BALANCED SCORE CARD
Technique & Process
for Better Performance
Saya mesti apa?
PENYEBAB PENYEBAB
Pesaing X Daya beli menurun X
Musim X Harga mahal V
Mutu V Pelayanan jelek V
Kurang profesional V Pasokan terlambat X
Promosi V After sales service V
M: Penjualan tidak memenuhi target : Mengapa?
AGF Consulting
Apa yang bisa saya lakukan?
AGF- COMPETENCE
(Achievement Generating
Factor) V
SGF- COMPETENCE
(Support Generating
Factor) X
KEPUTUSAN
FOKUS
SARAN
SINERGI
KINERJAFIT
Saya mesti apa?
M: Penjualan tidak memenuhi target : Mengapa?
KINERJA
PENJUALAN
MUTU
PRODUK
DAYA
SAING HARGA
PROMOSI
KOMPETENSI
MENJUAL
Scorecard Score
Measures
Target
Weight
If you can measure it you can
manage it, if you can manage it
you can achieve it (Kaplan dan
Norton)
Definisi
Sistem pengelolaan Stratejik yang mengkombinasi
ukuran-ukuran keuangan dan non keuangan.
•KEUANGAN
•PELANGGAN
•PROSES INTERNAL
•PERTUMBUHAN DAN INOVASI
Objectives
Measures
Targets
Objectives
Measures
Targets
Objectives
Measures
Targets
Balanced Scorecard Planning Process
Vision /
Mission
Objectives
Measures
Targets
Initiatives
Apa yang
Akan menjadi progress
Menuju visi kita
Apa Langkah
untuk mencapai
visi kita?
Balanced Scorecard dan Strategi
Artikulasi Komunikasi Penyesuaian
Financial?
•Pertumbuhan Pendapatan
•Reduksi Biaya
•Utilisasi Sumber Daya
•Surplus
Untuk sukses secara
finansial, apa yang
harus nampak
dimata anggota
kita?
Pelanggan?
Untuk mencapai
visi kita, apa yang
harus nampak
dimata pelanggan
kita?
Apa yang sangat
penting bagi
pelanggan
kita
Loyalitas
Anggota
Retensi
Anggota
Kemanfaatan
Anggota
Kepuasan
Anggota
Akuisisi
Anggota
• Atribut Produk
• Customer Relationship
• Image dan Reputasi
Siapa saja dalam dan
diluar organisasi kita
adalah pelanggan kita
Proses Pengelolaan
Internal?
• Perbaikan Mutu
• Perpendek Waktu
Pelayanan
• Efisiensi Internal
• Efektivitas Proses
• Reduksi Biaya
PUAS
LAYANI
ANGGOTA
Indentifikasi
Kebutuhan
Anggota
Ciptakan
pelayanan
yang baik
KEMBANGKAN
JENIS
PELAYANAN
DELIVER
PELAYANAN
Proses
Inovasi Proses Operasi
Pelayanan Pelanggan
Untuk memuaskan
semua fihak,
khususnya anggota
kita, proses internal
mana yang kita
unggul
Kompetensi
Inti
Pembelajaran dan
Inovasi?
• Profesionalisme Pelaksana
• Kehandalan Sistem Informasi
• Pemberdayaan
• Organisasi Pembelajaran
• Pembelajaran Organisasional
Bagaimana
kemampuan
berobah dan
memperbaiki
kinerja
Litbang Internal &
ExternalPerhatikan gap kemampuan pelayanan kita
Vision
&
Strategy
Vision
&
Strategy
CUSTOMER
CUSTOMER
“To achieve our
vision, how
should we
appear to our
member?”
Objectives Measures Targets Initiatives
FINANCIAL
FINANCIAL
“To succeed
financially, how
should we
appear to our
member?”
Objectives Measures Targets Initiatives
INTERNAL BUSINESS PROCESSES
INTERNAL BUSINESS PROCESSES
“To satisfy our
member, what
processes must
we excel at?”
Objectives Measures Targets Initiatives
INNOVATION AND LEARNING
INNOVATION AND LEARNING
“To achieve our
vision, how will
we sustain our
ability to
change and
improve?”
