Chapter 12 
Using Diagnostic Reading Measures
Why Do We Assess Reading? 
• It is a fundamental skill students need to be 
successful in a variety of areas 
• Need to know when instruction is working 
• Need to know when intervention is needed 
for certain students 
• Need to know how to intervene 
• A small group of students may need ongoing 
accommodation (e.g., screen-reading 
software)
History of Reading Instruction 
• Up until 1950s: Whole Word Instruction 
• After 1950: Increasing Evidence of the 
Importance of Phonics Instruction 
• Beginning in the 1970s: Recognition of the 
importance of teaching phonemic awareness 
as an early literacy skill 
• However, many still disregard research 
supporting phonics and phonemic awareness 
instruction
Skills Assessed by Diagnostic Reading 
Tests 
• Oral Reading 
• Reading Comprehension 
• Word-Attack 
• Word Recognition 
• Other Reading and Reading-Related Behaviors
Oral Reading 
• Rate of Reading 
• Reading Errors 
– Teacher pronunciation/aid 
– Hesitation 
– Gross mispronunciation 
– Partial mispronunciation 
– Omission 
– Insertion 
– Substitution 
– Repetition 
– Inversion
Reading Comprehension 
• Literal Comprehension 
• Inferential Comprehension 
• Critical Comprehension 
• Affective Comprehension 
• Lexical Comprehension
Word-Attack 
• Used to derive the pronunciation or meaning 
of a word through phonic analysis, structural 
analysis, or context cues
Word-Recognition 
• Ascertain a student’s sight vocabulary 
• Typically, with enough exposure, students will 
recognize a given word.
Other Reading-Related Skills 
• Vocabulary 
• Handwriting 
• Spelling 
• Auditory Discrimination
GRADE 
• Standardized, can be group administered 
• Provides a growth score 
• Large norm sample, but not all characteristics 
are provided 
• Total test score reliability is strong, subtests 
not as strong
DIBELS Next 
• Measures the following: phonemic awareness, 
alphabetic principle, advanced phonics, fluent 
reading, reading comprehension, and 
vocabulary 
• May be helpful as a screening tool; need 
multiple administrations for other purposes
TOPA-2+ 
• Measures early phonemic awareness and 
letter-sound correspondence for early 
elementary school students 
• Well-described norms 
• Reliability better for kindergarteners than 
more advanced students 
• Adequate evidence for validity

Pp ch12

  • 1.
    Chapter 12 UsingDiagnostic Reading Measures
  • 2.
    Why Do WeAssess Reading? • It is a fundamental skill students need to be successful in a variety of areas • Need to know when instruction is working • Need to know when intervention is needed for certain students • Need to know how to intervene • A small group of students may need ongoing accommodation (e.g., screen-reading software)
  • 3.
    History of ReadingInstruction • Up until 1950s: Whole Word Instruction • After 1950: Increasing Evidence of the Importance of Phonics Instruction • Beginning in the 1970s: Recognition of the importance of teaching phonemic awareness as an early literacy skill • However, many still disregard research supporting phonics and phonemic awareness instruction
  • 4.
    Skills Assessed byDiagnostic Reading Tests • Oral Reading • Reading Comprehension • Word-Attack • Word Recognition • Other Reading and Reading-Related Behaviors
  • 5.
    Oral Reading •Rate of Reading • Reading Errors – Teacher pronunciation/aid – Hesitation – Gross mispronunciation – Partial mispronunciation – Omission – Insertion – Substitution – Repetition – Inversion
  • 6.
    Reading Comprehension •Literal Comprehension • Inferential Comprehension • Critical Comprehension • Affective Comprehension • Lexical Comprehension
  • 7.
    Word-Attack • Usedto derive the pronunciation or meaning of a word through phonic analysis, structural analysis, or context cues
  • 8.
    Word-Recognition • Ascertaina student’s sight vocabulary • Typically, with enough exposure, students will recognize a given word.
  • 9.
    Other Reading-Related Skills • Vocabulary • Handwriting • Spelling • Auditory Discrimination
  • 10.
    GRADE • Standardized,can be group administered • Provides a growth score • Large norm sample, but not all characteristics are provided • Total test score reliability is strong, subtests not as strong
  • 11.
    DIBELS Next •Measures the following: phonemic awareness, alphabetic principle, advanced phonics, fluent reading, reading comprehension, and vocabulary • May be helpful as a screening tool; need multiple administrations for other purposes
  • 12.
    TOPA-2+ • Measuresearly phonemic awareness and letter-sound correspondence for early elementary school students • Well-described norms • Reliability better for kindergarteners than more advanced students • Adequate evidence for validity