SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Impact of Site Factors on the Effectiveness of Rigid and Flexible
Pavement Preservation Treatments
Nicholas McDonald, Syed Haider, Ronell Eisma
INTRODUCTION
OBJECTIVES
The objectives of the paper are:
1.  To evaluate and understand the effectiveness of pavement
preservation treatments on rigid and flexible pavements
under varying site conditions.
2.  To provide a more cost-effective way of maintaining
pavement by applying preservation treatments early on in
the life of the pavement section. This development will
reduce the cost of maintaining pavement structures in the
future by providing the pavement with a longer service life.
PAVEMENT SURFACE DISTRESSES
Based on the data analysis, on average, thin overlay is the most
effective treatment based on service life extension for the SPS-3
treatments. Thin overlay, slurry seal, crack seal, and chip seal were all
most effective in the wet no-freeze climatic zones for surface rutting.
Crack seal for flexible pavements and joint seal for rigid pavements
were the most effective for high levels of traffic. The treatments applied
performed better when the pavements had lower levels of pre-existing
rutting. In general, joint sealing in SPS-4 was more effective than joint
under sealing across all conditions for rigid pavements. Pavement
preservation treatments are a necessary tool to address pavement
maintenance needs at the network level. These treatments can provide
sustainability to pavement structures to increase the service life
extension.
SITE CONDITIONS
LONG TERM PAVEMENT PRESEVERATION DATABASE
(LTPP)
SUMMARY
Longitudinal Cracking Transverse Cracking
The data being evaluated are
from the SPS-3 and SPS-4 studies
of the Long Term Pavement
Preservation Database (LTPP).
The SPS-3 and SPS-4
experiments deal with pavement
maintenance and preventive
maintenance effectiveness of
flexible and rigid pavements.
The focus of this research is to determine the effectiveness of
rigid and flexible pavement preservation treatments under
various climates, traffic levels, and pre-existing conditions.
The goal is to determine the effectiveness among the treatment
types for different site factors. The study evaluated over 100
pavement sections located in 25 different states. For each
treatment, the pavement service life extension (SLE) was
determined based on temporal performance data. The
performance measures used were cracking, faulting and
surface roughness (IRI) for rigid, and rutting and IRI for
flexible pavements. Service life extension is the amount of
years gained from the benefits of the treatment compared to the
control section. However, the SLE will depend on the
performance measures used to calculate it.
Climatic Zones
WF- Wet-freeze
DF- Dry-freeze
WNF-Wet no-
freeze
DNF-Dry no-
freeze
•  There are a variety of conditions or site factors
which needs to be considered while determining
the service life extension of pavement
preservation treatments.
•  The different site conditions that were
considered are: (a) traffic (AADT, AADTT, and
18k ESALs), (b) treatment age, (c) pre-existing
conditions, (d) thickness, and (e) climatic zone.
Pavement Preservation Treatments
SPS-3 SPS-4
Thin Overlay (310) Joint Seal (410)
Slurry Seal (320) Joint Under Seal
(420)
Crack Seal (330) Control (430)
Control (340)
Chip Seal (350)
•  This image presents the
loads of different
vehicles in the traffic
mix on a typical
highway.
Negative service life
extension (SLE)
indicates that the
treatment did not extend
service life or there
were other errors.
Rutting Roughness
DATA ANALYSIS
This figure shows time series rutting data for
different treatments in the SPS-3 experiment.
This data can be used to determine SLE for each
treatment type. The red line on the graph is the
control section, service life extension is
determined by when these trends reach the
threshold.
Comparison of SLE based on
Rutting for SPS-3 Experiment
TreatmentSLE
310 10.4
320 13.3
330 -5.9
340 0
350 -8.1
Comparison of SLE based on IRI
for SPS-4 Experiment

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

The Effect of Climatic Conditions of Various Regions of Iran on Pavement Fati...
The Effect of Climatic Conditions of Various Regions of Iran on Pavement Fati...The Effect of Climatic Conditions of Various Regions of Iran on Pavement Fati...
The Effect of Climatic Conditions of Various Regions of Iran on Pavement Fati...
IDES Editor
 
Review Paper 8-10-2014
Review Paper 8-10-2014Review Paper 8-10-2014
Review Paper 8-10-2014
Chandrapal Khasiya
 
An approach in evaluating of flexible pavement in permanent deformation of pa...
An approach in evaluating of flexible pavement in permanent deformation of pa...An approach in evaluating of flexible pavement in permanent deformation of pa...
An approach in evaluating of flexible pavement in permanent deformation of pa...
Alexander Decker
 
