SlideShare a Scribd company logo
“Internal migration and 
the development nexus: 
the case of Bangladesh -by Rita Afsar” 
Date: 6. 05. 2014 
Md. Zakiul Alam 
Roll: ZH013 
BSS (Hons) 5th Semester 
Dept. Of Population Sciences 
University of Dhaka
Introduction 
 The land of Bangladesh has been changed rapidly because of mobility of people 
having questions about development strategies. Migration has great impact on 
people’s daily strategies and in the national economy like markets, 
communications and transportation and availability of electricity. 
 The rural area is no longer confined to food production but is now a source of 
labor for urban areas. Rural urban migration is one of the forces of changing 
among growing diversity and complexity in the patterns of migration. Changes 
through rural, the linkage between migration and development need to be re-examined. 
A lack of knowledge about the migration and poverty facing in 
Bangladesh. 
 Government policies can influence the impact of migration on development and 
poverty reduction. Knowledge about migration and the policy context in the 
country to enable DFID to understand and work toward maximizing the benefits 
of migration for poverty reduction and to promote the rights of poor migrants.
Objective and Structure of this Article 
This paper summarizes what is known about migration and the policy context in the 
country to enable DFID to understand and work toward maximizing the benefits of 
migration for poverty reduction and to promote the rights of poor migrants. 
 The paper aims to review existing policies related to migration in order to examine 
the relationship between migration and development. 
 In doing so, this paper examines: 
 The patterns and trends of internal migration in Bangladesh 
 Profile of migrants 
 Labor markets – conditions and entitlements 
 Key problems faced by migrants 
 Consequences of migration including remittances, migration and poverty and inequality 
 Policies issues …….. 
I. Government policies and instruments 
II. Policies and programmes of international agencies and donors 
III. Welfare entitlements 
IV. Main pro-poor organisations working to support migrants 
V. Key policy issues, gaps, drivers of change and recommendations
Scale and Determinants of Migration 
 Existing sample vital registration system such as BBS suggest that life time internal 
migration has increased significantly and the proportion of lifetime migrants doubled 
between 1974 and 1982 and reached 10.2% in 1991. 
 Migration pattern changes according to gender, 40% male migrant and 28% female migrant 
moved from rural to urban areas. 
 Marital migration and intra district migration are the important reason of rural-urban 
movement. 
 The net migration increased in urban areas than in rural areas .From panel data generated ,62 
randomly sampled villages in Bangladesh, Rahman et.al(1996),found that nearly two- thirds 
of emigration from rural to urban areas. The figure for rural-rural migration was 10% and 
was 24%for overseas migration.
Scale and Determinants of Migration cont. 
 Rural-urban migration is the most dominant form of migration. This is especially true for 17 
coastal district where accreted fertile char land is the cause of the violent confliction. 
 According to Kuhn's study of Matlab Thana (2000), he found that loss of homestead land 
does not necessarily lead to emigration. Sometimes debt seldom results in seizure of 
homestead lands unless the family’s local social ties are extremely weak. 
 The lack of year round employment in rural areas or recurrent flooding of coastal and other 
district can also push people into migration. Such as –Faridpur, Barisal, Noakhali, Rajbari 
and Sirajgong are the example of such district. 
Furthermore, migrants maintain connection with their natal families. In the context of limited 
provision of insurance and social security services, urban-rural co-operation and mutual 
support are important for both migrants and their natal families.
Migration and urbanization 
 Migration is one of the major contributors to urban growth in Bangladesh. The proportion of 
people living in urban areas rose from 6.2 in 1965 to 9.9% in 1975 and reached 25% in 
2000( UN 2002). 
 To reveal migration pattern and trend, we use sex ratios as indicator of emigration or 
immigration. cities with high sex ratios are generally considered to be receivers of migrant 
and those with lower sex ratios are considered to be sending areas. For instances 
1. Theremetropolitan is a positive correlation between higher sex ratio and and higher urban 
growth for all cities. A high sex ratio suggests that more men than women migrated to the 
cities. Chittagong had the highest sex ratios of 155 in 1974 but in 2001 it was declining only 
119. sex ratio for Dhaka 123,Khulna 112 and for rajshahi 110 in 2001. 
2. Among cities with population of 100000 or more a higher sex ratio is found in higher urban 
growth. For example Sylhet, Bogra ,Rangpur,and Jessore. cities where lower urban growth 
found lower sex ratio.Saidpur,Jamalpur and Tangail.Barsal and Nawabgonj are the exception. 
3. There is a close relationship between rapid urbanization and significant demographic change. 
for example Dhaka ,Chittagong,Khulna urbanized rapidly and also show high sex ratios. 
These cities benefited either from industrial or high agricultural growth.
Profile of Migrants 
 Migrants are predominantly young adults from low- income families. 
 But the traditional picture of young males leaving their villages is changing as more 
and more women migrants are more informed about job opportunities at work 
destinations. 
Selectivity of Migration: 
 Age 
 Household surveys at destination shows that 75% of temporary, 50% of permanent and 
33% of non-migrants of Dhaka city were 15 to 34 years of age. 
 Of the female labor force in RMG factories, 90% were under 30 years of age
Profile of Migrants cont. 
 Marital Status 
 Almost 90% of permanent migrants and non-migrants were married at the time of the 
survey. 
 In contrast, nearly half of temporary migrants were never married. 
 For female workers, almost half were never married and less than 10% were 
divorced/widowed or separated; the remainder were married. 
 Among the extreme poor, the divorced and widowed women were more likely to migrate. 
 Gender 
 The RMG sector absorbed more than 1.5 million workers in the mid-1990s of which 70% 
were women and more than 90% were migrants. 
 In other industries such as food processing, pharmaceuticals and electronics, migrants 
constitute about half of the work force and the gender ratio is almost balanced.
Profile of Migrants contd. 
 Socio-economic Background 
 Generally it is the landless who migrate as they have nothing to lose. 
 At the other end, are those who have enough resources to take the risk. 
 Thus 3/4 of women and 2/3 of men working in RMG factories were functionally landless. 
 Migrants to slums had only one year of schooling and were predominantly engaged as 
agricultural workers prior to migration. 
 On average, a non-poor migrant had 8 years’ education and they migrated mainly to give 
their children a better education. The extreme poor and destitute also migrated to earn 
money for survival in a situation of social exclusion and having little or no supportive 
networks.
Labour market: Conditions and entitlements 
 Studies on internal migration clearly demonstrate that greater job opportunities in the 
cities and metropolitan areas ‘pulled’ migrants from rural areas (Skeldon, 1997; Hugo 
1991; Afsar 1999, 2000). 
 Around 50% migrants came in Dhaka city had been agricultural labourers. 
 The migrants choose to migrate in nearer towns, cities or metropolitans in search for 
more income in non agricultural sector. But Why? 
 Because estimation about agricultural growth is that agricultural income was less then 1% as 
opposed to nearly 6% in annual income in non agricultural income between 1988 to 1995. rural 
landless agricultural workers has a little incentive in agriculture sector. As a result, they choose 
to migrate. But there has a risk of unemployment(Todaro). 
 Most of the rural poor migrants settle in the slum. 
 ¾th of the rural migrants are secured their first job by the help of their social networks. 
 Every three of five get their works/jobs within one weeks(Afsar, 1999). About 1/3 of 
migrants had information about his/her jobs before migration by their kin networks.
Labour market: Conditions and entitlements cont. 
 The unemployment rate of active-age migrants is 4% which is almost double to the 
non migrants age cohorts. 
 The fact is that poor people hardly try to remain unemployed, as a result they 
migrate to the nearest towns or cities to relief their unemployment & poverty 
temporarily. Thus unemployment rate is almost smaller in the case of recent than 
long term migrant. 
 Low and irregular payment of wages is so widely even in the formal sector. Because 
there is no labour entitlements for formal sector and informal sector workers enjoy 
no such provision. 
 Nearly half of the RMG sectors workers leave jobs for the particular reasons. 
 Income difference between male and female RMG workers remains at a quarter. 
Had they not migrated they would have remained either unemployment or under 
employment. This is a particular true for women that the scope wage employment 
is extremely limited in rural areas. Around one-tenth of the rural forces is engaged 
as employee and one-fourth of them as day labourer (BBS, 2002).
Labour market: Conditions and entitlements in 
the formal sector 
Worker 
strategy 
Income (monthly) 
Wage Others 
Working 
hours 
Paid leave and other 
entitlements 
Factory Condition 
Skilled/RMG 
Male 2000 500 11.1 Nearly 2/3rd of worker do not 
receive appointment letters, 
1/5th male and 1/3rd female 
worker had salary cuts for 
taking sick leave, more than 
1/3rd also do not enjoy 
maternity leave. 
Factories generally 
lacks adequate 
lighting, ventilation 
and washing 
facilities, canteen 
and safe drinking 
water. Rooms are 
crowded. Average 
per toilets for male 
are 40 and female 
81. 
Female 1800 500 10.8 
Remarks Delayed , irregular 
payment and severe 
penalties for coming 
late. 
30/45 
minutes 
launch break 
Other 
Manufacturing 
Male 2800 - 6.5 90% of women workers 
demanded paid leave for 
effective combination of 
productive and child-care 
facilities. 
Ventilation safe 
water, toilet 
facilities in most 
factories are not 
better than such in 
RMGs. 
Female 2300 - 6.0 
Remarks Not much problems 
in payment 
No shift duty 
in general
Trends in Population by Residence, 1901-2000 
Census 
year 
National 
population 
Growth 
rate % 
Urban 
population 
Growth 
Rate % 
Rural 
population 
Growth 
rate % 
Urban % 
1901 28928 - 708 0.00 28226 0.00 2.40 
1911 31555 0.94 807 1.40 30748 0.90 2.60 
1921 33254 0.60 879 0.80 32376 0.50 2.60 
1931 35604 0.74 1074 2.00 35428 0.90 3.00 
1941 41997 1.70 1537 3.60 40460 1.30 3.70 
1951 44166 0.50 1820 1.70 42346 0.50 4.30 
1961 55223 2.26 31111 5.40 52112 2.10 5.60 
1974 76398 2.48 73901 6.70 69008 2.20 9.70 
1981 89912 2.32 140891 9.20** 75823 1.30 15.70 
1991 109877 2.01 215602 4.20 88317 1.50 19.60 
2000 137439 2.51 34354 5.30 103085 1.73 25.00 
2001 - - - - - -
Changes in occupation by Migration Status, 1998: Pre & Post- 
Migrational status 
Occupatio 
n Status 
Long-term 
