Planning and Procurement
Management:
Transformers
Aman Jain
Prateek Duvedi
Ram Bangad
Sonik Garg
Vaibhav Agarwal
Varun Garg
Item Unit Unit/piece Price/Unit No. of Suppliers Power Total Cost
Aluminium Wire KG 100 225 5Company 22500
Insulation Paper KG 4 90 2Company 360
Core KG 240 190 3Company 45600
Clamp, Nut Bolt Pivot KG 12 65 10Company 780
Transformer Oil L 200 70 2Party 14000
Transformer Tank NO. 1 7500 2Company 7500
Drain Valve NO. 2 250 2Company 500
Oil gauge NO. 1 100 3Company 100
LT Bushing NO. 4 35 2Company 140
HT Bushing NO. 3 100 3Party 300
LT Connection Rod NO. 4 50 2Company 200
HT Connection Rod NO. 3 40 2Company 120
Paint L 1 250 8Company 250
Peeling Gasket/Cork Sheet M 6 40 3Company 240
Arcing Horn SET 3 30 3Company 90
Top Cover Nut-Bolt KG 4 75 4Company 300
Pressed paper board KG 7 110 3Company 770
Cotton Tape ROLL 2 35 4Company 70
Cleave M 5 2 4Company 10
Thimble NO. 8 25 3Company 200
Silica Gel Breather NO. 1 100 3Company 100
Gasket Set Set 7 20 3Company 140
Total 94270
Bill of Material (BOM)
Total Cost
of
Ownership
Labour
95,000
1000
1000
200
2000
100
10
100
200
20
Rs. 99,630
Kraljic Matrix
Importance
of purchasing
Complexity of supply market
LEVERAGE ITEM STRATEGIC ITEM
NON-CRITICAL ITEM
BOTTLENECK ITEM
Insulation Paper
Drain Valve
LT Bushing
Core
Transformer Oil
Aluminium wire
Transformation tank
Pressed paper board
Gasket set
Arcing Horn
Silica gel breather
1 3 5 71
3
1
5
1
7
1
9
9
Efficiency Heat
Dissipation
1 3 5 71
3
1
5
1
7
1
9
9
Efficiency Losses
1 3 5 71
3
1
5
1
7
1
9
9
Efficiency Bearing
Capacity
Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP)
Pair-wise Comparison:
Factors:
• Efficiency
• Heat Dissipation
• Losses
• Bearing Capacity
1 3 5 71
3
1
5
1
7
1
9
9
Heat
Dissipation
Losses
1 3 5 71
3
1
5
1
7
1
9
9
Heat
Dissipation
Bearing
Capacity
1 3 5 71
3
1
5
1
7
1
9
9
Losses
Bearing
Capacity
Continued…
1 3 5 7
1
3
1 3 5
1
5
1
3
1 3
1
7
1
5
1
3
1
Comparison Matrix
1 3 5 7
1
3
1 3 5
1
5
1
3
1 3
1
7
1
5
1
3
1
105
176
45
68
15
28
7
16
35
176
15
68
9
28
5
16
21
176
5
68
3
28
3
16
15
176
3
68
1
28
1
16
1
4
105
176
+
45
68
+
15
28
+
7
16
35
176
+
15
68
+
9
28
+
5
16
21
176
+
5
68
+
3
28
+
3
16
15
176
+
3
68
+
1
28
+
1
16
0.56
0.26
0.12
0.06
1
4
2.23
1.05
0.49
0.23
Continued…
176
105
68
15
28
3
16
→
Column Sums
, , , →
Dividing each element with
Sum of its column
→→
Normalized Principle Eigen Vector
Priority Vector
𝜆 max =
176
105
68
15
28
3
16X 0.56 X 0.26 X 0.12 X 0.06+ + + = 4.197
Consistency Index (CI) =
4.197− 4
4 −1
= 0.066
Consistency Ratio (CR) =
0.066
0.9
= 0.073 = 7.3%
CR < 10%
Functions of Transformer
Efficiency Heat Dissipation Less Losses Protection
Components Cost 40 20 25 15 100
Winding 22500
15000
20
7500
10
30
Core 45600
20000
15
15000
15
10600
5
35
Oil 14000
4000
5
10000
15
20
Tank 7500 2500
5
5000
10
15
89600 39000 12500 22500 15600
Value Analysis
WAREHOUSING
Green
Transformer
(Sustainable
procurement)
ABB’s line of distribution transformers can reduce operating costs, energy
bills and overall environmental impact?
The low-loss transformers can decrease electrical losses significantly. In fact,
if all transformers were replaced by amorphous metal core transformers, the
newest technology, distribution network losses could be reduced up to 70
percent.
These energy savings would ultimately mean lower operating costs and
reduced environmental impact.
As an added performance and environmental enhancement, our low-loss
transformers can be specified with our proprietary high temperature and
biodegradable insulation fluid.
ABB transformers with BIOTEMP fluid offer the optimum combination of
performance and safety.
