Crisis and crisis management in the
war on terror
Change,
Conflict
and Crisis
3
EUA 601 and 620 Contemporary World Arena
9-11
1
origins
2
crises
3
managing crises
4
perceiving crises
5
the attacks
1
acts of violence that are intentionally
directed at non-combatants for the
purpose of securing political objectives
(Philips 2020: 137)
Al-Qaeda and ‘transnational terror’
Use of aircraft and low technology
Part of a broader pattern
Bali
Madrid
London
Major impact on US foreign and
domestic policy, and on US allies
ever ything
two hours that
Halliday 2001
changed
changed the world
Where did it come from?
2
sub-humans
But beyond pain
and rhetoric…
serious thinking
suggests
it’s more complex
1991change in balance of power
Decoupling
of Cold War proxy
relationships
crises
3
borderlands
Autonomous civil wars in
failed states and
ungovernable zones
Helman and Ratner 1992; Kaplan 1994
Security-
development nexus
managing crises
4
Bush doctrine
to forestall or prevent such
hostile acts by our
adversaries, the United
States will, if necessary, act
pre-emptively in exercising
our inherent right of self-
defence
National Security Strategy,
20 Sept 2002
Moral certitude
Military primacy
M. East democracy
Legitimised by UN and ‘coalition of the willing’
ut
Extension into Iraq
legitimacy
undermined
perceiving crises
5
crisis for whom?
why was 9/11
welcomed by some
US supports ME
d i c t a t o r s
Persistent
interventions in
the borderlands
US foreign policy has…
strutted around for a
century, without
saying ‘thank you’,
or ‘please’…
Western universalizing project
Liberal
terror
Propensity
to flatten
whatever
disagrees
with US
policy, in
the name of
the
liberal
peace
Brad Adams
9-11
As
response
to
us
hegemony
since
1991
http://drones.pitchinteractive.com/
Meaning in IR
6
legitimate response to
violent
american
hegemony
Or
primitivism,
barbarism,
extremism
Who are the
‘terrorists’
How useful is it to
use such terms
To
demonise,
dehumanize and
delegitimize
to confiscate the word humanity, to invoke and monopolize such a
term… has certain effects, such as denying the enemy the quality of
being human and declaring him to be an outlaw of humanity; and a
war can thereby be driven to the most extreme inhumanity
Carl Schmitt, The Concept of the Political
since all such acts are barriers to
communication
Conclusion
nothing changes
everything
George Will (2005)
“
Little… has changed. The forces of globalization
continue unabated... The issues of the day… are largely
the same. Across broad measures of political, economic,
and social data, the constants outweigh the variations.
And United States' foreign policy is marked by no greater
strategic clarity than it had on Sept. 10, 2001
Dobson, 2006:1
Violence from
hegemonic
power inevitable
to maintain
status
realism
Attacks are war
of ideas, beliefs
and supremacy
constructivism
Violence
sanctioned and
condoned by
collective
security rules
liberalism
Opportunity to
further goals of
neoimperialism
marxism
Lecture 19 changeconflictcrisis 3 war on terror

Lecture 19 changeconflictcrisis 3 war on terror