This document provides a summary of a student project that aims to optimize land use along a proposed metro corridor in Zone N of Delhi through a transit-oriented development approach. The objectives are to examine the impact of the metro lines on zoning plans, prioritize land uses within metro station influence zones, and understand if higher floor area ratios can support the envisioned land uses. The methodology includes literature reviews, case studies, land use modeling, and stakeholder consultations. Key aspects analyzed are sustainable vs. unsustainable development near metro stations, land use transportation modeling, proposed development scenarios, and indicators to measure success. The project findings can help redefine sustainability and liveability through optimized compact mixed-use development around metro stations.
Presentación durante el evento de BRT2TOD de 2013 de la Universidad de los Andes, sobre cómo se puede planear, pagar y pensar el desarrollo orientado al transporte público en una ciudad.
Fecha: 11 de Julio de 2013
Lugar: Bogotá
Hiroaki Suzuki presents on land value capture and the ways that this innovative financing mechanism can be used to fund transit-oriented development, with the ultimate goal of enhancing urban sustainability.
Transforming Transportation 2015: Smart Cities for Shared Prosperity is the annual conference co-organized by the World Resources Institute and the World Bank.
Architecture and Town Planning _Unit 6_SPPU_Spacial Township, SEZ, CRZ, Smart...Shrikant Kate
Savitribai Phule Pune University
Board of Studies in Civil Engineering
B. E. Civil 2015 COURSE (w. e. f. June 2018)
401004 Elective I (4)- Architecture and Town Planning
Architecture and town planning _Unit 3_SPPU_Spacial Township, SEZ, CRZ, Smart City, AMRUT, GIS, GPS and RS in Planning by S. R. Kate
Unit VI:
• Special townships, SEZ, CRZ, Smart City, AMRUT Guidelines
• Application of GIS, GPS, remote sensing in planning.
Urban Sprawl and its Impact on Urban EnvironmentIOSR Journals
This Paper an attempt has been made to examine the urban sprawl of Gorakhpur City through the land sat Images . Remote sensing and GIS to analyze the urban sprawl mapping and detect changes of urban sprawl of Gorakhpur city through different year. Satellite data are found to be useful in mapping and quantifying the extent of urban area in different time periods. New urban region development growing largely towards north, north-west and south-west direction along the main transport route of the city. New urban development occurs mainly on vegetation and agricultural land. This study provides a methodology for better estimation of urban growth and population using various land sat images with time. Geographical information system(GIS) and satellite images have been used in this study to provide spatial inputs and test the statistical model describing growth. This is useful for the urban planning in Developing Countries where land use data is not available regularly. GIS and Rescan help a lot in monitoring urban sprawl compared to Conventional technique
Self Sustainable Integrated Township : A resource-base planning to improve th...Sahil Singh Kapoor
The objective of this study is to analyze the potential shift towards Integrated Township developmentwith mixed land use, creating employment opportunities close to residential place and requiring minimum land area.
Transforming Transportation 2015: Smart Cities for Shared Prosperity is the annual conference co-organized by the World Resources Institute and the World Bank.
Presentación durante el evento de BRT2TOD de 2013 de la Universidad de los Andes, sobre cómo se puede planear, pagar y pensar el desarrollo orientado al transporte público en una ciudad.
Fecha: 11 de Julio de 2013
Lugar: Bogotá
Hiroaki Suzuki presents on land value capture and the ways that this innovative financing mechanism can be used to fund transit-oriented development, with the ultimate goal of enhancing urban sustainability.
Transforming Transportation 2015: Smart Cities for Shared Prosperity is the annual conference co-organized by the World Resources Institute and the World Bank.
Architecture and Town Planning _Unit 6_SPPU_Spacial Township, SEZ, CRZ, Smart...Shrikant Kate
Savitribai Phule Pune University
Board of Studies in Civil Engineering
B. E. Civil 2015 COURSE (w. e. f. June 2018)
401004 Elective I (4)- Architecture and Town Planning
Architecture and town planning _Unit 3_SPPU_Spacial Township, SEZ, CRZ, Smart City, AMRUT, GIS, GPS and RS in Planning by S. R. Kate
Unit VI:
• Special townships, SEZ, CRZ, Smart City, AMRUT Guidelines
• Application of GIS, GPS, remote sensing in planning.