migrant 
Recent 
migrant 
Non- 
Slum 
Slum Non- 
Slum 
Slum 
Post 
migration 
occupational 
status 
Trading 31.5 21.4 41.3 - 
Labor: Non-farm 
8.7 43.8 7.1 50.0 
Services 21.5 71.4 8.7 - 
Renting - - - - 
Not working 7.9 3.1 - - 
Others - - - - 
Total 100(277) 100(13 
0) 
100(14) 100(46) 
Occupatio 
n Status 
Long-term 
migrant 
Recent 
migrant 
Non- 
Slum 
Slum Non- 
Slum 
Slum 
Pre-Migration 
occupational 
status 
Agriculture 5.4 3.9 - 17.4 
Trading 6.9 21.4 15.2 - 
Labor: Non-farm 
1.8 3.9 - 10.9 
Labor: Farm 10.5 43.9 7.1 41.3 
Services 3.8 35.7 2.2 - 
Unemployed 14.4 7.7 21.4 4.4 
Not working 48.7 29.2 14.3 8.7 
Others 0.7 - - - 
Total 100(277) 100(13 
0) 
100(14 
) 
100(46 
)
Labor market: Conditions and entitlements (Cont.) 
After all the proportion of underemployed is estimated at 6.5 million. And 
16.5% of the total employed population are under-employed of which 80% 
live in rural areas and 66% of them are women.
Problems of Migrants 
The main problems that migrants face 
1. lack of low cost housing, 
2. physical insecurity, 
3. skewed distribution of the delivery of basic services 
4. and subsequent health problems. 
Housing problems: 
 More than half (53%) of poor migrants live in private slums and 44% squat on public land 
with about 14 square metres space for a family of average five members or 2.7 square 
metres per capita space, which increases almost six times for a non-slum resident. 
 Although poor migrants eventually improve their living spaces, for example replacing 
thatched roofs with corrugated iron sheets for better protection from cold and rain, living 
in such conditions give rise to many health problems, particularly given the combination 
of mud floors, flimsy walls, heat and humidity and torrential monsoon rains (Afsar, 
1999). 
 Squatter settlements are formed with the help of muscle power, strong social networks 
built on kinship ties and district based affinities and with the patronage of political 
leaders.
Problems of Migrants cont. 
Water and sanitation problem: 
 Worse still are the health and environmental risks associated with poor access to water 
and sanitation services, which determine health and environmental safety. 
 Nearly three-quarters of slum dwellers depend largely on outside water taps, which are 
shared by 5-6 families. 
 To fetch water for drinking and cooking, a female slum resident must travel an average 
distance of 69 m daily, adding to her workload and affecting her health and productivity. 
 Nearly 90% of the slum dwellers use hanging and other types of non-sanitary toilets in 
Dhaka city, whereas 90% of non-slum residents have modern toilets and 25% of 
households in small and medium towns have septic tanks.
Problems of Migrants cont. 
Health and health service problems: 
 Morbidity rate is estimated at 52% for slum dwellers and 42% for a female worker in a 
garment factory (Afsar, 1999). 
 Around one-fifth of female garment factory workers also suffer from sexually transmitted 
diseases (Afsar, 2001 and Paul-Majumder, 1998). 
 Lack of safe, affordable transportation, inexpensive one-stop treatment and medical 
facilities increases women’s vulnerability. Institutions providing childcare, health care 
and boarding facilities at affordable prices are rare even in the capital city, and much less 
so in other cities and towns.
Problems of Migrants cont. 
Physical insecurity and negligence: 
 Women are the major victims of deteriorating law and order and the resulting human 
rights violations 
 Hossain, Khan and Seeley (2003) also found that problems of accommodation, sickness 
and disease, robbery and physical harassment loom large for seasonal migrants at 
destination. 
 Hossain, Khan and Seeley (2003) showed how poor migrants are treated as outsiders, 
deprived from entitlements and denied justice at the place of destination. 
The experience of one migrant – Nuru – is one example: 
 “Nuru is 18 years old works as a day laborer. A year ago, he moved to Cox’s Bazaar with a 
work crew for road construction job. They received only three days’ wages though they 
worked 7 days. When Nuru protested, the contractors threatened to kill him. Nuru has faced 
various other hardships as a migrant worker.”
Consequences of Migration 
 The consequences of internal migration remain unclear. They are influenced by a 
range of factors including 
1. Gender, 
2. Space, 
3. Time, 
4. Migration context 
5. And the strength of social capital among migrants. 
 It is widely acknowledged that migration provides material benefits for migrants 
and their families though difficult to prepare cost-benefit analyses from existing 
studies on internal migration.
Consequences of Migration cont. 
Consequences for Long distance Migration: 
 Kuhn’s qualitative study (2000) provides that the costs of a long weekend sojourn from 
Dhaka to Barisal Division could be around Taka 500. Added to the income loss of around 
Taka 100 per day, a four-day trip can consume more than 30% of a month’s potential 
earnings. 
 But, Active support and cooperation from social contacts at destination minimize the costs 
of moving. 
While travel costs and opportunity costs of internal migration depend on the distance 
between origin and destination and types of job, it ultimately also depends on the 
strength of migrants’ social capital at destination and origin. 
 It is finalized according to Hugo that, 
 Remittances do not represent the total economic losses or benefits in areas of origin. 
 As transmission of skills, status and experience, flow of ideas, loss of economic and 
political leaders and social disruption can influence development in the area of origin.
Remittance 
Problems of measuring internal remittance: 
 Remittances from internal migration are difficult to estimate due to the importance of in-kind 
transfer (Not in Cash). 
 It is also difficult to separate the contribution of internal migration from international 
migration since a sending household often has different types of migrant members. 
 Generally, panel data and in-depth interviews are needed to capture the role of 
remittances as a security back-up.
Remittance cont. 
Though remittance measurement is very tough; but estimates from different 
scholars are given below: 
 It is argued that rural-urban remittances range around 12–15% of the rural income for 
Asia and Africa. 
 Kuhn estimated from Matlab in 1996, that the net transfer from sons living in urban or 
overseas destination accounted for 18% of the total income for all households and 27% for 
migrant sending households. 
 Temporary migrants send around 40% of their urban incomes to rural households, which 
increases to 64% for married migrants but declines to 27% in the case of unmarried ones 
(Afsar, 2000a). But why? 
 It’s very simple as a married temporary migrant had left his spouse and children at the 
place of origin. 
 The intensity of social ties and the types of responsibilities that migrants bear at origin 
and destination influence remittances. 
 For example, sons who lived in the city with their conjugal families contributed less than 
their siblings who lived alone in the city (Frankenberg and Kuhn, 2001).
Use of internal remittance 
In Bangladesh, like in many other developing countries, migrants’ households in rural areas 
use remittances 
 Predominantly for consumption 
 Some portion for construction, savings and investment 
 And some portion for education . 
Use of remittance for consumption: 
 Existing evidence suggests that consumption expenditure alone constituted between 
80% and 90% of the remittances. 
 In a country like Bangladesh, where half of rural households live below the poverty 
line, priorities on consumption expenditure can be viewed as consonant with ‘basic 
needs’ approach to development; without this the situation of families of migrants 
would have been worse off (Afsar, 2000b). 
 Hossain et al (2002) suggest that remittances contributed 12.8% to the household 
income whereas trade and business enterprises accounted for 22%. 
 A 10% increase in income would lead to 6.5% increase in the demand for food items.
Use of remittance cont. 
Use of remittance for savings, investment: 
 From the existing data, we can say only that savings and funding from friends and relatives 
constituted around four-fifths of the initial capital invested in those enterprises but how much 
of the savings are generated from the remittances is not clear. 
 However, existing estimates (Hossain et al 2003b) also suggest that income gains from 
business are the most unequally distributed source of income, followed by services and non-rice 
agriculture, benefiting the higher income groups more than others. 
 House repairs, including extensions, building a new room and replacing thatch with 
corrugated iron roofing sheets, also consumes a significant proportion of remittances. 
 Investment in housing not only helps to expand business in construction materials but also 
gives rural families protection from natural calamities. In addition, it minmizes production 
and storage benefits. 
 Productive use of remittances to purchase irrigation equipment, to establish shops and other 
businesses also show up in survey data and case studies (Kuhn, 2000).
Use of remittance cont. 
Use of remittance for Education 
 Around 40% of temporary migrants’ families also used remittances to educate children and 
treat sick members. 
 Existing studies (Afsar, 2001b) reveal that remitters among RMG workers, predominantly sent 
money directly for family maintenance and education of siblings. 
 School enrolment rates among members of migrants’ families in rural areas is greater 
compared with age cohorts of non-migrant families (Rahman et al 1996).
Migration and poverty 
Migration have Positive effect for Rural but in some context negative effect for urban 
areas. 
Positive effect: 
1. Role of migration on Land in Rural: 
 Land-poor households before 1990s was much dependent but in the 1990s are much less 
dependent on the agricultural labor market. 
 Hossain et al (2003b) estimated that the proportion of agricultural workers was halved 
between 1987 and 2000, due to greater employment opportunities generated in the rural 
non-farm sector (labor transition). 
 A new ‘class’ of people has emerged in rural areas, which depends more on physical and 
human capital than on land and manual labor (laborer transition).
Role of migration on Land in rural cont. 
 The incidence of tenancy has increased, thus providing additional access to land 
for land-poor households. 
 For example, Hossain et al 2002 told that most of the tenants are small landowners 
who find it economical to rent land to increase the capacity-use of the farm 
establishment. 
% of Land Tenancy 
47% 40% 13% 
50% 
0% 
<0.2 hect 0.2-1 hect >1 hect 
 Rural-urban migration stimulated land tenancy. Hossain et al (2002) observed that, in 
rural areas, 1.3% of the owned land was sold, compared with 1.7% of owned land in 
1987/88; land purchase was reported at 2% in 1999/00. 
 The higher incidence of land purchase compared to land sale indicates the important 
contribution of rural-urban migration to the land market in a land-scarce country.
Migration and poverty cont. 
2. Role of migration on some important structural changes: 
 Income from agriculture declined from 59% to 44%, whilst income from trade, services and 
