Next	
  Genera*on	
  Mobile	
  Banking	
  
	
                            ©2011 Clairmail Confidential. Contains Proprietary Information. Not for Distribution.
Agenda

•    Key Trends in Mobile
•    Benchmarks for Mobile Banking – Europe
•    Benchmarks for Mobile Banking – ROW
•    Channel Growth Considerations




               ©2011 Clairmail Confidential. Contains Proprietary Information. Not for Distribution.
Key	
  Trends	
  in	
  Mobile	
  
                                    ©2011 Clairmail Confidential. Contains Proprietary Information. Not for Distribution.
Key Trends in Mobile Banking
    •  La Caixa
       http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gf5Qa89QAI8




4                   ©2011 Clairmail Confidential. Contains Proprietary Information. Not for Distribution.
Mobile	
  banking	
  dates	
  back	
  to	
  2001	
  


           2001	
                                                      2002	
  




                                                          Aug	
  2001	
                                        Apr	
  2002	
  
           Feb	
  2001	
                                                                                     SEB	
  (Estonia)	
  
    La	
  Caixa	
  launches	
                               HSBC	
  	
  
                                                        launches	
  SMS	
                                    launches	
  P2P	
  
          GPRS-­‐based	
                                                                                    payments	
  using	
  
     mobile	
  internet	
                                 alerts	
  and	
  
                                                         no*fica*ons	
                                               SMS	
  
            banking	
  

                                                                                                                               Dec	
  2002	
  
                                                                                                                             Santander	
  and	
  
                                                                                 Jan	
  2002	
                                BBVA	
  launch	
  
                                    Mar	
  2001	
  
                                                                               Nordea	
  launch	
                               Mobipay	
  
                                    Bankinter	
  
                                                                                “always	
  on”	
                            payments	
  scheme	
  
                                  launches	
  SMS	
  
                                                                              mobile	
  banking	
  in	
                         in	
  Spain	
  
                                    alerts	
  and	
  
                                                                                  Finland	
  
                                   no*fica*ons	
  




5
Mobile	
  banking	
  1.0	
  primarily	
  focused	
  on	
  extending	
  OLB	
  	
  



                 Mobile	
           •  No*fica*ons	
  and	
  alerts	
  
                 banking	
          •  Account	
  management	
  
                   1.0	
            •  SMS-­‐based	
  payments	
  




6
Key	
  trends	
  in	
  mobile:	
  From	
  mobile	
  banking	
  1.0	
  to	
  next-­‐
    genera*on	
  



         Mobile	
                    Distribu*on	
                  Payment	
  
       banking	
  1.0	
                channel	
                    method	
  




                                                                                   Mobile	
  
                        Standalone	
               Standalone	
                    driving	
  
                          channel	
                 business	
                     digital	
  
                                                                                  strategy	
  



7
Challenges	
  driving	
  this	
  mobile	
  banking	
  evolu*on	
  

                                   Technology	
  

                                                         Customer	
  
                 Regula*on	
  
                                                         behavior	
  

                                     Growing	
  
                                    pressure	
  on	
  
                                     OPEX	
  and	
  
                                      margins	
  




                    Mobile	
  centric	
  innova*on	
  focused	
  
                       on	
  differen*a*ng	
  services	
  
8
Benchmarks	
  for	
  Innova*on	
  -­‐	
  Europe	
  
                                 ©2011 Clairmail Confidential. Contains Proprietary Information. Not for Distribution.
Mobile	
  as	
  a	
  standalone	
  channel-­‐	
  La	
  Caixa	
  