Urban Sprawl and its Impact on Urban EnvironmentIOSR Journals
This Paper an attempt has been made to examine the urban sprawl of Gorakhpur City through the land sat Images . Remote sensing and GIS to analyze the urban sprawl mapping and detect changes of urban sprawl of Gorakhpur city through different year. Satellite data are found to be useful in mapping and quantifying the extent of urban area in different time periods. New urban region development growing largely towards north, north-west and south-west direction along the main transport route of the city. New urban development occurs mainly on vegetation and agricultural land. This study provides a methodology for better estimation of urban growth and population using various land sat images with time. Geographical information system(GIS) and satellite images have been used in this study to provide spatial inputs and test the statistical model describing growth. This is useful for the urban planning in Developing Countries where land use data is not available regularly. GIS and Rescan help a lot in monitoring urban sprawl compared to Conventional technique
Self Sustainable Integrated Township : A resource-base planning to improve th...Sahil Singh Kapoor
The objective of this study is to analyze the potential shift towards Integrated Township developmentwith mixed land use, creating employment opportunities close to residential place and requiring minimum land area.
Transforming Transportation 2015: Smart Cities for Shared Prosperity is the annual conference co-organized by the World Resources Institute and the World Bank.
Presentation at TOD training program by ADB - covering TOD basics, 5 TOD principles, What is TOD, Sustainability, Delhi, Bangaluru, ADB, ADB training, National TOD Policy, Pedestrian, Walkability, NMT, Non motorized transport, Women Safety, Setbacks, Women friendly environment, women oriented urban design, urban design, urban planning, Street safety, natural surveillance, Connectivity, Network planning, Pedshed analysis, multimodal integration, Form Based Codes, DDA, IRSDC, MOHUA, Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs, Railways, Delhi Development Authority, Karol Bagh, Ajmal Khan, Pedestrianization, Affordable Housing, Karkadooma, Recycling, Daylighting, Energy modeling
Transit Oriented Development and Land Value Capture: A Concept NoteHarshada Chavan
An optimal TOD scenario to reduce negative transportation impacts and enhance land value. The value generated will be captured using the Land Value Capture (LVC) mechanism, which could be utilized as a sustainable source of funding.
Multimodal in rail development: popularity and reaping benefitsAtkins
Dr Ghassan Ziadat, Atkins’ director of planning and infrastructure, looks in depth at transport planning, multimodal transportation and transit oriented developments. Ghassan believes that clear government direction, through policy and legislation, remains essential to ensure the consistent and effective adoption of multimodal transportation and transit orientated developments (TODs) in the Middle East’s major cities.
This presentation was first delivered in March 2014 at Infrastructure Outlook 2014, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia.
To assess the risks involved in BOT PROJECT by studying a specific case of Implementation of
integrated road development program me(IRDP) in the city on built, operate & transport (BOT) basis. To Study
the individualistic approach of the involved parties.
BOT has been one of the recent innovations in project finance. The Build-Operate-Transfer (BOT) scheme is a
limited recourse financing technique. Many have adopted this approach as an alternative to traditional public
financing for infrastructure development projects.
This study examines the type of SOCIAL risk due to, force shutdown of toll booths due to public riots .This paper
mainly representing therisk inBOT due to political & public pressure. A case study of IRDP project
implemented in municipal corporation area through BOT is studied in detail
This Presentation shows a comparative study of 5 construction projects in India & abroad enabling us to understand the process of conducting Pre-Project feasibility analysis.
Transforming the Urban Space through TOD: The 3V Approach
Presentation_Sahil Singh_26.11.15
1. Optimization of Land use along the
proposed Metro corridor in Zone- „N‟ of
the Delhi
A paradigm shift in Urban Planning...