remittances increased from 35% in 1987/88 to 49% in 1999/00. 
 Hossain et al (2002) also observed that the most dramatic increase has been in the share of 
remittances from relatives who migrated to cities and overseas. 
 The proportion of households receiving remittances in 1999/00 was 21%, almost double the 11% 
of such households in 1987/88. 
 The contribution of remittances to household income has increased significantly from 7.3% to 
12.8% over the period, registering 8.1% annual growth when per capita income grew at 3.2%.
Role of migration on some important structural changes cont. 
 Some positive consequences of migration 
 Landless and land-poor farmers have left the agricultural labour market for tenancies. 
 Wage labour in trade and business enterprises, 
 Rickshaw pulling and other manual non-agricultural activities. 
 Members of medium and large landowning households – with correspondingly larger 
endowments of human and physical capital – switched from cultivating their own farms 
to services and business. 
 As a result, the proportion of poor people dropped to 43% in 2000 from 59% in 
1988, a reduction of 1.2% per year. 
Year % of poor people 
1988 43% 
2000 59% 
 There is no direct estimate of the contribution of remittances to poverty alleviation 
but, indirectly, some conjecture can be made in this regard.
Role migration on Poverty Reduction 
 From the panel data from rural sending areas, Rahman et al (1996) found that the 
extent of poverty was much lower for households having migrant members, much 
lower than for non-migrant households. 
% of poor as different household 
30% 
60% 
Migrants household Non-migrant household 
 The proportion of those who perceived themselves poor or extremely poor 
declined from around 60% to 30% between 1990 and 1995, a -26.7% change. 
 In the case of non-migrant households, a large number (54%) still considered 
themselves poor or extremely poor and only a small proportion perceived (8.7%) 
improvement in their situation compared to 1991.
Negative effect migration 
 Rural-urban migration is often considered to be a process of transferring rural 
poverty to urban areas. 
 From their longitudinal study of Dhaka city, Hossain et al (1999) came out with the 
following startling results, which challenge this conventional wisdom: 
 For households in slum and squatter settlements, the head count ratio for 
moderate poverty was estimated at 79% in 1991; this dropped to a staggering low 
of 49% in 1998 and extreme poverty from 44.5% to 23%. These are basically 
migrant populations from the landless and marginal landholding households in 
rural areas.
Migration and Inequality: at the place of origin 
Internal migration is often considered a source of intra-village inequality because…… 
 better-off villages and villagers learn first, and are able to avail new job opportunities 
 whereas the extreme poor groups are generally excluded from such opportunities (Skeldon, 
1997). 
However, this negative picture should not be generalized.
Migration and Inequality: at the place of destination 
 At the place of destination however, existing evidence suggests growing inequality 
between the rich and the poor. 
 A longitudinal study on migration in Dhaka city (Hossain et al, 1999) indicates 
worsening of income distribution between slum and non-slum residents. 
 Slum dwellers, who are predominantly migrants from rural areas, earned around 
one-third of the income of non-slum households in 1991; this declined to one fifth in 
1998. 
 The bottom 40% saw their income drop from 17% of the income of non-slum 
households to 11% while the top 10% increased from 27% to 42%.
Migration and Inequality: at the place of destination cont. 
 The gini concentration ratio, a measure of income inequality, is estimated at 0.53, a 
staggering increase from 0.39 in 1991. 
 Urban inequality is not limited to income distribution but also leads to stunted 
development of human capital of poorer communities. 
 Although the enrolment rate of their age cohorts in slum and squatter settlements in 
Dhaka city rose from 41% to 58% between 1991 and 1998, more than 40% of the 
children remained out of school. 
 Little wonder, then, that Hossain et al (1999) found that nearly one-third of children in 
the 10–15 years age group from slums and squatters were in the labour force; the 
incidence of child labour remained almost unchanged between 1991 and 1998. 
 Thus, although the urban population have been ahead of the rural population on 
both poverty and social development indicators generally, the urban poor in general 
and migrants in particular find it difficult to sustain economic gains in the longer run, 
due to intra-urban inequality in income and delivery of social services.
Strategy for Poverty alleviation and economic growth 
 In Bangladesh poverty is considered as one of the key drivers of the rural-urban 
migration. 
 Government ,International agencies and donors focus on Poverty alleviation and 
economic growth through they failed to provide any direct policies and programs 
for internal migration . 
Government Strategy 
Pro-Poor economic 
Growth 
Women’s 
Human Development Advancement 
Diminishing Gender 
gaps 
Social safety 
Participatory 
Governance
International and National GOs /NGOs to develop the 
capacity of small and medium town 
International GOs /NGOs GOs/ NGOs in Bangladesh 
1. World Bank : With the help of Local 
Government and Engineering Department they 
initiated project to build capacity and effective 
financial management of Khulna and Rajshahi 
City Corporations and 14 municipalities, or 
Pourashava, since 1999. 
2. UNDP :Promoting broader participation in 
local decision making and building the 
capacity of locally elected bodies to better 
deliver services and to enable communities to 
address their development needs. 
3.UNICEF : Runs water, sanitation and 
primary health care programs for urban street 
children , they also use the mass media to 
promote girls’ education, water sanitation and 
public health issues including dengue 
prevention and arsenic contamination 
4. UNCHR : They is primarily work to 
rehabilitate poor migrants and refugees. 
Bastuhara Federation or federation of 
landless, which is a political 
organization involved predominantly 
in advocacy for the rehabilitation of 
squatters in major cities 
Coalition for the Urban Poor (CUP), 
working for poverty alleviation in 
urban poor communities mainly in 
Dhaka City, the bulk of whom are 
migrants from rural areas. 
Ain-O-Salish kendro works for the 
human rights and legal aids of 
migrants 
Nari Udyog Kendro (NUK), addresses 
governance and gender issues in the 
development process and caters to the 
housing needs of the city’s low-income 
and migrant women workers
 Government fails to provide an effective regional development framework for 
decentralizing the industrial process around the secondary towns and periurban areas 
due to 
1. Mismanagement. 
2. Corruption . 
Limitations of the strategy 
 The National Rural Development Policy 2001 was formulated to enhance the capacity and 
power of the rural poor to develop, protect and sustain their livelihoods but no such policy 
has been formulated for urban areas. 
 It also fails to outline any mechanism to cover the extreme poor and migrant groups, which 
find themselves largely outside of existing social security schemes of government. 
 It didn’t mention infrastructural development of periurban and small towns as a 
precondition for business investment and creating new job opportunities . 
 Without decentralizing power, finance and other services at the upazila/thana level, and 
without an effective policy framework for regional development, it is difficult to implement 
participatory governance.
Government’s poverty alleviation strategy (Poverty Reduction Strategy Paper, 
PRSP) must address the following issues : 
1) Important role of 
migration in reducing 
rural poverty by 
expanding rural land and 
labor markets and making 
more rural land available 
for tenancy. 
2) Migration has raised rural 
productivity and created 
scope for innovation by 
increasing the use of 
mechanism 
3)The needs of the migrants, 
particularly urban poor 
migrants who often suffer 
eviction, ill health and other 
problems. 
4)Vulnerable groups can be 
picked up from the work 
place, organized as 
occupational groups and 
provided with loans, food-for- 
work and other facilities 
on a daily basis 
Key Policy Issues 
Firstly 
Secondly 
Thirdly 
1)Remittances from internal 
migration generate both 
direct and indirect benefits 
with short-term, long-term 
and multiplier effects on 
poverty alleviation, regional 
development and the overall 
development of the country 
2) internal remittances 
Should be convert to 
Deposit 
Pension Scheme (DPS), so 
that remittances can be 
potential for development 
work as well as generating 
savings for land-poor 
groups 
1)Government strategy 
for poverty alleviation 
should add spatial and 
regional dimensions for 
development. 
2) Migration is a dominant 
force behind the coastal 
region ‘s impressive progress 
in poverty alleviation. So , 
3) Flood-prone regions and 
those with favourable 
ecosytems must be given 
priority attention 
in order to expand labour 
productivity and provide 
greater scope for 
occupational mobility.
Gaps in the implication of the strategy 
 There is profound disparity in income distribution and service delivery between 
space, class and gender, which often hinders the pace of poverty reduction. 
 Though government allocates around 20% of the development budget for local 
government and rural development. there are some inconsistencies between the 
PRSP objectives and budgetary allocations. 
 The class and gender dimension of poverty and inequality are 
considered, the spatial dimension of poverty and inequality get scanty 
attention in the PRSP. 
Basically without a regional development framework, 
decentralisation efforts will remain ad hoc and the growing 
inequality in income and services distribution cannot be 
controlled effectively.
Recommendation 
1) Telecommunications and other information technologies should be expanded as this 
would not only create employment opportunities but also help to decentralize businesses 
from large cities to potentially lower-cost smaller cities 
2) Small and medium towns can be made more attractive by developing infrastructure and 
communication, particularly efficient and safe transportation, and providing a good 
standard of social services such as hospitals, schools and colleges. 
3) With increasing urbanization, migrant women are likely to form a larger and larger 
proportion of the work force so policies should be favorable to female labor . 
 All labour legislation must be brought under a new labour code to ensure effective implementation 
and monitoring and it will provide written employment contracts of working hours and wage 
rates, overtime hours and rates, holidays, dismissal and retrenchment procedures to ensure labour 
right 
 Workers should be given proper skill training to equip with the changing nature of jobs through 
the private sector and NGOs. 
4) To ensure low-cost housing and hostel facilities for migrant factory workers, NGOs and 
housing companies may be given khas land at a reduced price.
Thank you for your patience 
Do you have any question? 
Please 
ASK……………….

