Reasoning
Dr Bhavin Chauhan
Reasoning: Definitions
• “Reasoning is a stepwise thinking with a purpose or goal in
mind” —Garrett.
• “Reasoning is the term applied to highly purposeful, controlled
and selective thinking”—Gates.
• “Reasoning is the word used to describe the mental recognition
of cause-and-effect relationships, it may be the prediction of an
event from an observed cause or the inference of a cause from
an observed event”—Skinner.
Reasoning: Characteristics
Reasoning is Typical Thinking:
• It thinks out a new relationship among the facts previously
observed and recalled at present.
• It is different from thinking of something, because it involves a
series of symbolic activities.
• When you reason, you call up some images, ideas or symbols,
which enable you to respond to absent stimuli.
• Thus, reasoning involves a sequence of symbolic activities
directed towards the solution of a problem, theoretical or
practical.
Reasoning: Characteristics
Reasoning is Mental Exploration:
• It finds a new relationship among the data perceived or recalled.
It is a substitute for motor exploration. Suppose, you have lost
your way in a new place. You may explore the different ways by
actual movements. Or you may sit down and think.
• You may explore the novel situation mentally and try to find out
a clue. By following one clue after another you may at last find
out the right way which will lead you to your destination.
Reasoning: Characteristics
Reasoning is Different from Trial-and-Error Behaviour:
• First, it does not involve motor exploration. The present
environment is not actually explored in reasoning. Secondly, the
leads to the goal are not always actually observed. They are
recalled from past experience. The clues are not actually
manipulated but thought out for the solution of the problem.
Reasoning: Characteristics
Reasoning as a Conative Tendency:
• McDougall holds that reasoning involves a conative tendency, a
desire to know the answer to a question, which may spring from
the instinct of curiosity. The desire selects the relevant material
to facilitate the drawing of the right conclusion. This selectivity
is an important factor of reasoning. It is the essence of
intelligent adaptation.
Reasoning: Types
Inductive reasoning:
• It is a specialized thinking aimed at the discovery or
construction of a generalized principle by making use of
particular cases, special examples and identifying of elements or
relations.
• For example, Mohan is mortal, Radha is mortal, Karim is
mortal; therefore, all human beings are mortal.
Reasoning: Types
Deductive reasoning:
• It is the ability to draw some logical conclusions from known
statement or evidences. Here one starts with already known or
established generalized statement or principle and applies it to
specific cases. For example, all human beings are mortal you are
a human being, therefore, you are mortal.
Reasoning: Types of Deductive
Reasoning
Conditioned reasoning:
• It is the reasoning tied down by some specific condition such as
the following.
• For example, if there is a solar eclipse, the street will be dark.
There is a solar eclipse
• ... The streets are dark.
Reasoning: Types of Deductive
Reasoning
Categorical reasoning:
• This type of reasoning is based on some categorical statements.
• For example, all Robins are birds.
• All birds lay eggs.
• ... All Robins lay eggs.
Reasoning: Types of Deductive
Reasoning
Linear reasoning:
• This type of reasoning involves straight forward relationships
among elements.
• For example, If Ram is taller than Mohan and Mohan is taller
than Sohan, Ram is the tallest.
Process of Reasoning
The process of reasoning contains the following parts:
(a) Gathering the data or facts or judgements.
(b) Combining the data or inter-relating them to one another.
(c) Seeing the implications of the combined data or drawing a
new conclusion from the combined data.
(d) Testing the conclusion so reached.
Improving Reasoning Skills in Sts.
• Pose thoughtful or insightful questions and intentionally allow
10–15 seconds of silence to elapse before calling on students to
respond. Cognitive science research has shown that a pause of
this length is necessary for the human brain to sufficiently
process a question and formulate a reasonable response.
Improving Reasoning Skills in Sts.
• Work from example to theory. Discuss the examples in the text
first, and then draw out the concepts they teach. This active
learning technique exercises students’ inductive reasoning skills
and promotes active engagement and inquisitiveness.