10
Mobile	
  as	
  a	
  standalone	
  channel-­‐	
  La	
  Caixa	
  




11
Mobile	
  as	
  a	
  standalone	
  channel-­‐	
  Akbank	
  

                                      •  SMS	
  and	
  Mobile	
  internet	
  
                                         managed	
  with	
  their	
  own	
  P&L,	
  
                                         and	
  embedded	
  within	
  a	
  more	
  
                                         tradi*onal	
  channel	
  structure	
  

                                      •  SMS	
  branch	
  genera*ng	
  over	
  
                                         $1	
  million/month	
  through	
  
                                         service	
  fees,	
  transac*on	
  fees,	
  
                                         and	
  mobile	
  specific	
  products	
  

                                      •  Mobile	
  internet	
  mone*zed	
  
                                         through	
  efficiency	
  gains;	
  low	
  
                                         value	
  transac*ons	
  migrated	
  
                                         from	
  more	
  expensive	
  channels	
  
12
Mobile as a distribution channel- Danske Bank

                                                             •  Smartphone	
  prolifera*on	
  has	
  
                                                                driven	
  adop*on	
  to	
  point	
  
                                                                where	
  it	
  is	
  now	
  considered	
  a	
  
                                                                “full	
  blown	
  channel”	
  

                                                             •  Currently	
  broadening	
  depth	
  
                                                                and	
  reach	
  of	
  mobile	
  services	
  to	
  
                                                                include	
  instant	
  loans	
  and	
  
                                                                mobile	
  brokerage	
  

                                                             •  Features	
  enhancement	
  
                                                                focused	
  on	
  introducing	
  
                                                                biometrics	
  and	
  CRM-­‐driven	
  
                                                                offers	
  

13            ©2011 Clairmail Confidential. Contains Proprietary Information. Not for Distribution.
Mobile	
  as	
  a	
  distribu*on	
  channel-­‐	
  Akbank	
  

                                      •  Akbank	
  began	
  distribu*ng	
  
                                         loans	
  on	
  mobile	
  telephones	
  in	
  
                                         2005	
  through	
  their	
  WAP	
  portal	
  

                                      •  Distribu*on	
  has	
  evolved	
  to	
  
                                         include	
  smartphone	
  apps,	
  SMS	
  
                                         and	
  banner	
  ads	
  at	
  non-­‐bank	
  
                                         mobile	
  internet	
  proper*es	
  and	
  
                                         applica*ons	
  

                                      •  Garan*Bank	
  and	
  YapiCredi,	
  
                                         among	
  others,	
  responded	
  by	
  
                                         incorpora*ng	
  similar	
  features	
  
                                         to	
  their	
  mobile	
  banking	
  service	
  
14
Mobile	
  as	
  a	
  distribu*on	
  channel-­‐	
  Bankinter	
  

                                      •  Relevant,	
  contextual	
  offers	
  
                                         pushed	
  to	
  the	
  mobile	
  phone	
  
                                         through	
  messaging	
  pladorm,	
  
                                         triggered	
  by	
  credit	
  card/debit	
  
                                         card	
  purchases	
  

                                      •  ≈	
  3%	
  opt-­‐in	
  rate	
  for	
  most	
  
                                         successful	
  offers,	
  at	
  a	
  
                                         significantly	
  lower	
  distribu*on	
  
                                         cost	
  than	
  tradi*onal	
  channels	
  

                                      •  Most	
  successful	
  with	
  low	
  
                                         value,	
  high	
  margin	
  products	
  
                                         such	
  as	
  consumer	
  finance,	
  
                                         travel	
  insurance,	
  etc.	
  	
  
15
Mobile	
  as	
  a	
  standalone	
  business-­‐	
  Bankinter	
  
                                   •  Bankinter	
  partnered	
  with	
  KPN	
  in	
  
                                      2007	
  to	
  distribute	
  SIM-­‐cards	
  under	
  
                                      a	
  branded	
  reseller	
  agreement	
  

                                   •  ≈10%	
  of	
  addressable	
  market	
  
                                      currently	
  using	
  Bankinter	
  SIM	
  card	
  	
  

                                   •  Ini*al	
  value	
  proposi*on	
  included	
  
                                        free	
  SMS	
  and	
  mobile	
  internet	
  
                                        banking	
  to	
  s*mulate	
  channel	
  
                                        adop*on	
  (3x	
  greater	
  among	
  MVNO	
  
                                        customers)	
  
                                   	
  