Construction of Road
Construction of RoadConstruction of Road
Construction of Road
Aman Shakya
 
Highway construction or Road work
Highway construction or Road work Highway construction or Road work
Highway construction or Road work
Abdul rahman kureshi
 
Flexible pavement failure
Flexible pavement failureFlexible pavement failure
Flexible pavement failure
Nabaraj Poudel
 
Flexible pavement presentation
Flexible pavement presentationFlexible pavement presentation
Flexible pavement presentation
Pawan Kumar
 
Road materials
Road materialsRoad materials
Road materials
Rron de Guzman
 
Presentation on FLEXIBLE ELECTRONICS.....
Presentation on FLEXIBLE ELECTRONICS.....Presentation on FLEXIBLE ELECTRONICS.....
Presentation on FLEXIBLE ELECTRONICS.....
Yalagoud Patil
 
Pavement materials in Road Construction
Pavement materials in Road ConstructionPavement materials in Road Construction
Pavement materials in Road Construction
srinivas2036
 
cement road construction in the rural areas
cement road construction in the rural areas cement road construction in the rural areas
cement road construction in the rural areas
Anshul Shakya
 
Flexible and-rigid-pavements
Flexible and-rigid-pavementsFlexible and-rigid-pavements
Flexible and-rigid-pavements
HARITSEHRAWAT
 
Construction of roads presentations
Construction of roads presentationsConstruction of roads presentations
Construction of roads presentations
Ijaz Hassan Khan
 
Pavement design
Pavement designPavement design
Pavement design
Garvit Goyal
 
Design Of Flexible Pavements
Design Of Flexible PavementsDesign Of Flexible Pavements
Design Of Flexible Pavements
whutton1
 
Pavements PPT
 Pavements PPT  Pavements PPT
Pavements PPT
Amol Pawar
 
Road Construction
Road ConstructionRoad Construction
Road Construction
Danish Mohd
 
Pavement Deterioration
Pavement DeteriorationPavement Deterioration
Road construction
Road constructionRoad construction
Road construction
Mohideen Al-haseb
 
Highway Materials Unit-III
Highway Materials  Unit-IIIHighway Materials  Unit-III
Highway Materials Unit-III
GAURAV. H .TANDON
 

Viewers also liked (20)

The Effect of Climatic Conditions of Various Regions of Iran on Pavement Fati...
The Effect of Climatic Conditions of Various Regions of Iran on Pavement Fati...The Effect of Climatic Conditions of Various Regions of Iran on Pavement Fati...
The Effect of Climatic Conditions of Various Regions of Iran on Pavement Fati...
 
Review Paper 8-10-2014
Review Paper 8-10-2014Review Paper 8-10-2014
Review Paper 8-10-2014
 
An approach in evaluating of flexible pavement in permanent deformation of pa...
An approach in evaluating of flexible pavement in permanent deformation of pa...An approach in evaluating of flexible pavement in permanent deformation of pa...
An approach in evaluating of flexible pavement in permanent deformation of pa...
 
Construction of Road
Construction of RoadConstruction of Road
Construction of Road
 
Highway construction or Road work
Highway construction or Road work Highway construction or Road work
Highway construction or Road work
 
Flexible pavement failure
Flexible pavement failureFlexible pavement failure
Flexible pavement failure
 
Flexible pavement presentation
Flexible pavement presentationFlexible pavement presentation
Flexible pavement presentation
 
Road materials
Road materialsRoad materials
Road materials
 
Presentation on FLEXIBLE ELECTRONICS.....
Presentation on FLEXIBLE ELECTRONICS.....Presentation on FLEXIBLE ELECTRONICS.....
Presentation on FLEXIBLE ELECTRONICS.....
 
Pavement materials in Road Construction
Pavement materials in Road ConstructionPavement materials in Road Construction
Pavement materials in Road Construction
 
cement road construction in the rural areas
cement road construction in the rural areas cement road construction in the rural areas
cement road construction in the rural areas
 
Flexible and-rigid-pavements
Flexible and-rigid-pavementsFlexible and-rigid-pavements
Flexible and-rigid-pavements
 
Construction of roads presentations
Construction of roads presentationsConstruction of roads presentations
Construction of roads presentations
 
Pavement design
Pavement designPavement design
Pavement design
 
Design Of Flexible Pavements
Design Of Flexible PavementsDesign Of Flexible Pavements
Design Of Flexible Pavements
 