More Related Content

What's hot

Rural Development and Planning of Bangladesh
Rural Development and Planning of BangladeshRural Development and Planning of Bangladesh
Rural Development and Planning of Bangladesh
Mohammad Mohaiminul Islam
 
Migration and its effects on urban life
Migration and its effects on urban lifeMigration and its effects on urban life
Migration and its effects on urban life
Rithika Ravishankar
 
URBANIZATION IN BANGLADESH PRESENT STATUS AND EMERGING CHALLENGES
URBANIZATION IN BANGLADESH PRESENT STATUS AND EMERGING CHALLENGESURBANIZATION IN BANGLADESH PRESENT STATUS AND EMERGING CHALLENGES
URBANIZATION IN BANGLADESH PRESENT STATUS AND EMERGING CHALLENGES
Surkhet technical Institute
 
Regional disperities
Regional disperitiesRegional disperities
Regional disperities
Himangshu Bailung
 
Bangladesh national environment policy
Bangladesh national environment policyBangladesh national environment policy
Bangladesh national environment policy
Parent Construction & Consultancy Ltd.
 
URBAN POVERTY
URBAN POVERTYURBAN POVERTY
URBAN POVERTY
shahkhushbu
 
Urbanization in bangladesh
Urbanization in bangladeshUrbanization in bangladesh
Urbanization in bangladesh
Mir Rasel
 
Urbanization
UrbanizationUrbanization
Urbanization
Aditya Kushwaha
 
Rural and urban poverty
Rural and urban povertyRural and urban poverty
Rural and urban poverty
Jubayer Alam Shoikat
 
Population data in the context of Bangladesh
Population data in the context of BangladeshPopulation data in the context of Bangladesh
Population data in the context of Bangladesh
Mohammad Mohaiminul Islam
 
Urbanisation in bangladesh : Recent trends and challenges
Urbanisation in bangladesh : Recent trends and challengesUrbanisation in bangladesh : Recent trends and challenges
Urbanisation in bangladesh : Recent trends and challenges
Reyad Hossain
 
Harris-Todaro Migration Model and it's Applicability in Bangladesh
Harris-Todaro Migration Model and it's Applicability in BangladeshHarris-Todaro Migration Model and it's Applicability in Bangladesh
Harris-Todaro Migration Model and it's Applicability in BangladeshMohaiminul Islam
 
Presentation population Problem in Bangladesh
Presentation  population Problem in BangladeshPresentation  population Problem in Bangladesh
Presentation population Problem in Bangladesh
Mia Manik
 
Origin of culture :Cultural hearth and cultural realm, cultural region.
Origin of culture :Cultural hearth and cultural realm, cultural region.Origin of culture :Cultural hearth and cultural realm, cultural region.
Origin of culture :Cultural hearth and cultural realm, cultural region.
RAJKUMARPOREL
 
URBANIZATION & MIGRATION
 URBANIZATION & MIGRATION URBANIZATION & MIGRATION
URBANIZATION & MIGRATION
Eminent Planners
 
Urbanization
UrbanizationUrbanization
Urbanization
Deighton Gooden
 
Migration
MigrationMigration
Urbanization
UrbanizationUrbanization
Urbanization
GCUF
 
Social Indicators and Well-being
Social Indicators and Well-beingSocial Indicators and Well-being
Social Indicators and Well-being
Mary Krystle Dawn Sulleza
 
A Short Presentation on Migration : A Bangladesh Perspective
A Short Presentation on Migration : A Bangladesh PerspectiveA Short Presentation on Migration : A Bangladesh Perspective
A Short Presentation on Migration : A Bangladesh Perspective
Rifat Jamal
 

What's hot (20)

Rural Development and Planning of Bangladesh
Rural Development and Planning of BangladeshRural Development and Planning of Bangladesh
Rural Development and Planning of Bangladesh
 
Migration and its effects on urban life
Migration and its effects on urban lifeMigration and its effects on urban life
Migration and its effects on urban life
 
URBANIZATION IN BANGLADESH PRESENT STATUS AND EMERGING CHALLENGES
URBANIZATION IN BANGLADESH PRESENT STATUS AND EMERGING CHALLENGESURBANIZATION IN BANGLADESH PRESENT STATUS AND EMERGING CHALLENGES
URBANIZATION IN BANGLADESH PRESENT STATUS AND EMERGING CHALLENGES
 
Regional disperities
Regional disperitiesRegional disperities
Regional disperities
 
Bangladesh national environment policy
Bangladesh national environment policyBangladesh national environment policy
Bangladesh national environment policy
 
URBAN POVERTY
URBAN POVERTYURBAN POVERTY
URBAN POVERTY
 
Urbanization in bangladesh
Urbanization in bangladeshUrbanization in bangladesh
Urbanization in bangladesh
 
Urbanization
UrbanizationUrbanization
Urbanization
 
Rural and urban poverty
Rural and urban povertyRural and urban poverty
Rural and urban poverty
 
Population data in the context of Bangladesh
Population data in the context of BangladeshPopulation data in the context of Bangladesh
Population data in the context of Bangladesh
 
Urbanisation in bangladesh : Recent trends and challenges
Urbanisation in bangladesh : Recent trends and challengesUrbanisation in bangladesh : Recent trends and challenges
Urbanisation in bangladesh : Recent trends and challenges
 
Harris-Todaro Migration Model and it's Applicability in Bangladesh
Harris-Todaro Migration Model and it's Applicability in BangladeshHarris-Todaro Migration Model and it's Applicability in Bangladesh
Harris-Todaro Migration Model and it's Applicability in Bangladesh
 
Presentation population Problem in Bangladesh
Presentation  population Problem in BangladeshPresentation  population Problem in Bangladesh
Presentation population Problem in Bangladesh
 
Origin of culture :Cultural hearth and cultural realm, cultural region.
Origin of culture :Cultural hearth and cultural realm, cultural region.Origin of culture :Cultural hearth and cultural realm, cultural region.
Origin of culture :Cultural hearth and cultural realm, cultural region.
 
URBANIZATION & MIGRATION
 URBANIZATION & MIGRATION URBANIZATION & MIGRATION
URBANIZATION & MIGRATION
 
Urbanization
UrbanizationUrbanization
Urbanization
 
Migration
MigrationMigration
Migration
 
Urbanization
UrbanizationUrbanization
Urbanization
 
Social Indicators and Well-being
Social Indicators and Well-beingSocial Indicators and Well-being
Social Indicators and Well-being
 
A Short Presentation on Migration : A Bangladesh Perspective
A Short Presentation on Migration : A Bangladesh PerspectiveA Short Presentation on Migration : A Bangladesh Perspective
A Short Presentation on Migration : A Bangladesh Perspective
 

Viewers also liked

Siegel Keynote, Migration and Development Conference, January 2014
Siegel Keynote, Migration and Development Conference, January 2014Siegel Keynote, Migration and Development Conference, January 2014
Siegel Keynote, Migration and Development Conference, January 2014UNU-MERIT
 
Top Ideas for Migration
Top Ideas for MigrationTop Ideas for Migration
Top Ideas for Migration
Copenhagen_Consensus
 
Migration And Push Pull Factors
Migration And Push Pull FactorsMigration And Push Pull Factors
Migration And Push Pull Factorstudorgeog
 
Contribution of Urban Informal Settlement Dwellers to Urban Economy in India
Contribution of Urban Informal Settlement Dwellers to Urban Economy in IndiaContribution of Urban Informal Settlement Dwellers to Urban Economy in India
Contribution of Urban Informal Settlement Dwellers to Urban Economy in India
Indicus Analytics Private Limited
 
Business Model for Smart Migration from Bangladesh - Brandwitz 2015 - Round 3...
Business Model for Smart Migration from Bangladesh - Brandwitz 2015 - Round 3...Business Model for Smart Migration from Bangladesh - Brandwitz 2015 - Round 3...
Business Model for Smart Migration from Bangladesh - Brandwitz 2015 - Round 3...
Sayem Faruk
 
International labour migration
International labour migrationInternational labour migration
International labour migrationpriyesh_karne
 
Research problem, criteria and characteristics
Research problem, criteria and characteristicsResearch problem, criteria and characteristics
Research problem, criteria and characteristics
Zakiul Alam
 
Unemployment & inflation presentation
Unemployment & inflation presentationUnemployment & inflation presentation
Unemployment & inflation presentationSiyamcela Finiza
 
Rural Urban Migration Ledc
Rural Urban Migration LedcRural Urban Migration Ledc
Rural Urban Migration Ledcwhiskeyhj
 

Viewers also liked (9)

Siegel Keynote, Migration and Development Conference, January 2014
Siegel Keynote, Migration and Development Conference, January 2014Siegel Keynote, Migration and Development Conference, January 2014
Siegel Keynote, Migration and Development Conference, January 2014
 
Top Ideas for Migration
Top Ideas for MigrationTop Ideas for Migration
Top Ideas for Migration
 
Migration And Push Pull Factors
Migration And Push Pull FactorsMigration And Push Pull Factors
Migration And Push Pull Factors
 
Contribution of Urban Informal Settlement Dwellers to Urban Economy in India
Contribution of Urban Informal Settlement Dwellers to Urban Economy in IndiaContribution of Urban Informal Settlement Dwellers to Urban Economy in India
Contribution of Urban Informal Settlement Dwellers to Urban Economy in India
 
Business Model for Smart Migration from Bangladesh - Brandwitz 2015 - Round 3...
Business Model for Smart Migration from Bangladesh - Brandwitz 2015 - Round 3...Business Model for Smart Migration from Bangladesh - Brandwitz 2015 - Round 3...
Business Model for Smart Migration from Bangladesh - Brandwitz 2015 - Round 3...
 
International labour migration
International labour migrationInternational labour migration
International labour migration
 
Research problem, criteria and characteristics
Research problem, criteria and characteristicsResearch problem, criteria and characteristics
Research problem, criteria and characteristics
 
Unemployment & inflation presentation
Unemployment & inflation presentationUnemployment & inflation presentation
Unemployment & inflation presentation
 
Rural Urban Migration Ledc
Rural Urban Migration LedcRural Urban Migration Ledc
Rural Urban Migration Ledc
 

Similar to Internal migration and the development nexus,the case of bangladesh

First record of two spotted stink bug, Perillus bioculatus (Fab.) from Meerut...
First record of two spotted stink bug, Perillus bioculatus (Fab.) from Meerut...First record of two spotted stink bug, Perillus bioculatus (Fab.) from Meerut...
First record of two spotted stink bug, Perillus bioculatus (Fab.) from Meerut...
Agriculture Journal IJOEAR
 
Determinants of internal migration in tanzania
Determinants of internal migration in tanzaniaDeterminants of internal migration in tanzania
Determinants of internal migration in tanzania
Alexander Decker
 
The urban poor get poor attention
The urban poor get poor attentionThe urban poor get poor attention
The urban poor get poor attention
M S Siddiqui
 
Reverse Migration Due to Long Lockdown in India- Is it Sustainable?
Reverse Migration Due to Long Lockdown in India- Is it Sustainable?Reverse Migration Due to Long Lockdown in India- Is it Sustainable?
Reverse Migration Due to Long Lockdown in India- Is it Sustainable?
Dr. Amarjeet Singh
 
3 ijreh mar-2018-3-evaluating the factors impact
3 ijreh mar-2018-3-evaluating the factors impact3 ijreh mar-2018-3-evaluating the factors impact
3 ijreh mar-2018-3-evaluating the factors impact
AI Publications
 
Lecture 3
Lecture 3Lecture 3
Lecture 3
Bernard Oduro
 
IRJET- A Geographical Evaluation of Daily Migration a Case Study of Surro...
IRJET-  	  A Geographical Evaluation of Daily Migration a Case Study of Surro...IRJET-  	  A Geographical Evaluation of Daily Migration a Case Study of Surro...
IRJET- A Geographical Evaluation of Daily Migration a Case Study of Surro...
IRJET Journal
 
Supporting the livelihood transition: jobs, migration, women and girls
Supporting the livelihood transition: jobs, migration, women and girls Supporting the livelihood transition: jobs, migration, women and girls
Supporting the livelihood transition: jobs, migration, women and girls
Migrating out of Poverty
 
Ageing&migrationin cambodia26dec2013 (1)
Ageing&migrationin cambodia26dec2013 (1)Ageing&migrationin cambodia26dec2013 (1)
Ageing&migrationin cambodia26dec2013 (1)Sopheak Sem
 
