation
    Impacts               Mitigation
                          Effectiveness                             Business
                          Triggers

Stress Testing

  • 1.
    STRESS MANAGEMENT Capital Mitigating P & L Impact RWA Impact Impact Measures Positive Impact Provisions, Interest Trade Divestment, Rate Income, Capital, Fees, etc Commission Impairment Rating Negative Impact Operating & Increased Adm. Costs Increased Net Cost of RWA P&L Funding Impact Trading Loss
  • 2.
    STRESS ASSESSMENT Capital Impact Liabilities & Assets Equity Bank Book Default Assets Restructuring Loans, Debt, Wholesale Macro Scenario Receivables, Retail Securitisation Inter Bank Interest Rate Scenario Trade Book Sovereign Haircut Real Estate Equity Market Risk Scenario
  • 3.
    RISK MANAGEMENT Risk Assessment Capital Risk Appetite ICAAP Economic Capital Counterparty Operating Environment Customer / Market / Credit / Operations / Regulatory / Insurance Risks External Factors Exposure Internal Factors Portfolio Product Scenarios / Sensitivity Policies / Models Valuation, Impairment, etc
  • 4.
    STRESS TESTING MODEL Operational Model Integrated Risk Processes & Appetite Stress Policy Risk Sensitivity & Scenario Definition Business Impact - Environment & Operations Financial Measures Strategic & Operational Parameters Macro Economic Reporting - Impact of Profit & Loss A/C Operating Balance Sheet Conditions Stress Test Capital Engine Liquidity Business & Including Explain Portfolio Factors & Assumptions Impact Business Scenarios Mitigating / Risk Stress Models - Remedial Impact Factors Model Selection Business, Risk, Actions & Calculation Finance, Valuation Criteria Treasury Validation & Reconciled Risk & Finance Data Approval Finance Infrastructure
  • 5.
    STRESS TESTING CRITICALSUCCESS FACTORS Robust and comprehensive models, with appropriate scenarios, vetted and supported by senior stakeholders. Senior Management uses insights derived from stress testing to address problematic business areas. Stress testing must be embedded into the decision-making process in a consistent manner across business units and into valuation models. Reconciled risk, finance and treasury data must be used for stress testing accordingly. Shortfalls in stress testing have led to a lack of credibility and limited buy-in from senior management in critical decision making and/or taking preventative actions based on stress testing results. Risk appetite should be embedded in business units and monitored with stress test results measured against it. Stress results should be applied to test how the firm responds to adverse market conditions in terms of risk sensitivity and risk management effectiveness. Stress testing capabilities should comprise of all risk types applicable, be consistent, aggregate exposures across product lines, businesses and legal entities, and address the secondary effects of risk in capital structure and strategy. A challenge is to define scenarios which are useful both to the business and to the risk management function. Behavioural assumptions must be consistently applied to gauge effects of risk events on market and credit activities. Valuation data and associated risk measures should be consistently applied across all positions, products, operating units, and legal entities. Data elements must be available across all required dimensions, including risk factor hierarchies, trade data, static data, daily valuations, sensitivity data, business entity exposures, VaR, and EaR, etc. Prior methodologies and procedures such as Value at Risk and Economic Capital provide an overall net view of risk making it incomplete, as they disguised the size of individual positions. Exposures were netted and reduced by hedges and further reduced by correlations, hiding the true size of gross exposures. Sensitivity Scenario Business & Mitigation & Plausibility Risk Types Aggregation Financial Factors Generation Contingency Test Impact Plan
  • 6.
    Integrated Stress Testing • Aggregate Level • For Decision Making Top Down • Available On Demand • Quick View of Position and Impact • 80 % Accuracy • Transaction Level • For Reporting Bottom Up • Annual Exercise or Expected Event Based • 100 % Accuracy • All Business and Operating Units Enterprise Wide • All Portfolios Risk Types • Across All Material Risk Types of the Enterprise Embedded In • Core of the Decision Making Level of the Business Business • Into Risk Appetite at Capital and Limit Setting Level
  • 7.
    Stress Testing Framework Directives Policy Initiative Economic Variables Sectoral Decomposition Credit And Materiality Scenarios Severity Counterparty Cross Risk Effects Concentration Decomposition Management Calculation Market Of Integration Material Risks Analysis Operational Test execution Reporting Liquidity Capital Approach Liquidity Funding Operational and Insurance Regulatory Resources Ratings Margins Compliance Capital Planning Insurance Business Planning Stress Contingency Planning Reputation Impacts Mitigation Effectiveness Business Triggers