Pavements PPT
 Pavements PPT  Pavements PPT
Pavements PPT
 
Road Construction
Road ConstructionRoad Construction
Road Construction
 
Pavement Deterioration
Pavement DeteriorationPavement Deterioration
Pavement Deterioration
 
Road construction
Road constructionRoad construction
Road construction
 
Highway Materials Unit-III
Highway Materials  Unit-IIIHighway Materials  Unit-III
Highway Materials Unit-III
 

Similar to Research Poster

D0322024034
D0322024034D0322024034
D0322024034
inventionjournals
 
Geo 101 detailed
Geo 101  detailedGeo 101  detailed
Geo 101 detailed
bgoehring
 
Pavement Preservation - Novel Lithium Densifier surface hardener
Pavement Preservation - Novel Lithium Densifier surface hardenerPavement Preservation - Novel Lithium Densifier surface hardener
Pavement Preservation - Novel Lithium Densifier surface hardener
Claudio Manissero
 
Geosynthetics&Geosystems In Coastal Engineering Pilarczyk2009
Geosynthetics&Geosystems In Coastal Engineering Pilarczyk2009Geosynthetics&Geosystems In Coastal Engineering Pilarczyk2009
Geosynthetics&Geosystems In Coastal Engineering Pilarczyk2009
Krystian Pilarczyk
 
Chip Seal and Scrub Seal Best Practices May 28, 2014
Chip Seal and Scrub Seal Best Practices May 28, 2014Chip Seal and Scrub Seal Best Practices May 28, 2014
Chip Seal and Scrub Seal Best Practices May 28, 2014
California Asphalt Pavement Association
 
Curing of Concret
Curing of ConcretCuring of Concret
Curing of Concret
IRJET Journal
 
BEB801 - Elliott Martin
BEB801 - Elliott MartinBEB801 - Elliott Martin
BEB801 - Elliott Martin
Elliott Martin
 
Road
RoadRoad
Road
juwes
 
"Factors Affecting the Design and Construction of High Capacity Minipiles"
"Factors Affecting the Design and Construction of High Capacity Minipiles""Factors Affecting the Design and Construction of High Capacity Minipiles"
"Factors Affecting the Design and Construction of High Capacity Minipiles"
Remedy Geotechnics Ltd
 
Sand erosion-experiments
Sand erosion-experimentsSand erosion-experiments
Sand erosion-experiments
Jose Manuel Garrido Collantes
 
International Journal of Engineering Research and Development (IJERD)
International Journal of Engineering Research and Development (IJERD)International Journal of Engineering Research and Development (IJERD)
International Journal of Engineering Research and Development (IJERD)
IJERD Editor
 
Permeability measurement and scan imaging to assess clogging of pervious conc...
Permeability measurement and scan imaging to assess clogging of pervious conc...Permeability measurement and scan imaging to assess clogging of pervious conc...
Permeability measurement and scan imaging to assess clogging of pervious conc...
Jahzeel Suarez
 
EVALUATION OF PERFORMANCE OF HIGH CALCIUM FLY ASH AS A MINERAL FILLER IN MIX ...
EVALUATION OF PERFORMANCE OF HIGH CALCIUM FLY ASH AS A MINERAL FILLER IN MIX ...EVALUATION OF PERFORMANCE OF HIGH CALCIUM FLY ASH AS A MINERAL FILLER IN MIX ...
EVALUATION OF PERFORMANCE OF HIGH CALCIUM FLY ASH AS A MINERAL FILLER IN MIX ...
civej
 
Evaluation of Performance of High Calcium Fly Ash as a Mineral Filler in Mix ...
Evaluation of Performance of High Calcium Fly Ash as a Mineral Filler in Mix ...Evaluation of Performance of High Calcium Fly Ash as a Mineral Filler in Mix ...
Evaluation of Performance of High Calcium Fly Ash as a Mineral Filler in Mix ...
civejjour
 
Erosionpresentationcompressed01 05-13
Erosionpresentationcompressed01 05-13Erosionpresentationcompressed01 05-13
Erosionpresentationcompressed01 05-13
BioScience Australia Pty Ltd
 
Petroleum Vapor Intrusion Strategies at UST and non-UST Sites Under 2015 EPA ...
Petroleum Vapor Intrusion Strategies at UST and non-UST Sites Under 2015 EPA ...Petroleum Vapor Intrusion Strategies at UST and non-UST Sites Under 2015 EPA ...
Petroleum Vapor Intrusion Strategies at UST and non-UST Sites Under 2015 EPA ...
Chris Lutes
 