                                   •  Began	
  pilo*ng	
  NFC	
  through	
  its	
  own	
  
                                        MVNO	
  using	
  a	
  SIM-­‐based	
  solu*on	
  
16
Mobile	
  as	
  a	
  payment	
  method-­‐	
  La	
  Caixa	
  
                                        •  In	
  2010,	
  La	
  Caixa	
  coordinated	
  a	
  
                                           SIM-­‐based	
  NFC	
  mobile	
  
                                           payment	
  trial	
  in	
  Spain,	
  
                                           enabling	
  customers	
  and	
  
                                           merchants	
  with	
  proper	
  
                                           infrastructure	
  

                                        •  Results	
  included	
  +30%	
  increase	
  
                                           in	
  transac*ons	
  and	
  +23%	
  in	
  
                                           billing	
  during	
  trial	
  

                                        •  Next	
  steps	
  included	
  
                                           commercial	
  rollout	
  which	
  
                                           began	
  in	
  May	
  2011	
  

17
Mobile	
  driving	
  digital	
  strategy	
  
 •  New	
  business	
  areas	
  introduced	
  to	
  mobile,	
  
    star*ng	
  with	
  brokerage	
  and	
  business	
  banking	
  
 •  Augmented-­‐reality	
  being	
  used	
  for	
  discovery	
  
 •  Tablet-­‐specific	
  sites	
  and	
  applica*ons	
  centered	
  
    around	
  account	
  management	
  (PFM-­‐like	
  features)	
  	
  
 •  Biometrics	
  and	
  security	
  being	
  introduced	
  	
  
 •  SmartTV	
  applica*ons	
  prototyped	
  and	
  launched	
  




18
Mobile	
  driving	
  digital	
  strategy-­‐	
  Banco	
  Sabadell	
  


                                      •  Currently	
  at	
  70%	
  SMS	
  and	
  14%	
  
                                         web	
  /	
  app	
  adop*on	
  (as	
  %	
  of	
  OLB);	
  
                                         targe*ng	
  30%	
  by	
  YE	
  2013	
  	
  

                                      •  Increase	
  will	
  be	
  primarily	
  driven	
  by	
  
                                         broadened	
  device	
  reach	
  and	
  
                                         enhanced	
  mobile	
  features	
  

                                      •  Device	
  strategy	
  now	
  includes	
  
                                         tablets	
  and	
  Windows	
  Phone	
  

                                      •  Broadened	
  features	
  with	
  
                                         introduc*on	
  of	
  mobile	
  brokerage	
  
                                         apps	
  and	
  RDC	
  

19
Benchmarks	
  for	
  Innova*on	
  -­‐	
  ROW	
  
                                 ©2011 Clairmail Confidential. Contains Proprietary Information. Not for Distribution.
Mobile as a standalone channel- Wells Fargo




21           ©2011 Clairmail Confidential. Contains Proprietary Information. Not for Distribution.
Mobile as a distribution channel- Information
                            Check	
                                          Low	
  
                           Cleared	
                                                                                     Withdrawal	
  	
  
                                                                            Balance	
  




     SallieMae	
                                         BMO	
                                               Bellco	
  CU	
  


22                   ©2011 Clairmail Confidential. Contains Proprietary Information. Not for Distribution.
Mobile as a distribution channel- Product delivery




23            ©2011 Clairmail Confidential. Contains Proprietary Information. Not for Distribution.
Mobile as a distribution channel- CBA

 •  Commonwealth Bank of Australia offering
    Augmented Reality application which helps
    users identify properties for sale
 •  All public information on a specific property
    published through the app
 •  Interested in the property? Apply for a loan with
    the push of a button on an app
 •  Similar initiatives for properties in Spain with
    Bankinter; used cars by Huntington Bank in US



24             ©2011 Clairmail Confidential. Contains Proprietary Information. Not for Distribution.
Mobile	
  driving	
  revenue-­‐	
  Bank	
  of	
  America	
  
Mobile as a payment method- US Bank




     Enter	
  recipient’s	
                    Debited	
  from	
                                             Payment	
  
      email	
  address	
                      payor’s	
  account	
                                       received	
  via	
  ACH	
  