Sahil Singh kapoor
M.Tech, major Project Part 1
TERI University, New Delhi
Final Presentation
27th November 2015
2. Contents
1
• INTRODUCTION: Brief on the NDMC, Department of Internship and Challenges
• BACKGROUND : Need for the Study and Literature review
• OBJECTIVES , RESEARCH QUESTIONS and METHODOLOGY
• SUSTAINABLE vs. UNSUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT
• MODELLING : LTSAP Approach
• DYNAMIC MODEL
• PROPOSED SCENARIO
• APPLICATIONS OF METRO INFLUENCE ZONE
• SMART CITY
• INDICATORS
• LEARNING OUTCOMES
3. INTRODUCTION : NORTH DELHI MUNICIPAL CORPROATION
2
• Department : TOWN PLANNNING, NDMC
• CHALLENGES IDENTIFIED –
• LAP approach is Bottom to Top approach with Public Participation as an
essential element.
Implementation of the 74th
Amendment
GNCTD has not been able to implement the 74th
Amendment. Vital decisions particularly in the
preparation and implementation of Master Plans and
related are taken by central agency, DDA
Local Area Plans (LAP) MCD has been a new system, LAP. But, LAP violates
the „Delhi Development Act, 1957‟ and amendments
required to existing Unified Building Byelaws of
Delhi.
4. BACKGROUND : NEED FOR THE STUDY
3
• Interaction with DDA officials reflected LACK OF CORDINATION among DDA
(Delhi Development Authority) and DMRC (Delhi Metro Rail Corporation)
particularly in the preparation of the Zonal Development Plans (ZDP) for the
URBAN EXTENSION AREAS, mostly unencumbered in nature and suitable for
Urban Development.
• CHAPTER 19 : TOD, MPD 2021- 19.4 : states the delineation and preparation
of Metro Influence Zones map from the centre of metro station. Further,
demarcation of TOD influence zone along the Metro corridor identified in the ZDP.
Figure – Location if Urban Extension areas in
Delhi, Source - http://image.slidesharecdn.com/
Figure – Urban Extension areas in Delhi,
Source – MPD 2021.
5. LITERATURE REVIEW
4
REPORTS : To develop study analysis framework
CASE STUDIES :
• Prioritizing land-use surrounding metro
system for optimization
• Land use modeling around Metro station.
6. BACKGROUND OF PROJECT
5
OBJECTIVES
The study has following objectives –
•To examine the impact of the proposed Metro corridor in Phase – 4& 5of MRTS on
the Zonal Development Plan of Zone - ‘N’.
•Prioritization of Detail Land uses in the delineated Influence zones falling within
Metro station influence (Maximum 500m on both sides) to encourage Transit Oriented
Development (TOD).
•To understand whether aspired Land uses and establishments envisaged around
the metro station can be reached by higher FAR guidelines of DDA which is an urban
development agency of Delhi.
RESEARCH QUESTION
•How a well envisaged compact planning with multiple land use within the
influence of metro corridor will control urban growth in urban extension areas of
Delhi?
7. METHODOLOGY
6
Population & Employment
Literature Review
ZDP of Zone- „N‟
Land use distribution
Internal /External Linkages
Proposed Facility/Utilities
Case Studies
Literature Review
DYNAMIC MODEL (EXCEL
SHEET)
Comments and
suggestions from
identified stakeholders
namely NMDC, DDA and
DMRC
REVIEW PROCESS
Reports & Guidelines
ANALYSIS OF
SECONDARY DATABASE
1
2
3
4
5
Conceptual 3D model
of Land use around
Metro station
3D MODELLING6
ANALYSIS
8. 7
JUXTAPOSE : ZONE M & N
SOURCE: ZDP,, DDA
Zone - M
Zone - N
Rithala Metro
station
Zone - L
10. 9
UNSUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT: METRO STATION
Source - http://tcpomud.gov.in/Divisions/MUTP/Visual_Study.pdf
Figure – Near Anand Vihar metro station, Unorganized parking
Figure – Near Laxmi Nagar Metro station,
Unorganized residential development
Figure – Near Laxmi Nagar Metro station,
Unorganized residential development
12. 11
SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT: METRO STATION
Figure - Stretch near IP metro station, Effective pedestrian movement
Source - http://tcpomud.gov.in/Divisions/MUTP/Visual_Study.pdf
13. MODELLING : LAND USE TRANSPORTATION STATION AREA PLAN
(LTSAP) , Chapter - 5
12
• Station area = 35m x 136m, delineating area of 500m around
the station is, 1035m x 1136m = 1.2 million square meters
(approx.) built up area.