Improving Reasoning Skills in Sts.
• Use critical thinking vocabulary when posing questions to
students to reinforce conceptual understanding and promote
recognition of reasoning. Use the names of the skills and the
habits of mind that are found in the textbook. For example, use
phrases such as: “What is your reason for that claim?” “Let’s
interpret this statement,” “What inferences can we reasonably
draw from these facts?” and “Let’s be systematic in our
analysis.”
Improving Reasoning Skills in Sts.
• Acknowledge when students use critical thinking to promote
their self-awareness and recognition of reasoning (don’t forget
to use the critical thinking vocabulary). For example, use
phrases such as: “The claim you are making,” “The
inquisitiveness of this group was evident when,” “I agree with
your interpretation of,” and “In your analysis of.”
Improving Reasoning Skills in Sts.
• Avoid sloppy, misleading, and imprecise expressions such as:
“How do you feel about that?” and “What is your view of this?”
and even “What did you think of this?”
Improving Reasoning Skills in Sts.
Allow for different learning styles.
• Some children like to jump right in and mess around. Provide
these children with lots of open-ended materials to explore.
Other children are more comfortable watching an activity and
asking questions. Make sure there's plenty of time for them to
discuss what's happening.
Improving Reasoning Skills in Sts.
Stimulate children's curiosity and thinking skills.
Offer a range of intriguing manipulatives. For example, ask
children to compare colored rods by size and string beads to
create patterns. Point out cause-and-effect relationships. As they
add an egg to flour during cooking experiments, ask, "What might
happen next?" Use open-ended questions to support estimating
and predicting.
Improving Reasoning Skills in Sts.
Offer thinking challenges throughout the day.
• As children put away blocks and books during cleanup time,
encourage them to classify objects. Invite them to compare
quantities while playing in their classroom grocery store.
Remember…
•Nothing changes until you change.

Reasoning

  • 1.
  • 2.
    Reasoning: Definitions • “Reasoningis a stepwise thinking with a purpose or goal in mind” —Garrett. • “Reasoning is the term applied to highly purposeful, controlled and selective thinking”—Gates. • “Reasoning is the word used to describe the mental recognition of cause-and-effect relationships, it may be the prediction of an event from an observed cause or the inference of a cause from an observed event”—Skinner.
  • 3.
    Reasoning: Characteristics Reasoning isTypical Thinking: • It thinks out a new relationship among the facts previously observed and recalled at present. • It is different from thinking of something, because it involves a series of symbolic activities. • When you reason, you call up some images, ideas or symbols, which enable you to respond to absent stimuli. • Thus, reasoning involves a sequence of symbolic activities directed towards the solution of a problem, theoretical or practical.
  • 4.
    Reasoning: Characteristics Reasoning isMental Exploration: • It finds a new relationship among the data perceived or recalled. It is a substitute for motor exploration. Suppose, you have lost your way in a new place. You may explore the different ways by actual movements. Or you may sit down and think. • You may explore the novel situation mentally and try to find out a clue. By following one clue after another you may at last find out the right way which will lead you to your destination.
  • 5.
    Reasoning: Characteristics Reasoning isDifferent from Trial-and-Error Behaviour: • First, it does not involve motor exploration. The present environment is not actually explored in reasoning. Secondly, the leads to the goal are not always actually observed. They are recalled from past experience. The clues are not actually manipulated but thought out for the solution of the problem.
  • 6.
    Reasoning: Characteristics Reasoning asa Conative Tendency: • McDougall holds that reasoning involves a conative tendency, a desire to know the answer to a question, which may spring from the instinct of curiosity. The desire selects the relevant material to facilitate the drawing of the right conclusion. This selectivity is an important factor of reasoning. It is the essence of intelligent adaptation.
  • 7.