Objectives Measures Targets Initiatives
Hubungan Kausal
Menentukan Objectives
Pecific - Jelas
easurable – Bisa diukur
chievable – Bisa dicapai
ealistic- Realistis
angible &Timeliness–
ada buktinya dgn rentang
waktu jelas
Cascading
Kembangkan proses dimana
setiap orang tahu bagaimana
organisasi akan bergerak, apa
yang dituju dan bagaimana
mencapainya
OBJECTIVES pada
semua level harus
disajikan dalam 4
perspektif
 Keuangan
 Pelanggan
 Proses Internal
 Pembelajaran dan
Innovasi
Business Unit
Mission and
Strategy
Strategic
Objectives
and
Measures
Departmental
Plans
Team Plans
Individual
Performance
Measures
CONTOH CASCADING PENGEMBANGAN SCORECARD
RENCANA DARI
KANTOR PUSAT
SCORECARD
RSM 1
SCORECARD
RSM 2
SCORECARD
RSM 2
SCORECARD
DM 1
DM 2
SCORECARDS
.SUP 1
SC .
SUP 2
SCORECARDS
Salesman 1
SC
S 2
SC
S 3
SC
S 4
SC
S 5
SC
S 6
Penting!!!
“Plan is nothing, planning is everything “
“If you can measure it, you can manage it, if
you can manage it, you can achieve it “
ARTIKULASI STRATEGI
PASTIKAN
JOB LOGIC
RANTAI NILAI
AGF
RANTAI
LEADING
RANTAI
LAGGING
PLAN
SCORECARD
DEFINISI
KINERJA
AUDIT
KINERJA
NERACA
KINERJA
ARTIKULASI STRATEGI
GRAND
STRATEGY
STRATEGIC
OBJECTIVES
(Tujuan Stratejik)
SUB
STRATEG
Y
SUB
STRATEG
Y
SUB
STRATEG
Y
STRATEGIC
OBJECTIVES
(Tujuan Stratejik)
STRATEGIC
OBJECTIVES
(Tujuan Stratejik)
ARTIKULASI STRATEGI (1)
STRATEGI
*INVEST
*CONSOLIDASI
*DEVESTASI
STRATEGI
KEUANGA
N
STRATEGI
PRODUKSI
STRATEGI
PEMASARA
N
STRATEGI
SDM
STRATEGI
PRODUK
STRATEGI
MARKET
ENTRY
STRATEGI
HARGA
STRATEGI
PROMOSI
STRATEGI
PENJUALAN
STRATEGI
PENGELOLAAN
PELANGGAN
STRATEGI
SELLING-
IN
STRATEGI
SELLING-
OUT
STRATEGI
SALES
VALUE
STRATEGI
SALES
TERRITORY
STRATEGI
SALES
FORCE
STRATEGI
CUSTOMER
RELATIONSHIP
ARTIKULASI STRATEGI (1)
STRATEG
I *INVEST
*KONSOLIDASI
*DIVESTASI
STRATEGI
KEUANGA
N
STRATEGI
PRODUKSI
&
OPERASI
STRATEGI
PEMASARA
N
STRATEGI
SDM
STRATEGI
PRODUK
STRATEGI
MARKET
ENTRY
STRATEGI
HARGA
STRATEGI
PROMOSI
STRATEGI
PENJUALAN
STRATEGI
PENGELOLAAN
PELANGGAN
STRATEGI
SELLING-
IN
STRATEGI
SELLING-
OUT
STRATEGI
SALES
VALUE
STRATEGI
SALES
TERRITORY
STRATEGI
SALES
FORCE
STRATEGI
CUSTOMER
RELATIONSHIP
PERSPEKTIF
STRATEGI
DALAM BSC-
BALANCED
SCORECARD
PERSPEKTIF
KEUANGAN
PERSPEKTIF
PELANGGAN
PERPESKTIF
PROSES BISNIS
INTERNAL
PERPEKTIF
PEMBELAJARAN
&
PERTUMBUHAN
CONTOH: ARTIKULASI SUB STRATEGI PENJUALAN
RUMUSAN STRATEGI: MENINGKATKAN
KINERJA PENJUALAN MENJADI Rp. 18
MILIAR PERTAHUN DI TAHUN 2004 atau
Rp.1,5 MILIAR PERBULAN
STRATEGIC
OBJECTIVES
(Tujuan Stratejik)
RINCIAN TUJUAN STRATEJIK DARI RUMUSAN
STRATEGI YANG DIBUAT
TUJUAN
STRATEJIK
MENINGKATKAN NILAI PENJUALAN