• Nearly, 20-25% of the max. development potential area is
lost to road network. Remaining is 900,000 square meters
• If FAR of 400 is attained with 150m (335m x 436m), nearly
5,88,000 square meters of total Floor space area can be
reached. Further large plot size (Embarq, 2011) required to
achieve high FAR.
• Outside 150m, FAR range between 150 to 200
Zone 1 : Intense
Metro influence
Zone
Zone 2 : Standard
Metro influence
Zone
Zone 3 : Standard
Metro influence
Zone
Zone 4 :
Transition zone
Up to 150 meters
of Metro station
150 - 250 meters
of Metro station
250 - 500 meters
of Metro station
>500 meters of
Metro station
Zone 1 : Intense
Metro influence
Zone (<150m)
Zone 2 : Standard
Metro influence Zone
(150 - 250m)
Zone 3 : Standard Metro
influence Zone (250 -
500m)
14. 13
Criteria for locating Metro
stations –
• Junction of Metro lines
• High Densities
Commercial areas
• Intense mixed use
development areas
.
Zone – „M‟
Zone – „L‟
Zone – „N‟
Figure –
Interchange
junctions of Metro
lines, Source-
DMRC
15. 14
DYNAMIC LAND USE MODEL: EXCEL SHEET
OBJECTIVE : Land use as a function of DISTANCE from Metro station
LAND
USE
Zone 1 (<150m):
Intense zone
Zone 2 (150 - 250m) :
Standard zone
Zone 3 (250 - 500m) :
Standard zone
Zone 4 (>500m) :
Transition zone
Land use
distribution
(%),
Detail within
Land use
Land use
distribution
(%),
Detail within Land
use
Land use
distribution
(%),
Detail within Land
use
Land use
distribution
(%),
Detail within Land
use
Residential 5 – 10
(A), (B),
(D)
Res. With
Mixed land
use
15 – 20
(A), (D) Apartments, Group
Hosing
25 – 30
(D)
Societies, Group
Hosing
45 – 55 Plots
Commercial 25 - 30
(A),(B),
(D)
Retail Shops
15 – 20
(A), (D) City Center, CBD
10 – 15
(D)
Hotels, CC 4- 5 Informal Bazar ,
Banquets
Industrial 0 (A),(D) 0 (A), (D) 5 – 10
(D)
Small scale 4 – 5
Green areas 10 – 15
(A), (B),
(D)
Parks
15 – 20
(D)
District Park
15 – 20
(D)
District Park 15 – 20 City Parks
P & SP. 20-25
(A),(B)
Institutional,
Offices
15 – 20
(A), (D)
Hospital, College,
Offices
15 – 20
(A), (D)
Hospital,
Colleges
8 - 10 Hospital
Circulation 20- 25
(A), (B),
(D)
No parking
allowed
15 – 20
(A), (D)
Parking spaces,
Bus Stops
15 – 20
(A), (D)
Taxi Drop off 10 – 12 Car parking
facility
(A)- Transit Oriented Recommendations Report 2013, Bangalore
(B) - MRTS impacts on Land-use in Bangalore ( urbanmobilityindia.in)
(C) - Pan Hai Xi Ao, Shanghai city
(D) - L. Yang 2014
16. 15
COMMERCIAL •PUBLIC & SEMI PUBLIC,
RECREATIONAL
•RESIDENTIAL
•Private
Development
•Sports / Leisure •Plotted Development
•Community support facilities •High value Residential
•Small retail •School •Group Housing (3- 7)
•Small industries •Healthcare •Community centers
•Entrepreneurs •Sports facilities
•Mixed use •Affordable Housing
•SME‟s •Urban Park
•Retail Shops •Apartments (8-15 storey's)
•Shopping market •Entertainment/ Leisure
•Piazza
0-150m
150-250m
250-500m
500-1000m
ANALYSIS DYNAMIC LAND USE MODEL
17. 16
CASE STUDY of BANGALORE CITY: OPTIMIZATION OF LAND USE
AROUND METRO STATION USING LTSAP APPROACH
SOURCE: TORR, 2013
Figure 1 & 2 – Land use within catchment of Metro station
19. APPLICATION OF METRO INFLUENCE ZONES : METRO STATION
18
A comprehensive Influence Zonal plan (document) will provide a
framework for envisaged TOD development comprising following
components:
A. Urban Design framework – Recreational and Open Public
spaces, Internal street network, Net FAR with residential
densities(@ 250 pph), Vertical mix uses and parking spaces.