Migration Report of Jharkhand
Migration Report of JharkhandMigration Report of Jharkhand
Migration Report of Jharkhand
SLDIndia
 
Access to agricultural extension services of marginalized farmers
Access to agricultural extension services of marginalized farmersAccess to agricultural extension services of marginalized farmers
Access to agricultural extension services of marginalized farmersHalim Miah
 
D0353019024
D0353019024D0353019024
D0353019024
inventionjournals
 
Intra State Migration, Migrants and their Socio Economic Condition A Case Stu...
Intra State Migration, Migrants and their Socio Economic Condition A Case Stu...Intra State Migration, Migrants and their Socio Economic Condition A Case Stu...
Intra State Migration, Migrants and their Socio Economic Condition A Case Stu...
ijtsrd
 
Permanent Migration and Remittances in Ethiopia
Permanent Migration and Remittances in EthiopiaPermanent Migration and Remittances in Ethiopia
Permanent Migration and Remittances in Ethiopia
essp2
 
Population Structures
Population StructuresPopulation Structures
Population Structures
PLANETGE0GRAPHY
 
Internal migration and poverty reduction in ghana
Internal migration and poverty reduction in ghanaInternal migration and poverty reduction in ghana
Internal migration and poverty reduction in ghana
Alexander Decker
 
Population of class 9
Population of class 9Population of class 9
Population of class 9
kendriya vidyalaya
 
GEO101- Assignment-- The impact of Bangladesh's demographic features on its e...
GEO101- Assignment-- The impact of Bangladesh's demographic features on its e...GEO101- Assignment-- The impact of Bangladesh's demographic features on its e...
GEO101- Assignment-- The impact of Bangladesh's demographic features on its e...
Samiya Yesmin
 

Similar to Internal migration and the development nexus,the case of bangladesh (20)

First record of two spotted stink bug, Perillus bioculatus (Fab.) from Meerut...
First record of two spotted stink bug, Perillus bioculatus (Fab.) from Meerut...First record of two spotted stink bug, Perillus bioculatus (Fab.) from Meerut...
First record of two spotted stink bug, Perillus bioculatus (Fab.) from Meerut...
 
Determinants of internal migration in tanzania
Determinants of internal migration in tanzaniaDeterminants of internal migration in tanzania
Determinants of internal migration in tanzania
 
6. migration
6. migration6. migration
6. migration
 
The urban poor get poor attention
The urban poor get poor attentionThe urban poor get poor attention
The urban poor get poor attention
 
Reverse Migration Due to Long Lockdown in India- Is it Sustainable?
Reverse Migration Due to Long Lockdown in India- Is it Sustainable?Reverse Migration Due to Long Lockdown in India- Is it Sustainable?
Reverse Migration Due to Long Lockdown in India- Is it Sustainable?
 
3 ijreh mar-2018-3-evaluating the factors impact
3 ijreh mar-2018-3-evaluating the factors impact3 ijreh mar-2018-3-evaluating the factors impact
3 ijreh mar-2018-3-evaluating the factors impact
 
Lecture 3
Lecture 3Lecture 3
Lecture 3
 
10320140501003
1032014050100310320140501003
10320140501003
 
IRJET- A Geographical Evaluation of Daily Migration a Case Study of Surro...
IRJET-  	  A Geographical Evaluation of Daily Migration a Case Study of Surro...IRJET-  	  A Geographical Evaluation of Daily Migration a Case Study of Surro...
IRJET- A Geographical Evaluation of Daily Migration a Case Study of Surro...
 
Supporting the livelihood transition: jobs, migration, women and girls
Supporting the livelihood transition: jobs, migration, women and girls Supporting the livelihood transition: jobs, migration, women and girls
Supporting the livelihood transition: jobs, migration, women and girls
 
Ageing&migrationin cambodia26dec2013 (1)
Ageing&migrationin cambodia26dec2013 (1)Ageing&migrationin cambodia26dec2013 (1)
Ageing&migrationin cambodia26dec2013 (1)
 
Migration Report of Jharkhand
Migration Report of JharkhandMigration Report of Jharkhand
Migration Report of Jharkhand
 
Access to agricultural extension services of marginalized farmers
Access to agricultural extension services of marginalized farmersAccess to agricultural extension services of marginalized farmers
Access to agricultural extension services of marginalized farmers
 
D0353019024
D0353019024D0353019024
D0353019024
 
Intra State Migration, Migrants and their Socio Economic Condition A Case Stu...
Intra State Migration, Migrants and their Socio Economic Condition A Case Stu...Intra State Migration, Migrants and their Socio Economic Condition A Case Stu...
Intra State Migration, Migrants and their Socio Economic Condition A Case Stu...
 
Permanent Migration and Remittances in Ethiopia
Permanent Migration and Remittances in EthiopiaPermanent Migration and Remittances in Ethiopia
Permanent Migration and Remittances in Ethiopia
 
Population Structures
Population StructuresPopulation Structures
Population Structures
 
Internal migration and poverty reduction in ghana
Internal migration and poverty reduction in ghanaInternal migration and poverty reduction in ghana
Internal migration and poverty reduction in ghana
 
Population of class 9
Population of class 9Population of class 9
Population of class 9
 
GEO101- Assignment-- The impact of Bangladesh's demographic features on its e...
GEO101- Assignment-- The impact of Bangladesh's demographic features on its e...GEO101- Assignment-- The impact of Bangladesh's demographic features on its e...
GEO101- Assignment-- The impact of Bangladesh's demographic features on its e...
 

Recently uploaded

what is the future of Pi Network currency.
what is the future of Pi Network currency.what is the future of Pi Network currency.
what is the future of Pi Network currency.
DOT TECH
 
Scope Of Macroeconomics introduction and basic theories
Scope Of Macroeconomics introduction and basic theoriesScope Of Macroeconomics introduction and basic theories
Scope Of Macroeconomics introduction and basic theories
nomankalyar153
 
Turin Startup Ecosystem 2024 - Ricerca sulle Startup e il Sistema dell'Innov...
Turin Startup Ecosystem 2024  - Ricerca sulle Startup e il Sistema dell'Innov...Turin Startup Ecosystem 2024  - Ricerca sulle Startup e il Sistema dell'Innov...
Turin Startup Ecosystem 2024 - Ricerca sulle Startup e il Sistema dell'Innov...
Quotidiano Piemontese
 
Greek trade a pillar of dynamic economic growth - European Business Review
Greek trade a pillar of dynamic economic growth - European Business ReviewGreek trade a pillar of dynamic economic growth - European Business Review
Greek trade a pillar of dynamic economic growth - European Business Review
Antonis Zairis
 
Isios-2024-Professional-Independent-Trustee-Survey.pdf
Isios-2024-Professional-Independent-Trustee-Survey.pdfIsios-2024-Professional-Independent-Trustee-Survey.pdf
Isios-2024-Professional-Independent-Trustee-Survey.pdf
Henry Tapper
 
一比一原版UOL毕业证利物浦大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版UOL毕业证利物浦大学毕业证成绩单如何办理一比一原版UOL毕业证利物浦大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版UOL毕业证利物浦大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
ydubwyt
 
when will pi network coin be available on crypto exchange.
when will pi network coin be available on crypto exchange.when will pi network coin be available on crypto exchange.
when will pi network coin be available on crypto exchange.
DOT TECH
 
Monthly Economic Monitoring of Ukraine No. 232, May 2024
Monthly Economic Monitoring of Ukraine No. 232, May 2024Monthly Economic Monitoring of Ukraine No. 232, May 2024
what is the best method to sell pi coins in 2024
what is the best method to sell pi coins in 2024what is the best method to sell pi coins in 2024
what is the best method to sell pi coins in 2024
DOT TECH
 
how to sell pi coins in South Korea profitably.
how to sell pi coins in South Korea profitably.how to sell pi coins in South Korea profitably.
how to sell pi coins in South Korea profitably.
DOT TECH
 
how can I sell my pi coins for cash in a pi APP
how can I sell my pi coins for cash in a pi APPhow can I sell my pi coins for cash in a pi APP
how can I sell my pi coins for cash in a pi APP
DOT TECH
 
The secret way to sell pi coins effortlessly.
The secret way to sell pi coins effortlessly.The secret way to sell pi coins effortlessly.
The secret way to sell pi coins effortlessly.
DOT TECH
 
US Economic Outlook - Being Decided - M Capital Group August 2021.pdf
US Economic Outlook - Being Decided - M Capital Group August 2021.pdfUS Economic Outlook - Being Decided - M Capital Group August 2021.pdf
US Economic Outlook - Being Decided - M Capital Group August 2021.pdf
pchutichetpong
 
how can I sell pi coins after successfully completing KYC
how can I sell pi coins after successfully completing KYChow can I sell pi coins after successfully completing KYC
how can I sell pi coins after successfully completing KYC
DOT TECH
 
innovative-invoice-discounting-platforms-in-india-empowering-retail-investors...
innovative-invoice-discounting-platforms-in-india-empowering-retail-investors...innovative-invoice-discounting-platforms-in-india-empowering-retail-investors...
innovative-invoice-discounting-platforms-in-india-empowering-retail-investors...
Falcon Invoice Discounting
 
Chương 6. Ancol - phenol - ether (1).pdf
Chương 6. Ancol - phenol - ether (1).pdfChương 6. Ancol - phenol - ether (1).pdf
Chương 6. Ancol - phenol - ether (1).pdf
va2132004
 
Summary of financial results for 1Q2024
Summary of financial  results for 1Q2024Summary of financial  results for 1Q2024
Summary of financial results for 1Q2024
InterCars
 
Intro_Economics_ GPresentation Week 4.pptx
Intro_Economics_ GPresentation Week 4.pptxIntro_Economics_ GPresentation Week 4.pptx
Intro_Economics_ GPresentation Week 4.pptx
shetivia
 
USDA Loans in California: A Comprehensive Overview.pptx
USDA Loans in California: A Comprehensive Overview.pptxUSDA Loans in California: A Comprehensive Overview.pptx
USDA Loans in California: A Comprehensive Overview.pptx
marketing367770
 
一比一原版Birmingham毕业证伯明翰大学|学院毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版Birmingham毕业证伯明翰大学|学院毕业证成绩单如何办理一比一原版Birmingham毕业证伯明翰大学|学院毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版Birmingham毕业证伯明翰大学|学院毕业证成绩单如何办理
betoozp
 

Recently uploaded (20)

what is the future of Pi Network currency.
what is the future of Pi Network currency.what is the future of Pi Network currency.
what is the future of Pi Network currency.
 
