This document outlines an evaluation methodology for reformed math courses. It proposes conducting a longitudinal study comparing student outcomes between a controlled group taught with old courses and an experimental group taught with new reformed courses. Student outcomes would be assessed using pre-and post-tests, pre-and post-questionnaires, and measures of grades, knowledge gain, drop-out rates, motivation, and student evaluations. Challenges include accounting for differences between groups and ensuring high response rates to electronic questionnaires.