BULANAN
MENATA TERITORI PENJUALAN
(TERRITORY ALIGNMENT) UNTUK
MENJAMIN MERATANYA
KETERSEDIAAN PRODUK DI PASAR
MENINGKATKAN PROFESIONALISME
TENAGA PENJUALAN (HARD
WORKING & SMART WORKING MODE)
MEMELIHARA HUBUNGAN
PELANGGAN YANG ERAT UNTUK
MENJAMIN KESETIAAN OUTLET
MENJUAL PRODUK PERUSAHAAN
KINERJA
PENJUALAN
MANAJEMEN
TERRITORI
MANAJEMEN
SALESFORCE
MANAJEMEN
HUBUNGAN
PELANGGAN
RANTAI NILAI UTAMA
PASTIKAN JOB LOGIC UNTUK STRATEGI YANG DIBUAT
HARGA
JUAL
JUMLAH
RETUR
UNIT
PENJUALAN
NILAI
PENJUALAN
PASTIKAN JOB LOGIC UNTUK STRATEGI YANG DIBUAT
MANAJEMEN
TERITORI
POTENSI
WILAYAH ACCOUNT
RECRUITMENT
PROGRAM
OUTLET
SHARE
OUTLET
COVERAGE
PASTIKAN JOB LOGIC UNTUK STRATEGI YANG DIBUAT
PROFESIONALISME
SALESFORCE
DIKLATMAN
ORIENTASI
KERJA KERAS
(HARD-WORKING)
ORIENTASI
KERJA CERDAS
(Smart Working)
ORIENTASI HASIL
(Standard;Target)
PASTIKAN JOB LOGIC UNTUK STRATEGI YANG DIBUAT
MEMBANGUN
HUBUNGAN
PELANGGAN
MUTU
HUBUNGAN
PEMASARAN
TRANSAKSIONAL
KOMITMEN PADA
KONSENSUS MUTU
PELAYANAN
MUTU
HUBUNGAN
PEMASARAN
RELASIONAL
AGF CHAIN-RANTAI NILAI
SELLING-IN
HARGA
JUAL
JUMLAH
RETUR
UNIT
PENJUALAN
NILAI
PENJUALAN
MANAJEMEN
TERITORI
POTENSI
WILAYAH
ACCOUNT
RECRUITMENT
PROGRAM
OUTLET
SHARE
OUTLET
COVERAGE
PROFESIONALISME
SALESFORCE
DIKLATMAN ORIENTASI
KERJA KERAS
(HARD-WORKING)
ORIENTASI
KERJA CERDAS
(Smart Working)
ORIENTASI HASIL
(Standard;Target)
MEMBANGUNHUBUNGANPELANGGAN
MUTUHUBUNGANPEMASARANTRANSAKSIONAL
KOMITMEN PADA
KONSENSUS MUTUPELAYANANMUTUHUBUNGANPEMASARANRELASIONAL
AGF Consulting
SCORECARD RENCANA PEMASARAN
Sasaran: Meningkatkan kinerja penjualan hingga mencapai Rp. 1.5 m per bulan di tahun 2004
Strategic Objective
Lagging
Performance
Leading
Performance
M T M T
1. Meningkatkan
penjualan
Sales
value
1,5 M ΣBox
Sales
7.500
Σ Outlet
Harga
Khusus
≤ 10%
Outlet
Σ Retur ≤ 5%
AGF Consulting
SCORECARD RENCANA PEMASARAN
Sasaran: Meningkatkan kinerja penjualan hingga mencapai Rp. 1.5 m per bulan di tahun 2004
Strategic Objective
Lagging
Performance
Leading
Performance
M T M T
2. Menata teritori
penjualan untuk
menjamin luas
availability produk
di pasar
%OS 14% Σ Outlet
Putus
≤ 10%
Outlet
%OC 65%=
3.000
Outlet
Aktif
Σ Outlet
Baru
≥20%
Outlet
Σ Survey
Outlet
Industri
12 kali
SCORECARD RENCANA PEMASARAN
Sasaran: Meningkatkan kinerja penjualan hingga mencapai Rp. 1.5 m per bulan di tahun 2004
Strategic Objective
Lagging
Performance
Leading
Performance
M T M T
3. Meningkatkan
profesionalisme
tenaga penjualan
% SF
Target
100%
90% Σ Training 12 kali
% Quota
Ratio
100% %RCP ≥100%
%ECP ≥80%
% Sales Mix ≥
8 Jenis Item
≥70%
Faktur
SCORECARD RENCANA PEMASARAN