Scope Of Macroeconomics introduction and basic theories
Scope Of Macroeconomics introduction and basic theoriesScope Of Macroeconomics introduction and basic theories
Scope Of Macroeconomics introduction and basic theories
 
Turin Startup Ecosystem 2024 - Ricerca sulle Startup e il Sistema dell'Innov...
Turin Startup Ecosystem 2024  - Ricerca sulle Startup e il Sistema dell'Innov...Turin Startup Ecosystem 2024  - Ricerca sulle Startup e il Sistema dell'Innov...
Turin Startup Ecosystem 2024 - Ricerca sulle Startup e il Sistema dell'Innov...
 
Greek trade a pillar of dynamic economic growth - European Business Review
Greek trade a pillar of dynamic economic growth - European Business ReviewGreek trade a pillar of dynamic economic growth - European Business Review
Greek trade a pillar of dynamic economic growth - European Business Review
 
Isios-2024-Professional-Independent-Trustee-Survey.pdf
Isios-2024-Professional-Independent-Trustee-Survey.pdfIsios-2024-Professional-Independent-Trustee-Survey.pdf
Isios-2024-Professional-Independent-Trustee-Survey.pdf
 
一比一原版UOL毕业证利物浦大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版UOL毕业证利物浦大学毕业证成绩单如何办理一比一原版UOL毕业证利物浦大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版UOL毕业证利物浦大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
 
when will pi network coin be available on crypto exchange.
when will pi network coin be available on crypto exchange.when will pi network coin be available on crypto exchange.
when will pi network coin be available on crypto exchange.
 
Monthly Economic Monitoring of Ukraine No. 232, May 2024
Monthly Economic Monitoring of Ukraine No. 232, May 2024Monthly Economic Monitoring of Ukraine No. 232, May 2024
Monthly Economic Monitoring of Ukraine No. 232, May 2024
 
what is the best method to sell pi coins in 2024
what is the best method to sell pi coins in 2024what is the best method to sell pi coins in 2024
what is the best method to sell pi coins in 2024
 
how to sell pi coins in South Korea profitably.
how to sell pi coins in South Korea profitably.how to sell pi coins in South Korea profitably.
how to sell pi coins in South Korea profitably.
 
how can I sell my pi coins for cash in a pi APP
how can I sell my pi coins for cash in a pi APPhow can I sell my pi coins for cash in a pi APP
how can I sell my pi coins for cash in a pi APP
 
The secret way to sell pi coins effortlessly.
The secret way to sell pi coins effortlessly.The secret way to sell pi coins effortlessly.
The secret way to sell pi coins effortlessly.
 
US Economic Outlook - Being Decided - M Capital Group August 2021.pdf
US Economic Outlook - Being Decided - M Capital Group August 2021.pdfUS Economic Outlook - Being Decided - M Capital Group August 2021.pdf
US Economic Outlook - Being Decided - M Capital Group August 2021.pdf
 
how can I sell pi coins after successfully completing KYC
how can I sell pi coins after successfully completing KYChow can I sell pi coins after successfully completing KYC
how can I sell pi coins after successfully completing KYC
 
innovative-invoice-discounting-platforms-in-india-empowering-retail-investors...
innovative-invoice-discounting-platforms-in-india-empowering-retail-investors...innovative-invoice-discounting-platforms-in-india-empowering-retail-investors...
innovative-invoice-discounting-platforms-in-india-empowering-retail-investors...
 
Chương 6. Ancol - phenol - ether (1).pdf
Chương 6. Ancol - phenol - ether (1).pdfChương 6. Ancol - phenol - ether (1).pdf
Chương 6. Ancol - phenol - ether (1).pdf
 
Summary of financial results for 1Q2024
Summary of financial  results for 1Q2024Summary of financial  results for 1Q2024
Summary of financial results for 1Q2024
 
Intro_Economics_ GPresentation Week 4.pptx
Intro_Economics_ GPresentation Week 4.pptxIntro_Economics_ GPresentation Week 4.pptx
Intro_Economics_ GPresentation Week 4.pptx
 
USDA Loans in California: A Comprehensive Overview.pptx
USDA Loans in California: A Comprehensive Overview.pptxUSDA Loans in California: A Comprehensive Overview.pptx
USDA Loans in California: A Comprehensive Overview.pptx
 
一比一原版Birmingham毕业证伯明翰大学|学院毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版Birmingham毕业证伯明翰大学|学院毕业证成绩单如何办理一比一原版Birmingham毕业证伯明翰大学|学院毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版Birmingham毕业证伯明翰大学|学院毕业证成绩单如何办理
 