Study on the approaches of soil stabilization
Study on the approaches of soil stabilizationStudy on the approaches of soil stabilization
Study on the approaches of soil stabilization
IRJET Journal
 
Effect of Compaction Moisture Content on Strength Parameters of Unsaturated C...
Effect of Compaction Moisture Content on Strength Parameters of Unsaturated C...Effect of Compaction Moisture Content on Strength Parameters of Unsaturated C...
Effect of Compaction Moisture Content on Strength Parameters of Unsaturated C...
ijtsrd
 
IRJET- Study on Flexible Pavement Failures and it’s Remedial Measures
IRJET- Study on Flexible Pavement Failures and it’s Remedial MeasuresIRJET- Study on Flexible Pavement Failures and it’s Remedial Measures
IRJET- Study on Flexible Pavement Failures and it’s Remedial Measures
IRJET Journal
 
C026010018
C026010018C026010018
C026010018
theijes
 

Similar to Research Poster (20)

D0322024034
D0322024034D0322024034
D0322024034
 
Geo 101 detailed
Geo 101  detailedGeo 101  detailed
Geo 101 detailed
 
Pavement Preservation - Novel Lithium Densifier surface hardener
Pavement Preservation - Novel Lithium Densifier surface hardenerPavement Preservation - Novel Lithium Densifier surface hardener
Pavement Preservation - Novel Lithium Densifier surface hardener
 
Geosynthetics&Geosystems In Coastal Engineering Pilarczyk2009
Geosynthetics&Geosystems In Coastal Engineering Pilarczyk2009Geosynthetics&Geosystems In Coastal Engineering Pilarczyk2009
Geosynthetics&Geosystems In Coastal Engineering Pilarczyk2009
 
Chip Seal and Scrub Seal Best Practices May 28, 2014
Chip Seal and Scrub Seal Best Practices May 28, 2014Chip Seal and Scrub Seal Best Practices May 28, 2014
Chip Seal and Scrub Seal Best Practices May 28, 2014
 
Curing of Concret
Curing of ConcretCuring of Concret
Curing of Concret
 
BEB801 - Elliott Martin
BEB801 - Elliott MartinBEB801 - Elliott Martin
BEB801 - Elliott Martin
 
Road
RoadRoad
Road
 
"Factors Affecting the Design and Construction of High Capacity Minipiles"
"Factors Affecting the Design and Construction of High Capacity Minipiles""Factors Affecting the Design and Construction of High Capacity Minipiles"
"Factors Affecting the Design and Construction of High Capacity Minipiles"
 
Sand erosion-experiments
Sand erosion-experimentsSand erosion-experiments
Sand erosion-experiments
 
International Journal of Engineering Research and Development (IJERD)
International Journal of Engineering Research and Development (IJERD)International Journal of Engineering Research and Development (IJERD)
International Journal of Engineering Research and Development (IJERD)
 
Permeability measurement and scan imaging to assess clogging of pervious conc...
Permeability measurement and scan imaging to assess clogging of pervious conc...Permeability measurement and scan imaging to assess clogging of pervious conc...
Permeability measurement and scan imaging to assess clogging of pervious conc...
 
EVALUATION OF PERFORMANCE OF HIGH CALCIUM FLY ASH AS A MINERAL FILLER IN MIX ...
EVALUATION OF PERFORMANCE OF HIGH CALCIUM FLY ASH AS A MINERAL FILLER IN MIX ...EVALUATION OF PERFORMANCE OF HIGH CALCIUM FLY ASH AS A MINERAL FILLER IN MIX ...
EVALUATION OF PERFORMANCE OF HIGH CALCIUM FLY ASH AS A MINERAL FILLER IN MIX ...
 
Evaluation of Performance of High Calcium Fly Ash as a Mineral Filler in Mix ...
Evaluation of Performance of High Calcium Fly Ash as a Mineral Filler in Mix ...Evaluation of Performance of High Calcium Fly Ash as a Mineral Filler in Mix ...
Evaluation of Performance of High Calcium Fly Ash as a Mineral Filler in Mix ...
 
Erosionpresentationcompressed01 05-13
Erosionpresentationcompressed01 05-13Erosionpresentationcompressed01 05-13
Erosionpresentationcompressed01 05-13
 
Petroleum Vapor Intrusion Strategies at UST and non-UST Sites Under 2015 EPA ...
Petroleum Vapor Intrusion Strategies at UST and non-UST Sites Under 2015 EPA ...Petroleum Vapor Intrusion Strategies at UST and non-UST Sites Under 2015 EPA ...
Petroleum Vapor Intrusion Strategies at UST and non-UST Sites Under 2015 EPA ...
 