B. Transport Impact Assessment framework - Priority for
NMT/Public transport, Parking management strategy as per
demand, mitigation of traffic noise.
C. Decentralized Infrastructure – Rain water harvesting in Open
Public spaces and green areas, ISWM (Compost plant, Plastic to
fuel, Pellet making), Roof top Solar Potential (meeting 10%
energy requirement).
D. Economic viability and social cohesion – Land value capture,
FAR benefits, provision of affordable housing, revenue collection
20. SMART CITY : OPTIMIZE LAND USE
19
•Optimization of Land uses can Redefine Sustainability and Liveability.
•Short on Land : Optimize Land use can SAVE the valuable space lost to private
vehicles since Metro systems occupy comparatively LESS LAND.
• Tackle urban sprawl : In a Mixed Land use urban areas, people prefer Pedestrian
movements and public transit against private vehicles.
•Integration : Integrate different Motorized and Non Motorized Transport into
convenient, efficient, affordable, safe and green system.
22. INDICATORS
21SOURCE: niti.gov.in
Questions Indicators Formula / Input
Does Metro alignment with
the Land use plan for the
urban area?
Intensity of development
FAR along metro corridor
Average FAR along Metro
corridor / Average FAR in the
ZDP = 3 – 4/1.5 - 2
What is avg. distance
travelled for work?
Average commuting
distance to work?
Avg. distance from residential
areas to work : nearly 500m
(7min. Walk)
Efficiency in transport
operations
% of population with
commute time <25 min.
Population with commute
time<25 min / Total population
Mixed Land-use % of area under mixed
Land use
Total area under mixed-land
use/ Total area of municipality x
100
City’s Carbon footprint Per capita land devoted
to transport faculties
Total area devoted to transport
facilities / Total population
23. LEARNING OUTCOMES
22
•Optimization can be achieved by maximizing FAR, Compactness and Mixed use.
•Mandatory provision of 15% of the total FAR for EWS housing
•FAR bonus for market developments near Low income housing
•Government built Low income housing within 800m from Metro corridor.
•Features of TOD – Compact, Mixed land use development
Safety
Affordability
Equity
Transparency
Democracy
Employment
Attraction
Land value
increment
Entrepreneur
Air, Water
Quality
Climate
comfort
Cleanliness
SOCIAL
ENVIRONMENTAL
ECONOMIC
SUSTAINABLE
24. METRO SYSTEM ENVIRONMENTAL BENEFITS IN DELHI
23
The Delhi metro rail system came with the following environmental benefits at certain
identified places in Delhi –
•35% reduction in CO levels for the area around ITO which is a dominant traffic
intersection area in central Delhi (Study by CDE, April 2013)
•3 to 47% reduction in NO2 concentration (Study by CDE, April 2013)
•About 20- 25 percent of trips are shifting from private vehicles to Metro as an
effective public transport. (Central Road Research Institute (CRRI) assessment)
•After completion up to Phase 3, nearly 3, 90,970 vehicles in the year 2014 went off
the roads. (Central Road Research Institute (CRRI) assessment)
Further, introduction of metro system in the outward URBAN EXTENSION areas
of Delhi can reduce about 4 lakh vehicles on the roads, curtail annual fuel
consumption of about 2.76 lakh tonne and minimize pollutants by about 5.8 lakh
tonne a year (Indian express, April 9, 2015).
DMRC certified by UN as First metro rail in world to get “Carbon credits for
reducing GHG emissions” (HINDU, September 26, 2011)
25. 24
A city that outdistances man’s walking powers is a trap for man.
(Arnold J. Toynbee)
THANK YOU