Cost benefit
analysis(Total
ownership cost)
In light of global climate concerns, many users agree that low loss
transformers should be chosen on criteria other than pure short term
profitability aspects. When purchasing transformers
ABB recommends the use of total ownership cost (TOC) which considers
the future operating costs of a unit over its lifetime, brought back into
present day cost and then added to its total purchase price.
In calculating TOC, the losses are evaluated by their financial impact,
capitalized for an expected payback period for the transformer.
Where
Ct = Transformer purchase price
A = Assessed financial value (e.g., USD/W), or capitalization factor,
for no-load loss
B = Assessed financial value (e.g., USD/W), or
capitalization factor,
for load-loss P0 = No load Loss
Pk = Load Loss
T1= c1 +(A*p0) +(B*pk)
The equation
Continued….
•With low loss, high efficiency transformers, the
higher material cost typically requires a higher
first cost.
• However, this will be compensated by reduced
running costs from lower losses
•Beyond a certain time, the lower losses will give
a net financial saving from reduced energy costs.
If higher loss transformers are replaced with new
low loss transformers,
•This saving becomes even greater. Furthermore,
lower losses result in cost avoidance derived
from elimination or deferral of extra generation
and transmission capacity additions.
Tender Process-WESCO Odisha
Tender Process-WESCO
Odisha
Bidder
Qualification
Bidder
Qualification
Evaluation of Bids
a) Delivery Schedule.
b) Deviations from Bidding
Documents as mentioned in
Non-Compliance Schedule.
c) Past performance and
capability to execute the
contract.
d) Type test reports from CPRI/
NABL Accredited Laboratories.
Force Majeure
Standards
IS:5 : Colour for ready mixed paints
IS:325 : Three Phase Induction Motors
IS:335 : New insulating oil for transformers, switch gears
IS:1271 : Classification of insulating materials for electrical machinery and apparatus
in relation to their stability in services
IS:2026(Part I to IV) : Power Transformer
IS:2071 : Method of high voltage testing
IS:2099 : High voltage porcelain bushings
IS:2147 : Degree of protection
IS:2705 : Current Transformers
IS:3202 : Code of practice for climate proofing of electrical equipment
IS:3347 : Dimensions for porcelain Transformer Bushings
IS:3637 : Gas operated relays
IS:3639 : Fittings and accessories for power Transformers
IS:5561 : Electric Power Connectors
IS:6600/BS:CP’10:0 : Guide for loading of oil immersed Transformers
IS:10028 : Code of practice for selection, installation and maintenance of
transformers, Part I. II and III
C.B.I.P. Publication : Manual on Transformers
Thank You

Planning and Procurement in Transformers

  • 1.
    Planning and Procurement Management: Transformers AmanJain Prateek Duvedi Ram Bangad Sonik Garg Vaibhav Agarwal Varun Garg
  • 2.
    Item Unit Unit/piecePrice/Unit No. of Suppliers Power Total Cost Aluminium Wire KG 100 225 5Company 22500 Insulation Paper KG 4 90 2Company 360 Core KG 240 190 3Company 45600 Clamp, Nut Bolt Pivot KG 12 65 10Company 780 Transformer Oil L 200 70 2Party 14000 Transformer Tank NO. 1 7500 2Company 7500 Drain Valve NO. 2 250 2Company 500 Oil gauge NO. 1 100 3Company 100 LT Bushing NO. 4 35 2Company 140 HT Bushing NO. 3 100 3Party 300 LT Connection Rod NO. 4 50 2Company 200 HT Connection Rod NO. 3 40 2Company 120 Paint L 1 250 8Company 250 Peeling Gasket/Cork Sheet M 6 40 3Company 240 Arcing Horn SET 3 30 3Company 90 Top Cover Nut-Bolt KG 4 75 4Company 300 Pressed paper board KG 7 110 3Company 770 Cotton Tape ROLL 2 35 4Company 70 Cleave M 5 2 4Company 10 Thimble NO. 8 25 3Company 200 Silica Gel Breather NO. 1 100 3Company 100 Gasket Set Set 7 20 3Company 140 Total 94270 Bill of Material (BOM)
  • 3.
  • 4.
    Kraljic Matrix Importance of purchasing Complexityof supply market LEVERAGE ITEM STRATEGIC ITEM NON-CRITICAL ITEM BOTTLENECK ITEM Insulation Paper Drain Valve LT Bushing Core Transformer Oil Aluminium wire Transformation tank Pressed paper board Gasket set Arcing Horn Silica gel breather
  • 5.
    1 3 571 3 1 5 1 7 1 9 9 Efficiency Heat Dissipation 1 3 5 71 3 1 5 1 7 1 9 9 Efficiency Losses 1 3 5 71 3 1 5 1 7 1 9 9 Efficiency Bearing Capacity Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) Pair-wise Comparison: Factors: • Efficiency • Heat Dissipation • Losses • Bearing Capacity
  • 6.
