Mating Systems Review of reproductive strategies from previous lecture
Mating Systems Monogamy Polyandry polygamy
Mating System You should be able to address the following questions: What sexual strategies are used in different mating systems?
Mating System You should be able to address the following questions: Why is it questionable whether polyandry is adaptive? What factors would make it adaptive and what factors would not? Why are females polyandrous?
Mating System You should be able to address the following questions: Is monogamy adaptive? What theories and data indicate it is and is not? What factors may influence whether or not it is adaptive? Why are males ever monogamous?
Mating System You should be able to address the following questions: Why is there a high diversity of polygamous sytems?
Mating Systems: What are we talking about? Evolutionary point of view What happens in a mating system related to natural selection?
Mating Systems: What are we talking about? Evolutionary point of view What factors related to mating systems influence an individuals fitness?
Mating Systems Mating systems primarily refers both to copulation events and offspring produced Additional behaviors influence if offspring are produced/survive from copulation
Mating Systems Several factors influence system Amount of Parental care Availability of other mates Frequency of mating with same partner
Operational Sex Ratio OSR – operational sex ratio Males ready to mate: females ready to mate Ratio of males to females, given they have different energy investments in reproduction Biased to sex with lowest reproductive investment in each offspring Gives that sex greater potential to increase genetic fitness through polygamous mating
Reproductive Rate What is a reproductive rate? What factors influence a reproductive rate?
Potential reproductive rates PRR – potential reproductive rates Sex with highest PRR has greatest capacity for polygamy  Temporal and spatial distribution of mates may alter the potential for polygamy and thus influence mating patterns If females only encounter one mate ata a time then monogamous patterns may arise
Monogamy Mate-assistance (male parental investment required) Female-enforced monogamy Mate-guarding (male mate-guarding is beneficial when females are receptive to males after mating and are rare, and females don’t kill males)
Monogamy: Mate Assistance Hypothesis: monogamy is advantageous to males because ecological factors when there are advantages to: parental care of offspring protection of offspring
Monogamy: Mate Assistance Example Seahorse ( Hippocampus whitei) Male seahorse – broods offspring for 3 weeks Pouch has room for one clutch of eggs PRR of males and females is very similar Females can't produce eggs faster than for one male Synchrony of reproductive cycle with partner increases male fitness Seahorse relative Fitness price to break off relationship Travel longer distance for new mate
Monogamy: Female Enforced  Female-enforced monogamy Example birds Female pokes holes in eggs of female  Razor bills  Rookeries attack females that demonstrate interest in mates Burying beetle Male and female find a carcass and bury it Used to feed larvae Male goes to top of mound to release pheremones for a second female Female pushes male off perch
Monogamy: Mate Guarding Prevent female from mating with other males Advantageous for males if females  remain receptive after mating are widely scattered are difficult to locate Beneficial if both have high value partner e.g., cichlid fish Removed male replaced with smaller male
Monogamy: Parental Care Males that invest in parental care should be monogamous Little support in mammals
Mating Systems There is a wide range of behavior patterns within polyandry and polygamy
Polyandry Female mates with multiple males
Polyandry Examples Honey bees Queen honey bees mate with many drones (a dozen); drones mate with one queen Queens will produce offspring with up to 12 different paternities Queen ants  Ability of ants to select sperm from different males (e.g., alternate generations different paternity, Sweden)
Polyandry: Female Choice Female Choice Females avoid extra-pair copulation Female solicit extra-pair copulations Selected sperm use by females Sperm removal by females e.g., birds Ants control use of which sperm for offspring
Polyandry: Benefits Benefits: Good genes hypothesis Guppies 80% more offspring Offspring hatched 9 days sooner Mothers were more competent Yellow-toothed cavy (wild guinea pig) Reduced stillbirths and loss before weaning How does sperm competition fit in here? Female choice for males in good condition