26                              ©2011 Clairmail Confidential. Contains Proprietary Information. Not for Distribution.
Mobile Channel Growth Considerations
                            ©2011 Clairmail Confidential. Contains Proprietary Information. Not for Distribution.
Summary: Key Trends in Mobile

 •  Extension of OLB                       à           Stand alone channel
 •  Account access                         à           Distribution of information
                                           à           Call-To-Action
 •  Customer Servicing                     à           Product Distribution

 •  Cost of Business                       à           Fee Generator, Fee Preservation
 •  Retail                                 à           Cross line of business

 •  Generic information                    à           Contextual (location, transaction
                                                        history, client tier)

 •  Banking                                à           Payment method


28               ©2011 Clairmail Confidential. Contains Proprietary Information. Not for Distribution.
Mobile is Exploding Across All Vectors
•    Access
      –  Device proliferation
      –  Access Channels
      –  Enrollment

•    Features
      –    Account Access
      –    Bill Pay
      –    Alerts
      –    Check Deposit
      –    Enrollment
      –    CSR / Mgmt Reporting
      –    P2P Payments
      –    Mobile Wallet
      –    NFC

•    Bank business lines and customer segments
      –    Retail
      –    Credit & Loans
      –    Consumer Payments
      –    Marketing
      –    Fraud
                        ©2011 Clairmail Confidential. Contains Proprietary Information. Not for Distribution.
Planning for Mobile Explosion: Our recommendations

 •  Mobile banking is more than just “Apps”
 •  Use an enterprise platform
     –  Facilitate growth of mobile channel

     –  Manage feature proliferation

 •  Transaction-based, two-way messaging capability




30                   ©2011 Clairmail Confidential. Contains Proprietary Information. Not for Distribution.
Questions

 •  Questions?

 •  Contact info-
     –  Twitter: @afontao
     –  Blog: http://www.mobilefiblog.com/
     –  Andres.Fontao@clairmail.com




31               ©2011 Clairmail Confidential. Contains Proprietary Information. Not for Distribution.
Thank	
  You	
  
                   ©2011 Clairmail Confidential. Contains Proprietary Information. Not for Distribution.