    1 3 571 3 1 5 1 7 1 9 9 Heat Dissipation Losses 1 3 5 71 3 1 5 1 7 1 9 9 Heat Dissipation Bearing Capacity 1 3 5 71 3 1 5 1 7 1 9 9 Losses Bearing Capacity Continued… 1 3 5 7 1 3 1 3 5 1 5 1 3 1 3 1 7 1 5 1 3 1 Comparison Matrix
  • 7.
    1 3 57 1 3 1 3 5 1 5 1 3 1 3 1 7 1 5 1 3 1 105 176 45 68 15 28 7 16 35 176 15 68 9 28 5 16 21 176 5 68 3 28 3 16 15 176 3 68 1 28 1 16 1 4 105 176 + 45 68 + 15 28 + 7 16 35 176 + 15 68 + 9 28 + 5 16 21 176 + 5 68 + 3 28 + 3 16 15 176 + 3 68 + 1 28 + 1 16 0.56 0.26 0.12 0.06 1 4 2.23 1.05 0.49 0.23 Continued… 176 105 68 15 28 3 16 → Column Sums , , , → Dividing each element with Sum of its column →→ Normalized Principle Eigen Vector Priority Vector
  • 8.
    𝜆 max = 176 105 68 15 28 3 16X0.56 X 0.26 X 0.12 X 0.06+ + + = 4.197 Consistency Index (CI) = 4.197− 4 4 −1 = 0.066 Consistency Ratio (CR) = 0.066 0.9 = 0.073 = 7.3% CR < 10%
  • 9.
    Functions of Transformer EfficiencyHeat Dissipation Less Losses Protection Components Cost 40 20 25 15 100 Winding 22500 15000 20 7500 10 30 Core 45600 20000 15 15000 15 10600 5 35 Oil 14000 4000 5 10000 15 20 Tank 7500 2500 5 5000 10 15 89600 39000 12500 22500 15600 Value Analysis
  • 10.
  • 11.
    Green Transformer (Sustainable procurement) ABB’s line ofdistribution transformers can reduce operating costs, energy bills and overall environmental impact? The low-loss transformers can decrease electrical losses significantly. In fact, if all transformers were replaced by amorphous metal core transformers, the newest technology, distribution network losses could be reduced up to 70 percent. These energy savings would ultimately mean lower operating costs and reduced environmental impact. As an added performance and environmental enhancement, our low-loss transformers can be specified with our proprietary high temperature and biodegradable insulation fluid. ABB transformers with BIOTEMP fluid offer the optimum combination of performance and safety.
  • 12.
    Cost benefit analysis(Total ownership cost) Inlight of global climate concerns, many users agree that low loss transformers should be chosen on criteria other than pure short term profitability aspects. When purchasing transformers ABB recommends the use of total ownership cost (TOC) which considers the future operating costs of a unit over its lifetime, brought back into present day cost and then added to its total purchase price. In calculating TOC, the losses are evaluated by their financial impact, capitalized for an expected payback period for the transformer. Where Ct = Transformer purchase price A = Assessed financial value (e.g., USD/W), or capitalization factor, for no-load loss B = Assessed financial value (e.g., USD/W), or capitalization factor, for load-loss P0 = No load Loss Pk = Load Loss T1= c1 +(A*p0) +(B*pk) The equation
  • 13.
    Continued…. •With low loss,high efficiency transformers, the higher material cost typically requires a higher first cost. • However, this will be compensated by reduced running costs from lower losses •Beyond a certain time, the lower losses will give a net financial saving from reduced energy costs. If higher loss transformers are replaced with new low loss transformers, •This saving becomes even greater. Furthermore, lower losses result in cost avoidance derived from elimination or deferral of extra generation and transmission capacity additions.
  • 14.
  • 15.
  • 16.
  • 17.
  • 18.
    Evaluation of Bids a)Delivery Schedule. b) Deviations from Bidding Documents as mentioned in Non-Compliance Schedule. c) Past performance and capability to execute the contract. d) Type test reports from CPRI/ NABL Accredited Laboratories.
  • 19.
  • 20.
    Standards IS:5 : Colourfor ready mixed paints IS:325 : Three Phase Induction Motors IS:335 : New insulating oil for transformers, switch gears IS:1271 : Classification of insulating materials for electrical machinery and apparatus in relation to their stability in services IS:2026(Part I to IV) : Power Transformer IS:2071 : Method of high voltage testing IS:2099 : High voltage porcelain bushings IS:2147 : Degree of protection IS:2705 : Current Transformers IS:3202 : Code of practice for climate proofing of electrical equipment IS:3347 : Dimensions for porcelain Transformer Bushings IS:3637 : Gas operated relays IS:3639 : Fittings and accessories for power Transformers IS:5561 : Electric Power Connectors IS:6600/BS:CP’10:0 : Guide for loading of oil immersed Transformers IS:10028 : Code of practice for selection, installation and maintenance of transformers, Part I. II and III C.B.I.P. Publication : Manual on Transformers
  • 21.