Internal migration and the development nexus,the case of bangladesh

  • 1. “Internal migration and the development nexus: the case of Bangladesh -by Rita Afsar” Date: 6. 05. 2014 Md. Zakiul Alam Roll: ZH013 BSS (Hons) 5th Semester Dept. Of Population Sciences University of Dhaka
  • 2. Introduction  The land of Bangladesh has been changed rapidly because of mobility of people having questions about development strategies. Migration has great impact on people’s daily strategies and in the national economy like markets, communications and transportation and availability of electricity.  The rural area is no longer confined to food production but is now a source of labor for urban areas. Rural urban migration is one of the forces of changing among growing diversity and complexity in the patterns of migration. Changes through rural, the linkage between migration and development need to be re-examined. A lack of knowledge about the migration and poverty facing in Bangladesh.  Government policies can influence the impact of migration on development and poverty reduction. Knowledge about migration and the policy context in the country to enable DFID to understand and work toward maximizing the benefits of migration for poverty reduction and to promote the rights of poor migrants.
  • 3. Objective and Structure of this Article This paper summarizes what is known about migration and the policy context in the country to enable DFID to understand and work toward maximizing the benefits of migration for poverty reduction and to promote the rights of poor migrants.  The paper aims to review existing policies related to migration in order to examine the relationship between migration and development.  In doing so, this paper examines:  The patterns and trends of internal migration in Bangladesh  Profile of migrants  Labor markets – conditions and entitlements  Key problems faced by migrants  Consequences of migration including remittances, migration and poverty and inequality  Policies issues …….. I. Government policies and instruments II. Policies and programmes of international agencies and donors III. Welfare entitlements IV. Main pro-poor organisations working to support migrants V. Key policy issues, gaps, drivers of change and recommendations
  • 4. Scale and Determinants of Migration  Existing sample vital registration system such as BBS suggest that life time internal migration has increased significantly and the proportion of lifetime migrants doubled between 1974 and 1982 and reached 10.2% in 1991.  Migration pattern changes according to gender, 40% male migrant and 28% female migrant moved from rural to urban areas.  Marital migration and intra district migration are the important reason of rural-urban movement.  The net migration increased in urban areas than in rural areas .From panel data generated ,62 randomly sampled villages in Bangladesh, Rahman et.al(1996),found that nearly two- thirds of emigration from rural to urban areas. The figure for rural-rural migration was 10% and was 24%for overseas migration.
  • 5. Scale and Determinants of Migration cont.  Rural-urban migration is the most dominant form of migration. This is especially true for 17 coastal district where accreted fertile char land is the cause of the violent confliction.  According to Kuhn's study of Matlab Thana (2000), he found that loss of homestead land does not necessarily lead to emigration. Sometimes debt seldom results in seizure of homestead lands unless the family’s local social ties are extremely weak.  The lack of year round employment in rural areas or recurrent flooding of coastal and other district can also push people into migration. Such as –Faridpur, Barisal, Noakhali, Rajbari and Sirajgong are the example of such district. Furthermore, migrants maintain connection with their natal families. In the context of limited provision of insurance and social security services, urban-rural co-operation and mutual support are important for both migrants and their natal families.
  • 6. Migration and urbanization  Migration is one of the major contributors to urban growth in Bangladesh. The proportion of people living in urban areas rose from 6.2 in 1965 to 9.9% in 1975 and reached 25% in 2000( UN 2002).  To reveal migration pattern and trend, we use sex ratios as indicator of emigration or immigration. cities with high sex ratios are generally considered to be receivers of migrant and those with lower sex ratios are considered to be sending areas. For instances 1. Theremetropolitan is a positive correlation between higher sex ratio and and higher urban growth for all cities. A high sex ratio suggests that more men than women migrated to the cities. Chittagong had the highest sex ratios of 155 in 1974 but in 2001 it was declining only 119. sex ratio for Dhaka 123,Khulna 112 and for rajshahi 110 in 2001. 2. Among cities with population of 100000 or more a higher sex ratio is found in higher urban growth. For example Sylhet, Bogra ,Rangpur,and Jessore. cities where lower urban growth found lower sex ratio.Saidpur,Jamalpur and Tangail.Barsal and Nawabgonj are the exception. 3. There is a close relationship between rapid urbanization and significant demographic change. for example Dhaka ,Chittagong,Khulna urbanized rapidly and also show high sex ratios. These cities benefited either from industrial or high agricultural growth.
  • 7. Profile of Migrants  Migrants are predominantly young adults from low- income families.  But the traditional picture of young males leaving their villages is changing as more and more women migrants are more informed about job opportunities at work destinations. Selectivity of Migration:  Age  Household surveys at destination shows that 75% of temporary, 50% of permanent and 33% of non-migrants of Dhaka city were 15 to 34 years of age.  Of the female labor force in RMG factories, 90% were under 30 years of age
  • 8. Profile of Migrants cont.  Marital Status  Almost 90% of permanent migrants and non-migrants were married at the time of the survey.  In contrast, nearly half of temporary migrants were never married.  For female workers, almost half were never married and less than 10% were divorced/widowed or separated; the remainder were married.  Among the extreme poor, the divorced and widowed women were more likely to migrate.  Gender  The RMG sector absorbed more than 1.5 million workers in the mid-1990s of which 70% were women and more than 90% were migrants.  In other industries such as food processing, pharmaceuticals and electronics, migrants constitute about half of the work force and the gender ratio is almost balanced.
  • 9. Profile of Migrants contd.  Socio-economic Background  Generally it is the landless who migrate as they have nothing to lose.  At the other end, are those who have enough resources to take the risk.  Thus 3/4 of women and 2/3 of men working in RMG factories were functionally landless.  Migrants to slums had only one year of schooling and were predominantly engaged as agricultural workers prior to migration.  On average, a non-poor migrant had 8 years’ education and they migrated mainly to give their children a better education. The extreme poor and destitute also migrated to earn money for survival in a situation of social exclusion and having little or no supportive networks.
  • 10. Labour market: Conditions and entitlements  Studies on internal migration clearly demonstrate that greater job opportunities in the cities and metropolitan areas ‘pulled’ migrants from rural areas (Skeldon, 1997; Hugo 1991; Afsar 1999, 2000).  Around 50% migrants came in Dhaka city had been agricultural labourers.  The migrants choose to migrate in nearer towns, cities or metropolitans in search for more income in non agricultural sector. But Why?  Because estimation about agricultural growth is that agricultural income was less then 1% as opposed to nearly 6% in annual income in non agricultural income between 1988 to 1995. rural landless agricultural workers has a little incentive in agriculture sector. As a result, they choose to migrate. But there has a risk of unemployment(Todaro).  Most of the rural poor migrants settle in the slum.  ¾th of the rural migrants are secured their first job by the help of their social networks.  Every three of five get their works/jobs within one weeks(Afsar, 1999). About 1/3 of migrants had information about his/her jobs before migration by their kin networks.
  • 11. Labour market: Conditions and entitlements cont.  The unemployment rate of active-age migrants is 4% which is almost double to the non migrants age cohorts.  The fact is that poor people hardly try to remain unemployed, as a result they migrate to the nearest towns or cities to relief their unemployment & poverty temporarily. Thus unemployment rate is almost smaller in the case of recent than long term migrant.  Low and irregular payment of wages is so widely even in the formal sector. Because there is no labour entitlements for formal sector and informal sector workers enjoy no such provision.  Nearly half of the RMG sectors workers leave jobs for the particular reasons.  Income difference between male and female RMG workers remains at a quarter. Had they not migrated they would have remained either unemployment or under employment. This is a particular true for women that the scope wage employment is extremely limited in rural areas. Around one-tenth of the rural forces is engaged as employee and one-fourth of them as day labourer (BBS, 2002).
  • 12. Labour market: Conditions and entitlements in the formal sector Worker strategy Income (monthly) Wage Others Working hours Paid leave and other entitlements Factory Condition Skilled/RMG Male 2000 500 11.1 Nearly 2/3rd of worker do not receive appointment letters, 1/5th male and 1/3rd female worker had salary cuts for taking sick leave, more than 1/3rd also do not enjoy maternity leave. Factories generally lacks adequate lighting, ventilation and washing facilities, canteen and safe drinking water. Rooms are crowded. Average per toilets for male are 40 and female 81. Female 1800 500 10.8 Remarks Delayed , irregular payment and severe penalties for coming late. 30/45 minutes launch break Other Manufacturing Male 2800 - 6.5 90% of women workers demanded paid leave for effective combination of productive and child-care facilities. Ventilation safe water, toilet facilities in most factories are not better than such in RMGs. Female 2300 - 6.0 Remarks Not much problems in payment No shift duty in general
  • 13. Trends in Population by Residence, 1901-2000 Census year National population Growth rate % Urban population Growth Rate % Rural population Growth rate % Urban % 1901 28928 - 708 0.00 28226 0.00 2.40 1911 31555 0.94 807 1.40 30748 0.90 2.60 1921 33254 0.60 879 0.80 32376 0.50 2.60 1931 35604 0.74 1074 2.00 35428 0.90 3.00 1941 41997 1.70 1537 3.60 40460 1.30 3.70 1951 44166 0.50 1820 1.70 42346 0.50 4.30 1961 55223 2.26 31111 5.40 52112 2.10 5.60 1974 76398 2.48 73901 6.70 69008 2.20 9.70 1981 89912 2.32 140891 9.20** 75823 1.30 15.70 1991 109877 2.01 215602 4.20 88317 1.50 19.60 2000 137439 2.51 34354 5.30 103085 1.73 25.00 2001 - - - - - -
  • 14. Changes in occupation by Migration Status, 1998: Pre & Post- Migrational status Occupatio n Status Long-term migrant Recent migrant Non- Slum Slum Non- Slum Slum Post migration occupational status Trading 31.5 21.4 41.3 - Labor: Non-farm 8.7 43.8 7.1 50.0 Services 21.5 71.4 8.7 - Renting - - - - Not working 7.9 3.1 - - Others - - - - Total 100(277) 100(13 0) 100(14) 100(46) Occupatio n Status Long-term migrant Recent migrant Non- Slum Slum Non- Slum Slum Pre-Migration occupational status Agriculture 5.4 3.9 - 17.4 Trading 6.9 21.4 15.2 - Labor: Non-farm 1.8 3.9 - 10.9 Labor: Farm 10.5 43.9 7.1 41.3 Services 3.8 35.7 2.2 - Unemployed 14.4 7.7 21.4 4.4 Not working 48.7 29.2 14.3 8.7 Others 0.7 - - - Total 100(277) 100(13 0) 100(14 ) 100(46 )
  • 15. Labor market: Conditions and entitlements (Cont.) After all the proportion of underemployed is estimated at 6.5 million. And 16.5% of the total employed population are under-employed of which 80% live in rural areas and 66% of them are women.
  • 16. Problems of Migrants The main problems that migrants face 1. lack of low cost housing, 2. physical insecurity, 3. skewed distribution of the delivery of basic services 4. and subsequent health problems. Housing problems:  More than half (53%) of poor migrants live in private slums and 44% squat on public land with about 14 square metres space for a family of average five members or 2.7 square metres per capita space, which increases almost six times for a non-slum resident.  Although poor migrants eventually improve their living spaces, for example replacing thatched roofs with corrugated iron sheets for better protection from cold and rain, living in such conditions give rise to many health problems, particularly given the combination of mud floors, flimsy walls, heat and humidity and torrential monsoon rains (Afsar, 1999).  Squatter settlements are formed with the help of muscle power, strong social networks built on kinship ties and district based affinities and with the patronage of political leaders.
  • 17. Problems of Migrants cont. Water and sanitation problem:  Worse still are the health and environmental risks associated with poor access to water and sanitation services, which determine health and environmental safety.  Nearly three-quarters of slum dwellers depend largely on outside water taps, which are shared by 5-6 families.  To fetch water for drinking and cooking, a female slum resident must travel an average distance of 69 m daily, adding to her workload and affecting her health and productivity.  Nearly 90% of the slum dwellers use hanging and other types of non-sanitary toilets in Dhaka city, whereas 90% of non-slum residents have modern toilets and 25% of households in small and medium towns have septic tanks.
  • 18. Problems of Migrants cont. Health and health service problems:  Morbidity rate is estimated at 52% for slum dwellers and 42% for a female worker in a garment factory (Afsar, 1999).  Around one-fifth of female garment factory workers also suffer from sexually transmitted diseases (Afsar, 2001 and Paul-Majumder, 1998).  Lack of safe, affordable transportation, inexpensive one-stop treatment and medical facilities increases women’s vulnerability. Institutions providing childcare, health care and boarding facilities at affordable prices are rare even in the capital city, and much less so in other cities and towns.
  • 19. Problems of Migrants cont. Physical insecurity and negligence:  Women are the major victims of deteriorating law and order and the resulting human rights violations  Hossain, Khan and Seeley (2003) also found that problems of accommodation, sickness and disease, robbery and physical harassment loom large for seasonal migrants at destination.  Hossain, Khan and Seeley (2003) showed how poor migrants are treated as outsiders, deprived from entitlements and denied justice at the place of destination. The experience of one migrant – Nuru – is one example:  “Nuru is 18 years old works as a day laborer. A year ago, he moved to Cox’s Bazaar with a work crew for road construction job. They received only three days’ wages though they worked 7 days. When Nuru protested, the contractors threatened to kill him. Nuru has faced various other hardships as a migrant worker.”
  • 20. Consequences of Migration  The consequences of internal migration remain unclear. They are influenced by a range of factors including 1. Gender, 2. Space, 3. Time, 4. Migration context 5. And the strength of social capital among migrants.  It is widely acknowledged that migration provides material benefits for migrants and their families though difficult to prepare cost-benefit analyses from existing studies on internal migration.
  • 21. Consequences of Migration cont. Consequences for Long distance Migration:  Kuhn’s qualitative study (2000) provides that the costs of a long weekend sojourn from Dhaka to Barisal Division could be around Taka 500. Added to the income loss of around Taka 100 per day, a four-day trip can consume more than 30% of a month’s potential earnings.  But, Active support and cooperation from social contacts at destination minimize the costs of moving. While travel costs and opportunity costs of internal migration depend on the distance between origin and destination and types of job, it ultimately also depends on the strength of migrants’ social capital at destination and origin.  It is finalized according to Hugo that,  Remittances do not represent the total economic losses or benefits in areas of origin.  As transmission of skills, status and experience, flow of ideas, loss of economic and political leaders and social disruption can influence development in the area of origin.