Mobile Banking 2011: Clairmail

  • 1.
    Next  Genera*on  Mobile  Banking     ©2011 Clairmail Confidential. Contains Proprietary Information. Not for Distribution.
  • 2.
    Agenda •  Key Trends in Mobile •  Benchmarks for Mobile Banking – Europe •  Benchmarks for Mobile Banking – ROW •  Channel Growth Considerations ©2011 Clairmail Confidential. Contains Proprietary Information. Not for Distribution.
  • 3.
    Key  Trends  in  Mobile   ©2011 Clairmail Confidential. Contains Proprietary Information. Not for Distribution.
  • 4.
    Key Trends inMobile Banking •  La Caixa http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gf5Qa89QAI8 4 ©2011 Clairmail Confidential. Contains Proprietary Information. Not for Distribution.
  • 5.
    Mobile  banking  dates  back  to  2001   2001   2002   Aug  2001   Apr  2002   Feb  2001   SEB  (Estonia)   La  Caixa  launches   HSBC     launches  SMS   launches  P2P   GPRS-­‐based   payments  using   mobile  internet   alerts  and   no*fica*ons   SMS   banking   Dec  2002   Santander  and   Jan  2002   BBVA  launch   Mar  2001   Nordea  launch   Mobipay   Bankinter   “always  on”   payments  scheme   launches  SMS   mobile  banking  in   in  Spain   alerts  and   Finland   no*fica*ons   5
  • 6.
    Mobile  banking  1.0  primarily  focused  on  extending  OLB     Mobile   •  No*fica*ons  and  alerts   banking   •  Account  management   1.0   •  SMS-­‐based  payments   6
  • 7.
    Key  trends  in  mobile:  From  mobile  banking  1.0  to  next-­‐ genera*on   Mobile   Distribu*on   Payment   banking  1.0   channel   method   Mobile   Standalone   Standalone   driving   channel   business   digital   strategy   7
  • 8.
    Challenges  driving  this  mobile  banking  evolu*on   Technology   Customer   Regula*on   behavior   Growing   pressure  on   OPEX  and   margins   Mobile  centric  innova*on  focused   on  differen*a*ng  services   8
  • 9.
    Benchmarks  for  Innova*on  -­‐  Europe   ©2011 Clairmail Confidential. Contains Proprietary Information. Not for Distribution.
  • 10.
    Mobile  as  a  standalone  channel-­‐  La  Caixa   10
  • 11.
    Mobile  as  a  standalone  channel-­‐  La  Caixa   11
  • 12.
    Mobile  as  a  standalone  channel-­‐  Akbank   •  SMS  and  Mobile  internet   managed  with  their  own  P&L,   and  embedded  within  a  more   tradi*onal  channel  structure   •  SMS  branch  genera*ng  over   $1  million/month  through   service  fees,  transac*on  fees,   and  mobile  specific  products   •  Mobile  internet  mone*zed   through  efficiency  gains;  low   value  transac*ons  migrated   from  more  expensive  channels   12
  • 13.
    Mobile as adistribution channel- Danske Bank •  Smartphone  prolifera*on  has   driven  adop*on  to  point   where  it  is  now  considered  a   “full  blown  channel”   •  Currently  broadening  depth   and  reach  of  mobile  services  to   include  instant  loans  and   mobile  brokerage   •  Features  enhancement   focused  on  introducing   biometrics  and  CRM-­‐driven   offers   13 ©2011 Clairmail Confidential. Contains Proprietary Information. Not for Distribution.
  • 14.
    Mobile  as  a  distribu*on  channel-­‐  Akbank   •  Akbank  began  distribu*ng   loans  on  mobile  telephones  in   2005  through  their  WAP  portal   •  Distribu*on  has  evolved  to   include  smartphone  apps,  SMS   and  banner  ads  at  non-­‐bank   mobile  internet  proper*es  and   applica*ons   •  Garan*Bank  and  YapiCredi,   among  others,  responded  by   incorpora*ng  similar  features   to  their  mobile  banking  service   14
  • 15.
    Mobile  as  a  distribu*on  channel-­‐  Bankinter   •  Relevant,  contextual  offers   pushed  to  the  mobile  phone   through  messaging  pladorm,   triggered  by  credit  card/debit   card  purchases   •  ≈  3%  opt-­‐in  rate  for  most   successful  offers,  at  a   significantly  lower  distribu*on   cost  than  tradi*onal  channels   •  Most  successful  with  low   value,  high  margin  products   such  as  consumer  finance,   travel  insurance,  etc.     15
  • 16.
    Mobile  as  a  standalone  business-­‐  Bankinter   •  Bankinter  partnered  with  KPN  in   2007  to  distribute  SIM-­‐cards  under   a  branded  reseller  agreement   •  ≈10%  of  addressable  market   currently  using  Bankinter  SIM  card     •  Ini*al  value  proposi*on  included   free  SMS  and  mobile  internet   banking  to  s*mulate  channel   adop*on  (3x  greater  among  MVNO   customers)     •  Began  pilo*ng  NFC  through  its  own   MVNO  using  a  SIM-­‐based  solu*on   16