    Reasoning: Types Inductive reasoning: •It is a specialized thinking aimed at the discovery or construction of a generalized principle by making use of particular cases, special examples and identifying of elements or relations. • For example, Mohan is mortal, Radha is mortal, Karim is mortal; therefore, all human beings are mortal.
  • 8.
    Reasoning: Types Deductive reasoning: •It is the ability to draw some logical conclusions from known statement or evidences. Here one starts with already known or established generalized statement or principle and applies it to specific cases. For example, all human beings are mortal you are a human being, therefore, you are mortal.
  • 9.
    Reasoning: Types ofDeductive Reasoning Conditioned reasoning: • It is the reasoning tied down by some specific condition such as the following. • For example, if there is a solar eclipse, the street will be dark. There is a solar eclipse • ... The streets are dark.
  • 10.
    Reasoning: Types ofDeductive Reasoning Categorical reasoning: • This type of reasoning is based on some categorical statements. • For example, all Robins are birds. • All birds lay eggs. • ... All Robins lay eggs.
  • 11.
    Reasoning: Types ofDeductive Reasoning Linear reasoning: • This type of reasoning involves straight forward relationships among elements. • For example, If Ram is taller than Mohan and Mohan is taller than Sohan, Ram is the tallest.
  • 12.
    Process of Reasoning Theprocess of reasoning contains the following parts: (a) Gathering the data or facts or judgements. (b) Combining the data or inter-relating them to one another. (c) Seeing the implications of the combined data or drawing a new conclusion from the combined data. (d) Testing the conclusion so reached.
  • 13.
    Improving Reasoning Skillsin Sts. • Pose thoughtful or insightful questions and intentionally allow 10–15 seconds of silence to elapse before calling on students to respond. Cognitive science research has shown that a pause of this length is necessary for the human brain to sufficiently process a question and formulate a reasonable response.
  • 14.
    Improving Reasoning Skillsin Sts. • Work from example to theory. Discuss the examples in the text first, and then draw out the concepts they teach. This active learning technique exercises students’ inductive reasoning skills and promotes active engagement and inquisitiveness.
  • 15.
    Improving Reasoning Skillsin Sts. • Use critical thinking vocabulary when posing questions to students to reinforce conceptual understanding and promote recognition of reasoning. Use the names of the skills and the habits of mind that are found in the textbook. For example, use phrases such as: “What is your reason for that claim?” “Let’s interpret this statement,” “What inferences can we reasonably draw from these facts?” and “Let’s be systematic in our analysis.”
  • 16.
    Improving Reasoning Skillsin Sts. • Acknowledge when students use critical thinking to promote their self-awareness and recognition of reasoning (don’t forget to use the critical thinking vocabulary). For example, use phrases such as: “The claim you are making,” “The inquisitiveness of this group was evident when,” “I agree with your interpretation of,” and “In your analysis of.”
  • 17.
    Improving Reasoning Skillsin Sts. • Avoid sloppy, misleading, and imprecise expressions such as: “How do you feel about that?” and “What is your view of this?” and even “What did you think of this?”
  • 18.
    Improving Reasoning Skillsin Sts. Allow for different learning styles. • Some children like to jump right in and mess around. Provide these children with lots of open-ended materials to explore. Other children are more comfortable watching an activity and asking questions. Make sure there's plenty of time for them to discuss what's happening.
  • 19.
    Improving Reasoning Skillsin Sts. Stimulate children's curiosity and thinking skills. Offer a range of intriguing manipulatives. For example, ask children to compare colored rods by size and string beads to create patterns. Point out cause-and-effect relationships. As they add an egg to flour during cooking experiments, ask, "What might happen next?" Use open-ended questions to support estimating and predicting.
  • 20.
    Improving Reasoning Skillsin Sts. Offer thinking challenges throughout the day. • As children put away blocks and books during cleanup time, encourage them to classify objects. Invite them to compare quantities while playing in their classroom grocery store.
  • 21.