  • 22. Remittance Problems of measuring internal remittance:  Remittances from internal migration are difficult to estimate due to the importance of in-kind transfer (Not in Cash).  It is also difficult to separate the contribution of internal migration from international migration since a sending household often has different types of migrant members.  Generally, panel data and in-depth interviews are needed to capture the role of remittances as a security back-up.
  • 23. Remittance cont. Though remittance measurement is very tough; but estimates from different scholars are given below:  It is argued that rural-urban remittances range around 12–15% of the rural income for Asia and Africa.  Kuhn estimated from Matlab in 1996, that the net transfer from sons living in urban or overseas destination accounted for 18% of the total income for all households and 27% for migrant sending households.  Temporary migrants send around 40% of their urban incomes to rural households, which increases to 64% for married migrants but declines to 27% in the case of unmarried ones (Afsar, 2000a). But why?  It’s very simple as a married temporary migrant had left his spouse and children at the place of origin.  The intensity of social ties and the types of responsibilities that migrants bear at origin and destination influence remittances.  For example, sons who lived in the city with their conjugal families contributed less than their siblings who lived alone in the city (Frankenberg and Kuhn, 2001).
  • 24. Use of internal remittance In Bangladesh, like in many other developing countries, migrants’ households in rural areas use remittances  Predominantly for consumption  Some portion for construction, savings and investment  And some portion for education . Use of remittance for consumption:  Existing evidence suggests that consumption expenditure alone constituted between 80% and 90% of the remittances.  In a country like Bangladesh, where half of rural households live below the poverty line, priorities on consumption expenditure can be viewed as consonant with ‘basic needs’ approach to development; without this the situation of families of migrants would have been worse off (Afsar, 2000b).  Hossain et al (2002) suggest that remittances contributed 12.8% to the household income whereas trade and business enterprises accounted for 22%.  A 10% increase in income would lead to 6.5% increase in the demand for food items.
  • 25. Use of remittance cont. Use of remittance for savings, investment:  From the existing data, we can say only that savings and funding from friends and relatives constituted around four-fifths of the initial capital invested in those enterprises but how much of the savings are generated from the remittances is not clear.  However, existing estimates (Hossain et al 2003b) also suggest that income gains from business are the most unequally distributed source of income, followed by services and non-rice agriculture, benefiting the higher income groups more than others.  House repairs, including extensions, building a new room and replacing thatch with corrugated iron roofing sheets, also consumes a significant proportion of remittances.  Investment in housing not only helps to expand business in construction materials but also gives rural families protection from natural calamities. In addition, it minmizes production and storage benefits.  Productive use of remittances to purchase irrigation equipment, to establish shops and other businesses also show up in survey data and case studies (Kuhn, 2000).
  • 26. Use of remittance cont. Use of remittance for Education  Around 40% of temporary migrants’ families also used remittances to educate children and treat sick members.  Existing studies (Afsar, 2001b) reveal that remitters among RMG workers, predominantly sent money directly for family maintenance and education of siblings.  School enrolment rates among members of migrants’ families in rural areas is greater compared with age cohorts of non-migrant families (Rahman et al 1996).
  • 27. Migration and poverty Migration have Positive effect for Rural but in some context negative effect for urban areas. Positive effect: 1. Role of migration on Land in Rural:  Land-poor households before 1990s was much dependent but in the 1990s are much less dependent on the agricultural labor market.  Hossain et al (2003b) estimated that the proportion of agricultural workers was halved between 1987 and 2000, due to greater employment opportunities generated in the rural non-farm sector (labor transition).  A new ‘class’ of people has emerged in rural areas, which depends more on physical and human capital than on land and manual labor (laborer transition).
  • 28. Role of migration on Land in rural cont.  The incidence of tenancy has increased, thus providing additional access to land for land-poor households.  For example, Hossain et al 2002 told that most of the tenants are small landowners who find it economical to rent land to increase the capacity-use of the farm establishment. % of Land Tenancy 47% 40% 13% 50% 0% <0.2 hect 0.2-1 hect >1 hect  Rural-urban migration stimulated land tenancy. Hossain et al (2002) observed that, in rural areas, 1.3% of the owned land was sold, compared with 1.7% of owned land in 1987/88; land purchase was reported at 2% in 1999/00.  The higher incidence of land purchase compared to land sale indicates the important contribution of rural-urban migration to the land market in a land-scarce country.
  • 29. Migration and poverty cont. 2. Role of migration on some important structural changes:  Income from agriculture declined from 59% to 44%, whilst income from trade, services and remittances increased from 35% in 1987/88 to 49% in 1999/00.  Hossain et al (2002) also observed that the most dramatic increase has been in the share of remittances from relatives who migrated to cities and overseas.  The proportion of households receiving remittances in 1999/00 was 21%, almost double the 11% of such households in 1987/88.  The contribution of remittances to household income has increased significantly from 7.3% to 12.8% over the period, registering 8.1% annual growth when per capita income grew at 3.2%.
  • 30. Role of migration on some important structural changes cont.  Some positive consequences of migration  Landless and land-poor farmers have left the agricultural labour market for tenancies.  Wage labour in trade and business enterprises,  Rickshaw pulling and other manual non-agricultural activities.  Members of medium and large landowning households – with correspondingly larger endowments of human and physical capital – switched from cultivating their own farms to services and business.  As a result, the proportion of poor people dropped to 43% in 2000 from 59% in 1988, a reduction of 1.2% per year. Year % of poor people 1988 43% 2000 59%  There is no direct estimate of the contribution of remittances to poverty alleviation but, indirectly, some conjecture can be made in this regard.
  • 31. Role migration on Poverty Reduction  From the panel data from rural sending areas, Rahman et al (1996) found that the extent of poverty was much lower for households having migrant members, much lower than for non-migrant households. % of poor as different household 30% 60% Migrants household Non-migrant household  The proportion of those who perceived themselves poor or extremely poor declined from around 60% to 30% between 1990 and 1995, a -26.7% change.  In the case of non-migrant households, a large number (54%) still considered themselves poor or extremely poor and only a small proportion perceived (8.7%) improvement in their situation compared to 1991.
  • 32. Negative effect migration  Rural-urban migration is often considered to be a process of transferring rural poverty to urban areas.  From their longitudinal study of Dhaka city, Hossain et al (1999) came out with the following startling results, which challenge this conventional wisdom:  For households in slum and squatter settlements, the head count ratio for moderate poverty was estimated at 79% in 1991; this dropped to a staggering low of 49% in 1998 and extreme poverty from 44.5% to 23%. These are basically migrant populations from the landless and marginal landholding households in rural areas.
  • 33. Migration and Inequality: at the place of origin Internal migration is often considered a source of intra-village inequality because……  better-off villages and villagers learn first, and are able to avail new job opportunities  whereas the extreme poor groups are generally excluded from such opportunities (Skeldon, 1997). However, this negative picture should not be generalized.
  • 34. Migration and Inequality: at the place of destination  At the place of destination however, existing evidence suggests growing inequality between the rich and the poor.  A longitudinal study on migration in Dhaka city (Hossain et al, 1999) indicates worsening of income distribution between slum and non-slum residents.  Slum dwellers, who are predominantly migrants from rural areas, earned around one-third of the income of non-slum households in 1991; this declined to one fifth in 1998.  The bottom 40% saw their income drop from 17% of the income of non-slum households to 11% while the top 10% increased from 27% to 42%.
  • 35. Migration and Inequality: at the place of destination cont.  The gini concentration ratio, a measure of income inequality, is estimated at 0.53, a staggering increase from 0.39 in 1991.  Urban inequality is not limited to income distribution but also leads to stunted development of human capital of poorer communities.  Although the enrolment rate of their age cohorts in slum and squatter settlements in Dhaka city rose from 41% to 58% between 1991 and 1998, more than 40% of the children remained out of school.  Little wonder, then, that Hossain et al (1999) found that nearly one-third of children in the 10–15 years age group from slums and squatters were in the labour force; the incidence of child labour remained almost unchanged between 1991 and 1998.  Thus, although the urban population have been ahead of the rural population on both poverty and social development indicators generally, the urban poor in general and migrants in particular find it difficult to sustain economic gains in the longer run, due to intra-urban inequality in income and delivery of social services.
  • 36. Strategy for Poverty alleviation and economic growth  In Bangladesh poverty is considered as one of the key drivers of the rural-urban migration.  Government ,International agencies and donors focus on Poverty alleviation and economic growth through they failed to provide any direct policies and programs for internal migration . Government Strategy Pro-Poor economic Growth Women’s Human Development Advancement Diminishing Gender gaps Social safety Participatory Governance
  • 37. International and National GOs /NGOs to develop the capacity of small and medium town International GOs /NGOs GOs/ NGOs in Bangladesh 1. World Bank : With the help of Local Government and Engineering Department they initiated project to build capacity and effective financial management of Khulna and Rajshahi City Corporations and 14 municipalities, or Pourashava, since 1999. 2. UNDP :Promoting broader participation in local decision making and building the capacity of locally elected bodies to better deliver services and to enable communities to address their development needs. 3.UNICEF : Runs water, sanitation and primary health care programs for urban street children , they also use the mass media to promote girls’ education, water sanitation and public health issues including dengue prevention and arsenic contamination 4. UNCHR : They is primarily work to rehabilitate poor migrants and refugees. Bastuhara Federation or federation of landless, which is a political organization involved predominantly in advocacy for the rehabilitation of squatters in major cities Coalition for the Urban Poor (CUP), working for poverty alleviation in urban poor communities mainly in Dhaka City, the bulk of whom are migrants from rural areas. Ain-O-Salish kendro works for the human rights and legal aids of migrants Nari Udyog Kendro (NUK), addresses governance and gender issues in the development process and caters to the housing needs of the city’s low-income and migrant women workers
  • 38.  Government fails to provide an effective regional development framework for decentralizing the industrial process around the secondary towns and periurban areas due to 1. Mismanagement. 2. Corruption . Limitations of the strategy  The National Rural Development Policy 2001 was formulated to enhance the capacity and power of the rural poor to develop, protect and sustain their livelihoods but no such policy has been formulated for urban areas.  It also fails to outline any mechanism to cover the extreme poor and migrant groups, which find themselves largely outside of existing social security schemes of government.  It didn’t mention infrastructural development of periurban and small towns as a precondition for business investment and creating new job opportunities .  Without decentralizing power, finance and other services at the upazila/thana level, and without an effective policy framework for regional development, it is difficult to implement participatory governance.
  • 39. Government’s poverty alleviation strategy (Poverty Reduction Strategy Paper, PRSP) must address the following issues : 1) Important role of migration in reducing rural poverty by expanding rural land and labor markets and making more rural land available for tenancy. 2) Migration has raised rural productivity and created scope for innovation by increasing the use of mechanism 3)The needs of the migrants, particularly urban poor migrants who often suffer eviction, ill health and other problems. 4)Vulnerable groups can be picked up from the work place, organized as occupational groups and provided with loans, food-for- work and other facilities on a daily basis Key Policy Issues Firstly Secondly Thirdly 1)Remittances from internal migration generate both direct and indirect benefits with short-term, long-term and multiplier effects on poverty alleviation, regional development and the overall development of the country 2) internal remittances Should be convert to Deposit Pension Scheme (DPS), so that remittances can be potential for development work as well as generating savings for land-poor groups 1)Government strategy for poverty alleviation should add spatial and regional dimensions for development. 2) Migration is a dominant force behind the coastal region ‘s impressive progress in poverty alleviation. So , 3) Flood-prone regions and those with favourable ecosytems must be given priority attention in order to expand labour productivity and provide greater scope for occupational mobility.
  • 40. Gaps in the implication of the strategy  There is profound disparity in income distribution and service delivery between space, class and gender, which often hinders the pace of poverty reduction.  Though government allocates around 20% of the development budget for local government and rural development. there are some inconsistencies between the PRSP objectives and budgetary allocations.  The class and gender dimension of poverty and inequality are considered, the spatial dimension of poverty and inequality get scanty attention in the PRSP. Basically without a regional development framework, decentralisation efforts will remain ad hoc and the growing inequality in income and services distribution cannot be controlled effectively.
  • 41. Recommendation 1) Telecommunications and other information technologies should be expanded as this would not only create employment opportunities but also help to decentralize businesses from large cities to potentially lower-cost smaller cities 2) Small and medium towns can be made more attractive by developing infrastructure and communication, particularly efficient and safe transportation, and providing a good standard of social services such as hospitals, schools and colleges. 3) With increasing urbanization, migrant women are likely to form a larger and larger proportion of the work force so policies should be favorable to female labor .  All labour legislation must be brought under a new labour code to ensure effective implementation and monitoring and it will provide written employment contracts of working hours and wage rates, overtime hours and rates, holidays, dismissal and retrenchment procedures to ensure labour right  Workers should be given proper skill training to equip with the changing nature of jobs through the private sector and NGOs. 4) To ensure low-cost housing and hostel facilities for migrant factory workers, NGOs and housing companies may be given khas land at a reduced price.
  • 42. Thank you for your patience Do you have any question? Please ASK……………….