  • 17.
    Mobile  as  a  payment  method-­‐  La  Caixa   •  In  2010,  La  Caixa  coordinated  a   SIM-­‐based  NFC  mobile   payment  trial  in  Spain,   enabling  customers  and   merchants  with  proper   infrastructure   •  Results  included  +30%  increase   in  transac*ons  and  +23%  in   billing  during  trial   •  Next  steps  included   commercial  rollout  which   began  in  May  2011   17
  • 18.
    Mobile  driving  digital  strategy   •  New  business  areas  introduced  to  mobile,   star*ng  with  brokerage  and  business  banking   •  Augmented-­‐reality  being  used  for  discovery   •  Tablet-­‐specific  sites  and  applica*ons  centered   around  account  management  (PFM-­‐like  features)     •  Biometrics  and  security  being  introduced     •  SmartTV  applica*ons  prototyped  and  launched   18
  • 19.
    Mobile  driving  digital  strategy-­‐  Banco  Sabadell   •  Currently  at  70%  SMS  and  14%   web  /  app  adop*on  (as  %  of  OLB);   targe*ng  30%  by  YE  2013     •  Increase  will  be  primarily  driven  by   broadened  device  reach  and   enhanced  mobile  features   •  Device  strategy  now  includes   tablets  and  Windows  Phone   •  Broadened  features  with   introduc*on  of  mobile  brokerage   apps  and  RDC   19
  • 20.
    Benchmarks  for  Innova*on  -­‐  ROW   ©2011 Clairmail Confidential. Contains Proprietary Information. Not for Distribution.
  • 21.
    Mobile as astandalone channel- Wells Fargo 21 ©2011 Clairmail Confidential. Contains Proprietary Information. Not for Distribution.
  • 22.
    Mobile as adistribution channel- Information Check   Low   Cleared   Withdrawal     Balance   SallieMae   BMO   Bellco  CU   22 ©2011 Clairmail Confidential. Contains Proprietary Information. Not for Distribution.
  • 23.
    Mobile as adistribution channel- Product delivery 23 ©2011 Clairmail Confidential. Contains Proprietary Information. Not for Distribution.
  • 24.
    Mobile as adistribution channel- CBA •  Commonwealth Bank of Australia offering Augmented Reality application which helps users identify properties for sale •  All public information on a specific property published through the app •  Interested in the property? Apply for a loan with the push of a button on an app •  Similar initiatives for properties in Spain with Bankinter; used cars by Huntington Bank in US 24 ©2011 Clairmail Confidential. Contains Proprietary Information. Not for Distribution.
  • 25.
    Mobile  driving  revenue-­‐  Bank  of  America  
  • 26.
    Mobile as apayment method- US Bank Enter  recipient’s   Debited  from   Payment   email  address   payor’s  account   received  via  ACH   26 ©2011 Clairmail Confidential. Contains Proprietary Information. Not for Distribution.
  • 27.
    Mobile Channel GrowthConsiderations ©2011 Clairmail Confidential. Contains Proprietary Information. Not for Distribution.
  • 28.
    Summary: Key Trendsin Mobile •  Extension of OLB à Stand alone channel •  Account access à Distribution of information à Call-To-Action •  Customer Servicing à Product Distribution •  Cost of Business à Fee Generator, Fee Preservation •  Retail à Cross line of business •  Generic information à Contextual (location, transaction history, client tier) •  Banking à Payment method 28 ©2011 Clairmail Confidential. Contains Proprietary Information. Not for Distribution.
  • 29.
    Mobile is ExplodingAcross All Vectors •  Access –  Device proliferation –  Access Channels –  Enrollment •  Features –  Account Access –  Bill Pay –  Alerts –  Check Deposit –  Enrollment –  CSR / Mgmt Reporting –  P2P Payments –  Mobile Wallet –  NFC •  Bank business lines and customer segments –  Retail –  Credit & Loans –  Consumer Payments –  Marketing –  Fraud ©2011 Clairmail Confidential. Contains Proprietary Information. Not for Distribution.
  • 30.
    Planning for MobileExplosion: Our recommendations •  Mobile banking is more than just “Apps” •  Use an enterprise platform –  Facilitate growth of mobile channel –  Manage feature proliferation •  Transaction-based, two-way messaging capability 30 ©2011 Clairmail Confidential. Contains Proprietary Information. Not for Distribution.
  • 31.
    Questions •  Questions? •  Contact info- –  Twitter: @afontao –  Blog: http://www.mobilefiblog.com/ –  Andres.Fontao@clairmail.com 31 ©2011 Clairmail Confidential. Contains Proprietary Information. Not for Distribution.
  • 32.
    Thank  You   ©2011 Clairmail Confidential. Contains Proprietary Information. Not for Distribution.