Polyandry: Benefits Benefits: Good genes hypothesis Genetic compatibility Number of offspring fertilized by one male was not consistent among females Rooster sperm. Female scorpions more likely to mate with stranger than a male she just mated with
Polyandry: Benefits Benefits: Increase material benefit Foraging territory e.g., polyandrous red-winged black-birds can forage on male controlled territories while monogamous birds are chased away Female Galapagos hawks control foraging territory Turn over territory to Multiple males to patrol
Polyandry: Benefits Spermatophore Contains nutritional value for female in some species (e.g., butterflies) Can be 15% of male's body weight More males, more spermatophores, more offspring
Polyandry: Benefits Parental assistance from more than one mate Female dunnocks  Dominant and subordinate male Both males will provide parental care if they have mated with female enough
Polyandry: Benefits Protection against dangerous males Primates Reduce infanticide (Hanuman lemurs) Males that have mated with a female will tend to leave her offspring alone
Polyandry: Benefits Benefits: Fertility insurance hypothesis Increased likelihood of  polyandrous red-winged  blackbirds eggs to hatch Pregnancies in Gunnison's prairie dogs Rapid loss of sperm in bearded tit
Polyandry:Risks Loss of partner (e.g., for parental care)
Polyandry:Risks Venereal Disease Relationship between degree of polyandry and white blood cell count
Polygamy Does it make evolutionary sense? See PRR theory
Polygamy Diversity of Polygamy Female defense Resource Defense Scramble competition Lek
Polygamy Female defense Males fight with other males to monopolize females e.g., elephant seal harems
Polygamy Resource Defense Males defend territories with resources that females need to reproduce
Polygamy Scramble competition Temporal competition for mates e.g., butterflies Avoid combat Do not control territories
Polygamy Lek No food or resource benefits of a lek Very few males mate with females e.g., grouse Similarly bower of bower bird contains few resources for female

Lec13 Mating Systems

  • 1.
    Mating Systems Reviewof reproductive strategies from previous lecture
  • 2.
    Mating Systems MonogamyPolyandry polygamy
  • 3.
    Mating System Youshould be able to address the following questions: What sexual strategies are used in different mating systems?
  • 4.
    Mating System Youshould be able to address the following questions: Why is it questionable whether polyandry is adaptive? What factors would make it adaptive and what factors would not? Why are females polyandrous?
  • 5.
    Mating System Youshould be able to address the following questions: Is monogamy adaptive? What theories and data indicate it is and is not? What factors may influence whether or not it is adaptive? Why are males ever monogamous?
  • 6.
    Mating System Youshould be able to address the following questions: Why is there a high diversity of polygamous sytems?
  • 7.
    Mating Systems: Whatare we talking about? Evolutionary point of view What happens in a mating system related to natural selection?
  • 8.
    Mating Systems: Whatare we talking about? Evolutionary point of view What factors related to mating systems influence an individuals fitness?
  • 9.
    Mating Systems Matingsystems primarily refers both to copulation events and offspring produced Additional behaviors influence if offspring are produced/survive from copulation
  • 10.
    Mating Systems Severalfactors influence system Amount of Parental care Availability of other mates Frequency of mating with same partner
  • 11.
    Operational Sex RatioOSR – operational sex ratio Males ready to mate: females ready to mate Ratio of males to females, given they have different energy investments in reproduction Biased to sex with lowest reproductive investment in each offspring Gives that sex greater potential to increase genetic fitness through polygamous mating
  • 12.
    Reproductive Rate Whatis a reproductive rate? What factors influence a reproductive rate?
  • 13.
    Potential reproductive ratesPRR – potential reproductive rates Sex with highest PRR has greatest capacity for polygamy Temporal and spatial distribution of mates may alter the potential for polygamy and thus influence mating patterns If females only encounter one mate ata a time then monogamous patterns may arise
  • 14.
    Monogamy Mate-assistance (maleparental investment required) Female-enforced monogamy Mate-guarding (male mate-guarding is beneficial when females are receptive to males after mating and are rare, and females don’t kill males)
  • 15.
    Monogamy: Mate AssistanceHypothesis: monogamy is advantageous to males because ecological factors when there are advantages to: parental care of offspring protection of offspring
  • 16.