Sasaran: Meningkatkan kinerja penjualan hingga mencapai Rp. 1.5 m per bulan di tahun 2004
Strategic Objective
Lagging
Performance
Leading
Performance
M T M T
4. Membangun &
memelihara
hubungan
jangka panjang
dengan outlet
Σ Outlet
Pindah
Pemasok
0% Σ Delivery
tepat waktu
100 %
Σ Outlet
Aktif
3000 Σ Kesalahan
Item yang
dikirim
0%
Σ Missionary
Call
1/bln/
outlet
Rationale: Dengan 3000 outlet aktif sebagai hasil dari 80% ECP dengan rata rata
potensi 250 box @ Rp.20.000, diharapkan menghasilkan value penjualan Rp.1.5
miliar per bulan
INDIKATOR
KINERJA
Target SB
(5)
B
(4)
S
(3)
K
(2)
SK
(1)
Sales Value 1.5 M 1.5 1.25 1.1 0.9 0.75
Outlet Share 14% 14 13 12 11 10
Outlet Coverage 65% >65 65 50 45 <45
%SF mencapai
target 100%
90% 86% 83% 80% 75% 70%
Quota Ratio 100% 95% 90% 85% 83% 80%
Outlet Buy 3000 >3000 3000 2750 2500 <2500
Σ Outlet Pindah
Pemasok
0% 2% 4% 6% >6% >10%
SCORECARD DEFINISI KINERJA
LAGGING PERFORMANCE INDICATOR
KINERJA
PENJUALAN
MANAJEMEN
TERRITORI
MANAJEMEN
SALESFORCE
MANAJEMEN
HUBUNGAN
PELANGGAN
INDIKATOR KINERJA Target SB
(5)
B
(4)
S
(3)
K
(2)
SK
(1)
Σ Box Sales 7.500
Σ Outlet Harga Khusus ≤ 10% Outlet
Σ Retur ≤ 5%
Σ Outlet Putus ≤ 10% Outlet
Σ Outlet Baru ≥20% Outlet
Σ Survey Outlet Industri 12 kali
Σ Training 12 kali
%RCP ≥100%
%ECP ≥80%
% Sales Mix ≥ 8 Jenis Item ≥70% Faktur
Σ Delivery tepat waktu 100 %
Σ Kesalahan Item yang dikirim 0%
Σ Missionary Call 1/bln/ outlet
SCORECARD DEFINISI KINERJA
LEADING PERFORMANCE INDICATOR
KINERJA
PENJUALAN
MANAJEMEN
TERRITORI
MANAJEMEN
SALESFORCE
MANAJEMEN
HUBUNGAN
PELANGGAN
INDIKATOR KINERJA BOBOT KINER-
JA
INDEX
KINERJA
KINERJA
PUNCAK
GAP
Sales Value 0.20 5 1.00 1.00 0
Outlet Share 0.05 4 0.20 0.25 -20%
Outlet Coverage 0.1 3 0.30 0.50 -40%
%SF mencapai 100% 0.075 3 0.23 0.375 -40%
Quota Ratio 0.25 5 1.25 1.25 0%
Outlet Buy 0.15 3 0.45 0.75 -40%
Σ Outlet Pindah Pemasok 0.175 5 0.88 0.88 0%
TOTAL 1.0 4.3 5.0
DOCS ( Degree of Compliance to Standard) 86%
SCORECARD AUDIT KINERJA
LAGGING PERFORMANCE INDICATOR
KINERJA
PENJUALAN
MANAJEMEN
TERRITORI
MANAJEMEN
SALESFORCE
MANAJEMEN
HUBUNGAN
PELANGGAN
INDIKATOR KINERJA BOBOT KINERJA I.K K.P GAP
Σ Box Sales
Σ Outlet Harga Khusus
Σ Retur
Σ Outlet Putus
Σ Outlet Baru
Σ Survey Outlet Industri
Σ Training
%RCP
%ECP
% Sales Mix ≥ 8 Jenis Item
Σ Delivery tepat waktu
Σ Kesalahan Item yang dikirim
Σ Missionary Call
TOTAL 1.0 2.6 5.0
DOCS ( Degree of Compliance to Standard 52%
SCORECARD AUDIT KINERJA LEADINGKINERJA
PENJUALAN
MANAJEMEN
TERRITORI
MANAJEMEN
SALESFORCEMANAJEMEN
HUBUNGAN
PELANGGAN
NERACA KINERJA
LAG
86%
LEAD
52%
Apa makna dan
implikasinya?