Study on the approaches of soil stabilization
Study on the approaches of soil stabilizationStudy on the approaches of soil stabilization
Study on the approaches of soil stabilization
 
Effect of Compaction Moisture Content on Strength Parameters of Unsaturated C...
Effect of Compaction Moisture Content on Strength Parameters of Unsaturated C...Effect of Compaction Moisture Content on Strength Parameters of Unsaturated C...
Effect of Compaction Moisture Content on Strength Parameters of Unsaturated C...
 
IRJET- Study on Flexible Pavement Failures and it’s Remedial Measures
IRJET- Study on Flexible Pavement Failures and it’s Remedial MeasuresIRJET- Study on Flexible Pavement Failures and it’s Remedial Measures
IRJET- Study on Flexible Pavement Failures and it’s Remedial Measures
 
C026010018
C026010018C026010018
C026010018
 

Research Poster

  • 1. Impact of Site Factors on the Effectiveness of Rigid and Flexible Pavement Preservation Treatments Nicholas McDonald, Syed Haider, Ronell Eisma INTRODUCTION OBJECTIVES The objectives of the paper are: 1.  To evaluate and understand the effectiveness of pavement preservation treatments on rigid and flexible pavements under varying site conditions. 2.  To provide a more cost-effective way of maintaining pavement by applying preservation treatments early on in the life of the pavement section. This development will reduce the cost of maintaining pavement structures in the future by providing the pavement with a longer service life. PAVEMENT SURFACE DISTRESSES Based on the data analysis, on average, thin overlay is the most effective treatment based on service life extension for the SPS-3 treatments. Thin overlay, slurry seal, crack seal, and chip seal were all most effective in the wet no-freeze climatic zones for surface rutting. Crack seal for flexible pavements and joint seal for rigid pavements were the most effective for high levels of traffic. The treatments applied performed better when the pavements had lower levels of pre-existing rutting. In general, joint sealing in SPS-4 was more effective than joint under sealing across all conditions for rigid pavements. Pavement preservation treatments are a necessary tool to address pavement maintenance needs at the network level. These treatments can provide sustainability to pavement structures to increase the service life extension. SITE CONDITIONS LONG TERM PAVEMENT PRESEVERATION DATABASE (LTPP) SUMMARY Longitudinal Cracking Transverse Cracking The data being evaluated are from the SPS-3 and SPS-4 studies of the Long Term Pavement Preservation Database (LTPP). The SPS-3 and SPS-4 experiments deal with pavement maintenance and preventive maintenance effectiveness of flexible and rigid pavements. The focus of this research is to determine the effectiveness of rigid and flexible pavement preservation treatments under various climates, traffic levels, and pre-existing conditions. The goal is to determine the effectiveness among the treatment types for different site factors. The study evaluated over 100 pavement sections located in 25 different states. For each treatment, the pavement service life extension (SLE) was determined based on temporal performance data. The performance measures used were cracking, faulting and surface roughness (IRI) for rigid, and rutting and IRI for flexible pavements. Service life extension is the amount of years gained from the benefits of the treatment compared to the control section. However, the SLE will depend on the performance measures used to calculate it. Climatic Zones WF- Wet-freeze DF- Dry-freeze WNF-Wet no- freeze DNF-Dry no- freeze •  There are a variety of conditions or site factors which needs to be considered while determining the service life extension of pavement preservation treatments. •  The different site conditions that were considered are: (a) traffic (AADT, AADTT, and 18k ESALs), (b) treatment age, (c) pre-existing conditions, (d) thickness, and (e) climatic zone. Pavement Preservation Treatments SPS-3 SPS-4 Thin Overlay (310) Joint Seal (410) Slurry Seal (320) Joint Under Seal (420) Crack Seal (330) Control (430) Control (340) Chip Seal (350) •  This image presents the loads of different vehicles in the traffic mix on a typical highway. Negative service life extension (SLE) indicates that the treatment did not extend service life or there were other errors. Rutting Roughness DATA ANALYSIS This figure shows time series rutting data for different treatments in the SPS-3 experiment. This data can be used to determine SLE for each treatment type. The red line on the graph is the control section, service life extension is determined by when these trends reach the threshold. Comparison of SLE based on Rutting for SPS-3 Experiment TreatmentSLE 310 10.4 320 13.3 330 -5.9 340 0 350 -8.1 Comparison of SLE based on IRI for SPS-4 Experiment