    Monogamy: Mate AssistanceExample Seahorse ( Hippocampus whitei) Male seahorse – broods offspring for 3 weeks Pouch has room for one clutch of eggs PRR of males and females is very similar Females can't produce eggs faster than for one male Synchrony of reproductive cycle with partner increases male fitness Seahorse relative Fitness price to break off relationship Travel longer distance for new mate
  • 17.
    Monogamy: Female Enforced Female-enforced monogamy Example birds Female pokes holes in eggs of female Razor bills Rookeries attack females that demonstrate interest in mates Burying beetle Male and female find a carcass and bury it Used to feed larvae Male goes to top of mound to release pheremones for a second female Female pushes male off perch
  • 18.
    Monogamy: Mate GuardingPrevent female from mating with other males Advantageous for males if females remain receptive after mating are widely scattered are difficult to locate Beneficial if both have high value partner e.g., cichlid fish Removed male replaced with smaller male
  • 19.
    Monogamy: Parental CareMales that invest in parental care should be monogamous Little support in mammals
  • 20.
    Mating Systems Thereis a wide range of behavior patterns within polyandry and polygamy
  • 21.
    Polyandry Female mateswith multiple males
  • 22.
    Polyandry Examples Honeybees Queen honey bees mate with many drones (a dozen); drones mate with one queen Queens will produce offspring with up to 12 different paternities Queen ants Ability of ants to select sperm from different males (e.g., alternate generations different paternity, Sweden)
  • 23.
    Polyandry: Female ChoiceFemale Choice Females avoid extra-pair copulation Female solicit extra-pair copulations Selected sperm use by females Sperm removal by females e.g., birds Ants control use of which sperm for offspring
  • 24.
    Polyandry: Benefits Benefits:Good genes hypothesis Guppies 80% more offspring Offspring hatched 9 days sooner Mothers were more competent Yellow-toothed cavy (wild guinea pig) Reduced stillbirths and loss before weaning How does sperm competition fit in here? Female choice for males in good condition
  • 25.
    Polyandry: Benefits Benefits:Good genes hypothesis Genetic compatibility Number of offspring fertilized by one male was not consistent among females Rooster sperm. Female scorpions more likely to mate with stranger than a male she just mated with
  • 26.
    Polyandry: Benefits Benefits:Increase material benefit Foraging territory e.g., polyandrous red-winged black-birds can forage on male controlled territories while monogamous birds are chased away Female Galapagos hawks control foraging territory Turn over territory to Multiple males to patrol
  • 27.
    Polyandry: Benefits SpermatophoreContains nutritional value for female in some species (e.g., butterflies) Can be 15% of male's body weight More males, more spermatophores, more offspring
  • 28.
    Polyandry: Benefits Parentalassistance from more than one mate Female dunnocks Dominant and subordinate male Both males will provide parental care if they have mated with female enough
  • 29.
    Polyandry: Benefits Protectionagainst dangerous males Primates Reduce infanticide (Hanuman lemurs) Males that have mated with a female will tend to leave her offspring alone
  • 30.
    Polyandry: Benefits Benefits:Fertility insurance hypothesis Increased likelihood of polyandrous red-winged blackbirds eggs to hatch Pregnancies in Gunnison's prairie dogs Rapid loss of sperm in bearded tit
  • 31.
    Polyandry:Risks Loss ofpartner (e.g., for parental care)
  • 32.
    Polyandry:Risks Venereal DiseaseRelationship between degree of polyandry and white blood cell count
  • 33.
    Polygamy Does itmake evolutionary sense? See PRR theory
  • 34.
    Polygamy Diversity ofPolygamy Female defense Resource Defense Scramble competition Lek
  • 35.
    Polygamy Female defenseMales fight with other males to monopolize females e.g., elephant seal harems
  • 36.
    Polygamy Resource DefenseMales defend territories with resources that females need to reproduce
  • 37.
    Polygamy Scramble competitionTemporal competition for mates e.g., butterflies Avoid combat Do not control territories
  • 38.
    Polygamy Lek Nofood or resource benefits of a lek Very few males mate with females e.g., grouse Similarly bower of bower bird contains few resources for female