KINERJA
PENJUALAN
MANAJEMEN
TERRITORI
MANAJEMEN
SALESFORCE
MANAJEMEN
HUBUNGAN
PELANGGAN
Target terlalu rendah
Windfall performance

Konsep Balanced Score Card

Editor's Notes

  • #2 Session objectives: To ensure alignment and commitment to the balanced scorecard and remove any conceptual theoretical understanding issues. To gain an understanding of what we will have to do if we are to succeed. To agree to following a balanced scorecard based approach to structure the 2 day planning session.
  • #3 Words to emphasis:erlambaX Strategic Measurement and Management - its is about making it happen, not just measuring its progress.
  • #4 Words to emphasis: Strategic Measurement and Management - its is about making it happen, not just measuring its progress.
  • #5 Words to emphasis:erlambaX Strategic Measurement and Management - its is about making it happen, not just measuring its progress.
  • #7 Words to emphasis: Strategic Measurement and Management - its is about making it happen, not just measuring its progress.
  • #8 It is important to do the Vision / Mission first, and the initiatives last. The vision / mission provides the unifying themes of purpose in the Balanced Scorecard Strategy. The initiatives should be designed so that a few carefully selected initiatives synergistically tackle multiple objectives in a co-ordinated fashion. You can then do all the objectives, all the measures, all the targets, etc. or the objectives, measures and targets for each perspective in turn. Typically, the Vision and Mission and Objectives are set top-down, while the measures, targets and initiatives have more of a bottom up contribution. Ultimately, we must aim for total buy-in into the strategy.
  • #9 The use of SMART objectives, measures, targets and initiatives provides a vehicle for articulating the strategy in a very tangible manner. It is therefore easier to communicate throughout the organisation, and people will better be able to align their efforts with the strategy. This is the real benefit that a Balanced Scorecard offers.
  • #10 At individual sub-unit level, your shareholder may be your management structure. Example Issue: What kind of a balance sheet do we want to have?
  • #12 Don’t ask “How can we improve our existing processes?” ask “What processes do we need to excel at?” “Process” Oriented Organisation ABC, etc.
  • #13 This is where we can introduce concepts like the Learning Organisation and Knowledge Management, and Intrapreneurship. We can also develop measures of the appropriateness and level of skills, and identify and fill any gaps. % sales from new products Skills / Vancancies
  • #14 It is important to identify few, but unified themes, rather than have 16 odd unconnected measures.
  • #15 Specific: Not: “We want people to like us” But: “We want our clients to rate us as the most customer friendly organisation in the country” Measurable” Not: “To have the smartest employees” But: “For each employee to spend 12 days a year on formal training” Achievable: Not:”To achieve sub 1 second response on the Internet Site all the time” But: “To achieve a less than 8 second response on the Internet site, 80% of the time”. Realistic Not: “For all our competitors customers to switch to us” But: “To capture a 1% market share by December 2000” Tangible: Not: “For everyone to feel warm and fuzzy about what they do” But: “To score over 7 on the employee satisfaction index”
  • #16 For each Balanced Scorecard (I.e. for each employee or role) you need to do a visioning and strategy exercise as part of the exercise  this must drive the construction of the Balanced Scorecard.